Also, what you are ignoring is that the US can't just come along and close a transnational or foreign company. Also, what about subsidaries? Does condé nast get closed if reddit violates the law? Does GM get closed if Opel cheats?
A human could be put to death even if they have a family to support, so the workers argument is settled. The only issue is the matter of scale, but the death penalty is pretty rare to begin with, and I would expect a corporate death penalty have even stricter requirements.
They don't have to close a transnational, they can just force them to stop doing business in the country. They can close their US operations and ban their imports. We already have import bans on companies, countries, and products.
For subsidiaries, it would depends on how far up the chain the crime went. If Opel committed the crime but GM didn't know, Opel dies. If GM knew, GM dies. You could likely even spin off the "innocent" subsidiaries. If a husband commits a crime and the wife was not involved, the wife doesn't go to jail. If they both did it but their children were not involved, the children don't go to jail, they go to live with another set of parents.
You're not wrong, but this is also the same argument your parent post was making, namely that it will have a large scale negative effect on many regions.
This is actually an interesting thought. What if they did have to fear punishment? Perhaps in the form of having a percentage of the settlement/regulatory fees passed to them via their brokerage accounts. A mechanism like this would mean that potentially shady/unethical corporate behavior would be reflected much more strongly in the stock price, since holding onto those stocks would carry risks beyond just the stock price temporarily going down during lawsuits.
It would also put immense pressure on corporations to not do shady shit.
Perhaps increase fees/taxes on "toxic" shares in companies that have broken significant laws with intent or maybe force these companies to settle by issuing diluting stock that goes to agencies responsible for cleaning up the mess. Or even tax revenue instead of profit on these toxic shares which would create a huge incentive, especially for executives and large stock holders.
The point is to tweak and realign incentives, it doesn't have to be passing on extreme financial liability to shareholders. Most investors can't take a huge hit on their portfolio like a company with tens or hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue can.
You can argue it should be worse, but we don't need some special new mechanism. The fine can be anywhere from $1 to the the market capitalization+1 and the effects would then range from a slap on the wrist to bankruptcy and the loss of all equity in the company for shareholders.
What about people who may have invested in a fund that bought shares? Should the fund managers fear punishment? Should the people that bought into the fund be punished?
This is where the "punishment for those who benefit" gets complicated. It's hard to work out the people that should NOT be punished.
Shutting down a company doesn't mean you destroy all of its assets. Factories or entire divisions could continue to run under new ownership. Just treat it as a Chapter 7 bankruptcy where the company owes the government more than the total of its assets.
> The shareholders would still be richer and don't have to fear punishment
Shareholders would lose out to the maximum extent allowed without piercing the corporate veil since their ownership stake in VW would become worthless.
> Also, what you are ignoring is that the US can't just come along and close a transnational or foreign company.
No, but they could close down the US subsidiary (Volkswagen Group of America) and take all assets that are in the US.
> Also, what about subsidaries? Does condé nast get closed if reddit violates the law? Does GM get closed if Opel cheats?
Easy, just sell them for whatever you can get for them.
Detailed analysis of the cheat:
Where do you draw the line between it being the corporation's fault and the individual?
(I suspect these questions are part of the reason it is the way it is currently)
Fires, jail and fines for the involved execs, but don't hurt the customers and shareholders and the rest of the employees.
They destroyed the livelihoods of thousands, if not millions of innocent people, and thoroughly polluted huge swaths of the Gulf of Mexico coastline (and a bit of the Atlantic coast, as well). They caused the biggest single environmental disaster in United States history, and it was due to negligence.
If this wasn't an accident, but rather a deliberate attack "in the name of Islam", we would have gone back into Iraq. It would have been 9/11 all over again, but with far more actual damage caused. But since they're a company, they get a slap on the wrist and keep on going. (I'm exaggerating, I know they paid a lot, but they're still more than alive and kicking. I just wish their stock tanked more after the Brexit vote.)
If you want to make an example of a company with a clear-cut case, you can't really do better than this. They committed mass destruction of the Southern coastline. Seriously, if this was intentional it would be a war crime.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_Modification_C...
Nonono, don't compare anything to terrorism please: We have a far to belligerous action on terrorism, while we don't do much against other causes of death. Smoking still causes an order or magnitude more deaths of innocents than terrorism (non-smokers) and the people still defend it's ok to smoke on the sidewalk (and defend it's ok to kill Muslims without trial as long as it's a military action). Responses to terrorism are disproportionate.
Utter scumbags - they should never have been let off the hook the way they were after that disaster. I fully expected the company to be on its knees at the very least but nope - they're trading happily ever after.
All of them? All 80,000 employees are scumbags are they?
I happen to know a few, and at the very least they don't denigrate people they don't know on the internet.
However, BP as a legal entity and a subset of its employees fucked up, causing untold damage to the world we live in. There are people who work for BP who I would hold accountable, and those people do not deserve to have my hard earned cash spent on their company.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_issues_in_the_Ni...
The total volume of oil spilt was on the same order of magnitude - about half that at Deep Water Horizon. But the environmental and health problems are perhaps worse. It's close to shore and there's hardly any cleanup work, compensation or health protection.
As anyone who's ever been near a major automaker's test engineering lab knows, ~all [0] of VW's competition is doing something similar, to varying degrees of sophistication. I remain perplexed by the pitchforks, outrage, and witch-hunt mentality displayed towards VW alone.
[0] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/mitsubishi-s... and many more
No.
I am assuming you meant this as a figure of speech, but it is a very unfortunate one.
As for your edit:
I am assuming that the downvotes are because you express yourself in a way that doesn't help at all. The statistic being what they are you are either unware of the statistical insignificance of that number or you are but you are inflating it to make it seem more important than it really is.
Yes, statistically speaking there may be 59 'premature deaths', but that does not quantify just how premature those deaths were, nor does it acknowledge that transportation carries an enormous cost in lives over and beyond that tiny little bit extra because of these emissions.
Yes, VW did a really bad thing, yes, they should be punished. But the cost of transportation already being what it is the punishment seems to be roughly in line with the extent of the crime.
If you're really concerned about this you should campaign for us all to stop driving, that will really move the needle.
I do that, too, to the best of my ability. And, whenever given the chance I argue for self-driving cars, too. Yes, the entire auto industry (and our addiction to it as a society) is terrible.
But, my point is that even the mild environmental and health regulations we have were defeated for years for VW profits, all while they advertised "clean diesel" and went head to head in the market with technologies that are actually superior and safer (unless those companies are cheating, too), claiming to be better than them by using falsified data.
My point is really that when a company in an industry that already kills on an unprecedented scale decides to willfully harm even more because they'll profit, there should be truly dire consequences. BP is another great example of a company that consistently made decisions that knowingly endangered entire communities over a long period of time. Their only regret seems to be getting caught.
VW messed up, sure. I've been pretty explicit about my criticism of what they've done, and I would happily see Winterkorn serve jailtime (fat chance of that ever happening).
But I think you are magnifying the damage done way out of proportion.
FWIW, 15B for 59 premature deaths is a very large premium compared to what we, the western nations typically think a life in some Oil rich country is worth, and those people too are indirect victims of our transportation.
Proportionality is what it is all about and I really miss that element in your comments here.
My argument is that cheating our already lax air quality and environmental standards should be a tremendous deal. It shouldn't be something that can be swept under the rug or written off as a cost of doing business.
I'm not suggesting that imposing a "death penalty" on a corporation would be a nice thing, or that it would make employees of the corporation happy. I'm not even saying it wouldn't have negative consequences for more than just those directly employed by the company. But, I am saying that when someone commits a truly heinous crime, our society removes them from society by force. Volkswagen has committed a truly heinous crime. If I had my druthers, the CEO and a wide variety of other executives who knew what was going on would be spending their days in a lonely grey room contemplating what they've done. That'd be a good start toward justice.
But, we also have to address the company as a whole. It was not one person who made this decision, and it's probably literally impossible to know who knew and who did what with any precision. Pretty much the entire company is suspect. We can't expect internal processes to correct this kind of malfeasance...they had years to do so, and chose profit over human lives.
Finally: Many corporations have died, through all manner of faults over the years...often, they've failed due to inefficiencies, the Innovator's Dilemma, etc. Very few companies have failed because they killed people. But, it is not the end of the world when a company, even a very large one, dies. It makes room in the market for new competitors. And, in this case, a shake up in the auto industry is a great thing. We need new auto companies that don't willingly trade human and environmental health for greater profits. While VW exists, and wields political power, those new companies (or old companies that want to do right by the world) are competing with a company shown to have no scruples. Ever tried to compete in a business that has high health and safety costs with a competitor that ignores health and safety regulations? That's a part of why Chinese manufacturing destroyed American manufacturing industries.
Someone else mentioned Enron in another comment. I think it's a useful example. The fallout from Enron was hard for a lot of people; and, it was painful across several industries for a little while. But, I believe we're better for killing Enron (and Arthur Andersen). And, I believe the world would be better off, in the long run, by killing VW.
Flagged
I don't think you're alone in interpreting my comment that way, but I'm not sure I understand why it's been so misinterpreted. I'd like to do better in the future (without giving up entirely on humor, though perhaps I shouldn't quit my day job).
You're getting down-voted because you're asking for company executives, who are human beings, to be killed for something that hasn't quite proven out to be a "crime" yet.
Most reasonable people find that repulsive.
While we're at it, why don't we kill everyone who every bought a VW? Surely they are partly culpable.
Did you really interpret it that way? I'm speaking of companies, not people. Apologies for not being clear. I am speaking of a "corporate death penalty"; one for companies. The person I was replying to said other car companies are doing the same thing, and I would hope they would face consequences as well, if so.
I explicitly stated in my first comment that I oppose the death penalty for humans in criminal cases.
Since we have neither a corporate death penalty nor adequate criminal statutes for malfeasance, how is the "corporate death penalty" superior than laws that make it more straightforward to hold managers and directors accountable criminally? People who are willing to commit crimes to enrich themselves using companies are unlikely to be especially motivated by the well-being of the company, its employees, or shareholders.
Consumers also lose out, because of decreased market competition.
It's nice to imagine that maybe it would breed "super companies" that are tougher, smarter, and more efficient because they thought they had to be to compete. But, there aren't any order-of-magnitude wins to be had in automobile technology. There are no lone geniuses who figure out how to eke out 10% more efficiency with this one weird (but patentable) trick. It takes research over a long period time to make even modest gains, and a cheater in the market bleeds the honest companies of resources.
And, to go further: Because Volkswagen made these claims about diesel tech, other honest companies may have been wasting resources trying to match the dishonest VW claims...when there are actual better techs they could have been pursuing. This may have led to even less gains over the time VW were faking data.
I think, all around, it is lose-lose.
If the business is otherwise competitive but the owners sued out of existence, it's nonsensical for new owners to dismantle it.
Do you think shareholders of a company like VW, which includes pretty much everyone with a retirement plan, shoulder _all_ the responsibility? Because that's pretty much what a "corporate death penalty" means.
No. That's why I said "a degree of culpability".
The question isn't whether companies (and thus their shareholders) should be penalized for wrongdoing. It's whether shareholders should be zeroed out by a "corporate death penalty". I think it's an interesting question, why we don't have one of those.
You can't just blame automobile makers for the existence of automobiles.
Whereas if the corporation were liquidated, the assets would be bought up by different corporations and run by different management.
Banks, most of all, are just bags of assets that can be run by other managers who run the same types of assets (otherwise these assets would be illiquid and not need active management) at other banks.
The same goes for airlines: If an airline is a brand + planes (probably leased) and routes, why EVER bail out an airline? Especially a legacy airline when it's assets could be bought by an economically viable new airline?
We don't have corporate death penalties because to a first approximation there are no laws that enable us to do that. To put companies to death, we'd need to pass enabling laws. But those aren't the only new sanctions we can enable in new laws.
It seems to me that we can break down those impacted by sanctions against corporations as follows:
* Officers and directors of the company
* Employees of the company
* Shareholders in the company
* Customers of the company
When we think about how to structure sanctions against a company, we should think about where (a) deterrence will have the most effect and (b) where retribution is most warranted.
How does a "corporate death penalty" apply those effects? It seems to me:
* Officers and directors of the company have a demonstrated track record of harming their employers for personal short-term gain; see, for instance, every stock buyback scandal. Moreover, officers and directors tend to be wealthy and thus more likely to have a professionally or at least competently managed portfolio: they're diversified out of a lot of impact.
* Employees of the company have extremely limited ability to alter strategic decisions made by management, and so aren't useful for deterrence. They also tend not to profit from strategic high-level malfeasance, and so aren't deserving of much retribution. Meanwhile: mergers, spinoffs, and acquisitions are almost invariable dreadful for employees, huge numbers of whom are made redundant, pension obligations scrapped, benefits reduced, and so on.
* Shareholders have virtually no insight into the operation of their holdings. Moreover, vast numbers of shareholders don't even know they hold companies, because they do so through pension plans and mutual funds.
* Customers who, for instance, bought VW cars during this scandal did so in an effort to minimize their impact on the environment; the scandal is that VW lied to them. Not only are they demonstrably incapable of being deterred from future scandals, but it's hard to argue that they've in any way earned warranty confusion, loss of service stations and personnel, and slashed resale values.
Compare that to a new law making this kind of malfeasance a strict-liability felony for officers of the company. Doesn't that make much more sense than a death penalty?
So I'm acknowledging that you could pass laws that make an effective death penalty (through fines or through literally forcing liquidation) a reality, but then asking: why would you want to do that? Aren't there better laws we could pass instead?
If you think it is defensible perhaps you could explain why it's just that an assembly line worker should lose his livelihood because a few folks implemented this scheme? The worker had no actual or theoretical knowledge of the "crime". Further, the worker had no way of even spotting that a "crime" was taking place.
Group punishment just adds victims.
It gives one hell of an incentive not to stand by while shit goes down. Though whistleblower protections would be quite helpful as well.
Not punishing the behavior penalizes honest competitors and defrauded customers and vendors / suppliers.
Would you suggest that Enron should have continued to exist because employees losing their jobs is a bad thing? Do you think we, as a society, would be better or worse off if bad companies, like Enron (and Volkswagen), are allowed to continue to exist? There is a certain necessary destruction in the free market. There's all sorts of things that the market corrects for (by killing off weak companies); why shouldn't society also impose some corrections based on some basic ethical factors?
Further, society does impose corrections on small companies; if my small company killed 59 people by hiding facts about my products, I'd pretty much certainly go to jail (as it should be). It is only very large corporations, and their executives, that are effectively immune to these kinds of corrections; even this, heralded as a huge penalty, is unlikely to impede VW significantly going forward.
What's so bad about opening up a place in the market for new auto makers, who don't cheat the system for profit? We are talking about criminal activity here over a period of years, not mere "irregularities".
How about you stop buying VW cars if you disagree with what the company did (let the market do its work)?
We do not have a perfectly "free market" (and that's OK), though markets are nice things, and in some cases I am in agreement with wanting more free markets. But, do you sincerely believe the right answer to a company killing people is a boycott?
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/04/eric-holder-1999-me...
So, my question is: Would we be better off with Enron still existing, including the same executive team (VW executive team is still largely unchanged)? Would we be better off with a more aggressive response to the banking crisis a few years ago?
I believe ending criminal companies probably makes room for better companies, and in the long run makes our economy and our society healthier. I may be wrong; there are certainly negative impacts. But, I feel like the cost of looking the other way, or a slap on the wrist, is too high.
There are thousands -- millions? -- of innocent people who would definitely have been better off had Enron survived. You could be right about the long term, but you're playing pretty fast and loose with other people's money.
I'd say Enron was playing fast and loose with other people's money; likewise VW was, too. Why blame me for the malfeasance of the executives at these companies, just because I think they shouldn't be allowed to do it again? The rolling blackouts Enron caused likely led to deaths (hospitals need power to keep machines and people running, refrigerators need power to prevent food-borne illnesses, etc.). It should be a really big deal when a company makes an intentional decision to harm people.
It should be a really big deal when a person makes an intentional decision to harm people and that person should be punished.
So where are the criminal prosecutions? My argument is that very large corporations wield so much power, and have disbursed responsibility so widely, that no one faces any significant consequences for making these decisions. I think maybe what I haven't really made clear is that I think we (we, as in, governments, nations, communities) don't seem to be equipped with legal tools needed to prosecute people within corporations, because responsibility for actions becomes this wisp of an idea that sort of floats around inside a company but never really sticks to anyone. And, when it does stick to someone, it sticks to low-level workers; trickle-down economics for blame.
My suggestion was barely thought out; an expression of frustration that companies like BP, and Shell, and VW will keep ticking after committing horrible crimes. And, more importantly perhaps, the C-levels at those companies still have jobs in those companies, in most cases. Blame trickled down, profits trickled up. The incentives remain for companies to skirt the law and put communities at risk.
Maybe there's some other way to hold executives accountable. I don't think this settlement has done that.
There's no point in burning down the village because the mayor's corrupt. The town still has value!
It happens to share a second-level domain name with a startup accelerator. That's the extent of it.
Certainly there should always be a constant review of regulation in light of events like this, but to confiscate and destroy an entire company for this type of cheat would be chilling for future investment and company formation. That directly leads to a lower level of living for everyone, far worse than the relatively minor increase in emissions in this case.
There seems to be an attitude around that corporations are some evil thing, and that is not healthy at all.
One post like yours, I shrug my shoulders and/or roll my eyes and move on. A continuous barrage of populist drivel like it, anywhere 'the average voter' gets a chance to express their 'opinion' on anything really - I worry what goes through the minds of all those people I see out there walking through the city when I look out my window, and how stable they really are; and if that collective instability might culminate into a real societal upheaval given the right circumstances.
I'm not, at all, anti-corporation. I'm anti-criminal behavior. How is wanting the rule of law to apply equally a "populist" notion?
"Equality" is, admittedly, pretty tricky when talking about a fictional construct. But, when a company kills people we can't put the company in prison to protect people from it and to dissuade other companies from doing similar things. So, I think there should be other tools that can strip away the corporate veil that executives are hiding behind and stop the criminal company from being in a position to cause further harm.
Here's my "free market" question for you: Do you want to be in an industry where you're competing with companies that cheat on health and safety standards? They have lower compliance costs because they're cheating. What do you do? How do you deal with that? Do you want to have to cheat, break the law, and lie to customers, in order to compete effectively with them?
YMMV. (Especially if you have a Volkswagen.)
Isn't this the whole reason for the invention of limited companies in the first place? It's considered a progress in human society to have developed limited liability laws. Besides, the good thing about not killing juristic persons is also true for not killing natural persons - it's considered an improvement by and large if a society gets rid of the medieval practice of executing prisoners.
According to Google finance, its 56 billion, and probably less after this news. The US branch is probably worth 10% of that, or 5.6 billion. That way, the 15 billion are basically a three-fold death penalty.
I think I need you to be more specific, is what I'm trying to say.
Venezuela nationalized many corporations, which meant they were simply confiscated. That is pretty much giving them the death penalty.
What do you intend by "corporate death penalty" if not being siezed?
More importantly, think about the difference between a serial killer and a single person being executed. Venezuela is the former, while SwellJoe advocates the latter. Your comparison makes about as much sense as "we can't jail anyone, because if we jailed everyone there would be no workers left".
In one case the government ends up owning and running the company, in the other, the assets are sold off to the highest bidder with the creditors (and in the case of a criminal company like VW, restitution for their victims, which in this case would be VW owners and public health systems, among others) receiving the proceeds.
How is that functionally the same?
And, regardless of that: The single most important element of my suggestion is that VW committed a crime (well, a number of crimes, spread over many years) and caused harm to human lives and health. Unless the Venezualan companies you're talking about were criminal companies causing harm to humans, it is unrelated to this conversation. No one (certainly not me) has suggested a bunch of random major companies should be owned by the government.
In both cases the company is confiscated from the owners.
> it is unrelated to this conversation
It shows what happens when companies are confiscated from the owners. Note you suggested more than just VW, the entire industry.
I see you're not alone in thinking my joking "line them all up against the wall" comment was intended to be taken seriously. Someone said, "everybody's doing it", and I meant to imply, "well, everyone who is doing it should be investigated and punished". I did not mean "everyone who ever sold a car should be put out of business".
I can't blame you for making that assumption, since others have made it, too. So, apologies for not being clear. I have no desire to see every car manufacturer closed down. Only the ones that have committed crimes on a level similar to Volkswagen (or worse, if there are any who've done worse things). In fact, I would like for the honest ones, the ones that are sincerely working on cleaner technology and accurately representing it in the market, to be able to compete in a market free from cheaters like Volkswagen.
If some automakers are cheating, and some are playing fair, the ones playing fair are effectively fighting with one hand tied behind their backs. They're virtually guaranteed to lose market share to the cheaters over time. That's the kind of screwed up market that no honest person wants to compete in.
To suggest otherwise is disingenuous.
Many people replying seem to think you are advocating the execution of every man and woman who work for the company. I suspect that's not what you mean.
But how do you execute the entity economically?
To me, the right way to do it would be for the US government to take ownership of all the stock, and for the stock to be resold under a new corporate name. A criminal trial should then take place, with the C-suite officers and board of directors under scrutiny regarding their roles in the decisions, with clemency/immunity given to engineers and laborers for their full and complete testimony.
The only way the behavior changes is if you sanction it with meaningful consequences.
My words were probably poorly chosen; and it was a casual comment, intended to be taken casually, not as a call for a bloody revolution. I thought my disclaimer of being opposed to the actual death penalty for humans was sufficient to alleviate any fear that I actually ever want anyone killed, but the angry response seems to indicate otherwise.
I'm sorry, but I find the comparison ludicrous, despite the name.
Civilized like in 'western civilization'? E.g. USA? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_the_Unit...
Have the US transfer this amount (should be north of a trillion) to the victims or their representatives and serve justice!
This would hurt those with claims against the company but no hand in the decisions as much (if not more) than the responsible actors.
A real corporate parallel of the death penalty -- or at least, an ultimate corporate penalty for serious violations -- should take a different form. A couple ideas:
(1) personal, joint-and-several, liability of corporate officers with responsibility over (whether or not directly involved) and those employees actively directing the offense,
(2) allowing piercing the corporate veil to make equity holders liable in the event the corporation itself and legally responsible officers and employees as described in (1) cannot meet the liability for the offense.
You're probably right that there are better ways that cause less harm. I just don't know how to get there. Corporations at this level wield so much power, it's hard to figure out how governments or courts can effectively regulate them.
Regardless, I don't think this settlement is enough, because the people involved (generally, though I think a couple of low-level engineers were fired) will continue going to work each day, drawing their massive salaries. I'm willing to concede I don't have all the answers on what justice really looks like, but I'm confident it's not this. This just isn't enough for years of cold, calculated, destruction of human life for profit.
Maybe put a 30% tariffs on all of their imports for 30 years or something. What of splitting it up?
The problem is that the regular factory workers are the ones that would end up paying the bigger price in a corporate death penalty situation, and that companies trading abroad would be able to escape the penalty (in this case, for instance, the US could simply forbid VW to do business on their soil).
That would get the CxO in other companies attention, in a double-quick-time fashion.
I do agree that fines that seem astronomical to us (USD15Bn is huge in any personal context), to a corporation can be just The Cost of Doing Business. Depending on how long they've been doing this, they may have made twice that amount.
We're not talking smog monsters here, we're talking one chemical in particular (NPC), from one kind of engine by one car maker. I don't want to sound like I'm downplaying this, but given the kind of comments I see about this, I want to think the visceral reaction is based in rationality.
Is it?
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/oct/29/vw-emiss...
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/29/upshot/how-many-deaths-did...
I guess it's possible to look at these numbers, and compare them to the number of deaths caused by autos in general (even the ones that follow all the rules), and consider it a small thing; something that doesn't justify a massively disruptive response.
But, from my perspective, VW made a conscious decision, and an ongoing choice over many years, to violate the law, and caused illegal levels of dangerous emissions in exchange for greater profits.
So...I don't think I'm responding irrationally when I am extremely critical of a company that would make those decisions over a span of many years, knowingly trading human life and human health for greater profits.
I'm critical of internal combustion auto companies, in general, but I'm not calling for them to be destroyed, and I don't go out of my way to talk trash about them. I'm pretty specific in my ire toward VW (though others have suggested several car manufacturers are pulling similar tricks and emitting illegal and dangerous levels in real world environments), and if that's the case, I'd consider those to be criminal companies, as well. I hope such companies will also be investigated, and also face consequences. But, "everybody's doing it" shouldn't be a defense when the stakes are this high.
Going off a direct analogy with a human, it appears it would require destroying the equivalent of the brain, so perhaps a forced wiping of the IT infrastructure, inventory ledgers, blueprints? Probably also a seizure of all patents.
At the end of the day it's just money, except it's probably simpler to just take it in cash. (Or however the $15B is expected to be disbursed).
My thinking is merely that at some point, we as a society should probably consider refusing to allow a corporation that has shown an ongoing wilful disregard of human life to continue to exist.
There is lots more comments on this below, it's just an interesting problem.
I had been following this thread with a certain amount of blasé, but the thought of seizing a patent portfolio and releasing it into the public domain makes me raise an eyebrow or three.
Same if they e.g. issued a ban on VW selling cars in the EU for say 5 years.
We just need strict liability for corporate officers.
Every business decision comes with a cost/benefit analysis. Hurting your employees goes into the "cost" side, and if you do the bad thing anyway, obviously the "benefits" outweighed the "cost" of potentially hurting your employees.
But you don't have to defend yourself from this company. You aren't in danger. As a result punishing the workers would be nothing but a crime.
Maybe in 2 pieces, maybe into lots more pieces.
http://www.cnbc.com/2015/10/29/vw-excess-emissions-linked-to...
Allowing some New World Judge the power to destroy all international subsidiaries of a global corporation with 610,067 employees at the stroke of a pen might not improve the situation.
WikiPedia places the economic cost at $39+ billion, by one measure.
"A peer-reviewed study published in Environmental Pollution estimated that the fraudulent emissions are associated with 45 thousand disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) and a value of life lost of at least 39 billion US dollars."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal#D...
Anyway, CO2 is not comparable to NOx in terms of danger to human health; CO2 is a real problem, of course, but as I understand it, this was an environmental and human health trade-off that is not at all well-balanced. It produced out-sized harm in exchange for small reductions on the CO2 side. Even if the amount of NOx produced only increased by the same amount that CO2 decreased (which is not the case, if I understand it correctly), it would still be a bad trade. I'm no expert, but the experts I've read on the subject haven't been saying, "oh, it's really no big deal because CO2 went down."
Numbers and studies have been posted by another user in this thread, it’s definitely a huge difference.
That’s kinda why VW did it, it saves fuel and is cleaner.
This is one of those cases where the corporate death penalty is the only just outcome I can think of.
$15 billion looks like a large sum; and maybe it's even enough to deter car companies from doing something similar in the future. Maybe. VW is worth $73 billion, and they generated a lot of money on the strength of their diesel campaigns. Amortized over the many years that they were shipping out these cars, it begins to look like a cost of doing business, rather than a massively punitive expense.