News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by tim333 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:05AM (#19652780)
I stayed in Guangzhou and was struck by how differently they'd handled housing compared to London or SF. Basically there were a lot of approx 35 story similar tower blocks and most people used public transport/taxis rather than having cars. There's really no reason why London/SF couldn't do that apart from government policy. I live in London and like it but wonder if having all the property being some silly multiple of wages is the best way to do things.

This kind of stuff https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/article/1761639...

You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article and maybe pay out 50% above market to existing buildings in the way so they are not too pissed off but it could be doable.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by rayiner on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:51AM (#19653004)
> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article

It’s amusing to suggest there is “historic stuff” in SF, as there is in China. I saw a “historic” building with a plaque in Palo Alto. It was constructed in the 1900s! Like, after my grandfather was born.

Historical preservation is stealing from the future. If I had my druthers, the opportunity cost of designating buildings or areas as historic would come directly out of the pockets of the preservationists.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by PaulHoule on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:26AM (#19653168)
I dunno.

As an Northeasterner, I am amused at the poor condition of single-story commercial buildings in California, particularly Los Angeles.

You don't see many buildings of that type built before 1970, particularly in New England, because they are poorly built and the roof starts to leak at some point. In the Northeast that is reason to rebuild, in LA you can probably manage a leaky roof with a bucket for much longer.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by jvagner on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:33AM (#19653564)
I love LA, was born there.. have moved in and out of the place a dozen times in my life. I don't live there now, but I visit often, and I am drawn tor return again, permanently.

I've always said that LA is beautiful at night, and pretty ugly during the day. That can be more or less true depending where in LA you're looking, but some of my favorite places in LA are absolutely hideous by the light of the day. But after dusk, same places can be magical.

Some of those old houses are built really beautifully, but there were a lot of shanty buildings that have been patched and patched. But some of the trees between those shanties are old and gorgeous. Somehow it works, but it's not a model for anything else.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by nugator on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:17PM (#19655159)
Please give some examples of your favourite/magical places in LA! (As a foreigner I've gotten the impression that LA is a huge superficial city without a soul. Would like to balance that with something else.)
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by kaz_kaz_kaz on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:05PM (#19655721)
I've lived in LA for many years. The impression of superficiality might come from people expecting LA to be one city, when it is actually many cities with their own downtown and culture centers. Also, visitors tend to drive too much, which isolates them to touristy areas.

Some of my favorites:

1. Old Town Pasadena 2. Baldwin hill Overlook 3. Little Tokyo and Sawtelle 4. San Gabriel / Alhambra (Chinese food) 5. Signal Hill / Downtown Long Beach 6. Melrose and the area near Laurel Canyon

I could go on, but really there's gems everywhere. I've found that LA is more so a place you live than a place you visit, despite it's reputation otherwise. It's packed to to the brim with artists, developers, and good food, and there's space to stretch.

Not really hacking news, but file this under lifestyle.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by enjo on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:55PM (#19656574)
I’m moving out of LA and this post highlights why. Yep those places are great. In a typical Angelenos year they’ll see maybe one of them. None of those things are near each other. The ones that are sort of close are in reality an hour+ apart because of traffic.

I have friends scattered throughout the city and we never see each other. Even the ones who live just a few miles away don’t want to leave their neighborhoods ever because.... traffic.

My dream job is in LA. I love the idea of LA, just don’t like living here. That’s just me tho, lots of people do really love it :)

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by idontpost on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:26PM (#19657416)
> That’s just me tho, lots of people do really love it :)

And the rest of them are still sitting in their packed U-Hauls in traffic on the Sepulveda pass.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sizzle on Sunday April 14, 2019 @06:21AM (#19658517)
Where are you headed to with less traffic?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by enjo on Friday April 19, 2019 @04:56PM (#19702935)
Back home to Denver. Where I can live in a place that affords me the chance to walk to everything, something there just isn't much of in Los Angeles.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by aphextron on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:04PM (#19655717)
Werner Herzog describes LA as “the city with the most substance anywhere on earth”. The thing with LA is that it can be anything. It’s so huge, and so diverse that you can find absolutely anything your heart desires there if you seek it out. There is the superficial glamour of Hollywood, but also the high tech cutting edge manufacturing of aerospace, endless immigrant communities from every corner of the world, every food imaginable, even family friendly enclaves of community. LA requires that you know what you are doing and what you want; it wont drop anything in your lap. But the heights of experience to be had there are like nowhere else.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sologoub on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:21PM (#19655816)
Don’t forget that to experience all this wonderful stuff you have to contend with one of the worlds worst traffic problems.

I called LA home for two decades and the transportation hell largely kept me in my general community. Going to Pasadena from the Westside is a full day commitment, unless you leave at sunrise on a Sunday.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by StudentStuff on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:13PM (#19656656)
Big mood, 3+hrs each way in traffic is hellish :c
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by jvagner on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:08PM (#19655742)
Thanks, I don't think I can say it better.

When I lived there, it was best to live/work/play in adjacent neighborhoods, and then explore as you found yourself available the rest of the time.

I do love the global diversity aspect of it.

But I sympathize with those who didn't like it.. it's a really easy town to "miss" on.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by verelo on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:24PM (#19655510)
+1. I wish i could love LA the way some do, all my experiences have been pretty gross and i have zero desire to return.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by mixmastamyk on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:00PM (#19656840)
Two big factors are among the causes:

- Majority of city (outside old towns) built after WWII with an emphasis on brutalist 60s suburbia.

- Prop 13 and the NIMBY revolution that cemented it in for the long haul.

It's only in the last five years or so that extreme economic pressure has enabled new buildings over two stories (gasp) to be built outside downtown, while NIMBYs scream bloody murder.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by village-idiot on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:50PM (#19657287)
Proper 13 was California’s biggest mistake.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by rb808 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:54PM (#19655357)
My best quote from a friend coming towards the end of the drought: "There 8 year old kids in LA that have never seen it rain"
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by peteretep on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:14AM (#19653111)
> It’s amusing to suggest there is “historic stuff” in SF, as there is in China

It’s amusing to suggest there’s historic stuff in China, as there is in Europe. I saw a “historic” building in China. It was constructed in 1600s! Like, 400 years after the bar I used to work in started.

It’s amusing to suggest there’s historic stuff in Europe, as there is in Egypt. I saw a “historic” building in the UK. It was constructed in the 900s! Like, 4,000 years after the pyramids were built!

etc etc etc

That there’s older shit elsewhere doesn’t remove the historicity of anywhere else

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by baybal2 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:23AM (#19653153)
Before the revolution, Chinese used to count years in eras. Very few Chinese indeed knew how old the country was, except on a level like "Yellow emperor and co." lived a horrificly long time ago.

To most, that was making the impression that "time is not actually going," and that people lived exactly like it was today for millennia. There was little regard for "historical things" outside of microscopically small class of educated elites.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by pishpash on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:49PM (#19654554)
This is a good point, because time is perceived to be not moving, nothing is actually historical.

The preservation impulse perks up with change.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by 0815test on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:29AM (#19653187)
They still do that kind of thing in Japan. Indeed, the Japanese "era" is due to switch over when the reigning emperor's abdication becomes effective in May 2019.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ascar on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:59AM (#19653353)
It's different today though. While the historically famous Edo period lasted 265 years, today the periods just end when an emperors reign ends. They are also counting years (today, not sure if they did earlier). E.g. 2018 is 平成30年 (Heisei year 30).
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by jpatokal on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:37PM (#19654865)
You're mixing up eras and reigns. The "Edo period" refers to the years when the shogunate ruled from Edo (today's Tokyo), during which there were over a dozen (notionally) reigning emperors:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Timeline_of_Japanese_...

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ascar on Sunday April 14, 2019 @04:02AM (#19658133)
Thank you. Didn't know that :) I misinterpreted stuff there
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by gumby on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:47AM (#19653280)
It doesn't affect your daily life much any more though. Those eras used to change when super significant events happened but now they are simply tied to emperors. The same system still applies in the UK where laws are numbered by the year of the reign of the then-current monarch, but I doubt anyone outside the parliament and law profession pays any attention.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by laretluval on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:41PM (#19656511)
China lacks many old buildings because historically things were built from wood, not stone, and wood burns.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by csomar on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:44PM (#19656527)
> Historical preservation is stealing from the future.

No, it is not. SF problem can be fixed with a few blocks. A 35 stories building with 1 bed-room condos can host up to 700-1000 persons. I'd bet lots of SF tech developers will opt for a very small high tech condo with amenities (pool, gym, library...) than the crap that is right now.

Say you build a hundred of these. That's 100K person and more than 10% of the population of San Fransisco. You plot the land 10 miles south of the downtown. You make a fast, efficient and new subway that connect from the plot to the downtown.

It is easy considering that the Chinese, Korean, and Japanese are doing it everyday. SF has the money, land and tech to do it.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by StudentStuff on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:09PM (#19656631)
Rather than building housing way outside the city center and building expensive transit to it, upzoning around current transit would be a better use of the resources we already have.

A 35 story building's residents will make much greater use of existing mass transit when located within 3 blocks of said transit than existing low rise development will.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by rayiner on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:44PM (#19657488)
Remember that it costs the US $2.5 billion per mile to build subway now in a city like SF. That’s $250,000 per person in capital costs alone to build that subway, not including the money-losing operation of it. SF has the land, money, and tech, but not the political and moral discipline to do it like the Japanese, Chinese, or Koreans.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by csomar on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:12AM (#19658013)
$2.5bn/mile? Euh, sorry, I don't think it costs this much. "Get your shit together", the world will not wait. There is a reason why I go vacationing in SEA and not in Europe despite proximity.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by yourapostasy on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:59AM (#19658127)
The crazy part is partly we don't know for sure why it costs this much in the every US project [1]. A deep dive into details shows a thicket of intertwingled challenges [2] that are solvable by goring an army of oxen.

[1] https://www.marketplace.org/2019/04/11/economy/subways-US-ex...

[2] https://pedestrianobservations.com/2019/03/03/why-american-c...

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by rak00n on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:26PM (#19661175)
What's the reason?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by incompatible on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:03PM (#19656606)
Are blocks of 35 story buildings the best that can be done? Perhaps some of the arcology designs from historical urban design and scifi could be tried instead.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by csomar on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:09AM (#19658001)
Sure. But you don't need that. You can do what people around the world have already done and there is ready tech for that.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by incompatible on Sunday April 14, 2019 @05:55AM (#19658443)
Yes, I guess we should prefer to go with tried and tested solutions and never try anything new. Now where did I leave my abacus?

It will be interesting to see which cities do the best in future: the ones that try to house large numbers of people at low cost? The ones that are quickest to adopt new ideas? The ones where billionaires prefer to live? Who knows.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by csomar on Sunday April 14, 2019 @06:05AM (#19658470)
That's not what I'm saying. The best is to try new innovative ideas. But if you are in a hurry and your house is a mess, at least start with the traditional house cleaning and then move from there.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by incompatible on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:35PM (#19657214)
As an aside, the building with the largest floor space is also found in China, the "New Century Global Center". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PJwc4fL_rpo
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by dehrmann on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:50PM (#19656799)
> A 35 stories building with 1 bed-room condos can host up to 700-1000 persons. I'd bet lots of SF tech developers will opt for a very small high tech condo with amenities (pool, gym, library...) than the crap that is right now.

Sure, but you'll induce demand. As SF prices drop, think of all the people who will move in from (mostly) the East Bay. Prices will drop, but not nearly as much as you think without 100,000 units.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by maxander on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:17PM (#19656905)
Well, if prices don't drop, those 100k people will be paying something like a billion a year in rent (and/or condo mortgages,) making it probably one of the most high-return investments possible. There's not really a downside.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by landryraccoon on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:58PM (#19656826)
That drops rent in the East Bay too so I don’t see the problem. And there’s no way prices in SF don’t drop at all with that’s much construction.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by siruncledrew on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:54PM (#19657296)
35 stories is not even that tall for buildings in Guangzhou: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_G...
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:06PM (#19656620)
Those buildings are tall and skinny, they aren’t hosting 700-1000 people on 35 floors, I’d guess the number is more likely to be around 3 or 4 hundred, serviced by two elevators.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by StudentStuff on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:11PM (#19656640)
Tall and skinny buildings are creatures created by zoning. We can build wider and taller, but in the US most cities have zoned higher square footage buildings away with setbacks & allowances based on height and depth, forcing developers to build skinny or shrink the width of the building as it rises.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:06PM (#19657343)
I’m talking China, not the USA. A big slab of a tall building is something that was done in the 60s but is hardly done anymore. Tall and skinny works much better in balancing residential space with a couple of elevators and a staircase.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by londons_explore on Sunday April 14, 2019 @12:11PM (#19660200)
Wide buildings lead to rooms without windows which most people don't like.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by throwaway2048 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:19PM (#19656678)
there is much more pent up demand than that, even 100k units wouldn't budge prices much.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by andrewem on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:41PM (#19657476)
As a rough estimate, Wikipedia says the SF area's population is roughly 8-9 million, depending on how you count. If you assume that each new unit would house 2 people, that's enough to house about 2% of the current population. (I have no idea how to estimate the effect of that on prices.)
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:50PM (#19654559)
> If I had my druthers, the opportunity cost of designating buildings or areas as historic would come directly out of the pockets of the preservationists.

The easiest way to do this would be to require consent of the current owner to designate a building as historic.

Then if you want to designate a building as historic but you don't actually want to own it, no problem, you buy the building, designate it as historic and then sell it again. The difference in value before and after comes out of your pocket.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by londons_explore on Sunday April 14, 2019 @12:14PM (#19660221)
Buildings are movable.

Require a bond be put up to cover the cost of moving the historic building out of the city, so the land can be used for modern construction.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by dragonwriter on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:33AM (#19653565)
> Historical preservation is stealing from the future.

Historical preservation is sacrificing for the future. It's literally the exact opposite of stealing from the future

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:01PM (#19654627)
It's binding the hands of future generations. Once something is designated a historic, it's hard to undo, even if the opportunity cost tomorrow is much higher than it is today.

It's also cumulative. There is a finite amount of land. If you designate another 1% of it as historic each year, a hundred years later you're locked in stasis.

There is a reason for the rule against perpetuities.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by moorhosj on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:23PM (#19655822)
If you destroy something today, you have also binded the hands of a future generation who will never get to enjoy it. Most of the popular vacation places in the world are historic/old sites. If we tear down everything old to put up cheaper, more efficient buildings are we necessarily better off?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by TheOperator on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:32PM (#19656166)
If we took things to the absolute extreme and tore it all down? Yes we would be better off. I don't think the current value of historic sites outweighs the deadweight. This is coming from a North American perspective though.

It wouldn't be the best option but the sites that have survived a hundred of years didn't survive because some legal mandate dictated it. It's because they were buildings built to last.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by moorhosj on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:44PM (#19657261)
You are right that this is a very American perspective. Maybe we could learn something from societies that have been around much longer and tend to care more about their past.

==It wouldn't be the best option but the sites that have survived a hundred of years didn't survive because some legal mandate dictated it. It's because they were buildings built to last.==

Or they have historical value specifically because they were built to last. Obviously, we wouldn’t know that unless we allow them to last.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by TheOperator on Sunday April 14, 2019 @11:08PM (#19662917)
Caring about the past is not the same as paying for the upkeep of a historic museum that costs as much as 3 museums when the historic museum was actually kind of a dump. The status quo is goddamned rediculous.

If I had to choose my position it would be less broad protection of historic buildings. However if I have to choose one extreme or the other I see homelessness exploding where I live and a bunch of money spent on bullshit. We're not talking about preserving the Sistine Chapel here.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by gridlockd on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:05PM (#19656328)
> Most of the popular vacation places in the world are historic/old sites.

No, they're the remains of historic/old sites that were left after people of yore tore down everything else to build anew.

You don't have to preserve 100% of the "old city" to get a glimpse into an era, just like you don't have to preserve 100% of the city wall just to show that once upon a time, city walls were a thing.

> If we tear down everything old to put up cheaper, more efficient buildings are we necessarily better off?

You don't have to tear down everything in San Francisco, but most of it has little to no "historic value".

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by moorhosj on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:40PM (#19657236)
Not everything is about San Francisco, even if HN wants to think otherwise. Plenty of other cities have historic buildings with their own value, Chicago bungalows are an example. They represent a point in time and are still viable structures for today’s families.

Places like Cinque Terra, Istanbul and Cartagena are popular specifically because they have been preserved and are not just remains.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by gridlockd on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:05AM (#19657699)
> Not everything is about San Francisco, even if HN wants to think otherwise.

Perhaps, but if we're talking about bulldozing and rebuilding the place to get rent down, San Francisco is at the top of the list.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by moorhosj on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:33PM (#19660593)
Or you could build higher. For reference, San Fran has 26 skyscrapers and 900k people. Chicago has 123 skyscrapers and 2.7 million people.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by dragonwriter on Sunday April 14, 2019 @11:47AM (#19660060)
> It's binding the hands of future generations.

That's true in the sense the statement is true of every human action.

> Once something is designated a historic, it's hard to undo

Only because there is widespread support for the general idea of historical preservation; it's usually not more difficult than reverding or passing a normal law to either eliminate a particular designation or an entire system of historic preservation.

People who find it difficult do so not because their hands are tied by the past, but because their hands are tied by their present opposition.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by PeterisP on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:05PM (#19656330)
Once something is designated as historic, it's exactly as easy or hard to undo as the future generations want it - you're not binding their hands; you're binding hands of this generation so that the next ones can make the choice whether to continue preserving that particular thing or not.

Once something is destroyed, though, that is impossible to undo, no matter what the future generations would want.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:29AM (#19658052)
> Once something is designated as historic, it's exactly as easy or hard to undo as the future generations want it - you're not binding their hands; you're binding hands of this generation so that the next ones can make the choice whether to continue preserving that particular thing or not.

In exactly the same sense you're not binding current generations either.

The issue is that it's a lot easier to get something designated as historical than to get it undesignated as such or to change the process in order to make it easier.

Moreover, changing it is hard because it's a complicated issue that the large majority of people don't really care about and a concentrated special interest group (landlords who want to retain high rents) does care about and doesn't want changed.

Unless you expect that dynamic to change significantly over time, you're binding the future as much as the present.

> Once something is destroyed, though, that is impossible to undo, no matter what the future generations would want.

That is true of all action and inaction. You can't change the past once it has already happened.

You have to choose for them whether the future gets the old buildings or the new buildings. If it turns out the old buildings are worse, e.g. because continued high rents cause lasting economic damage to the region, you can't undo that either.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by mac01021 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:11PM (#19654307)
I tend to agree, but this assumes that the thing preserved will be valued going forward. If someone's fundament values are not such that they see any benefit in preservation of an old statehouse or whatever, this won't be a compelling argument.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by jdhn on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:42AM (#19653256)
>Historical preservation is stealing from the future.

There definitely needs to be more barriers when it comes to designating places and areas as historical, but this is a pretty harsh take.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by nitrogen on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:33AM (#19653563)
I do think there is some legitimacy to the view, though. It's a bit like saying that no future people could ever do something more important or more interesting with a location than what was done by someone long in the past.

Especially in a world with a growing population and increasing centralization, there will be fewer and fewer opportunities for individuals from new generations to do new things.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by taysic on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:39AM (#19653600)
Though I’m not impressed by much of modern architecture... I guess it comes down to personal taste for some.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by throwawayjava on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:50PM (#19654556)
This doesn't really have anything to do with architecture. No one is arguing that newer buildings look nicer than older buildings. The new buildings won't be historical landmarks, and will probably also be bulldozed when they outlive their usefulness.

The argument is being able to look at some court house built in 1925 is not more important than people in 2018 (and forever into the future) having more affordable places to live.

I tend to agree that the "no historical preservation" viewpoint is way overblown. E.g., there are lots of monuments and buildings in Boston and Philly that should always be preserved because they are integral to telling the nation's founding story. But there are lot of "historical landmarks/buildings" in the USA that are really only significant to the handful of people who pushed to make them "historical" (and are probably now dead anyways).

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by skissane on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:31PM (#19656160)
> The argument is being able to look at some court house built in 1925 is not more important than people in 2018 (and forever into the future) having more affordable places to live.

A compromise can be converting the court house into apartments or offices, so that it can have contemporary use but at the same time some aspects of its historic appearance are preserved (such as its façade). Of course, other parts of its historical value are going to be lost – it is likely impossible to maintain the historical integrity of the actual court rooms in the process of converting the building into offices or apartments – but it is still better than knocking down the building entirely.

I used to live around the corner from an old water pump house converted to offices. When they switched from coal-fired pumps to electrical ones, suddenly the amount of space consumed by the pumps shrunk dramatically. So they removed all the boilers and turned it into office space instead. Part of me wishes the boilers had stayed, but it is better than knocking down the building entirely.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by throwawayjava on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:54PM (#19656567)
Sure. The answer will be different for different buildings. See the grading system in https://www.citylab.com/perspective/2019/02/tax-credit-histo...
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by loktarogar on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:08AM (#19653416)
Australia as a country was founded in 1901, so there's plenty of historic stuff from that era over here (it was only settled by europeans 113 years before that, so there's a very small window for historic buildings)
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by stevekemp on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:28PM (#19653945)
Similar story here in Finland. Officially the country is 100 years old, but of course people have been living here for much longer than that. Sadly there is little evidence of them though, because they built their houses from wood.

By contrast the city I grew up in, York, had stone walls that are ~2000 years old. The next city I lived, Edinburgh, has some proper-old buildings too. e.g. The Royal mile contains buildings from the 12th century, and I regularly used to drink in pubs that were 600-800 years old.

In short "old" is relative.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by andrewem on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:49PM (#19657502)
My favorite historical thing in York was seeing the Roman foundations under the cathedral (York Minster). You can see a similar thing next to the cathedral in Leon, Spain (whose name came from "legio" for Legion, since it was originally a Roman army camp, rather than "Leon" meaning "lion" as it's called now.)
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ajmurmann on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:26AM (#19653519)
I think you are adding to their point. To people from Europe or Asia that's just not even a historic timescale.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by loktarogar on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:06PM (#19654268)
I'm saying that just because something isn't that old relatively, doesn't mean it doesn't have historical value. There's definitely some historic buildings in australia, especially from colonial time.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sgt101 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:07PM (#19653807)
On the other hand, once it's not preserved the future never gets to see it. So you could say that the cultural cost of removing the past should come out of the pockets of the developers.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by TheOperator on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:37PM (#19656189)
Which in turn gets passed on to the tenants who have to pay a bunch of money because gamgam insisted that it would culture future generations to be able to look at an old courthouse.

If everybody just left a historic building alone it would just decay into disrepair. If somebody is not using the location it has no value. The people going around designating every building that stays standing beyond a certain number of years historic causing said land to go underutilized need to pay some of the cost. The status quo is overbroad.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by michaelmrose on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:27PM (#19655214)
Historic value is what out of the multitude of current things that people in the future find worth keeping.

The only way to tax "historic value" would be to put a sliding scale tax on things in proportion to their subjective quality and incentivize garbage that nobody thinks anyone will want 20 years from now.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by BurningFrog on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:01PM (#19655050)
There are some things that should genuinely be historically preserved.

But overwhelmingly it is a pretext for NIMBYism as part of the overall strategy for always having an excuse to not build anything anywhere.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by thatfrenchguy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:30AM (#19653541)
Yeah let’s destroy all the cute neighborhoods which makes San Francisco one of the only beautiful cities in the US, and forget about prop 13.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by CPLX on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:14PM (#19653856)
Nothing says cute like endless streets defined completely by garage doors at the ground level.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by jlarocco on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:36PM (#19654856)
LOL! There's nothing more beautiful than a homeless guy taking a dump in the middle of the side walk.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by vecinu on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:02PM (#19654635)
I don't find SF that beautiful, everything around it on the other hand is amazing (Golden Gate bridge, Golden Gate park, the Presidio and further away like the Marin Headlands/Sausalito etc..)
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by jjjensen90 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:14PM (#19654705)
There are many, many beautiful cities and towns in the US. San Francisco is not one of them, if you mean the actual city.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by friedman23 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:37PM (#19654485)
San Francisco is a very ugly city.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by bitwize on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:27PM (#19655524)
Sounds like someone hasn't been to San Francisco 2, aka Portland, OR.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by drharby on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:05PM (#19653793)
Bostons a cute little city and i quite love the beauty of little mountain hamlets in colorado, thank you very much
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by dragonwriter on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:01AM (#19653364)
> There's really no reason why London/SF couldn't do that apart from government policy. I live in London and like it but wonder if having all the property being some silly multiple of wages is the best way to do things.

But Guangzhou has a much higher property price to income ratio than either London or SF. So, the policy you suggest doesn't fix the problem you raise.

https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/Guangzhou

https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/San-Francisco

https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/London

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by evancox100 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:39PM (#19656501)
But the higher prices in Guangzhou could be due to a much higher "maximal use" value from allowing denser development. If the property is 2x as expensive but holds 6x as many units (30 story tower in article vs typical 5 story American midrise), then that's a win. That type of cookie cutter high rise is very common in many Chinese cities. They will plop down several of these towers in the same area, typically 10+ stories, with few burdensome restrictions on parking and elevators. Can't speak to London, but I was blown away when visiting SF just how little dense development there was in most of the city, and how little new construction there was even of midrise buildings.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by geodel on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:46PM (#19657017)
I believe it is per unit price not the whole building. It would be like family with 30 grand/year going for million dollar home. In China's case if would be an apartment accommodating 3-4 whereas in US it would be a large home in 99% of areas which are at max 20 miles from a city.

I lived in city of Mumbai, India where median income is about $3K per annum and median apartment price is would be about $200K.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by reaperducer on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:57AM (#19653339)
There's really no reason why London/SF couldn't do that apart from government policy.

Well, that "government policy" is the will of the taxpayers and voters who want to decide what happens to the city they live in and not just accept that living conditions imposed upon them by some bureaucrat. People in Guangzhou may be accustomed to living in Sim City, but that's not how it works in a democracy.

Personally, I've been to all three cities, and I wouldn't want to live in Guangzhou, compared to London or San Francisco.

People aren't robots to be warehoused.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by TACIXAT on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#19653387)
You frame nimbyism and protectionist housing policies as the will of the people, but I'd take a Chinese city with clean air over 3400 / month in a second. SF housing is broken, I would not put it on a pedestal of being some grand embodyment of democracy.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:55AM (#19653710)
The only Chinese city with clean air is Xiamen. It is a nice place, but you might have trouble getting the right job.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by imjustsaying on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:24PM (#19654772)
>The only Chinese city with clean air is Xiamen.

I was about to disagree but I just looked it up and it seems to be doing a lot better than I remembered.

http://pm25.in/xiamen

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:35PM (#19654854)
Xiamen has geographical benefits, lots of wind blowing any pollution out into the ocean. Not to mention that they have a lot of nice colonial architecture as well.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by reaperducer on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:13AM (#19653442)
I'd take a Chinese city with clean air over 3400 / month in a second.

So go ahead. No one is stopping you.

SF housing is broken

I don't disagree, and that's also the case in most large cities these days.

I would not put it on a pedestal of being some grand embodyment of democracy.

I don't think it's grand, but I think there's more value to it than current generations understand.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ComputerGuru on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:27AM (#19653521)
> that's also the case in most large cities these days.

Chicago, as always, begs to differ. But no one notices it, it always flies under the radar which probably contributes to it's success in this regard.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by mylons on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:21PM (#19654754)
Chicago, and more importantly IL at large, is broken. The state gov is one of the most corrupt in the country. 4 out of the last 6 or 7 governors have went to jail. Dennis Hastert comes out of the IL political machinery. State employees pension funds will likely bankrupt the state as the taxbase shrinks. The job prospects for most engineers are limited. I grew up there and wouldn't move back.

https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/editorials/ct-ed...

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by nitrogen on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:42AM (#19653631)
I've only visited Chicago once and really enjoyed it, but I suspect its reputation, whether vaild or not, for crime, cold, and corruption serves as a rate limiter on migration to the city.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by notfromhere on Monday April 15, 2019 @10:54AM (#19665764)
Chicago has a nice balance between QoL and CoL; I don't see the huge appeal of moving to the bay when most of it is just overgrown suburb and living costs are out of control
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by 121789 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:01PM (#19656307)
I moved to SF from Chicago and agree that the value for money is nuts there (I loved Chicago), but the extended winter, isolated nature, and the fact that it isn't really destination city for any industry puts pretty hard limits on how much people will pay.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ShorsHammer on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:36PM (#19657217)
> So go ahead. No one is stopping you.

There's some sort of open border policy between the US and China?

Seems like a lot of effort simply to live somewhere with reasonable housing policies.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by evancox100 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:41PM (#19656510)
That's absurd, there are plenty of large cities doing relatively ok keeping housing costs in line. Try visiting San Antonio, Dallas, or Houston, 3 of the 10 largest cities in the US that are quite affordable.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by nitrogen on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:39AM (#19653597)
People aren't robots to be warehoused.

Heh, that's how I would describe much of the SF market in comparison to the (better designed subset of) suburbs. An apartment in SF that is anything more than a place to park one's sleeping corpse is quite expensive.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by zanny on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:40PM (#19654901)
I'd massively prefer to live on the 25th floor of block apartments with public transit access for $100 a month than to have no such option and be forced to toil a quarter of my adult life to have way more space than I want or need.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by BurningFrog on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:03PM (#19655058)
But what if, compared to London or San Francisco, places like Guangzhou are the only places normal people can afford to live in?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by crdb on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:00AM (#19653050)
> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article and maybe pay out 50% above market to existing buildings in the way so they are not too pissed off but it could be doable.

Already exists, see e.g. Croydon. Yes, not in Zone 1, but 14 minutes to London Bridge by Thameslink, about the same time it took me to go from South Kensington to Westminster/St James in the early 2000s and probably without having to wait out a couple trains at rush hour due to lack of space within.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by lazyjones on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:41AM (#19652957)
> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article and maybe pay out 50% above market to existing buildings in the way so they are not too pissed off but it could be doable.

And, presumably, they'd be as cheap as possible, leading to higher probability of hazards like at Grenfell Tower?

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by baybal2 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:25AM (#19653166)
Read the backstory. Isocyanate foam maker lobbied cheaper rockwool makers out of the country in UK, with all blessings from the "elites"
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sgt101 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:18PM (#19653874)
24 floors (like Grenfell) will not happen again in London - at least in our lifetimes, foam or no foam, bad redesign or no redesign or one staircase or two. High residential is gone. On the other hand 8 to 12 floors is pretty dense and requires less surrounding space and infrastructure so works out quite well.

What's needed in London is a change in the development law that mandates 3 good sized bedrooms, two baths and one large living / cooking area. This would provide liveable accommodation for families and would chop out the drivers for a house at any cost.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by holoduke on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:06PM (#19655732)
No a law is needed that prevent foreign individuals or other entities owning lots of property for the sole purpose of renting it out. Half of London is currently owned by them. And the normale working class is barely capable of paying the rent
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sgt101 on Sunday April 14, 2019 @06:12AM (#19658490)
I agree about that law, Private Eye [1] has done a great job in making the facts about property ownership in the UK more transparent, I find it particularly abhorrent that property is being used for money laundering and tax evasion draining money away from some of the most needy in the world and then as a secondary effect making life difficult for average people in London and SE England.

Actually buying to rent, while bad, isn't the biggest issue. Buying to speculate and drive up prices to flip for a cheap buck while driving others with less capital into penury is. The only good thing that Osbourne got through was the new taxes on property transactions, I think we need more - especially a tax on transactions done in quick succession. If there was a premium on a property being sold (say 5% of the transaction price) less than 24mths after it had previously been sold I think that would kill speculation stone dead.

[1] http://www.private-eye.co.uk/registry

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by icebraining on Sunday April 14, 2019 @07:04AM (#19658640)
So they'll need to create a bunch of shell companies?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sgt101 on Sunday April 14, 2019 @11:52AM (#19660101)
In the era of graph databases that doesn't work so well as it used to if transparency laws are set properly.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by tim333 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:16AM (#19653465)
I was thinking more medium quality. A lot of London stuff seems to either be bad council construction or £1m+ extra lux.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by tonyedgecombe on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:07AM (#19653408)
The council spent quite a lot of money on Grenfell tower, I seem to remember it worked out at £66K per flat.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by nine_k on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:57PM (#19656823)
Moscow did a very similar thing in 1990s and 2000s, allowing to build huge swathes of 25-32 story buildings. It allowed for quite accessible mortgages, with the cost of the buildings being moderate.

It did allow for significant growth. It also put a lot of strain on public transportation.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by drugme on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:47PM (#19654945)
It isn't a simple matter of "paying people" to get them out of their homes. You have to force them out via eminent domain. And not only that, rewrite your laws to extend the powers of eminent domain well beyond their current scope -- which in most jurisdictions almost certainly do not cover the scale of forced redevelopment and mass evictions you are imagining.

You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas

These neighborhoods aren't "nondescript" to people who have been living there for generations. And your apparent obliviousness to this central fact goes to the heart of the matter of why redevelopment politics are so contentious in many cities.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by BurningFrog on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:56PM (#19655014)
> It isn't a simple matter of "paying people" to get them out of their homes. You have to force them out via eminent domain.

Nonsense.

If zoning was changed so large housing buildings became legal, existing home owners in prime locations could become very rich selling to skyscraper developers. Or even build tall buildings of their own.

All experience indicates that people with a chance to become very rich will take that chance.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by drugme on Monday April 15, 2019 @09:42AM (#19665211)
Nonsense.

You can say it's "nonsense" if you want.

But the simple fact is, this idea you apparently have -- that a developer can deterministically "buy people" out of their property (or rental status), even assuming that that it had adequate capital on hand -- is just not how this stuff works.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by chillacy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:13PM (#19655786)
I think it's everyone around who complains when the new skyscraper blocks their ocean view they paid $200k for in extra home equity.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by didibus on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:41PM (#19654070)
> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article

You mean like the Projects?

I feel like that's been done before and failed.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by dmoy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:28PM (#19654421)
Projects failed for a lot of reasons, not simply because they were high density housing.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sologoub on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:28PM (#19655835)
To make these liveable, you have to have very strong central planning. Many former/currently communist cities look like this with varying height.

In Moscow for example, new apartments tend to be 25-40 stories high. However, they have large offsets from the street, are not built “shoulder to shoulder” with neighbors and generally developments from inner courtyards that are big enough to have parking and a soccer field.

There’s also a phenomenon of what locals call “pinpoint development”, where some unscrupulous developer will try to stick a tower in these courtyards and ruin the setup for everyone.

Contrast that with SF or NYC - you hardly have open plots of lands and everything is one giant wall of buildings.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by writeslowly on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:57PM (#19656286)
NYC does this through zoning regulations. Older buildings were typically designed with setbacks [1]. After zoning code changes in the 1960s most buildings became tall boxes attached to open plazas or low rise buildings instead.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Zoning_Resolution

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by sologoub on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:50AM (#19657962)
NYC doesn’t really accomplish this. Take a look at Google maps satellite view and you’ll see a huge difference.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by microcolonel on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:05AM (#19653070)
Of course, if you had to deal with the incredibly poor quality of this housing for much time, you'd probably change your mind.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by reaperducer on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:02AM (#19653372)
I'm not sure why you're being downvoted. The construction quality in mainland China is terrible.

I've witnessed a lot of it, myself, but this video was posted on HN a couple of days ago:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XopSDJq6w8E

As bad as that is, it only scratches the surface because they didn't actually go inside any of the buildings. It would be unimaginable for a building outside of the Chinese bubble to literally start collapsing upon itself after standing on its own for only three years.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ubercow13 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:42AM (#19653630)
The quality of housing many people can afford in London can be pretty terrible too, in its own way
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by microcolonel on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:01PM (#19653762)
The typical quality of newly constructed housing in these regions of mainland China is illegal in London, and increasingly alien to even the most wretched Londoner.

It was international news when there was a serious fire in a tower recently in London, it's not news at all in some places.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ubercow13 on Thursday April 18, 2019 @01:06AM (#19688863)
Yes, of course safety is not comparable and is paramount in importance. However just in terms of the day-to-day experience of living in these places - I'm not so sure London has an obvious advantage.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by mr_toad on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:49AM (#19657793)
How many of your politicians national and local own multiple residential properties?

If England is like New Zealand guess it’s close to 100%

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by madengr on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:41AM (#19652958)
Soviet bloc housing; no thanks. That is the end result of government policy.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by mikeash on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:06AM (#19653078)
The difference is that nobody would be forcing you to live in one.

Note that sprawling suburbs with identical single family houses and lawns controlled to the inch by HOAs are also the end result of government policy.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by reaperducer on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:03AM (#19653382)
HOA's are, quite literally, not government. They're an association of home owners.

They sometimes act like government, but are still very limited in scope and power. And a good HOA or condo association (there are some) is even better than a government.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by wongarsu on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:13AM (#19653443)
They are not The Government, but they govern various areas relating to the homes and lifes of the people living under them. Since they govern, they are a government. Being limited in scope and power is irrelevant, unless you try to also claim US states don't have a government.

Not entirely related but illustrating the point: an HOA is surprisingly similar to a local government: they approve or deny building requests, compel property owners to pay a share of common expenses (in other contexts called taxes), issue fines for violating "laws", hold elections, etc.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by tathougies on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:08AM (#19653419)
Of course they are government. If you don't pay their fee, they can evict you. They are the only agency able to do this, despite having no lien on the house. That makes them a government, whether you like it or not
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by reaperducer on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:11AM (#19653436)
If you don't pay their fee, they can evict you.

And that's why I wrote that they act like a government. But unlike a government, you can move away from the HOA's project and not be under its thumb. To escape government, you have to buy a ship and anchor it in the middle of the ocean.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by tathougies on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:13AM (#19653445)
So the government of California is not a government because you can move to Nevada? Have you thought about what you're claiming? Is the government of London not a government because you can move to Birmingham?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by skellera on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:59PM (#19655391)
No need to take it so literally. Moving to the next development or town over is different from moving out of a country or state.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by tathougies on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:40PM (#19655571)
So yes... City governments are not governments because you can just move to the neighboring city. Redefining words is fun!!
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by quotemstr on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:14AM (#19653456)
Governments are associations of citizens --- well, at least the ones that aren't despotic. HOAs are, well, private governments. That might seem like a contradiction in terms, but it really isn't.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ajmurmann on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:38AM (#19653592)
What makes one of them private and the other one isn't? Aren't all governments just the way we organize ourselves in groups and give power to the group?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by mikeash on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:30PM (#19653954)
I said they were the end result of government policy. I said nothing about them being government.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by Cerium on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:59AM (#19653047)
I have spent some time living in one of these tall thin Chinese towers. They have benefits that are not at apparent at first glance. Since they are thin every room can have a window and they have good airflow. Since they are high density public transport can be very close, and catching a taxi is easy.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by badpun on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:46PM (#19655320)
Also, if someone 15 floors below or above you is using a jackhammer, your day is screwed. Or, if there's a child who is bouncing a ball against the wall in some appartment. The noises travel pretty well across the structure, that's why I prefer to live in a building which has as few units within a single structure as possible. Mine curently has 25, which is livable, previous one was over a hundred and was much worse in this regard.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by wongarsu on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#19653389)
> That is the end result of government policy.

Everything is the result of government policy. Even if the government did absolutely nothing, it would be the result of a government policy not to intervene.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by trophycase on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:14PM (#19654336)
Having seem them in person in China, they very much resembled bloc houses. 3x3 pr 4x4 squares of identical apartment buildings, and it seemed like there were miles and miles of these
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by kzcqt on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:45AM (#19652975)
This is very classist. Everybody should have the opportunity of living in a big city, especially given that that's where the jobs are (and it's only going to get worse every year).
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by alexandercrohde on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:06AM (#19653402)
Well, London and SF are historic and beautiful cities (at least architecturally). Part of the reason people WANT to live there is because they aren't full of skyscrapers and megacorporations.

In fact, one of the defining traits of San Francisco is that it disallows chain restaurants, walmarts, etc. It also has many parks. When I see a stone church that has stood for 200 years in a city, I think it's priceless.

If you don't, well there's plenty of cities that don't give a crap about aesthetics at all, and so they're cheap, and so they're full of poor people, and so they're full of crime.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by badpun on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:49PM (#19655332)
> Part of the reason people WANT to live there is because they aren't full of skyscrapers and megacorporations. > When I see a stone church that has stood for 200 years in a city, I think it's priceless.

I think that actually there are megacorporations in SF (or within commuting distance in the Valley), and they are the reasons people want to live here. I see no less than 6 historic churches out of my window in a historic city in Poland, and yet rent is $300 a month and no one wants to move here. Why? No megacorporations.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by woah on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:14AM (#19653452)
Your argument is that affordable market rate housing allows poor people to live in a city, which you don’t want?

I think we’ve found the world’s most honest NIMBYist!

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by thaumasiotes on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:32PM (#19654461)
> one of the defining traits of San Francisco is that it disallows chain restaurants, walmarts, etc.

For very narrow values of "chain restaurants, walmarts etc." Target is basically the same thing as Wal-mart. Chain restaurants are common. (For example, I used to eat lunch at a nearby Jimmy John's, a sandwich chain from Illinois. Which Jimmy John's I ate at might vary; there was more than one nearby.) There's a Starbucks on every block.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by BurningFrog on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:04PM (#19655067)
Yeah, I always assumed that ban just means the chain has to bribe the right officials.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by justforyou on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:23AM (#19653504)
Megacorporations are actually the reason SF has become the real estate nightmare that it is -- but hey, no poor people.

When a city makes decisions that don't favor its residents, it becomes an unaffordable haven for transplants, speculators and people who value the facade of the 200 year old stone church as opposed to the poor people the church was created to serve/bilk.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by refurb on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:06PM (#19653798)
I’m pretty sure SF is making the decisions it’s residents want and that’s the problem - most of the residents don’t want more density.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by uuwp on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:53PM (#19655350)
It's not so much about the density. It's about ludicrous mortgage that they signed up in past and want their house to at least maintain its price.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by uuwp on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:50PM (#19655338)
It's not the corporations, but the current mortgage system. Corp workers with 100-200k pay pair up and put their entire life earnings (30 years) towards a house. Banks back this deal and the couple gets a house they can't really afford. Same with our education system and healthcare. If the gov made a law that mortgage can't exceed 1 year income, prices would adjust to that number.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by hw on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:26PM (#19655828)
If SF really gave a crap about aesthetics, they would tax residents like you in order to clean up its streets and build affordable housing (hello skyscrapers) for the homeless people who are ruining the aesthetics of such a 'beautiful' city. Good luck bringing your kids to one of the 'many parks' in the city to play without being worried about getting pricked with a used needle hidden in the grass, or walk to that beautiful 200year old stone church without getting harassed by the homeless.

SF is overrated. The reason you would pay $3000 for a tiny studio is because commuting into the city to work for one of the megacorporations is untenable. There are much nicer places to live in the Peninsula and South Bay, or even in other states.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by bobthepanda on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:09PM (#19654289)
Presumably you need some people to be poor in every metropolitan area, because six figure software developers are not going to scrub the office floors after hours or serve brunch. Without poor people basic services start falling apart, and they have to live somewhere.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by gurumeditations on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:49PM (#19654552)
You must be kidding if you’re suggesting SF isn’t full of crime and poor people. It’s a city known for being full of bussed-in homeless lining the streets, covered in shit and used needles, where you can expect to have your car broken into on a regular basis.

This speaks to a much larger problem. As opportunity concentrates in dense areas, the lucky few elite will try their hardest to keep it all to themselves, one way being by hoarding it in an artificially-low population city like SF. Eventually they’ll start building a wall to keep the undesirables out, or have police harass everyone who isn’t driving a luxury vehicle like in Marin.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ComputerGuru on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:26AM (#19653517)
> Well, London and SF are historic and beautiful cities (at least architecturally)

One is not like the other.

Seriously. You can't compare any American city with a European counterpart from a "historic" perspective.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by kitten_mittens_ on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:53AM (#19653695)
Boston was founded in 1632. Mexico City is even older if you want to pull in Latin America.

There is plenty of history in North America.

Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by ema on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:21AM (#19653488)
Wouldn't it be much more efficient to require a minimum income/wealth of would be residents and so lower the demand for housing enough that all these rich people can invest into something more productive than real estate?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by thaumasiotes on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:36PM (#19654480)
Yes; laws like that can get into trouble with US laws against segregated neighborhoods.
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by wbl on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:13AM (#19653441)
And SF isn't?
Re:Construction has kept rent in Chongqing, China to $75 a m... by Simon_says on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:10PM (#19656361)
> When I see a stone church that has stood for 200 years in a city, I think it's priceless.

Meh. When I see it, I see a monumental squandering of human labor.