News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by aloknnikhil on Thursday August 06, 2020 @11:57AM (#24072132)
> Just like all Pixel devices, Pixel 4 will continue to get software and security updates for at least 3 years from when the device first became available on the Google Store in the U.S.

This is something I just don't understand. As phones get more powerful, there is absolutely no excuse to not support them for longer. When did the standard for supporting consumer devices get so low? Love it or hate it, Apple still supports the iPhone 6s Plus. A phone which is almost 5 years old now.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Guest19023892 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:19PM (#24072400)
I was thinking the same thing the other day. I just updated my parents' computers (which are 10 years old) to Windows 10. They still work great for their needs and they're up-to-date. I'm running a 7 year old ultrabook also on Windows 10. I'm planning to upgrade this year, but at least it's secure with the latest updates. I feel like we've been able to get a ton of use from these devices.

Meanwhile, I have a Samsung Note 2 phone which is 8 years old. It's fast enough for what I do (browse the internet for 10 minutes a day, send a dozen WhatsApp messages, book an Uber). That thing was released in 2012 and could no longer upgrade to new Android releases in 2014. That's pathetic. I need to replace it this year, not because it's too slow, but because it's insecure and no longer supported by anything. I was going to buy a smart scale the other day, but the app doesn't support my Android version. Also wanted an app for syncing the time with my Bluetooth GShock. Not supported. Sonos speakers? Not supported. It's a garbage phone now not because of the hardware, but because of the lack of support.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by exmadscientist on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:45PM (#24072701)
You're talking about three different classes of device: PCs, phones, and IoT (IoS)/deep embedded.

Embedded development is hard. Really hard. And much of that difficulty is intrinsic to the problem space, so it isn't going away anytime soon. But much of it is just embedded developers being masochists and embedded tool developers being sadists. For phones, the pain is probably 90% avoidable. 90 percent!

No, I don't know why we live with it either.

The reason your phone is different than your PC is that the PC's OS has all the drivers for everything built in, then loads whichever drivers your specific machine needs. Embedded Linux images are built specific to one model of hardware, with weird crappy OEM-provided drivers baked in and nowhere else available. It doesn't _have_ to be this way. But it is.

So to support your phone, the vendor basically maintains a custom-patched kernel with a bizarre build process. And that's done more or less independently for every model they're supporting. It's a huge headache!

Why deep embedded is this way is a little more understandable. (It's also where I prefer to work if I'm doing software; I don't like embedded Linux. It's just not my thing. So if I'm wrong when talking about it, that's why.) Deep embedded is often working with very limited hardware, custom circuits, and general strangeness. It also can serve the industrial, automotive, or medical markets, which naturally tend to longer product cycles. So the product is generally less standard, meaning it makes more sense (at least to me) why the support flow is so bespoke.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by eigenvector on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:45PM (#24074122)
> You're talking about three different classes of device: PCs, phones, and IoT (IoS)/deep embedded.

Not really, Google applies the same disposable approach to supporting ChromeOS on bog-standard x86 hardware. I have an x86 Chromebox that Google suddenly dropped all support for - including security patches - with a generic message that "your device is out of its support window". This basically rendered it useless as a ChromeOS device, because you can't browse the public web with an unpatched web browser. Yet I can run up-to-date Linux in Crouton.

I don't see how this is technically any different than Microsoft deciding to stop all Windows 10 patches on PCs older than a certain age not because of any blocking compatibility issue, but just because they've passed a certain age threshold and they don't want to do it anymore.

I used to evangelize ChromeOS as a great, simple solution for non-technical users who just want to browse the web without the hassle of maintaining a full-fledged PC, but I won't do that if Chrome devices are part of the smartphone "time based support model" rather than the "compatibility based support" model we've had on PCs for decades. A PC for basic use can easily last 10 years, OEMs who arbitrarily shorten that are not helping their customers.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by vidanay on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:59PM (#24072887)
That "custom-patched kernel with a bizarre build process" is a self-inflicted wound on the part of both Google and the carriers. It could have been corrected years ago.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by sangnoir on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:41PM (#24073401)
Surely, you mean "Qualcomm-inflicted wound"?

After TI left the Android SoC space, most OEMs and Carriers are beholden to Qualcomm, who write their own drivers and will never mainline them, if they can help it: long upgrade cycles will hurt Qualcomms bottomline, planned obsolescence via kernel incompatibility is how they achieve that. I don't think customers will upgrade from Snapdragon X05 to Snapdragon X20 for the minor gains in performance, if their old device could get the latest Android features.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by JetSpiegel on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:54PM (#24074219)
Couldn't Google bend Qualcomm to their will? Or even just buy them out, it's not like they lack the cash.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by sangnoir on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:55PM (#24074794)
Google decided on a cheaper technical solution instead - they only recently started abstracting Android drivers from the linux kernel (Project Treble[1]), which should allow drivers to continue working after the kernel has been updgraded.

1. https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2018/11/an-update-...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by corty on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:19PM (#24075018)
Except Qualcom drivers are so crappy, you can rely on a remote exploit via WiFi or BT every year. So no chance to use the phone longer than maybe 2 years, even if nominally the software support might be longer.

Not incidentally, "Qual" is german for "torture".

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by cogman10 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:23PM (#24073159)
Yup, and to that point, the fix is really stupid simple, push the drivers into the linux kernel mainline and give google (or whoever) a kernel build profile for your device.

Done. You don't have to support the device for an eternity and, as a bonus, you can benefit from OS improvements to your drivers/etc. Hell, you and other manufactures using the same broadcom SOC (and hear me out... this might sound crazy) wouldn't have to spend the same engineering effort building drivers!

Of course, that would require manufactures to actually give a damn about driver quality, whereas the current situation allows them to push out the most broken patch imaginable to pass whatever conformance tests google asks for.

That would also cut into manufactures bottom line which is why I suspect they've not gone down this route. Gotta sell them phones every year... (they'd cut support to 1 month if they could)

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ebg13 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:17PM (#24073842)
> Yup, and to that point, the fix is really stupid simple, push the drivers into the linux kernel mainline and give google (or whoever) a kernel build profile for your device.

"If only the bad people would just stop being bad!"

This mantra continually assumes goodwill from people who continue to show that they have none. At some point one needs to stop gaslighting themselves and their users and make the system more robust to bad actors. Manufacturers don't want to mainline their drivers? Fine. You can work on getting drivers mainlined while also stabilizing the interface so that it doesn't injure a billion customers when they don't.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by JetSpiegel on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:57PM (#24074245)
Google earns more money with the current scheme, so they have no incentive to improve this. Android One is a joke, it should be the baseline for Android, not a "special" version.

They could force the OEM to play ball, like they require Google Play Services to be pre-installed.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by kelnos on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:56PM (#24075376)
> They could force the OEM to play ball, like they require Google Play Services to be pre-installed.

I think Google really has to walk a fine line here. Android OEMs are already not thrilled with their lack of freedom when it comes to changing the experience on their phones. The more restrictions Google adds on, the closer some of them (especially Samsung) will be to cutting ties with the Android name and forking.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by GeekyBear on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:28PM (#24075650)
Google had absolutely no problem with forcing the hands of device makers when it came to their ability to build devices running a fork of Android.

They are not powerless. They simply made the decision to treat carriers and device makers as the customers they cared about and not the people using the devices.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by JetSpiegel on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:25AM (#24109580)
And lose access to the Play Store? Ain't gonna happen! Not even Microsoft was able to break the duopoly.

Huawei only stopped shipping the Store because they were legally obligated.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by cogman10 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:36PM (#24074035)
Yeah, there definitely needs to be some sort of enforcement that keeps bad actors from misbehaving.

Google seems like the natural point for that. Maybe a law is needed? Too bad most law makers are completely tech illiterate.

But I agree, it won't change without some central force to kibosh it.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ansible on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:31PM (#24075674)
So this situation has persisted for years, across the entire Android ecosystem. You're not going to just fix it with "one simple trick".

> Yup, and to that point, the fix is really stupid simple, push the drivers into the linux kernel mainline and give google (or whoever) a kernel build profile for your device.

Yeaaaaahhh... I don't see most companies doing that.

1. It is a lot of work to clean up your driver (that will only ever be used on one product) enough to be accepted into the mainline kernel. It takes time, effort and skill. Companies don't want to pay for that, because it doesn't contribute to bottom line. The MO is: get the product out... yesterday so we can sell it and make some money.

2. Even if it was accepted, does that mean it is going to work forever afterwards because the Linux kernel fairies / pixies / whatever will maintain it? No. If you're going push out a new release to end users, you'd better make damn sure it works. So that means each Android release has to go through a long round of QA. Who's going to pay for that?

There's only a couple ways out of the current mess we are in. Only one is likely to actually work.

Option 1: Release the IP! Have basically all phone SoCs (system on chip) use the same IP blocks for the display, I2C, SPI, memory controllers, GPIO, various sensors, power management, etc. Then you can be more like a PC where the system can basically boot up, and you can then download additional drivers as needed. This will never happen.

Option 2: Fuchsia style microkernel. Create a device driver API for the various SoC hardware blocks, and make it good and flexible enough that you never, ever have to change the API. The device driver binary is written once during initial product development, and can be carried into newer OS updates with no changes at all.

People need to realize that the SoC world is not like the PC world. Hardware interfaces change all the time, with every release of a new family member. Some stuff doesn't change much, like a USB host controller, because the SoC world has standardized that somewhat. Other stuff like power management is a total pain.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by vetinari on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:39PM (#24074077)
Partially.

You know, your PC has BIOS/UEFI and PCIE busses and other ways for kernel to discover what it is really running on, which drivers to load and so on.

ARM devices have none of these (except for servers, where Redhat had enough clout to say, that if your ARMv8 server has no UEFI, it will have no RHEL). Not only they add up to energy consumption (it is extra hardware, after all), they add up in the BOM as well (again, it is extra hardware). So we are stuck with kernels targeting only a known hardware (which today devicetree describes to some degree) and where a poke on a wrong port could mean that the entire device hangs. And after all, no consumers base their decision on whether a third party can replace the operating system, so why make a worse (=worse battery) and more expensive (=more BOM) than the competition?

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by nonbirithm on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:38PM (#24076169)
> No, I don't know why we live with it either.

Maybe it's the profit motive.

If companies are not incentivized to change, then nothing is going to change. If companies pushing OS and hardware refreshes every year means people are going to buy more phones, I'm not sure why they would have any reason to stop.

Anecdotally, I needed a new phone because my Pixel XL was getting 4 hours of standby time and was constantly overheating. I had just gotten back from an overseas trip and was nearly stranded several times from finding myself in remote places with my backup battery dead. In the end, I settled for a OnePlus 7 (ironic, I know). I would rather have used the Pixel for many more years. hate not having a headphone jack or bezel, and I know that some product manager is going to use my purchase as evidence that those "features" were the correct move and continue to propagate the belief that nobody wants headphone jacks or bezels anymore. But I was in serious need of a smartphone that was actually reliable over one that had a headphone jack or bezel, so I got one without those features anyway.

People like me are now reliant on smartphones to do things like make calls, navigate unknown places or look up things on cellular data. In my book, if people need to have a cellphone in order to function in modern society, or are at least strongly incentivized to have one, then planned obsolescence only increases profits. Companies can market this as "upgrading" to new phones with a festureset that doesn't have to be a significant improvement over the last generation, and if people are used to this and don't mind spending the money to upgrade, then this will continue. And there are surely a lot of people who will buy the lastest model anyway even if they don't absolutely need to upgrade.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ffpip on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:47PM (#24072729)
Since you are planning to replace it, first unlock the bootloader of the old device. Then install whatever version of android is available for your device on xda-developers.com

Always check exact version/model (US model, Indian Model, etc) before flashing ROMs

Full Guide to unlock - https://gearallnews.com/how-to-unlock-the-bootloader-of-sams...

Your phone's XDA page - https://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-note-2

Check out what Custom ROM you want here https://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-note-2/orig-developm...

Use TWRP to flash ROM - https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1938733

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by knorker on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:50PM (#24072765)
That's not a fair comparison. PCs have barely gotten faster in the last 10 years. 20 years ago you could spend $2000 every 3 years and get a 10x better computer. Not so last 10 years. Aside from graphics cards the hardware has not gotten noticeably better or faster for day to day work.

So of course you can upgrade to windows 10.

Phone hardware has. Very much so.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by cogman10 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#24073326)
Yeah, but that's not why windows 10 still works on 10 year old hardware.

Windows works on 10 year old hardware because hardware manufactures don't get to modify the windows kernel. Instead, they have to push out drivers which work with the windows kernel.

It's really that simple.

There are several solutions here.

Google could make their own kernel which is closer to the microsoft kernel methodology (Fuchsia is basically just that)

Google could ban devices that with custom kernels from the play store (They MIGHT be able to do that now, then again, Android could be forked).

Google could create a private kernel repo and have manufactures submit to it. They could have their own kernel build profiles. (if getting things into mainline linux are deemed too difficult).

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by hyko on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:23PM (#24073160)
PCs have gotten a lot faster in the last 10 years. Not 10x every three years better, but significantly better. The high end PC of 2020 would crush the high end PC of 2010.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by majormajor on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:44PM (#24073441)
Performance has increased, sure, but it's different.

Compare the best PC from 1990 with the best one from 2000. That change makes 2010-2020 look like it was standing still.

Phone evolution for maybe 5-10 years after 2007 was more like the nineties, though it's definitely starting to slow now.

And Windows 2000, from 1999, for instance, only supported ~4 year old hardware. Windows 10 has it much easier!

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by hyko on Saturday August 08, 2020 @01:51AM (#24089397)
Yes, the rate of change for PC performance in the 90s was insane, and the effect was magnified by the fact that most horizontal applications benefitted from the extra power.

The OP was claiming that there’s barely been any change in performance in the 2010s, which is just not true.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by basch on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:11PM (#24074941)
a mid grade 2010 PC with an SSD upgrade will still be extremely usable. Go 5 years to something like a Broadwell i7, and many people might not be able to tell its 5 years old. I would expect that CPU to function fine for 5 more years. (albeit it no longer has support or security patches.)

The biggest improvement, from a most people perspective, in the last 5 years is power usage. They run cooler, and batteries last longer.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by magicalhippo on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:32PM (#24075160)
Indeed. I just picked up a laptop from my shelf the other day that had been collecting dust for years (literally booted it last in July 2017), as a friend needed a replacement laptop.

The laptop was bought in 2011. It was a fairly cheap one then, and has a dual-core i3 with hyperthreading, and it came with an SSD. I added another some RAM I had laying around so now it has 8GB.

After getting a fresh copy of Win10 on it, it's surprisingly usable. Webpages loads just fine, YouTube is accelerated so is smooth. I could totally use that for my daily laptop had it not been for the rather lackluster 1366x768 screen.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by boring_twenties on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:57PM (#24074247)
Yeah, but does it make any difference in day to day usage? I don't think it does. I'm using a 4770K at the moment. A Ryzen 3600 compiles my C++ project 30-40% faster, but that's literally the only time my old CPU is a bottleneck. If I wasn't working with C++, I can't see any reason I would want to upgrade the CPU -- even 7 years later.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by stepbeek on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:38AM (#24079017)
A Ryzen 3600 is a different tier than a 4770k though. So you're effectively saying a mid-tier CPU today will handily beat a top tier CPU from 7 years ago.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by boring_twenties on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:15PM (#24085486)
It doesn't matter what tier it is. The point is that compiling C++ is the only thing that even comes close to maxing out the 7 year old CPU.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by pjmlp on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:02AM (#24078841)
I still do most of my Java, .NET, C++ development on a 2009 laptop, it does the job, doesn't matter what will crush it on 2020.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scarface74 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @07:36PM (#24076540)
That’s true. But a high end PC released in 2010 can still run the latest version of Windows, Office, and Chrome well.

This was my work laptop in 2010 with 8GB of RAM and a 2.66Ghz Core Duo. They let me keep it after the company folded. Until late last year, it was my Plex server and I used it occasionally since it sat right by my work computer.

https://www.cnet.com/reviews/dell-latitude-e6500-review/

The only time that it felt slow compared to a modern computer was disk access. I could have upgraded it with an SSD if I wanted to.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by tokamak-teapot on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:46PM (#24073475)
It’s not obvious when doing just normal stuff on an iPhone SE vs an iPhone 5s, which is about 7 years old now.

I use the 5s as a Spotify player and when I wiped it and set it up for the task, I was pleasantly surprised at how snappy it still felt and how everything I tried with it continued to work.

The hardware doesn’t have to be incredibly fast to support most of the functions supported - it’s only a small subset that really benefit from extra CPU speed and hardware acceleration.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by cowmoo728 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:56PM (#24072847)
Desktops and laptops are commodity hardware with standardized drivers and interfaces. Phones are secretive buggy hardware running secretive buggy binary blobs. It's difficult to get manufacturers to upstream anything or even give you any information at all about their hardware, and it's a herculean task to work around all the firmware oddities to upgrade devices yourself.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scns on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:46PM (#24072717)
You can put LineageOS on the Note 2 if it is the LTE version.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:39PM (#24075745)
More and more apps break with custom ROMs now though. Netflix is the big one.

Still probably worth the trade off though - Lineage OS is great.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mindslight on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:10PM (#24075986)
The answer is to start using open ROMs before you get sucked into attractive nuisances like Netflix. However if you're stuck now, get a second device and work on weaning yourself off.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by theodric on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:18PM (#24076022)
Hear, hear. Who wants to watch TV for 19 minutes on a phone before it overheats and the battery dies, anyway? And then how am I supposed to compulsively doomscroll while ignoring the show I'm ostensibly watching? Hard pass.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ogre_codes on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:18PM (#24073109)
I don't think comparing the phone to a PC is entirely fair. A smartphone gets used everywhere and more or less constantly. Even a laptop is mostly used on a desk or other flat workspace where it's less likely to get dropped/ flushed/ etc. Also, up until 4-5 years ago, smartphones were moving pretty quickly in terms of capabilities.

On the other hand, comparing the useful life of this to the iPhone is entirely reasonable, particularly since its the price of a mid-high end iPhone. It's pretty sad when you realize that the new iPhone SE released just 6 months after the Pixel 4 will almost certainly be supported for 2-3 years after Google has abandoned the twice-as-expensive Pixel 4.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by _nothing on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:25PM (#24073189)
They're not talking about hardware durability though. They're just talking about software support. Wear and tear on the physical device should have nothing to do with the company's willingness to continue supplying software/security updates to the phone years down the road.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by swebs on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:08PM (#24072996)
This is the exact reason why my next phone will be a Pinephone (just waiting for it to ship now). I'm expecting it to last a good 10 years just like any decent Linux laptop.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jneplokh on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:12PM (#24072323)
People love to hate (which seems justified on the surface) on Apple's high prices, but the unparalleled years of support makes it worth it for me. Especially for phones like the SE.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by fmakunbound on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:03PM (#24072933)
I have an iPhone 6S Plus. Apparently it came out in 2015. The ORIGINAL Pixel was announced in 2016. I'm still getting support for the 6S Plus - I actually have iOS14 beta running on it rather pleasantly. It's plenty fast, too.

Based on support period, one can easily justify the most costly iPhone over the seemingly temporarily supported Google/Samsung etc. flagship.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by JetSpiegel on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:00PM (#24074276)
https://wiki.lineageos.org/devices/sailfish

Non-professional developers support Android Q on the original Pixel, but Google is too resource-starved, apparently.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mywittyname on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:16PM (#24073826)
I still rock an OG Pixel. I haven't seen an update in a while, but hardware-wise the phone is solid.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mywittyname on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:30PM (#24074540)
Why all of the downvotes?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by delecti on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:39PM (#24074630)
Likely because your statement that your Pixel 1 still works and is not receiving software updates is exactly in line with the points being made in the comment you replied to, and people are probably interpreting your point as "but my device is fine, what's the problem". The problem is that your device which is still working fine isn't receiving software support.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mrguyorama on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:49PM (#24073505)
If only they put even remotely good batteries in their phones. The battery they generally spec out seems to only handle one day of mild use (including accounting for Apple's very efficient processors), and VERY quickly loses capacity and other specs. I'm sad they don't provide an option for if you like having 3500mAh or more.

Unfortunately I still wouldn't be happy with an iPhone as I'm just not a fan of iOS

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Tepix on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:06PM (#24073723)
The batteries are usually decent for the first two years. After two years, getting a battery replacement from a 3rd party has gotten cheaper and can be worthwhile (right now it's 35€ for an iPhone 6S and 45€ for an iPhone X)
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by theodric on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:19PM (#24076035)
Comment was referencing multi-day usage, not overall lifetime
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by entropea on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:07PM (#24073739)
I tend to use my phone more as a computer with a lot of SSH, unzip/unrar, downloading audio files, editing audio files, sending videos, full file manager access, and I want to move to iOS because I am absolutely not liking Google at all, and have tried, but it's just not there yet. I see improvements being made, but things like not being able to hold open an SSH session without subscriptions or expensive applications is a big issue for me. iPhones also can't play .webm's and other media files. I have a 6S plus I keep trying, but its personally not there yet.

Also not a fan of face unlock and wish they'd implement a fingerprint into the screen. I usually block out the front camera and any sensors that I don't use.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by GuB-42 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:59PM (#24072884)
Early Android devices had removable batteries and most of the popular ones had custom ROMs that extended support for way beyond OEM updates.

The irony is that early Android phones were built to last, but quickly got obsoleted by more recent models. Now, progress is much slower, but the thing that kept devices alive (removable batteries and community ROMs) are dying. Real obsolescence is replaced by planned obsolescence.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by gruez on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:37PM (#24073345)
> Early Android devices had removable batteries and most of the popular ones had custom ROMs that extended support for way beyond OEM updates.

how long is "way beyond OEM updates"? one year? two years? three years? five years? The main problem is that third party roms can only update so much. Without OEM support, you're not going to be getting updates for the proprietary bits of your phone. This includes blobs, baseband, and even the kernel (technically it's open source, but all android phones run off a customized kernel that's specific to that SoC. When that SOC gets EOLed, the updates stop coming).

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jneplokh on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:57PM (#24075395)
Even if there are custom ROMs and the like, as gruez said, you will not be receiving updates for other critical parts of the phone. Regardless, those are only community supported, and not from the vendor.

I have far less trust in a random community. Plus, their EOL could be completely unexpected.

I do not want my phone to be reliant on community updates, personally.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by class4behavior on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:14PM (#24074407)
This thread talks about Apple as if they're the only company offering support and warranties. Whether it's their products or services, Apple's success is based on a smooth experience and they pursue to control the entire ecosystem. So for them to offer long-lasting support is neither surprising nor significant.

The Android phone market is distributed. You can get almost anything there you can get from Apple, in particular wherever the competition regulators had done their work.

The stuff Google itself is participating in is a different matter. Honestly, with respect to consumer products and UX Google is generally a failure. It's like Google is full of engineers and analysts but lacks talent in every other profession. Even Microsoft which has been so often a late-comer and the death for so many brands seems to be better at it.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ensignavenger on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:42PM (#24073413)
How long is Apple's guaranteed support?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by supernova87a on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:02PM (#24073683)
They don't have a "guaranteed support" lifetime, because instead they just have a track record of supporting hardware well beyond the (2-3 sigma) x (average) person keeping their hardware.

When you see "guaranteed support" by a manufacturer, you can be sure that it actually means "guaranteed end of support" timeline. Which Google follows exactly.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by davidbarker on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:14PM (#24074416)
I was curious so I looked to see if I could find a chart that shows how long iPhones typically receive iOS updates. Some are up to 6 major releases (and possibly more — we'll find out next year).

https://www.statista.com/chart/5824/ios-iphone-compatibility...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ensignavenger on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:50PM (#24074177)
Their track record seems to be more recent- earlier iPhone's were not supported nearly as long, from what I have seen.

While Google may end support as soon as they can, not all manufacturers do.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by outworlder on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:36PM (#24075199)
> Their track record seems to be more recent- earlier iPhone's were not supported nearly as long, from what I have seen.

This is sort of true.

It is true that Apple dropped support for older devices much faster in the past. But it is also true that the older devices were way underpowered.

As an example: when Apple introduced home screen backgrounds on the iPod Touch, they released the same software upgrade for all iPods. However, since the older generation didn't have enough compute power (most likely GPU), they disabled the feature for older generations. I thought they were trying to force people to upgrade, but after a jailbreak and force enabling the feature, I realized that it was not the case. It was not smooth, so this is why they disabled it.

Same goes for, say, iPads. The first iPad quickly got obsoleted, but it was also very underpowered compared to subsequent devices.

They will not hesitate to drop hardware if it turns out to be insufficient, but they are just as likely to disable a feature if there is insufficient hardware support and allow the OS upgrade anyway.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by geodel on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:22PM (#24074481)
Other vendors are far worse. After using iphone 5s for 4+ years, My kid now watches youtube or play game etc on that phone. Android phones after 2-3 years basically turn to crap. It could be OS/ battery/plastic shell/screen that fail for sure.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by eisa01 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:22PM (#24074483)
The original iPhone had 3 years support, same as the Pixel 4 :)
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by tw04 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:21PM (#24072426)
As someone who has bounced back and forth between iPhone and Android over the years: my hate hasn't seemed to have been fixed over the years. Sure Apple will push updates for 5 years, but after about 3 years somehow the latest update makes the phone so slow as to be unusable. It's happened to me with every iPhone I've owned (3G, 6, and I guess we'll see on the latest).
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by alyandon on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:33PM (#24072575)
If it helps ease your concerns any - my current work issued phone is the lowest end iPhone 6S model and it is still running fine to this day on latest iOS. Granted, the 6S is a pretty significant spec bump up from the iPhone 6.

The performance of my personal Pixel 2 on the other hand has not held up nearly as well by comparison and my next personal phone will likely be an iPhone even though I'm not a great fan of Apple.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by plif on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:15PM (#24073071)
I also have a work iPhone and a Pixel 2 personal phone. I haven't encountered the same thing as you in terms of performance, they seem to be aging pretty similarly to me.

Google's attitude to customer support and brand loyalty, on the other hand, is a different story...

My girlfriend's Pixel 4 screen cracked and was a huge PITA to fix even though we paid a ton for extra warranty. Trying to get that fixed was far more painful than any experience I've had with other brands.

Worse than that, there is a software bug that can / will irreversibly brick your Pixel 2 rear camera. You can find a ton of info on it by searching. It doesn't seem to affect everyone, but I was unlucky enough to hit it last week, presumably from a recent update. Google has been absolutely silent on this issue. Unethical at best, and probably worse.

There was a time where I would have scoffed at paying a premium for Apple or other brands that sell an experience more than just a device. That's completely changed now. I don't have the patience or energy in my life to deal with what I perceive to be Google's cold / impersonal / numbers oriented approach to customers. It's just not worth the stress. If anything, I'm willing to pay a pretty big premium for the opposite. If that means switching our household to Apple products, so be it and good riddance.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by alyandon on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:17PM (#24073839)
I didn't mean to imply my Pixel 2 is unusable by any means. The phone is still perfectly usuable but it is certainly not as snappy as it used to be despite its ridiculous overpowered specs. For instance, bringing up common applications like the camera or dialer has noticeable lag now under current Android 10 that wasn't present in previous versions of Android.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by BiggsHoson on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:49PM (#24072746)
My Pixel 2 XL has been humming along nicely, even on Android 10. Maybe I should worry how Android 11 will run on it--it will be the last update planned for this phone, and hence an opportunity for Google to make me unsatisfied with my old phone--but as it stands now I have no performance complaints whatsoever.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by daok on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:58PM (#24072877)
My Pixel 2 XL had heating issue. The battery couldn't last much at the end. I couldn't use it as GPS anymore (plugged or not) because it was over heating. I have a Pixel 4... still get warning about heat when using it as GPS once in a while ( I have the phone in the A/C vents so it has no reason to get that warm).
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mrguyorama on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:54PM (#24073576)
Contrary to your view, I have a Pixel 2 XL and the battery is still stupendous. My only disappointment is how long it takes to charge on an old style, 500ma-1amp charger.

Did you leave in plugged into the AC adapter overnight? anecdotally that killed my previous phones and there's also (anecdotal?) evidence that it isn't great for it.

Have you checked what apps are eating all the battery? On older phones, newer versions of certain apps seemed to turn them into pocket warmers, getting stuck in a tight CPU loop and efficiently turning 3000mAh into heat at about 5 watts

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by iainmerrick on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:55PM (#24074221)
Did you leave in plugged into the AC adapter overnight? anecdotally that killed my previous phones and there's also (anecdotal?) evidence that it isn't great for it.

Don’t most people do exactly that with their phones? If that’s something that actually breaks a phone, that’s ridiculous and they should fix it.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ufmace on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:17PM (#24073092)
Similar complaint - I have a Pixel 2. Everything still works great, except for the battery, which lasts around a third as long as when it was new. I checked out replacing it, appears to be highly difficult to not damage the screen when replacing. Sigh. I'm ordering a Pixel 4a to replace it.

It's kind of a drag that once they finally got the fundamental hardware and OS good enough to really last for a few years, they also made it nearly impossible to do what should be simple maintenance.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by _nothing on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:34PM (#24073302)
Anecdotal for sure, but my Pixel 2 is still running great. My last one was running even better until it got stolen. The batter life, while not phenomenal, was still pretty good since I took care to preserve it (just basic things like not charging it over night, keeping it around 60-80% battery).

After it was stolen, I bought another Pixel 2 used and while the battery life is worse, it still runs perfectly well as far as I can tell.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by andredz on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:33PM (#24075689)
Even the iPhone 6 runs all right. I have dropped mine quite a few times and it still works fine for my needs (which are not many since I have a computer). I have to admit that sometimes it doesn't start charging without shaking the cable a bit though, and not being able to update to the latest iOS version is regrettable.

But what I'm saying is that my iPhone 6 is still running mostly fine as well.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by FreakyT on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:33PM (#24072568)
I've heard that was the case for some of the older devices, but they're really gotten better at it. I'm currently using an OG iPhone SE (a 4 year old phone) and I'm running iOS 14 beta and it runs great.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by dunnevens on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:43PM (#24072683)
I'm still running an 6s plus. My luck might run out with iOS 14, but so far so good. It was expensive when new, but I've gotten 5 years out of it. Might get 6 if the update doesn't hurt it. Still runs quickly. Screen is still scratch free. Despite it's high initial price, it's been a bargain overall.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by andredz on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:38PM (#24075730)
I still have the iPhone 6. Since it became "obsolete" I stopped keeping tracking of iOS updates but I feel like it hasn't hurt much. I can't really install many apps anyway since it only has about 11 GB of effective space (the "System " uses 6.87 GB)
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jonathanlydall on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:32PM (#24072561)
I'm using iPhone 6S with latest iOS and no issues with performance. Although I did replace the battery last year for about 800ZAR (~$45) from a certified Apple repairs company.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by 52-6F-62 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:38PM (#24072621)
I'm on an iPhone 8 Plus which is a 3-year old device and I've had 0 performance or battery issues. I plan on keeping this one as long as possible.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jl6 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:25PM (#24075623)
Same here. I purchased it expecting it to last me 5 years, and so far that plan looks sound. I’ve followed the release of subsequent phones in the review media, and I don’t feel like there have been any compelling new features since that would tempt me to upgrade sooner.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by skellera on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:24PM (#24072471)
The newest phones are so overpowered for their actual use. They should last years. The only thing will be switching out batteries from time to time.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jventura on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:08PM (#24072991)
I’m replying to you on a iPhone 5S (2013 model) running iOS 12 (the last supported version), and it runs perfectly fine for me.. Maybe it’s slow as hell comparing to the latest model, but it allows me to do everything I need it to do for me..
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by 0x202020 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:42PM (#24072675)
I use a first generation iPhone SE every day in conjunction with my regular iPhone 11 Pro Max and I definitely wouldn’t call it unusable. The main pain point I have with it is loading a heavy webpage if I don’t have ad blocking on
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by supernova87a on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:04PM (#24073708)
You should get your battery replaced. That is generally the cause of performance slowdown -- see the iphone battery complaints thread. But it is known, and an easy fix.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by maxaht on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:58PM (#24072867)
This seems like an odd thing to say about a company that was caught purposefully slowing down older models
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by thedanbob on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:19PM (#24073112)
As I understand it, Apple slowed down certain models to deal with the problem of batteries losing capacity over time. Which actually could give those phones a longer usable life (slower is better than shutting off completely). The problem was they didn't tell people they were doing it.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mrguyorama on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:56PM (#24073592)
Also usable here should be in pretty big quotes. The phone didn't die and turn off, but it didn't get much done either. It could possibly still make phone calls
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by valuearb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:13PM (#24073807)
No, the phone was still usable, just slower.

If Apple didn’t throttle, the phone would restart every time it’s power requirements outstripped the batteries declining capacity.

I think it’s pretty clear which use case is better.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by supernova87a on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:06PM (#24073733)
That has been explained a bunch of times:

Apple gives performance beyond what you would expect for a similar phone, in terms of battery life and responsiveness. Then, as you burn through your battery's age beyond what even other phone manufacturers would warrant, the OS slows down the CPU to let you continue using it. So it's actually giving you more than you would've gotten otherwise.

But all the complaints are that iPhone sucks, I guess.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by chillwaves on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:14PM (#24073816)
Be transparent.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by somehnguy on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:01PM (#24074290)
Move the goalposts
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by chillwaves on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:21PM (#24075586)
Is that really such a bold expectation that when I buy a phone the manufacture will not use hidden software to downgrade the performance without informing me?

Your standards are in the basement.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by GeekyBear on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:40PM (#24075767)
As opposed to this?

>the past couple of months have seen a sudden increase in Nexus 6P battery complaints, with many users reporting that their phones suddenly shut down, even though there was plenty of battery life remaining

It's not a simple system crash, because your phone will stay dead until you connect it to a charger.

https://android.gadgethacks.com/news/nexus-6p-battery-random...

That seems especially problematic if you are on the go and need to make an emergency call to summon help.

A working phone seems preferable.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by chillwaves on Thursday August 06, 2020 @08:14PM (#24076735)
Yes, and what part of transparency is opposed to a working phone? Apple did not have to do what they did in secret. Nothing you have said responds to what I said.

This isn't an "Apple vs Android" discussion. Maybe that's where you got confused.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by GeekyBear on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:29AM (#24078671)
Google didn't provide a working phone.

When users complained that their phones died while showing a 50% charge and would not work again until connected to a charger, Google did nothing to fix the problem.

>The processor easily overheated, a bootloop bug made quite a few units die prematurely, and lastly, a battery problem surfaced that led to early shutdowns anywhere between 50 and 0 percent. At least the remaining owners of this Nexus device don't have to worry about the latter issue anymore — according to Google, that is. An engineer just marked the early shutdown entry in the company's issue tracker as "fixed."

I don't know about you, but when I just retrieved my Nexus 6P from my junk drawer a minute ago, it didn't have an update pending.

https://www.androidpolice.com/2019/11/16/nexus-6p-early-shut...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by thebruce87m on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:31PM (#24073970)
I can’t believe people still perpetuate this distortion of the truth. It has to be malicious by this point.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by maxaht on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:26PM (#24075629)
Is it really too much to ask of a company for them to tell us when they're throttling our phones? Yes, they had a technical reason to do so, but people are right to be skeptical about this when it takes a lawsuit for this to come out.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by somehnguy on Thursday August 06, 2020 @10:03PM (#24077296)
You willfully tried to spread misinformation in your original comment.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by maxaht on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:54PM (#24084032)
Where did I lie? Apple was hit with a $500 million fine for nothing?

I'm not an Apple hater by any means. I understand they had their technical reasons, I was just pointing out the dichotomy between their perceived willingness to support older models and the lawsuit that says they are slowing them down.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by somehnguy on Saturday August 08, 2020 @04:02PM (#24094746)
Right here:

>This seems like an odd thing to say about a company that was caught purposefully slowing down older models <END>

That is a half truth and considered lying through omission. It's misleading because as written it implies that they slowed down phones without a valid reason, AKA to force upgrades.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mnm1 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:00PM (#24072900)
Yeah, but I can buy 5 to 6 android phones for the price of Apple's high end phones. So while this makes sense for their cheapest product, even that is twice the price. So the comparison is between 2 to 5 generations of android phones and one generation of an apple phone.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by esperent on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:19PM (#24073123)
And who cares about the stupid environment, am I right?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by blacksmith_tb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:58PM (#24074814)
Well, a smartphone is fairly bad for its small size, but we're talking less than 100kg of CO2[1][2] to make and operate for its lifetime. But driving a car for a year in the US produces 4600kg[3]...

1: https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-iphone-x-environmental-repor...

2: https://sustainability.google/reports

3: https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/greenhouse-gas-emissions-t...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by esperent on Thursday August 06, 2020 @10:57PM (#24077553)
My understanding is that CO2 output is the least worrying part of smartphone usage. It's all the other toxic waste released during mining. Also, if cars are more polluting, that just means cars are bad too, not that smartphones are magically ok.

https://phys.org/news/2018-08-ways-smartphone-environment.ht...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mnm1 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:42PM (#24074100)
You are right. Few do. If people cared about the environment that much, they would have lobbied for laws against planned obsolescence. Me buying 5 phones or even 500 won't make a difference to the environment. Laws forcing phone makers to support their phones for a minimum of x years might. Clearly, our society is not interested in that. Why should I then go out of my way to inconvenience myself to do something that will make zero difference? No reason to at all.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by gpm on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:54PM (#24073581)
Typically price is a pretty good indicator of the amount of resources that went into making something. I'd expect the environmental cost of an iphone to be a similar multiple of the environmental cost of an android.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by saagarjha on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:37PM (#24074051)
Cheaper devices also tend to be less environmentally-friendly.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Dig1t on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:42PM (#24074655)
The corollary of your point is that its okay because we can just buy more phones more often, which seems like an environmentally horrible option.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mnm1 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @07:11PM (#24076389)
Socially and legally, we are ok with it, indeed. Otherwise, we wouldn't allow such a short support window. Our culture is now completely based upon planned obsolescence. I don't agree with it, but that's reality. These are the incentives society provides. In theory, it could easily provide others. In reality, Apple/Google are in many way more powerful than our government so it's unlikely. Like I said above, if this is a problem, it can be fixed. It's not a problem for me. I'd like more support, but I'm ok without support also. Not ideal, but I'm also not going to waste a thousand bucks on a phone either. Or even $400 for the cheapest iphone.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Sidnicious on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:50PM (#24072756)
Apple has support statuses for discontinued products which kick in five years ("vintage") and seven years ("obsolete") after the it stops being sold.

It's disingenuous for Google to start counting when the product is released. As the buyer, I don't care when it was released, I care when you sold it to me as new. I could buy a Chromecast Ultra (the current-generation 4K Chromecast, released November 2016: https://store.google.com/us/product/chromecast_ultra) and, by this standard (which may not even apply to Chromecasts, FWIW), they could discontinue it and drop support for it tomorrow.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by kps on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:30PM (#24073954)
> Apple has support statuses for discontinued products which kick in five years ("vintage") and seven years ("obsolete") after the it stops being sold.

That doesn't mean OS support. Apple sold the iPhone 6 until September 2018¹ but it did not get iOS 13 only one year later.

¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPhone_6

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ISL on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:01PM (#24072198)
I believe I purchased my present desktop in 2010.

Perpetual donations to debian and apt update; apt dist-upgrade keep it in tip-top shape. The same cannot be said for a growing drawer of phones/tablets that are no longer supported/updated.

(I was glad to see that partial postmarketos support is present for at least some of those devices now. Looking forward to trying that out when I get a chance.)

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by rsync on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:34PM (#24074595)
"I believe I purchased my present desktop in 2010."

My daily driver desktop, from which I do all of the rsync.net CEO things - from terminal to VMWare - is an octo-mac-pro from early 2009.

Currently running el-cap. Nothing is ever slow. 11 years and counting ...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by dehrmann on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:09PM (#24072285)
To be fair, x86 Debian will happily run on a Pentium II from 1998.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mrguyorama on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:58PM (#24073621)
"Happily" is a stretch. I ran Damn Small Linux (because puppy actually wouldn't fit) on a 233mhz pentium II, with 32mb of RAM and it was..... semi functional (including allowing the USB 1.0 ports on the motherboard to work!) but multitasking or complex tasks caused it to hard lock up and I was too young and uneducated to diagnose the problems
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by dehrmann on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:30AM (#24078680)
I think my 440BX motherboard supported up to 384 MB of RAM--that would have helped a lot. You can still get PCI SATA controllers for fast swap. You're still capped at 133 MBps because of PCI, but PC100 RAM only runs at 800 MBps, anyway.

What's amazing about the PII is it's the oldest "modern" computer in a few ways. USB came out around the same time, and i686 is the oldest x86 architecture still supported by modern distros out-of-the-box. i686 will be 25 years old in November. The fact that it's still supported is incredible.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by akerro on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:19PM (#24072402)
Yes, I still have AMD Duron 800 which runs on Linux
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by qchris on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:47PM (#24072722)
Alternatively, depending on your hardware requirements, you might want to consider taking a look at the Mobian (mobile Debian) project. Only the Pinephone is currently supported, but you get things like `apt` instead of `apk` on pmOS, which is based on Alpine Linux. Both are great projects, of course, and I think pmOS is focused on more devices.

[1] https://mobian-project.org/

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by deelowe on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:31PM (#24072546)
Is all of the hardware in that desktop still supported by the vendors? I'd imagine not. Go check the ram compatibility list for the motherboard and see when the newest module was manufactured. This is always the first thing that gets dropped from support.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ISL on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:53PM (#24072813)
I installed a couple of new sticks of RAM in the Spring.

In terms of security updates for motherboards and other hardware, they're very rare. For my phones/tablets, some are literally pinned to ~Android 6, with just oodles of known security holes.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by fulafel on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:10PM (#24074939)
rowhammer?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ptman on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:48AM (#24079405)
Those phones really should be recycled instead of collecting dust. Of course being usable and secure would be the best, but you can't have everything.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by necheffa on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:45PM (#24072706)
Some of it has to do with hardware vendors like Qualcomm refusing to support older chipsets with newer kernels, or you know, just open sourcing their drivers.

My pixel 1 is basically stuck on a 3.18 kernel forever, even if I go and compile AOSP myself, because of Qualcomm's nom-free drivers.

At a certain point, companies like Google have to decide how much they want to backport fixes to older systems. Apparently they've decided on 3 years.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by kevincox on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:21PM (#24073138)
Yup, it is hard to commit to a long security patch lifetime if you can't patch around bugs in major hardware components.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by MBCook on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:12PM (#24073792)
If only Google could make their own phone or phone OS so they were in control over these kind of issues.

Wait...

These are issues totally within their control. These excuses shouldn’t be acceptable.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by kevincox on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:15PM (#24073822)
I'm not saying that Google couldn't make their own processor but it is a serious undertaking. I don't think we can scoff at them for not doing it yet.

Even in their datacenters they use third party CPUs. It's not surprising that they haven't made their own for phones.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by MBCook on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:48PM (#24074159)
They don’t have to make their own CPU. They could use a CPU with a couple of years of guaranteed support. If Qualcomm doesn’t want to do that, choose someone else.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by themacguffinman on Thursday August 06, 2020 @08:06PM (#24076686)
I'm sure they would if they could, but almost everyone uses Qualcomm for a reason: Qualcomm has a practical monopoly on high-end smartphone chips and competition is difficult because of their patent ownership.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Leherenn on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:01PM (#24075423)
Well, actually Qualcomm has 2 years of support, that's why most Android manufacturers also have 2 years usually.

They need more like 5/6, but no one seems to be willing to pay for it.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mywittyname on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:23PM (#24073895)
I think Google should start because I think the long-term viability of Android depends on it.

They don't even need to design the chips themselves. They could partner with Samsung / LG / Motorola to form a hardware consortium.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by kevincox on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:32PM (#24073991)
I wouldn't be surprised if they have started. They have only been in the phone game for ~4 years which I imagine is quite quick to get a custom CPU into a shipping product.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ta1234567890 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:07PM (#24072265)
I'm still using an iPhone 6 and it works great.

Nowadays 5 years is really not that old for a phone.

Phone manufacturers should release the specs and/or an open source version of the phone's os so people can provide their own support.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by philg_jr on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:19PM (#24072397)
The OS isn't the problem. The binary blobs from Qualcomm is the real problem.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ogre_codes on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:22PM (#24073149)
This is the massive advantage of rolling your own silicon.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by dudul on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:16PM (#24072371)
I would be interested in seeing data on that. When you say "5 years is not that old" it can be read as "a 5 year old phone works just fine" and I fully agree with that, but it may be considered old in the sense that not many 5 year old phones are in use today.

Do a lot of people ignore their carrier's emails about upgrading at the expiration of the contract? I know I do, but I always assumed most people just upgraded almost right away to the new version.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by andredz on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:40PM (#24075753)
Right, mine works fine as well. So you think that Apple should release the specs for the latests iOS that works with the iPhone 6?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ta1234567890 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:55PM (#24076279)
That would be great. But it would also be great if they just released the specs/code of the first version of iOS that worked with any older-than-5 phone.

I still run iOS 10.3 on mine, and really don't care about the latest one, probably would run very slow anyway.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Godel_unicode on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:17PM (#24072377)
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by drewg123 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:55PM (#24072836)
I'm an xoogler who has only owned Google Nexus and Pixel phones until recently when I switched to iPhone. The primary reason I switched was the limited support window that Google has for its phones.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by culopatin on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:55PM (#24073589)
Google and Microsoft lost me when I built a hackintosh on a Thinkpad X1 and my iPhone from work started syncing with it without me doing anything at all. Handoff, personal Hotspot, Airdrop, iMessage, continuity and all that working automatically is something google is very far from achieving with Microsoft.

I’ll keep a windows desktop for gaming, but once Apple settles down through its processor changes I might just get a personal iPhone and a MacBook Pro

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mdm_ on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:57PM (#24073619)
I was watching a review of the Pixel 4a on YouTube last night in which the reviewer likes the Pixel 4a and calls the iPhone SE “trash” in comparison because it has bezels. Nevermind that the iPhone will run circles around the 4a in terms of performance and probably receive OS updates for 2-3 years after the 4a is EOL’ed. But no, bezels = “trash”.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by hocuspocus on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:27PM (#24075097)
I've watched many Pixel 4a and OnePlus Nord reviews and they get compared against the SE a lot, yet I haven't heard anyone calling it trash. You should probably stick to more reputable YouTubers.

Also the form factor and screen to size ratio are very important criteria for a lot of people, if not the most.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by entropea on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:17PM (#24073838)
A significant portion of phone users are there for aesthetics and status. Those same people are unlikely to have a phone past 1-2 years after paying it off with their carrier.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by mywittyname on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:21PM (#24073870)
I haven't noticed the phone status thing in years. Everyone covers their phones with gigantic cases and phone design is largely generic anymore. So it's pretty hard to tell who has the latest one.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by entropea on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:28PM (#24073935)
iPhones have the largest amount of cases and commidity accessories, so cases and their designs are also a status and aesthetics thing.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by fsflover on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:24PM (#24073165)
This is exactly why people created Pinephone and Librem 5 with lifelong updates.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinephone

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Librem_5

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Multicomp on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:43PM (#24075798)
I'm so there with the Pinephone as soon as that slide out keyboard comes out.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jeremyjh on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:12PM (#24072317)
I love my 6s. I got a new battery last year and it still works great. I don't expect support to last a whole lot longer but the SE is not a very expensive replacement. I just don't want to give up my headphone jack.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by valuearb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:21PM (#24073869)
Just bought my daughter the new SE for her birthday. It’s amazing for the price!
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by whereistimbo on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:03PM (#24072928)
Blame Qualcomm. I'm sure this issue doesn't exist in Windows 10 ARM. This might change if Google-Samsung Exynos partnership came into fruition, so Google uses its own chip for its own phones
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by hn_check on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:29PM (#24073951)
"Blame Qualcomm"

This seems incredibly dubious as an excuse (for a variety of technical and business reasons), but has been the Google get out of jail card for a decade+ now.

More likely Google loses interest, the devices no longer make them any money and they want to wipe their hands of them.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scottlamb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:22PM (#24072448)
I agree they could and should be supported for longer, but regarding your comparison to Apple:

> Love it or hate it, Apple still supports the iPhone 6s Plus. A phone which is almost 5 years old now.

You're comparing what Google guarantees up-front for all devices to what Apple has done for the one device. Did Apple give a guaranteed support date for the iPhone 6s Plus at launch? In a quick search, I couldn't find one. I did find articles (eg [1]) from January speculating if Apple would include the iPhone 6S in the iOS 14 update or not.

Google still may support the Pixel 4 for longer than three years.

edit: forgot to add the disclaimer earlier that I'm a Google employee. I don't work on Android or hardware.

[1] https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/ios/story/don-t-ditch-y...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ogre_codes on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:21PM (#24073139)
Actions speak louder than words. 10+ years of supporting iPhones and continuously increasing the service life of them says a lot more than a marketing promise.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Sidnicious on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:56PM (#24072854)
Apple considers a product "vintage" five years and "obsolete" seven years after the last one is sold: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201624
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scottlamb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:02PM (#24072915)
Interesting, thanks! That covers hardware service/parts. Do they have a matching policy for software updates, at least security-related ones?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:26PM (#24072494)
Apple has a sufficient track record that speaks for itself.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by supernova87a on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:09PM (#24073759)
When you say Google guarantees support up front (like a benefit), what you'll really find is that's a guarantee support ends on that timeline.

Apple (in my observation) tends not to say what length of support will be given, but offers it well beyond when an average person would throw away a device 2-3x over.

When Google says 3 years guaranteed, you can be damned sure you're done at 3 years.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scottlamb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:36PM (#24074037)
> When you say Google guarantees support up front (like a benefit), what you'll really find is that's a guarantee support ends on that timeline.

No, they say at least and have extended support dates before, eg: https://chromeunboxed.com/chromebook-end-of-life-extended-13... (That's Chromebooks; I'm not sure about Nexus/Pixel phones in particular.)

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by djanogo on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:20PM (#24073135)
I constantly get down voted when I say iPhone is the cheapest and most secure mobile device you can buy. "Price is what you pay, value is what you get" -you know who.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by fsflover on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:27PM (#24073208)
It is only most secure if you undoubtedly trust Apple with everything and do not need to run any software except what they allow.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by heavyset_go on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:49PM (#24073504)
iOS exploits are cheaper to buy than Android exploits because iOS exploits are so plentiful.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by eitland on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:07PM (#24072979)
I switched to Apple last year.

It is now possible to use a decent[0] 3rd party keyboard on them and the XR is actually not that expensive compared to a number of other phones.

And for the first time since Samsung SII I'm happy with my phone :-)

[0]: the Apple keyboard doesn't support autocomplete while showing Norwegian letters, and it is also hilariously bad it seems wrt autocorrecting correctly spelled sentences into embarrassing ones and even going as far as autocorrecting one medicine name to another at some point. On SwiftKey one can at least turn of autocorrect.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by pragmatic on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:43PM (#24073423)
Third party keyboards don't seem to work well land are always getting reset to the standard one.

(On my iPad). User error?

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by eitland on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:11PM (#24073783)
I had to disable the built in to stop that from happening.

Not user error. Bad QA from Apple and/or third party keyboard.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by zantana on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:54PM (#24074211)
On my iphone the problem is solved by restarting the app. My assumption was either the keyboard or the app updated and lost contact with the other, but I find killing the app solves the problem.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by e40 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:55PM (#24073586)
It makes iPhones look cheaper, given you don't have to replace them as often. I expect to keep my 11 for more than 5 years, which will make that $800 price less painful.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by valuearb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:19PM (#24073858)
Today’s phones are cheap.

Even expensive phones are cheaper than their wireless service contracts in the US. A good rule of thumb is they depreciate about 50% in their first two years (at least for iPhones).

That means your $800 phone is costing you less than $20/month: A $1400 phone less than $30/month.

Right now I’m paying over $40/month each for service for four phones right now.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by e40 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @10:24PM (#24077395)
I pay around $65 for service on 3 phones with Google Fi. But, I'm lucky, I live in an area where it works just fine. Many people live in Verizon-only country, and that's not cheap.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by pvarangot on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:46PM (#24072715)
My life is a tiny bit more active than your average gym/yoga rat and phones last me around 2 years. That's consistent across something like 10 years now.

- One got stolen

- Two broke while hiking/kayaking

- One was a lemon and the battery started working funny after a year and a half, it's one of the pixels that came with a high capacity battery and the replacement one is lower capacity so I didn't risk spending money on servicing it

I'm on my fifth phone now.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by shirakawasuna on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:08PM (#24072987)
This why I will only ever use a smartphone with LineageOS (formerly CyanogenMod). Supported until your phone dies, putting aside the firmware.

Unfortunately, you have no options at all for having a modicum of control / openness over your firmware if you want to use a smartphone. Gotta use/build your own odd device if you want that.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Mediterraneo10 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:38PM (#24074626)
LineageOS is NOT guaranteed to be supported until your phone dies. The Lineage OS devs have repeatedly stated that builds are maintained by volunteers, and if the dev responsible for one phone model loses interest in that job or loses his own phone of that model, he can quit maintaining it at any time, and the community has no right to complain. Because Android development is such an arcane science, usually no one else steps in to pick up an abandoned phone model once the original developer has quit.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by thinkingemote on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:43PM (#24075268)
My phone, an non flagship brand was supported by lineage when it was still being sold and used. Now as main android support has gone, so has the users and so has lineage support. I think it's the same for the majority of android phones. Only the phones with the longest vendor support also get the longest lineageos support. Other phones are out of luck from any angle.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by valuearb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:09PM (#24073764)
My iPhone 5s is 7 years old and tho it can’t be updated to the latest iOS, still gets security updates.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by blck on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:13PM (#24072330)
I've always heard that it's the SoC that doesn't get updated after X number of years so Google is supposedly limited by how much support Snapdragon is willing to give their SoC.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by hellcow on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:16PM (#24072367)
Google is one of the richest companies in the world. If they wanted to, they could demand updates for longer periods or just create their own chips.

It's just not a priority for them.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by kelnos on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:53PM (#24075345)
> This is something I just don't understand. As phones get more powerful, there is absolutely no excuse to not support them for longer.

From our perspective, sure. From the manufacturers perspective, it costs money to port, build, and test new releases. And if people are happy with their up-to-date 5-year-old phone, they'll be less likely to buy the latest shiny new one.

Not saying those are good excuses -- they're explicitly customer-hostile -- but they're completely understandable.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by theodric on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:13PM (#24075997)
My freshly-reinstalled Pixel 2 XL with a minimal app load has four goddamn gigabytes of RAM and can't even manage to run my podcast player in the background without killing it after 5-30 minutes to economize on resources, despite my having turned off every optimization function on the device. That's why. The software is garbage, and it necessitates an upgrade treadmill to keep pace. It's PCs in the 90s all over again!
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by ksec on Thursday August 06, 2020 @08:37PM (#24076849)
>This is something I just don't understand.

Bump up the price of Pixel by additional $100, and you get an 5 years guarantee upgrade.

Not to mention the Pixel isn't that powerful. iPhone 6s despite being 5 years ago, is probably as fast or still faster than some of the sub $300 Android Phone released today. ( Excluding Chinese Brands )

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by treis on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:25PM (#24072485)
I think it's a combination of two things:

(1) Battery life goes down while wear and tear build up. After ~3 years you are looking at spending money replacing a battery for a banged up phone. Or you can spend another $200 and get a new phone.

(2) Cameras are still getting better. Going from a Pixel to the Pixel 3 was a phenomenal upgrade in the camera.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by PopeDotNinja on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:28PM (#24072514)
> Or you can spend another $200 and get a new phone.

I'd guess people aren't replacing a ~$500 phone with a ~$200 phone, but I get your point. Who wants to replace the battery on a phone worse less that the battery?

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by treis on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:44PM (#24073434)
>I'd guess people aren't replacing a ~$500 phone with a ~$200 phone

That's fair. I buy used/refurbished 1 model behind the current flagship. For me it was ~$140 more to get a lightly used 3 XL than replacing my battery.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by harrygeez on Thursday August 06, 2020 @03:20PM (#24074464)
To be fair, one of the reasons is Apple sells their old flagships as "mid-tier" options
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by bdcravens on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:16PM (#24073087)
Obviously they want people to buy more often. For most top-tier devices most are probably bought on payments and generally speaking those customers can get a new phone every 12 months if they assume they’ll always have that smallish monthly payment.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by aaomidi on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:25PM (#24073185)
Major issue here is Qualcomm and the fact that Google has no power over them
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by HumblyTossed on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:12AM (#24081016)
Not sure if it still is this way, but Qualcomm used to stop supporting their chipsets after a couple years.

Apple makes their own, so...

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by seebetter on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:09PM (#24073004)
It's called fraud.

Or an aggressive business model that is fair only to the top 10% of customers who are not concerned with spending $250 per month in effective charges to have a wireless handheld computer with 4G.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by hocuspocus on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:52PM (#24073546)
It isn't entirely fair to compare iOS and Android update models.

A lot of stuff on Android is delivered directly by the Play store/services, for many years after the end of OS updates for a particular device.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Markoff on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:00PM (#24072179)
just buy phone with unlockable bootloader and good custom ROM community and you can have this even now, just not officially from manufacturer

anyway in Pixel case the phone will have already after 2 years completely unusable battery, not that it would be satisfactory for heavy user even out of box

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by pizza234 on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:04PM (#24072237)
"Just not officially" is a simplistic view. You don't know how long the phone is still going to be supported, and you have to have the skills and the patience to go through unofficial documents and procedures in order to make the whole process work. I know because I'm in this situation, and I do support this approach (to "fight against the market"), but it's not an easy feat.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Godel_unicode on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:22PM (#24072451)
My pixel 3 XL, which is coming up on 2 years old, gets me through the day just fine on the original battery.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Markoff on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:03PM (#24075949)
well yeah, if you don't use your phone it can get you even through two days, turned off even longer
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Godel_unicode on Thursday August 06, 2020 @11:06PM (#24077617)
Not sure what that statement has to do with anything, but good point I guess?
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Markoff on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:00AM (#24080956)
> gets me through the day just fine

just because it gets YOU through the day, doesn't mean it gets others, people use phones differently, for starters their phones have different Screen on Time per day, so while 1-2 hours is fine for you and gets you through the day, for others 7hrs is not enough and phone will die for them before dinner

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Godel_unicode on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:16PM (#24083537)
I average 6 hours of screen on time, easily lasts the whole day. You should be careful talking about the performance of a phone you haven't used, I don't know if you've heard but people on Reddit sometimes don't tell the truth...
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by timwaagh on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:18PM (#24073108)
just try that on a modern pixel and you are quite likely to introduce unstable behavior. its really not recommended
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by cdumler on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:00PM (#24072899)
If it means anything to you, the reason why is:

Google stack ranks employees regularly. Lowest of a group is always fired. Doesn't matter how good you are or how much satisfaction you give to your customers, you're basically asked, "what have you built that could be the next billion customer thing?" If you're not answering how you're part of the next big thing, you're going to lose. So, once something is acquired or released, consider it deprecated.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scottlamb on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:13PM (#24073049)
This isn't true. I've worked at Google for 13 years and have rarely seen someone fired for performance; it's certainly not automatic based on being at the bottom of a stack rank. Other companies have or had such a system [1] but Google never has.

The sliver of truth is that Google's once-or-twice-yearly performance evaluation system asks colleagues to stack rank folks they are reviewing. I wish they'd get rid of it, but it's not used for much. It's only a partial order of folks they're reviewing, nothing really enforces that people actually do it, I suspect some people just rank all the people trying for promo this cycle above the people who aren't, and the many reviewers' stack ranks are never reconciled into one authoritative stack rank of the folks in a group. I don't know why it's still around.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by dbspin on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:15PM (#24073068)
This appears to be incorrect - https://www.quora.com/Why-does-Google-stack-rank-its-employe...

I think you may be confusing the stack ranking at google, that doesn't result in dismissal (Google were in fact, right up until Covid, still on a hiring spree with a shortage of engineers); with what Microsoft historically did (and stopped doing in 2013).

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by xenihn on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:52PM (#24074197)
Google actually has the reputation of being the hardest FAANG to get fired from for performance reasons. Amazon is the easiest, due to stack ranking. Facebook is sort of a middle-ground where you risk getting fired if you aren't being promoted at the expected rate, but it's not the same as Amazon's stack ranking.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by markstos on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:17PM (#24073095)
Stack ranking only contributes to planned obsolescence if the company values decisions which contribute to it.

If the company high prioritized environmental concerns, stack ranking would reward those who figured how to keep products in service longer.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by neya on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:37PM (#24072611)
Planned obsolescence.

I owned an iPhone 5S, my phone terribly slowed down in just a year to the point of becoming unusable. Opening the camera app would take 10 seconds. It would randomly freeze during calls and in the end, started having random shut downs. At the time, I didn't know they were throttling the phone. Funnily enough, my battery was replaced a couple of times and had no impact.

I paid $1000 at the time for it. I wrote it off in a year and a half due to all these issues. The manufacturer DID support with updates, but in the end, it didn't really matter because they just kept introducing more bugs and did nothing to address the throttling until very recently when they were caught in the act.

In contrast, I still own an Android 2.x HTC Desire that works flawlessly as a backup phone till date. I got it 8 years ago and is absolutely stunning - be it the beautiful OLED display or usability, and solves my needs perfectly.

I would say, software support for older phones is overrated. If you thought I am lucky with the HTC, then how about my other Android - Xperia X. I've dropped this thing so many times and not once had the screen gotten a single scratch. Supports dual sim and camera is great for low light. Still fluid to use. Again, software support for long term is really overrated in my opinion. As long as you can make calls, surf the web, check emails, take photos, I'd say the purpose of the phone is complete.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by Jtsummers on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:50PM (#24072757)
The throttling didn’t happen until later, and was dependent on battery health. If you were having issues in the first year it wasn’t the throttling it was probably another issue with the device. I had an iPad like that and was able to get it replaced with the same generation and then-current OS, any issues like yours disappeared with the new hardware.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by jordache on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:40PM (#24072637)
your anecdote is in direct contrast to mine.

My 5S is still very usable.

-Download offline google maps files on it and use it as a gps in my car. Smooth as butter map animation and everything. -Use it when I'm doing yard work, Podcasts, audiobooks.. The latest overcast app is a little bit hiccupy.. but very usable. -Take pictures with it once in a while...

Still on original battery... On the latest iOS that Apple is currently supporting the 5S with.

Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by supernova87a on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:55PM (#24072838)
Were you using the phone each day to battery 0% straight? Did you consider getting the battery replaced? Those performance issues are completely explainable by the battery age + performance throttling for aged batteries, if you were a 100->0% without any charge during the day kind of user over the course of 1.5 years.
Re:Google discontinues the Pixel 4, nine months after release by scns on Thursday August 06, 2020 @12:53PM (#24072805)
A phone without updates becomes insecure.