News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by opwieurposiu on Thursday January 30, 2020 @10:58AM (#22192293)
The F-35 project is a stealth Jobs program that pretends to be a stealth airplane program. Seen through this lens, things are actually going ok. It concentrates incompetence in the defense sector, where it can do less harm. (as long as we dont get a real war)
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by gherkinnn on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:23PM (#22196490)
Military spending is the Republicans’ wellfare. Or something.

While it might sound a tad simplistic, I can’t but see some truth in it.

This is also a classic: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2014/12/18/congress-agai... (2014)

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by simonh on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:09PM (#22197960)
“We all too often have socialism for the rich and rugged free market capitalism for the poor.” Martin Luther King Jr.

Benefits for the well off are ‘subsidies’ and ‘tax breaks‘, such as the fact corporate health insurance is not taxed, while benefits for the less well off are ‘handouts’.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by jboy55 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:24PM (#22197605)
I got into a debate with a republican over defense funding. I stated how the great bay-area recession of the early nighties was caused by scaling back of cold-war funding. Bases were closed and Lockheed Martin and others laid off alot of workers. They agreed it was terrible for the economy.

So I pointed out how they admit that Government funded make-work projects can have a positive effect on economies. So why not just switch from military spending to other tech spending? Why is it the military is the only government run make-work programs that R's support?

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by thatcat on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:34PM (#22197677)
Yea or just ya know hire civil engineers to do basic maintenance on us infrastructure. Plenty of work to go around, there's no need to make up stuff to do.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjs3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:31PM (#22198115)
Maybe the most insightful comment I've read this month.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by goatinaboat on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:26AM (#22199810)
why not just switch from military spending to other tech spending?

What sort of tech spending? I mean military spending paid for development of the internet, jet engines, satellite communications, radar, a million other real actual things that people use everyday. Modern day Silly Valley piggybacks on all this stuff and uses it to show us ads...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by SlowRobotAhead on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:54PM (#22203757)
>Modern day Silly Valley piggybacks on all this stuff and uses it to show us ads...

Less truth please :|

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by scarejunba on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:09PM (#22197964)
Because this way you can also reap the gains if you invest in these firms? If you keep the make-work in like 3 companies, then I, a human, can get the rewards of owning the stock by doing manual work.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by burfog on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:47PM (#22198533)
That classic example is poor. The idea is that congress is forcing the military to buy things that the military doesn't want. We need to question that.

The military follows orders. The president is commander in chief. If the president doesn't want to buy something, then the military doesn't want to buy something.

Given that the date was 2014, saying "the military doesn't want" was exactly equivalent to saying "Obama doesn't want".

Fully retired members of the military, not seeking to gain something like a DoD or cabinet-level position, might be able to speak more freely to congress.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WesternStar on Thursday January 30, 2020 @10:44PM (#22198833)
If congress appropriates the money the president is required to spend it on the things that congress wants[1].

1.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impoundment_of_appropriated_fu...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by burfog on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:12AM (#22199522)
I mean we need to question "military doesn't want", not that we need to question "forcing the military to buy".

We may have a situation where the military really wants the equipment, but isn't permitted to admit it. They follow orders. The orders, coming down from the president, are that the military is to claim that they don't want the equipment.

Example: the military really wanted the F-22, then we got a new president, and suddenly the military isn't interested in the F-22

The military is not free to speak.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by aggie on Thursday January 30, 2020 @10:03PM (#22198617)
The military isn't a borg collective, it is full of people trying to get their way, climb the ladder, make money, etc. Those motivations produce behavior counter to what the command structure 'wants'.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tsimionescu on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:42PM (#22196694)
Well, apparently military spending has long been a method for directly financing companies and research that the federal government likes, such as the beginnings of computer technology.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by pstuart on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:57PM (#22196863)
Yes, there's been technical benefits to this spending, but it is a corrupt and immoral practice (guns vs. butter).
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by shrewduser on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:14PM (#22198003)
the point of guns vs butter is that there's a ideal balance of the two that maximises output. it's not a moral argument.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by pstuart on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:59AM (#22199699)
War is a moral argument. Health and welfare of society is a moral argument.

As for "maximizing output", I'm failing to see big returns here. Afghanistan? Iraq? Vietnam? The only output that was maximized was cashflow to the military industrial complex.

I do believe in national security but the way we do it is not only inefficient, but manufactures more insecurity that feeds into the cycle.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tsimionescu on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:44AM (#22199880)
My point was different: it's that some of the so-called military spending is in reality simply a way for the federal government to fund research it wants done, without any relation to actual (direct) military applications.

The sad reality is that it is easier for people to accept a massive military budget than to accept a large National Endowment for the Sciences, or to accept direct government grants for a strategy of technical development (that would be 'government interfering in the market'). Of course, this reality was created through a lot of fear-mongering propaganda, and through a lot of anti-"socialist" propaganda.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by pstuart on Friday January 31, 2020 @03:47PM (#22205538)
Sure, and we're discussing it via a consequence of such a case (arpanet). But because the military by default has zero accountability, any funds that go there should be strongly vetted.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Waterluvian on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:07AM (#22192386)
That's an interesting take. And maybe we don't disagree and it's just wording, but I think it's more of a "program to funnel money into the military complex in as many politician's states as could get involved"

If you want a jobs program, fix bridges and roads. If you want a "stealth" jobs program, declare it a national security threat and use the military budget too.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by klodolph on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:18PM (#22195728)
From what I understand, the number of states with jobs related to F-35 production is 50.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by munk-a on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:40PM (#22196009)
I'm not certain all 50 states have bridges and infrastructure in critical state - but if it isn't all 50 it's really close to all 50.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by gscott on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:52PM (#22197346)
And 8 countries countries are making parts

https://www.f35.com/global

"Suppliers in all nine of the program's partner countries are producing F-35 components for all aircraft, not just those for their country."

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by astrodust on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:28PM (#22196543)
It's 57.

Every state and territory has infrastructure that is an absolute shambles.

America loves to build things but it sure seems allergic to maintenance.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by dylan604 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:03PM (#22196921)
Maintenance programs don't grab headlines like the initial program to build does. Unless it's an extremely large package like what Trump proposed (what happened to that one?), it's just not sexy enough to get ink
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by astrodust on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:03PM (#22197435)
My hypothesis is that since everyone plus dog in the US is an elected official that is perpetually campaigning, they're incentivized to focus on big splashy headlines.

That and the press loves to pulverize people over spending money to avoid disasters, but celebrates those that help when disaster strikes, even if it was entirely preventable.

Oh, and "Infrastructure Week" has been going on for about three years now.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by munk-a on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:05PM (#22197451)
I don't think DoD projects ever get positive press, when the products work people are apathetic and when they break they are criticized as boondoggles - infrastructure actually tends to get relatively positive press.

I think the problem here isn't in public opinion - it's strictly a matter of corruption at the political level.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by jbob2000 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @12:22PM (#22193187)
Repairing bridges and roads doesn't attract weapon systems developers away from other nations. We gotta keep these guys busy so they don't go work for Russia or China
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by DanTheManPR on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:05AM (#22192365)
The F-35 has been highly successful at it's goal of funneling hundreds of billions of dollars into the military industrial complex.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by neximo64 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:33PM (#22195928)
That employs and affects millions (directly and indirectly) of people across multiples countries in high deficit areas. Which is the ultimate goal of the project. A plane that may work is merely the bonus of the R&D spend.

Countries that don't do regional-deficit spending in this manner (that seems economically inefficient) end up having severe problems, particularly after the GFC. Much of Europe is easily in this bucket. The F35 is part of the reason the US isn't in as much hell economically speaking as Europe is.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by baddox on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:37PM (#22197220)
You seem to imply that the program is distributing resources more equitably or fairly (according to some definition) than their initial distribution. Can you explain that? The money is taken from tax-payers, and most of the jobs created in the US are presumably tax-payers. But we also know that the companies with these defense contracts are making profit, which means it's not purely money being distributed to workers. There are presumably executives and investors making huge amounts of money from tax-payers.

If the money is just being taken from tax-payers and then distributed to a much smaller group of tax-payers, including some of it making a very small number of people very rich, I would need to see a lot of evidence to convince me that it's beneficial to society in the way that the term "jobs program" makes it sound.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:24PM (#22198417)
You’re right. It’s the Broken Window fallacy [1]

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:17PM (#22198377)
Or, to be more efficient, we could funnel the money going towards the F-35 to productive uses that would employ as many people and actually create value. Saying the F-35 is good because it creates jobs is an example of the Broken Window fallacy; [1] we’re expending economic effort for no purpose, much like you can’t create economic growth by going around breaking windows so the glazier industry can have a boom. As I said in another comment, we might as well had spent the $1.5 trillion to build a fleet of metal platypuses that we keep in large hangars around the world. The existence of an F-35 has no practical use to the U.S. economy other than as a money sink.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by neximo64 on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:30PM (#22208671)
If you would like to use broken windows as an example the parable doesn't apply exactly. For it to apply the same way it would mean both providing a job (by giving funds to do so) to fix the broken window/damaged buildings as well as having a need to fix the damage, versus simply having a natural distaster/broken window and hoping that works as economic stimulation.

The broken window fallacy/parable has no notion of outside money being inserted into the system and is a poor characterization of the F35 program/deficit fiscal spending.

That is the critical difference. Also these forms of spending are already empirically proven as being net beneficial due to a financial multiplier/accelerator.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Saturday February 01, 2020 @04:11PM (#22213264)
So if I’m understanding your argument correctly, you consider the F-35 to effectively be a wealth redistribution program. Taxes are gathered from taxpayers nationwide, and some of that money is funneled into the communities where the F-35 is designed and built. I’m 100% down with wealth redistribution as a way to reduce income inequality, but I think we could be way more efficient in the redistribution; we could employ these people and use this money to create actually useful things, like say construct affordable housing or construct anything other than a $1.5 trillion lemon. That was why I mentioned the parable; the idea is that value isn’t added when you introduce an artificial, costly phenomenon into an economy (i.e. a storm that creates demand for repairs or a worthless fighter jet that creates demand for defense workers). But if you instead use that money to build productive things, then you can get the redistribution and actually make something that someone wants. Thus, it is impossible for the F-35 to be as efficient at wealth distribution as say an equivalent costing program to create working civilian aircraft that could actually be used.

The most efficient way of redistribution would be to use the money spent on the F-35 to directly fund social programs and jobs programs for the poor in these economically disadvantaged communities; this would redistribute all of the money to people who actually need it and will spend it, rather than send huge chunks of it into defense executives/shareholders’ pockets in the currently lossy transactions used in defense contracting.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjs3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:38PM (#22198165)
Having recently been in Ireland, France and Germany talking to financial industry peers, vetting a bunch of startups and meeting with regulators, how exactly did I miss out on this hellscape you're talking about?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by munk-a on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:38PM (#22195997)
I don't disagree that do-nothing projects can be valuable to society - but defense contractors are an extremely inefficient way to inject money into the economy. Most of that money ends up going into the pockets of people who could find quite decent jobs elsewhere.

Redirecting that money to small business grants would provide a much bigger boost to general societal well being.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Kalium on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:09PM (#22196327)
Some of it is less about injecting money than it is about maintaining capacity and capability. It's not always about jobs in general, but sometimes about specific jobs.

The US defense-industrial complex may not always have a high need for people who can design stealth fighters, but it definitely prefers to keep a few around in case it does suddenly need them.

Small business grants may not be a good way of meeting the same need.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by andrewflnr on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:13PM (#22197010)
I get maintaining the capability, but they clearly can't develop a stealth fighter, so that justification doesn't really work either anymore.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Kalium on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:16PM (#22197035)
I mean, maybe? That this program isn't working may not be the same as the US no longer having the capability. It's possible that the F-35 isn't really expected to produce a functional stealth fighter, all rhetoric aside.

I honestly have no idea.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by munk-a on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:55PM (#22204412)
That seems to stretch the argument pretty far - maybe if we just want to keep vaguely military folk in the country then we could employ them building military grade roads to replace the aging infrastructure. If the project they're actually working on isn't supposed to bear any real fruit then maybe just redirect them to something that isn't a complete waste of resources.

Also, I disagree, I don't think anyone in that realm of government would knowingly sink that much money into a project they intended to fail - they might be overly optimistic about the success, they might be trying to funnel money into their retirement but it takes clout to secure a budget like that and people had to work hard to secure it initially and keep it going - so a failure is probably going to fall under one of these categories - un-achievable, poorly managed, or wholly corrupt.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by ska on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:25PM (#22196510)
I suspect there is some truth to this. But I wonder how much of that effort could be directed to more useful infrastructure projects and still maintain skills.

The other issue is that some fraction of defense spending seemingly can be viewed as funneling public money into a get-your-friends-rich scheme. I don't think you can find much net upside to that aspect.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by akiselev on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:10PM (#22196978)
Stealth airplanes are extremely complex engineering projects that stretch across many fields. Maintaining any individual skill set is easy, but they're all highly specialized and require the industry to be maintained or else the combination of cross disciplinary skills, including project management, disappears.

Think back to Boeing's problems with the Dreamliner, where Boeing tried a new model of splitting out the design to a bunch of subcontractors and ended up with tons of problems with the integration ranging from missed design milestones due to problems with the composites to miscommunications leading to battery problems in production and so on. Those are a small taste of what happens when the engineering-management hierarchy is broken up and fractured across organizations. It becomes a lot worse when they are fractured across time.

The US famously lost it's top launch capabilities with the Saturn V and we didn't have a domestic replacement until the Falcon Heavy in 2018! By their very nature, maintaining the capabilities needed for weapons of war that can be deployed anywhere in the world is even more expensive if you want to have any sort of certainty that they'll work when the shots are fired instead of once a few years when you want to launch a satellite.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by ska on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:17PM (#22198029)
I don’t think we are disagreeing, but I wouldn’t rely on the industry to define how much is needed.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by akiselev on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:37PM (#22198157)
I'm saying that the resources cannot be redirect towards "more useful infrastructure projects and still maintain skills". The cross disciplinary skills in military aviation are unique.

Whether or not the cost of the F35 program is an efficient way to maintain those skills is a different issue altogether that gets at the fundamental structure of our government and how money impacts politics. That's a much more difficult discussion than "can we reasonably defend ourselves in the future."

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by ska on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:31AM (#22199828)
sure, but it’s the more interesting discussion to have, and it’s what I was pointing out. Plausibly the majority of the resources spent on this program could in fact have gone to more useful programs without affecting baseline capability. Plausibly the could not ... but it’s not clear anyone who should be asking that question, is.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:14PM (#22197015)
> inject money into the economy

The money "injected" into the economy must come from somewhere, and that somewhere is the economy. I.e. it's zero-sum.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by myhf on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:32PM (#22197174)
It's not zero-sum. It can change the velocity of circulation money, which impacts economic activity in predictable ways.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:35PM (#22198470)
Circulating money doesn’t create economic value. We might as well had spent $1.5 trillion (the cost so far to develop the F-35) to make a fleet of large metal platypuses which we keep in hangars and occasionally launch into the air.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by neximo64 on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:31AM (#22199827)
Circulating money does create economic value in far multiples of the initial amount. It's well established military spending has an impact on GDP far more than the amount itself.

Funds are never 'spent' as such, the money always circulates around even if you do buy metal platypuses - someone is going to get a salary and spend it somewhere or invest in their future by buying things that improve their productivity.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:40AM (#22200337)
But a large portion of the money ends up in the F-35 itself, which is useless. Think of all the energy, all the time and brainpower used to build the platypus. Think of all the money and materials used to create something that no one wants, which could instead be used to create things that people want while still providing jobs/income. The point of an economy is to enable exchanges so that people produce things that other people need. That is the benefit of an economy; money is a medium for trading things of value for other things of value.

In this case, the trade is one-way; the F-35 is effectively a black hole. The transaction to defense workers is immensely lossy. Ultimately, the program is funded by taxpayers whose money went into building a $1.5 trillion boondoggle instead of any number of useful purposes. The unseen harm of using the public’s funds in this way far outweighs the benefits the defense industry brings. It’s the same as taking five dollars from everyone, paying people three dollars to throw two of every five dollars into a campfire, and calling it economic growth. Sure, some people get paid, but the net gain is negative. The two dollars isn’t used to create things that other people want; it is locked inside a metal platypus.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by neximo64 on Friday January 31, 2020 @05:18AM (#22200505)
> But a large portion of the money ends up in the F-35 itself,

How does it 'end up' there? - A human being is paid in the end. This is the notion I don't believe you're accurately looking at.

Say you were to pay the cashier $100 for your groceries, s/he wouldn't end up with the money either it would go to suppliers and seep back into the economy. Money is a bit like energy to a degree it can't be destroyed it ultimately ends up being spent again and again. Unless of course it goes into a bank account that is locked and never spent - for which inflation will tax it and even that would leak back.

The F35 is deliberately built in very high deficit areas to have the largest multiplier effect- this results in extremely good stimulus spending. Just to throw some numbers out there money spent this way (even if the end product is useless) ends up increasing GDP 30-60% more than the original spend. E.g $100 spent => $130-160m. It depends on the unemployment rate in the area but it can be as high as 3x. There is hardly a government program that can be as effective unless its building infrastructure, where it can stretch to as high as 7 (read Japan roads to nowhere)

The F35 is certaintly not a black hole. Almost certainly if you look at it in the way we buy things and consume them - then yes it is, almost 100%, but in terms of the economic effects its a very helpful project. If France had for example done this type of spending it would not be sitting in economic contraction territory at the moment - wheras the US hardly sees contraction because of this type of deficit spending.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:06PM (#22205734)
> ends up increasing GDP 30-60% more than the original spend.

This does not take into account the deleterious effect of extracting the stimulus money from whence it came.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:03PM (#22205702)
> Circulating money does create economic value in far multiples of the initial amount.

Again, that assumes the "initial amount" came from dead or poorly invested money. I have seen no rationalization or evidence that this is the case.

Consider that 37% of Federal Income Tax revenue comes from the 1%. The 1% are the most effective investors, because that's how they became the 1%. Government spending would have to be incredibly good to outdo the best investors.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by sitkack on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:14AM (#22199529)
Could they please be chrome?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:59AM (#22199701)
I like the aesthetic, but we’re on a budget here. Rhinestone and we call it a compromise?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:44PM (#22198199)
This implies that the money extracted from the economy is dead money or poorly invested. I've seen no rationale nor evidence for why that might be true.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by numpad0 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:56AM (#22200394)
Economy being a zero-sum game is a layman’s approximation, and not the reality, at all. Merely supposed to be that way in the days of gold standards.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:05PM (#22205719)
The economy is not a zero-sum game. But transferring money from one place to another is zero-sum. It's not free money.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by raisedbyninjas on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:10PM (#22196339)
In these times of low unemployment, a dearth of applicants may push Lockheed to literally burning money. Could this provide more economic benefit until spring when heating costs drop?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by _visgean on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:20PM (#22198057)
> "US isn't in as much hell economically speaking as Europe is"

I am sorry, as EU citizen I have to ask, in what hell am I? Forgot to notice being in hell :/

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjaftaedi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:49PM (#22198548)
A manned base on Mars would be a much more practical way to spend money, create just as many jobs, and be cheaper.

Using all of these resources to instead build a poorly functioning aircraft is not in society's best interest.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by dTal on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:28AM (#22201462)
>The F35 is part of the reason the US isn't in as much hell economically speaking as Europe is.

Funny, I've never seen a trailer park in Europe. And oddly, the infrastructure is typically way better too. Bizzarely, fewer people seem to die of preventable disease as well.

Clearly Europe is doing something terribly wrong, and needs to adopt the American model.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by adventured on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:14AM (#22192475)
> funneling hundreds of billions of dollars into the military industrial complex

What's the total spending on the F-35 program so far, going back to 2006?

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by gknoy on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:27AM (#22192581)
> The total cost of the F-35 program is expected to be $1.5 trillion over its 55-year lifespan

As of 2018, the estimated program cost was ~1.5T, or 1500 billion dollars.

"""The F-35 currently costs between $94 million (F-35A) and $122 million (F-35B) for low-rate initial production run 10, though sustainment cost projections are as big a concern as production costs for a program that is expected to cost $1.5 trillion over its 55-year lifespan."""

https://www.aviationtoday.com/2018/09/04/f-35-program-update...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:22PM (#22198406)
And people have the gall to say we can’t afford universal healthcare.

“Oh, but now that money is lost, and now we actually can’t afford to spend money on our own citizens,” say the next couple generations of warhawks as we spend $2.7 trillion on a drone army made of caviar.

We can do better things with our money.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by jml7c5 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:20PM (#22198053)
"Through FY2017, the F-35 program has received a total of roughly $122.6 billion of funding in then-year dollars, including roughly $54.7 billion in research and development, about $65.7 billion in procurement, and approximately $2.7 billion in military construction."

via https://fas.org/sgp/crs/weapons/RL30563.pdf

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by BinaryIdiot on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:39PM (#22196006)
I worked on a large DoD contract where there was a core of about 12-20 people doing the majority of the work and about 140 additional people just... having a job.

The legal requirements to collecting money on defense contracts pretty much always does this.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wonderwonder on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:54PM (#22196824)
I know someone personally who's company was hired as a subcontractor to one of the majors on the F-35 project. He was put in a room to do nothing. They forgot he was in a meeting once and he overheard them saying that they were just hiring the subcontractors to get the government schedule people off of their backs, they were not there to actually do anything.

So happy my tax dollars are going towards this rather than feeding the hungry or providing shelter to homeless kids.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by AdrianB1 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:09PM (#22196974)
Part of the problem is you; not a personal attack, just an explanation: if you would be more concerned about your tax dollars staying in your pocket, you would be much more careful with all the government spending and putting much more pressure on doing the right thing. If your position is "the government take my tax money, at least I wish they spent it on something good" then you are less involved, it's no longer your money and you care less.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wonderwonder on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:13PM (#22197011)
This is an odd statement. How do you know what my level of concern is with my tax money staying in my pocket. No matter the level of concern, I still have to pay taxes and the amount does not change based on my level of concern.

"you would be much more careful with all the government spending and putting much more pressure on doing the right thing"? what exactly can I do to be more careful about government spending besides voting for my preferred candidate?

Are you fully in control of everywhere your tax dollars are spent? Do you protest every dollar that is spent on a program you don't agree with?

All in all an odd statement but best of luck to you and I wish you well.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by dTal on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:38AM (#22201533)
I'm guessing the logic went like this:

You displayed support for "feeding the hungry or providing shelter to homeless kids". Therefore you are a "socialist".

"Socialists" want the government to take people's money, and spend it on all kinds of dubious rubbish.

Your are complaining that your taxes are being spent on dubious rubbish.

Ergo, your position is hypocritical.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wonderwonder on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:31AM (#22201918)
In my opinion: "feeding the hungry or providing shelter to homeless kids" != "dubious rubbish". "Hiring engineers to sit in a room to placate government officials" == "dubious rubbish". Each to their own though.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by AdrianB1 on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:57AM (#22201658)
Only the second part; not only socialists spend people's money on all kinds of rubbish, every government does. People should keep governments accountable for every dollar they take from you, whatever is spent on.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wonderwonder on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:30AM (#22201910)
Again, you stated I was the problem. What do you do personally that renders you not the problem? How are you personally and key here; effectively, holding the government accountable "for every dollar they take from you"?

As far as the socialist charge from the poster above you, I am not against taxes, I just believe they should be used to create a society where the least among us are provided for instead of endlessly feeding the military.

unfortunately in this country (USA) people who want the government to feed the hungry, provide health care and ensure a clean environment are called socialists while those that want the government to spend trillions on the military and the fossil fuel industry are called conservatives.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by AdrianB1 on Friday January 31, 2020 @07:39PM (#22207548)
Fortunately I don't live there and I am neither of these 2 categories.

Hint: read "you" as the generic taxpayer. As I said, it is not an attack to a person, but a comment on taxpayer mentality that tax have to be paid, so the only thing to be cared of is what the tax money is spent on: not true, this is what I am trying to say. It is a false dilemma.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by 01100011 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:32PM (#22197665)
Defense companies sell butts in chairs. They know the game and play it well. I remember working on defense and the PM was pushing me to reduce hours. I was costing the project over $500/hr. The IC who was working with me could work all he wanted though, due to the way his costs were billed.

Working at that place, I heard stories from other defense veterans detailing massive, unending incompetence and graft.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Traster on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:01PM (#22196906)
If there's one thing I've learned over my time as an engineer, it's that there's far fewer people actually doing anything than you expect. I've worked with engineers building 5G infrastructure, the people who are actually doing the work probably account for a few dozen, but add the managers, sales, marketing, business development, and bloody project manager and you're up to hundreds immediately. It's always a nice surprise when you end up in a meeting and someone utters a shibboleth and ting this guy must actually do the work!
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by friendlybus on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:09AM (#22192407)
What does a competent fighter jet program look like?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by hef19898 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:12AM (#22192448)
The F-117. Great story, was finished in budget and ahead of time. But then it was a black program without any political oversight. Basically a couple of brilliant engineers closed into a room with the sole task to built a stealth plane.

EDIT: They used components from the F-16 and F-15 programs. Being a black program, this was hidden in spare parts needs for these other planes. I have congress report lying around somewhere which complains about excess spare needs for the F-16 from that period. So, maybe some of the F-117 costs are driving costs of other programs.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @12:16PM (#22193116)
The F-117 had very limited requirements compared to the F-35. What's killing the F-35 is the extreme complexity of the program.

The requirements for the F-117 were basically that it had to be stealthy, and had to be able to carry a minimal payload a reasonable range. There was no radar, no vertical takeoff, no carrier landings, no air-to-air, no sensor fusion, no datalinks, no cooperative engagement, etc etc etc.

It's poorly understood how the combination of high performance requirements, complexity, and flexibility mix. Optimizing a system for performance generally requires cutting across domains. Subsystems need to be designed jointly to wring out performance. This means there are many dependencies between the subsystems, so if one thing changes on one subsystem, it may affect a number of other subsystems. If you then add flexibility to the mix -- you want a modular system like the F-35, all of this optimization work has to be done on every combination of parts. Now combine this with a complex set of mission requirements -- every change has to be optimized for multiple missions and multiple aircraft variants. Due to the optimized and complex nature of the aircraft, each change will also affect many subsystems.

Because the system is so complex, no person or even a small group of people can have the entire system in their head, so it's hard to know exactly what will be affected with a subsystem change. Subsystems affected by a change will furthermore not even be built by the same company. This all means that each change has to go through very slow formal processes to make sure it keeps working.

All of this is to say that layering on all of these categories of requirements has an exponential effect. If the F-35 didn't have to be high performance, or if it didn't have three variants, or if it didn't have to perform multiple missions, the project would have been much easier.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tempestn on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:05PM (#22195572)
So does it follow from that that the entire concept is flawed, and what should have been designed instead are multiple different aircraft?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:35PM (#22196617)
Yes, it should have been multiple aircraft, or the scope should have been reduced. It's hard enough to make an aircraft that's good on an aircraft carrier and on land. Adding the vertical landing (B model) version compromised the whole program.

VTOL is a very specialized capability, and there's never been another airplane that has VTOL as an optional feature. You have to design the plane and its engine around this capability, and you compromise on many other things to get it. The A and C models then have to live with many of these design compromises. Even the basic shape of the aircraft, with such a wide front fuselage reduces the performance of the F-35, even though on the A and C models there's no need to be so wide since there's no lift fan.

Meanwhile, it's not even clear that the Marines need a VTOL airplane. The B model has the ability to operate off Navy helicopter carriers, which gives them significantly more punch, but there's basically no real scenario where a helicopter carrier would need it. In a real war, there will always be full deck carriers anywhere a helicopter carrier is. In theory the helicopter carriers would offer additional capacity, but carrier air wings have been scaled back, and full deck carriers only go to sea with 60-65 aircraft even though they have the capacity for 90. If the Marines wanted more of their own air assets they could have just bought C models and operated them off the big carriers like they already do with the F-18.

The B model is also significantly lower performance. It has to takeoff at lower weights, and it has the huge extra weight of the lift fan. This means it has a much shorter range and carries less weapons. If they had simply bought C models and put them on the big carriers, the overall capability would be greater.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wahern on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:50PM (#22196769)
Maybe someone more knowledgable about the history can chime in, but the first thought that entered my mind when you were discussing full deck carriers is that the F-35 was designed from the very beginning for international sales. Only a few nations have full deck carriers, while many more have helicopter carriers. It's not surprising then that there are 2 allies with F-35Bs, 3 allies with plans for the F-35B, and none for the F-35C: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:28PM (#22197144)
Yes, that's true, but look at the F-35 orders. There are 563 orders for the B model out of 3200 total. The foreign customers are the UK with 138, to operate on their Queen Elizabeth carriers, 30 for Italy to operate on their small carriers, and 42 to Japan for the same.

In 2010, the UK decided to make the QE carriers ski-jump and operate the B model for cost reasons, however they considered making them CATOBAR and operate the C model. If the B model had not existed, they would have simply spent another couple of billion dollars to make them CATOBAR.

It's probably not practical from a budget and political standpoint for Japan and Italy to make CATOBAR carriers, but does it really make sense to compromise a 3200 aircraft program that's the backbone of the USAF and USN's fleet so that Italy and Japan can buy 72 aircraft? Italy and Japan could just buy tanker aircraft for long range power projection.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by adwww on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:34AM (#22200308)
You could also claim it was quite a coup by the UK to get the US to spend trillions subsiding a VSTOL aircraft for the RN.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by craftinator on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:36PM (#22198156)
Your comments make up the most competent and comprehensive analysis I've seen on the F35 program; way more thorough than those presented in Congress or by the various involved aerospace companies. Are you involved in the project in any way?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:17PM (#22198379)
I'm just an interested observer, but my observations are hardly unique. The same points have been made in many forums including congressional hearings.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by craftinator on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:13AM (#22199267)
Much of what I've seen in congressional hearings is so watered down and blame-shifted it is difficult to assemble into a coherent story. You did a great job of the spark notes version
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by discordance on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:51PM (#22197815)
aka, The Homer (also known as "The Car Built for Homer")
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by GVIrish on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:12PM (#22195655)
Exactly this. The DoD basically took the mistakes of the F-111 program, doubled down on them, and added on some reckless new mistakes.

The result is the most expensive weapons program in history.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by DuskStar on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:23PM (#22195808)
And congress went along with it (or encouraged it) because theoretically it would be cheaper...

(And the Marines liked it because no one was going to spend the money to build a stealthy V/STOL strike fighter for them unless it was part of someone else's development budget)

(And the Navy IIRC just wanted their fucking A-12 [0] already)

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_A-12_Avenger...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Already__Taken on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:49PM (#22196762)
> 2009 ... required the two contractors to repay the U.S. government US$1.35 billion, plus interest charges of US$1.45 billion

...

> January 2014, the case was settled with Boeing and General Dynamics agreeing to pay $200 million each.

Quite the settlement

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Already__Taken on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:45PM (#22196716)
It's mental the v22 osprey platform isn't further explored.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by DuskStar on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:07PM (#22197953)
What do you mean? Bell's working on a followup right now, as an entry in the US army's Future Vertical Lift program [0].

And the osprey itself is still getting adopted in more places - I think carrier onboard delivery is its latest role.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_V-280_Valor

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by smacktoward on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:26PM (#22196527)
The old "sports car/dump truck" problem: you can make a good sports car, you can make a good dump truck, but what you can't make is a good sports car that is also a good dump truck.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by natmaka on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:15PM (#22198987)
Things are more and more complicated (interacting, and also wide, dense, fast-moving...), and therefore unpredictability grows.

This is true for nearly everythoing, and war reflects it, as up to the Industrial Revolution things (strategy, tactics, weaponry...) evolved gradually. Nowadays nobody knows anymore how all this really works, therefore there is less and less way to predict (how/what/why/when/...) sufficiently accurately in order to prepare/act adequately (for example to equip soldiers).

Hence the need for "something which can cope with any situation".

Fun fact: this 'something' has to be complicated, adding up complication to the complicated global state of affairs, nurturing the very cause of the underlying challenge.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:08PM (#22198950)
You can almost though. Make it out of titanium, give it gas turbine engines with an electric drive, put the thing on hydraulics so it can get lower to the ground, add electronic stability control to get artificial sports car feel, and some rocket thrusters on the top to keep it from tipping over in tight turns. Maybe you could make the tires out of some metamaterial so it can have slick tires for racing and deep treads for the construction site.

All of that is to say it can be done, but you're going to pay, and it might not be delivered on time.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tempestn on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:29AM (#22199345)
Nice extension of the metaphor. Makes building the sports dump truck sound very much like the F35 project.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:46PM (#22198223)
>The F-117 had very limited requirements compared to the F-35. What's killing the F-35 is the extreme complexity of the program.

This. The only thing the F35 doesn't do it blow the pilot and hand him a beer. Since nobody is willing to settle for a plane that can do everything and sucks at it (and rightfully so) it's turned into this massive project where there's a billion dollars in man hours spent arguing over each little nut and bolt in order to find the compromises needed to create something that satisfies all the stake holders well enough to get sign off.

I think a lot of this is driven by the fact that we have no real enemy at present. It's much easier to say "no we need a system that can do X and Y and we need it now, Z can wait" when you're worried about the USSR having the jump on you. There is no such pressure for competency at present.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by mcv on Saturday February 01, 2020 @03:49PM (#22213133)
That's pretty much my take too. The F-35 had to be able to do absolutely everything, and that generally means it's not going to any of those particularly well.

For a small airforce, a jack-of-all-trades fighter makes a lot of sense (hence the popularity of the F-16 among small airforces), but for the US, it makes no sense to abandon all specialised fighters in favour of a single compromise.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjs3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:43PM (#22198191)
Well...maybe the right answer is to limit scope and not try and pack every requirement into one package.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by throw0101a on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:33AM (#22192635)
> Basically a couple of brilliant engineers closed into a room with the sole task to built a stealth plane.

I think being able to focus was a big part of it. The F-35 (and F-32) is a 'kitchen sink' of a plane: multi-purpose sounds great in theory, but rarely works out in practice. Especially if you try shoehorning VTOL into the picture.

If they had tried focusing on the F-35A and C variants, perhaps things should be less complicated.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by trhway on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:35PM (#22196619)
>I think being able to focus was a big part of it. The F-35 (and F-32) is a 'kitchen sink' of a plane: multi-purpose sounds great in theory, but rarely works out in practice. Especially if you try shoehorning VTOL into the picture.

if you look into the history - F-35 started as VTOL, ie. Yak-141, as Lockheed didn't have any VTOL and needed a response to Boeing/Harrier - onto which the "kitchen sink" of everything else was shoehorned/bolted-on. The Yak-141 was never intended and never imagined to be a good fighter plane or a good attack plane, etc., its primary and the only raison d'etre was VTOL as USSR/Russia just hasn't been capable of having real aircraft carriers.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Godel_unicode on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:43PM (#22198192)
I know that it has an "f" in the designation and was called the "stealth fighter", but the f-117 was in no way a fighter.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by JustARandomGuy on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:19PM (#22198044)
Do you remember the name and date of that congressional report? Would love to read it.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by hef19898 on Friday January 31, 2020 @03:26AM (#22200025)
That's the one, sold through Amazon. But I guess you should be able to get it as a pdf somewhere as well: F-16 Integrated Logistics Support: Still Time to Consider Economical Alternatives: LCD-80-89
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by dr_dshiv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:26AM (#22192570)
My dad was convinced this was how they paid for UFOs. I really hope that's true, but I find it nearly impossible to believe our government would be competent enough to maintain secrecy.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by erulabs on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:51AM (#22192843)
Well at very least these USAF/USN Stealth jet programs are at least competent at secrecy. From an Occam's Razor perspective, it's almost certainly that UFOs are either strange optical aberrations in peoples camera lenses or experimental military aircraft, so in part I think I agree with your dad. Camera weirdness being more common than billion dollar black programs, and those being more common than apparent life in the universe.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Zancarius on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:52PM (#22196142)
My father worked in connection to some of these programs many years ago (long since retired), and his favorite quip was to suggest that a closer inspection of "real" UFOs would reveal a USAF roundel painted on the side. So, naturally, I'm inclined to believe that if any such thing were ever spotted, it would be the result of one of these programs.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tropo on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:43AM (#22192754)
SuperHornet, the F-18D and F-18E, was great.

Basically the navy pretended to update the Hornet (F-18A, F-18B, F-18C) but actually built a completely new plane. Clearly it isn't the same, because the airframe is dramatically larger. There is a tiny bit of stealth (nothing fancy) but otherwise it looks like the Hornet... except way larger.

It was designed very quickly and cheaply. That was the requirement, and it was met. The whole project was sort of an open secret, pretending to be a revision of the Hornet while actually being an entirely new aircraft. This seems to have evaded lots of bureaucracy.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by moosedev on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:41PM (#22198180)
Small nitpick: the Super Hornet is actually the F/A-18E and F variants. F/A-18D was the two-seater variant of F/A-18C.

(Great planes though, yeah!)

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by adwww on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:41AM (#22200338)
This reminds me of how my city managed to secure money for a world class concert hall by claiming it was just a multipurpose hall that _could_ possibly be used for concerts.

I've submitted the story here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22200328

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Xixi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @12:51PM (#22193469)
France's Rafale program is usually considered to have been very competently managed. Of course it's quite a bit older than the F-35, as the program started in the early 80s. But it has been mostly on time [1], on budget and on spec. This is despite sharing some of the complexity of the F-35 in that it replaced most previous aircraft types in use in the French air force (a true multi-role aircraft), and even has a carrier capable version (CATOBAR, not VTOL). It's basically equivalent to making the F-35A and F-35C, without the F-35B.

Of course, having only one nation in the program helped a lot keeping the specifications consistent over time. I strongly doubt the NGF currently being developed with Germany and Spain is going to be that smooth...

[1] delays were incurred by the end of the Cold war: the so-called peace dividends, resulting in military budget restrictions.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Glawen on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:57PM (#22194194)
It definitely is a competently managed program, as were the mirage programs.

However if you look at the a400m or eurofighter programs, you see delays and budget overruns. The issue lies in the spec creep by the funding parties of these programs. For example the french took deliveries of the first a400m because they needed the plane, but it could not drop parachutists in the first version !

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Xixi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:43PM (#22194685)
Also note that the makers of these three products are completely different. The Rafale was helmed by Dassault, the A400M by former CASA (Construcciones Aeronáuticas SA in Spain, now part of Airbus) and the Typhoon by what I believe is a former part of British Aerospace (now also part of Airbus).

Airbus really is a collection of companies, so it can be hard to figure out exactly which part does what. I hope Dassault remains the project manager on the NGF, although in the end spec creep really is the biggest program killer...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by greedo on Thursday January 30, 2020 @03:52PM (#22195438)
Rafale was doomed to be too expensive due to the limited production run. This makes it hard to sell to other countries.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by hestefisk on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:34PM (#22195939)
F-16 Fighting Falcon.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by laydn on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:12AM (#22192442)
I believe no such thing exists in the western world. Russian fighter jet program costs appear to be orders of magnitude smaller though, at least on paper.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by adventured on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:26AM (#22192569)
The Su-57 has a supposed ~$35-$45 million unit cost (versus closer to $78m for eg the recent F35A planes [1]). If you adjust that to the US economic output per capita figures, you're looking at up to a quarter of a billion dollars per plane equivalent for the Su-57. A crushing sum, in other words, for the Russians and their economic capabilities.

However, the Russians sold Su-35s to China at a cost of $83 million a few years ago. So the quoted Su-57 numbers certainly appear fraudulent. The real unit cost is probably twice the claims. There is minimal transparency in such things as it pertains to Russia.

So far it appears they can't afford or deliver their supposedly cost effecient plane:

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/russias-stealth-fight...

[1] https://www.defensenews.com/air/2019/10/29/in-newly-inked-de...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Xixi on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:17PM (#22193724)
It's very hard to compare sales figures with fly-away costs as they measure completely different things. Sales figures usually include many extras like weapons, simulators, training, support, spare parts, spare engines, integration with other (usually local) weapons, and other custom developments that can massively raise the bill. Conversely fly-away costs tend to exclude everything to look as small as possible: things like radars, helmet mounted displays, sometimes even engines are left aside.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Polyisoprene on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:33AM (#22192646)
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by bjourne on Friday January 31, 2020 @07:27AM (#22201069)
Another way to see it is as a conduit for funneling tax payer money to the billionaire class. Seen that way, it's a huge success.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by unapologetic on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:31PM (#22195918)
in doing so it leeches money from places it would be more useful and further enriches and entrenches defense contractors.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by rodgerd on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:55PM (#22196190)
Just think, the US could have had universal free education.

But instead it has fighters that don't work.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wonderwonder on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:55PM (#22196844)
Amazing how we always have money for the military industrial complex and the fossil fuel industry but never for new social programs.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tromp on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:21PM (#22196465)
or universal basic income...
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by briandear on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:43PM (#22198510)
An individual can pay for their own schooling, but it’s pretty hard for an individual to pay for national defense.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by AdrianB1 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:11PM (#22196991)
There is nothing in the F35 program preventing universal free education: free education does not cost anything (it is free), so the money spent on the program is not impacting it. /s
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjs3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:45PM (#22198214)
free education does not cost anything (it is free)

Do you maybe need a few minutes to actually think about that statement? Because it doesn't reflect well on your critical thinking capabilities...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by AdrianB1 on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:58AM (#22201661)
It is sad when jokes needs to be explained.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjs3 on Saturday February 01, 2020 @01:29AM (#22209075)
It is sad when a jokes delivery is so bad no one gets it.