News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by brandon272 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:31PM (#24536127)
I let my spouse, who likes the novelty of a touchscreen, talk me into a Whirlpool oven a couple years ago that is controlled by touchscreen. I had no idea it was possible to hate an oven so much. The only saving grace is that the stovetop elements are still controlled by knobs.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by vagab0nd on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:38PM (#24536734)
Ah yes, the touch screen ovens. I have one. Every time I open it, the steam rushes out and registers the touch screen, doing something random each time. You never know what it'll do, it's exciting.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by yholio on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:26PM (#24537556)
I have an all glass Electrolux induction cooktop with touch buttons. The idea is not necessarily bad because it allows very easy cleaning in an area where gooey spills are frequent, very hard to clean complex features like buttons and knobs.

However, you know what else reacts to gooey spills? Why, touch buttons, of course. You literally cannot boil anything with a lid on the front areas, since the lid will condense vapor that will drip towards the button area and either startup other areas, or turn-off the device. The same if a pot without a lid boils too intensely. Dangerously, it has other resistive areas that heat up when their respective touch buttons are hit with droplets.

It has a lock button, but the lock button itself is placed in exactly the same area and has the same problem.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by radley on Sunday September 20, 2020 @06:27PM (#24537969)
We have a Samsung oven. Often I'll lean a pot lid against the back and a random button event will be triggered (like setting the over to Bake). The lib doesn't press any buttons, it just triggers something via proximity (and steam, eh?).

Half of those unplanned triggers will cause the system to lock up. Samsung Support's solution: unplug the oven.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ddingus on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:11PM (#24537441)
Good grief! I chuckled. We are lucky hand have easily maintained appliances from an older era.

So easy.

Not as efficient or cool, but nobody wants the newer stuff.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by systemvoltage on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:54PM (#24536349)
I don't understand why people find novelty of touchscreens appealing.

We've got to do a better job of educating consumers. The marketing behind touchscreens is so powerful that it is unanimously considered as a feature, something you must have.

I get angry just thinking about the amount of marketing bullshit around touchscreens. Just go to Garmin Aviation website and now a lot of operation in airplane cockpits is offloaded to touchscreens. What happened to the scratch pad and press an index key in FMCs? Age old UI and it is so crisp and clear, there is absolutely zero ambguity. Write something in a scratch pad, click the button where you wanna insert the data.

This is a cost saving measure disguised as a feature. Public is dumb and does'nt understand UI/UX in the slightest bit.

It is just sad. As long as consumers keep buying, nothing will change.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by skohan on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:24PM (#24536621)
Touch controls are only warranted when you need to support a large number of varied interactions which can't be supported by physical controls, or if you have to support arbitrary gesture-based input (like a drawing tablet for example). If that's not the case, physical controls are always better. If you're operating a vehicle, or can't look at the display for any reason, tactile controls are leagues better.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by cgriswald on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:06PM (#24536955)
I don’t think it’s quite so black-and-white although I agree roughly with where you draw the line.

My car has tactile controls but they control a cursor on a non-touch screen. In this case touch screen controls would be superior because it would be faster and there would be less time looking at the display.

An argument could be made for more controls to get away from the need for a cursor/menu at all, and while I largely agree, at some point you’re likely to have so many controls you end up looking at the controls anyway, even with tactile hints.

Even if not, in this case the major controls are basically shortcuts and they’re the most commonly used and important shortcuts. Adding more buttons and knobs for things used less frequently or of lesser importance would muddy the waters and make these controls more difficult to use.

To muddy the waters further, some controls can do double duty with things like cycling through functions, double clicks, contextual presses, etc.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by pessimizer on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:57PM (#24537779)
General purpose computing requires generic control systems. If your device knows its purpose, it shouldn't need a touchscreen.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by throwaway744678 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:50PM (#24537311)
Another benefit, for kitchen appliances: a flat screen is easier to clean than physical knobs.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by systemvoltage on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:31PM (#24536678)
Agreed and you nailed it - an iPhone with touchscreen makes total sense.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by nexuist on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:05PM (#24536946)
I disagree wholeheartedly that cockpit touchscreens (as a concept) are worse than physical knobs and switches. What are you doing in an FMC that requires you to split focus between operating the plane and operating the FMC? In what scenario are you going to need to create a new flight plan while pulling stunt maneuvers? When are you going to need to do anything involving navigation if you do not first have control (i.e. straight and level) of the airplane?

>This is a cost saving measure disguised as a feature.

Cost saving is not bad. Cost saving allows thousands of new aviators to enter into a field they otherwise would be price locked out of, and enables them to have a safe and enjoyable experience. Consider the AV-20 and AV-30 touch screen instruments:

https://youtu.be/hhRrNQsBl2w https://uavionix.com/product/av-30-exp/

For $1600 they provide in one instrument what you usually would need 10-13 instruments for. These instruments are not cheap; they all cost multi-hundred dollars to buy on top of drilling the holes in the cockpit and the associated maintenance to keep them all airworthy. If one component of your AV-20 fails? Who cares; throw it away and install a new one. It's dead simple.

As for UX, physical interfaces are not immune either. There have even been fatal crashes attributed to putting a lever in a stupid place, labeling a button incorrectly, not flipping a switch on time, etc. Just because you may see some horrible touchscreen interfaces out there does not mean that touchscreens are horrible.

The difference is that the touchscreen can receive software updates. At any point you can completely rearrange menus and control to address shortcomings in the interface. Doing this is practically free; the only downtime is waiting for the firmware update to complete. Addressing shortcomings in physical interfaces? You're looking at dozens to hundreds of man hours on top of buying the new equipment to replace the old.

It costs Tesla $0 per vehicle to add a new button to their cars. It costs millions for everyone else. This is not a useless capability; it makes a difference every single day.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by serf on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:05PM (#24537417)
>It costs Tesla $0 per vehicle to add a new button to their cars. It costs millions for everyone else. This is not a useless capability; it makes a difference every single day.

Complaint #1 about Teslas' from owners that I have spoken to is that the UI/UX requires total re-learning as opposed to other cars, and then when the re-learning phase is complete, it's still difficult to operate without full attention.

Sure, the argument 'Oh, they shouldn't be dividing their attention from driving.' is all well and good; but try convincing normal commuters that they should pull over to adjust the volume on their stereo. I don't think you'll win that one.

Tactile/physical components are just easier to operate without know-how, and without focus being pulled to them in its' entirety. The linear movement of a volume jogging dial is intuitive; there are two diretions on both the knob and the mechanism which is being affected -- it's direct, and obvious.

Touchscreens, usually, are none of these. Using a touch screen telephone is not an eyes off exercises, but dialing and talking to someone on any of my old flip phones or Nokias was. There was a fundamental shift from worrying about being able to do one thing very well to doing all things OK in the cell phone world, and I think that it's a shame that companies like Tesla think that this is a philosophy that should be pursued among auto-makers.

Thankfully, many automakers that were dead set on touch interfaces have begun to realize that they're not good everywhere.

Mercedes/BMW/Audi went away from buttons just to find themselves crawling back... and i'm okay with that. It makes the cars easier to operate, and less focus dividing on the road.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by nexuist on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:21PM (#24537528)
> but try convincing normal commuters that they should pull over to adjust the volume on their stereo.

But they don't have to. On a Tesla you can adjust the volume using the physical knob on the steering wheel; similarly you can activate or deactivate turn signals using the stalks. This is an example of touchscreens and physical controls working together, just like it would be outlandish to expect pilots to touch-and-drag on a screen rather than using a joystick.

> Using a touch screen telephone is not an eyes off exercises, but dialing and talking to someone on any of my old flip phones or Nokias was

Is it not? Can't you use Siri or Google Assistant to call a contact, or in the case of Tesla the on board voice control? Of course the voice control may suck; but that again can be fixed with software updates just as we've seen in the mobile phone space.

> Mercedes/BMW/Audi went away from buttons just to find themselves crawling back...

Because their implementations sucked. Try using an iPad vs whatever you found in their cars; why is the iPad so much better? It doesn't have to be. You could very well have had an iPad-like experience with your car's touchscreen if the manufacturer actually put in the effort to refine it. Instead we got menus in menus in menus: a horrible experience.

In the aviation world, one of the most popular apps is ForeFlight, which enables you to navigate and perform common tasks on an iPad:

https://www.foreflight.com/products/foreflight-mobile/

It is popular precisely because you can interact with information on the iPad, rather than having to deal with the shitty UX on your on board GPS or weather instrument. ForeFlight is an example of touch done right, as opposed to doing touch for the sake of touch.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by fomine3 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:43AM (#24564170)
Touchscreen (lack of physical response, unable to locate position without seeing) is really bad for while driving cars. I won't saying for other use cases like airplanes, tables. IANAP but I suspect that pilot needs less continuous attention for the air during fly compared to driving a car.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by gumby on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:46PM (#24537278)
> I don't understand why people find novelty of touchscreens appealing. We've got to do a better job of educating consumers.

You’ve answered your own question: it’s the novelty. Plus people have been educated — by their phones.

Of course HN readers know that other than a few special cases (of which the phone is one) the touchscreen interface is worse. The problem is that white goods (washers, stoves) are cap ex and have a lifetime measured in decades. So there are plenty of people who have learned the hard way, but many more who have not yet learned the lesson.

As gratuitous touch screen is currently a fashion item attempting to differentiate between largely similar items. In another decade or so it will be considered an artifact of the 2020s, much like avocado-colored appliances and fold out stoves (we had one in the 70s) scream “1960s”.

But notice I said “2020s” (though touch screens have been around for a while), and that we had an item that screamed “60s” in a later decade. The latency in this sector is enormous.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by slowmovintarget on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:05PM (#24537411)
Very high-end or professional ovens will not have this. These are gimmicks for people with too much money, and too little sense.

I don't want my toaster posting on Facebook. I don't want to link my refrigerator with my Google account. And no, I do not expect my microwave to post pics of my food to Instagram. I want a toaster that toasts properly and can be cleaned. I want a refrigerator that runs forever, doesn't leak, and doesn't build up frost in the freezer. I want a microwave that won't burn out after a year and will heat evenly.

I've managed to find all of these things, but it is becoming increasingly difficult to find appliances that aren't disposable, favoring internet-enablement to high-quality construction. I'll pay for the stainless steel... leave the wi-fi hardware out, please.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Thlom on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:34PM (#24537593)
Looks like some connectivity is creeping into the high-end stuff like Gaggenau as well, but at least they still stick to TFT screens and not huge LCD touch displays, and it looks like the connectivity stuff is actually useful for stuff like remote diagnostics.

My Samsung fridge can connect to wifi, but lord knows why. I can adjust the temperature, but why I would want to do that on my phone and not on the appliance itself I do not know.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by reincarnate0x14 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @11:58PM (#24539657)
My recent Samsung washer and dryer units have wifi options because I couldn't find any local available models without, but I'm also confused what the real use case is for it.

If I'm home to deal with them, I can hear them sing. Yes, they play cute little songs when they complete their loads. If I'm not home, it makes no difference to me whatsoever if my dryer can send me artisanally curated messages about the glorious dryness of my garments.

I could see a use case if you had some sort of home SCADA controller that was locally networked and could operate a vent fan based on appliances being in operation or tell your fridge and HVAC to switch to power-saving modes based on the local energy market's posted power prices. But that's invariably not what corporate interests are offering because their incentives are so totally divorced from that of the end users.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by neilpanchal on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:14PM (#24537464)
We have the ability to design things better. SV folks should get toghether and start a startup in this space - it is ripe with many opportunities. One company comes in uses the truthful marketing to change the tune of GE/Haier/Samsung and others.

Unfortunately, we're battling vicious hardware market forces and whatever you do - it won't beat the cost of existing players who cheapout in parts and UI, especially when mass produced in China. Hardware requires serious funding to get started and ME/EE skills are disappearing from the west.

Physical controls are getting more and more expensive due to dwindling demand. Many encoders from ALPS have been EOL'ed.

I don't think we're gonna get out of this horrible UX/UI rut.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by combatentropy on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:34PM (#24536696)
> What happened to the scratch pad and press an index key in FMCs? Age old UI and it is so crisp and clear, there is absolutely zero ambguity. Write something in a scratch pad, click the button where you wanna insert the data.

I am not a pilot but am always interested in seeing examples of great user interfaces. Can you post a link or more information about what this device is? (Bonus: the version you love and the version you now hate)

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by systemvoltage on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:44PM (#24536778)
They look like this: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/RZawxJ6TLuY/maxresdefault.jpg

The amber boxes are required fields and ---- are optional. The bottom line is a scratch pad. You first punch in the data there and push one of the index switches on the side to insert it in place.

Yea its not beautiful to most people (I disagree) but it is very clear in the way it works.

Here is the new one: https://www.aviationpros.com/tools-equipment/maintenance-it/...

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by combatentropy on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:32PM (#24537153)
Got it. Thanks!

> its not beautiful to most people

I think the same could be said about audio mixing boards, for example. I've found that interfaces for professionals often look ugly to the uninitiated.

I've said many times that you should give an interface two weeks, not two seconds. Interfaces that you love after two seconds, you may come to hate after using it every day. Interfaces that are intimidating on the first day, you may come to love after a few weeks, and even more and more through the years. For me, a great example is vi.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by systemvoltage on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:19PM (#24537506)
> Interfaces that you love after two seconds, you may come to hate after using it every day

I wish more people knew this tradeoff.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by CyberDildonics on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:25PM (#24537104)
I think people assume it's a step forward without thinking it through. It's a classic example of 'just because you can, doesn't mean you should'.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by wvenable on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:03PM (#24536431)
My work coffee maker has a touch screen and the interface is so laggy it's insane. The manufacturer controls every aspect of the hardware and software so it makes no sense -- either make the hardware more powerful or make the software simpler!
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by charles_f on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:18PM (#24536559)
Oh hell on earth, my work coffee machine takes no less than 6 consecutive choices including a scroll through options and questions, with lag at each step of the process to select what you want. To make black coffee. What drink do you want? What roast? What size? How much sugar? How much milk? Confirm your selection. All that for the option than more than 1/2 users are selecting.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by avip on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:07PM (#24536965)
I can reproducibly deadlock my workplace coffee machine.

You press the coffee type and immediately hit the "clean" button. Then the machine is dead with no recourse other than unplug. Try that trick on a Makineta.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by whywhywhywhy on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:34PM (#24537170)
>The manufacturer controls every aspect of the hardware and software so it makes no sense

Makes perfect sense, the only way you'll get a responsive touchscreen is if one of the engineers behind it actually cares about it being responsive.

Otherwise the job goes down to the designer to try and pressure the engineers into making it responsive which there is a chance they might not even be skilled enough to understand how to make that happen. If they don't want to make it happen there is a hundred excuses as to why its not actually their fault.

To make an actual good, responsive product you need people at every level of the implementation who care deeply about their work.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by oriolid on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:12PM (#24537451)
Most importantly, you need product manager that cares about the UI being responsive. As an engineer it's not produce a responsive UI if you have time only for a barely working product.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ericlewis on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:40PM (#24536746)
This is where NLP would excel or even some nice regex. It doesn’t have to be this hard.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by exdsq on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:16PM (#24537033)
That’d require typing something in though? I’d like a dial for strength and a button per coffee option
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by tomp on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:13PM (#24537010)
Or just a simple “repeat last choice”.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by echoteecat on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:11PM (#24536998)
"Computer, Coffee. Black."
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by rytis on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:09PM (#24536464)
Few years ago we were in the market for a new oven. The main criteria was the absence of any "smarts". Ended up getting Smeg gas oven (SF6341GVX if anyone's interested). So simple, so intuitive, and most importantly, so dumb that there's very few thing that could go wrong with it.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by puranjay on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:43PM (#24536229)
My office (well, former office) used to have a touchscreen coffee maker.

Why does a coffee maker even need a touchscreen? There are literally three options!

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by pwg on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:12PM (#24536499)
> Why does a coffee maker even need a touchscreen?

To differentiate it from the previous model so as to sell new product when the previous model that has already been purchased is continuing to perform its designated task. I.e., to convince some segment of their customer base to throw out the working model from last year in exchange for the "new fancy" model of this year.

Humans are often fooled way too many times by "oohhh... shiny and new and different... gotta have that...".

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by vidanay on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:47PM (#24536281)
Our old office had a $5k fancy coffee maker with touch screen.

Nobody knew what the hell all the icons meant, and nobody cleaned the milk siphon so it went moldy and was thrown out after two weeks.

I insisted that we keep the old Bunn that had an advanced UI with a red illuminated On-Off switch. Six months later, it was the only one coffee maker still in use.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:47PM (#24536810)
> Nobody knew what the hell all the icons meant

Still can't figure out how to turn on the defroster in a new car. My old truck was simple - turn the knob to "DEFROST". My cat feeder invented all its own icons, trying to get it set up is a nightmare. I keep the instruction manual next to it.

I hate Steve Jobs for convincing the world that written words are bad and random cute pictures are cool. Please, bring back "DELETE".

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by pilsetnieks on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:17PM (#24537491)
Did Steve Jobs really do that? Unless you mean going from a text based CLI to a graphic UI but even those had plenty of words, especially those well thought out.

When Jobs had to choose a washing machine for his family, he chose a Miele with plenty of words on it:

https://9to5mac.com/2011/03/07/how-steve-jobs-picks-a-washer...

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by CamperBob2 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @11:57PM (#24539651)
It absolutely was Steve Jobs's fault, although we're talking about the pre-NeXT Steve Jobs the Grey rather than the revenant Steve Jobs the White.

Around the time Walter was working on Datalight C, I was working at a computer game company in Austin that most geeks over the age of about 35 have heard of. All decisions of note at this well-regarded company were made by a figure of equal repute, someone with the tech chops of one Steve and the charisma of the other. This guy wasn't a Mac user himself, but there were a few Macs in use around the office, and he fell for the WIMP paradigm hard.

The games in the series he was known for were historically keyboard-driven, but the one we were working on at the time, the sixth, was the first to be developed on the PC rather than the Apple II and also the first to feature a GUI. So everything was icon-based whether it needed to be or not, because "that's how the Mac does it." Hieroglyphics were hot again, who could've seen it coming? Don't complain, just work like an Egyptian.

At the time this flavor of Kool-Aid was being consumed all over the place, from game companies to office/productivity software companies, and it unquestionably all went back to Jobs, or more accurately the cues Jobs took from PARC. We weren't alone in being ordered by management to Think Different(tm) by ripping off some guys in Cupertino.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:58PM (#24537783)
> Did Steve Jobs really do that?

Famously, using a trash can instead of "DELETE".

A Mac evangelist came to my workplace shortly after the Mac was released. His entire presentation was about how icons were far better than words. He asserted the function of the icons was obvious, and so needed no explanation. He passed around a sheet of paper with a bunch of icons on it, and said isn't that right?

This all fell apart when nobody could figure out what the box of Kleenex icon was. He was visibly flustered by this, eventually exclaiming that it meant "PRINT".

This was all made worse by the practice of copyrighting icons so every company invented their same-only-different icons.

But, the Mac won anyway and PRINT and DEFROST became hopelessly uncool, unhip and old-fashioned.

I predict that, like all hieroglyphic writing systems, icons will eventually evolve to have associated sounds with them, then they'll morph into simple pen strokes, then we'll be back to a new phonetic alphabet.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by puranjay on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:08AM (#24540323)
Words are better than icons - as long as you speak the language.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:34AM (#24540787)
You don't need to speak the language. Learning O-I-L is not any harder than learning that squiggle is an ancient biblical oil lamp. It's easier, in fact, because everyone has an English=>YourLanguage translator in their pocket, and who has an icon decoder?

Is it really that hard to figure out what STOP on the international stop sign means?

I know from experience traveling in foreign countries. Even in Japan.

For another example, how long did it take you to figure out that that "hamburger" icon was really MENU?

I'm using Chrome Browser. To the right of the address bar there's a star icon. Sorry, I have no idea what that means and have to hover over it - "Bookmark this tab". I have no idea why anyone would associate a star with bookmark. I have no idea how anyone would look up a star icon on google. But I know how to look up "bookmark".

When I open up my Twitter page, there are 5 icons under my picture:

1. two triangles and a dot

2. GIF

3. three cantilevered beams

4. a happy face

5. a car battery with a clock attached

Sorry, I don't know what any of these do. Hovering over them provides no information. (Maybe GIF means add picture, but my pictures are JPGs, not GIFs. What does a happy face do? Inject me with heroin?) I can click on them and find out - but really, what kind of argument is that for "icons are better!"? It isn't any better than randomly turning controls hoping to turn the damned defroster on so I can see, and hoping I don't hit the ejector seat button.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by DoingIsLearning on Monday September 21, 2020 @08:50AM (#24542695)
> Learning O-I-L is not any harder than learning that squiggle is an ancient biblical oil lamp

I fully agree with your points on UI icons and flat hamburgers. It repeatedly violates discoverabilty. But to add to your point, most products will already have some form of regionalization. Software will typically have language specific strings, physical products will have instruction manuals and warranties in the local language. In practice the translation effort already happens anyway for non-anglo markets. So even the reservation you mention of learning a foreign language for non-english users is most of the times a non-issue.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by CamperBob2 on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:24AM (#24540426)
Or if you're a verbal thinker rather than a visual thinker. I can learn enough of $LANGUAGE to operate a control panel in less time than I can puzzle out the average set of Ikea assembly instructions.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:01PM (#24536411)
> Nobody knew what the hell all the icons meant, and nobody cleaned the milk siphon so it went moldy and was thrown out after two weeks.

What’s the takeaway here?

A group of spoiled adults couldn’t be bothered to read an instruction manual or clean something?

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by chronolitus on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:17PM (#24536548)
This kind of argument always ticks me off, because it's technically correct, assuming your brain can care and focus on infinitely many things.

But I know that I can't: I can care very effectively about one thing really well (typically oscillating between my job and family). Then there's space left in my brain to be sort-of effective at caring for three or four other things (social life, hobbies, sports, learning, personal growth, etc..). There's a little space in the end for things which are good, but I can't afford to think about more than the minimum amount necessary (voting, taxes, coffee machines, subscription services, recycling, keeping my plants alive, car/motorcycle maintenance, ...).

So the point is, I really really value things which don't require me to care or RTFM, because that frees me up to care and focus more on my job, family and friends. Maybe that's being spoiled, but it feels more to me like a pragmatic approach to mental health and productivity.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:25PM (#24536624)
I think what’s striking me as being spoiled is using the thing, intentionally not taking care of it, and ruining it.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Reason077 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:26PM (#24537561)
In a communal environment such as an office, complex equipment that requires maintenance and reading the manual is always going to be problematic without someone who's job it is to explicitly maintain it.

That's why $5000 coffee machines normally come with either a maintenance contract, where someone comes around regularly to restock/clean/maintain it, or you have a designated person or department within your company who's job it is to take care of them.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by toast0 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:38PM (#24536731)
The takeaway is don't buy something that requires maintenance without a plan for who is going to do the maintenance. Coffee machines that use milk products need to have (at least) daily maintenance; for a commons coffee machine it's better to get the model without automated milk processing, or declare it's not to be hooked up or used.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by rytis on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:16PM (#24536543)
I guess the takeaway is that everyday utility instruments should not require time invested in studying manuals to operate them. Imagine that every screwdriver you buy requires you to read 20 page document that tells you how to operate it. As a user all I want is "a cup of coffee". Why do I need to read that manual? What if I'm just a visitor, and was told that "the coffee machine is over there". Do I really want to read the manual to get a cup of coffee?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:53PM (#24536846)
Fortunately, my cheapo coffee machine has only one button - a mechanical rocker on switch. Unfortunately, it uses icons for which side is "ON", so I rock it until it starts getting warmer.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:24PM (#24536612)
Somebody buys you a $5,000 screwdriver. Do you just use it wrong, not take care of it, and ruin it to make a point about how all you wanted was to turn a screw?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by nicoburns on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:38PM (#24536728)
If that screwdriver makes it more difficult to turn a screw than a $50 screwdriver (or a $5 screwdriver) then... maybe?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:50PM (#24536829)
Another thing being missed here is that the users in the original post didn’t want just a cup of coffee. If that’s all they wanted, they wouldn’t have used, not cleaned, and ruined the milk steaming wand.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by kempbellt on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:19PM (#24537047)
You sell it, buy a regular screw driver, and spend the rest on cookies
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:49PM (#24536825)
> couldn’t be bothered to read an instruction manual

The manual for a new car is an inch thick, and flipping through it while driving trying to figure out how to turn on the defroster is BAD BAD BAD BAD design.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by teknologist on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:10PM (#24536479)
Fancy touch screens could potentially tell users how/when to clean stuff?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ionwake on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:11PM (#24536487)
That the UI was shit and you’re the kind of person who endorses it.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by dang on Sunday September 20, 2020 @07:42PM (#24538384)
Personal attacks will get you banned on HN, so please don't do that here. Also can you please stop posting in the flamewar style? You've done it repeatedly lately, and it's against the site rules because we're trying for something a bit different on this site. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and posting in the intended spirit, we'd be grateful.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ionwake on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:27PM (#24546079)
Sorry, I caused offence and will be more careful.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by dang on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:49PM (#24548849)
Appreciated!
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Skunkleton on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:56PM (#24536365)
I love my coffee maker so much. It has one chunky physical switch and no other controls or moving parts. No wifi, no smart bs, no pointless brew size settings, its not spying on me, or inflicting me with DRM. I've had it for over 10 years now, and have had to perform no maintenance.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Natales on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:20PM (#24536581)
Same. About 10 years ago I bought a Jura-Capresso super automatic coffee machine (S7). Very simple. 4 buttons. Small matrix text display with a good UX. Really nothing fancy. I clean it when it asks me to, and that's all the maintenance it needs.

I recently looked at the latest models, and they've basically have not changed. Maybe a bit more silent. That's it. The rest is all connectivity and LCDs. Solutions looking for a problem.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ClikeX on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:43PM (#24536768)
I got a Saeco full-automatic machine. It has no DRM or spyware to speak of. All the features work through physical buttons.

The smartest thing it does is tell me to replace my water filter or that I need to descale. Which is really just a matter of counting.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by YarickR2 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:18PM (#24536562)
You'll love this https://www.flairespresso.com/ Besides doing damn good espresso , it isn't even connected to the grid
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by whywhywhywhy on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:38PM (#24537200)
>Why does a coffee maker even need a touchscreen?

It's probably cheaper than physical buttons and can be used across multiple SKUs where each one would require it's own set of buttons otherwise.

Oh it can show you adverts too.

Objectively worse in every way to the end user than a nice set of buttons.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by appleiigs on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:07PM (#24536450)
I love my cuisinart ddc-1200 coffee maker. Has two knobs and an old fashion toggle switch. I realize it's not a pure mechanical switch but at least they're still using a physical switch.

https://www.cuisinart.com/shopping/appliances/coffee_makers/...

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by skohan on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:26PM (#24536633)
Didn't you hear? These millenials spend all day on their phones! They must love touchscreens.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by avian on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:50PM (#24536305)
Had a similar experience. Also, the guy with the desk closest to the machine quickly got fed up of everyone asking “how do I just get a normal coffee out of this?”
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by rhacker on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:19PM (#24536564)
3 options? I think on all the coffee pots I've owned it's just a POWER button. How can a company replace that with a screen to be better?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by masklinn on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:49PM (#24536296)
> Why does a coffee maker even need a touchscreen? There are literally three options!

What’s the option besides on and off, keep warm?

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by vidanay on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:53PM (#24536338)
Coffee, Cappuccino, Latte, Frappe

All of the above multiplied by small, medium, large.

All of the above multiplied by weak, normal, strong, and double shot.

All of the above multiplied by zone defense, man to coverage, and missile command.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Skunkleton on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:57PM (#24536374)
Is it even a coffee maker if it doesn't run DOOM?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by masklinn on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:30AM (#24540120)
That’s not 3 options. I was replying to a message which spoke of 3 options not 12000
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by coldtea on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:46AM (#24541488)
Yes, but you still seemed surprised there are could be more than two options -- not just "what would a 3rd, given 3 options only" would be.

And for 3 options, most classic home espresso machines have 3 buttons: (a) on/off toggle, (b) coffee/hot water toggle, (c) steam toggle.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by bashinator on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:30PM (#24536666)
So, four selector dials?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by numpad0 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:46PM (#24536797)
Or one(1) touchscreen
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by coldtea on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:52PM (#24536334)
Depending on the coffee maker there can be a dozen or more options. A home espresso maker might adjust how many "shots" to drip, different temperatures, adding milk or not, etc.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by masklinn on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:30AM (#24540127)
> Depending on the coffee maker there can be a dozen or more options.

Yes but that’s not relevant, I’m asking specifically what the third option would be in a or with 3 options.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by coldtea on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:47AM (#24541493)
Yes, but you still seemed surprised there are could be more than two options. You didn't explicitly ask "what would a 3rd option, given 3 options only, would be".

That said, most classic home espresso machines have 3 buttons: (a) on/off toggle, (b) coffee/hot water toggle, (c) steam toggle.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by maneesh on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:57PM (#24536377)
On, Off, Brew. On without (or after) Brew keeps it warm.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by masklinn on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:33AM (#24540138)
Interesting. All the pots in these styles I’ve seen “on” is “brew”, the pot just automatically switches to warm after brewing.

If you shut down the device it tries to brew again, though I expect that it’ll quickly switch to keep warm when there’s no water to boil (I never actually tried).

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by benttoothpaste on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:50PM (#24536309)
My mom’s oven requires regular power cycle because it’s touch UI locks up so often.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Natales on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:25PM (#24536628)
I think we can't underestimate that one of the biggest problems with all this is the poor quality of the software.

This is particularly shameful in devices that are so simple. Basically finite-state machines, something that everyone in CS should learn in 101 classes.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Symbiote on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:45PM (#24536783)
Is that easy to do?

My oven is hardwired into the mains supply. To power cycle it, I would need to turn off the circuit at the breaker panel. I don't think this is at all unusual.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by sundvor on Sunday September 20, 2020 @08:35PM (#24538651)
We have a Thermomix TM4, two models down from the current TM6. It's very handy for a lot of cooking; makes rice pudding in a flash!

Now, I keep getting invitations to upgrade for the new one. The TM6 is a lot less noisy, and that would be amazing as mine is probably audible across the street - but, and this is a massive BUT: It has a touch screen interface, introduced with the TM5.

NO WAY. The TM4's physical interface is brilliant in its simplicity; every button does one thing, and one thing only; the motor speed knob is big and tactile.

I don't need nor want the complexity and latency of a touchscreen, and dealing with crappy firmware updates. Hopefully I'll be able to keep servicing mine for the longest time.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ufmace on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:54AM (#24539936)
Reading all of these comments, I'm really glad I have a dumb gas stove with no special electronics, just an actual mechanical gas valve. Turn knob -> more gas -> bigger fire -> more heat into pot, and that's all there is to it.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by bluedino on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:00PM (#24536405)
Dials are so much better. Ovens with those membrane buttons always crack and wear out too soon.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by brokenmachine on Sunday September 20, 2020 @09:34PM (#24538945)
Ah yes, all this engineering for a device that has a single control, heat level, and has to function for possibly decades.

What better use for a fragile and overly complicated touchscreen than in a hot, moist, harsh environment?

Please tell me it has to sync with a cloud server as well, lol!

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by 29athrowaway on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:44PM (#24536772)
Ovens are OK until you have to clean them after thanksgiving.