News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by munk-a on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:38PM (#22195997)
I don't disagree that do-nothing projects can be valuable to society - but defense contractors are an extremely inefficient way to inject money into the economy. Most of that money ends up going into the pockets of people who could find quite decent jobs elsewhere.

Redirecting that money to small business grants would provide a much bigger boost to general societal well being.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Kalium on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:09PM (#22196327)
Some of it is less about injecting money than it is about maintaining capacity and capability. It's not always about jobs in general, but sometimes about specific jobs.

The US defense-industrial complex may not always have a high need for people who can design stealth fighters, but it definitely prefers to keep a few around in case it does suddenly need them.

Small business grants may not be a good way of meeting the same need.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by andrewflnr on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:13PM (#22197010)
I get maintaining the capability, but they clearly can't develop a stealth fighter, so that justification doesn't really work either anymore.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Kalium on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:16PM (#22197035)
I mean, maybe? That this program isn't working may not be the same as the US no longer having the capability. It's possible that the F-35 isn't really expected to produce a functional stealth fighter, all rhetoric aside.

I honestly have no idea.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by munk-a on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:55PM (#22204412)
That seems to stretch the argument pretty far - maybe if we just want to keep vaguely military folk in the country then we could employ them building military grade roads to replace the aging infrastructure. If the project they're actually working on isn't supposed to bear any real fruit then maybe just redirect them to something that isn't a complete waste of resources.

Also, I disagree, I don't think anyone in that realm of government would knowingly sink that much money into a project they intended to fail - they might be overly optimistic about the success, they might be trying to funnel money into their retirement but it takes clout to secure a budget like that and people had to work hard to secure it initially and keep it going - so a failure is probably going to fall under one of these categories - un-achievable, poorly managed, or wholly corrupt.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by ska on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:25PM (#22196510)
I suspect there is some truth to this. But I wonder how much of that effort could be directed to more useful infrastructure projects and still maintain skills.

The other issue is that some fraction of defense spending seemingly can be viewed as funneling public money into a get-your-friends-rich scheme. I don't think you can find much net upside to that aspect.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by akiselev on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:10PM (#22196978)
Stealth airplanes are extremely complex engineering projects that stretch across many fields. Maintaining any individual skill set is easy, but they're all highly specialized and require the industry to be maintained or else the combination of cross disciplinary skills, including project management, disappears.

Think back to Boeing's problems with the Dreamliner, where Boeing tried a new model of splitting out the design to a bunch of subcontractors and ended up with tons of problems with the integration ranging from missed design milestones due to problems with the composites to miscommunications leading to battery problems in production and so on. Those are a small taste of what happens when the engineering-management hierarchy is broken up and fractured across organizations. It becomes a lot worse when they are fractured across time.

The US famously lost it's top launch capabilities with the Saturn V and we didn't have a domestic replacement until the Falcon Heavy in 2018! By their very nature, maintaining the capabilities needed for weapons of war that can be deployed anywhere in the world is even more expensive if you want to have any sort of certainty that they'll work when the shots are fired instead of once a few years when you want to launch a satellite.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by ska on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:17PM (#22198029)
I don’t think we are disagreeing, but I wouldn’t rely on the industry to define how much is needed.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by akiselev on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:37PM (#22198157)
I'm saying that the resources cannot be redirect towards "more useful infrastructure projects and still maintain skills". The cross disciplinary skills in military aviation are unique.

Whether or not the cost of the F35 program is an efficient way to maintain those skills is a different issue altogether that gets at the fundamental structure of our government and how money impacts politics. That's a much more difficult discussion than "can we reasonably defend ourselves in the future."

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by ska on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:31AM (#22199828)
sure, but it’s the more interesting discussion to have, and it’s what I was pointing out. Plausibly the majority of the resources spent on this program could in fact have gone to more useful programs without affecting baseline capability. Plausibly the could not ... but it’s not clear anyone who should be asking that question, is.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:14PM (#22197015)
> inject money into the economy

The money "injected" into the economy must come from somewhere, and that somewhere is the economy. I.e. it's zero-sum.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by myhf on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:32PM (#22197174)
It's not zero-sum. It can change the velocity of circulation money, which impacts economic activity in predictable ways.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:35PM (#22198470)
Circulating money doesn’t create economic value. We might as well had spent $1.5 trillion (the cost so far to develop the F-35) to make a fleet of large metal platypuses which we keep in hangars and occasionally launch into the air.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by neximo64 on Friday January 31, 2020 @02:31AM (#22199827)
Circulating money does create economic value in far multiples of the initial amount. It's well established military spending has an impact on GDP far more than the amount itself.

Funds are never 'spent' as such, the money always circulates around even if you do buy metal platypuses - someone is going to get a salary and spend it somewhere or invest in their future by buying things that improve their productivity.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:40AM (#22200337)
But a large portion of the money ends up in the F-35 itself, which is useless. Think of all the energy, all the time and brainpower used to build the platypus. Think of all the money and materials used to create something that no one wants, which could instead be used to create things that people want while still providing jobs/income. The point of an economy is to enable exchanges so that people produce things that other people need. That is the benefit of an economy; money is a medium for trading things of value for other things of value.

In this case, the trade is one-way; the F-35 is effectively a black hole. The transaction to defense workers is immensely lossy. Ultimately, the program is funded by taxpayers whose money went into building a $1.5 trillion boondoggle instead of any number of useful purposes. The unseen harm of using the public’s funds in this way far outweighs the benefits the defense industry brings. It’s the same as taking five dollars from everyone, paying people three dollars to throw two of every five dollars into a campfire, and calling it economic growth. Sure, some people get paid, but the net gain is negative. The two dollars isn’t used to create things that other people want; it is locked inside a metal platypus.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by neximo64 on Friday January 31, 2020 @05:18AM (#22200505)
> But a large portion of the money ends up in the F-35 itself,

How does it 'end up' there? - A human being is paid in the end. This is the notion I don't believe you're accurately looking at.

Say you were to pay the cashier $100 for your groceries, s/he wouldn't end up with the money either it would go to suppliers and seep back into the economy. Money is a bit like energy to a degree it can't be destroyed it ultimately ends up being spent again and again. Unless of course it goes into a bank account that is locked and never spent - for which inflation will tax it and even that would leak back.

The F35 is deliberately built in very high deficit areas to have the largest multiplier effect- this results in extremely good stimulus spending. Just to throw some numbers out there money spent this way (even if the end product is useless) ends up increasing GDP 30-60% more than the original spend. E.g $100 spent => $130-160m. It depends on the unemployment rate in the area but it can be as high as 3x. There is hardly a government program that can be as effective unless its building infrastructure, where it can stretch to as high as 7 (read Japan roads to nowhere)

The F35 is certaintly not a black hole. Almost certainly if you look at it in the way we buy things and consume them - then yes it is, almost 100%, but in terms of the economic effects its a very helpful project. If France had for example done this type of spending it would not be sitting in economic contraction territory at the moment - wheras the US hardly sees contraction because of this type of deficit spending.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:06PM (#22205734)
> ends up increasing GDP 30-60% more than the original spend.

This does not take into account the deleterious effect of extracting the stimulus money from whence it came.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:03PM (#22205702)
> Circulating money does create economic value in far multiples of the initial amount.

Again, that assumes the "initial amount" came from dead or poorly invested money. I have seen no rationalization or evidence that this is the case.

Consider that 37% of Federal Income Tax revenue comes from the 1%. The 1% are the most effective investors, because that's how they became the 1%. Government spending would have to be incredibly good to outdo the best investors.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by sitkack on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:14AM (#22199529)
Could they please be chrome?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by csb6 on Friday January 31, 2020 @01:59AM (#22199701)
I like the aesthetic, but we’re on a budget here. Rhinestone and we call it a compromise?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:44PM (#22198199)
This implies that the money extracted from the economy is dead money or poorly invested. I've seen no rationale nor evidence for why that might be true.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by numpad0 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:56AM (#22200394)
Economy being a zero-sum game is a layman’s approximation, and not the reality, at all. Merely supposed to be that way in the days of gold standards.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by WalterBright on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:05PM (#22205719)
The economy is not a zero-sum game. But transferring money from one place to another is zero-sum. It's not free money.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by raisedbyninjas on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:10PM (#22196339)
In these times of low unemployment, a dearth of applicants may push Lockheed to literally burning money. Could this provide more economic benefit until spring when heating costs drop?