Who suffers if the price is quickly adjusted downward by the market? How is that different than it being released at that final market price from the get go? Naively I would think that setting it too high ensures maximum value is captured rather than going to early traders.
So the bank has every incentive to price it low, and usually does. So when the market goes even lower, we know that the IPO was done out of desperation and that early investors who had influence over the IPO price were eager to dump some or all of their positions.
One day is too soon to know for certain that this happened. But if the price is still down a week or two later then it probably did.
How is that the correct conclusion. It sounds like the correct conclusion is they still over estimated the market price. Nothing about desperation for or against.
The bank has every incentive not to do that. The bank must juggle the needs of its various constituencies, preferred investors (who provide capital expecting not to have it lose value right away), the firm (which wants to raise capital) and existing investors (who may want to liquidate).
If a bank routinely over-prices IPOs, then preferred investors will stop providing capital. If the bank routinely under-prices IPOs, then firms will choose other banks to underwrite their IPOs.
In addition to the above, the investment bank owns a lot of inventory and strategically buys and sells in order to help keep the price close to the expected price. When this doesn't happen, it might be because the bank couldn't afford to constrain the price movement and had to settle for the bad optics.
This is how the system is supposed to work, but the main reason an IPO would be over-priced (all things considered) is if the existing investors had too much say in the price, since this tarnishes the bank's credibility for future IPOs events.
I'd be keen to hear why you believe it's "just not right at all."
https://techcrunch.com/2019/04/05/morgan-stanley-which-is-un...
[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-05-07/lyft-s...
Unless these preferred clients are active traders, this isnt a problem. Remember when government nixed fiduciary resposibility?
Just slide a soon-to-drop, over-valued-at-IPO stock into say,... someones' retirement account? Wouldnt it be weird if a bunch or Morgan-Stanley-managed 401Ks were shifted to include that?
Especially if the bank managing the IPO gets a cut of the cash, there's no downside to such. At least for them.
The reality is Uber isn't worth $65-70 today given long term risk. As many others have pointed out opex is well over 150% of revenue. Now that could be fine if the long strategy can reel that in over the next decade. I don't see any of that other than a smattering of "bets" (Uber Eats, scooters, etc). I could very well be wrong but I intentionally didn't buy given what all tech IPOs have done lately. As a consumer who doesn't have the option to get in early I'm at the mercy of the large firms who can take profit off large positions which snowball bringing the valuation back to reality. I think we see more of these "backfires" as people are sick of propping up large financials and more caution around waiting for stocks to settle. If Uber employees expected it to pop north of $50 they're going to be waiting a while. There's no reason to buy now, risk is high that a few large trades sinks the stock into mid $30s or lower territory.
Business Insider had a nice graph that put the valuation into context: https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/uber-technol...
https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2019/04/22/ub...
Doesn't make too much sense to conflate the two.
Logistics is a low margin winner-takes-all industry which is fairly well understood.
Love to see your working on how logistics is winner takes all.
facebook had paying users AND advertisement targets AND an ability for the paying user to precisely target an ad at the product AND an extremely powerful incentive for the product to not move to competition (product's friend network).
out of the above uber has only paying users - who are ready to jump ship to competition for a penny per mile.
Just saying Facebook had 10x the user as Uber is meaningless.
I feel like Uber's biggest revenue generator would be putting a small smartboard in front of passengers and selling targeted ads.
Data isn't valuable. Using that data to create a product that people will pay for is (e.g. showing an ad to someone en route to the restaurants across the street).
Or most likely the driver will agree to put the running gadget in the glove compartment for an off-the-app tip.
"Uber needs to access your microphone to communicate with the information screen"
"I can't communicate with the information screen Dave. It's voice sounds muffled. Have you done something with it?"
The market is convinced building these huge treasuries of consumer data, at any expense in cost and creepiness, will result in wildly better advertising performance. We've given Google and Facebook 12-digit valuations on that principle.
But advertising is a 80/80 problem: You can get to 80% of potential results easily, and spend 80% of your money, effort, and goodwill chasing the rest. Content-based ads (think the early era of Google AdSense when the ads would be text or fall back to PSAs) sell pretty well, considering you didn't need an exabyte of profile data to build them.
Eventually, fundamentals have to come into play-- these companies need the revenue numbers to justify the valuation-- and the only way to get there is to charge premium prices for their advertising services. At that point, the music stops, when advertisers realize the cost-per-acquisition is poor compared to much cheaper, more scattershot technology, or even just earlier stops on the targeting continuum.
(I kid.)
It feels like Uber is a really fucking long way from 33% operating margins.
Sorry, first time that what happened?
$45 was the IPO price, meant it will be the fist time since 2008 that a major IPO closed below its IPO price on the first day of trading.
Really? I was under the impression that closing below your IPO price is quite rare indeed. Do you have other data?
Edit: actually, just saw a NYTimes article with info that it is indeed rare:
Since 2000, only 18 companies valued at more than $1 billion and listing on American exchanges have opened below their I.P.O. price. On average, tech stocks have jumped — or “popped,” in Wall Street parlance — 21 percent on their first day of trading over the past 24 years, according to Dealogic.
2008 has 31 Total IPO’s, restrict that to 1+ billion and you are not talking about a huge list. Restrict that to an unusual few years and it’s easy for an abnormal but meaningless pattern to show up. But, we have no need to make such assumptions.
PS: Facebook is something of an oddity, opening day has technical issues which ended up inflating the price.
The claim was that Uber might be the first major IPO to close below its IPO price that day.
If its not that uncommon then please show me the other major IPO's that traded below their IPO price on the day they went public.
I'll wait :)
Alstom and CIT Group where both top 20 IPO’s of all time and they fell opening day. Several others where up and down at various points in the day. Which is more my point, being down at some point on opening day is fairly common.
And you site an IPO form the 90's? sigh...
If the closing price is below the IPO that is generally regarded as a failure and may imply over-valuation.
Generally regarded by whom* exactly? The world is full of examples of IPOs that did badly on opening day/week but soared like mad afterwards. These generalizations and pretense of knowledge helps no one; especially considering that "over-valued" is not something that can be determined in a short period of time as value is relative to the context in which the asset presents itself.
* as a non-native English speaker, did I use whom correctly or should it be "who"?
Edit: thank you for the reply mr scarejunba!
The goal of the investment bank is to work with the company to come up with a sensible valuation that will clear and pop on the IPO date. The bank has to take into account the market conditions and investor appetite when structuring the trade and setting the price. It is also why you hear of company’s pulling out of IPOs when market conditions are not favourable.
I don’t follow your point exactly, if the value of the asset is relative to the context it presents itself, and the price you set for the IPO is not consistent with the said context, then you are incorrectly valuing the asset. The asset can be under or overvalued.
For the record I have actually worked on IPOs at an investment bank structuring these kind of trades, so it’s not a pretense of knowledge on my part.
It is correct. Object of the sentence. Common mnemonic: whom answered by him/them, who answered by he/they
It reflects badly on the investment bank. But doesn't mean anything about the companies fundamentals or where their stock is going to be in a year. Friend of mine bitched that when his company went IPO the bank priced it low and the result was the bank made a fortune and the companies war chest was smaller than it would have been with a higher initial price.
You used whom correctly, but an English speaker wouldn't notice if you used who either.
Why? There are plenty of examples of equity research analysts pulling no punches on names that the other side of the Chinese wall took public months earlier. And Uber is a classic opportunity for a smart young analyst to get invited on CNBC by throwing some sharply worded shade in their initiating coverage.
Wouldn't someone have to have bought in at $45 and sold for lower in the same day? Why would anyone do this?
http://archive.fortune.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive...
should really start looking at this from the underwriter and issuer perspective to understand the success story here. Retail buys ticker symbols that have been marketed to them. Everyone else dumps. Company made a ton of money and can do whatever it wants with it, they gain nothing from secondary market trading today. VCs, founders and employees can't sell for another 60-90 days, but founders can give themselves big bonuses (and employees too but I mean.. lets be honest)
Thats interesting definition of "literally traded a bunch of shares to underwriters in exchange for $8,100,000,000 and let the underwriters worry about liquidity on the stock exchanges"
Uber has dollars for the shares they sold. Liquidity is not a concern for the party of the transaction I talked about.
Sure, you can argue that the $8.1B is something "real" that the owners of Uber have more of, afterwards.
But you also have to acknowledge that the business of running Uber is also something "real" that the owners of Uber have less of, afterwards, having traded it in a heavily-scrutinized auction.
In this case Uber Inc exchanged illiquid stock for liquid dollars.
Why the semantical debate? Did the use of the word “make” really bother you? What about when there is dilution like in most funding rounds? Shares of equivalent value are literally made. In this IPO Im not sure if that happened with the sale to the underwriters or not.
This kind of asset exchange is what we are all trying to do, exchange one asset for a more liquid one, dollars. They succeeded in doing that to the tune of 8.1 billion usd. The same us dollars that give access to everything in the global financial system via wire transfer.
It's actually a big factor.
> It's actually a big factor.
I assume you are trolling but just in case....
the SPY is now up on the day and Uber is still below its IPO price, so I guess we can put to rest the idea that a down market is a big factor in Uber trading below its IPO price.
SV Unicorn hype aside, there's not a big moat around running a jitney cab company.
- if it closes below $45(its IPO price) it will be the first time since 2008 that the happened for a major IPO
- TD Ameritrade executed more orders in the first 10 minutes of trading than they did for the first 2.5 hours with Lyft.
- Uber is 9% of all trading at TD Ameritrade, retail loves this stock,
- market is down today, which isn't helping Uber but its probably not much of a factor
- Kudos to Citadel, stock opened without a hitch and they seemed to nail the opening price,
- Boo to the underwriters(Morgan Stanley), who seemed to misjudge the market's appetite, important to note that major buyers at IPO, Fidelity and such already had exposure to Uber pre IPO so maybe this staying private longer but selling shares to public fudns had an effect?
https://news.yahoo.com/uber-employees-may-not-partying-15171...
- interesting piece on how Uber has grown its market cap in the past few years at the expense of its share price and how that effects later employees.
- later investors like the Saudi Public Investment Fund can’t be happy with the opening.
- from Bloomberg without comment...."Overheard trader on the floor: “That’s what you get when you don’t make a profit. If you don’t make money, people don’t want to buy you.”
- Biggest IPO since Facebook, that's something to be proud of!!
Date:
- June 4 is expiration of 25-day quiet period for analysts at underwriting banks. Expect bullish initiations on this date
- Nov. 6 expiration of Uber's IPO lockup. Large selling pressure expected to be asserted on this day as is typical for most IPO's.
Personal thought. It may be tough for employee's to not see this pop to say $65-$70 but in the long run its almost certainly better to open flat than to pull a "lyft" and get a first day pop that you price your options at in your head and to then have to cut that price by 40% before you get a chance to sell.
EDIT for comment below.