News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @12:16PM (#22193116)
The F-117 had very limited requirements compared to the F-35. What's killing the F-35 is the extreme complexity of the program.

The requirements for the F-117 were basically that it had to be stealthy, and had to be able to carry a minimal payload a reasonable range. There was no radar, no vertical takeoff, no carrier landings, no air-to-air, no sensor fusion, no datalinks, no cooperative engagement, etc etc etc.

It's poorly understood how the combination of high performance requirements, complexity, and flexibility mix. Optimizing a system for performance generally requires cutting across domains. Subsystems need to be designed jointly to wring out performance. This means there are many dependencies between the subsystems, so if one thing changes on one subsystem, it may affect a number of other subsystems. If you then add flexibility to the mix -- you want a modular system like the F-35, all of this optimization work has to be done on every combination of parts. Now combine this with a complex set of mission requirements -- every change has to be optimized for multiple missions and multiple aircraft variants. Due to the optimized and complex nature of the aircraft, each change will also affect many subsystems.

Because the system is so complex, no person or even a small group of people can have the entire system in their head, so it's hard to know exactly what will be affected with a subsystem change. Subsystems affected by a change will furthermore not even be built by the same company. This all means that each change has to go through very slow formal processes to make sure it keeps working.

All of this is to say that layering on all of these categories of requirements has an exponential effect. If the F-35 didn't have to be high performance, or if it didn't have three variants, or if it didn't have to perform multiple missions, the project would have been much easier.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tempestn on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:05PM (#22195572)
So does it follow from that that the entire concept is flawed, and what should have been designed instead are multiple different aircraft?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:35PM (#22196617)
Yes, it should have been multiple aircraft, or the scope should have been reduced. It's hard enough to make an aircraft that's good on an aircraft carrier and on land. Adding the vertical landing (B model) version compromised the whole program.

VTOL is a very specialized capability, and there's never been another airplane that has VTOL as an optional feature. You have to design the plane and its engine around this capability, and you compromise on many other things to get it. The A and C models then have to live with many of these design compromises. Even the basic shape of the aircraft, with such a wide front fuselage reduces the performance of the F-35, even though on the A and C models there's no need to be so wide since there's no lift fan.

Meanwhile, it's not even clear that the Marines need a VTOL airplane. The B model has the ability to operate off Navy helicopter carriers, which gives them significantly more punch, but there's basically no real scenario where a helicopter carrier would need it. In a real war, there will always be full deck carriers anywhere a helicopter carrier is. In theory the helicopter carriers would offer additional capacity, but carrier air wings have been scaled back, and full deck carriers only go to sea with 60-65 aircraft even though they have the capacity for 90. If the Marines wanted more of their own air assets they could have just bought C models and operated them off the big carriers like they already do with the F-18.

The B model is also significantly lower performance. It has to takeoff at lower weights, and it has the huge extra weight of the lift fan. This means it has a much shorter range and carries less weapons. If they had simply bought C models and put them on the big carriers, the overall capability would be greater.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by wahern on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:50PM (#22196769)
Maybe someone more knowledgable about the history can chime in, but the first thought that entered my mind when you were discussing full deck carriers is that the F-35 was designed from the very beginning for international sales. Only a few nations have full deck carriers, while many more have helicopter carriers. It's not surprising then that there are 2 allies with F-35Bs, 3 allies with plans for the F-35B, and none for the F-35C: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @06:28PM (#22197144)
Yes, that's true, but look at the F-35 orders. There are 563 orders for the B model out of 3200 total. The foreign customers are the UK with 138, to operate on their Queen Elizabeth carriers, 30 for Italy to operate on their small carriers, and 42 to Japan for the same.

In 2010, the UK decided to make the QE carriers ski-jump and operate the B model for cost reasons, however they considered making them CATOBAR and operate the C model. If the B model had not existed, they would have simply spent another couple of billion dollars to make them CATOBAR.

It's probably not practical from a budget and political standpoint for Japan and Italy to make CATOBAR carriers, but does it really make sense to compromise a 3200 aircraft program that's the backbone of the USAF and USN's fleet so that Italy and Japan can buy 72 aircraft? Italy and Japan could just buy tanker aircraft for long range power projection.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by adwww on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:34AM (#22200308)
You could also claim it was quite a coup by the UK to get the US to spend trillions subsiding a VSTOL aircraft for the RN.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by craftinator on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:36PM (#22198156)
Your comments make up the most competent and comprehensive analysis I've seen on the F35 program; way more thorough than those presented in Congress or by the various involved aerospace companies. Are you involved in the project in any way?
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:17PM (#22198379)
I'm just an interested observer, but my observations are hardly unique. The same points have been made in many forums including congressional hearings.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by craftinator on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:13AM (#22199267)
Much of what I've seen in congressional hearings is so watered down and blame-shifted it is difficult to assemble into a coherent story. You did a great job of the spark notes version
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by discordance on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:51PM (#22197815)
aka, The Homer (also known as "The Car Built for Homer")
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by GVIrish on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:12PM (#22195655)
Exactly this. The DoD basically took the mistakes of the F-111 program, doubled down on them, and added on some reckless new mistakes.

The result is the most expensive weapons program in history.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by DuskStar on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:23PM (#22195808)
And congress went along with it (or encouraged it) because theoretically it would be cheaper...

(And the Marines liked it because no one was going to spend the money to build a stealthy V/STOL strike fighter for them unless it was part of someone else's development budget)

(And the Navy IIRC just wanted their fucking A-12 [0] already)

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_A-12_Avenger...

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Already__Taken on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:49PM (#22196762)
> 2009 ... required the two contractors to repay the U.S. government US$1.35 billion, plus interest charges of US$1.45 billion

...

> January 2014, the case was settled with Boeing and General Dynamics agreeing to pay $200 million each.

Quite the settlement

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by Already__Taken on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:45PM (#22196716)
It's mental the v22 osprey platform isn't further explored.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by DuskStar on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:07PM (#22197953)
What do you mean? Bell's working on a followup right now, as an entry in the US army's Future Vertical Lift program [0].

And the osprey itself is still getting adopted in more places - I think carrier onboard delivery is its latest role.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_V-280_Valor

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by smacktoward on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:26PM (#22196527)
The old "sports car/dump truck" problem: you can make a good sports car, you can make a good dump truck, but what you can't make is a good sports car that is also a good dump truck.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by natmaka on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:15PM (#22198987)
Things are more and more complicated (interacting, and also wide, dense, fast-moving...), and therefore unpredictability grows.

This is true for nearly everythoing, and war reflects it, as up to the Industrial Revolution things (strategy, tactics, weaponry...) evolved gradually. Nowadays nobody knows anymore how all this really works, therefore there is less and less way to predict (how/what/why/when/...) sufficiently accurately in order to prepare/act adequately (for example to equip soldiers).

Hence the need for "something which can cope with any situation".

Fun fact: this 'something' has to be complicated, adding up complication to the complicated global state of affairs, nurturing the very cause of the underlying challenge.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by cameldrv on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:08PM (#22198950)
You can almost though. Make it out of titanium, give it gas turbine engines with an electric drive, put the thing on hydraulics so it can get lower to the ground, add electronic stability control to get artificial sports car feel, and some rocket thrusters on the top to keep it from tipping over in tight turns. Maybe you could make the tires out of some metamaterial so it can have slick tires for racing and deep treads for the construction site.

All of that is to say it can be done, but you're going to pay, and it might not be delivered on time.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by tempestn on Friday January 31, 2020 @12:29AM (#22199345)
Nice extension of the metaphor. Makes building the sports dump truck sound very much like the F35 project.
Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:46PM (#22198223)
>The F-117 had very limited requirements compared to the F-35. What's killing the F-35 is the extreme complexity of the program.

This. The only thing the F35 doesn't do it blow the pilot and hand him a beer. Since nobody is willing to settle for a plane that can do everything and sucks at it (and rightfully so) it's turned into this massive project where there's a billion dollars in man hours spent arguing over each little nut and bolt in order to find the compromises needed to create something that satisfies all the stake holders well enough to get sign off.

I think a lot of this is driven by the fact that we have no real enemy at present. It's much easier to say "no we need a system that can do X and Y and we need it now, Z can wait" when you're worried about the USSR having the jump on you. There is no such pressure for competency at present.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by mcv on Saturday February 01, 2020 @03:49PM (#22213133)
That's pretty much my take too. The F-35 had to be able to do absolutely everything, and that generally means it's not going to any of those particularly well.

For a small airforce, a jack-of-all-trades fighter makes a lot of sense (hence the popularity of the F-16 among small airforces), but for the US, it makes no sense to abandon all specialised fighters in favour of a single compromise.

Re:F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster o... by kjs3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @08:43PM (#22198191)
Well...maybe the right answer is to limit scope and not try and pack every requirement into one package.