News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Thorentis on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:01AM (#27048415)
Why couldn't we just have stuck with yellow? Introducing skin tone provided no advantage and just opened a can of worms.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jakobnissen on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:13AM (#27048482)
It's US's current cultural trend, which is now enforced on the rest of the world, and also on our descendants who may have different sensibilities.

Maybe the Unicode Consortium should spend their energy on the real problem of third world languages underrepresented in the Unicode standard and spend less energy on the racial and sexual identity of pictograms.

Related: https://modelviewculture.com/pieces/i-can-text-you-a-pile-of...

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:09AM (#27048879)
> also on our descendants who may have different sensibilities

Unicode describes flags of nations that no longer exist, dead languages, etc - I don’t see why having a few pictograms that may or may not be relevant in 1000 years time is the place to draw the line. If skin tones play a role in pictographic communication today, then that’s good enough for inclusion.

Put another way: Unicode seeks to describe all human written language. Emojii is unusual in that TUC is actively playing a role in the evolution of the language, but they’re still trying to describe a written language the way people want to use it. This feature sees a lot of use, which to me says that TUC has correctly described how people want to use pictographic communication.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jakobnissen on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:19AM (#27048945)
The problem is that it's not about human language. If it was about human language, the consortium would give a shit about Bengali speakers. It's about the sensibilities of a small, particular group of privileged people, in a particular time at a particular place, who consider their weird priorities to be universal.

Let's not forget that adding all this complexity to Unicode has a real burden for people who implement Unicode. In practice, the consortium has to prioritize what symbols to support. So, in practice, it's less "embracing all variants of human expression", and more "the ability to communicate in your native language doesn't matter as much as the gender identity of this police emoji".

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:27AM (#27049009)
What’s wrong with the Bengali character set? A Google search doesn’t show any discussion on limitations here. And while power and privilege do inevitably play an unintended role in prioritization, Unicode successfully encodes several entirely dead languages - so it’s not like everything not relevant to English speakers has fallen by the wayside.

And while you’re correct that emojii do require some amount of UTC resources, it’s worth noting that most of that work is done by a special subcommittee to not distract from the mainline work of other languages, and that emojii have brought new attention and new volunteers to TUC - so I’m not sure how significant the impact of adding emojii to their workload really is.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by treebog on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:07AM (#27049356)
Blog post and interesting HN discussion on Bengali/Unicode https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9219162

I would summarize the key issues here, but they are complex and I don’t feel qualified to do them justice.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by dijit on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:04AM (#27049333)
The issues with Bengali writing are a large portion of TFA, I would highly recommend reading submitted articles before commenting.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by lupire on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:19AM (#27049458)
You appear to be confusing the submitted article with the article linked from a comment, with was put in context (and I'm being extremely charitable to the Bengali article OP with this language) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9219162
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:16AM (#27049436)
I apologize, I missed your link. But please don’t assume hostility for me missing a URL - I was clearly interested enough in the issue to do a Google search.

In any case, please see the comments on the HN post (linked by a sibling comment) for that. The issue is in fact wickedly complex, and it’s not clear (even among Bengali speakers) that this is a deficiency in Unicode (vs a deficiency in text entry and rendering software).

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by stdbrouw on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:33AM (#27049070)
> Let's not forget that adding all this complexity to Unicode has a real burden for people who implement Unicode.

We're talking about emoji for crying out loud, the entire idea is frivolous (and that's fine!)

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by colejohnson66 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:47AM (#27049190)
Technically, flag emojis are just two codepoints that encode two Latin letters. They are the “regional indicator symbols”[0]. This solves the problem of countries coming and going, and leaves the job of implementing them all to the font designer (through ligatures), not Unicode.

For example, the US flag is composed(?) as U+1F1FA U+1F1F8 (REGIONAL INDICATOR SYMBOL LETTER U) and U+1F1F8 (REGIONAL INDICATOR SYMBOL LETTER S).

It can get even crazier with “emoji tags”[1]. Say you want to encode the flag for California, US. You’d think it’d be done using those regional indicators as “CA”, but that’s actually Canada. The way to do it is: U+1F3F4 U+E0075 U+E0073 U+E0063 U+E0061 U+E007F. This encodes a black emoji flag, “USCa” in tag characters, and a “tag cancel” code point.

Basically, if your font has symbols for countries that don’t exist yet, or are missing some, that’s on the font designer, not Unicode.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regional_indicator_symbol

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tags_(Unicode_block)

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:56AM (#27049261)
True, but Unicode does say that all alpha-2 codes are valid. So while Unicode isn’t saying “this is a list of countries you need flags for”, they do say “go here to find the list of countries you need flags for” - which is mostly a (reasonable) decision to punt political pressure onto somebody else :)

So all that to say: Unicode is still representing language and/or written culture as it is at a point in time (which may be less relevant in the future) - and that’s OK, and absolutely compatible with their aims.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by NoGravitas on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:04AM (#27049334)
I'm just happy we have three ancient Egyptian hieroglyphic penises in Unicode. Mobile keyboard developers need to step up and make them more easily accessible, though.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by smithmayowa on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:45AM (#27050495)
I'm not american, I'm African but I find the black toned emojis to be ideal for me, I wish all face emoji's were available in other skin tones.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by batch12 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:54AM (#27049243)
My hope is that our children transcend this division and look back with bewilderment.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:14PM (#27052695)
The Unicode Consortium is a consortium, big enough to work on multiple issues at once. If you think the consortium should work on third world languages, then you should join the consortium and work on third world languages.

https://www.unicode.org/consortium/joinform.html

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Rayhem on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:06PM (#27054997)
This doesn't at all track as an argument. The US government is far larger than the Unicode Consortium, and I do feel that the government should work on fixing some of our crumbling infrastructure. That does not at all mean I should join the government to do so. Moreover, any number of people in this thread believe they should work on skin tone variants; should they all join to advance that work?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:44PM (#27055534)
Actually, participating in your local government is a pretty effective way to ensure that your viewpoint is represented.

It's true that "any number of people" in this tread believe that the consortium's efforts towards skin tone variants are a good thing. Is anybody here calling for more work to be done in this area? Those are the people who I'd make a similar recommendation to.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by qwerty456127 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:59AM (#27050720)
Why do these require much energy? Unicode is big, why not just add everything? I still am pissed of by the fact they rejected Tengwar - how much energy would it take to add (id nobody opposed)?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by lucas_codes on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:31AM (#27048582)
Although yellow seems like it's good for everyone (since no one is actually yellow), it ends up still representing the majority. Just look at the Simpsons - all the characters are yellow, but not Apu.

Also skin tone options are extremely popular with people of colour - probably because they feel the default yellow doesn't represent them.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by mort96 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:11AM (#27050901)
> All characters are yellow, but not Apu.

This is a great example. All the yellow characters in The Simpsons are coded white (from my recollection).

Nobody is actually yellow, but bright yellow skin is very clearly obviously not black or dark brown; it's much more functionally similar to light skin tones.

Maybe the "true" solution would be to use a color that's completely different from all skin tones, such as a very deep blue color. But my immediate reaction to the thought of deep blue emoji is that I wouldn't identify with them - which, again, kind of proves the point that bright yellow is much easier to identify with for light-skinned people

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by tylerf on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:48AM (#27051429)
PBS Kids did a good job with this, in my opinion, with their green characters. [0] I think replacing the default yellow skin with green would be a good thing.

That said, the on-going work into representing all humans in emojis is wonderful, and I really admire the clever technical solutions like this handshake proposal.

[0] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/7/76/PBS_Kid...

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jozvolskyef on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:23AM (#27048981)
I'd wager that the popularity of dark emojis has more to do with their contrast and less with politics. Most dark people in the world aren't minorities where they live.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by lupire on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:22AM (#27049480)
Contrast on what sense?

Would dark mode users prefer yellow?

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by recursive on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:30AM (#27050305)
In the sense of contrasting significantly from light backgrounds.

Maybe.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:14PM (#27051825)
I haven't watched the Simpsons, but it's really unfortunate that they did that. I suppose the problem with fictional skin colors is people will always assume it represents the racial majority. Similar to how icons are usually coded male in the absence of female signifiers.

I wonder if it's possible to avoid that. What if at the outset, we'd used a different color for every emoji? Smile could be green, frown could be blue, wink could be yellow, etc.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by watwut on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:49PM (#27052342)
I think that Simpsons never intended their characters to be race neutral. They are social/cultural parodie where it is always pretty clear who exactly they make jokes about.

There are also some episodes that are very clearly explicitly about race. If nothing else, the use of n-word makes it super clear who is white.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by virologist on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:58AM (#27048790)
i have never seen a yellow person except in cartoons and emoji
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by SamBam on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:12AM (#27049398)
What race do you think the yellow characters on the Simpsons are supposed to represent?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by johnhenry on Friday May 07, 2021 @10:13AM (#27076093)
If anyone on this thread has any doubt, here is Homer Simpson explicitly declaring that he is a "white male": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t28ZB1t6gg8&ab_channel=Mostl...
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by toto444 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:11AM (#27050037)
Homo Sapiens?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by thejoeflow on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:54AM (#27051531)
*Homer Sapiens
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by SamBam on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:08PM (#27051729)
That's a species.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fuzzer37 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:08AM (#27050003)
A null race that doesn't exist
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by SamBam on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @02:19PM (#27053639)
So, Carl Carlson, Dr. Hibbert and Bleeding Gums Murphy are pretty clearly Black, Apu is pretty clearly Indian, Bumble Bee man is pretty clearly Mexican, but all the yellow characters are... "a null race?"

Despite all clearly having signifiers of white people, and several of them clearly ethnically Italian or German, and most of the rest being Waspy?

Does this not simply speak of what you perceive as the "null race" or, perhaps, default race?

And when the Simpson's producers said a few years ago that they were going to stop voicing non-white characters with non-white actors, who did they find to voice all the "null-race" characters?

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by moate on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:18AM (#27050142)
So the majority of people are yellow, and yet we still have black/brown characters (Bleeding Gums Murphy, Apu, Carl, Dr. Hibbert, etc) and most East Asian characters were given almond shaped eyes.

It's almost like there's a correspondence with the "average" yellow Simpson's character and some real world US ethnic majority...

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by devmunchies on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:43AM (#27051370)
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by autoreleasefool on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:59AM (#27051609)
This is actually further to the point, all the examples you’ve given are explicitly racially diverse characters, meaning that yellow does in fact represent the majority, and implies whiteness.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by devmunchies on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:08PM (#27051742)
> meaning that yellow does in fact represent the majority, and implies whiteness

in The Simpsons, yes.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Chris2048 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:01AM (#27048816)
> it ends up still representing the majority

What does that mean though? I see Fat Tony as Italian-American, Rainier Wolfcastle as Austrian, and Akira as Japanese. The majority of the population of Springfield, which is supposed to be somewhere in North America, is probably "white".

So the context of the show itself, and how characters are portrayed imply their race/nationality. This is not true of an emoji.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by lupire on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:29AM (#27049555)
Th color isn't neutral. A neutral color choice would be green like Android, that's an orthognat color to human melanin spectrum/range.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Chris2048 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:04PM (#27058723)
Which humans are bright yellow?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by helipad on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:48AM (#27049746)
IIRC Akira is a different shade of yellow compared to most of the characters.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Chris2048 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:04PM (#27058722)
Similar shade to sideshow Mel, who I think is either British, or Dutch.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by moate on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:19AM (#27050171)
His eyes are also drawn squinting.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Latty on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:43AM (#27048676)
I wonder why I see the take "I don't use this thing/see the value, therefore it is bad and shouldn't exist." so much more on HN than anywhere else? It's such a weird view.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:20AM (#27048957)
In my opinion it’s part of the famous hackernews shallow/middlebrow dismissal that PG described almost a decade ago. “This isn’t my use case, and is therefore worthless” is also very similar to the famous “This is silly, anybody could build this” top comment on the Dropbox launch post. It’s not limited to HN either - see the Reddit comments on any movie not targeted at the 20-30 male demographic, or hackaday comments on anything looking to improve usability.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by username90 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:11AM (#27048897)
I didn't read his statement like that at all. Sounds like just your biased take about opinions you don't like, and that you don't find opinions you don't like much outside HN.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by halfmatthalfcat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:50AM (#27049212)
The statement "Introducing skin tone provided no advantage" is pretty ignorant and unaware, especially when skin tone variants are widely used so they objectively hold some utility. At best it's an uninformed and lazy take, at worst it's someone showing their lack of empathy and distain for people who don't look like them.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by hombre_fatal on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:32AM (#27049585)
Huh? What if they just don’t think it’s something worth having in unicode? This does just seem like disdain for opinions you don’t hold.

I think it would also be unnecessary to add modifiers to unicode that let me, say, represent a glyph of a man in a dress, or a modifier that lets you use those family emojis while clarifying that one of the parents is an amputee. Just because you can find someone who can write a twitter thread on why those additions are absolutely necessary doesn’t mean I’m lazy or disdainful or, let’s say, transphobic/ableist.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by halfmatthalfcat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:36AM (#27049624)
What is it to you what is put in Unicode? Seriously, how does it affect you in anyway what is put into Unicode? We should be making things _more_ accessible and if that means adding all of the necessary variations of emoji to represent humanity, as it is, than I'm all for that and so should everyone else because it costs us literally zero to do.

Any argument to the contrary really needs to examine from what angle they're making their argument because they are not based on empathy but something of the opposite.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by hombre_fatal on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:53AM (#27049803)
I don’t like encumbering our communications with the crowd madness of the age.

You could make your same argument for “latinx”. Who cares if people on NPR say it? It’s harmless and inclusive! Well, that’s where we disagree.

Once again, attacking arguments that you disagree with by asserting they come from a place of bad character isn’t a discussion. It also seems like you risk giving yourself too much credit by seeing your views as some sort of paragon of virtues like empathy, thus anyone who disagrees must be against your self-appointed virtues.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by halfmatthalfcat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:10AM (#27050018)
People making argument against their inclusion (futilitously) are doing so in bad faith under various reductionist arguments like not wanting to make a complex language more complex when there are aspects to our language that _should_ be changed.

The arguments against are not based on any logical or rational footing (because adding them is trivial and people want them to be added) so the assumption is that they are making arguments on emotion. Why would someone argue against inclusion based emotion? Because they don't want to be inclusive. You don't have to arrive at this conclusion because you believe you have some moral superiority, you can arrive on it based on common sense.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by nitrogen on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:13PM (#27052690)
The arguments against are not based on any logical or rational footing

How convenient it must be to believe oneself to be in exclusive possession of logic and reason. This is not the way to charitably interpret an argument.

The biggest reason these features should never have been added in the first place: the more opportunities everyone has to notice and be reminded of everyone's differences, the longer those differences will remain divisive.

The saying used to be, "On the Internet nobody knows you are a dog." We were all brought together by the common language of text. I became friends with people of many nations, colors, and sexual backgrounds. Now, every single interaction has to be labeled with your "identity," as if a single color code point could remotely capture that, and it drives us all apart.

This is amplifying exclusivity in the name of inclusivity.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by halfmatthalfcat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @02:56PM (#27054125)
The biggest reason these features should never have been added in the first place: the more opportunities everyone has to notice and be reminded of everyone's differences, the longer those differences will remain divisive.

So because people are discriminatory, we shouldn't be more inclusive at the risk of enabling those who...discriminate? The only reason these issues are divisive is because those who are insecure with their personal identity make them divisive. We shouldn't appease discriminators at the cost of letting people express their true identities.

Also, you cannot "remotely capture" ethnicity and culture in a single color code, even yellow. Yellow is light and implies a lighter skin. It's inherently (no matter how you want to argue it) promoting or portraying human skin as light.

I'm not sure where you get to your conclusion but it seems like, based on the adoption of skin tone variants, the only ones amplifying exclusivity are those that want things to stay exclusive.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by andrewzah on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:14AM (#27050081)
Unlike latinx, people actually use the skin-tone emojis. I see them used quite a lot, actually. You can disagree if you want, but usage states otherwise, and I'm glad that we're adding emoji that actually get used.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by madeofpalk on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:19AM (#27050156)
I don't use kubernetes, but I'm not going to post on every HN article about it that i don't think it should exist.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:31AM (#27049054)
Last fall, I found the plist files which control OS X's character picker, and spent an evening backporting seven years worth of new emojis to OS X 10.9 Mavericks[1]. The one thing I couldn't get working was skin tone variants, because Mavericks has no concept of them. All emojis in the picker are yellow.

Anyway, a couple of weeks ago I got a really nasty email accusing me of being all sorts of racial things, because I hadn't included skin tones. I don't know if this person was just trolling or crazy or what, but they were really mad! I'd never received an email like this before, so I was pretty upset.

1: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/updating-maverickss-emo...

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by eplanit on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:58AM (#27049274)
One complaint, from an irrationally upset person, can and should be ignored. It's way past time to stop giving power to the vocal minority.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by crumbshot on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:41AM (#27051347)
> Why couldn't we just have stuck with yellow?

It was because of a demonstrated demand for emojis with different skin tones to the default yellow. Before the Unicode Consortium had even considered this, there was a popular app called iDiversicons, which had similar emoji-like characters customisable with five different skin colour options, as images that could be copied by the user into their messages.

After trying and failing to convince Apple to allow their app to modify the iOS keyboard to make these easier to enter, the authors of the app took a broader approach, and wrote a proposal to the Consortium to include their emojis as standard:

https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2014/14154r-idiversicon-emoji-re... https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2014/14085-emoji.pdf

Based on this, the Consortium refined it into their own proposal that used the Fitzpatrick scale for skin tone modifiers:

https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2014/14172r-emoji-enhancements.p... https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2014/14173r-emoji-skin-tone.pdf https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2014/14174r-emoji-additions.pdf

And then, eventually, these were included in Unicode 8.0.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:47AM (#27048706)
From what I’ve seen, the skin tone feature sees lots of use (particularly in some minority communities), which to me is a good indication that this is something that people wanted.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:03AM (#27049919)
Not at all. Major apps and OSes put a "choose your race" message on their UI (and very strongly direct people to make that choice). This does not mean there was pre-existing latent demand for this.

What this shows is if you inject the concept of racial self-identity onto cartoon symbols, and afford people a way to navigate that selection, people can do that. Not that anyone wanted this, or that this feature is beneficial.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by andrewzah on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:19AM (#27050163)
"Not that anyone wanted this, or that this feature is beneficial."

Usage clearly states otherwise. No one is forced to use a particular skin tone (they can continue using the default yellow one).

This comment frankly is quite dismissive. Just because you don't use a feature doesn't mean "no one wanted it".

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:31AM (#27050326)
Users follow prompts, so "people choose a race when presented with a racialized emoji picker" doesn't mean "people want their emojis racialized". It means, people understand what they are being asked to do, and want to get back to their business.

You would need to have a theory of benefit, and then design a survey which tests users to understand if that benefit was achieved. You, frankly, are confused about causation -- we put a dialog in front of people and they made a selection, therefore people wanted this dialog?

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by andrewzah on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:39AM (#27050411)
"we put a dialog in front of people and they made a selection, therefore people wanted this dialog"

You're suggesting that it's impossible for people to have wanted a feature, because UXs have a popup showing people that it's possible to use that feature now. I disagree. You're projecting your personal opinion as everyone's personal opinion.

And that emoji picker still allows you to pick the default yellow color. So if people -really- didn't want to use them, they wouldn't.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:46AM (#27050514)
I'm not suggesting it's impossible. I'm saying you don't know what you claim to know, and to my knowledge nobody has tried to know it. People, such as yourself, assume that because this feature is used, it's desired. This is not at all warranted, given what we know about how people use computers.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:34AM (#27051229)
No, it's more like, we put up this dialog, and people didn't overwhelmingly pick jaundice. And therefore the available variety is preferred over less variety.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by recursive on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:33AM (#27050338)
Just because something is used a lot doesn't mean that any number of people wanted it.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by crazygringo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:55AM (#27050650)
If they're using something a lot that's non-default, and they have to go out of their way to select it...?

Yeah, it does mean those people want it.

There's literally no other way to interpret it.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:35AM (#27051248)
People choose to pay their taxes, therefore people want taxes. People choose to accept EULAs before they use software, therefore people want EULAs. People choose to stay with spouses with whom they occasionally fight, therefore people want fighting in their lives. People choose to navigate complex civil bureaucracies in order to get things done, therefore they want bureaucracy.

Or, people can suffer through a certain amount of bullshit in order to get to their goals. The word you're looking for is "instrumental" -- there's your missing interpretation.

At some point in the past ten or so years, the cultural discourse has devolved to such an extent that people cannot think even one move ahead. Zero tolerance manicheanism rules everything now.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by crazygringo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:23PM (#27054449)
None of those are analagous to the question at hand.

People are clearly using the emoji they want because they want to in and of itself, end of story.

They're not doing it to satisfy the government or access software or whatever. And no, I'm not looking for the word "instrumental", because emoji are about expression, which is literally the polar opposite of something being instrumental.

Sometimes it's not about looking twenty moves ahead. Some things are just valuable in and of themselves. Some things are about the moment. Perhaps that's the perspective you're missing here?

Just because some things are instrumental doesn't mean everything is. And thank goodness for that!

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:41PM (#27058922)
In my experience, "because I said so" is not a great argument.

Just one look at the way these color pickers are presented on first use, and how that selection becomes the default thereafter, tells you everything you need to know about the flimsy basis of your claims. The picker pops up and interrupts you while you're in the middle of writing a message, and then persists your choice. It's a speed bump on the way to your actual goal -- gosh, does anyone have a word for that sort of thing?

A person would have to be mighty well motivated to believe that this would be evidence of a latent demand for self-expression via skin tone.

[dead]
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by dang on Sunday May 09, 2021 @05:17AM (#27094481)
Please don't post flamewar comments to HN. It's not what this site is for. Crossing into personal attack is particularly not ok. No more of this, please.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by dang on Sunday May 09, 2021 @05:16AM (#27094479)
Whoa whoa whoa, please don't post like this. Obviously we have to ban accounts that do, regardless of how provocative or wrong the other person was or you feel they were.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by recursive on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:59PM (#27057466)
It's not clear to me that anyone went out of their way to select it. I mean, maybe they did. Maybe they didn't. I don't know all the UIs of all the devices that are capable of producing emoji characters.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kevincox on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:03PM (#27054951)
It's not non-default. When I used macOS every time I tried to send a new emoji for the first time it popped up a modal asking what colour I wanted. So the yellow was no more "default" than the skin-tone ones are.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by z0r on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:49AM (#27051453)
look, i'm not making a point specifically about the topic of this overall post. but DAU type metrics are used to justify all kinds of poor designs
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kalleboo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:36AM (#27050376)
> Major apps and OSes put a "choose your race" message on their UI (and very strongly direct people to make that choice)

I have literally never seen this, can you provide a few examples? I'm curious how it's presented.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:40AM (#27050428)
I don't mean they literally print these words. You can see how it's done if you search for "emoji color picker" or similar.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by watwut on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:15AM (#27050955)
The two phrases are massively different. One is asking you which color of emoji you prefer. Other is asking you which race you are.

The difference is big enough to make original statement lie - inflammatory lie that makes people outraged over something that dont exists.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#27051163)
>One is asking you which color of emoji you prefer. Other is asking you which race you are.

How would you recommend which emoji color I should pick? How do you imagine most people would navigate that decision?

>The difference is big enough to make original statement lie - inflammatory lie that makes people outraged over something that dont exists.

I'm very sorry that your notions of epistemology and morality are this underdeveloped, for you to be so confused about what lies are.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:36AM (#27051260)
> How would you recommend which emoji color I should pick?

Think for yourself, pick what you want to pick

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by watwut on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:04PM (#27051673)
Personally, I would use the one most people around me use.

The second choice for me would be the least bright one. I don't like how shiny bright colors mixed into text.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by barbazoo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:45AM (#27051389)
I've never in my life seen a OS or app ask me what my race is for the purpose of determining what emojis to show me. Is that really a thing?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:59PM (#27053327)
No, I'm shooting from the hip and exaggerating (slightly). When you're sending an emoji for the first time, an app typically presents you with a selection of skin colors for the hand or face icon you're choosing. My point is that this is a design decision to impart significance into racial self-identity.

So the entire exercise is tautological -- of course people pick a skin color, when you frame the choice as "pick your skin color before you send this (or don't and we'll just keep using the inhuman color, which might communicate its own signal, or just look weird when everyone else has a skin tone)". And of course it's meant to be informed by race.

We decided to present skin tone (race) as something important, and people responded as though it's important, is not a surprising finding.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by rsynnott on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:30PM (#27052058)
> Major apps and OSes put a "choose your race" message on their UI (and very strongly direct people to make that choice).

Eh? Never having set it, I went looking for the setting in Slack. It's so discreet that I had to Google it. I still have no idea where it might be in MacOS.

The idea that this is being forced on people is kind of absurd.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by hrktb on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:54AM (#27048772)
We can’t eternally keep the status quo just to avoid opening cans of worms. If we don’t intend to throw it away, we might as well open it and face the worms.

This all reaction reminds me of the “new” skin tone palette of band aids: some people were happy with the change, and it seems to me the impact for everyone else who liked the standard ones was null.

But there was sooooo many reactions against the very idea that more than one color was now available.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:00AM (#27048802)
I think skin tone color band aids are different, people have different skin tones and the old default only blended well on people with light skin so the new ones are nice for people.

With emoji people took a neutral non-racial thing and inserted race into it. In addition to the complexity of doing that well it just puts race and all the identity issues tied to it into a place it didn’t need to be. I think this generally makes things worse.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by SamBam on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:19AM (#27049459)
> neutral non-racial thing

But was it really?

Serious question: Do you think that if the majority of people in the US, and particularly the majority of middle and upper classes and tech folk, were Black that they would have defaulted to a yellow color for emoji?

That's not even getting into how all the "man" "woman" "child" etc emoji had stereotypical white-people hair etc.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kalleboo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:42AM (#27050442)
To expand on this: The original emoji were created in Japan and had light skin tone to match Japanese users[0] (with a few exceptions of other racial stereotypes - like "person wearing turban"[1]). After they gained international popularity, their rendering was changed to yellow in an attempt to be more neutral.

I'm guessing yellow was chosen to match the yellow "smiley face" which few had objected to historically

[0] https://emojipedia.org/apple/ios-6.0/boy/

[1] https://emojipedia.org/apple/ios-6.0/person-wearing-turban/

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:25AM (#27049517)
Make the color blue then if yellow isn’t neutral enough (like iMessage tapbacks, or Facebook thumbs up). Make the people more abstract.

I’d argue the direction should be towards generality not identity specificity.

I’m not dogmatic and obviously my point of view on this is a lost cause, but I generally think the universalist ideal is better and should be the goal.

I do think yellow was intentionally chosen to be universal and not to be read as “white”.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Timpy on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:49AM (#27049207)
I agree that it would be a more apt comparison if the original band-aid color where neon pink, or some other non-human-skin-tone.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:57AM (#27049269)
Yeah - even then it’s not perfect because people in real life may have a cosmetic interest in skin tone matching bandages. It’s not about inserting race, it’s about blending the bandage so it looks nice.

With emoji, it’s different - it’s explicitly about inserting race into a place it didn’t need to be. I think this type of thing is generally worse for society. It leads to people thinking about our differences more than our similarities.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by hrktb on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:40AM (#27049667)
One could argue the original band-aid was just rubber colored and non-racial in some way, but keeping ignoring it matched light color skins better was becoming a choice in itself.

Emojis are the same to me, in that they were introduced with very limited scope (original ones were simple outlines, with bright pink, blue or green faces). Then expanded and got more detailed, less caricatural, and stopped fitting a single byte.

IMO the can of worm got opened the moment we got detailed drawings with artistic choices that best match one category of people. We have shown we weren't limited in number, and accepted a ton of complexity to deal with flags or gender representations for instance, it would be tone-deaf to just go on saying it's too complex to also care about racial representations where they might apply.

If you're arguing for getting back to simple outlines of random colors, I'm with you. But I think we're not in a stable place right now to say "we made enough diversification, let's just stop here".

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:45AM (#27049706)
> “ If you're arguing for getting back to simple outlines of random colors, I'm with you.”

Yes that is what I want. I basically agree with everything you said - I just wish we chose generality over specificity.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by teachingassist on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:06AM (#27049973)
> Yes that is what I want.

You have it - use the yellow emoji.

If that's not good enough, then commission your own emoji font. Or, don't use emojis/don't use Unicode. And let other people communicate in the way that they want.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:32PM (#27052095)
I’m not talking about personal use?

I do use the neutral colors, I just think inserting identity into something is a worse outcome. Generality would be better.

See this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27049269

Or this one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27049517

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by teachingassist on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:46PM (#27052297)
Generality is not, in general, better - we all communicate with different symbols (including different letters and words, different languages and dialects and subtexts and slang) to evoke different aspects of language and communication.

Identity is extremely important to communication - I, personally, am communicating my opinion to you, personally.

If you want to stick to [what you consider] neutral or impersonal language in whatever aspect, you can. That option hasn't been removed from you.

If you want to impose your preference on others, that is to prevent other people from communicating effectively. I don't respect that.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:54PM (#27052416)
I'm not dogmatic about it and obviously my position is a lost cause, but I don't think inserting race into everything is better.

Race is socially constructed, lines between 'races' dissolve and change over time. Reinforcing our differences in software and communication unnecessarily over arbitrary categorizations and physical characteristics is worse for society (imo).

I think people should generally have the freedom to do what they want, but defaults and incentives matter - it's better to choose ones that lead to a better outcome when possible. That's all I'm getting at.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by teachingassist on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:02PM (#27052527)
Race is socially constructed, but skin colour is not - it's a physical attribute.

Emojis literally offer people the choice to use "Light Skin Tone", "Medium-Light Skin Tone", "Medium Skin Tone", "Medium-Dark Skin Tone" and "Dark Skin Tone".

Those are not racial differentiators.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fossuser on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:19PM (#27052760)
Yeah you're right of course - and that's the strongest argument in favor of them, but given how modern society operates today where people use skin tone as a (the main?) racial differentiator, the emoji's imply more than that.

If it was just hair color or something it would be different. It shouldn't be different (imo) and hopefully we eventually get to a world where they're just physical attributes. I just don't see this kind of thing helping in the mean time.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by watwut on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:21AM (#27048964)
> This all reaction reminds me of the “new” skin tone palette of band aids: some people were happy with the change, and it seems to me the impact for everyone else who liked the standard ones was null. But there was sooooo many reactions against the very idea that more than one color was now available.

And now we have superheroes band aids, Elsa band aids, transformers band aids, teddy bear band aids.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by akomtu on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @06:22PM (#27056570)
You'd be fired for this comment in any big american corp today. The big players in the US have been pushing a new version of the divide&conquer agenda to the poor so they wouldn't accidentally develop class conscience. Basically, most Americans are being divided along the gender and race lines: men vs women vs trans, and white vs black vs asian vs latino. The goal must be dividing the society into a few tens of alienated camps that don't talk to each other. This policy is being pushed hard at every level: from schools and offices, to DoD and WH. It's pretty much an awkward religion or rather a cult, with church, heresy, bishops and inquisition.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by PurpleFoxy on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:10AM (#27048465)
Because Unicode emoji started out with a bunch of crap they couldn’t ever say no to new proposals because someone will say “why do we need a man levitating emoji and not skin tone modifiers?” And while we are at it, we need a woman levitating and gender neutral person levitating.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by enriquto on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:33AM (#27048593)
How do you know if they are men or women? Just because of their hair? That's pretty non-inclusive!
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:40AM (#27051331)
The emoji is literally named "Man in Business Suit Levitating" by the unicode consortium
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by throw0101a on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:41AM (#27048665)
> Because Unicode emoji started out with

It started out with the 'base' symbols of a bunch of Japanese mobile carriers:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emoji#The_origin_of_emoji_pict...

If they simply stuck with supporting those for legacy reasons, then things would have been fine. But no line in the sand was drawn.

IMHO there should be a moratorium for (say) five years to let things settle, and see new ones are actually needed, or if it's just inertia driving recent additions.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by ceejayoz on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:12AM (#27048905)
Why? What's the downside to having a bunch?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by yummypaint on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:04AM (#27049936)
I can't think of one. There are already far too many of them to view at once on a phone, so adding more doesn't make things much more disorganized. Storage capabilities also grow faster than the standard adds new symbols.

Frankly I think it's a bad look when people suddenly become very passionate about opposing updates once they are reminded of the existence of dark skinned emojis. They're just silly little drawings, people. If someone is so upset by others being able to send silly little drawings that vaguely resemble themselves, they should do some introspecting.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by throw0101a on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:23AM (#27050227)
What problem does adding all of these random 'hieroglyphs' solve? We have:

* Grinning Face {, Big Eyes, Smiling Eyes, Sweat}

* (Slightly) Smiling Face {, Smiling Eyes, Halo, Hearts, Heart-Eyes}

* (Wo)man {,Bald, Red Hair, Curly Hair, White Hair, Blond Hair}

* Family: {{,M,W}, {M,W}, {,B,G}[1-2] }

* Leg, Foot, Ear (with Hearing Aide), Nose, Brain, Longs, Tooth, Bone, Eye(s), Tongue, Mouth

* {, Man, Woman} {Superhero, Supervillain, Mage, Fairy, Vampire, Elf, Genie, Zombie}

How many combinations / permutations do we need?

* https://emojipedia.org/people/

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by ceejayoz on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:29AM (#27050296)
> What problem does adding all of these random 'hieroglyphs' solve?

That's a dodge. You proposed a five year moratorium on new emoji. I'm asking what harm is caused by these that justifies that.

"I personally find them pointless" isn't a great reason to deny the folks who clearly find proposing and implementing them to be worthwhile.

(Side note: "Update your device to get the new emoji" is a great way to get folks doing their security patching regularly.)

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by throw0101a on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:45AM (#27050493)
Time used to implement all of these things is time not spent working on more 'useful' things. Like, from a comment up-thread, languages and scripts that people use in their daily lives:

* https://modelviewculture.com/pieces/i-can-text-you-a-pile-of...

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by teachingassist on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:36AM (#27049090)
The Simpsons (partially serious).

Coloring Black and Asian characters with skin tones, means that yellow in the Simpsons represents only white people.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by CyberRabbi on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:00AM (#27049294)
The Simpsons is not the authority on the meaning of yellow skin for generically representing human body parts. It’s a tv show. The iconic happy face symbol is not intended to specifically be a white person. Pac man is not a white person.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by andrewzah on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:22AM (#27050214)
I agree that they're not an -authority-, but the Simpsons is a huge cultural institution. They definitely made an impact on how the yellow tone is coded (as white).

So yes it seems silly, but I think a default of blue or green would be better.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by barbazoo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:47AM (#27051422)
This is a very North America centric view I think. The Simpsons aren't nearly as popular in other countries.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by teachingassist on Thursday May 06, 2021 @02:14PM (#27067151)
I tried to informally fact-check this and I found out (for example) that The Simpsons is dubbed into Luxembourgish.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by oblio on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:22AM (#27049484)
I've seen plenty of people use a different emoji skin tone. So there was demand for it, you just never noticed it.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by lucretian on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:07AM (#27048863)
> Introducing skin tone provided no advantage

awfully confident take.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by celticninja on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:40AM (#27048650)
Exactly, yellow was neutral and in line with emojis in general. Now do I have to decide on my skin tone? Will people get offended if I choose a darker tone?

And what would someone use a handshake emoji for exactly?

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by libeclipse on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:26AM (#27048553)
Agreed. The fallback emoji in particular is very confusing, doesn't look like a handshake, and is only necessary because of this particular solution to a problem that no one had.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by batch12 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:51AM (#27049226)
I don't have an issue with this-- if people find value in it, fine. I don't think I will use this though. There are too many combinations that I am too likely to get wrong.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by gumby on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:13AM (#27050922)
Why shouldn’t people have a way to express themselves that they want? Are there words or spellings that computers should refuse to display?

I am not a fan of how Unicode has treated emojis, but there is no question they are completely within scope in principle (they were part of extant keitai character sets) though the way they are being extended by the UCS makes me uncomfortable.

But so what? People like to use them which seems like enough justification.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 3v1n0 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:26AM (#27048552)
Well complexity in technology is not really something we try to stay away, is it?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by gwbas1c on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:23AM (#27049494)
Or just 100% get rid of skin tone and use an outline of a hand.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kalleboo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:52AM (#27050586)
Yeah, in retrospect going from the original Docomo-style of emoji[0] to the more graphical ones[1] was a step back

[0] https://emojipedia.org/docomo/

[1] https://emojipedia.org/softbank/

edit: although to be fair to Softbank, it seems their initial color version had pink faces https://emojipedia.org/softbank/1999/

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by planb on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:34AM (#27050357)
You could argue the same for gendered emojis.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Chris2048 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:51AM (#27048734)
It's funny how gender-neutral terms where sought after, but we need alternatives to race-neutral emojis.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by ceejayoz on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:13AM (#27048907)
"We should have options to choose from" is a pretty consistent approach.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by Chris2048 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:50AM (#27049217)
Until someone chooses white, and potentially benefits from it.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by ceejayoz on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:01AM (#27049299)
If using a white-skinned emoji gets you special treatment the yellow, brown, or black-skinned emoji does not, I think that's worth being concerned about.

Until that happens, there are probably bigger fish to fry.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by sim_card_map on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:18AM (#27048937)
emojis was a mistake
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by JoeyBananas on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:46PM (#27055563)
unicode itself is a terrible can of worms. There are so many edge cases that adding black emojis is hardly a big deal. Black emojis is not complicated compared to some of the languages out there.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by CyberRabbi on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:55AM (#27049247)
The appearance of skin tone emojis are bad enough but the thought that someone consciously took their time to choose the skin tone of the emoji that best matched their own in their mobile phone UI makes it that much more bad.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by bonaldi on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:25AM (#27049513)
Emojis communicate. Race of the speaker can add important context to the thing being communicated. Adding skin tone to emojis allows them to communicate this.

With emoji you can, in one glyph, raise your hand in a conversation to say, eg, "me too". With skin tone support, you can still raise your hand but can also say, "and I'm a person of colour" which may be a crucial piece of context for the conversation.

TLDR People need to talk about race. People talk using emojis. Skin tone allows them to talk about race while using emojis.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by f1refly on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:38AM (#27051285)
what could you possibly add to a debate that is altered by an emphasis your skin tone before you bring it up?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by bonaldi on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:58AM (#27051585)
I'm slightly amazed that nobody sees any value in being able to talk about race using a full range of expression.

The wave-hand emoji with a black colour allows you to compactly say "+1 as a black person", for example. That means emojis now support conversations about race. I've seen it used exactly like this in the wild in multiple fora.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by f1refly on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:03AM (#27105529)
Yes, exactly. My point is why it is important what colour your skin is. Are there arguments that are only valid because someone is white? Isn't that racist?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by bonaldi on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @05:13PM (#27123602)
Why is it important to be able to talk about what colour your skin is? Have you lived through the past year?

There is more to language than debate-club argumentation, too. Consider - why is it important what gender someone is? Or age? Should emoji only have had unisex and age-less figures instead of its current set? Is it sexist to use a female-presenting emoji?

These things all have obvious utility for communication, and you're ending up making some deeply strange arguments to try and dismiss that utility.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by f1refly on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @01:58AM (#27127096)
> Consider - why is it important what gender someone is? Or age?

It really isn't when it comes to arguments. An argument should not be attached to whoever brought it up. If it is it's hardly an argument and most likely something personal or morally loaded which is not suited for objective discussion.

> Should emoji only have had unisex and age-less figures instead of its current set?

Yes!

> Is it sexist to use a female-presenting emoji?

Obviously not and I don't know why you would get the impression it is. It is however mostly irrelevant: So now people assume you are an XX chromosome female or are trying to present as one. What now? Do you expect special treatment now?

> These things all have obvious utility for communication,

No they don't? And I don't know what would be "obvious" about it? You can't just present this as "obvious" fact when it's really not clear at all.

> and you're ending up making some deeply strange arguments to try and dismiss that utility.

You did not explain to me why my arguments are "deeply strange" and you also failed to explain why it should be useful to convey your own skintone in the context of discussion. My argument is that all you do with skintones and a nursing male is to bring political discrimination into electronic discussion, without providing any benefit whatsoever or even doing harm.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by bonaldi on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:39AM (#27128737)
> It really isn't when it comes to arguments ... not suited for objective discussion

Emoji is used for more than arguing or "objective discussion"!

Emojis are used for friendship, for flirting, for jokes, for sexting, for gossiping, for nattering. "I'm a woman who likes to dance", "I am white", "oh but I'm an old man" — these are all valid statements people say to one another; adding this capability allows emoji to be used to convey these meanings.

If your argument is "people shouldn't conduct electronic discussion in these sorts of ways, when using emoji they should only have arguments over objective facts" that's ... well, it's a stance, but you're at odds with how billions of people communicate electronically. This is why I use terms like "obvious" and "strange".

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by baggy_trough on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:22PM (#27051937)
Yellow is ugly.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by layoutIfNeeded on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:14AM (#27050086)
Because Americans are obsessed with skin color.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by moate on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:25AM (#27050255)
Yes, Americans invented the Cotton Gin and Racism around the same time, and no other culture ever has cared at all about representation or inclusion./s

I doubt this was solely Americans or that Americans are the only group of people that care about race/ethnicity. Maybe your findings are different. Please let me know where to find your publishings.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by layoutIfNeeded on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:59AM (#27050705)
Yikes! Like I said, obsessed... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

There are way more ethnicities and races than skin colors. E.g. there are hundreds of distinct ethnicities in Europe that Americans would merrily categorize as "white" based on their obsession with melanin.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by moate on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:49PM (#27053177)
I don't understand your thesis. Only Americans care about race? Only Americans homogenize outside cultures? I mean you just rolled a country large enough to encompass 30 different European countries, where over 300 different languages are spoken into a single cultural belief system, but go off sis...

Your point: There are more races/ethnicities than skin colors would show exactly why it should be relatively simple to undertake this project: a black person from the US, Congo, or the Dominican Republic could all use the same emoji.

I get that you seem to be here exclusively to dunk on ugly American, but I don't think caring about race is something exclusive to the US. If you're from Europe, remember: we learned it from watching you dad.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by hrjykrlfkfk on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:47AM (#27048707)
Because it "erases Blackness and centers whiteness as a default", that's the standard answer.

Yellow codes for the default, which is whiteness. Or said another way, white skin is the only unracialized skin color. Thus the supposedly neutral yellow stands for it.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by virologist on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:00AM (#27048800)
we are talking about yellow here. not black or white.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by selfhoster11 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:20AM (#27048955)
Yellow is a stand-in for "any skin tone".
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by nobodywasishere on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:29AM (#27050295)
Yellow is stand-in for white
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by selfhoster11 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:37PM (#27052163)
Proof? Besides, we've got to have some sort of skin tone to stand for skin tones that are absent or not given for some reason. It's got to be _some_ colour, and it might as well be yellow.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by sigzero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:41AM (#27049140)
Yes, we should have 100%.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by fsociety on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:34AM (#27049598)
It is so people can express themselves with emojis that represent their own skin color. Seems important, no?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kome on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:29AM (#27049035)
> Why couldn't we just have stuck with yellow? Introducing skin tone provided no advantage and just opened a can of worms.

I 100% agree. But technology follows the imperialist idiosyncrasies of US American political debate.