As an aside, my time there was a hugely formative experience for me. Given a $500K budget and armed with nothing more than a little sql, I was able to immediately start saving the company multi-millions of dollars annually. I was considered a big star among the fresh batch of talent they inhaled that year, but I left because I could see the writing on the wall about the industry. Given the bailout and all that, I am pretty happy with that decision.
This is kind of irrelevant, but somewhat amusing, so I figure I'll tell it. My neighbour (in the middle of nowhere in rural Japan) was some kind of automotive manufacturing expert before he retired. I don't even know his name (he tells me to call him "Tom"), but we go out drinking occasionally. He must have been a big wig because he spent a considerable amount of time in the US and even has a personally signed thank you card from George Bush Sr.
Anyway, we were at the bar and I was telling him about the use of kanban in software development. My wife interrupted and asked what kanban was (because in Japanese "kanban" just means "signboard"). I tried to explain the concept, but she remained confused. He said, "I can explain it very easily". He picked up an empty plate and handed it to my wife. "We're out of fish", he said, motioning to the bar. :-)
I don't get it.
Only, we've caught almost all the tuna in the ocean, so please make sure to ask for something else at the bar.
Edit: Just to be clear, that was not Tom's point. His point was that the plate was empty, so by simply noticing it is empty, we can ask for more fish which "pulls" all the activity that ends up producing fish on our plate. In a kanban system, you only really need to worry about how much inventory you want to carry at each station and the connection to the previous station.
If you don't ask for it you don't get it.
Its just a organized way of building a todo list which has a few features like:
1. Priority.
2. Ability to see the work-item move through various stages of work(Accepted, in-progress, blocked-by, done).
3. Means to track the progress of the work-item.
4. Means to the improve the process through methods described by the process.
That's actually a very meta reply (like that joke about UDP).
Tesla have been trying to and they are still running into many problems, many industry veteran hires and tens of thousands of cars sold later.
I have talked to many people who have worked/work in production as well, and unfortunately they don't share with you the same optimism on how easy it is to scale up supply chain for a large scale luxury auto company. Daimler-Benz has had major reliability problems with both Chrysler and Mercedes and it took Mercedes over a decade to get back to industry average, while Chrysler is still in the gutters.
If I had to guess right now, many years after leaving I would guess that Chrysler will eternally be a fail, it's culture is just wrong at every level. Tesla isn't hamstrung by that, or the UAW either (yet).
Except they are. The Model S is 5 years old (even the refresh model is a year old) and they are still running into parts and build issues. It has improved a long way but during the whole process they had to cut the number of interior and exterior colors/trims just to streamline the production. Other manufacturers introduces new fit/finish and trim options along a model's life span and Tesla does the opposite.
Case in point, the original P85+ came with sports trims inside (such as the red piping on the leather seats) and some unique fit and finishes, with unique sports suspensions and chassis tuning. But later on they eliminated all of those and now a top of the line P100D have the exact interior trim and chassis tuning as the cheapest S60 that cost less than half as much, all for the sake of streamlined production.
And even then they can't find parts for when cars need service or are in an accident.
The in 98 along comes that infamous Daimler Mercedes merger where Mercedes basically looted Chrysler to prop themselves up. At that time Chrysler was making money hand over fist with their minivan.
Once bled dry, a lot because most new car projects dried up or worse, the platform sharing using older Mercedes setups, they got sold to an investment firm. There were even claims of value gone missing during that sale.
A more apt comparison is watching GM. After bankruptcy they still pushed out the first generation Volt, the second generation took longer but arrive in 2016. However the real kicked was how fast the Bolt went from conception to production. In 2015 it was shown in concept, Jan 2016 in production form, and in customer hands by end of the same year.
The Bolt on the other hand, seems to addressed all those. The local car show is in a couple of weeks and I hope to see one there.
Totally agree about "The merger of equals". No such thing. The Germans took Chrysler for everything they could, like you said - to prop up product quality disasters like the ML and E class (a coworker went through 5 window regulators on his E-430 over 2 years. I had something break on my ML-320 on average every 8.5 weeks)
My mom bought a Chrysler LeBaron that, in one year of ownership, the brakes, exhaust, cylinder head, a/c and shock absorbers required service. We were later informed by a federal court that her car was one of the "rollback" vehicles. Chrysler denied it and basically told us "see you in court."
What I mean is, you appear to be trying to apply the standard of a very broadly experienced car magazine critic, which yes, will absolutely 100% find a laundry list of grave shortcomings. And they won't matter.
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/06/23/the-disruption-...
I'd say a company like Foxconn is probably a much better example. They are able to mass produce millions of widgets with astonishingly few defects and even begin doing it in secret. Very impressive logistics. If just one component of the iPhone isn't ready the whole line grinds to a halt.
Yes, this is a chicken-and-egg problem. But a real one nonetheless.
fyi, I cut my teeth on WK1 and WK2. I love JNAP, and Jeep - I found a home there.
Final Vehicle is concerned with testing and certification and whatever other finishing touches need to be performed. It also operates the repair department, and the 'yard' with all the defect jobs. Our yard was so packed the company was renting new yards away from the factory.
The repairmen who worked in the bays and yard were stone cold experts on the vehicles and they kept written logs. Those logs were typed up and put in the database by the office clerks. These were mostly signal. There were also networked terminals at some stations but not all down the line.
Finding the root cause of an issue was basically like git-bisect. You knew where a part was added and where it ended up. So you just needed to narrow it down. For a high priority issue, I'd go do a visual inspection myself at the mid station before a part got covered by another part. Broken? Go to the mid station between here and start. Not broken, go the other way. We got stumped sometimes, but mostly we could narrow it down pretty fast. For the workers, it's impossible to lose your job so there isn't a care factor about covering up shoddy workmanship.
Wow.
Blah blah make better software blah blah world makes better idiots.
Yeah, that's pretty much it. The question then is do you think they can fix the issues that lead to those negative experiences with a little bit of time, and a billion more dollars?
Yes to all of those. Rationally I can no longer justify this investment to be honest, but I like the Koolaid they are selling too much :/
Disclaimer: I'm long on both TSLA and Solar Bonds. Even if I lose it all, I'm willing to take that risk if it gives them a better chance of successfully executing their mission statement.
That whole part of the system is a rent seeking protection racket.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UZ1XLqc5IUg
I guess it's a good reality check for autonomous cars when you take away the LIDAR toys. One rather important point is that the car often doesn't realize it is screwing up, because quelle surprise, realizing you don't have a correctly detected lane can be just as difficult as detecting one in the first place.
That's an absolute disaster.
How much value are they expecting to get from riding the "Beta" train? There's a huge difference between their self-congratulatory demos of features and the reality here.
Oh, and you have to pay for this.
I can easily see a new version with Lidar coming along and all those old cars not getting that full self-driving update after all, even in places where the law allows it.
Just today I drove by a temporary orange sign saying "X St. closed; use Y St. detour," which I'm sure would have confused a fully autonomous vehicle. I bet we'll get fully autonomous cars to drive on existing roads about the same time we create strong AI.
In any case, I'm pretty sure there shouldn't be a button that instantly makes your car swerve into the ongoing lane..
That local roads update was an embarrassment, what was Tesla thinking? I mean, they're talking L5 by the end of the year, and this is what their autopilot division has to show for themselves.
I'm not disputing that some of the rules around auto sales are problematic, but it seems to me like the limiter on Tesla's ability to sell cars is its ability to produce them.
"I'm not sure anyone should have made this car," he said at a press conference just hours before the first Model Xs were delivered to VIP customers."
""We probably should have just [modified the Model S]," he added. "There are so many more features and difficult to build parts on [the Model X] than it is necessary for us to sell the cars.""
This is one thing I really don't get about Tesla. Why haven't they made an estate-ish version of the Model S? I'm thinking along the lines of the Mercedes CLS Shooting Brake:
http://images.car.bauercdn.com/upload/28771/images/1752x1168...
It's a very nice looking car, and adds that little bit of luggage practicality that the Model S is missing. The aerodynamics aren't much worse than the coupe, so range shouldn't suffer very much.
This has nothing to do with EVs, it has to do with Tesla wanting to sell cars differently than anyone else sells cars. If Tesla wanted to do a dealer model they could certainly give it a go and be treated no differently than any other auto maker.
"Tesla General Counsel Todd Maron argued that the automaker wouldn’t thrive under a franchise dealership model because independent dealers make most of their profit from servicing cars while electric cars have little long-term maintenance and fewer moving parts."
It is true that a Tesla dealership won't be able to charge for oil changes, but tires, suspension, interior fixes (e.g. power windows or that strange squeak) are still required.
It is an easy fix:. Don't charge much for the franchise given the alleged lower service volumes. How many would show up at a Tesla dealership and then be convinced to buy an ICE car? If possible, write the franchise agreement to prohibit colocation with other ICE brands.
But I completely agree with you. I think the Model 3 will end up costing way more that $35k, to turn a profit. The timeline will slip and it won't come out until 2018. The whole solar city deal was premature.
I think Musk knows this isn't going to work, at least for a while. I think he knows Telsa is going to have a more expensive Model 3 and they're going to bleed cash. Telsa will lose money on every sale of the Model 3. I bet money, he plans to ride the stock for the next 5 years until they can get things turned around.
That's Tesla's biggest risk - they can't deliver profitably at the price point they pre-sold at. The Model 3 is an ambitious car to sell for $35K. Tesla is not a "lean manufacturing" operation; their head counts at the auto plant per car sold are currently quite high. They'll probably get that figured out eventually, but meanwhile, they need the high margins of luxury cars.
The timeline will slip and it won't come out until 2018.
Probably. They're claiming "late 2017" now, and new orders won't be processed until 2018.
The whole Solar City deal was premature.
The Solar City operation has political problems. It assumes Government subsidies for solar, which may be going away for political reasons.
Residential solar costs average out at 15c per kWh, post 30% tax credit. If the credit goes away, the 20c per kWh generation cost is still competitive compared to utility's retail rate. The bet is on solar technologies to continue incremental gains in efficiency, pushing the final price per kWh down.
In the commercial and industrial world the cost can be driven down significantly since the installations are larger (4c per kWh is the lowest I've seen), and the one-time installation costs are recouped faster, so that sector is likely to grow with or without tax credits. It's subject to the same efficiency metrics as consumer-grade tech.
[1] https://financere.nrel.gov/finance/content/don%E2%80%99t-be-... [2] http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_juice/2016/01/sol...
Residential has zero transportation cost, post-installation, and I think those solar roof tiles SolarCity pre-announced is an attempt to blend the solar installation costs into the roofing costs. "You are paying the roofing guy for labor and materials to build/replace the roof anyway, so why not pay our roofing guy to build/replace the roof, and get solar as an incredible bonus" is I think their marketing strategy with that.
Isn't their car operation also vulnerable? Tax credits may be less easy to get rid of, from a political perspective, but I think Trump would be far more interested in promoting cars that run on coal than cars that run on electricity.
So it would be better to have electric vehicles than ICE in its current form, but more power grid usage will likely accelerate other technologies rather than make coal profitable again.
On-ramp to Off-ramp
Once on the freeway, your Tesla will determine which lane you need to be in and when.
In addition to ensuring you reach your intended exit, Autopilot will watch for opportunities
to move to a faster lane when you're caught behind slower traffic. When you reach your exit,
your Tesla will depart the freeway, slow down and transition control back to you.(At which point, you may ask: What is the point of AP2..?)
Similarly, the heart of Tesla's tech is its batteries (I imagine they but the motors from someone). After that, outsource everything else and focus on manufacturing and distribution.
Regarding Tesla, surely I am not the only one waiting for competition. I think the problem Tesla has is that when the giants awake they will outclass them at nearly every level.
It's like thinking you are doing great in your open water swim until the triathletes leave you in their wake. Surely companies who have been honing their skills and optimizing their design, engineering, manufacturing, distribution and support over decades will have non-trivial advantages over Tesla.
The way I see it, building an electric car is significantly simpler than one with an internal combustion engine. All you have to do to see this is take an accounting of the thousands of parts and many fluids you leave out. The design, manufacturing, supply chain, distribution and service costs of having another 1,000 to 2,000 parts in a car are monumental. Any company that knows how to deliver quality, reliable and reasonably priced internal combustion cars will have a laugh delivering electrics at scale.
They know how to do this today. They are all waiting for the same thing: Cheaper, lighter, better energy storage. Recent developments might indicate this could be just a few years out.
Tesla has a problem: It has to achieve scale before that moment in time. Today choices are few and Tesla might have an advantage with Model 3 (if it ships on time and has no problems). In some respects they are the only game in town (range). The minute that changes people are going to flock to other manufacturers.
>Tesla has a problem: It has to achieve scale before that moment in time.
Do they though?
With the gigafactory, they could very well be the company providing the batteries that the big manufacturers are waiting for.
I need to go back a ways on this one. I have been flying model aircraft for decades.
If you go back far enough it was impossible to even consider flying an electric powered airplane because alkaline batteries simply didn't have the energy density.
Sometime later came NiCd batteries and they eventually hit that sweet spot where you could stick a few of them in a plane, put a motor in the nose and fly for a few minutes. I had gliders with 27 NiCd cell packs what weighed in at somewhere around six or eight pounds all by themselves.
A few years went by (6 to 10, don't remember) and LiPo batteries surfaced. Now I could actually fly jets. And the glider with the super heavy 27 cell NiCd pack got a very light and small six cell LiPo pack, a far more efficient brushless motor and performance was out of this world.
Today electric powered model aircraft are probably the majority of the product sold and they include high powered helicopters and even the "impossible" quadcopters.
These transitions were mainly the result of energy storage technology, nothing else mattered until you could carry enough energy at a favorable weight ratio and in a favorable volume.
The companies that brought us these transitions, very much in the spirit of "The Innovator's Dilemma" [1], were not the same companies that provided the older energy storage technologies.
This is where I come full circle to Tesla and the Gigafactory.
Tesla has done a great job with this and it has positioned itself to benefit from scale in manufacturing battery packs with the existing best-in-class energy storage technology. They will, in this regard, do well.
Yet, this will become a significant liability if and when the next step change in energy storage technology comes about. Scale has it's benefits, but it can also kill you.
Again, this is conjecture. Imagine a day within the next 3 to 5 years when someone demonstrates a technology with three times the capacity, in half the volume, with half the weight and none of the longevity problems. We recently saw just such an announcement, although it seems the technology suffers from a power-to-weight issue at the moment.
Imagine someone else finally develops a supercapacitor system that makes current Lithium-based cells look as bad as they made NiCd cells look years ago.
Whoever does that will trigger the inflection point and a massive migration away from internal combustion engines to electric powerplants. Just like it did with model airplanes.
In the model airplane world, the pioneers of electric flight were absolutely skewered by the established (and some new) players in model airplane manufacturing. Most people today don't even know the names of the pioneers.
Tesla could suffer this fate. The Gigafactory could actually become a huge liability. Imagine having such an operation at a time when nobody has any interest in the technology you can produce.
I truly believe other manufacturers are waiting in the wings for this inflection point while they experiment and get ready. I have a gut feeling we are not too far from that moment in time when a significant enough technology shift occurs to make electric transportation viable for the masses.
I think the choice Tesla has right now is to fix up their supply chain and reliability issues or expand. Musk has chosen "expand". Incidentally that choice also brings focus to the supply chain -- just in a different way.
My concern is that long-term, delivering several years of great performing, flashy but not-luxurious, and very unreliable cars, is going to hurt the company in the long run. Honda and Toyota both either have or have announced vehicles competitive to the Model 3 on price, range and features. Ford already sells a couple electric vehicles at competitive prices. BMW has entered, and so on.
Amazon made the same bet years ago, focus or expand, and after years of no profitability the gamble has played off. However, Amazon also provided good service and product during those years. So far Tesla owners love their cars, even if they spend as much time in the shop as an exotic Italian car.
The other electrics don't have the brand cachet like Tesla, but they can fast follow until they simply overwhelm the much smaller company.
But, while even the iPhone is a minority smart phone these days, Apple makes most of the profits. Tesla might be able to do the same.
I don't see Tesla being the #1 electric vehicle maker in 10 years, but I do see them being a major player in the industry. Musk is also trying to diversify the company in various ways. It will be interesting to see how this pays off.
Historical performance is also not an indicator of future performance. Everyday I'm holding onto the shares is the same as if I made the decision to buy that many shares on that day. If anything the fantastic return would encourage long term investors so far to partially cash out and diversify their risk a bit.
This is a great way to think about holding investments. I remember using this argument to try and convince a family member that they should sell what I considered to be a bad investment. I phrased it as 'If you were forced to sell your shares right now would you use the money from the sale to immediately buy back your shares?'. He responded that no, he wouldn't. Obviously this ignores brokerage fees, but it is a useful thought experiment nonetheless.
Unless you believe in the efficient market hypothesis...
While I'm not a banker, I find with this method looking at investments highly disagreeable. The price of the stock at the time of purchase is the projected future profits discounted to present day. In other words, it is the fundamental value of the firm, which is invariant of its day-to-day fluctuations.
If you have to be watching for the daily upticks, it's a sign the company is either incompetent or is operating in a highly unfavorable environment.
I don't see how any good can be gained from envisaging a purchase price other than your lock-in price.
> I don't see how any good can be gained from envisaging a purchase price other than your lock-in price.
If I have a thing valued much higher than I believe it is worth, surely the logical thing for me to do is sell and buy something else that is valued lower than I believe it is worth. The price I paid for it is completely irrelevant (except, importantly, when it comes to taxes but this may not be an issue, much less relevant for many in the UK).
TSLA is ~$256. If I only think it would be worth buying at $100, then why would I keep the ones I own? The purchase price is a sunk cost.
Share prices can be fantastic while a company is horribly, even comically mismanaged. They soar right up until they don't.
In the long term, markets are a weighing machine, but in the short term, they are a popularity contest.
In August 1998, YHOO traded under $10/share. In December 1999, YHOO traded at > $100/share, a > 1000% return over 16 months. From February 2001 to February 2003, YHOO traded under $10/share. Markets are fickle.
The only argument against that is one has a badge that says "Chevrolet" and the other says "Tesla". If the Model 3 didn't have the Tesla name, no one would think anything of it. It'd just be yet another compact electric car, yawn, who cares, and then they'd buy the Chevrolet.
The Chevrolet Bolt is similar in price, but I think somebody making a comparison between a BMW and a Chevy would be similarly mistaken. BMW and Tesla are luxury car manufacturer. Chevrolet isn't.
IMHO, the bolt is overpriced. It's a crossover SUV from a manufacturer that is known for making low cost, high-volume cars. It looks like it is most similar to the Chevy Trax, which starts at $21,000.
They are fun to drive, but try a Tesla and then a Audi, BMW or Mercedes and it is a different world inside the car.
Tesla is not a luxury car, just a very highly priced and high performance car.
If GM decided to do this, it would have many advantages over Tesla: a huge dealership and service network, lots of suppliers, easy financing, and all of the other perks you get when you buy a "normal" car from an established company.
The thing that Tesla is producing, however, is really expensive to build right now. The cost curves are great for it to come down, but until they do they are in the ironic business of selling expensive things with thin margins.
GM would find it harder than it thinks to compete against Tesla with an equivalent product. Just as Tesla is running into challenges scaling up production.
They don't have an automatic mark-up, but car dealers also operate on razor thin margins (the real money is in service and trade ins). However dealers pay their own rent and even spend money advertising. Tesla is on the hook for all of its dealerships, a significant cost that its competitors don't have. In the end I don't think it's such a game changer. It makes sense for Tesla, but doesn't magically make things cheaper.
But it's not.
Developing a long-term-viable car company is hard even when it makes regular old gasoline cars. Tesla also needs to fulfill the Model 3 preorders, and that process could be derailed by a number of issues: manufacturing speed, quality control, factory problems, etc. That's a big challenge for a company that has made small numbers of high-end luxury cars until now.
I'm impressed by Tesla's success so far, but if I were to invest in a car company today, I would rather invest in GM. They are getting into the electric car market big time with the Bolt, and unlike Tesla, they already have realized economies of scale in car production. If the Bolt succeeds, GM could choose to produce a car that would be a good competitor to the Tesla Model 3.
And to achieve that plan, they have to deal with lots of competition.
While the 600% is impressive, the year to date performance matches the overall market.
Gotta hit those Model 3 dates to maintain the confidence.
MSCI ACWI Autos and Components was at 3.44% YTD at the end of Feburary while MSCI ACWI was at 5.37%. The S&P 500 is at about 7% YTD return.
Tesla's YTD return more than matches the overall market
https://www.msci.com/documents/10199/f87aad4f-6f38-4878-a149...
What is so significant about YTD?
You can arrange the data in any number of ways to tell a story: A Tesla investment since 2014 has lost money (and been diluted). Go back to 2013 and suddenly it's a goldmine.
Tesla having been a "good purchase" depends on what you paid. But I have a feeling that more people are sitting on a cost basis >$250 than <$100, in which case a TSLA investment has been mediocre.
The markets can't predict the future. Investors' expectations about the future are priced into the stock, but those expectations are often wrong.
Right now, having a Tesla is like having a Maserati.
I know zero people who have one, my wife (a structural integrationist) _works_ on people who have them, so I am like two social tiers away from thinking of affording one, which, for me, is like dreaming of that Kawasaki Ninja I had postered on my wall as a ten year old boy.
He, and his team, need to dramatically scale down costs somehow. I read something cool today about Chinese charging stations that swap batteies instead of sitting and waiting to recharge. I wonder if something like that with an attendant would work to extend the battery "life" ad infinitum for grids in other nations.
Seems like his head is on straight though. He took profits and looked up. He said, yeah, I could drive down prices on my car by saturating more, but I'll build rockets that don't waste as much on reentry costs instead. That's smart innovation, that's passing the baton in the 400m instead of sprinting 10m and saying "I win!".
I do think there is stigma (even in my own mind, and I really am a fan of Elon) surrounding borrowing money over and over, but the reality is: almost EVERYONE does this. If you aren't Dow, or Ford, or some huge ass fucking company that has a war chest the size of Dubai, you aren't going to weather the stormy market conditions we are facing as a result of globalization (see Brexit et al for moreon that topic of discussion).
Businesses need floating because they don't exist in a vacuum, they exist because they aren't welcomed by their competitors, in fact, they are actively "sabotaged" by those that stand to lose market share, and that, my friends, is a HUGE problems with mercantilism. Unless we decide to get along, it's not going to get better, and corporate espionage has not lessened in my lifetime, not by a moonshot.
So, yeah, play nice and he and those like him will stop having to borrow money, and maybe he will throw us a bone and make a car that doesn't cost as much as my entire post-secondary education (including grad school).
Peace y'all.
Seems like an unwelcome offer.
Vision statements are predictive instead of descriptive.
Apple can have a vision of building cars in the future but it doesn't change the fact that they are a consumer electronics company today.
Vision is cheap, execution is where the money is at.
Given the Tesla's SolarCity merge, the associated solar shingles project, the battery gigafactory, the PowerWall, and their grid energy storage projects, I wouldn't invest in Tesla today thinking "Tesla is a car company, and 5 years from now they'll be a bigger car company with new car models!" in the same way that I'd approach Apple.
I can operate my bagel shop like the CIA but it won't be spying on the Trump Tower through microwaves anytime soon :)
It was supposed to take 2 months, but viola, 6 months later they are still struggling and there are many YouTube videos out there showing how terrible and unsafe it is.
It still lack many features of AP1 such as automatic lane changing and blind spot detection at this point. Lane keeping is also not as stable and safe as AP1 and many videos show that the car like to drift into oncoming traffic.
People look at that recent video of the Tesla car doing a full A to B drive and they're like, wow, that's awesome!
Then, they ask themselves, hmm, I wonder why Google hasn't released anything after a decade of research. And realize too that google had a simple A to B video 8 years ago too... yet 8 years later it's still not ready.
Cars with the second generation autopilot hardware were sold without any autopilot at all. It also had no auto park, no automatic headlights, no automatic wipers, no automatic emergency braking, no side collision warning, no lane departure warning, no automatic lane change, or summon.
A 45Mph speed limited version of autosteer was enabled in an update, and maybe some of those other features. I sadly do not actually own one myself to know.
Wait, does this mean Tesla is currently selling a 100K car with none of those features, just a hopeful promise of them coming soon?
That's... interesting.
http://www.theverge.com/2016/9/27/13079472/elon-musk-mars-sp...
Edit: Just for one challenge with no current solution: http://www.nature.com/articles/srep34774
There are others.
He's positioned for LEO cargo, and in the longer-term (I suspect) for potentially surveying and mining asteroids. There is almost literally money out there, for the first people to stake a claim. It's daring, it's risky, but it's possible to do with a combination of human explorers and robotics.
It's not sexy however, and it calls to mind all of the dystopian sci-fi of the last few decades. "We're going to Mars folks!" is just... easier to swallow than... mining space rocks.
People like you and me want to believe in a secure future for the species, which requires getting a self-sustaining group of humans off this planet. It's a powerful dream that could really move some very bright and dedicated people, who might not be similarly moved by the dream of simply gathering more resources for Earth.
Elon Musk, I think, has perfectly blended PR and a real business plan, but the PR and plan are not one and the same. More credit to him, but it's a bit discouraging to see so many people flip the switch on their skepticism out of pure "wanting it to be true".
I hope this doesn't apply to you, but I feel really sorry for people who can't believe in altruistic motivations. It seems people who don't believe anyone works for the greater good often disbelieve because they have only selfish motivations, so imagining someone motivated by altruism or higher order goals sounds fantastical, and they can only understand it as a "trick."
Further, I don't think it is at all clear that those obstacles are insurmountable. They are technical problems. Nasa thinks solutions are possible and worth discussing:
http://www.space.com/29512-mars-mission-radiation-nasa-chall...
He's made some interesting points about using Mars to shield from radiation, but it doesn't matter because they'd be cooked before they ever arrived. Worse, it seems that radiation is going to have an impact on cognition, which is just about the worst thing you can imagine. Dying in your 50's from cancer is tragic, but dying because you stopped thinking clearly before your mission ever truly begins? Wasteful.
The notion of using water as a shielding works at first glance, but then you realize that you'd need a looooot of it, and that you've kicked the problematic can. Now your biggest concern shifts to micro-impacts, which no longer just erode your armor (you'll need armor... expensive as it will be to lift, you'll need it), but open your radiation shielding to vacuum. Presumably you'd have some means to circulate the water through the outer crew quarters, so large parts suddenly freezing and slowly sublimating away strike me as catastrophic.
What we need is a material that is incredibly strong, durable, manages thermal stress, and which can shield against all kinds of radiation (without just cooking the poor bastards with gamma rays secondary to the incident radiation). That material need to be light enough that lifting it into orbit doesn't bankrupt any potential operation, and frankly... no such material exists.
That is just one problem.
Edit: To be clear, I don't think that Elon Musk being something other than altruistic, is for example, malevolent. I think of all the arena in which he could have acted, he chose ones that were potentially beneficial to the species. Not being altruistic doesn't mean that you have to be terrible... most of us aren't altruistic.
In short. :)
Tesla is a battery / energy company.
A modern car company is as much of a production and supply chain company as it's a product and tech company. I get the feeling that due to Tesla being cutting edge in the tech department it led to all the supply chain/production problems being treated as if they are speed bumps on the way, when in reality they are fundamental core competitive areas for an automotive company. Toyota is not the world's premier automaker because they have cutting edge tech, they are what they are because they build unbelievably number of reliable cars at an unbelievable scale.
The bleeding of cash after so many promises of "not going to raise money again" just shows that their vision is way ahead of their execution ability. Decisions like the terribly executed Falcon Wing Doors on a SUV that delayed production and increased cost and hurt reliability just further gave fuel to all the doubters.
I also have a strong suspicion that Tesla has not been honest with their Auto Pilot 2 and full self driving tech's progress. The current AP2 is an unsafe joke and I have no idea how people are ok with paying $5-10k for a significant downgrade when compared to AP1 because of a non-binding promise that it "might" get upgraded before their lease term is out. Any other automakers would be laughed out of the room for suggesting this kind of sales tactics.
I still believe in Tesla/Elon's end game vision, and I think what they accomplished is nothing short of brilliant, but I think it's a very risky investment at this point and the road ahead is bumpier than many like to admit.
The upcoming Model 3 will be the acid test for Tesla. It will no doubt be a good car, but at this point people should focus less on what the car can do and on how the car will be rolled out, sold and supported afterwards. A wealthy Model S customer may be ok with having the car in the shop after a minor accident for 5 months due to lack of replacement parts, but for an average Joe paying $500/month leasing a Model 3 that would just be the birth of a new BMW customer.