News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kryps on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:03AM (#27182921)
It does not just feel faster, in many cases it is faster.

E.g. compiling Rust code is so much faster that it is not even funny. cargo install -f ripgrep takes 22 seconds on a Mac Book Air with M1, same on a hexacore 2020 Dell XPS 17 with 64GB RAM takes 34 seconds.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by josephg on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:25AM (#27183102)
I did a side-by-side comparing with my friends' M1 macbook and my (more expensive, nearly brand new) ryzen 5800x workstation compiling rust. The ryzen was faster - but it was really close. And the macbook beats my ryzen chip in single threaded performance. For reference, the ryzen compiles ripgrep in 19.7 seconds.

The comparison is way too close given the ryzen workstation guzzles power, and the macbook is cheaper, portable and lasts 22 hours on a single charge. If Apple can keep their momentum going year over year with CPU improvements, they'll be unstoppable. For now it looks like its not a question of if I'll get one, but when.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by omegabravo on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:53AM (#27183408)
I've done a side by side with my Ryzen 3700x compiling a Go project.

6 seconds on the Ryzen, vs 9 seconds on the M1 air.

`time go build -a`, so not very scientific. Could be attributed to the multicore performance of the Ryzen.

Starting applications on the M1 seems to have significant delays too, but I'm not sure if that's a Mac OSX thing. Overall it's very impressive, I just don't see the same lunch eating performance as everyone else.

The battery life and lack of fans is wonderful.

edit: Updated with the arm build on OSX. 16s -> 9 seconds.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coder543 on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:05AM (#27184283)
> `time go build -a`, so not very scientific.

A tool I have enjoyed using to make these measurements more accurate is hyperfine[0].

In general, the 3700X beating the M1 should be the expected result... it has double the number of high performance cores, several times as much TDP, and access to way more RAM and faster SSDs.

The fact that the M1 is able to be neck and neck with the 3700X is impressive, and the M1 definitely can achieve some unlikely victories. It'll be interesting to see what happens with the M1X (or M2, whatever they label it).

[0]: https://github.com/sharkdp/hyperfine

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by ngngngng on Monday May 17, 2021 @03:01PM (#27186947)
M1 S Pro Max
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by brailsafe on Monday May 17, 2021 @03:12PM (#27187102)
Faster SSDs on the Ryzen machine? The SSD on even my 2019 Macbook pro is ridic
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by ideamotor on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:24AM (#27183772)
I find M1 optimized apps load quickly while others vary. But what really varies is website load times. Sometimes instant, sometimes delayed.

All this said, there really is no comparison. I don’t even think about battery for the M1, I leave the charger at home, and it’s 100% cool and silent. It’s a giant leap for portable creative computing.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:45AM (#27184014)
> Starting applications on the M1 seems to have significant delays too, but I'm not sure if that's a Mac OSX thing.

That's a Mac OSX thing. It's verifying the apps.

https://appletoolbox.com/why-is-macos-catalina-verifying-app...

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kemayo on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:01PM (#27184964)
If it's Intel-compiled apps, it's also that Rosetta is translating them to run on M1 when they're first run, as I understand it.

Both of these are first-time launch issues, so comparing launch times on the second launch is probably more reasonable.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:51PM (#27188875)
Good point. I'm really surprised they don't translate during installation (ahead of time).
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by lukeh on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:57PM (#27190535)
I believe they do.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by saagarjha on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @04:08AM (#27192272)
In certain cases, such as when they come from the App Store. I believe other apps do not get this.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by lukeh on Thursday May 20, 2021 @07:50AM (#27219945)
I think Installer.app triggers the AOT translation, too?
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by yaktubi on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:33AM (#27183889)
I’d like to point out that compiling stuff is usually disk/io intensive. Could this not just be that the Apple machine has a faster hard drive/memory?
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by vetinari on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:27AM (#27184539)
It doesn't. It has the same 4 lanes, PCIe 3.0 flash as everyone else.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by monocasa on Monday May 17, 2021 @03:38PM (#27187433)
They have an extremely heavily integrated flash controller. Part of it is what they bought from Annobit.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by vetinari on Monday May 17, 2021 @03:42PM (#27187482)
I know, but the flash controller isn't the slow part (usually ;) ).
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by monocasa on Monday May 17, 2021 @03:43PM (#27187502)
It does for real world tasks, rather than benchmarks. The FTL plays a big part in real world, small access latency.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by vetinari on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:08PM (#27187814)
We still don't know how good is the FTL in the Apple controller; all the devices are still too new and haven't been dragged through the coal as all the other controllers. It is still in the "easy job" part of it's lifecycle, with brand new flash cells.

However, to quote @Dylan16807 from similar discussion few weeks ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26118415):

> The analog parts are the slow parts.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by monocasa on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:17PM (#27187922)
They've been using custom controllers for over a decade.

And the Annobit IP includes the analog parts as a large piece of their value add.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by vetinari on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:46PM (#27188242)
We are getting too deep into irrelevant things. We don't know how much of Anobit IP was used in M1 macs; they may own it, but they might not use it all. They purchase their NAND and it may be not compatible with the current gen, just like when it was not compatible with Samsung's V-NAND/3D TLC.

In practice, the I/O performance of M1-based Macs is comparable to random PCIE 3.0 NVMe drive. (I'm typing this comment on M1 MBP, I'm well aware how it performs).

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by markandrewj on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @10:37AM (#27195148)
PCIe 4.0 is the current standard.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by omegabravo on Monday May 17, 2021 @03:00PM (#27186934)
update:

time GOARCH=amd GOOS=linux go build -a

6s for the M1 too!

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jrockway on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:07PM (#27188467)
Do keep in mind that go heavily caches for "go build":

https://golang.org/cmd/go/#hdr-Build_and_test_caching

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coder543 on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:38PM (#27190717)
the "-a" directive in "go build -a" should cause a clean rebuild, which is what they were using
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by atq2119 on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:23AM (#27183749)
Did both machines compile to the same target architecture? If you did native compiles, then perhaps LLVM's ARM backend is simply faster than its x86 backend...
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by bombcar on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:23PM (#27185230)
I think this is potentially a huge part of it - I'd do the benchmark by doing a native compile and a cross compile of each, and also do the same on a RAM disk instead of SSD (a large compile can end up just being a disk speed test if the CPU is waiting around for the disk to find files).
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by outworlder on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:13PM (#27188526)
Maybe that would have been the case if only compilation times were reported to be good. But no, this is across many different kinds of workloads. Even Blender running in Rosetta can beat native x86 processors, which is bonkers.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by yaktubi on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:22AM (#27183735)
I think these performance metrics are somewhat limited in their usefulness. A Ryzen workstation might not have the same single-core performance or energy efficiency—however, a ryzen workstation can have gobs of memory for massive data-intensive workloads for the same cost as a baseline M1 device.

In addition: let’s talk upgradability or repairability. Oh wait, Apple doesn’t play that game. You’ll get more mileage on the workstation hands-down.

The only win for those those chips I think is battery efficient for a laptop. But, then why not just VNC into a beastmode machine on a netbook and compile remotely? After all, that’s what CI/CD pipeline is for.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by harikb on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:29AM (#27183822)
granted they charge exorbitant prices for their hardware, but I can’t believe how my 2010 MacBook Pro is still functioning perfectly fine.. except for them making it unsupported. I can’t say that about any other pc/laptop I have had. Not even desktops
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by apexalpha on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:32AM (#27183873)
I don't know, I feel other laptops at the same price point as Apple Macbooks do this too, sometimes even better. I bought a HP 8530w in 2009 or so and it still works. Replacing the DVD drive for a SSD required just a common Philips screwdriver and battery replacements are sold by HP themselves or many others.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by davidy123 on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:05AM (#27184284)
Exactly. Too many people compare a $400 cheap Windows laptop to a $1200 Macbook. Compare like for like, and the thing is likely to last until it's absolutely obsolete. And, while I don't really support this, some might find it an advantage to replace the computer three times for the same price. But people should be comparing to a well built, upgradable laptop (especially those that support not just RAM and disk but also display upgrades and adequate ports), running an operating system that has no arbitrary end of life.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by emteycz on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:22PM (#27186424)
Lenovo or Dell displays are much worse than Apple displays even though the machine costs the same.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by davrosthedalek on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:44PM (#27188216)
Sure, but my macbook pro has cooked it's display /twice/ now. Didn't go to sleep properly, and it overheated in my laptop bag.

No good way to check for it, because no LEDs on the outside. Only way to check is to see if the fans switched on after five minutes in the bag.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by emteycz on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:07PM (#27189010)
You don't want to know what the Dells are capable of doing. My XPS 15 2020 literally got on fire somewhere on the motherboard - not even a battery thing. Then I decided to go Apple only.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by MonaroVXR on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:59PM (#27215071)
I would believe that, because Dell XPS laptops are bad. (I'm in group full of laptop needs who check these things. Anecdotal and "scientifically".)

You are better of with a business or workstation laptop.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by simonh on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:42PM (#27188202)
I’d love to see an actual serious comparison between an M1 Mac and a $400 laptop. That would be hilarious. Since there are so many of them, can you direct me to one, or even a few?
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by eldaisfish on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:20AM (#27184449)
The point is that with mid-2010s apple laptops, >5 year lifespans are the norm. With the majority of other, even comparably priced laptops, that is the exception.

There are other laptops that are similar or superior build quality to those from Apple (N.B. - older MacBooks, not the newer ones) but those are also easy to spot. They’ll usually be ThinkPads or some XPS models from dell.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kogepathic on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:54AM (#27184880)
> With the majority of other, even comparably priced laptops, that is the exception.

Consumer grade PC hardware has terrible build quality, and regardless of the price of your unit, the consumer build spec is just inferior to the business/professional lines. Asus, MSI, Sony, Acer, etc laptops all have consumer grade build quality and they just aren't designed to last a decade.

> They’ll usually be ThinkPads or some XPS models from dell.

Precision/XPS and Thinkpad models (with the exception of the L and E series) are almost always in the same price range as a MacBook. Any business-class machine (Thinkpad, Precision/Latitude, Elitebook) should easily last >5 years. These are vendors which will sell you 3-5 year on-site warranties for their laptops.

This is why you can find so many off-lease corporate laptops on eBay from any model year in the last 10 years or so. The hardware doesn't break, it just becomes obsolete.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by supercheetah on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:23PM (#27185229)
For Dell, at least the business class desktops, they're trash, and are barely useable after 2-3 years and usually have some kind of problem long before that. I'm pretty sure Dell expects most businesses to buy new ones in that time frame.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by spideymans on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:32PM (#27185926)
I really want to like Dell's XPS line. I really do. But their technical support is atrocious. My XPS trackpad stopped working months after purchase, and getting them to repair it was an utter nightmare. Their tech support seemingly hasn't improved at all in the past decade (which is when I last vowed to never buy a Dell again due to their horrible tech support). They may fool me twice, but never again.

(I do hear that their business support is pretty good though)

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by w0m on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:32PM (#27186544)
> and getting them to repair it was an utter nightmare

~8 years ago; within 48h of the laptop breaking - had a Dell repair tech sitting at my kitchen table replacing mainboard on an XPS laptop. Has turnaround when you have the proper support contracts gotten that much worse?

(admittedly, we did pay for the top support tier for a personal device as it was expensed for work. I wouldn't do anything else from any manufacturer though unless I had on-site tech support/replacement.)

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by varjag on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:36PM (#27189244)
Not sure about consumer side, but as a business we have 24h turnaround service with Dell.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by salamandersauce on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:54PM (#27189380)
Oh that's baloney. There's nothing special about Apple laptops besides the metal case. Arguably they have worse cooling than most PC laptops. My 2018 MBP runs like it's trying cook an egg and has since day one. My Brother's 2012 MBP suffered complete logic board failure after 4 or 5 years.

If it wasn't for the replacement keyboard warranty offered by Apple a good chunk of butterfly keyboard Macs would be useless junk due to the fact it's so hard to replace them. Frayed MagSafe adapters were a regular occurrence. And swollen batteries pushing up the top case not that rare either.

I think maybe people keep MacBooks longer, but it probably has more to do with the fact they spent so much on them that they feel it's worthwhile to repair/pay for AppleCare than them actually being magically more durable.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by markandrewj on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @10:47AM (#27195321)
Except that Apple considers these devices ’vintage' and will not provide OS updates or repairs.

https://support.apple.com/en-ca/HT201624

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by salamandersauce on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:39PM (#27189267)
I was using my Dad's old ThinkPad 385XD from 1998 in 2009. Battery was unsurprisingly dead but every other piece was stock and worked although at some point I swapped the worn down trackpoint nub with one of the included spares we still had.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by eropple on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:33AM (#27183882)
My "writing desk" PC is a Thinkpad X201 tablet from 2010, with the same SSD upgrade I put in my own 2010 Macbook Pro (a dedicated Logic Pro machine these days). There have always been manufacturers for whom that's the case on the PC side of things--you just kinda had to pay for it up front.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by KozmoNau7 on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:59AM (#27184208)
My two main PCs are a Phenom II-based desktop and a Thinkpad X220i (with the lowly Core i3, even!). Both are perfectly functional and usable today, with a few minor upgrades here and there, the usual SSDs, more RAM and a Radeon RX560 for the desktop.

The Thinkpad is obviously no powerhouse, but still works great for general desktop use, ie. browsing, email, document editing, music, video (1080p h264 is no problem). The desktop plays GTA V at around 40-50 FPS at 1080p with maximum settings. And this isn't some premium build, it's a pretty standard Asrock motherboard with Kingston ValueRAM and a Samsung SSD.

Decade-old hardware is still perfectly viable today.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by sleepybrett on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:44PM (#27186690)
I just had storage fail on my first gen touchbar macbook. It's a PITA, the storage is soldered onto a board. They replace the board, the can't recover the data (didn't expect them to). I'd pay the extra mm or two it would require them to just use a standard like m2. SSD storage just fails after awhile, especially if you do lots of things that thrash the disk.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by xfer on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:45AM (#27184018)
Using 2011 sandybridge motherboard with a xeon-1230 i bought in 2012. I Had to replace 2 HDD + started using ssd for OS partition. It's working great, need to replace my nvidia GPU that is EOL but still working great.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by FpUser on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:22PM (#27185218)
I have an old gaming ASUS laptop from 2010. Still works like a charm after hard drive was switched to SSD. I have an even older Asus Netbook (15 years old eee PC I think) that still works. Netbook is too slow for modern software and I do not really use it but it works.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by zepto on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:33AM (#27183885)
> But, then why not just VNC into a beastmode machine on a netbook and compile remotely? After all, that’s what CI/CD pipeline is for.

Is this how you work?

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by monoideism on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:38AM (#27184680)
> Is this how you work?

This is exactly how I've worked for a number of years now, for my home/personal/freelance work. Usually using a Chromebook netbook ssh'ing into my high spec home server. I'd do the same for work, but work usually requires using a work laptop (MacBook).

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by usefulcat on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:42PM (#27185431)
I've worked that way for 10 years. My current desktop is a 5 year old Intel i3 NUC with a paltry 8G of memory. Granted, it uses all that memory (and a bit more) for a browser and slack, and the fan spins up any time a video plays. But usually it's silent, can drive a 4k monitor, and most of the time I'm just using mosh and a terminal, which require nearly nothing.

OTOH, the machine that I'm connecting to has 32c/64t, half a terabyte of RAM and dozens of TB of storage.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by hiq on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:27PM (#27188660)
> the machine that I'm connecting to has 32c/64t, half a terabyte of RAM

Ok I'll bite, what do you do? Do you think halving the number of cores / RAM would impact your productivity?

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by usefulcat on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @11:21AM (#27195838)
A lot of what I do is compiling, so for that I'd still be fine with fewer cores and a lot less RAM. But I also do backtesting of trading strategies, and for that I can use all the cores I can get. The memory is needed to cache the massive amount of data that is being read from a pair of 2T NVME SSDs. Without adequate caching, I/O can easily become the bottleneck, even though the SSDs are pretty fast.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by wayneftw on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:53AM (#27184133)
My work takes place at a beefy desktop machine. I wouldn't want it any other way... I get to plug in as many displays as I need, I get all the memory I need, I can add internal drives, there's no shortage of USB ports or expansion - and I get them cheap. For meetings or any kind of work away from my desk I'll remote in from one of my laptops.

All that and my preferred OS (Manjaro/XFCE), which runs on anything, has been more stable than any Mac I've ever owned. Every update to macOS has broken something or changed the UI drastically and in a way I have no control over...

If I ever switch away from desktops, it will be for a Framework laptop or something similar.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by zepto on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:26AM (#27184526)
This is interesting - in the sense that you are someone who doesn’t want the UI to change, but it’s really not clear what this has to do with the question or the article.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coupdejarnac on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:19PM (#27185811)
I'm not the guy above, but I concur with the sentiments. After a while, adjusting to trivial UI changes becomes a huge chore and unnecessary cognitive overhead. It's relevant, because in order to use the M1, you have to buy into Apple's caprice.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by zepto on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:43PM (#27186028)
Caprice seems like a weird way to characterize an aspect of the Mac a lot of people like.

I think it’s valid to want not to have to deal with the cognitive overhead of UI evolution.

It’s equally valid not to want to deal with the cognitive overhead of various attributes of Linux.

What’s not obvious is why people sneer about it.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by yaktubi on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:39AM (#27183953)
Well, actually I have a beastmode mobile workstation that gets maybe 3 hours of battery life on high intensity. And when the battery is depleted I find a table with an outlet and I plug it in.

Everything in the machine can be upgraded/fixed so it should be good for a while.

I’m not saying this to be snarky. I just want to emphasize that while M1 is great innovation, I put repairability/maintainability and longevity on a higher pedestal than other things. I also highly value many things a computer has to offer: disk, memory, CPU, GPU, etc. I want to be able to interchange those pieces; and I want to have a lot of each category at my disposal. Given this, battery life is not as important as the potential functionality a given machine can provide.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by emteycz on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:26PM (#27186472)
Which 2021 laptop has replaceable CPU?
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by w0m on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:32PM (#27186558)
That's 90% how I've worked in ~15 years as an SWE.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by simonh on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:37PM (#27188147)
> The only win for those those chips

I suspect the number of people, even developers, for whom 16GB memory is plenty probably greatly exceeds the number who need a beast mode Ryzen. But even then, a large proportion of the devs who might need a Build farm on the back end would be doing that anyway so they might as well have an M1 Mac laptop regardless.

Anyway Mac Pro models will come.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by barbazoo on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:15PM (#27185770)
Power consumption is a good point. I wonder what the M1's power consumption is during those 19.7 seconds of compiling ripgrep compared to other platforms.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by minimaul on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:55PM (#27186852)
Low.

For me, SoC power draw when compiling apps is usually around 15 to 18W on a M1 mac mini.

My example app (deadbeef) compiles in about 60 seconds on that mac mini.

On a 2019 i7 16” MBP (six core), it takes about 90 seconds, and draws ~65W for that period.

So… radically more power efficient.

edit: this is the same version of macOS (big sur), xcode, and both building a universal app (intel and ARM).

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by therockhead on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:28PM (#27185268)
I'm seeing a big different when compiling our project, with the M1 Macbook Pro beating the iMac Pro when building our projects (23min vs 38 mins).

Is it all CPU though, or is building ARM artefacts less resource intensive than bulding ones for Intel ?

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by ben-schaaf on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:41PM (#27185408)
iMac Pro has a large variety of performance, going from 8 to 18 cores and it uses a 4+ year old Xeon CPU. Unsurprisingly the 18 core handily beats the M1 in multi-core benchmarks:

18 core iMac Pro 13339: https://browser.geekbench.com/macs/imac-pro-late-2017-intel-...

M1 Mac mini 7408: https://browser.geekbench.com/macs/mac-mini-late-2020

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by ArcMex on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:54PM (#27185550)
>For now it looks like its not a question of if I'll get one, but when.

My exact sentiments. I've been looking for a gateway into Apple and the M1 Air seems like it. It has now become a matter of time and not just a fleeting thought.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by f6v on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:11PM (#27185725)
> If Apple can keep their momentum going year over year with CPU improvements

I’ve been blown away with games running on M1. If Apple could up their GPU game as well, that’d be really cool.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by NicoJuicy on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:44PM (#27185450)
Are you sure Rust compilation can use multiple cores to the fullest?

I don't use Rust, but a quick search returned for example this issue:

https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/64913

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by josephg on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:42PM (#27188201)
My cpu usage graph shows all cores at 100% for most of the compilation. But near the end it uses fewer and fewer cores. Then linking is a single core affair. It seems like a reasonable all-round benchmark because it leans on both single- and multi- core performance.

And I really care about rust compile times because I spend a lot of small moments waiting for the compiler to run.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by postalrat on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:53AM (#27183400)
How long is the battery life on both if compiling non-stop? Assuming both keep similar compile from start of battery to end it would be interesting to see if the ryzen is truly guzzling batteries.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by gpm on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:08AM (#27183588)
I'm guessing the 5800x work station is a desktop, not battery powered...
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by postalrat on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:15PM (#27187904)
You are right. Missed then when i was angerly responding.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by JudasGoat on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:34PM (#27188735)
I have a Ryzen 7 4700g. I wanted to compare this to the GPU side of the M1. On Geekbench OpenGL test, it was slightly faster than the M1. I would like to find a better test.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by anw on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:50PM (#27185517)
> macbook … and lasts 22 hours on a single charge

I keep hearing this but have not experienced this in person. I usually get about 5 hours of life out of it. My usual open programs are CLion, WebStorm, Firefox (and Little Snitch running in the background).

However, even with not having IDEs open all the time, and switching over from Firefox to Safari, I’m only seeing about 8 hours of battery life (which is still nice compared with my 2013 MBP that has about 30 minutes of battery life).

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by spideymans on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:36PM (#27185956)
>However, even with not having IDEs open all the time, and switching over from Firefox to Safari, I’m only seeing about 8 hours of battery life (which is still nice compared with my 2013 MBP that has about 30 minutes of battery life).

I would consider getting a warranty replacement. Something is wrong.

For reference, my M1 Air averages exactly 12 hours of screen-on time (yes, I've been keeping track), and the absolute worst battery life I've experienced is 8.5 hours, when I was doing some more intense dev workflows.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jhickok on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:07PM (#27185684)
The Macbook Air does not get 22 hours but the Macbook Pro gets kinda close under the conditions specified in the test.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by snarfy on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:45AM (#27184015)
I'm still unconvinced it's the M1's design and not TSMC's fab process.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by GeekyBear on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:02AM (#27184236)
When you move to a smaller process node, you have a choice between improving performance or cutting power. (or some mix of both)

Apple seems to have taken the power reduction with the A14 and M1 on TSMC 5nm, not the performance increase.

>The one explanation and theory I have is that Apple might have finally pulled back on their excessive peak power draw at the maximum performance states of the CPUs and GPUs, and thus peak performance wouldn’t have seen such a large jump this generation, but favour more sustainable thermal figures.

https://www.anandtech.com/show/16088/apple-announces-5nm-a14...

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:47AM (#27184048)
I think the latest Ryzen 5800x CPUs kind of prove it's the TSMC fab process. You've now got M1s, Graviton2s, and Ryzens all crushing it to similar levels.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:43AM (#27183998)
I dunnoh... the Ryzen 5800x laptops seem to be able to stay ahead of the M1's for most tasks.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by josephg on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:36PM (#27188125)
Huh? 5800x laptop? The 5800x is a desktop chip.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:53PM (#27188895)
The 'X' was meant to be "various letter extensions on the 5800 series", such as 5800U, 5800H, 5800HS. I probably should have used different terminology from the model number, as there are other Zen 3 mobile processors like the 5900HX, 5980HS and 5980HX that if anything make the point stronger.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by ryanmarsh on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:03AM (#27184248)
After buying my M1 and benchmarking it against the top of the line i9 I considered shorting Intel's stock, alas they're so large it'll take a while for the decline to catch up with them.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by pedrocr on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:58AM (#27183451)
In previous discussions about this it was pointed out that LLVM may be significantly faster at producing ARM code versus x86. The comparison may still be the one that actually matters to you but at least in part be an advantage of ARM in general and not just the M1. rust is very good at cross-compiling so compiling to ARM on Dell and to x86 on the M1 may add some interesting comparisons.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by mumblemumble on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:31AM (#27184584)
So then the next question is, is this really an apples-to-apples comparison? It wouldn't surprise me at all if the x86 back-end takes more time to run because it implements more optimizations.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by alkonaut on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:56AM (#27184911)
Are you compiling for ARM in both cases (or x86 in both cases)? Otherwise you are building 2 completely different programs, one is ripgrep for ARM and the other is ripgrep for Intel.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by saagarjha on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @04:12AM (#27192287)
The programs would be pretty much identical until they are lowered, which is generally not a bottleneck for Rust compiles…
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by agloeregrets on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:14AM (#27183012)
In native Typescript compile of a very large angular app I see an even more dramatic 1:20s to 40s compared to a desktop i9. I feel as if the M1 may have been designed around a detailed and careful look at how computers and compliers work and then designed a CPU around that rather than the other way around.

It's like buying a car and modifying to take it racing vs buying a race car, the race car was designed to do this.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by zerkten on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:45AM (#27183309)
>> I feel as if the M1 may have been designed around a detailed and careful look at how computers and compliers work and then designed a CPU around that rather than the other way around.

This is the position that Apple have set up for themselves with their philosophy and process. It would seem that Intel and AMD have to play a very conservative game with compatibility and building a product that increments support for x86 and x64. They can't make some sweeping change because they have to think about Linux and Windows.

Apple own their ecosystem and can move everything at once (to a large degree.) This also gives an opportunity to design how the components should interact. Incompatibility won't be heavily penalized unless really important apps get left behind. The improvements also incentivize app makers to be there since their developer experience will improve.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:51AM (#27184113)
> It would seem that Intel and AMD have to play a very conservative game with compatibility and building a product that increments support for x86 and x64.

Talk to people who design chips. The compatibility barely impacts the chip transistor budget these days, and since the underlying CPU isn't running x86 or x64 instructions, it really doesn't impact the CPU design. There may be some intrinsic overhead coming from limitations of the ISA itself, but even there they keep adding new instructions for specialized operations when opportunities allow.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by apozem on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:48PM (#27185503)
Exactly this. Apple has spent decades drilling a message into third-party developers: Update your apps regularly or get left behind.

Everyone who develops for one of their platforms is just used to running that treadmill. An ARM transition is just another thing to update your apps for.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by karmelapple on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:40PM (#27186005)
App developers are incentivized in another way: software that takes advantage of new features or performance are often what Apple chooses to promote in a keynote or in an App Store’s featured section.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jeswin on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:17AM (#27183681)
Typescript compilation doesn't use all the cores available on the CPU; I think it maxes out at 4 as of now [1]. This might be working well for M1, which has 4 high performance cores and 4 efficiency cores.

[1]: https://github.com/microsoft/TypeScript/issues/30235

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by blinkingled on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:30AM (#27183150)
What OS are you running on the Dell though? Windows is notoriously slower for file system operations even without AV and the default there is to prefer foreground apps vs something like compile tasks.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kryps on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:36AM (#27183212)
Yep, see below. With WSL and an ext4 virtual disk it takes only 29 seconds. Still quite a bit more than the 22 seconds on the Macbook.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by blinkingled on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:39AM (#27183240)
WSL2 right? Given the virtualization overhead for IO I would expect native Linux to be faster.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kryps on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:41AM (#27183264)
WSL2, correct.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by Nullabillity on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:12AM (#27182995)
Hard to compare without mentioning the actual CPU in it. FWIW my Ryzen 3900X completes that compile in 15s.

To be fair, that is a relatively high-end desktop CPU, but it's also a massive margin for a last-gen model.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by throwaway5752 on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:43AM (#27183275)
We also have to consider the i7 and M1 run at about 1/7 the TDP of the Ryzen. Just underscores the good design behind the QoS and judicious use of the Performance cores vs Efficiency cores.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:57AM (#27184185)
Yeah, but that's previous generation. Get a 5850U or even a 5980HX...
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by sundvor on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:51AM (#27183383)
My water-cooled 3900XT is locked to 4.4ghz all cores with relatively fast double banked 2x16GB c15 3600mhz memory. (It never drops under 4.4 on any of the 12/24 cores.)

Also has a Samsung 980 1TB drive, and a 3070 GPU; the system truly is extremely quick. (Win10+WSL2).

(I'll have to try that compile in the next day or so; will reply to myself here).

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by chmod775 on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:27PM (#27185882)
OS matters for this comparison. If your Dell XPS was running Windows, that might explain the discrepancy.

For instance Windows on NTFS etc. is notoriously slow at operations that involve a lot of small files compared to Linux or whatever on ext4.

Unless your Dell was also running OSX, you're probably not comparing hardware here.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by vetinari on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:55PM (#27185562)
For me, it takes 34 seconds on M1 (MBP13):

    Finished release [optimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 34.50s
    ...
    cargo install -f ripgrep  137,66s user 13,00s system 435% cpu 34,632 total
For comparison TR1900x (yeah, desktop, power-guzzler, but also several years old), Fedora 34:

    Finished release [optimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 25.15s
    ...
    real        0m25,271s
    user        4m41,553s
    sys         0m7,216s
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by Fergusonb on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:30PM (#27188698)
Thank you for the perspective.

Here's r7 4800HS (35w) on linux:

Finished release [optimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 24.98s

real 0m25.151s

user 4m54.987s

sys 0m6.764s

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by adriancr on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:30AM (#27183842)
I just did a test on my old Lenovo laptop... Intel i7-8565U CPU @ 1.80GHz

# git clone https://github.com/BurntSushi/ripgrep && cd ripgrep

# cargo clean

# time cargo build

real 0m23,805s

user 1m11,260s

sys 0m3,806s

How is my crappy laptop on par with your M1? :)

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kryps on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:41AM (#27183980)
You are not doing a release build.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by adriancr on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:47AM (#27184051)
thanks, problem solved - now it's 1 minute...
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by bscphil on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:28PM (#27189184)
Wow. The fact that my Sandy Bridge laptop from 2011 does it in only 1:41 is pretty indicative of how badly processor improvements stalled out last decade. My processor (like yours, 4c8t): https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/52219/i...
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by fomine3 on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @12:12AM (#27191177)
You compare TDP 45W CPU vs 15W. I think this is great improvement. (But latter one is also 25W cTDP and turbo boost provides more power, many factors depends on how the laptop implemented)
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by adriancr on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @12:43PM (#27197329)
I think the point is even a laptop from 2011 is acceptable for development. I wouldn't mind the power draw since its plugged in, the compile time either, cold compile 20s-2min is much the same for me, recompile where it counts is much faster
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by Keyframe on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:15AM (#27183023)
Are you counting download time as well? It took 8.30 sec on hexacore now when I tried it.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kryps on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:22AM (#27183084)
Nope, pure compile time on a Core i7-10750H with Windows and Rust 1.52.1, antivirus disabled. WSL did not make much of a difference though (29 seconds).
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by Filligree on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:29AM (#27183139)
The Windows filesystem is extremely slow, even without WSL. It can be mitigated to some extent by using completion ports, but I doubt the Rust compiler is architectured that way--

You should benchmark against Linux as well.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by kryps on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:34AM (#27183191)
cargo install on WSL2 uses the non-mapped home directory, which is on an ext4 virtual disk. That is probably one reason why it is six seconds faster.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by otabdeveloper4 on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:37AM (#27183223)
> Windows

There's your problem.

Even Microsoft concedes that Windows is legacy technology now.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by sinsterizme on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:49PM (#27191082)
You must be joking? If not, provide us with a source
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by hawski on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:13PM (#27185121)
And here I thought that having a desktop CPU like Ryzen 5 2400G with loads of RAM would take me somewhere. It took the machine around 71 seconds.

EDIT: could you measure C compilation. For example:

  git clone --depth 1 --branch v5.12.4 "git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/stable/linux.git"
  cd linux
  make defconfig
  time make -j$(getconf _NPROCESSORS_ONLN)
For me it's slightly below 5 minutes.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by danieldk on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:31PM (#27186539)
It took the machine around 71 seconds.

Are you including download time? On my Ryzen 7 3700X, it's done in 17 seconds.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by hawski on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:12PM (#27187871)
Specifically I did it two times to not see the download/syncing time. Also to a fresh home. 3700X has 16 threads, 2400G has 8, that probably makes up for the most of the difference. But M1 has 8 cores (4× high-performance + 4× high-efficiency. Maybe rust version also counts? I'm on rust 1.48.

EDIT: I checked on 1.52.1, which is latest stable and it went down to 54 seconds. So that also makes up a significant difference.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by thefourthchime on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:24PM (#27186448)
It's been amazing for me.... EXCEPT for when resuming from sleep, for some reason it would be very slow for a minute.

I have since FIXED THIS! The solution is to just not let it sleep. I'm using Amphetamine and since then it has been amazingly fast all the time.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by RankingMember on Monday May 17, 2021 @02:27PM (#27186482)
> I'm using Amphetamine and since then it has been amazingly fast all the time.

I think these app makers might need to start focus grouping some of these app names. Not only is it going to be harder to search for this app, but it'll inevitably also lead to some humorous misunderstandings.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by sgerenser on Monday May 17, 2021 @08:47PM (#27190116)
They already got pulled from the App Store (although Apple reversed course after significant badgering): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25605880
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by elcomet on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:31AM (#27183159)
Is 22 seconds insetad of 34 seconds so much faster ? The difference does not feel huge to me
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by leetcrew on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:36AM (#27183211)
yes, it compiled the project in 35% less time. doesn't really matter much for such a small project, but imagine if on a larger project the intel part took an hour and the m1 did it in 39 minutes. that's a substantial speedup. of course, we might see different results after leaving the turbo window.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cptskippy on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:36AM (#27184649)
You're assuming that the scaling is linear though. What if there's a fixed 10 second ding on x86? That 39 minute compile on the m1 would only be 39:10 on the x86.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coder543 on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:00PM (#27184958)
> What if there's a fixed 10 second ding on x86?

There isn't.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jfrunyon on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:33PM (#27189653)
And yet it is extremely unlikely that it's linear or anywhere near it.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coder543 on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:47PM (#27189764)
What is "linear" in this context? If the Y-axis is performance, what is the X-axis? That statement doesn't seem to make much sense without any additional explanation.

If I run a benchmark for a program on the M1, that's a single data point. It's hard to call a single data point "linear", "quadratic", or anything else... and you can't really put multiple benchmarks on the X-axis, because they're measuring different things.

What would even make it (whatever "it" is) "extremely unlikely"? People have had over 6 months to run benchmarks on the M1. Surely you can find a concrete answer to your question that doesn't involve random speculation on internet forums?

Based on my own experiences, I have no reason to believe that the M1's performance starts tanking if you run it for longer than a few seconds, in case you're implying that the other processors will "catch up" if they have longer to get up to speed... why would they? That makes no sense either. Longer compilations are faster on M1 too, relative to my Intel hexacore MBP, from what I've seen in the past. I mean, obviously, right? Why wouldn't they be? Intel's processors change frequencies in milliseconds... it doesn't take them minutes to warm up.

The M1 isn't a silver bullet. AMD makes laptop processors that are more powerful. But the M1 is still really good for what it is, and those AMD processors consume notably more power than the M1 to achieve their performance.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cptskippy on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @10:19AM (#27194898)
> I have no reason to believe that the M1's performance starts tanking if you run it for longer than a few seconds

This statement speaks volumes about your bias. You're immediately on the defensive and assuming we're attacking the M1 rather than the assumptions made in a test and it's methodology.

No one was implying that the M1's performance would tank. I specifically conjectured that perhaps x86, not M1, might have a penalty.

The original assertion made was that all x86 compiles were ~30% slower than the M1, but the benchmark was a ~20 compile. What happens if the compile is hours?

If the penalty is ~30% linear then a 60 minute compile on M1 is 80 minutes on x86. But if there's just a 10 second warmup penalty on x86 the compile time might only be 60 minutes + 10 seconds.

The truth is probably somewhere in between.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coder543 on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @10:26AM (#27194993)
> But if there's just a 10 second warmup penalty on x86 the compile time might only be 60 minutes + 10 seconds.

But that doesn't make any sense, as I previously asserted. That's just not how any of this works. x86 is not suffering a "penalty". It doesn't need time to "warmup". I already discussed my views (based on actual real world experience) on all of this, but you conveniently bypassed those statements.

> This statement speaks volumes about your bias. You're immediately on the defensive and assuming we're attacking the M1 rather than the assumptions made in a test and it's methodology.

It really doesn't speak volumes. The default position I've seen is for people to assume that new technology is just a gimmick, and that results are only being cherry picked. And that's exactly what you just said you were assuming ("the truth is probably somewhere in between"), so I was right to reach that conclusion. No one here (that I've seen) is claiming the M1 is the unequivocal performance champion in all things, but it does really well in some use cases that impress me as a developer.

If it's really just about test methodology, you would just look up other tests, or run your own. Putting out completely unfounded statements like "what if there's a fixed 10 second ding on x86?" doesn't move the conversation forward when the hardware and results are so readily available. It's just a way of attempting to cast doubt on results. There's little need for speculation at this point, but you continue to speculate in defense of your previous comment without apparently having any hands on experience with M1.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jfrunyon on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:38PM (#27236327)
> But that doesn't make any sense, as I previously asserted.

Correct. It is an extreme used as an illustration to point out that you can not simply take the time savings on one compile and assume it will save the same percentage on a longer compile. I am not sure why that is so difficult for you to comprehend, particularly since cptskippy has specifically said "The truth is probably somewhere in between."

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cptskippy on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @11:23AM (#27195864)
> But that doesn't make any sense, as I previously asserted.

Where did you assert that in our thread?

> It really doesn't speak volumes.

It does, you immediately assume someone is attacking the M1 because we question someone's assertion that the M1 is 30 something percent faster based on one small compilation benchmark.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by coder543 on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @11:35AM (#27196075)
> Where did you assert that in our thread?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27189764

"[...] in case you're implying that the other processors will "catch up" if they have longer to get up to speed... why would they? That makes no sense either. Longer compilations are faster on M1 too, relative to my Intel hexacore MBP, from what I've seen in the past. I mean, obviously, right? Why wouldn't they be? Intel's processors change frequencies in milliseconds... it doesn't take them minutes to warm up."

This is where I asserted that.

The only way there could be a "10 second penalty" is if the Intel processor just takes 10 seconds to warm up, and then it's on even footing after that point.

Intel processors takes milliseconds to change frequencies, so... clearly this is not a logical discussion point.

> It does, you immediately assume [...]

You actually misinterpreted my comment, possibly because you didn't read the rest of the paragraph that I copied above in this comment.

I didn't assume in that comment that anyone was "attacking M1" in the way you keep implying, based on the sentence fragment that you had cherry picked in your previous response. When I said that the M1 performance wouldn't tank, I clarified in that same paragraph that I meant this to be a relative measure compared to the Intel processor, since the Intel processor had its time to warm up and suddenly be super fast. If you read the whole paragraph, you should be able to see what I actually said.

If anything, I was defending Intel's Turbo Boost technology... which is the opposite of the conclusion you apparently jumped to.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cptskippy on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:22PM (#27198859)
> in case you're implying that the other processors will "catch up" if they have longer to get up to speed... why would they?

I never implied that x86 would catch up or even surpass the M1. I was suggesting that x86 might have some sort of delayed start but that actual compilation might occur at a similar pace to the M1.

The OP had a single data point based on a sub 60 second execution of a small project and extrapolated it out to a 30+ minute compilation of a larger project for comparison. He suggested that on a graph of Compile Time based on Project Size the divergence in performance might be linear.

I was merely suggesting there might be something else at play causing a delayed start of compilation on the x86 side. You came in and authoritative shut me down and then tried to suggest that we were being vague with our use of the term linear.

Imagine two runners that can keep similar pace but one always starts the race with his shoes untied and has to lace up as part of the race. Once he's laced up he can start running and will keep pace with the other runner, who has a head start, but will always be behind. That's what I was suggesting. In this analogy the length of the race is irrelevant.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jfrunyon on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:34PM (#27236266)
The X-axis is complexity. Please go back and re-read the context of my comment.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by mousepilot on Monday May 17, 2021 @12:58PM (#27185601)
I'd gladly spend 14 seconds if it helps me avoid Apple products!
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by tobyhinloopen on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:45AM (#27183295)
How long does it take on a Ryzen 9 5950X
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by Synaesthesia on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:04AM (#27183537)
Note that's a 16 core CPU with 105W TDP compared to a quad core < 10W M1
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:00AM (#27184220)
5850U is an 8 core CPU with a TDP that is adjustable between 10-25w. If you want to keep it to 4 cores just so it is a fair fight, there's the 5400U/5450U. AMD does pretty well...
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by Synaesthesia on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @08:17AM (#27193627)
Yeah I'd say the M1 and latest AMD CPUs are virtually tied for fastest single threaded performance, edging out the best by Intel.

But for something like compilation which is multithreaded obviously the higher core count will win.

Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jbverschoor on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:21AM (#27183725)
Yup, and the new macbook pro will probably be twice as fast
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by ChuckNorris89 on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:46AM (#27184038)
Source?
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jbverschoor on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:38PM (#27185992)
Gut feeling ;-)
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by InvaderFizz on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:48AM (#27184810)
Ran a few cycles on my 5950x hackintosh:

  invaderfizz@FIZZ-5950X:~$ hyperfine 'cargo -q install -f ripgrep'
  Benchmark #1: cargo -q install -f ripgrep
    Time (mean ± σ):     19.190 s ±  0.392 s    [User: 294.890 s, System: 17.144 s]
    Range (min … max):   18.352 s … 19.803 s    10 runs
The CPU was averaging about 50% load, the dependencies go really fast when they can all parallel compile, but then the larger portions are stuck with single-thread performance.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by peteri on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:28PM (#27189187)
My 5950X came in faster running in WSL2, but then I do have a Samsung 980 PRO running in a PCIe 4.0 slot.

  Benchmark #1: cargo -q install -f ripgrep
    Time (mean ± σ):     11.585 s ±  0.474 s    [User: 176.733 s, System: 5.677 s]
    Range (min … max):   11.271 s … 12.867 s    10 runs
Which I suspect leans towards an IO bottleneck.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by V1ndaar on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:12PM (#27189052)
Just for reference (5950x too): ran 3 times just measuring with `time` on void linux using cargo from xbps. Mean of the last two runs (first was syncing and downloading) was ~13.8 s.
Re:How M1 Macs feel faster than Intel models: it’s about QoS by jfrunyon on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:49AM (#27183352)
Okay, compiling is faster. But you compile once and run many times. What about running it?