News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by vidanay on Sunday September 20, 2020 @02:47PM (#24536281)
Our old office had a $5k fancy coffee maker with touch screen.

Nobody knew what the hell all the icons meant, and nobody cleaned the milk siphon so it went moldy and was thrown out after two weeks.

I insisted that we keep the old Bunn that had an advanced UI with a red illuminated On-Off switch. Six months later, it was the only one coffee maker still in use.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:47PM (#24536810)
> Nobody knew what the hell all the icons meant

Still can't figure out how to turn on the defroster in a new car. My old truck was simple - turn the knob to "DEFROST". My cat feeder invented all its own icons, trying to get it set up is a nightmare. I keep the instruction manual next to it.

I hate Steve Jobs for convincing the world that written words are bad and random cute pictures are cool. Please, bring back "DELETE".

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by pilsetnieks on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:17PM (#24537491)
Did Steve Jobs really do that? Unless you mean going from a text based CLI to a graphic UI but even those had plenty of words, especially those well thought out.

When Jobs had to choose a washing machine for his family, he chose a Miele with plenty of words on it:

https://9to5mac.com/2011/03/07/how-steve-jobs-picks-a-washer...

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by CamperBob2 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @11:57PM (#24539651)
It absolutely was Steve Jobs's fault, although we're talking about the pre-NeXT Steve Jobs the Grey rather than the revenant Steve Jobs the White.

Around the time Walter was working on Datalight C, I was working at a computer game company in Austin that most geeks over the age of about 35 have heard of. All decisions of note at this well-regarded company were made by a figure of equal repute, someone with the tech chops of one Steve and the charisma of the other. This guy wasn't a Mac user himself, but there were a few Macs in use around the office, and he fell for the WIMP paradigm hard.

The games in the series he was known for were historically keyboard-driven, but the one we were working on at the time, the sixth, was the first to be developed on the PC rather than the Apple II and also the first to feature a GUI. So everything was icon-based whether it needed to be or not, because "that's how the Mac does it." Hieroglyphics were hot again, who could've seen it coming? Don't complain, just work like an Egyptian.

At the time this flavor of Kool-Aid was being consumed all over the place, from game companies to office/productivity software companies, and it unquestionably all went back to Jobs, or more accurately the cues Jobs took from PARC. We weren't alone in being ordered by management to Think Different(tm) by ripping off some guys in Cupertino.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:58PM (#24537783)
> Did Steve Jobs really do that?

Famously, using a trash can instead of "DELETE".

A Mac evangelist came to my workplace shortly after the Mac was released. His entire presentation was about how icons were far better than words. He asserted the function of the icons was obvious, and so needed no explanation. He passed around a sheet of paper with a bunch of icons on it, and said isn't that right?

This all fell apart when nobody could figure out what the box of Kleenex icon was. He was visibly flustered by this, eventually exclaiming that it meant "PRINT".

This was all made worse by the practice of copyrighting icons so every company invented their same-only-different icons.

But, the Mac won anyway and PRINT and DEFROST became hopelessly uncool, unhip and old-fashioned.

I predict that, like all hieroglyphic writing systems, icons will eventually evolve to have associated sounds with them, then they'll morph into simple pen strokes, then we'll be back to a new phonetic alphabet.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by puranjay on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:08AM (#24540323)
Words are better than icons - as long as you speak the language.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:34AM (#24540787)
You don't need to speak the language. Learning O-I-L is not any harder than learning that squiggle is an ancient biblical oil lamp. It's easier, in fact, because everyone has an English=>YourLanguage translator in their pocket, and who has an icon decoder?

Is it really that hard to figure out what STOP on the international stop sign means?

I know from experience traveling in foreign countries. Even in Japan.

For another example, how long did it take you to figure out that that "hamburger" icon was really MENU?

I'm using Chrome Browser. To the right of the address bar there's a star icon. Sorry, I have no idea what that means and have to hover over it - "Bookmark this tab". I have no idea why anyone would associate a star with bookmark. I have no idea how anyone would look up a star icon on google. But I know how to look up "bookmark".

When I open up my Twitter page, there are 5 icons under my picture:

1. two triangles and a dot

2. GIF

3. three cantilevered beams

4. a happy face

5. a car battery with a clock attached

Sorry, I don't know what any of these do. Hovering over them provides no information. (Maybe GIF means add picture, but my pictures are JPGs, not GIFs. What does a happy face do? Inject me with heroin?) I can click on them and find out - but really, what kind of argument is that for "icons are better!"? It isn't any better than randomly turning controls hoping to turn the damned defroster on so I can see, and hoping I don't hit the ejector seat button.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by DoingIsLearning on Monday September 21, 2020 @08:50AM (#24542695)
> Learning O-I-L is not any harder than learning that squiggle is an ancient biblical oil lamp

I fully agree with your points on UI icons and flat hamburgers. It repeatedly violates discoverabilty. But to add to your point, most products will already have some form of regionalization. Software will typically have language specific strings, physical products will have instruction manuals and warranties in the local language. In practice the translation effort already happens anyway for non-anglo markets. So even the reservation you mention of learning a foreign language for non-english users is most of the times a non-issue.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by CamperBob2 on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:24AM (#24540426)
Or if you're a verbal thinker rather than a visual thinker. I can learn enough of $LANGUAGE to operate a control panel in less time than I can puzzle out the average set of Ikea assembly instructions.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:01PM (#24536411)
> Nobody knew what the hell all the icons meant, and nobody cleaned the milk siphon so it went moldy and was thrown out after two weeks.

What’s the takeaway here?

A group of spoiled adults couldn’t be bothered to read an instruction manual or clean something?

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by chronolitus on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:17PM (#24536548)
This kind of argument always ticks me off, because it's technically correct, assuming your brain can care and focus on infinitely many things.

But I know that I can't: I can care very effectively about one thing really well (typically oscillating between my job and family). Then there's space left in my brain to be sort-of effective at caring for three or four other things (social life, hobbies, sports, learning, personal growth, etc..). There's a little space in the end for things which are good, but I can't afford to think about more than the minimum amount necessary (voting, taxes, coffee machines, subscription services, recycling, keeping my plants alive, car/motorcycle maintenance, ...).

So the point is, I really really value things which don't require me to care or RTFM, because that frees me up to care and focus more on my job, family and friends. Maybe that's being spoiled, but it feels more to me like a pragmatic approach to mental health and productivity.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:25PM (#24536624)
I think what’s striking me as being spoiled is using the thing, intentionally not taking care of it, and ruining it.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by Reason077 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @05:26PM (#24537561)
In a communal environment such as an office, complex equipment that requires maintenance and reading the manual is always going to be problematic without someone who's job it is to explicitly maintain it.

That's why $5000 coffee machines normally come with either a maintenance contract, where someone comes around regularly to restock/clean/maintain it, or you have a designated person or department within your company who's job it is to take care of them.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by toast0 on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:38PM (#24536731)
The takeaway is don't buy something that requires maintenance without a plan for who is going to do the maintenance. Coffee machines that use milk products need to have (at least) daily maintenance; for a commons coffee machine it's better to get the model without automated milk processing, or declare it's not to be hooked up or used.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by rytis on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:16PM (#24536543)
I guess the takeaway is that everyday utility instruments should not require time invested in studying manuals to operate them. Imagine that every screwdriver you buy requires you to read 20 page document that tells you how to operate it. As a user all I want is "a cup of coffee". Why do I need to read that manual? What if I'm just a visitor, and was told that "the coffee machine is over there". Do I really want to read the manual to get a cup of coffee?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:53PM (#24536846)
Fortunately, my cheapo coffee machine has only one button - a mechanical rocker on switch. Unfortunately, it uses icons for which side is "ON", so I rock it until it starts getting warmer.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:24PM (#24536612)
Somebody buys you a $5,000 screwdriver. Do you just use it wrong, not take care of it, and ruin it to make a point about how all you wanted was to turn a screw?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by nicoburns on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:38PM (#24536728)
If that screwdriver makes it more difficult to turn a screw than a $50 screwdriver (or a $5 screwdriver) then... maybe?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by paulcole on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:50PM (#24536829)
Another thing being missed here is that the users in the original post didn’t want just a cup of coffee. If that’s all they wanted, they wouldn’t have used, not cleaned, and ruined the milk steaming wand.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by kempbellt on Sunday September 20, 2020 @04:19PM (#24537047)
You sell it, buy a regular screw driver, and spend the rest on cookies
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by WalterBright on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:49PM (#24536825)
> couldn’t be bothered to read an instruction manual

The manual for a new car is an inch thick, and flipping through it while driving trying to figure out how to turn on the defroster is BAD BAD BAD BAD design.

Re:We need physical audio kill switches by teknologist on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:10PM (#24536479)
Fancy touch screens could potentially tell users how/when to clean stuff?
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ionwake on Sunday September 20, 2020 @03:11PM (#24536487)
That the UI was shit and you’re the kind of person who endorses it.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by dang on Sunday September 20, 2020 @07:42PM (#24538384)
Personal attacks will get you banned on HN, so please don't do that here. Also can you please stop posting in the flamewar style? You've done it repeatedly lately, and it's against the site rules because we're trying for something a bit different on this site. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and posting in the intended spirit, we'd be grateful.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by ionwake on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:27PM (#24546079)
Sorry, I caused offence and will be more careful.
Re:We need physical audio kill switches by dang on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:49PM (#24548849)
Appreciated!