News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by MisterTea on Sunday June 17, 2018 @01:34PM (#17333326)
These companies are obsessed with fragmenting the market for the sake of owning content from production to delivery. I have bad news for them: you're going to lose. People don't want to go back to paying $100/month for a dozen streaming "channels" with one or two good shows and a the same crap the rest of the other "channels" have.

We want an on-demand nexus. A single hub. Just the other day I had the urge to watch ghost in the shell. Not available on any of the major streaming sites (Netflix, Hulu, Prime) but available on stars via prime. So I have to pay an addition $7/month to watch a single show? No thanks. Off to a torrent site or asking around to see if someone has rips or a box set. I have better things to do with $7 like buy dinner.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by bookbinder on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:06PM (#17335467)
People don't want to pay $100 a month for cable TV either, but they did it anyway (for decades) and continue to do so. Now we're being asked to buy a bunch of streaming services and we'll bitch and moan, but ultimately we'll pay because every major platform will have at least one show that justifies their existence.

I associate CBS with bland procedural crime dramas and awful three-camera sitcoms. CBS All Access would have been doomed without Star Trek: Discovery. Admittedly, the show isn't particularly good, but I'm a trekkie so it doesn't matter. On the plus side, I discovered The Good Fight (a surprising smart, entertaining and well written show) so I now I have a legitimate reason to give a damn about All Access.

And then Apple will offer their own gateway drug (Lord of the Rings?) and Disney (...well they could just offer their back catalogue alone and still be a major player) and so on.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by pwinnski on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:39AM (#17338576)
> People don't want to pay $100 a month for cable TV either, but they did it anyway (for decades)...

In the absence of alternatives, it seemed like what entertainment cost. The alternatives for free or cheap are enough that many, many, many people are opting out.

> ...and continue to do so.

Evidence[0] suggests otherwise.

Leaving evidence aside, I think that each service will likely have something to attract some number of subscribers, yes. Amazon is doing LotR, Disney wants a piece, CBS has Star Trek, etc. I don't think it follows that a large number of people are going to subscribe to more than one or two on an ongoing basis. People subscribe to CBS All-Access for one month, perhaps a trial month, and binge all of ST:D, then cancel. They already have a subscription to Amazon Prime for non-TV reasons. Maybe they share subscriptions with friends, or maybe they turn to piracy, or maybe they just shrug and go back to watching Netflix and YouTube, which is enough. Most people never had all the available channels, including premium channels, anyway. Going without a show or two isn't a problem for most people when the marginal cost is so high.

[0] https://variety.com/2018/biz/news/cord-cutting-2017-high-cos...

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by daveFNbuck on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:40AM (#17336352)
I've paid for 2 months of CBS All Access, once at the end of each season of The Good Fight. That one show only gets me to pay a bit less than $1/month.

Comedy Central doesn't have a streaming service, so I have to pay for shows individually on Amazon. That also ends up being a lot cheaper than CBS All Access, and it cuts me off from learning about their other shows. I think all the Comedy Central shows I used to watch have been cancelled, so they won't be getting any of my money going forward unless I somehow learn about their new shows. That's a lot easier to do if my existing services start recommending Comedy Central shows to me.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by adjkant on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:47AM (#17336063)
> continue to do so

What are the numbers on that? My impression was that cable is declining fast.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by s2g on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:54PM (#17350586)
I won't pay for Star Trek Discovery because it's on CBS all access. It's just not worth it.

Amazon/Netflix/Hulu/HBO are worth it. thats what, about 50 a month? not bad. Even so I still end up on youtube a lot of the time.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by EADGBE on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:35AM (#17347623)
> I associate CBS with bland procedural crime dramas and awful three-camera sitcoms.

The Good Fight is really good, now I'm going back to watch the predecessor.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by MikusR on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:58AM (#17336969)
Lord of the Rings is Amazon
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lgregg on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:16PM (#17334630)
> We want an on-demand nexus. A single hub.

That is close to existing, it'd be nice if the top players agreed to open their APIs so you could integrate it into a unified TV external like Chromecast or Firestick. Or, to go further, a unified platform that can process subscriptions and PPV across each library.

> $100/month for a dozen streaming "channels" with one or two good shows and a the same crap the rest of the other "channels" have.

Amen, we cut the cord officially on Friday. We went to $67 (including modem rental) per month plus about $25 dollars in streaming services and $40 for YT TV per month. That's still $35 dollars cheaper than what we were paying for Comcast TV and once we buy a compatible modem then we'll drop our internet to about $55 per month. We also have renters, so we loop them into YTTV for them to watch to their heart's desire for an extra $5 on their rent per month.

> Ghost in the Shell

Respect just got done rewatching an episode of the TV show.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by JimmyAustin on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:13PM (#17335106)
The on-demand nexus already works on Apple TV. Say "I want to watch Billions" into the remote and it shows you all the services you can watch it on, then tap through to actually watching it.

Now if only it existed on other platforms.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Sargos on Sunday June 17, 2018 @11:57PM (#17335941)
Like most features this has existed on other platforms like Android TV way before Apple TV.

The parent comment was actually talking about paying for one service that has everything I think not just a shortcut to each disparate service.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by developer2 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:15PM (#17335528)
Can you elaborate? Does Apple TV let you purchase à la carte (on-demand) from any service, or do you still have to buy into a monthly subscription for a service just to watch one movie or TV series from its catalog?

The "one hub nexus" we are clamoring for requires either a) preferably, a single monthly fee to access everything; or b) less ideally, assuming reasonable prices, on-demand pay-per-view pricing.

A nexus that simplifies signing up for a dozen different streaming service subscriptions from one UI is not good enough. All that does is improve the frontend experience, while doing nothing to resolve the subscription hell that expects consumers to shell out $80+/month across many services to watch maybe 1% of the content.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by sharcerer on Monday June 18, 2018 @09:15AM (#17337964)
I think this will take some time. Right now, for a few years Prime, Netflix ,Apple etc are already putting in money for their own Originals. I don't exactly know the solution, but these players won't bundle right now for sure, nobody wants to lose leverage. I think Google might be playing smart or maybe they've lost already. They have already conceded that Netflix is far ahead. And, now they're bundling their premium shows with Youtube Music for additional 2-3 bucks a month. Their content strategy has been really poor. Frankly, Video is a sort of leverage tool for Apple, Amazon. But for Netflix, it's bread and butter. Also, read this article: https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2017/7/13/content-is...
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by toast0 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:19PM (#17335543)
Roku has a pretty large list of providers and the ability to search across them. It does feel like I'm being nickle and dined to death though when back catalog stuff I want to watch costs the same as recent shows :(
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lgregg on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:46PM (#17335387)
> Now if only it existed on other platforms.

and has everyone's original content.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by EADGBE on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:37AM (#17347640)
Amazon's Fire TV devices have this, as well.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by s2g on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:55PM (#17350596)
Fire TV does that.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by virusduck on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:56AM (#17338687)
$12/mo on modem rental??!! A cable modem only costs like $30--I can't believe that's what they're charging for rental.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lgregg on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:06PM (#17339317)
It is a gateway rather than just a normal modem. I understand the charge. Their default router is a Cisco DPC3939 with the voice option which already retails at a high price. They buy it in bulk, but it's still likely in the upper double-digit range on a year-long contract. They probably don't make an actual profit until you're 75% through your initial contract then it's just cash.

Overall, I think a lot of people go far as to look at the prices then balk and back out or just don't even want to deal with it. Comcast also have a strict list of modems and gateways they will approve to use their network.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by virusduck on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:22PM (#17367217)
I only have internet service from Comcast. I snagged this on amazon (although it was $35 at the time): https://www.amazon.com/D-Link-DCM-301-Compatible-Comcast-Cab...
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by axaxs on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:28PM (#17334423)
Agreed. TV for me is a nicety, I enjoy it from time to time. I'm already a bit putoff from having both Netflix and Hulu, forgetting which show is on which, two apps, etc. I have a feeling we're heading towards each player making their own ecosystem, apps, monthly charges. If/when that happens, I'll either not watch TV at all, or use the 'free' options widely available. I want to give them money, but not if it makes my life more of a hassle.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by giancarlostoro on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:50PM (#17334525)
>forgetting which show is on which

On my Android TV device (Mi Box $60 at WalMart) if I search a show it aggregates results from all my apps so it doesn't even matter which app it's on I just click from the results and it opens what I want.

Disclaimer: Not affiliated with anything I just mentioned just a happy customer.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by axaxs on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:56PM (#17334847)
Ohhh...that sounds like a nice feature! I'll research this thank you.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by giancarlostoro on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:05AM (#17337249)
Yeah no problem, I had seen the Android TV box at WalMart and said to myself: if this thing is awesome I'm gifting one to my parents, now they want two more... They've been asking for it to replace cable and they're not extremely tech savvy or anything! It's also a 4K capable device, so it's pretty good, I've had it for almost 2 years now.

I otherwise would of had to use a Raspberry Pi with Kodi (and yes, the Android TV can run Kodi, much smoother).

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by henrikschroder on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:29PM (#17334973)
My current and my previous Samsung TVs had this built-in as well. It can search the channel guide in the cable-box, the installed apps, as well as some pay-per-view alternatives.

Works pretty damn well, actually.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by axaxs on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:28PM (#17335155)
I have a Samsung 'smart' tv. Oddly enough, I'm pretty tech averse when it comes to media. Do you mind sharing where this global search is, if I had it?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by henrikschroder on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:54AM (#17337197)
I can either just press the microphone button on my remote and say what I'm searching for, or hit the search icon in the home interface, it's almost all the way to the left, next to settings and source.

If you don't have either, I have no idea. Read the user manual, maybe?

Edit: It's surprisingly hard to find images online of what the search screen looks like, I'm having absolutely no luck finding any, I only get screenshots of their older smarthub crap.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:18AM (#17335996)
Apple has been selling TV shows by the episode since 2005.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by sosborn on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:17PM (#17333822)
> Off to a torrent site or asking around to see if someone has rips or a box set.

The other option is to just not watch it.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rayiner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:42PM (#17333934)
The down voting you’re getting is emblematic of the entitlement mentality among tech folks when it comes to content. There is no right to consume entertainment someone else produced for free. If you don’t like the terms on which they’re selling the fruits of their labor, don’t buy it.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:35PM (#17334200)
If that feeling went both ways I could agree. Companies however, obviously don't like not controlling everything the public has and do things like increase copyright to a length that their own company would have never started(Disney), or try to claim that users no longer own products they buy and can no longer repair things themselves (John Deere).

Companies have already taken multiple sustained attacks against consumers rights so why would consumers care about the companies rights?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rayiner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:53PM (#17335231)
“Companies” are not an undifferentiated mass. What does John Deere have to do with Dexter or Game of Thrones? Are people only pirating the work of “bad” companies?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:58PM (#17335247)
Consumers aren't an undifferentiated mass either. Why are paying customers sitting through 5 minutes of FBI warnings in front of DVDs because some other people pirate? These arguments go both ways but a large portion of this forum seems to only view it from the companies perspective
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by adventured on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:41PM (#17335368)
> Why are paying customers sitting through 5 minutes of FBI warnings in front of DVDs because some other people pirate?

It's not your product to design, in this case you don't get to decide how it's presented. You also don't get to decide the design of iOS, or how Apple designs its next processor, or what color Stack Overflow's logo is, or the design of Wikipedia, or what resolutions YouTube offers, or what algorithms Google uses in its search product.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:21PM (#17335553)
"your product" is a function of our laws concerning property and those are not a fundamental law of the universe. Corporations have had a large say in defining what property is in the modern world but consumers get a say too, through their actions.

Why are a series of 1s and 0s this companies property or that person's property other than because society declares them to be so? If they can declare who owns what then that declaration can change

Edit: For example, if steam boat Willie was still under the copyright laws that existed when it was created, it would be society property now. Because the rules were changed, it's Disney's property. If "property" can be taken from society by companies, then the reverse can happen as well

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scrumption on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:15AM (#17336135)
Just like you don't get to decide if I download it for free or not, lol.

But for your information, I can and do run userscripts, custom ROMs, jailbroken firmware etc to change the exact sort of thing you spent the second half of your post talking about. You sound like you have a very boring consumerist relationship to technology and the opposite of a hacker ethos.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rayiner on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:43PM (#17340129)
"Hacker ethos" is using other peoples' work for free?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by AtlasBarfed on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:11PM (#17335501)
These companies are explicitly setting up vertical monopolies, when they already have horizontal monopolies.

The entitlement here is the elites, who don't have anything to fear from antitrust legislation and can fundamentally undermine the free market, which allegedly is important to the underlying Ayn Rand undercurrent of this site.

In that context, rebellion/revolt/resistance is a somewhat legitimate choice by some points of view.

Seriously, we just had an election directly related to the over-concentration of media in a few powers, and now we're allowing them to vertically monopolize the delivery of that content.

Which would be a bit... ok... if it was just Mickey Mouse, but the news is fully controlled by oligarchs.

By vertically integrating the internet access, they can censor the only uncontrolled news outlet: the internet.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Retra on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:46PM (#17334245)
I down-voted them for stating the obvious and adding nothing of value to the discussion.

Either way, it doesn't take an 'entitlement mentality' to prefer paying less for something. That's just good sense. And lots of people do pay for entertainment with the expectation that they can share it with people. Humanity has spent its entire history freely sharing things that grab our social fancy and percolate through our cultural attentions. Just because a business wants to make money doesn't mean they have a right to deny the basic workings of the human brain.

>If you don’t like the terms on which they’re selling the fruits of their labor, don’t buy it.

I'm pretty sure finding someone else who has access to it involves not buying it. Next thing you'll be telling me I have a moral obligation to not watch my sister's Breaking Bad DVD's with her. Or worse: a legal obligation.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by zaphirplane on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:45AM (#17337154)
I don’t think people are not replying to your comment because it makes a convincing argument. I suppose if you refuse to lend your car out for a $ it’s ok for someone to take it. Oh it’s a digital copy, so it’s ok for people to copy your work and give it away.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Retra on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:34PM (#17342519)
You're over-simplifying the problem, which is that digital distribution naturally promotes decentralization of distribution. Media and information products suffer due to that, but most media and information-content producers are already piggybacking on human social behaviors to produce value in the first place.

If you produce digital music, for instance, it has almost no value if nobody shares it. The decentralization of distribution is exactly the mechanisms one uses to make money off of these things. Your hope is that things go "viral" and that they are shared so prolifically that you'll be able to extract value out of your importance to the network overall, not due to some analogous 'artificial' manufacturing bottleneck like you would with concrete goods.

The argument that it is ok to consume media for free hinges on the fact that it is both efficient and natural human behavior, and that it doesn't undermine the whole-network of value. If the latest Avenger movie makes $1Bn in one week, then it's pretty clear that plenty of value is being extracted from the network, regardless of how many people have not paid to see it. People have no moral obligation to allow a content producer to monopolize all distribution, especially when the rational basis for such level of profit is simply not there. And you can't have it both ways anyway: you can't expect to have "viral" information that people also have to pay to exchange. (Or rather, you can't expect them to be Ok with that.)

The appropriate analogy for that situation would be more like Toyota trying to make it illegal to sell cars that they manufacture without their consent. It would destroy the second-hand market and be highly inefficient for people. If my sister streams her DVDs over the internet to me, all we're doing there is avoiding the coordination costs and being economically efficient. In either case, I pay for my internet access, so I would, in fact, be paying for media that I torrent or share online.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by cam_l on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:22AM (#17336007)
Sure, if i don't like the terms of distribution I don't get the privilege to have it. If society doesn't like the terms, the company doesn't retain the privilege to sell it.

Plenty of people do work which is not properly compensated. I don't get to set the terms of the sale of my intellectual property, as I work in an industry where this has little worth.. and I am an employee.

This is all about power. The power to set prices, the power to use propaganda to change peoples morals, the power to change the law to criminalise minor contract infringements. And as such I get to say, whenever and wherever i can get away with it, fuck their power.

For the very, very minimal amount that's about the sale of the fruits of labour of the creatives and workers producing this entertainment.. Well I wish there was an easier way to compensate them that didn't involve also paying off the distributors.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by esturk on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:02AM (#17336102)
There's a public library system that gives everyone in their city the entitlement to do so. There's nothing you can do or say to stop it too. It will be bought once and watched over 100+ times.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mlthoughts2018 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:26PM (#17335332)
What do you think about a situation in which a consumer would be happy to pay full price to watch content, but they are prevented entirely by a service provider?

For example, suppose where you live there is a monopoly ISP-cable conglomerate, you cannot afford to move away, and you are literally unable to consume from any other ISP / cable level provider.

For some content, like watching European soccer in the US, this situation can mean that you are literally prevented from properly paying money to see that content, even though providers exist who can take your money and give you the content. It might even come down to your specific zip code, street, or even apartment building in some cities, where a content provider is case-by-case prevented from selling their content to certain residents purely based on whether a certain ISP has a monopoly on that location.

Telling the consumer to just not watch seems morally hollow in that specific case (which is a really common case). The customer wants to pay, and a third-party wants to give the content, but a rent-seeking middleman that the consumer has no control over (ISP) can limit the customer’s choices. The customer cannot do what the market would suggest and take their business elsewhere to incentivize the services they want, and because of the ubiquitous need for internet connectivity to conduct basic life duties, totally boycotting the monopoly ISP is functionally not an option. (Really, it would not be reasonable to suggest such a drastic option.)

I don’t see any ethical reason why the consumer should just accept being worse off (in terms of planned consumption), since it’s pure rent-seeking and value destruction on the part of the ISP, which the consumer is literally prevented from rejecting.

Many other ISP behaviors are likewise just artificial rent-seeking attempts, to construct artificial tiering, bundling, etc., which the consumer is prevented from “not buying” because the service provider is often literally a monopoly.

I’m just curious if you take an extreme view of this, that the ISPs or monopoly providers “are right” to use their monopoly position to introduce artificial rent-seeking opportunities? And that if a customer must choose between either paying the rent-seeking premium, stealing the content, or not consuming at all, that the customer should accept that the ISP / content provider’s ability to inflict this situation (through what are unequivocally antitrust violations that are just not punished solely because of regulatory capture) does indees mean the consumer just should opt to not consume at all?

Essentially, “because ISPs spend money on regulatory capture, I should accept living a worse life by not consuming at all rather than watching illegally.”

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by geodel on Sunday June 17, 2018 @11:07PM (#17335758)
> Telling the consumer to just not watch seems morally hollow in that specific case

Seems like big word for something which is not food, water, life saving drug or some such. Now people are free to consider entertainment as basic human right. But similarly other powerful people/institution feel free to take away more fundamental things from helpless people.

From where I am, government is more than happy to offer free entertainment produced by private parties while feel no obligation to clean up almost sewer quality water running through taps of millions of homes.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mlthoughts2018 on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:36AM (#17336032)
So because information content is not the same as food, it’s ok for corporations to be artificially advantaged and consumers to be artificially disadvantaged? And consumers aren’t allowed to consider the moral implications of the arrangement? Or what it incentivizes companies to do? Or whether their ability to consume content is limited by regulatory capture?

I am not convinced by your reply because it tries to flip it around and blame the consumer (the victim of regulatory capture and ISP monopolies or oligopolies) just because the thing they are being deprived of “is not food.”

No part of this is related to whether something is a human right — that’s completely unrelated.

The problem is why should I, as a consumer, agree to accept a worse life in any way, even a minor way based on what is convenient for a corporation acting to ensure regulatory capture and ensure monopolistic or oligopolistic conditions within which it can unilaterally control what a consumer is allowed to consume.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ponchotek on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:46AM (#17336206)
It's not just entertainment. I live in New Zealand and have very limited (1 satellite tv provider and a few streaming services) choice in what news and documentaries I can legally watch. If I wanted to watch an interview on MSNBC my there is no legal way to do so and I would have to stream it illegally. Same case for many HBO documentaries.

I see this as a limiting factor on freedom of speech that will only continue to get worse if the market is further fragmented.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mikec3010 on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:13AM (#17338379)
By offering their product to me, they implicitly agreed to my terms of service which gives me the express right to use a torrenting service. It also waives their right to sue and requires binding arbitration with an arbiter of my choosing.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by freehunter on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:29PM (#17334432)
Completely playing devil's advocate here, but why should the companies feel entitled to money? If someone is going to go out of their way to pirate something, they're not spending money on it any anyway. So the company is spending their own money and time coming up with ways to prevent people from accessing their content which the other person wouldn't have paid for in the first place, then using that to show how much money they've lost.

Think about it like this: a comedian tells a joke that offends someone. But the people who get offended aren't the audience of that comedian, and wouldn't have seen the comedian's show anyway. Should the comedian worry at all about these people boycotting the show if they never have and never will buy tickets anyway?

Ending the devil's advocate, if these companies want to completely control popular culture and change the definition of society, they have to understand that memes (not the Internet kind, the real life kind) spread until they are pervasive. There's a limit to how much Disney can force Avengers into our cultural identity then demand payment for it. Either Avengers becomes a cultural meme and spreads virally, or you can keep people from seeing it unless you control the experience end-to-end and only have it become a moderate success and only make a moderate amount of money.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rhino369 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:42PM (#17334494)
>Completely playing devil's advocate here, but why should the companies feel entitled to money? If someone is going to go out of their way to pirate something, they're not spending money on it any anyway.

Entitled to money for services rendered is differnet than just being entitled to money. They don't think they deserve your money if you don't want to pay. They just don't think you should also get the product.

I seriously doubt the people spending time pirating and watching media would just suddenly take up reading books from the library or maybe sewing. They'd probably spend some money on media.

Not every pirated media is a lost sale. But some of them are.

I know when I sailed the high seas I just ended up forking down money for stuff I couldn't successfully pirate (multiplayer games and movies in theatres).

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by tzs on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:34AM (#17337092)
> Completely playing devil's advocate here, but why should the companies feel entitled to money? If someone is going to go out of their way to pirate something, they're not spending money on it any anyway. So the company is spending their own money and time coming up with ways to prevent people from accessing their content which the other person wouldn't have paid for in the first place, then using that to show how much money they've lost

That analysis maybe works in the context of an individual piece of content from a single company, but it is a lot more shaky when applied to multiple pieces of content from multiple companies.

For instance, suppose someone wants to watch a movie tonight. Their first choice is not yet available on any streaming platform they subscribe to, nor is it available on any of the rental platforms they have reasonable access to. It's only available for purchase at $25.

If they cannot pirate it they aren't likely to cancel their movie night. They are likely to move on to their second or third choice that is available on one of their streaming services or is rentable.

If they pirate their first choice, then the company that provides that movie loses nothing because, as you note, they were not going to get the money anyway. The company providing their second choice however does lose out on the sale they would have made if there was no piracy.

(Well, actually, the company that makes their first choice loses nothing that night. If they could not have pirated it, they probably would not have given up on watching it. They would more likely have postponed it to a later movie night after it does become available for rental or streaming).

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by falcor84 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:38PM (#17334994)
Human rights are a very politically controversial topic, so let's instead reverse our focus and address this via Dawkins's concept of memetics. Looking at a piece of well-designed popular consumer entertainment content, we can see that its main reason of being is to spread out as if it were an epidemic, infecting people's minds and getting them to pass it around.

Continuing with the epidemiological metaphor, there are several possible vectors for the content to spread, and the prevalence of each depends on the particular circumstances of specific hosts or communities of hosts. For example, if the vector of "Alice advising Bob to consume it on subscription service X" is effective in a particular community (and this effectiveness obviously depends on several different parameters), then piracy wouldn't be an issue there. But if all such legal vectors are ineffective in that community, while the content is still very potent in its memetic properties, then it will still spread out, in one of several forms of alternative less legal vectors.

To paraphrase John Gilmore's famous quote about the internet, society treats inconvenient content providers as if they weren't there and routes around them, creating alternative distribution methods.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by IAmGraydon on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:55PM (#17335058)
I think most of us are aware of why people steal content without lengthy, pretentious explanations. The point is that the OP acts as if he couldn’t possibly consider not watching. He believes that someone should provide it to him on the terms he deems fair or he has no choice but to steal it. OP is the textbook definition of a sociopath.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by benchaney on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:42PM (#17335188)
> He believes that someone should provide it to him on the terms he deems fair or he has no choice but to steal it

He made no such claim. You have to foundation from which to argue he believes this.

> OP is the textbook definition of a sociopath.

Blatantly lying about what someone else believes to paint them in a negative light is much more sociopathic than pirating something.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by falcor84 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:16PM (#17335113)
I would argue that by using the term "steal" in regarding to content, you demonstrate why we do need to continue this dialog.

There is no single truth here and I think that you are being overly offensive in saying that, by advocating for a different set of social rights, the OP is a sociopath. By the same token, any civil disobedience should be treated as sociopathy, no?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by teamk on Monday June 18, 2018 @09:06AM (#17337908)
If I told you a short story and then informed you it was copyrighted by me and you were morally forbidden from repeating said story, but you still repeated it, are you now a sociopath?

What a ridiculous stretch of logic.

On the contrary the idea that people's lives/property should be threatened (e.g. Kim Dotcom, ThePirateBay, etc.) for interfering, vaguely, in multinational conglomerates attempts to prevent the copying of 1s and 0s is entirely sociopathic. Something that most corporations end up behaving as.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ekianjo on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:45AM (#17337769)
> If you don’t like the terms on which they’re selling the fruits of their labor, don’t buy it.

He's not buying it. He just got it for free. Problem solved.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rhizome on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:31PM (#17335343)
The other option is to just not watch it.

Why wouldn't I take advantage of every possible opportunity and technology to participate in our shared culture?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by consumethreads on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:02PM (#17334310)
"We want an on-demand nexus."

up until a point ... HBO has been all about the entire pipeline from its inception because it feels (and has proven) that its content alone is good enough for it to be purchased a la carte.

Netflix and all others see this and say ... theres a business model here.

Fastforward 20 years, creating good content is cheaper. There are more film grad students to make the supply cheaper. Add to that the internet which allows you to be your own distributor. Basically its easier to be HBO today than when HBO started and you still get the added profits that HBO gets vs not generating your own content.

We want a hub but well take what we can get as long as the content is good. And we will get custom content because we have shown it pays. I guess we dont want the hub enough.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by hakfoo on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:05AM (#17336111)
"We want a hub but well take what we can get as long as the content is good."

I'm not sure. Convenience seems to trump content in a lot of markets. If you have a solid baseline level of content, the best experience wins.

In that regard, a fragmented market could cause the entire streaming model to-- well perhaps not collapse, but fail to flower fully.

Cable says "Yeah, you're spending $80 per month, but there's one consistent UI, one login, one bill."

Streaming with one service like pre-fragmentation Netflix, says "You're spending $10 per month, getting a modest content pool, and it's all still pretty easy to use."

But how will people respond to "You're spending $50 per month, get a fairly broad selection of content, but it's all scattered across a bunch of services which behave subtly differently and have to be managed independently?"

They might well respond by going back to the less-hassle cable option, or just shed services til they get to something that feels manageable-- one or two services, maybe paying for a month of something else to binge its signature show once a year. Netflix and HBO might kick out enough big draws to justify subscribing year-round, but will a low-budget or niche player?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by skinnymuch on Sunday June 17, 2018 @01:38PM (#17333344)
Lionsgate Starz isn’t a big company with a lot of products so paying extra to watch things for that channel will be a challenge no matter what. On the other hand, HBO seems to be doing well enough with their not so cheap stand alone offering.

Disney with Fox’s media would be a pretty big streaming provider and many people would likely get onto it. Good chance of it becoming a standard streaming service. So I don’t see how that specific merger is a bad idea in a battle against Netflix.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by yebyen on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:32PM (#17333595)
If you're talking about HBO Go, I don't know how you gauge success, but if it's subscriber numbers I would take that with a grain of salt.

I am a Comcast subscriber, and like many Comcast subscribers I'm sure, I have one of their boxes in my house, with the most basic Cable TV package, because if I don't take it my cost goes up (I mean the overall price of the monthly billed amount from Comcast/Xfinity).

We get crappy quality SD letterbox channels including some local OTA channels that we can watch Jeopardy on, at lower quality than OTA whenever the antenna isn't doing the job.

Oh, and HBO/On-Demand is also included. That includes HBO Go (but not HBO Now.) I don't use either HBO service and I don't know how they are different, at the risk of adding anecdata to an otherwise solid argument...

Whether or not any of this works out to be a favorable deal for HBO, I can't say, but I hope this explains why I would say to take their digital subscriber numbers with a grain of salt. (On the other hand, I will actually pay for Showtime standalone when they have put out a new season of Homeland.)

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rgbrenner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:24PM (#17335142)
HBO had $8.6B [0] in revenue last year.. For comparison, Netflix had $11.7. HBO is clearly succeeding..

0. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/hbo-had-its-largest-subscr...

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by yebyen on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:07PM (#17339323)
Yes, but how much of that can you attribute to direct internet sales?

> HBO’s direct-to-consumer subscriptions, which include HBO Now sign-ups through internet-based distributors like Amazon and DirecTV Now, have topped five million in the U.S.

> 5,000,000 * 12mo * $15

> $900,000,000

I'm sure not saying that is a sign they are not successful, but unless I'm missing something, $7.5B of those revenue are probably not related to their direct-to-customer subscriptions or internet streaming products. (I'm not sure what kind of gatekeeping I am engaging in here, but it would be interesting to know what HBO's actual sales numbers are wrt every particular mode of distribution channel.)

Yeah they're getting something from every Comcast subscriber that ostensibly pays $10 for the cheapest TV package or better that bundles HBO, I just know that I'm not using my cable TV service at all, or HBO Go enough to warrant paying ${netflix_subscription} many dollars direct to them and I'd probably cancel it today, if it wouldn't ultimately end up costing me something for the trouble in the long run.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by tzs on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:02PM (#17334020)
> I am a Comcast subscriber, and like many Comcast subscribers I'm sure, I have one of their boxes in my house, with the most basic Cable TV package, because if I don't take it my cost goes up (I mean the overall price of the monthly billed amount from Comcast/Xfinity)

This seems to vary region to region. Where I am (western Washington, west of Seattle) all the internet-only packages are cheaper than all the internet + TV packages at the same internet speed, as far as I can tell.

When comparing the price with and without TV, are your taking into account the fees and equipment charges that go away if you don't have TV? Although here internet only is cheaper than internet + TV, it isn't much cheaper. I've got 400 Mb/s internet, Preferred TV (220+ channels + Starz), and Phone, and dropping down to just 400 Mb/s internet would only knock $20 off the base price. That's a small enough change that it is probably less than I'd end up spending on streaming subscription and rental services to make up for the lost TV.

However, dropping TV and phone would also drop $11/month for the DVR service, $8/month for the broadcast TV fee, $6.30/month for the regional sports fee, and $4.60 for the franchise fee (and maybe some sales tax, if any of those fees are taxable). That's another $30/month, so we are talking $50/month less on my total bill. Now I would come out ahead even if I have to subscribe to multiple streaming services for my TV.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by yebyen on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:38AM (#17338563)
The TV deal is a promotional pricing structure, I have found that you can get them to offer you a new promotional rate if you threaten to send their hardware back and downgrade your service to Internet-only. (Again this may vary from region to region, I am in the midwest/Indiana in case it matters.)

These threats are credible when they know you have the crappiest TV service they offer and you probably aren't even using it but 30 minutes a day when Jeopardy comes on, but for some reason the sales reps seem to be pretty heavily incentivized to make sure you have some kind of TV service, even if you don't get any addons bundled with it. (Probably getting a kickback from the government, that's how they get their listening devices into your living room... /s)

I've declined as many services as I can otherwise, I don't have DVR service, HD channels (I get about 10 channels, all SD), extra super-premium internet package (mine claims up to 150Mbit, while it is not the lowest they offer, it's also not the highest...) I don't get a paper bill in the mail, or manual payments for billing (all of those things also cost ~$10 extra each); still my cable internet service is good, and it does come with HBO as I mentioned.

(I'm pretty sure it's standard def HBO over the wire, and that's another good reason to register for and use the bundled HBO Go service at least once...)

I think that $8/mo broadcast TV fee is the only one you mentioned that I can actually identify on my bill. And as I've had it explained to me, I would not be able to qualify for any promotional pricing after my first year of service without that.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by nobleach on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:28PM (#17335336)
Those SD letter boxed locals are Comcast actively degrading the signal, so they can sell the HD version (which is how they receive it) at an inflated price. I sometimes think this might be illegal to tamper with a broadcast signal to degrade it on purpose.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by yebyen on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:42AM (#17338595)
Amen! I was told it would cost me another $10/mo to add HD service, and that I probably wouldn't get any new channels. And I will still be dealing with commercials.

No thanks. It doesn't cost you anything extra to allow me to decrypt the commercials. I'll take my chances with OTA signals if I'm still going to be stuck watching commercials.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by vincentmarle on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:19PM (#17333835)
HBO Go is what you get when you subscribe to HBO through your cable service, HBO Now is a direct subscription to HBO.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by yebyen on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:19PM (#17339420)
Thank you. That was clear-as-mud every time I wondered what the difference was before.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:44PM (#17333938)
Even without Fox, Disney has the best chance of success even if it e dis up having a smaller library. Small kids will watch the same thing over and over again. If you have kids, being able to pay $10-$15 a month for all Disney content is a great deal.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mmt on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:43PM (#17334781)
> Small kids will watch the same thing over and over again. > being able to pay $10-$15 a month

That seems like a terrible deal, compared with just paying for that "same thing" once and watching it over and over for free.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by EastSmith on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:21PM (#17334947)
That "same thing" this month is Finding Nemo, next month is Cars, next month is something else.

Also, you can buy it and they watch it half a time and never think about it again.

$10-$15 is cheaper.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mmt on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:37PM (#17334993)
Thanks (I'm not a parent). In those cases, yes, that pricing would make sense.

Of course, it doesn't really matter if they control all the distribution anyway. They can just make "buying" a non-option, which I believe Disney has tried for certain titles already.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by jasonjayr on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:12PM (#17335506)
... and children + discs often ends poorly.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mmt on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:34PM (#17335621)
I can't imagine buying a disc and not immediately ripping and trans-coding it, though I was assuming buying some cheaper, downloadable content in the first place.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:16AM (#17335992)
And then when you rip it, you have to go through the trouble of either setting up a Plex Server to stream the content (which I've done) or putting it on each device.

Just another FYI: If you buy DRMd movies by Disney or three of the other four major movie studios, from either iTunes, Vudu, Google Play or Amazon and link your accounts with Movies Anywhere, they will show up as purchased movies in your other libraries as if you purchased them from the other services.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by StillBored on Monday June 18, 2018 @03:14PM (#17340865)
Do you think its going to be "all" content or just the couple hundred titles they think you should watch this month?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:54PM (#17341617)
For kids, that would probably be enough....
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Benji_San on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:45AM (#17337770)
I would be OK with occasionally paying for other streaming services than Netflix if they actually worked, I.e. better than torrents and preferably on Netflix's level.

The other services available in the Nordics are not even close with some "not working at all" and some have shitty/exclusive device support. Subtitle/language options tend to be abysmal and Netflix, which isn't very good on this front, seems to be the winner there too.

I'm more or less still waiting for Steam for films and TV series where I could just download the video file with whatever audio/language track I want. Providing a Netflix quality streaming service seems to be ridiculously non-trivial so it would be great if less complex and better working solutions were offered until the streaming platforms are figured out. Until that happens torrents offer a vastly superior way to watch content that is not on Netflix.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rayiner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:43PM (#17333646)
What you’re proposing would lead to a terrible market structure. It would eliminate the most important differentiating factor: content. Subscribing to multiple streaming services might be somewhat less convenient, but it also allows competition based on producing and distributing quality content.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:54PM (#17333692)
Subscribing to many services because each offers some exclusive stuff is inconvenient and taxes the user with the overhead of each service. People want to find more in their favorite stores.

If creators would have been independent of distributors, this wouldn't have been a problem to begin with. Each creator would distribute in each store. But all this integration causes exclusivity that only inconveniences the end user. Netflix isn't any better in this sense, since they have tons of exclusives too. Competition on exclusivity is not good in the end and only benefits the distributor.

In this sense, the idea above is spot on. How are these fragmented services (with DRM to boot) going to compete with torrents that offer everything without DRM through unified hubs? Film makers need to pull stuff together and fix it.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:51PM (#17333973)
The whole spiel about DRM is that you don’t truly own the content you buy and the inconvenience of not being able to use the content on the device of your choice.

When you subscribe to streaming services you aren’t paying for ownership, you are paying for access. As far as convenience, the major streaming services are all on the web for computers and they all have apps for everything imaginable. Netflix, Hulu, et. al. are much more convenient that piracy. Besides they said the same thing about iTunes back in 2003. I stopped pirating music when the iTunes Misic Store was introduced. I definitely wouldn’t worry about pirating now over paying $15/month for the family Apple Music plan.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:18PM (#17334122)
> When you subscribe to streaming services you aren’t paying for ownership, you are paying for access.

I personally prefer to avoid DRMed services and buy DRM-free. It's reasonably good with music and games for example, but with films you barely can find anything that way.

The reason for renting digital goods is usually presented as an option to get it for lower prices, even though there is no scarcity like with physical goods. That's fine, people might want to rent something and pay less. But why does it mean there should be no option to buy (for higher price)? That is already not right, i.e. forcing renting only approach. That's why I quite dislike DRM attached to renting services as well.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:23PM (#17334679)
It’s not about “scarcity”. Content costs money to make. Should developers not get paid because once they create a piece of software it can be infinitely reproduced?

How much would you be willing to pay for all the content you can get on Netflix, Hulu, etc.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:50PM (#17334818)
> It’s not about “scarcity”.

Renting for physical goods has scarcity involved. To make a new item, you have constant expenses, thus when you rent it, avoiding that expense allows lower price.

With digital goods, you have fixed expense, which after it's paid off has no constant expense involved. So the above renting logic isn't applicable. The remaining reason for renting to be cheaper is artificial, i.e. its limited nature, that prevents you from making backups and etc. That crippling of the product makes it cheaper, but the whole crippling is artificial to begin with.

> How much would you be willing to pay for all the content you can get on Netflix, Hulu, etc.

Depending on the film, may be different prices. Definitely more for something I'd watch more than once.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:53PM (#17334833)
Does that mean every single software as a service company business model is invalid?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:01PM (#17334871)
> Does that mean every single software as a service company business model is invalid?

I'm OK with someone offering digital renting, if there is an option to buy the same thing (though I wouldn't use it if it has DRM). I'm not OK with it, if renting only is mandated.

Software as a service isn't exactly the same case as buying books, films, music, games and etc. For instance Web search is software as a service and I'm OK with it running remotely (though decentralized search is a way to improve it in theory). But when I listen to music and the like, I want to have a backup of it and run and use it on any device I want, and not on what some DRM authorized it for on condition of some existing account.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:21PM (#17334953)
How is Netflix, Hulu, etc. not the same? You pay $10.99 a month and get unlimited access to an entire library of content. What device that you own can’t play Spotify music?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:19PM (#17335123)
As I explained above, their problem is offering renting only video which you can't buy.

> What device that you own can’t play Spotify music?

Anything they didn't think about? DRM-free formats can be accessed anywhere, you can re-encode them in any codec and etc. For example I can take my audio files and play them in RockBox on my portable Sansa player. How would Spotify help for that? Benefits of DRM-free are quite self explanatory.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:11PM (#17335296)
I have 700 songs in my various Spotify playlists and growing. Back in the day I would have had to pay $700 for my songs. Now so pay $10 a month.

I pay $10.99 for Netflix. That doesn’t pay for one movie, let alone a dvd box set.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:12PM (#17335507)
I don't mind paying to creators for the music I'm listening to. Didn't you yourself say that it costs money to make?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:09AM (#17335975)
They are getting paid. I've never suggested pirating media. The streaming media companyed pay the creators. Netflix alone pays billions per year for Netflix.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:26AM (#17336014)
So do DRM-free stores like Bandcamp.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:55AM (#17337524)
All purchased digital music has been DRM free for a decade.

Netflix says we watched about 60 hours last month and my son watched 5 seasons of "Everybody Hates Chris" on Hulu - combined price of both services was $23 a month. How much would that cost to buy?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:57AM (#17337536)
> How much would that cost to buy?

Price usually depends on many factors of the market. But if it's not available at all, it doesn't matter how much you would be willing to pay - you can't buy it, period.

> All purchased digital music has been DRM free for a decade.

So if music can be sold DRM-free in parallel to renting services, what problem is there with video that prevents it?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:07AM (#17338343)
Commercial video for the most part has always been copy protected even in the analog days with Macrovision.

From a historical reason, the only reason we have DRM free music sells is because of Apple. In 2008, the music industry was trying to pressure Apple into licensing its DRM scheme so that competitors could sell music compatible with iPods. Steve Jobs countered saying that if the music industry would sell all of their music DRM free, there would be cross platform compatibility [1]. The movie industry didn’t make the same mistake the music industry did. They allowed multiple companies to buy and rent movies so Apple wouldn’t have the same power they had over music over movies.

As far as the cost to buy movies, you don’t have to guess. Most popular movies cost $14.99 to own and the less popular movies are $9.99.

The box set for “Everybody Hates Chris” is $110.00 on Amazon. So to buy all of the content we watched between Hulu and Netflix would be at least $700 - as opposed to $24.

[1] Thoughts on Music (http://macdailynews.com/2007/02/06/apple_ceo_steve_jobs_post...)

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:55AM (#17338686)
We are talking about buying DRM-free digital films. Who sells them now at scale? I doubt you can draw pricing parallels with sales of physical legacy media (optical disks).

And there is no valid reason for them lacking, all reasons are invalid and crooked. The last major push for that was from GOG, and it didn't go far because of backwards thinking lawyers:

https://www.gog.com/forum/general/introducing_gogcom_drmfree...

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:12AM (#17338818)
We are talking about buying DRM-free digital films. Who sells them now at scale? I doubt you can draw pricing parallels with sales of physical legacy media (optical disks).

Why do you think that making them DRM free would cost less? Today the cost of digital movies is between $9.99 and $14.99 and the cost of a season of Everybody Hates Chris is $20 on iTunes.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by shmerl on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:40AM (#17339050)
Digital product should cost less than physical, since there is no expense of printing physical disks. But if it already costs so for DRMed digital, then sure, price won't likely be less.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:47PM (#17340155)
Digital product should cost less than physical, since there is no expense of printing physical disks. But if it already costs so for DRMed digital, then sure, price won't likely be less.

The cost of manufacturing a disc is less than a buck in volume (http://www.dvdreplication.com/blu-raydiscmanufacturing.htm). The cost of a movie is in mostly in creating the content.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mikeash on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:31PM (#17334441)
Music seems to have no trouble competing on quality content despite the nearly identical catalogs of the various streaming services. You just allocate subscription money based on plays (or whatever other metric approximates “how much the paying customers like this”) and it works fine.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by AnAfrican on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:32AM (#17337383)
Music production costs are much much lower than TV/Movies.

The argument is that differentiation (and then exclusive content) is the reason why content distributors are willing to take risks.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by mikeash on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:54PM (#17341961)
TV production has typically been tied to consumer channels, but movies certainly haven't. Back in the day, we'd go to the video store and find tapes (and later DVDs) from all the major studies. Today, you'll find them all on places like the iTunes store. Throughout that time, theaters have carried movies from many different studios. It seems to work fine, and I don't see why subscription services would be different. (Netflix did a DVD subscription service for years, still does, with a broad catalog.)

Content distributors don't need to take risks. Theaters do a bit, because screens are limited. Stores do a tiny bit, because shelf space is limited. Online services don't have to at all. The producers take the big risks, but I don't see why that should imply that streaming services have to involve exclusivity agreements.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Thriptic on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:01PM (#17333735)
That would be true if each of these services had enough unique content to stand on it's own. Netflix does, Amazon does, and HBO does if you take their entire historical cannon into account. The rest of the services (Starz, Cinemax, Hulu, Showtime et al) have 1-2 great exclusives and a bunch of old so-so content.

I shouldn't have to pay for 5 additional instances of Netflix to get one instance of Netflix worth of quality content. You were late to market and lost, deal with it and list your content on Netflix or Amazon, band together to form a joint competitor, or service a niche market like what Crunchyroll did with anime.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rayiner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:14PM (#17333808)
If you don’t want to subscribe, then don’t. But these services are cheap compared to what they’re replacing. The average cable bill is over $100. These streaming services are the a la carte channels everyone was always saying they wanted in the bad old days when content was bundled together in cable packages.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ryandrake on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:13PM (#17334923)
What we have today is far from a la carte. Yesterday: if you want shows 1, 2, and 3, you have to purchase cable bundles A, B, and C, even if you don’t watch 99% of the content in those bundles, since the shows were spread across those bundles. Today: if you want shows 1, 2, and 3, you have to subscribe to streaming service A, B, and C. There is almost no difference, except now you’re paying three separate companies instead of one for 99% of content you don’t watch.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by hsod on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:05PM (#17335271)
You can buy shows and movies a la carte on iTunes and Amazon Video if you want. Perhaps a company should create a $9/month streaming service where each customer gets to choose their catalog personally.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Thriptic on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:34PM (#17333900)
Most of these services are the same a la carte premium channels that already existed 10 years ago for roughly the same price (HBO, Starz, Cinemax, and Showtime). Little has changed except the content delivery mechanism and availability of content on demand.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rayiner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:40PM (#17333923)
It’s completely different now—they’re no longer tied to an expensive cable package with a bunch of other channels you don’t want.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ryandrake on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:14PM (#17334927)
Right. They are instead tied to slightly less expensive streaming bundles with a bunch of other content you don’t want. Completely different.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by friedman23 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:31PM (#17334184)
> Little has changed except the content delivery mechanism and availability of content on demand.

What? You don't need to pay $100 for cable anymore, how is it that nothing has changed? Anyway, I think arguing with you is pointless, pirates will always find a way to justify their behavior.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Thriptic on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:17PM (#17334384)
A. I've never advocated for piracy anywhere here, so I'm very confused as to where you got that from. If my intent was to pirate, why would I even be a part of this discussion? Please engage in honest discourse or don't bother posting.

B. If I have to pay for a live sports package and 5 streaming networks to watch what I want, then I'm not really saving much money (if any). A move to a la carte content should result in a substantial cost savings, not a marginal cost savings. Netflix has set the bar at $10 per month for access to a massive catalog of content across networks. By default, this means no one (except maybe HBO) should be charging anywhere near this amount of money for access to their content library which is not nearly as deep or as high quality.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by DmenshunlAnlsis on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:44PM (#17334239)
Right, now you spend for Netflix, Hulu, Amazon, HBO, Showtime, Stars, CBS, and soon Disney. Plus Crunchyroll if you like anime, plus a sports package for sports.

If this keeps going $100 will seem like a bargain, and piracy will surge.

I also think it’s rude and out of line to tell someone that arguing with them is pointless. Do the mature thing and just stop responding, or the even more useful thing and actually try to have the conversation.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by friedman23 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:07PM (#17334584)
>Right, now you spend for Netflix, Hulu, Amazon, HBO, Showtime, Stars, CBS, and soon Disney. Plus Crunchyroll if you like anime, plus a sports package for sports.

And why are you subscribed to every single streaming platform? Do you actually need to watch every single show you might possibly like?

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by DmenshunlAnlsis on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:29PM (#17334714)
I’m not, but neither is that the point. Obviously no one needs any of this, it’s always a matter of want. The question is how much it costs to get it, today, yesterday, and tomorrow. People crowing about the downfall of cable packages while ignoring splintering subscriptions for the same content are missing that point, don’t you think?

The point is that it seems media companies, in their greed, have forgotten that streaming only works when it offers something better than piracy. A dozen subscriptions that cost more than a cable package did is offering less, with more impediments to use than a Kodi box. The model will, as a previous poster said, fail. The attempt turn everything from software to hardware into a subscription service, because it’s the easiest way to milk money isn’t some god-given right of corporations either.

Now you can yell about entitlement and whatever else, and I’m not wading into that mess, just explaining how it is based on past precedent.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ryandrake on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:17PM (#17334938)
I think he is simply addressing the argument that today’s environment (multiple streaming services each with exclusive content) is any different than yesterday when it was multiple cable bundles each with exclusive channels.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by friedman23 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @11:18PM (#17335805)
Of course it is different, today you can pick and choose what you want whereas before you needed to buy the entire thing
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Thriptic on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:04AM (#17337242)
You're speaking as if there are only two models: pay a lot for everything or pay for individual channels or shows. I want neither of those things. I want the Spotify model, where I pay 9.99 per month and I get 80% of all music across genres. I'm willing to pay for 1-2 of such services but not 5-6.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by scarface74 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:45PM (#17333950)
Hulu’s biggest appeal for a cable cutter is day after content with no commercials from the major networks and their back catalog of TV is not bad.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by macspoofing on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:16PM (#17334937)
>I have bad news for them: you're going to lose. People don't want to go back to paying $100/month for a dozen streaming "channels" with one or two good shows and a the same crap the rest of the other "channels" have.

No. That's not the correct way to think about this. You are dreaming if you think media and production companies are going to leave $90/mo on the table. You will see prices rise. You will see multiple streaming services. You will see bills in the same ballpark as those of cable/satellite ... because that's about the sweet spot for people willing to spend monthly for media content.

>We want an on-demand nexus. A single hub.

You won't get it. Nobody is going to let anyone control all media distribution.

>So I have to pay an addition $7/month to watch a single show?

Yeah. Or you can just pass on that single show.

>Off to a torrent site or asking around to see if someone has rips or a box set. I have better things to do with $7 like buy dinner.

Age of piracy is going to end as well. And by the way, you are free to go and buy dinner and read a book. Nobody needs to watch the latest season of GoT - its not a human right. Talk about entitled!

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by paulie_a on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:41PM (#17335004)
Then fuck it, I will pay for some cheap streaming services and pirate the rest.. And pirating content is not going to end ever. If anything it has become easier to do. And lately easier to do than use the legitimate streaming service. I've actually was trying to watch a movie through a paid service this weekend and basically said "fuck it" watched it on a copyright infringing service within 45 seconds.

I honestly no longer care about copyright or piracy. I simply will do whatever is easiest. The greed of the entertainment industry has made me not give a shit.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by vlozko on Monday June 18, 2018 @09:20AM (#17337994)
> The greed of the entertainment industry has made me not give a shit.

> I will pay for some cheap streaming services and pirate the rest.

I'm still trying to wrap my head around the hypocrisy here.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by SimbaOnSteroids on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:33PM (#17335166)
>Age of piracy is going to end as well.

I don't know how to break this to you but as long as there are more than one country there's going to be one that will not hunt down the privateers of the other.

>You are dreaming if you think media and production companies are going to leave $90/mo on the table. You will see prices rise.

Then so do my sails

>Talk about entitled!

Not really, I'm willing to pay you something for it, just not the scalpers price you want me to pay to test the waters. If a show is really good I buy it on blueray because I value the show and want more of it/want to reward the quality of the show. If studios weren't greedy and produced objectively garbage content I would buy a product on faith but in a world where there are how many Pirates of the Caribbean movies, I'll be more skeptical.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by macspoofing on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:52PM (#17335414)
>I don't know how to break this to you but as long as there are more than one country there's going to be one that will not hunt down the privateers of the other.

Ok. Piracy will be made harder and harder, to the point where it will be inaccessible to mainstream. This also means that the tech savvy pirates will be more exposed.

>If studios weren't greedy and produced objectively garbage content I would buy a product on faith but in a world where there are how many Pirates of the Caribbean movies, I'll be more skeptical.

That entire paragraph is weirdly nonsensical. You don't have an ineliable right to watch movies, you aren't the universal judge of movie quality (lots of people like the Pirates of the Caribbean movies), and you aren't entitled to dictate how you want the business of media to operate (i.e. you get to pick how much or how little you pay). It's one thing to pirate, it's another to think you're a 'good guy'.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by sean2 on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:28PM (#17342477)
I'm not the author of GP, but I'm really feeling his vibe.

> You don't have an inalienable right to watch movies

If you include news and documentaries, I kinda do. Though not quite as righteous, I get a little indignant that some company gets to dictate how much I'll have to pay to remain informed of our shared (though purely-entertainment) culture.

> universal judge of movie quality

The word "objectively" here is used like "literally", a in a meaningless sentence enhancer.

> you aren't entitled to dictate how you want the business of media to operate

I think I should be, it's my money I'm giving them after all, I'd like to have a vote in the content, how I access it, and even how much it's worth.

>(i.e. you get to pick how much or how little you pay)

Demand and supply: if you want to charge more than I want to see your service I guess I can unsubscribe; I wish we could barter about it. However, if I have to pay $39.99/month for who knows how long to watch one documentary, which I know was dirt cheap to make, I'm going to feel so morally justified while I pirate it that I will indeed think I'm the 'good guy'.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by jacoblambda on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:58PM (#17335720)
I'd like to hear how you think piracy will be made more difficult. I'm not trying to be antagonistic, I am just curious as I have only seen the piracy community grow in recent years.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Crespyl on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:08PM (#17339844)
It's not so much that the act of fetching and viewing pirated content will become more difficult, it's that rightsholders will continue to apply more and more restrictive techniques and outright deny content to paying customers.

See the new DRM features in Windows 10 and the way the Windows Store version of Netflix interacts with perfectly legitimate screenshot tools, or the way Netflix simply refuses to provide 4k content to any other platform.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by DrJaws on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:31PM (#17334979)
some poeple will just go back to p2p and there is nothing they can do.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by macspoofing on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:47PM (#17335027)
I think you'll find avenues for piracy are going to be limited. Even now piracy isn't quite the same as it used to be.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by LeoNatan25 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:03PM (#17335458)
Easier than ever to get season packs, rips, remuxes. And that’s downloads. If you want to stream, it’s even easier.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by freeone3000 on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:55AM (#17336085)
You're right, instead of getting a XDCC link from a listserv, you now buy a modded HTPC off Craigslist. It's way easier to pirate things now.

People are pirating music. Off youtube. ACCIDENTALLY. To the point where there's an elaborate automated filtering system. It's not even viewed as piracy!

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rileyphone on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:48AM (#17336067)
The fact is the reason anyone pays for content online is because the cost to access it is less than the cost to download and manage it as well as the possible cost of acquiring it is less than the cost of accessing it, which goes down the more content can be accessed. Every monthly subscription has an additional cost of maintaining beyond it's numenary value which quickly bring them above just torrenting the content. Ultimately the content is just constant information, which is pretty cheap on the internet.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Karishma1234 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:33PM (#17334454)
Well the ATT and other behemoths are set for a massive failure. Their core business has been navigating regulatory mazes while trying to seek near monopoly and push expensive and crappy subscriptions down the throats of old and gullible people.

With each passing Year Netflix and Hulu are adding more and more original content which is becoming part of pop-culture. Within 5 years most of the cool things we want to watch would be from Netflix and Hulu and everything else would come from torrents or youtube.

Dinosaurs are dying and we should cheer.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by paul7986 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:57PM (#17334559)
Hulu is owned by Fox, Comcast, Warner and Disney.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by heroprotagonist on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:37PM (#17334472)
Once that torrent download becomes 'Miscellaneous data' charged per gigabyte due to loss of net neutrality, won't that encourage you through their preferred channel?

Personally, I'll start reading books more but I imagine 90% of my country won't. They'll go through the service that has a deal with their ISP.

The scarier part being that regardless of whether I go through the recommended source or disregard the content altogether, it's an impact on the information and ideas I consume.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by tzs on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:36PM (#17333911)
> Just the other day I had the urge to watch ghost in the shell. Not available on any of the major streaming sites (Netflix, Hulu, Prime) but available on stars via prime ... Off to a torrent site or asking around to see if someone has rips or a box set. I have better things to do with $7 like buy dinner

Or you could have rented the Blu-ray at Redbox for $2 (or streamed it from Redbox for $5).

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by bonyt on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:44PM (#17334235)
I recently started collecting blu-rays. A lot of them are available for $5-6 and I like having a shelf and feeling some sense of ownership over them (bizzare DRM aside[1]). Best Buy has a bargain bin with some gems, Book-off in NYC has a nice wall of $4-10 used blu-rays too, and I’m sure other places do too.

[1]: With BD+, the disc maker adds artifacts into the bitstream, and then includes executable code for a VM that can look around, see if it is satisfied with its environment, and correct the artifacts. Seriously. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/BD%2B

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by YokoZar on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:47PM (#17333958)
Or streamed it from Google Play for $2
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:32PM (#17334192)
How does any of this change the OP's point about fragmentation of the market? It does nothing to benefit the consumer, the competition is not lowering prices, so why would consumers not go back to piracy when it results in a superior product?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rainbowmverse on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:11PM (#17334351)
Some of us have this bizarre wish to support the companies and people who produce things we enjoy even if they sometimes make it difficult.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:37PM (#17334473)
I pay for things I could steal as well, because I like to support those companies. However what we have here is an entire industry working towards setting up their offerings as a worse product than free. Not just more expensive than free, but an objectively worse product, and they've acommplished this in part by eroding consumer rights.

You might expect some people to take an extremely principled stance but it would be unreasonable to expect the majority of society to do so when the companies themselves are operating as unprincipled entities.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rainbowmverse on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:22PM (#17334674)
The choice isn't between stealing and paying for it. Choosing something else is the principled stand.

There's plenty of good media out there to support without stealing. I'd rather grab an eBook from the library (they get paid) or buy a random indie album on Bandcamp than spend time on media published by people who don't respect their customers.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by DmenshunlAnlsis on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:35PM (#17334744)
Oh please. So individuals have to play by a rigged and ever-changing set of rules laid down by media conglomerate lobbyists and copyright lawyers, or they’re unprincipled? By that logic everyone would still be buying CD’s with malware from brick and mortar stores because Sony makes more money that way than with iTunes or Spotify. The media landscape today didn’t just happen, it’s the result of a tension between different forces, and you don’t want to see what it looks like if one group lets go. Pirates were the first digital distributors, most not out of selfish desire to get something for free, which was proven by the overwhelming support for legal digital distribution.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:32PM (#17334732)
Art doesn't have competition in many cases. There is no alternative good to "Gone in the Wind", it is a unique product with a monoply on it due to copyright.

Many of these companies, and Disney especially,have done their best to prevent works from falling into the public domain when they make a lot of money off of deriviations of public domain works

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by YokoZar on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:47PM (#17334514)
The larger point is that if you're willing to pay a la carte for individual shows/films (rather than a subscription service), basically all content is acceptable from a lot of providers.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by consumethreads on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:05PM (#17334328)
because we are not cheap and are ok with paying for a service.

How cheap should it be. There will be no service that people will pay for if they pirate content. The service they want is a service where they dont have to pay.

If you are pirating you are not a customer. Any business man should not be concerned with trying to gain your market, its not profitable.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:39PM (#17334479)
Steam, iTunes, and Spotify have almost completely killed off pirating for games and music. It's still possible but people would rather pay for those services because the services actually add a value over the actual data which is post scarcity.

TV and the film industry have decided they'll make more money by making a worse product and doing everything they can to prevent users from finding alternatives

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by closetCS on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:21PM (#17334952)
I'm not quite sure about this, but aren't the products you have mentioned also have the same problem as Netflix. Spotify is able to provide lots of music options, but for how long? They are being effectively strangled by music labels and competitors, which will eventually lead to a content fragmentation between music streaming services. Then people will turn back to pirating music just as fast and they have for video. I'm not sure about steam , but I'm sure that eventually the gaming industry will face the same problem, it's only a matter of time.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by lovich on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:44PM (#17335018)
Yes, if their products value F(steam) < F(free) then of course people will pirate. Why would you expect consumers to pay for a product that is inferior to something that was left untouched? Why should a firm exist when they supply negative value to their consumers? It would be the same situation as it was 10 years ago in the heyday of pirating and companies should expect to lose out on income, in this case the music labels

If this was a natural state of affairs there might be considerations about morals, but the current rules and laws came about through direct intervention by these same companies

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by godelski on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:59PM (#17334867)
> If you are pirating you are not a customer. Any business man should not be concerned with trying to gain your market, its not profitable.

A poor businessman. A good businessman sees the black market and determines if they can provide a similar service in the white market. Clearly there are consumers and they want something that they aren't getting already.

And in this case, things like popcorn time have a great interface and are easier than most streaming services.

People want to see new movies in their homes (and I always laugh at the "no movie should be reduced to this shrinks from theater screen to computer screen, because clearly people like it that way).

And people want to see population and good movies at the top of their lists, not problem garbage. There's a lot of people that complain about even Netflix because of this. Their recommendation engine isn't what it used to be.

There's a lot more reasons too. People pirate for many more reasons than because it's free, though that definitely is a big component. But people seem to be ignoring these other reasons.

There's a market, or two, here that aren't being served. A good businessman would serve them.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Latteland on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:21PM (#17334398)
Or signed up for a temporary membership to stars. That's my go to method of seeing things I want. It's gotten so that I have had so many temporary membership I have to keep track of them in a spreadsheet.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by chrismcb on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:12AM (#17336130)
Instead of stealing" it, you could have just rented it. There was a time if you wanted to watch a show you went down and rented it.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by always_good on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:24PM (#17334408)
> We want an on-demand nexus.

Ah right, the utopia of extreme centralization I keep hearing HNers rave about.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by phobosdeimos on Monday June 18, 2018 @09:42AM (#17338145)
Technically pirates figured that one out a long time ago.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by im3w1l on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:17PM (#17334939)
Careful what you wish for, because that hub will be censored and the useful idiots will scream that it's not censorship if it's not the government.

I'd much rather a very very fragmented space with lots of diverse productions and perspectives.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by JohnJamesRambo on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:55PM (#17335428)
How noble of you to steal what you didn’t want to pay for to fulfill your urge. Do you try this at the grocery store also when you get frustrated by the prices charged by the people that created the items?
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by IntelMiner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:29PM (#17335592)
Piracy is not the same as theft. Please do not conflate the two
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by SomewhatLikely on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:42AM (#17336361)
We have the nexus for music and I assume for books, not sure why video is still a hold out except I believe music and books are more regulated.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by tootie on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:38PM (#17334996)
Rent it. Usually $4 on Amazon or Google or Vudu.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rhino369 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:01PM (#17333453)
>We want an on-demand nexus. A single hub.

So you want one company to control all media? Seems like a poor plan longterm.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by woolvalley on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:09PM (#17333499)
There seems to be quite a few available for music. Using apple music, spotify, tidal or whatever else doesn't seem to have the exclusivity problems that TV equivalents have.

I can probably count the number of exclusive artists to each music provider on my hand.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:46PM (#17333668)
They're trying to recreate the cable TV channel package model on the internet, because it's a mechanism for price discrimination.

If you make twenty shows and you want to sell subscriptions a la carte, how much do you charge per show? If you charge $10/month per show then you lose the business of everyone who might have paid you anything even slightly less than that. If you charge $.50/month per show to get those customers, you lose $9.50/month from everyone who would have paid $10/month per show. But if you put all twenty shows together in a bundle and sell them collectively for $10/month, you get $10/month from everyone who values the collection of shows at $10/month or more, regardless of the value they place on each individual show. Which can turn out to be more money.

But that is less likely to work in a more competitive market. People only have so many hours to watch television. It may be worth $10/month for a package of shows to get the one you really want when that's the only option, but when someone else is offering an equivalently good show a la carte for $10/year and you don't have time to watch both, people will choose the one that saves them $90/year worth of shows they weren't actually interested in.

The broader problem is that without a distribution monopoly to use as a chokepoint, content creation is a highly competitive market, and highly competitive markets have low margins. So the incumbents are flailing around trying to find something that looks like the model they're used to, even though that model is now defunct.

The model which is likely to out-compete a la carte is the one where content producers make non-exclusive licenses to multiple aggregation companies that sell flat rate plans to their customers. Because $10/month for twenty shows can't out-compete $10/year for the one show you actually want anymore, but $20/month for every show can.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:56PM (#17335714)
This is actually untrue: Jay-Z and Beyonce's new album is Tidal exclusive, and I just saw someone complaining about it on social media today. I'd expect this trend to increase, not decrease, over time.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rhino369 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:14PM (#17333809)
There are laws that set statutory royalty fees for music recordings, which strongly encourages non-exclusive licensing, even when those laws don't apply.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by drngdds on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:14PM (#17333521)
There could be many such hubs. They don't have to control the content, just buy the (non-exclusive) right to distribute it.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by bertjk on Sunday June 17, 2018 @04:16PM (#17334111)
And how would you suggest that these many hubs differentiate themselves to compete for your business? If your answer is "they can compete on price," then I think you've just answered the question of why they don't want to do it that way.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by tomjen3 on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:37AM (#17336036)
Useability. Netflix is so much better at their apps and website than anybody else I have seen.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by rhino369 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:11PM (#17333795)
So much content is already locked behind exclusive streaming rights. I don't see how this would happen without extensive regulation.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Mindwipe on Sunday June 17, 2018 @03:07PM (#17333777)
Non-exclusive distribution is a failed business model.

Exclusivity works. Most of the population don't torrent. Exclusivity drives subscriptions.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by Spivak on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:07PM (#17333486)
Don't really care if it's a single company so long as they operate actually independently of content production and are only a distributor.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by petre on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:56AM (#17336088)
They will bundle Internet subscriptions with cable plans. UPC already does that.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by NicoJuicy on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:11AM (#17336253)
Well, except if your kids want it. Disney is probably in a good position there
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by SllX on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:11PM (#17334605)
You have it backwards: a la carte is exactly what people want. If they didn’t, they wouldn’t pay for so many different subscriptions.
Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:46PM (#17335673)
The idea you'd be able to see everything you want for $9/month when the going rate was $100/month is and remains an utter fantasy. There is no way, shape, or form where the industry is going to suddenly operate on 90% less income.

Ironically, when you ask for one big hub, you're asking for a traditional cable subscription: Comcast will give you most of the channels out there (often, throwing HBO in for free), and due to the APIs the major ISPs and channels are on board with, you can either watch them on Comcast's site or the individual channel websites. Oh, and Comcast boxes now integrate your Netflix subscription too.

Cable packages when bundled with Internet service are often pretty price-competitive for what they offer. I recently left Comcast, but picked up their competitors' cable package for the same reasons: It's a pretty inclusive streaming package for a good price.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by felipemnoa on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:54PM (#17335708)
>>The idea you'd be able to see everything you want for $9/month when the going rate was $100/month is and remains an utter fantasy. There is no way, shape, or form where the industry is going to suddenly operate on 90% less income.

Reminds me of at&t. They made boatloads of money at one time until they didn't. I'm sure they didn't like it when suddenly their main product, long distance calls, became dirt cheap. I still remember paying huge amounts of money in late 1990s to make calls from NYC to Buffalo. The whole thing was such a big racket.

I for one will not shed a single tear if these companies go out of business. Some other companies will take their place.

Re:Netflix Is Why AT&T bought Time Warner, and Comcast and D... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:57PM (#17335717)
Bear in mind, everyone's talking about how must-see a given TV show is, and how much they loathe "having to" shell out money to see it on X streaming service.

Prices go down when demand is low. Demand for TV is not low, ergo, prices are not going to go down.

Also, when it does, the first casualty isn't going to be the companies: It's going to be the shows you love. People on HN were thrilled when Amazon saved The Expanse. But if The Expanse doesn't drive X number of new Prime subscribers, it won't be around much longer than that.