This is a great way to think about holding investments. I remember using this argument to try and convince a family member that they should sell what I considered to be a bad investment. I phrased it as 'If you were forced to sell your shares right now would you use the money from the sale to immediately buy back your shares?'. He responded that no, he wouldn't. Obviously this ignores brokerage fees, but it is a useful thought experiment nonetheless.
Unless you believe in the efficient market hypothesis...
While I'm not a banker, I find with this method looking at investments highly disagreeable. The price of the stock at the time of purchase is the projected future profits discounted to present day. In other words, it is the fundamental value of the firm, which is invariant of its day-to-day fluctuations.
If you have to be watching for the daily upticks, it's a sign the company is either incompetent or is operating in a highly unfavorable environment.
I don't see how any good can be gained from envisaging a purchase price other than your lock-in price.
> I don't see how any good can be gained from envisaging a purchase price other than your lock-in price.
If I have a thing valued much higher than I believe it is worth, surely the logical thing for me to do is sell and buy something else that is valued lower than I believe it is worth. The price I paid for it is completely irrelevant (except, importantly, when it comes to taxes but this may not be an issue, much less relevant for many in the UK).
TSLA is ~$256. If I only think it would be worth buying at $100, then why would I keep the ones I own? The purchase price is a sunk cost.
Historical performance is also not an indicator of future performance. Everyday I'm holding onto the shares is the same as if I made the decision to buy that many shares on that day. If anything the fantastic return would encourage long term investors so far to partially cash out and diversify their risk a bit.