6 seconds on the Ryzen, vs 9 seconds on the M1 air.
`time go build -a`, so not very scientific. Could be attributed to the multicore performance of the Ryzen.
Starting applications on the M1 seems to have significant delays too, but I'm not sure if that's a Mac OSX thing. Overall it's very impressive, I just don't see the same lunch eating performance as everyone else.
The battery life and lack of fans is wonderful.
edit: Updated with the arm build on OSX. 16s -> 9 seconds.
A tool I have enjoyed using to make these measurements more accurate is hyperfine[0].
In general, the 3700X beating the M1 should be the expected result... it has double the number of high performance cores, several times as much TDP, and access to way more RAM and faster SSDs.
The fact that the M1 is able to be neck and neck with the 3700X is impressive, and the M1 definitely can achieve some unlikely victories. It'll be interesting to see what happens with the M1X (or M2, whatever they label it).
All this said, there really is no comparison. I don’t even think about battery for the M1, I leave the charger at home, and it’s 100% cool and silent. It’s a giant leap for portable creative computing.
That's a Mac OSX thing. It's verifying the apps.
https://appletoolbox.com/why-is-macos-catalina-verifying-app...
Both of these are first-time launch issues, so comparing launch times on the second launch is probably more reasonable.
However, to quote @Dylan16807 from similar discussion few weeks ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26118415):
> The analog parts are the slow parts.
And the Annobit IP includes the analog parts as a large piece of their value add.
In practice, the I/O performance of M1-based Macs is comparable to random PCIE 3.0 NVMe drive. (I'm typing this comment on M1 MBP, I'm well aware how it performs).
time GOARCH=amd GOOS=linux go build -a
6s for the M1 too!
In addition: let’s talk upgradability or repairability. Oh wait, Apple doesn’t play that game. You’ll get more mileage on the workstation hands-down.
The only win for those those chips I think is battery efficient for a laptop. But, then why not just VNC into a beastmode machine on a netbook and compile remotely? After all, that’s what CI/CD pipeline is for.
No good way to check for it, because no LEDs on the outside. Only way to check is to see if the fans switched on after five minutes in the bag.
You are better of with a business or workstation laptop.
There are other laptops that are similar or superior build quality to those from Apple (N.B. - older MacBooks, not the newer ones) but those are also easy to spot. They’ll usually be ThinkPads or some XPS models from dell.
Consumer grade PC hardware has terrible build quality, and regardless of the price of your unit, the consumer build spec is just inferior to the business/professional lines. Asus, MSI, Sony, Acer, etc laptops all have consumer grade build quality and they just aren't designed to last a decade.
> They’ll usually be ThinkPads or some XPS models from dell.
Precision/XPS and Thinkpad models (with the exception of the L and E series) are almost always in the same price range as a MacBook. Any business-class machine (Thinkpad, Precision/Latitude, Elitebook) should easily last >5 years. These are vendors which will sell you 3-5 year on-site warranties for their laptops.
This is why you can find so many off-lease corporate laptops on eBay from any model year in the last 10 years or so. The hardware doesn't break, it just becomes obsolete.
(I do hear that their business support is pretty good though)
~8 years ago; within 48h of the laptop breaking - had a Dell repair tech sitting at my kitchen table replacing mainboard on an XPS laptop. Has turnaround when you have the proper support contracts gotten that much worse?
(admittedly, we did pay for the top support tier for a personal device as it was expensed for work. I wouldn't do anything else from any manufacturer though unless I had on-site tech support/replacement.)
If it wasn't for the replacement keyboard warranty offered by Apple a good chunk of butterfly keyboard Macs would be useless junk due to the fact it's so hard to replace them. Frayed MagSafe adapters were a regular occurrence. And swollen batteries pushing up the top case not that rare either.
I think maybe people keep MacBooks longer, but it probably has more to do with the fact they spent so much on them that they feel it's worthwhile to repair/pay for AppleCare than them actually being magically more durable.
The Thinkpad is obviously no powerhouse, but still works great for general desktop use, ie. browsing, email, document editing, music, video (1080p h264 is no problem). The desktop plays GTA V at around 40-50 FPS at 1080p with maximum settings. And this isn't some premium build, it's a pretty standard Asrock motherboard with Kingston ValueRAM and a Samsung SSD.
Decade-old hardware is still perfectly viable today.
Is this how you work?
This is exactly how I've worked for a number of years now, for my home/personal/freelance work. Usually using a Chromebook netbook ssh'ing into my high spec home server. I'd do the same for work, but work usually requires using a work laptop (MacBook).
OTOH, the machine that I'm connecting to has 32c/64t, half a terabyte of RAM and dozens of TB of storage.
Ok I'll bite, what do you do? Do you think halving the number of cores / RAM would impact your productivity?
All that and my preferred OS (Manjaro/XFCE), which runs on anything, has been more stable than any Mac I've ever owned. Every update to macOS has broken something or changed the UI drastically and in a way I have no control over...
If I ever switch away from desktops, it will be for a Framework laptop or something similar.
I think it’s valid to want not to have to deal with the cognitive overhead of UI evolution.
It’s equally valid not to want to deal with the cognitive overhead of various attributes of Linux.
What’s not obvious is why people sneer about it.
Everything in the machine can be upgraded/fixed so it should be good for a while.
I’m not saying this to be snarky. I just want to emphasize that while M1 is great innovation, I put repairability/maintainability and longevity on a higher pedestal than other things. I also highly value many things a computer has to offer: disk, memory, CPU, GPU, etc. I want to be able to interchange those pieces; and I want to have a lot of each category at my disposal. Given this, battery life is not as important as the potential functionality a given machine can provide.
I suspect the number of people, even developers, for whom 16GB memory is plenty probably greatly exceeds the number who need a beast mode Ryzen. But even then, a large proportion of the devs who might need a Build farm on the back end would be doing that anyway so they might as well have an M1 Mac laptop regardless.
Anyway Mac Pro models will come.
For me, SoC power draw when compiling apps is usually around 15 to 18W on a M1 mac mini.
My example app (deadbeef) compiles in about 60 seconds on that mac mini.
On a 2019 i7 16” MBP (six core), it takes about 90 seconds, and draws ~65W for that period.
So… radically more power efficient.
edit: this is the same version of macOS (big sur), xcode, and both building a universal app (intel and ARM).
Is it all CPU though, or is building ARM artefacts less resource intensive than bulding ones for Intel ?
18 core iMac Pro 13339: https://browser.geekbench.com/macs/imac-pro-late-2017-intel-...
M1 Mac mini 7408: https://browser.geekbench.com/macs/mac-mini-late-2020
My exact sentiments. I've been looking for a gateway into Apple and the M1 Air seems like it. It has now become a matter of time and not just a fleeting thought.
I’ve been blown away with games running on M1. If Apple could up their GPU game as well, that’d be really cool.
I don't use Rust, but a quick search returned for example this issue:
And I really care about rust compile times because I spend a lot of small moments waiting for the compiler to run.
I keep hearing this but have not experienced this in person. I usually get about 5 hours of life out of it. My usual open programs are CLion, WebStorm, Firefox (and Little Snitch running in the background).
However, even with not having IDEs open all the time, and switching over from Firefox to Safari, I’m only seeing about 8 hours of battery life (which is still nice compared with my 2013 MBP that has about 30 minutes of battery life).
I would consider getting a warranty replacement. Something is wrong.
For reference, my M1 Air averages exactly 12 hours of screen-on time (yes, I've been keeping track), and the absolute worst battery life I've experienced is 8.5 hours, when I was doing some more intense dev workflows.
Apple seems to have taken the power reduction with the A14 and M1 on TSMC 5nm, not the performance increase.
>The one explanation and theory I have is that Apple might have finally pulled back on their excessive peak power draw at the maximum performance states of the CPUs and GPUs, and thus peak performance wouldn’t have seen such a large jump this generation, but favour more sustainable thermal figures.
https://www.anandtech.com/show/16088/apple-announces-5nm-a14...
The comparison is way too close given the ryzen workstation guzzles power, and the macbook is cheaper, portable and lasts 22 hours on a single charge. If Apple can keep their momentum going year over year with CPU improvements, they'll be unstoppable. For now it looks like its not a question of if I'll get one, but when.