Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by lostlogin on Monday June 27, 2016 @08:18PM
(#11990580)
Often shareholders have a degree of culpability. Arms companies and tobacco are examples where in my view shareholders are using their money to promote harm. Automakers fall somewhere on the harm - good spectrum and I'd mostly not put them down as a net good. Fossil fuel emissions would be be the key reason. Shareholders have a choice where to put their money and many (most?) choose high returns over anything else. I'd say punishing this behaviour might be worth considering.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by tptacek on Monday June 27, 2016 @08:29PM
(#11990627)
Every time we assess a multi-billion-dollar penalty against a public company, we acknowledge that its shareholders share some culpability.
Do you think shareholders of a company like VW, which includes pretty much everyone with a retirement plan, shoulder _all_ the responsibility? Because that's pretty much what a "corporate death penalty" means.
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by lostlogin on Monday June 27, 2016 @10:55PM
(#11991186)
> Do you think shareholders of a company like VW, which includes pretty much everyone with a retirement plan, shoulder _all_ the responsibility?
No. That's why I said "a degree of culpability".
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by tptacek on Monday June 27, 2016 @11:05PM
(#11991218)
Sure. I agree! I don't think it's fair for shareholders to reap returns that were derived in part from malfeasance.
The question isn't whether companies (and thus their shareholders) should be penalized for wrongdoing. It's whether shareholders should be zeroed out by a "corporate death penalty". I think it's an interesting question, why we don't have one of those.
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by lostlogin on Monday June 27, 2016 @11:20PM
(#11991267)
I appear to be arguing with someone who has the same viewpoint as me. Perhaps a better summary of my view is that the existing penalty system would be OK if the fines were larger (and this hit shareholders hard enough to incentivise others not to break the law).
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by tptacek on Monday June 27, 2016 @11:53PM
(#11991383)
Yep. In particular, I think it should be easier for prosecutors to make felony cases against corporate officers.
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by SixSigma on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @04:30AM
(#11992280)
Presumably then you don't use any fossil fuels, or do you self flaggilate?
You can't just blame automobile makers for the existence of automobiles.
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B
by lostlogin on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @06:18AM
(#11992594)
I think that blaming VW for cars that have emissions greater than what a buyer would expect is probably fair. Who do you blame?