News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by 542458 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:47AM (#27048706)
From what I’ve seen, the skin tone feature sees lots of use (particularly in some minority communities), which to me is a good indication that this is something that people wanted.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:03AM (#27049919)
Not at all. Major apps and OSes put a "choose your race" message on their UI (and very strongly direct people to make that choice). This does not mean there was pre-existing latent demand for this.

What this shows is if you inject the concept of racial self-identity onto cartoon symbols, and afford people a way to navigate that selection, people can do that. Not that anyone wanted this, or that this feature is beneficial.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by andrewzah on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:19AM (#27050163)
"Not that anyone wanted this, or that this feature is beneficial."

Usage clearly states otherwise. No one is forced to use a particular skin tone (they can continue using the default yellow one).

This comment frankly is quite dismissive. Just because you don't use a feature doesn't mean "no one wanted it".

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:31AM (#27050326)
Users follow prompts, so "people choose a race when presented with a racialized emoji picker" doesn't mean "people want their emojis racialized". It means, people understand what they are being asked to do, and want to get back to their business.

You would need to have a theory of benefit, and then design a survey which tests users to understand if that benefit was achieved. You, frankly, are confused about causation -- we put a dialog in front of people and they made a selection, therefore people wanted this dialog?

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by andrewzah on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:39AM (#27050411)
"we put a dialog in front of people and they made a selection, therefore people wanted this dialog"

You're suggesting that it's impossible for people to have wanted a feature, because UXs have a popup showing people that it's possible to use that feature now. I disagree. You're projecting your personal opinion as everyone's personal opinion.

And that emoji picker still allows you to pick the default yellow color. So if people -really- didn't want to use them, they wouldn't.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:46AM (#27050514)
I'm not suggesting it's impossible. I'm saying you don't know what you claim to know, and to my knowledge nobody has tried to know it. People, such as yourself, assume that because this feature is used, it's desired. This is not at all warranted, given what we know about how people use computers.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:34AM (#27051229)
No, it's more like, we put up this dialog, and people didn't overwhelmingly pick jaundice. And therefore the available variety is preferred over less variety.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by recursive on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:33AM (#27050338)
Just because something is used a lot doesn't mean that any number of people wanted it.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by crazygringo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:55AM (#27050650)
If they're using something a lot that's non-default, and they have to go out of their way to select it...?

Yeah, it does mean those people want it.

There's literally no other way to interpret it.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:35AM (#27051248)
People choose to pay their taxes, therefore people want taxes. People choose to accept EULAs before they use software, therefore people want EULAs. People choose to stay with spouses with whom they occasionally fight, therefore people want fighting in their lives. People choose to navigate complex civil bureaucracies in order to get things done, therefore they want bureaucracy.

Or, people can suffer through a certain amount of bullshit in order to get to their goals. The word you're looking for is "instrumental" -- there's your missing interpretation.

At some point in the past ten or so years, the cultural discourse has devolved to such an extent that people cannot think even one move ahead. Zero tolerance manicheanism rules everything now.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by crazygringo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:23PM (#27054449)
None of those are analagous to the question at hand.

People are clearly using the emoji they want because they want to in and of itself, end of story.

They're not doing it to satisfy the government or access software or whatever. And no, I'm not looking for the word "instrumental", because emoji are about expression, which is literally the polar opposite of something being instrumental.

Sometimes it's not about looking twenty moves ahead. Some things are just valuable in and of themselves. Some things are about the moment. Perhaps that's the perspective you're missing here?

Just because some things are instrumental doesn't mean everything is. And thank goodness for that!

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:41PM (#27058922)
In my experience, "because I said so" is not a great argument.

Just one look at the way these color pickers are presented on first use, and how that selection becomes the default thereafter, tells you everything you need to know about the flimsy basis of your claims. The picker pops up and interrupts you while you're in the middle of writing a message, and then persists your choice. It's a speed bump on the way to your actual goal -- gosh, does anyone have a word for that sort of thing?

A person would have to be mighty well motivated to believe that this would be evidence of a latent demand for self-expression via skin tone.

[dead]
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by dang on Sunday May 09, 2021 @05:17AM (#27094481)
Please don't post flamewar comments to HN. It's not what this site is for. Crossing into personal attack is particularly not ok. No more of this, please.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by dang on Sunday May 09, 2021 @05:16AM (#27094479)
Whoa whoa whoa, please don't post like this. Obviously we have to ban accounts that do, regardless of how provocative or wrong the other person was or you feel they were.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by recursive on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:59PM (#27057466)
It's not clear to me that anyone went out of their way to select it. I mean, maybe they did. Maybe they didn't. I don't know all the UIs of all the devices that are capable of producing emoji characters.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kevincox on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:03PM (#27054951)
It's not non-default. When I used macOS every time I tried to send a new emoji for the first time it popped up a modal asking what colour I wanted. So the yellow was no more "default" than the skin-tone ones are.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by z0r on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:49AM (#27051453)
look, i'm not making a point specifically about the topic of this overall post. but DAU type metrics are used to justify all kinds of poor designs
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by kalleboo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:36AM (#27050376)
> Major apps and OSes put a "choose your race" message on their UI (and very strongly direct people to make that choice)

I have literally never seen this, can you provide a few examples? I'm curious how it's presented.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:40AM (#27050428)
I don't mean they literally print these words. You can see how it's done if you search for "emoji color picker" or similar.
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by watwut on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:15AM (#27050955)
The two phrases are massively different. One is asking you which color of emoji you prefer. Other is asking you which race you are.

The difference is big enough to make original statement lie - inflammatory lie that makes people outraged over something that dont exists.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#27051163)
>One is asking you which color of emoji you prefer. Other is asking you which race you are.

How would you recommend which emoji color I should pick? How do you imagine most people would navigate that decision?

>The difference is big enough to make original statement lie - inflammatory lie that makes people outraged over something that dont exists.

I'm very sorry that your notions of epistemology and morality are this underdeveloped, for you to be so confused about what lies are.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:36AM (#27051260)
> How would you recommend which emoji color I should pick?

Think for yourself, pick what you want to pick

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by watwut on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:04PM (#27051673)
Personally, I would use the one most people around me use.

The second choice for me would be the least bright one. I don't like how shiny bright colors mixed into text.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by barbazoo on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @11:45AM (#27051389)
I've never in my life seen a OS or app ask me what my race is for the purpose of determining what emojis to show me. Is that really a thing?
Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by jessedhillon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:59PM (#27053327)
No, I'm shooting from the hip and exaggerating (slightly). When you're sending an emoji for the first time, an app typically presents you with a selection of skin colors for the hand or face icon you're choosing. My point is that this is a design decision to impart significance into racial self-identity.

So the entire exercise is tautological -- of course people pick a skin color, when you frame the choice as "pick your skin color before you send this (or don't and we'll just keep using the inhuman color, which might communicate its own signal, or just look weird when everyone else has a skin tone)". And of course it's meant to be informed by race.

We decided to present skin tone (race) as something important, and people responded as though it's important, is not a surprising finding.

Re:The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think by rsynnott on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:30PM (#27052058)
> Major apps and OSes put a "choose your race" message on their UI (and very strongly direct people to make that choice).

Eh? Never having set it, I went looking for the setting in Slack. It's so discreet that I had to Google it. I still have no idea where it might be in MacOS.

The idea that this is being forced on people is kind of absurd.