News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android 10 by alistproducer2 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @03:22PM (#20870162)
I recently bought a Nokia 2.2, which in in the Android One program. Two main reasons: a removable battery and OS updates for two years and security for 3. At this point, there's very little difference between the hardware of flagships and commodity, especially considering the real-world use of smartphones. I mean, is anyone compiling programs on these things or doing anything particularly intensive? Not really. So given the choice between a $1000 phone and a $140 one, I choose the latter because in 2019 your really paying for the software.

Since Android 9, I really enjoy Android. It feels like a totally different experience with things like split screen, gesture nav, and smart replies. The Android team is doing a great job as of late. I look forward to getting this update. I hope we get to a point where the OEMs stop being the gate keepers of our phone's OSs and these devices become more like laptops, in the sense of being able to run whatever we want.

Re:Android 10 by unicornporn on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:19PM (#20871288)
> a removable battery and OS updates for two years

This provokes me. Are we supposed to be happy with two years? The environmental impact of e-waste and the production of electronics should not be understated. I have a Nexus 5 as a backup phone. It works just as well as my main handset. I know how to duck the G-surveillance and I'm able to keep it alive because I have the knowledge to install roms. Not everyone does. Personally, I much prefer Android over iOS. But when someone asks me what phone they should get I always tell them to buy an iPhone. This is one of the reasons why.

Re:Android 10 by coryfklein on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:52PM (#20871571)
> Are we supposed to be happy with two years? The environmental impact of e-waste and the production of electronics should not be understated.

Can you elaborate on this? Because I'm thinking of the amount of garbage I put in the bin over a period of two whole years, and the size of my phone, its packaging, chargers, cables, and manuals all together is just not even comparable. Even if you add in the environmental cost of the manufacturing I can't imagine it's even a drop in the bucket compared to other waste.

I'm sure it is a good idea to optimize for waste in some respect, but cell phones seem like they must contribute such a minuscule relative amount so as to be safely ignored for now.

Re:Android 10 by staz on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:15PM (#20871788)
plenty or rare earth element https://www.techradar.com/news/phone-and-communications/mobi...

Also plenty of other elements in your smartphone that you wouldn't find in your normal bin

Re:Android 10 by indecisive_user on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:27PM (#20871900)
That article meanders quite a bit, but it didn't convince me that the environmental impact from manufacturing phones is a huge concern, just that the price of some rare earth elements will increase as our current supply runs low, at which point we'll create new mines to increase the supply again.

And how much of that impact is mitigated from recycling phones after you upgrade?

Re:Android 10 by thedays on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @03:01AM (#20874658)
This article reports that "producing a single iPhone (6) requires, roughly, mining 34 kilos of ore, 100 liters of water, and 20.5 grams of cyanide." Also, "a billion iPhones had been sold by 2016, which translates into roughly ...37 million tons of mined rock". https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/433wyq/everything-thats-i...

Those numbers are pretty substantial - we shouldn't underestimate the environmental impact of our smartphone and gadget addictions.

Re:Android 10 by beowulfey on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:02PM (#20873016)
As with anything, any bit counts. It may not seem like it makes a huge difference but in general anything that mitigates the culture of consumerism helps prevent waste.

Yes your own immediate impact on global waste is much higher from your kitchen trash than your device purchases. But people buying a new device every year, regardless of what they do with it after, encourages companies to keep producing these products at tremendous rates, which in turn results in far more environmental impacts due to everything that comes with it.

It’s sometimes hard to see the effects beyond the scope of what we see on a day to day basis, but they are absolutely there at the societal level.

Re:Android 10 by thekid314 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:34PM (#20871959)
The lifetime of most electronics is much longer than 2 years. The only thing I need to replace regularly is headphones.
Re:Android 10 by sundvor on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @08:31PM (#20872814)
My Hifi system is 22 years old now, and going strong. Rotel and Infinity built some seriously good stuff back then.

I'm afraid of how much it'll cost me to replace it when it eventually breaks, if I can't fix it. Have already refurbished the speaker surrounds once, about 10 years go.

Guy at Speakerbits (Melbourne AUS) said the speakers would be worth more than when I bought them, as the mid range quality market just didn't exist anymore - either cheap throw away after a few years crap, or you'd have to go really high end.

I thought I'd check, and it seems like Speakerbits have now closed down. That's such a shame, they did a most excellent job. I guess that's a reflection of the times, people aren't willing to repair anymore. :(

Re:Android 10 by sundvor on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @10:58PM (#20873605)
Correction: Speakerbits went offline for a while a couple of years and that was talked about - then silently came back it would seem.

Great, at least I know where I'll go if I wear out the current surrounds or anything else.

Re:Android 10 by driverdan on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:58PM (#20872631)
Headphones should last a lifetime. Stop buying garbage and treat them well.
Re:Android 10 by sundvor on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @08:34PM (#20872831)
It'll be interesting to see how long Bluetooth headphones will last. You lose one vulnerability (the darned cable) and replace it with another (battery).
Re:Android 10 by bscphil on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @11:20PM (#20873717)
Good headphones have cables that you can detach and replace, with a universally supported standard (like mini-XLR) built in, so you're not locked into a cable made by a single manufacturer.
Re:Android 10 by ehsankia on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @10:27PM (#20873434)
Just because OS upgrades stop after 2 years doesn't mean security updates stop. Also technically, 2 years of OS upgrades means 3 years of use since each upgrade last a year afterwards.
Re:Android 10 by lupinglade on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @08:34PM (#20872829)
Garbage is garbage.
Re:Android 10 by pvinis on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @04:20AM (#20875074)
What's interesting is that most people that buy the 140 dollar phones tend to keep them for 3 or 4 years, and people who buy the flagship 1000+ dollar phones, tend to keep them for 1 or 2 max.
Re:Android 10 by melling on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @04:47AM (#20875227)
Yeah, I’m getting a new iPhone every year on the Apple trade-in plan.

Somehow I doubt that Apple just throws my phone away.

Re:Android 10 by kllrnohj on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:32PM (#20871408)
> Are we supposed to be happy with two years? The environmental impact of e-waste should not be understated.

Note it's 2 years of feature updates not 2 years and it turns into a brick. Everything will still work and you'll still get new apps and app updates for far longer than 2 years. Security updates go for longer, too.

Re:Android 10 by neilalexander on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:45PM (#20871510)
Given that Apple are still managing to roll out operating system updates to iPhones that are 5 years old, a potent question is why Google and Android device manufacturers are either unable or unwilling to attempt to do the same. Planned obsolescence isn't just an attack on your customers, it's also environmentally irresponsible.
Re:Android 10 by penagwin on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:56PM (#20871622)
It's because of how updates work. A good overview is here [0]

Basically for an android phone to get an update, Google, the Carrier, the Manufacturer, etc. all have to update the OS for that specific model, of which there are hundreds/thousands of models of phones.

Apple doesn't let the carriers configure the OS, and is also the manufacturer. They also have only like a dozen models. So they basically get to skip all of the parts that slow down updating your IOS version.

[0] https://www.xda-developers.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/HT...

Re:Android 10 by bscphil on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:49PM (#20872062)
That's just an excuse. The Nexus 5X got updates directly from Google, but it was discontinued a year after it was released. ~1 year after the last 5X was sold, it received the last feature update (Android 8.1). ~2 years after the last 5X was sold, it received the last security update.
Re:Android 10 by dgacmu on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:55PM (#20872612)
Google doesn't make the CPU or hardware components that need firmware updates. Apple has far more control.
Re:Android 10 by kalleboo on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @11:40PM (#20873804)
There's no way that hardware firmware on the CPU(?!) is what's holding back Android updates.
Re:Android 10 by ansible on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @12:22AM (#20873978)
Yes and no.

If you're not getting updates from the chip vendor, you're going to have a hard time moving to later version of Linux, for example. It would cost a lot of money to port new software to the platform, and then the question is... who's going to pay for it?

If everyone still using a Nexus 5X chips in $50 USD to fund continued development, then maybe that could continue. But it is easier at some point to just buy a new phone.

Re:Android 10 by mrguyorama on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:09AM (#20876808)
The phone originally sold for $400. Is that really not enough money to fund software development for 4 years or more?
Re:Android 10 by ansible on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @02:27PM (#20880043)
> The phone originally sold for $400. Is that really not enough money to fund software development for 4 years or more?

No, not really.

First comes the reality of retail pricing. The "leaving the factory door with everything amortized in" unit price of a $400 phone is likely around $250 or less. The rest of that is markup for the store, shipping, warranty returns, marketing, and a bunch else.

A good chuck of that $250 (if it is even that high), pays for the actual hardware, patent licenses, carrier testing, and a bunch of other stuff.

That doesn't leave much left to actually pay for development.

And since most consumers aren't thinking about operating system updates a couple years down the road, the lower selling price will generate more profits than long-term support will.

Re:Android 10 by ksec on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:49AM (#20885454)
Yes and No.

1. If it was really $400, the problem is most ( pretty much all apart from Apple ) gives plenty of Retail margin and incentive to carriers. That means on average it is highly likely not even getting $250 out of it.

It is like those Flagship Samsung and Huawei phone, their pricing strategy is always $100 lower than comparative official iPhone price, except they are often retailing for 20% lower. Compared to Apple, you could hardly find any decent discount on iPhone, and iPhone has much lower margin for Carrier and Retail, from low end of 10s to even single digit percentage.

2. Only if it is sold for 100 millions unit +. And Google didn't even manage 10. You need Scale for it to work. That is why iPhone is unprecedented, when was the last time you saw a product in its segment taking 20% of shipment and 80-90% of industry profits?

The answer often to all these question is simple, paid up, and find enough people to paid up, in business terms this means market fit. Unfortunately apart from small bunch of people on HN, no one is willing to paid extra $50 - $100 more just for Software update, they expect it to be free, or they would rather not update at all.

Re:Android 10 by penagwin on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:50AM (#20877176)
And more to your point - The iPhone 7 is currently 450$ brand new and is nearly 3 years old. Not only has it received feature updates for those 3 years, but all it's predecessors down to the 5S have been receiving feature updates (ends this year unfortunately) - we should be able to expect the iPhone 7 to at least get another year or two of feature updates.
Re:Android 10 by 29083011397778 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @12:45AM (#20883901)
The 5X started out at $400. The iPhone 7 is not only still more expensive, but it started out far above the 5X's retail price.
Re:Android 10 by kllrnohj on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:54PM (#20871591)
Apple does also cut features when they roll out those updates though. Not all iOS versions are equal.

It is a shame Android's update story is bad, but realistically it also doesn't matter much. Non-enthusiasts tend to not even want major updates in the first place (it's a chore - especially if anything changed on them).

It sucks for app developers a lot more than it matters to the majority consumer.

Re:Android 10 by megaremote on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:33PM (#20872464)
> Apple does also cut features when they roll out those updates though. Not all iOS versions are equal.

Only when the hardware does not support the features.

Re:Android 10 by panpanna on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @06:41AM (#20875802)
It is widely established that Apple selectively disables features on previous generations to force people buy new ones.

Example: with ios7 siri was disabled for some devices. Worked just fine on jailbroken devices.

Re:Android 10 by sciurus on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @08:18PM (#20872744)
I checked https://www.android.com/one/ and see monthly security updates are promised for three years.
Re:Android 10 by panpanna on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @06:44AM (#20875814)
Note that this is the minimum requirement by contract.

Samsung for example is still updating 4 year old note devices.

Re:Android 10 by rstuart4133 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @07:21AM (#20885599)
> Are we supposed to be happy with two years?

If it was a laptop of desktop definitely not. And initially I wasn't happy with 2 years on a mobile phone because I thought they would age like their bigger brethren.

The reality is none of my mobile phones have aged gracefully. They've all slowed down to almost unusable some time after the 2 year mark, despite me fighting my way past the glue and tape to replace the non-replaceable battery. The really annoying part for me, a veteran embedded programmer who has rolled his own multitasking operating systems, is I have no idea what is causing this slowdown. Nothing I've done fixes it, up to and including including re-imaging the flash.

With my latest phone I've come to accept that I'll be replacing it in 2 years. My previous phone was a Nexus 6P which cost me around $1200, which I planned to have for about 5 years (but didn't). This time around it is a Nokia 8.1 which cost me a tad over $400, so even on a 2 year vs 5 year replacement schedule it would cost me less than the 6P.

The thing that did catch me by surprise is the Nokia 8.1 is a better phone than the 6P ever was - faster, better screen. Do things really move that fast in the mobile space? Maybe they do - everyone is adding bigger and bigger IPU's now. Compare that to desktop CPU's: I don't think they don't have IPU's yet.

Which brings me back to my original point. That 5 year expectation was set by my experience with desktop's. It seems for all sorts of reasons that experience doesn't translate to mobile phones.

Re:Android 10 by thaumasiotes on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @11:34PM (#20873780)
> I know how to duck the G-surveillance and I'm able to keep it alive because I have the knowledge to install roms.

This is unconvincing. The Nexus 5 is prone to hardware failure. My ability to install roms didn't help at all when the phone stopped recognizing its own permanent storage.

Re:Android 10 by signal11 on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @05:58AM (#20875569)
This. 2 years (and 3 for security) is a joke.
Re:Android 10 by mda on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @03:44AM (#20874882)
Why do you throw it away after 2 years? It still gets security updates. Perfectly useable for more time.
Re:Android 10 by mcovey on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @08:39AM (#20876577)
My phone is going on 3 years. No removable battery, but I followed the iFixit guide and managed to replace the battery anyway a few months ago, since it had lost a lot of capacity. I intend to keep it for another 2-3 years at least.
Re:Android 10 by drusepth on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:57PM (#20872623)
>This provokes me. Are we supposed to be happy with two years?

As someone who buys a new phone around every 2-3 years, two years is perfect for me. I know the developers are focusing on making the update work as well as they can on just the last two years' worth of hardware, and not "wasting time" on making it work well on lesser/older hardware.

Take "wasting time" here defined as selfishly as possible. If I'm buying a new phone every 2 years, any amount of development time that goes into making sure that update works on 3+-year-old phones is wasted on me, and explicitly means less development time was spent on features that are actually relevant to me.

Honestly, I'd be just as happy if updates were guaranteed for just 1 year (though I'd probably just sit for a year without updates between upgrades), and I'd definitely be less happy if they were guaranteed for 5 years because I feel like a significantly larger portion of development time would go towards backwards compatibility instead of pushing tech forward.

Re:Android 10 by pgcj_poster on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @08:11PM (#20872704)
> I feel like a significantly larger portion of development time would go towards backwards compatibility instead of pushing tech forward.

In what ways do you feel that cell phones need to be pushed forward? Phones have been capable of doing everything I want and more for many years now. My biggest complaint is how quickly they become insecure.

Re:Android 10 by kalleboo on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @11:46PM (#20873833)
Do you just throw away your old phone? Mine become hand-me-downs.

Until her birthday this year, my mother-in-law was using my old iPhone 5S, a 6-year-old phone which still runs the latest iOS. Now she got my wife's old iPhone 6S (4 years old), and my wife has my old iPhone X (3 years old).

Throwing away a phone after 2 years is incredibly wasteful.

Re:Android 10 by drusepth on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @12:55AM (#20874095)
I usually sell or give them away to friends that need them, with anything that isn't wanted sitting in reserve in case I ever need a backup phone (I always keep an extra one in my backpack in case my current driver breaks).

The only phone/tablet I've actually thrown away was my 2012 Nexus 7 that finally completely died last year. Everything else finds a home somewhere. :)

Re:Android 10 by distances on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:04PM (#20870599)
I wouldn't mind the lower power that much, but camera is one of my main use cases for phone. Pixel is just so damn good at taking pictures. The cheap phones do have considerably worse cameras, no way around that.
Re:Android 10 by on_and_off on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:38PM (#20870917)
At some point cameras are going to be commoditized as well though, partly thanks to all the investment in computerized photography.

I bought a mid range phone for my parents, they find its camera amazing.

It does not hold a candle to a pixel, but it is adequate. For users that don't feel the need for the best in class phone camera, it is already enough.

I wonder what will be the distinguishing factor in 5 years.

Re:Android 10 by _fzslm on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:21PM (#20870769)
The Pixel 3a is fantastic for that reason.
Re:Android 10 by shpx on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:07PM (#20871189)
The Pixel 1 XL has a good camera and you can buy a used one for under $200.
Re:Android 10 by nineteen999 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:44PM (#20871504)
Not to mention they are still getting updates, I'm installing Android 10 now.
Re:Android 10 by MattSayar on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:47AM (#20878306)
Does it still get regular security updates as well? I read they stop those after a couple years as well.
Re:Android 10 by shpx on Saturday September 07, 2019 @05:39AM (#20902785)
> Pixel phones get Android version updates for at least 3 years from when the device first became available on the Google Store.

> Pixel 1/Pixel 1 XL: No guaranteed Android version updates after October 2018, no guaranteed security updates after October 2019.

https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/4457705

but I've been running Android 10 for a couple months now, since the beta. Pixels (all of them) are the only phones that could be enrolled in the beta. In general, they get new features first, for example the offline voice recognition in Gboard https://techcrunch.com/2019/03/12/googles-new-voice-recognit...

The new Pixel 3a XL has only slightly better Geekbench scores than the Pixel 1 XL (347 vs 307 respectively), so at least there shouldn't be any performance reasons to not support this phone for another 3 years.

So, officially, not anymore. Unofficially, I'd baselessly speculate for another year? But you're right, I take back my recommendation. Security updates must be guaranteed.

Re:Android 10 by nineteen999 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:53PM (#20890537)
Mine got all the regular Android 9 security updates up until I installed Android 10, which I suppose is not bad for a phone that was released 3 years ago.

I'll probably replace it soon anyway since the battery life is starting to slip away. That's probably the worst aspect of the phone, since I bought it in Feb 2018.

Re:Android 10 by jcknight on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:42PM (#20870947)
I bought a Nokia 3.1 as a lower end test device, which also belongs to the Android One program. The device is so slow to respond to input in every way that it's become the device I use to test our apps absolute worst case performance on.

Even knowing it was meant to be a lower end device it routinely gets frustrating to use for even the most simple tasks, such as Chrome tab switching, keyboard response and even just plain navigation.

We have had similar, buy not as bad, reactions to other low end device we use for testing.

I genuinely feel sorry for people who use these devices as their primary phones.

Re:Android 10 by cwyers on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:52PM (#20871580)
I bought a few cheap (under $100) Nokia Lumias back when Nokia was Windows Phone's last, best hope, and it always annoyed me how a cheap Lumia with Windows Phone was in so many ways nicer to use than a mid-range Android phone -- much more responsive to input, less lag, etc.
Re:Android 10 by rstuart4133 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:47AM (#20885449)
Microsoft's latest revisions of the WinPhone were software engineering wise the best mobile phone OS on the planet. As you say, it was quick, silky smooth and yet ran on low end hardware with excellent battery life. I gather they achieved that buy tightly locking down how software developers could do things. Perhaps is why their app store was so thin which was major factor in their downfall, but still it was a remarkable effort. I take my hat off to that team.

It as even more remarkable because if you went back a few short years WinPhone was the worst phone OS on the planet. It crashed regularly, a misbehaving app could drain it's batter in no time, and the UI was horrible.

So much for "if you build a better mouse trap them will come" I guess, especially if your reputation is for making crap mousetraps.

Re:Android 10 by pjmlp on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:55PM (#20872130)
Thanks to everything being AOT compiled using full optimizations with their cloud compiler, including .NET code.
Re:Android 10 by boznz on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:50PM (#20872577)
Mostly Agree. But Microsoft fucked up both the desktop and mobile trying to make 1 operating system fit all.
Re:Android 10 by brlewis on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:11PM (#20871226)
> We have had similar, but not as bad, reactions to other low end device we use for testing

Let me guess -- Nexus 5X? I use one as my primary phone, and the slowness is noticeable but usually tolerable.

Re:Android 10 by unicornporn on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:24PM (#20871333)
Hope you have it backed up, because they die sooner or later. For me it was sooner, for my friend it was later. Some soldering problem if I recall things right. A bootloop is the first (and sometimes the last sign).
Re:Android 10 by wutbrodo on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:46PM (#20873240)
> Hope you have it backed up, because they die sooner or later

Tangential to your point, but is there anything useful that isn't backed up more or less by default in the standard Android workflow? I get that the privacy-concerned wouldn't use eg Google Photos, but they also likely heavily overlap with the set of people savvy enough to set up backup solutions for important data.

Re:Android 10 by zaarn on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @04:30AM (#20875124)
Plenty of apps can't be backed up (Google's TOTP App for example), at least in my experience, recovering from Android's native backup is just as good as dumping your SD card and having sync setup for applications that support it, which isn't a lot.
Re:Android 10 by unicornporn on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:55AM (#20909987)
I've run Graphene or Lineage without gapps on most phones. So, no auto backups.
Re:Android 10 by prab97 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:30PM (#20871385)
I can confirm that. My Nexus 5X died with bootloop after the warranty was over and all the googling led me to make peace with the fact that it was a soldering issue, hence a manufacturing defect.
Re:Android 10 by nineteen999 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:45PM (#20871516)
Yep same here, I didn't understand what went wrong at the time, but I did read here on HN a month or two ago that it was a known issue.
Re:Android 10 by brlewis on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:47PM (#20871530)
I do. This is my 2nd Nexus 5X from craigslist, but when this one dies I plan on replacing it with a Pixel 3a.
Re:Android 10 by alistproducer2 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:15PM (#20873082)
The 2.2 specs are better, with exception of RAM which is equivalent. I've never had any performance issues surfing, watching videos, or using apps. I couldn't recommend this phone enough. The review over at ars was good and that's what put it in my radar.
Re:Android 10 by apexalpha on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:18PM (#20871275)
>At this point, there's very little difference between the hardware of flagships and commodity, especially considering the real-world use of smartphones.

Cameras.

Re:Android 10 by mderazon on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:23PM (#20871871)
Exactly. In 2019 you're paying for software and camera
Re:Android 10 by wutbrodo on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:48PM (#20873248)
Would you include screens? I feel like my decisions (between flagships) tend to be driven primarily by screen.
Re:Android 10 by Eridrus on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:41PM (#20870943)
I recently started playing some games on my phone that require 3d rendering. Pretty sure it would struggle on an older phone. The 4GB of RAM I have feels slightly insufficient since the game gets closed by the OS if I switch to another resource intensive enough app.

I'm not going to say you should pay $1000 for a phone, but just because you have no issues with a $120 phone doesn't mean no-one does.

Re:Android 10 by JohnJamesRambo on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:45PM (#20870970)
I wish they made something like that in an iPhone SE size. Every phone is just so huge these days.
Re:Android 10 by nunodonato on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @03:44PM (#20870378)
Samsung DeX (or similar) is a very interesting use case for more powerful hardware. But if that's not something you'd use, then I fully agree with you.
Re:Android 10 by ivankolev on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:41PM (#20870941)
I am setting myself up on DeX as a full blown Intellij IDEA multi language environment but their locked down Linux distro makes me very uneasy...
Re:Android 10 by pezo1919 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:50PM (#20871011)
I am on iOS but if that happens I might migrate! Is this something available today?
Re:Android 10 by ivankolev on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @01:56AM (#20874397)
It is a beta program, search for "Linux on DeX" for details.
Re:Android 10 by pezo1919 on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:13PM (#20883005)
Thanks!
Re:Android 10 by coryfklein on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:57PM (#20871638)
Apps are going to use whatever CPU and memory is available. It's the same reason a chat app can use hundreds of MB of memory on a desktop. Why optimize that lower when laptops ship with 16+ GB these days?

In my experience that $140 phone actually does end up being laggier and less responsive which can be super annoying when scrolling and tapping with your fingers. I'm not a hardware engineer, but somehow this seems to hold true even if the memory is sized the same and the CPUs seem comparable. There must be something deeper in the specs involved that leads to UI slowness.

Re:Android 10 by godelski on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @06:49PM (#20872058)
While I think your comment is accurate, I'd argue that optimization is a better use of money and time than changing icons every 6 months to a year just so that the app looks new.

Honestly, why do icons change so much? Is it some psychological thing? I'm going to get used to whatever layout it is anyway and most popular apps have gone through a few designs and figured out what works. Like HN has not changed its layout. Why change it? Job security?

Re:Android 10 by Someone on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @09:28PM (#20873154)
I think it’s a signal that says “I run the newest OS, so I have fairly recent hardware, so I’m relatively wealthy”, and that sells phones.
Re:Android 10 by godelski on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @01:25AM (#20874246)
But how does this help with applications like Slack? Why not make Slack as light weight as possible so you can get it on more devices? Or Skype? Or whatever app? Those apps still do the layout change thing too.
Re:Android 10 by jhoechtl on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @12:34AM (#20874020)
> I hope we get to a point where the OEMs stop being the gate keepers of our phone's OSs and these devices become more like laptops, in the sense of being able to run whatever we want.

I own a Lenovo x13 convertible. Bios updates come in Windows executables only and whenever there is a Windows update the GPT is reconfigured, wiping my options to dual-boot Linux. It's been a while in the Laptop segment that there was free choice and you really had the feeling to own your device, sadly.

Re:Android 10 by andrepd on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:41PM (#20870934)
I agree that performance is good enough on 100$ phones, but there are other things, namely camera, battery, screen.

By the way, have you considered the fairphone 3?

Re:Android 10 by flukus on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @08:28PM (#20872789)
> OS updates for two years and security for 3

OS updates for 2 years assuming you buy it on launch day, for the vast majority of owners it will be significantly shorter than 2 years.

Also as a Nokia 3 owner, don't count on those updates actually working, mines been getting stuck in a boot loop when updating for a year now.

Re:Android 10 by leokennis on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @03:18PM (#20880499)
Of course one reason you’d want a faster processor is it will “race to idle” faster and increase your battery life (longer life with similar battery / equal life with smaller battery that’s charged quicker):

https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/race-to-sleep

Of course there is an optimum between price, workload and battery life that will differ per person.

Re:Android 10 by makomk on Thursday September 05, 2019 @05:27AM (#20885148)
Race-to-idle only means that it's often more efficient to run a processor designed for a given speed at that speed, complete the task sooner, and then power it down than to run it slower. That's because modern high-speed processors waste a lot of power via leakage just by being turned on. I think it's often still more efficient to design a slower, lower-power processor in the first place, and most modern phones have such processor cores.
Re:Android 10 by thekyle on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @03:47PM (#20870417)
I agree. I recently purchased the Nokia 7.1 on eBay ($200) and it does everything I need in a phone and has nice build quality. I feel that there aren't really many applications that utilize the powerful hardware of modern flagships, so I don't see why I should pay the premium for it.
Re:Android 10 by Scene_Cast2 on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @11:19PM (#20873716)
Depends on what you do with your phone. I noticed that even mobile web pages often lag on my 3-year-old (Snapdragon 820) phone. I noticed that most native apps lag on a 4-year-old Galaxy S6. I'm not sure how well new mid-low tier phones do.
Re:Android 10 by thekyle on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:03AM (#20876765)
That's interesting. My old phone was the OnePlus 3 (I used it up until a few days ago) and it had a Snapdragon 820 running Lineage OS Pie. I can't say I really noticed webpages lagging too bad but I use Firefox with uBlock Origin so that could be it.
Re:Android 10 by chronogram on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @04:29PM (#20881089)
https://i.ibb.co/DK0SB5h/Android-One-Removable-Battery.png

Wow that's really not a lot of phones (just 1) available with Android One and a removable battery.

Re:Android 10 by StreamBright on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:23PM (#20872377)
Do I need to reconfigure the entire OS + all applications after every OS upgrade back how it was prior? One of the main reasons I switched to iOS.
Re:Android 10 by Havoc on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:49PM (#20871005)
Camera on the 1k phone will be better than the 200 phone. Somewhat relevant to the instagram generation...
Re:Android 10 by ProZsolt on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @08:12AM (#20876340)
When phone cameras got reasonably better (Nexus 5X) I started to carry my DSLR less and less and after a while I completely ditched it. I was still clinging to my 5X before the Pixel 3a came out because there wasn't any reasonably priced phone with a decent camera.