News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:52AM (#27379378)
> Are there sufficient people interested in ... ?

There's people interested in caring for others and/or growing food on the countryside. Cleaning toilets is a task nobody does by pleasure but i don't see a reason there should be a specific class in society handling undesired tasks for the others.

Why can't we take turns doing what HAS TO be done? I've lived in communities for about two decades now and it's never ever crossed our mind we should designate someone to clean the toilets for others. I'm happy to do it every now and then if you're happy to do the same.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:10AM (#27379481)
I would rather pay someone to take my turn for me.

There’s a whole theory of competitive advantage [0] where I’m better doing some things than others. I’d rather do the thing I’m good at and use the money to pay others to do stuff I’m marginally worse off doing.

I’ve lived in communities for a few decades and every day it crosses my mind that I want to establish a price for someone to come clean my toilet.

[0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/comparativeadvantage.as...

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Applejinx on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:17AM (#27381708)
When my parents were alive, in their retirement, they'd hire 'Merry Maids' to come and clean for them. As near as I could tell, they were very nice about it, and I remember being over there and the amusing interplay as the maids tried very hard to not impose on the family visiting going on, while the kids tried just as hard to arrange where they were at to not get in the way of the maids :) it was a very Alphonse and Gaston, 'oh no, after you!' sort of thing.

I feel like the real litmus test here is: given that the maid is cleaning your toilet, would you freak out if the maid took a dump in your toilet AND then cleaned it? That cuts to the heart of whether they're a fellow human doing exchange-value with you as a true equal, or whether they're a class that should not be using the employer's private toilet.

I would bet you maid services like that are very strict about not blurring that line, knowing that some people are paying to set up a class dynamic they expect to be honored.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:18PM (#27387469)
> would you freak out if the maid took a dump in your toilet AND then cleaned it? That cuts to the heart of whether they're a fellow human doing exchange-value with you as a true equal, or whether they're a class that should not be using the employer's private toilet.

Ha, no of course not. I also think it’s not a very good test because almost no one would care. Me not being able to afford to buy things or not being skilled enough to command a high wage doesn’t mean I’m not equal as a human being, it just means I can’t afford things.

I would expect that maid services are very strict because some people are super picky about their toilets. I know people who won’t let family members use their toilet, much less some stranger. It’s not worth the risk for a maid service to lose the work. Not really a good indicator of valuing humans.

Maybe a better test would be whether I allow a maid to drink from my water or something like that.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by throw0101a on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:47AM (#27379835)
> I would rather pay someone to take my turn for me.

You're not wrong, but it's not (all) about efficiency but rather about solidarity and social cohesion. As an example, in Japan, children clean the school:

* https://www.japantimes.co.jp/life/2001/11/30/lifestyle/kids-...

* https://www.thejapanguy.com/japanese-kids-clean-their-classr...

* https://www.quora.com/How-do-Japanese-students-feel-about-th...

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:54AM (#27379912)
> I would rather pay someone to take my turn for me.

Yeah, that's precisely what's wrong in our society that it appears normal to pay for inconveniences to disappear. Except of course for most of us who don't have money so we get paid shitty wages for making other people's inconveniences disappear. If such jobs were the highest paid, that would be less of a problem of course. But the highest paid jobs under capitalism are the least useful to society at large because they don't produce anything (CEOs, managers, financial/legal advisors, marketers, etc).

> I’m better doing some things than others.

That makes sense. However some tasks such as cleaning are not skilled labor. Yes it requires (some) learning, but by the second time you've cleaned a toilet you pretty much know how to do it for the rest of your life. Cleaning a single toilet takes about 5 minutes and is not much effort (contrary to doing that for a living)That makes sense. However some tasks such as cleaning are not skilled labor. Yes it requires (some) learning, but by the second time you've cleaned a toilet you pretty much know how to do it for the rest of your life. Cleaning a single toilet takes about 5 minutes and is not much effort (contrary to doing that for a living). Have you considered why you're so reluctant to do it?

> I’ve lived in communities (...) my toilet

We're probably not living in the same kinds of communities then if you've got a personal toilet. In the communities i've resided in everybody's got their personal room but everything else is communal.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:23PM (#27387533)
> that's precisely what's wrong in our society that it appears normal to pay for inconveniences to disappear.

I disagree, it’s what is awesome about our society. It’s a feature, not a bug.

I’ve gotten all the character I’ll get from cleaning toilets and I’m happy that someone else is willing to do it for me.

There’s no way toilet cleaner will be a high paying job because the skill set is so low. As with most manual labor. Low skill set means lots of people will do it means low wages.

I understand how to clean a toilet and the time involved. I choose not to do it. I won’t make me a better person to do it. I have considered why I’m reluctant and understand pretty completely. I grok why I don’t want to clean toilets. I’m comfortable with my understanding in this area.

It’s also ok that we value these experiences differently. I don’t have to convince you to pay someone to clean your toilet. I just have to convince you to continue letting me, and others, pay for toilet cleaning.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:00PM (#27387946)
> Low skill set means lots of people will do it means low wages.

High supply relative to demand or low demand relative to supply means low wages.

It is possible (and very real in many areas) that there are low numbers of people willing to clean toilets in a given area compared to the demand. It could be due to government assistance providing them enough such that they do not need to clean toilets to meet their needs.

It could be better job opportunities opening up nearby such as higher paying factory work. It could be that they move away from the area due to higher real estate prices. There are myriad causes for a low skill task to have few willing suppliers for the labor to perform that task.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by muttled on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:31AM (#27382849)
>Have you considered why you're so reluctant to do it?

It's funny, I had a conversation with a roommate that went something like I said I hated dishes, and that I'd rather be outside in the cold, under the car lifted on jackstands, draining the oil and replacing it and servicing the oil filter, coming back in and cleaning up. For both our cars. And my roommate seemed shocked. It seemed like such a bigger task to them than just quickly cleaning the dishes and throwing them in a rack to dry. But I just hate doing the dishes. And I don't mind changing the oil in the car.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:05AM (#27380030)
> Except of course for most of us who don't have money so we get paid shitty wages for making other people's inconveniences disappear. If such jobs were the highest paid, that would be less of a problem of course. But the highest paid jobs under capitalism are the least useful to society at large because they don't produce anything (CEOs, managers, financial/legal advisors, marketers, etc).

This might be able to be rectified under the current system by giving money to the lowest paid, so that they can go to school and learn a trade which they find has a more acceptable price:undesirability ratio. Ideally, everyone will have the option to not have to do tasks like cleaning toilets, and hence everyone will have to do it themselves or pay a lot to get someone else to do it.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:53AM (#27379389)
> Why can't we take turns doing what HAS TO be done?

What happens when someone does not take their turn?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:32AM (#27379664)
Depends on the reason. You may be temporarily/long-term disabled. Or maybe you were having a really bad week and you'll be happy to take your turn next week (maybe you even said so in advanced and arranged to swap your shift with somebody else?).

Or maybe you just don't care to exploit other people you live with, in which case you're free to go and do that elsewhere because that's the norm in all of capitalist societies.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:40AM (#27379753)
Why would someone that wants to exploit other people leave a place that lets them exploit others?

I’ll cut to the chase. My point is your concept of society does not work at scale. You will have people that want to use the system, you will need to use force and adjudicate in the system, and you will need something more than good vibes to serve as incentives.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:01AM (#27379985)
> Why would someone that wants to exploit other people leave a place that lets them exploit others?

Because we'll kick them out. I'm always up for doing things i don't particularly enjoy because there's value in them, but I certainly don't want to live with someone who treats me like a slave.

> you will need something more than good vibes to serve as incentives

Sure. But you'll probably concede that we live in a world run by psychopaths where children in schools are taught how to become psychopaths themselves. The first thing we teach children is "copying is cheating" and we're wondering why we're fucked? I'm not saying there's a time and place where everything will be perfect and we can all live happily ever after (i'm not a hippy), but there's very rational reasons for the ways everything around us is bad, and very rational courses of actions to fix those.

Abolishing property as State-mandated religion doesn't mean that some people won't have more than others (this would be ridiculous). But at least it would mean that nobody would sleep on the streets while there are empty homes, and nobody would starve while there is wasted food. Both ridiculous situations are the consequence of private property and require considerable amounts of force and resources to apply. It obviously is not working at scale, as we can see from environmental damage and previously-unimaginable levels of inequality.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:12AM (#27380090)
> Because we'll kick them out. I'm always up for doing things i don't particularly enjoy because there's value in them, but I certainly don't want to live with someone who treats me like a slave.

It’s hard enough to get many married couples to live like this, and even harder for small extended families. I would assign something very close to 0% as the probability for viability of this on a country or global level.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ycombobreaker on Friday June 04, 2021 @12:52AM (#27390722)
> The first thing we teach children is "copying is cheating"

Sharing and cooperative play come long before anything resembling an individual assignment.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:37AM (#27379724)
They are ostracized or otherwise lose social status within the community. Functional human societies have existed and do exist in the absence of capitalism.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:41AM (#27379765)
I do not know what definition of capitalism you are using, but I was strictly addressing the ability of society to function without compensation.

I am not aware of any functional society exists today without the use of compensation on a notable scale, certainly not notable enough to be able to defend itself.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:04AM (#27380026)
Considering that functional societies exist, regardless of their size and technological state, without monetary compensation as a primary motivation, I am forced to wonder how much our narrative that we cannot have technological civilization without forcing a class of people into handling unsavory tasks via threat of starvation and death is just part of the self-perpetuating mechanism of our particular societal organization structure.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:12AM (#27380094)
Which societies today function like this, that could be scaled up to country level tasks and responsibilities? Regardless of size would make it a meaningless claim, as the parameters are greatly different between a tribe of 100 vs 10,000 vs 1,000,000,000.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:19AM (#27380167)
> Which societies today function like this, that could be scaled up to country level tasks and responsibilities?

None that I'm aware of, though I am not entirely convinced it is impossible for the reasons I stated. I am forced to wonder: what is the virtue of scale like that if it is largely built on the back of human suffering?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:34AM (#27380300)
So another tribe does not roll over you.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:00AM (#27379977)
To me that's moving the goal posts. There are plenty of nomadic and tribal societies out there that function the same way they have for thousands of years.

Certainly our technologically advanced civilizations as they exist today are founded on capitalism, but I am not sure that is required, it has just become such an ingrained concept that "no one would ever do these unsavory tasks if we didn't threaten them with starvation and death" that we have difficulty imagining any other possibility.