As an Northeasterner, I am amused at the poor condition of single-story commercial buildings in California, particularly Los Angeles.
You don't see many buildings of that type built before 1970, particularly in New England, because they are poorly built and the roof starts to leak at some point. In the Northeast that is reason to rebuild, in LA you can probably manage a leaky roof with a bucket for much longer.
I've always said that LA is beautiful at night, and pretty ugly during the day. That can be more or less true depending where in LA you're looking, but some of my favorite places in LA are absolutely hideous by the light of the day. But after dusk, same places can be magical.
Some of those old houses are built really beautifully, but there were a lot of shanty buildings that have been patched and patched. But some of the trees between those shanties are old and gorgeous. Somehow it works, but it's not a model for anything else.
Some of my favorites:
1. Old Town Pasadena 2. Baldwin hill Overlook 3. Little Tokyo and Sawtelle 4. San Gabriel / Alhambra (Chinese food) 5. Signal Hill / Downtown Long Beach 6. Melrose and the area near Laurel Canyon
I could go on, but really there's gems everywhere. I've found that LA is more so a place you live than a place you visit, despite it's reputation otherwise. It's packed to to the brim with artists, developers, and good food, and there's space to stretch.
Not really hacking news, but file this under lifestyle.
I have friends scattered throughout the city and we never see each other. Even the ones who live just a few miles away don’t want to leave their neighborhoods ever because.... traffic.
My dream job is in LA. I love the idea of LA, just don’t like living here. That’s just me tho, lots of people do really love it :)
And the rest of them are still sitting in their packed U-Hauls in traffic on the Sepulveda pass.
I called LA home for two decades and the transportation hell largely kept me in my general community. Going to Pasadena from the Westside is a full day commitment, unless you leave at sunrise on a Sunday.
When I lived there, it was best to live/work/play in adjacent neighborhoods, and then explore as you found yourself available the rest of the time.
I do love the global diversity aspect of it.
But I sympathize with those who didn't like it.. it's a really easy town to "miss" on.
- Majority of city (outside old towns) built after WWII with an emphasis on brutalist 60s suburbia.
- Prop 13 and the NIMBY revolution that cemented it in for the long haul.
It's only in the last five years or so that extreme economic pressure has enabled new buildings over two stories (gasp) to be built outside downtown, while NIMBYs scream bloody murder.
It’s amusing to suggest there’s historic stuff in China, as there is in Europe. I saw a “historic” building in China. It was constructed in 1600s! Like, 400 years after the bar I used to work in started.
It’s amusing to suggest there’s historic stuff in Europe, as there is in Egypt. I saw a “historic” building in the UK. It was constructed in the 900s! Like, 4,000 years after the pyramids were built!
etc etc etc
That there’s older shit elsewhere doesn’t remove the historicity of anywhere else
To most, that was making the impression that "time is not actually going," and that people lived exactly like it was today for millennia. There was little regard for "historical things" outside of microscopically small class of educated elites.
The preservation impulse perks up with change.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Timeline_of_Japanese_...
No, it is not. SF problem can be fixed with a few blocks. A 35 stories building with 1 bed-room condos can host up to 700-1000 persons. I'd bet lots of SF tech developers will opt for a very small high tech condo with amenities (pool, gym, library...) than the crap that is right now.
Say you build a hundred of these. That's 100K person and more than 10% of the population of San Fransisco. You plot the land 10 miles south of the downtown. You make a fast, efficient and new subway that connect from the plot to the downtown.
It is easy considering that the Chinese, Korean, and Japanese are doing it everyday. SF has the money, land and tech to do it.
A 35 story building's residents will make much greater use of existing mass transit when located within 3 blocks of said transit than existing low rise development will.
[1] https://www.marketplace.org/2019/04/11/economy/subways-US-ex...
[2] https://pedestrianobservations.com/2019/03/03/why-american-c...
It will be interesting to see which cities do the best in future: the ones that try to house large numbers of people at low cost? The ones that are quickest to adopt new ideas? The ones where billionaires prefer to live? Who knows.
Sure, but you'll induce demand. As SF prices drop, think of all the people who will move in from (mostly) the East Bay. Prices will drop, but not nearly as much as you think without 100,000 units.
The easiest way to do this would be to require consent of the current owner to designate a building as historic.
Then if you want to designate a building as historic but you don't actually want to own it, no problem, you buy the building, designate it as historic and then sell it again. The difference in value before and after comes out of your pocket.
Require a bond be put up to cover the cost of moving the historic building out of the city, so the land can be used for modern construction.
Historical preservation is sacrificing for the future. It's literally the exact opposite of stealing from the future
It's also cumulative. There is a finite amount of land. If you designate another 1% of it as historic each year, a hundred years later you're locked in stasis.
There is a reason for the rule against perpetuities.
It wouldn't be the best option but the sites that have survived a hundred of years didn't survive because some legal mandate dictated it. It's because they were buildings built to last.
==It wouldn't be the best option but the sites that have survived a hundred of years didn't survive because some legal mandate dictated it. It's because they were buildings built to last.==
Or they have historical value specifically because they were built to last. Obviously, we wouldn’t know that unless we allow them to last.
If I had to choose my position it would be less broad protection of historic buildings. However if I have to choose one extreme or the other I see homelessness exploding where I live and a bunch of money spent on bullshit. We're not talking about preserving the Sistine Chapel here.
No, they're the remains of historic/old sites that were left after people of yore tore down everything else to build anew.
You don't have to preserve 100% of the "old city" to get a glimpse into an era, just like you don't have to preserve 100% of the city wall just to show that once upon a time, city walls were a thing.
> If we tear down everything old to put up cheaper, more efficient buildings are we necessarily better off?
You don't have to tear down everything in San Francisco, but most of it has little to no "historic value".
Places like Cinque Terra, Istanbul and Cartagena are popular specifically because they have been preserved and are not just remains.
Perhaps, but if we're talking about bulldozing and rebuilding the place to get rent down, San Francisco is at the top of the list.
That's true in the sense the statement is true of every human action.
> Once something is designated a historic, it's hard to undo
Only because there is widespread support for the general idea of historical preservation; it's usually not more difficult than reverding or passing a normal law to either eliminate a particular designation or an entire system of historic preservation.
People who find it difficult do so not because their hands are tied by the past, but because their hands are tied by their present opposition.
Once something is destroyed, though, that is impossible to undo, no matter what the future generations would want.
In exactly the same sense you're not binding current generations either.
The issue is that it's a lot easier to get something designated as historical than to get it undesignated as such or to change the process in order to make it easier.
Moreover, changing it is hard because it's a complicated issue that the large majority of people don't really care about and a concentrated special interest group (landlords who want to retain high rents) does care about and doesn't want changed.
Unless you expect that dynamic to change significantly over time, you're binding the future as much as the present.
> Once something is destroyed, though, that is impossible to undo, no matter what the future generations would want.
That is true of all action and inaction. You can't change the past once it has already happened.
You have to choose for them whether the future gets the old buildings or the new buildings. If it turns out the old buildings are worse, e.g. because continued high rents cause lasting economic damage to the region, you can't undo that either.
There definitely needs to be more barriers when it comes to designating places and areas as historical, but this is a pretty harsh take.
Especially in a world with a growing population and increasing centralization, there will be fewer and fewer opportunities for individuals from new generations to do new things.
The argument is being able to look at some court house built in 1925 is not more important than people in 2018 (and forever into the future) having more affordable places to live.
I tend to agree that the "no historical preservation" viewpoint is way overblown. E.g., there are lots of monuments and buildings in Boston and Philly that should always be preserved because they are integral to telling the nation's founding story. But there are lot of "historical landmarks/buildings" in the USA that are really only significant to the handful of people who pushed to make them "historical" (and are probably now dead anyways).
A compromise can be converting the court house into apartments or offices, so that it can have contemporary use but at the same time some aspects of its historic appearance are preserved (such as its façade). Of course, other parts of its historical value are going to be lost – it is likely impossible to maintain the historical integrity of the actual court rooms in the process of converting the building into offices or apartments – but it is still better than knocking down the building entirely.
I used to live around the corner from an old water pump house converted to offices. When they switched from coal-fired pumps to electrical ones, suddenly the amount of space consumed by the pumps shrunk dramatically. So they removed all the boilers and turned it into office space instead. Part of me wishes the boilers had stayed, but it is better than knocking down the building entirely.
By contrast the city I grew up in, York, had stone walls that are ~2000 years old. The next city I lived, Edinburgh, has some proper-old buildings too. e.g. The Royal mile contains buildings from the 12th century, and I regularly used to drink in pubs that were 600-800 years old.
In short "old" is relative.
If everybody just left a historic building alone it would just decay into disrepair. If somebody is not using the location it has no value. The people going around designating every building that stays standing beyond a certain number of years historic causing said land to go underutilized need to pay some of the cost. The status quo is overbroad.
The only way to tax "historic value" would be to put a sliding scale tax on things in proportion to their subjective quality and incentivize garbage that nobody thinks anyone will want 20 years from now.
But overwhelmingly it is a pretext for NIMBYism as part of the overall strategy for always having an excuse to not build anything anywhere.
It’s amusing to suggest there is “historic stuff” in SF, as there is in China. I saw a “historic” building with a plaque in Palo Alto. It was constructed in the 1900s! Like, after my grandfather was born.
Historical preservation is stealing from the future. If I had my druthers, the opportunity cost of designating buildings or areas as historic would come directly out of the pockets of the preservationists.