News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by amelius on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:46AM (#11619144)
I'm still wondering about one thing: if everybody has a basic income, then who will be doing the dirty jobs like collecting our waste? Will the price for waste collecting go up? And will there then be a kind of economic "inversion", where the intellectual people prefer to work on interesting stuff at the expense of money, while the "non-intellectual" (need a better word here) people will make all the money doing the dirty jobs?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by arximboldi on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:03AM (#11619204)
I don't know if that would actually be the case, but if it were, the question would be: is it actually a bad thing?

I don't see any moral justification for a software engineer earning more than someone collecting waste [1]. In fact, it is normal that as our society gets more educated and the supply of unskilled workers goes down, a lot of hard manual labor will become expensive. This is already the case with mining, for example. The fact that we software engineers do a job that we like and is well paid at the same time is a very lucky (for us) historical accident.

On the other hand, I see in basic income an opportunity to also do unalienated work. For example, I'd very happily use BI to take buy some time off and to do a kinda "libre software retreat", hacking on free projects for a while without needing to bargain with an employer that owns everything that comes out of my head.

[1] Excluding the cost of education, let's assume university is free as in a few places in Europe.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by weddpros on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:04AM (#11619501)
"I don't see any moral justification for a software engineer earning more than someone collecting waste"

That's because moral justification isn't at the center of our society. The market is. Many attempts have been made to switch from the market to something else, not many were brilliant.

The "lucky historical accident" you cite isn't one... It's just the way our society was built.

Also you could argue on many different levels. To me, long studies meant delayed enjoyment of life, less freedom until 23, etc... You get less immediately, more later.

In the end, the question is really: "Do we want to use social engineering (as it's called) and try to build a brand new society, when all other attempts lead to poverty and war?"

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mcv on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:26AM (#11619583)
The labour market is not going away with BI. It will just become more free. Currently, many workers are forced to accept crappy jobs for little pay because the alternative is starvation. With BI, they can afford to say no when they don't think the compensation is worth it. If those crappy jobs are necessary, they will have to improve, either by making the jobs more fun or interesting, or increasing the pay.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:18PM (#11623861)
> The labour market is not going away with BI. It will just become more free.

Of interesting note in this domain, BI is often advocated as an alternative to minimum wage (such that in a mature BI system, there would be no minimum wage, though in some models there'd be a transitional period as the BI ramped up and the minimum wage wound down, at least in real if not nominal terms.)

So, while BI removes economic duress that forces people to take low-wage jobs, that also allows it to remove regulatory barriers which, while they exist to prevent abusive profiteering from economic duress, also have a side-effect of preventing generally mutually-beneficial arrangements that happen to have low wages (but where the low-wage earner might benefit from experience that increases future potential, etc.)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by DominikR on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:10AM (#11620799)
If you subsidise people so they don't need to accept "crappy jobs" then it distorts the market instead of making it more "free" because now a potential worker with fewer skills valued by the market doesn't need to make his living by taking a job that is adequate for his level of education/skills.

> If those crappy jobs are necessary, they will have to improve, either by making the jobs more fun or interesting, or increasing the pay.

You make this sound as if an employer simply can raise the pay of his employees without taking into account the realities of the market.

Some services or products are worth less precisely because there is no customer available willing to pay more for it.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mcv on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:20AM (#11621417)
No, duress (which is what the prospect of death is) does not make a market more free. If you are forced to accept a crappy deal because otherwise you will die, you are not making a free decision. A fair deal in a free market is one that you can afford to say no to.

> Some services or products are worth less precisely because there is no customer available willing to pay more for it.

And for some services or products there simply isn't a viable market. If it's necessary to keep people in poverty to keep it viable, then I say we're better off without it.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by DominikR on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:30PM (#11623068)
What duress are you talking about? No one in the EU or the US will actually die if they don't take some crappy job.

These people are free to live in a tent and dive into trashcans for food if they don't like to work, which isn't nice but this certainly isn't death! It's just a crappy lifestyle.

It's just they don't want to live in a tent and they want to have a smartphone, a car and enjoy all the things that the working population enjoys.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by zyxley on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:09PM (#11623798)
> which isn't nice but this certainly isn't death!

It took me literally five seconds of searching to find a study [1] that notes that homeless people in the UK have a death rate that starts at twice that of people with homes and increases up to six times that of people with homes with age.

[1]: http://www.crisis.org.uk/data/files/publications/Homelessnes...

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by DominikR on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:36PM (#11624023)
This isn't surprising considering the alcohol/drug abuse and crime among homeless people.

The reason why their death rate is higher is their state of mind.

It causes them to not take that crappy job that barely affords them a normal life and can potentially open up new perspectives for the future and instead choose to do nothing and hang out with the wrong people until it is too late and they end up on the street.

I don't see how giving them free money will in any way change their psychological condition. (of course there are always exceptions)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by zyxley on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:05PM (#11624238)
Are you really trying to claim that literally every homeless person is a drug-abusing criminal?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by DominikR on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:19PM (#11624705)
No I did not claim this. I wrote that drug and alcohol abuse is affecting more homeless people than others. This is obviously one of the causes why the death rate for homeless people is higher.

But you are obviously not interested in a normal discussion since you just try to read something into my statements to attack me.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ticviking on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:22PM (#11623894)
The same duress that uses force to prevent me for moving into the hills and living in a tent off the land.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by humanrebar on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:45AM (#11619671)
> That's because moral justification isn't at the center of our society. The market is.

The moral argument is that the market is more fair at setting prices because it is a more fundamentally democratic mechanism than price controls. That is, all of us together, compared to a handful of easily-lobbied people, are better at finding sensible prices.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by panic on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:28AM (#11619593)
That's because moral justification isn't at the center of our society. The market is.

So how much do you pay your friends to hang out with you? I've been going with $20 a visit, but I've heard that might be a little on the low side these days.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:21AM (#11620920)
The market rate is closer to $100, at least in luxury cities like New York.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by atom-morgan on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:54AM (#11620134)
What are you even talking about?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pasquinelli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:11PM (#11624969)
the center of society: human relationships.

edit: at least that's what i assume they're talking about.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by vixen99 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:45AM (#11620057)
George Orwell in "Keep the Aspidistra Flying" suggested that friendly personal offline relationships are all but impossible between people with widely disparate incomes. Exceptions as always, prove the rule.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by octobyte on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:11AM (#11621335)
> To me, long studies meant delayed enjoyment of life, less freedom until 23, etc... You get less immediately, more later.

What do you think life is like if you choose to skip postsecondary education? In most cases, it's straight into a factory/manual labor job that is much more physically (and in many cases mentally and emotionally) draining than your standard white-collar coding job.

To characterize those who choose education as having less in the near term seems to ignore what modern universities have become: in America at least, it's basically a secular rumspringa, wherein students dabble in drugs, sex, and other "counter culture" in addition to their studies. This may not be the experience of every CS student (perhaps due to the field's gender inequality and the number of introverted personalities), but it's just a gross misrepresentation to state that choosing further education means less freedom and enjoyment of your life and you should be rewarded thusly.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by weddpros on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:23AM (#11626582)
I think it's often a matter of immediate freedom... even if I have a clear idea of what life is without high education.

"You'll do whatever you want but get a degree first": tell me you've never heard these words. Maybe this education-then-life approach is counter-productive: education should be a life long journey, and life shouldn't start after your studies. "Finish your homework first, then you'll get to play" may be related...

Also, I suffered a stroke at 32 because of my job, so I'm not sure IT is as safe as you think. YMMV.

And I didn't study in the USA. Free education in Europe is not always as sexy as some may think. I often think that maybe this difference is what makes Europeans boring, and americans so creative and innovative. It's like we're trained through higher education to be obedient (white collar) workers, and you're trained more to achieve whatever you really want.

Lastly, it's been studied/proven/observed/shown that children who can delay immediate gratification for a better future outcome will perform better at school and in their lives (cf The Stanford marshmallow experiment).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mrottenkolber on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:29AM (#11619597)
Who or what is your society? Moral justification is absolutely at the center of European society. Sure, we have lots of criminal capitalists here as well, but morals is our way to deal with those people.

You seem to suggest letting these American-style gangsters go unchecked. Why though?

You also seem to be suggesting that studying until 23 is less enjoyable than working 9-17 from 17/18 onwards.

This all leads me to think you have a very upper-class, down-upon, shielded from trouble perspective.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by atom-morgan on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:55AM (#11620150)
All they said was morality doesn't set prices for labor. Buyers of labor do (market).
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pasquinelli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:12PM (#11624973)
in a market, no one sets prices. at least if a market is free, people only take prices.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by foldr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:31AM (#11619945)
>The "lucky historical accident" you cite isn't one... It's just the way our society was built.

The point is that you couldn't have been a software engineer if you'd been born 100 years ago. And demand for software engineers might tank in the future. People who currently enjoy their jobs as software engineers are lucky to be living in a time when it's possible to make a good living doing that. If you'd been born in another time, there might not have been such a good match between what you're good at, what you enjoy, and what's profitable.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by danieldk on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:11AM (#11619230)
I don't see any moral justification for a software engineer earning more than someone collecting waste [1].

In general I agree. However, besides education costs (I have quite many friends who have a sizeable loan), software engineers also enter the workforce quite a bit later. E.g., taking Netherlands as an example:

- Waste collector: age 12-16 VMBO

- Software engineer: age 12-18 VWO, age 18-23 BA+MA university

Also, very few students actually finish university in time. So, they are usually 24 or 25 when they are on the market. So, there would be less opportunity to build up a pension at equal wages.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by oselhn on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:35AM (#11619626)
I think that most of those students already work during their studies and income difference is so big that they will definitely earn more money in total before 30. I would be more worried about doctors which start to work independently a lot later and do not earn much in the beginning of their carrier (at least in my country).
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by toyg on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:37AM (#11619370)
In the brave new world of guaranteed income, why would you need a pension?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by LukeB_UK on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:45AM (#11619409)
Because while the basic income would suffice for the basics, the pension allows you to live your retirement in comfort.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by icen on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:43AM (#11619397)
The same reason you have pensions now, despite guaranteed state pensions. Whilst $10K is probably liveable, in some places, if you own a house, it's likely not going to be terribly comfortable.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by redsummer on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:48AM (#11619689)
"I don't see any moral justification for a software engineer earning more than someone collecting waste"

Garbage Disposal people earn over $100k. Software engineers earn about $80k. A job that can be outsourced or automated is not valuable. http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/24/news/economy/trash-workers-h...

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by treerock on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:08AM (#11619792)
According to the article "Nationwide, the annual salary for a garbage truck driver is $40,000"
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:24AM (#11620946)
> A job that can be outsourced or automated is not valuable.

Garbage disposal is at this point a lot closer to automation than software development.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by hasenj on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:45PM (#11623172)
> I don't see any moral justification for a software engineer earning more than someone collecting waste

Do you see a moral justification for paying a doctor more than a receptionist? I see none for paying them the same.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by rmc on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:10AM (#11619227)
Higher wages for dirty jobs would certainly spur innovation in labour saving devices to reduce the amount of manual labour.

"Dirty" jobs being paid more certainly does sound a little more ethical than today, where those with little options have to work those dirty jobs to keep their house and to eat, and they are paid low.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:34AM (#11619620)
How would it spur innovation? After enacting a BI, we've just reduced the labor supply and funneled resources toward consumption (since rich people invest, poor people consume, and we've shifted resources from rich to poor).

Labor supply = Labor servicing consumption + labor servicing investment

Rearranging this implies:

Labor providing investment = labor supplied - labor providing consumption

Simple arithmetic shows we now have less resources devoted to investment. So how will this innovation actually occur? I realize demand for it might go up, but if supply doesn't increase correspondingly, so what?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:59AM (#11619738)
>funneled resources toward consumption (since rich people invest, poor people consume, and we've shifted resources from rich to poor) //

That's a natty turn of phrase but I'm calling bullshit.

Rich people invest with the excess financial wealth they have after they've consumed hugely more than a poor person.

Give me more money and I can afford to eat better (reduced healthcare burden), can repair my house (reducing total resources needed over the lifetime of the building; and again there are health implications). Give that money to someone rich and yes, they will invest - sucking more value away from the populous without producing more value - but they'll also do things like buying a private jet which consumes/pollutes hugely and wastes resources.

Perhaps some of the wealthy won't be able to have private islands and maintain their more liquid assets, for shame.

Why not cooperatives and micro-investment? Why does a rich capitalist have to be the investor and suck all the value from the system?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:17AM (#11619860)
If you believe that the rich consume and the poor invest, then the best stimulus during times of recession is tax cuts for the rich. I take it this is your preferred policy for the next recession?

There is no particular reason investment has to come from rich people. That's just how western economies seem to work. As I noted, in Namibia, poor people do seem to invest new wealth.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:24AM (#11620370)
Where did I say that the poor invest (they do, in The West, eg in pensions, but we're talking generalities)? We're all clearly consumers. Rich people costume more than there share, they still have excess financial wealth to invest.

Redistributing this would allow poorer people opportunity to take part in investment which in turn should lead to more redistribution.

Tax increases for the rich in recession would (with a similarly naive analysis to the one you proffered) reduce the tax burden on the poor and allow then to become richer, increasing their consumption. Millions can buy a new TV instead of one person getting a yacht.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:30AM (#11620424)
You just contradicted yourself, and agreed that the rich invest while the poor consume. Glad we are in agreement!
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:51PM (#11622282)
>agreed that the rich invest while the poor consume //

You just twisted my words and acted disingenuously.

I said, for the third time, the rich consume. The rich consume far more than the poor. The rich invest more than the poor, but that's because the poor don't have money to invest. Take all the money from the rich and give it to the poor and consumption and investment will shift. The people holding the money aren't as special as capitalism would have us assume.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:33PM (#11622652)
The point is what will happen in aggregate. If the poor gain $1 additional and the rich lose $1 additional, will investment go up or down? If it goes up then we should target fiscal stimulus at the rich during bad economic times. If it goes down then a BI will reduce future investment.

You are unfortunately in the situation that the stated reasons for your preferred policies contradict each other. That's quite strange - it's almost as if those stated reasons are post-hoc justifications and not your real motivation.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by aninhumer on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:23PM (#11625310)
Perhaps investment goes down, but it will be more focused on things that benefit society as a whole, because they are much more able to consume it.

Basic Income makes "vote with your wallet" a meaningful concept, instead of a hollow joke.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by adwf on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:26AM (#11619919)
Well putting aside that you might be making a kind of post-hoc fallacy there with your equation; Is reducing labor supply really a bad thing?

Most developed countries have unemployment permanently somewhere between 5-10% or even more during recession. Some, like Spain, have closer to 25%. Reducing labor supply may be the only answer.

It's not that I don't agree with you in principle. But you can only gain productivity if there are things for people to do. The fact of modern society is that we are running out of jobs.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:34AM (#11619969)
Really? Child care is easily available to working mothers? House cleaning services are cheap and readily available to all skilled workers? Professionals sit in the back of their car working on their laptop while a driver watches the road?

There are lost of things to do. We have a situation of labor scarcity, not a surplus.

Complaining about a labor surplus right now is like a 350lb man eating french fries on the theory that he might starve in the future.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by adwf on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:57AM (#11620161)
For the correct pay, yes.

Some jobs aren't paid enough for people to do and still afford to live. Basic income actually fixes that by giving people a baseline to live off, upon which their salary can build.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:19AM (#11620316)
If those jobs "aren't paid enough for people to afford to live" then India should be full of a billion rotting corpses. I was there last week and I feel like I would have noticed the apocalypse.

A much better solution than BI would be a guaranteed job and/or an expanded EITC. These solutions - while not sounding as cool and hipster as BI - have no labor disincentive and cost a lot less.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by adwf on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:37PM (#11622151)
Putting aside the absurd comparison of living costs in a 3rd world country vs 1st world...

India is filled with a ton of misery. It's the only country in the world where I saw dead people just lying in the gutter. The Mumbai slum was one of the worst places I've ever been and you want to hold that up as some sort of ideal? That people should just live down to that level instead of striving for better? If it wasn't for the Indian government welfare programs, that slum would be filled with rotting corpses.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:35PM (#11622666)
I didn't hold it up as an ideal. I held up the middle class experience there as an example of what happens when labor isn't scarce.

You seem to think I'm endorsing having very few goods and services. I'm not. On the contrary, I oppose policies like BI which will reduce goods and services available.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:03AM (#11620729)
More money for consumers -> more money that can be earned by businesses -> more incentive to come up with innovative things for people to spend money on
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:23AM (#11620936)
Forget about money - that's a red herring which is confusing you.

Humans are needed to actually invent those innovative things. But in the BI world, we have fewer humans actually devoting their time to this. (See simple arithmetic above.)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by iza on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:12PM (#11622942)
How many potential innovators and inventors are currently slaving away at menial jobs instead of pursuing their passions? The idea that innovation is driven purely by investment is an oversimplification.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:41PM (#11623147)
Innovation is not driven by humans devoting time and effort to figuring out how to do things better? What do you think innovation is driven by?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by aninhumer on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:36PM (#11625361)
Yes, but "humans devoting time and effort" is not the same thing as "rich people investing money".

Certainly the latter can enable the former, but the point made above is that Basic Income can do that as well.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Chronic51 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:08AM (#11619521)
Dirty jobs will pay more. But their rent will also increase. Net negative for them.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chongli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:33AM (#11620450)
Their rent won't increase. It'll decease because they can quit their dirty job and move somewhere nice with low rent but few jobs, like a small town.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:13AM (#11619832)
It may be possible to control the outcomes of property owner's greed with heavy taxation on non-owner occupied properties? Certainly it wouldn't work to leave rent increases uncontrolled as landlords would then just increase prices (in the UK at least).
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by NhanH on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:50AM (#11619157)
> And will there then be a kind of economic "inversion", where the intellectual people prefer to work on interesting stuff at the expense of money, while the "non-intellectual" (need a better word here) people will make all the money doing the dirty jobs?

In the long run, any menial task is supposed to be automated away completely. In short term, what you described already happened in area like Post-doc and game industry (or humanities degree, if you will ...).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nine_k on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:54AM (#11619448)
I don't think plumbing or even waste collection is going to be seriously automated any time soon.

Can you imagine what kind of autonomous robot would it take to be able to do regular plumbing work, in cramped spaces, with low visibility, requiring relatively significant physical efforts? The software side of it can definitely be solved (though not easy at all). The hardware side would require significant breakthroughs, if the device is going to be cost-effective even compared to a highly-paid certified plumber.

Same applies to electricians, and in certain degree to car mechanics, too. We have large swaths of infrastructure built with maintenance by humans in mind. These humans are not exactly easy to replace with robots.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by sokoloff on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:01AM (#11619488)
Agreed, though I don't think I'd include electricians, plumbers, and car mechanics work in the set of things called "menial tasks". Those are skilled trades, even though blue-collar.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nine_k on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:24AM (#11621456)
Totally agreed. E.g. working successfully with old, crooked, space-constrained pipe connections, let alone broken and misbehaving pipes, does take some ingenuity. The manual component of the work can only be helped so much even with the best tools. Maybe when plumbing standards change drastically this could be reasonably automated, but this would take decades if not centuries, because old buildings are not going anywhere anytime soon.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by cududa on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:24PM (#11623919)
Waste collection I can see being automated in suburbs. Already many of them have arms that grab the trash/ recycling and dump them automatically with just a driver behind the wheel.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by aninhumer on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:40PM (#11625379)
I'd imagine the way plumbing might eventually be automated is by new buildings being designed with that in mind.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by FiReaNG3L on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:50AM (#11619156)
It is already the case - go try and pursue a career in academia and see how much money you make compared to a plumber.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gjm11 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:21AM (#11619277)
Some intellectually satisfying jobs (academic, author, artist, ...) pay badly. But many others are well paid, and probably most of the best-paid jobs are (1) largely brainwork and (2) pretty interesting to do.

Some not-very-intellectual jobs (plumbers are everyone's favourite example, which makes me suspect there aren't many others) pay pretty well. But most don't.

Some jobs that usually pay pretty well: Software developer. Lawyer. Doctor. Quant. Corporate executive.

Some jobs that usually pay pretty badly: Cleaner. Waiter. Shop-floor sales person. Bank cashier.

I think these are more representative than comparing adjunct professors with plumbers.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by vintermann on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:33AM (#11619348)
Plumbers, electricians, carpenters, automation mechanics, fishermen off the top of my head. Just from local personal experience in a place with low unemployment.

It's hard to disentangle the effects, since many of my age peers who went the blue-collar route weren't exactly responsible... but those who were, and some who weren't, still did very well for themselves. Theoretically, maybe we white-collar workers would do better after 20 years - but not if our blue-collar friends invested their savings in the meantime (which many do).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by argonaut on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:57AM (#11619184)
In CS, if we include industry pure research, you make a lot more ;)
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Roritharr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:08AM (#11619223)
I'd wager that there are a lot of people that avoid a career in CS much more than a career in plumbing...
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by thiagoperes on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:40AM (#11619385)
First of all, no job should be considered dirty.

Second, if you go to places like Netherlands, Norway and Japan you'll see that it's not about money. Higher education prepares workers to do more complex, more efficient and more productive jobs.

Also, the society is more conscious about not having someone to do stupid things for them like collecting their trays after they eat at the McDonadls, this is YOUR responsibility as a member of a society, to look for others as well.

So in Amsterdam for example, street cleaning and trash collection are done with specialized vehicles. In Denmark, subways are autonomous.

I like to believe that as you increase education and income, the people that would be considered "dumb" in an very unequal society will spend their time developing technologies to automate tasks no one likes to perform and increase productivity.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by latch on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:06AM (#11619514)
Your parent probably meant dirty in a very physical way, not, as you seem to have taken it, a demeaning way. I don't think of "dumb" when I hear "dirty"; maybe the popular Discovery TV Show "Dirty Jobs" is a reason for that.

Also, while I've never been to Norway or Netherlands, I think you're underestimating the number of "dirty jobs" that support you. Who's tilling the land? Mining the minerals? Excavating land? Driving the garbage trunks? Emptying the lobster traps? De-greasing the engines? Tending the public spaces?

I'm not against legalized prostitution, but I think its a strong strike against any claims of higher responsibility towards society.

Yes, many of these things might be automated one day, but that seems far away (a century at least). Your parent's question is valid and, as far as I'm concerned, there's no place on earth that comes remotely close to what you seem to be describing.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by corin_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:50AM (#11619436)
> First of all, no job should be considered dirty.

Some jobs, such as cleaning, and collecting waste, literally deal with dirt. I don't think he was using "dirty" as an insult.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by sokoloff on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:59AM (#11619478)
You're suggesting that people that would be considered "dumb" today will suddenly start inventing automation of street cleaning, trash collection, and the like if we implement a basic income and better education?

That strikes me as an extraordinary claim.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by spurgu on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:29AM (#11619598)
Yeah, it's more like the people owning the waste companies that would try to drive up automation because of the high costs associated with manual labor.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by spacecowboy_lon on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:18AM (#11619865)
They meant in the industrial relations sense of being "dirty" Jobs which traditionally came with a premium - sewer workers dustmen steel workers both because its unplesant work and there s also a risk premium.

Its why a pit deputy (coal miner) in the UK can charge £2k for a single weekend shift.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by arethuza on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:45AM (#11620056)
I don't think there are any "pits" in the UK anymore - the last deep coal mine closed at the end of 2015:

http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/dec/18/kellingle...

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by spacecowboy_lon on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:07PM (#11621867)
Ah this might have been before that i was at a training course for TUPE and some of the senior Union Guys where there on the same course.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:29AM (#11620986)
> Also, the society is more conscious about not having someone to do stupid things for them like collecting their trays after they eat at the McDonadls, this is YOUR responsibility as a member of a society, to look for others as well.

To play devil's advocate, why? If my time is more valuable than a McDonald's worker's, why should I be wasting it on cleaning up trays?

Your argument could easily be extended to saying that restaurants are in general frivolous. Isn't feeding yourself a fundamental responsibility as a member of society? Except that destroying restaurants would actually be quite economically negative.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by vanviegen on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:06AM (#11619212)
Apart from the extra income, consider that most people don't actually want to be hanging around their houses all day every day. Of course, employers may have to make working conditions more attractive and many people may want to work shorter weeks. Hurray for quality of life, I say!
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by PietdeVries on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:18AM (#11620310)
Sure - or alternatively, employers move to another country where wages are lower and employees complain less. China for instance. Think back: what is still entirely made in the US or the UK? What can we still produce without China? And why with free money down the streets would that all over a sudden change or improve? But it will change in a worse way when employees want better working conditions...
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gonzo41 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:01AM (#11619196)
People join the military for reasons other than money. Become doctors and emergency services etc all for reasons that are not related to money. People will do the things they do, but having some money means that people can take risks and feel safe in society. It removes the hard floor.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Loic on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:06AM (#11619215)
"people can [...] feel safe in society": This is the most important thing from my point of view. If people feel safe, you reduce stress, tension in the society and you increase the quality of life of everybody in the same society. It should benefit everybody.

This is really why I want this to happen on a large enough scale to see if it really works or not.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mtbcoder on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:57AM (#11619469)
> It removes the hard floor.

In the US, we could already make great strides with removing the hard floor by simply implementing universal, primary health care coverage, free/low-cost higher education and wages that keep up with inflation. I feel that BI in some form is inevitable and the next logical step of civilized society, however, given the incredible resistance to providing universal health care, I do not see BI happening in my lifetime.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by _Understated_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:09AM (#11619224)
I haven't read into it too much at the moment as it's still a bit of a pipe-dream just now although it's looking more likely to change but I sit on the fence at this time (with a lean towards "no").

I don't see that happening to be honest but I do see something worse...

Won't the price of everything go up for those that don't currently need the welfare system? Is this a sort of stealth tax increase on the middle class?

I live in the UK and pay a lot into the system but I am by no means rich. I don't claim anything except child benefit (dunno how I qualify but I do... for £80 a month or something).

If you remove the need for someone currently on welfare to take a min-wage job then that means the job either doesn't get done or the salary for it must go up. So, if it goes up, then that company's price will go up or they face going out of business.

If they manage to stay in business, I will need to pay more to use their service than I did before but if they go out of business because I am not willing to pay it, they end up claiming welfare and my tax goes up to pay for it.

Honestly, I don't see an upside for anyone except those that can't/won't work!

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yks on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:31AM (#11619340)
I think that is the point, there will be too many people "that can't work" due to tech innovations.

It all makes sense if you think about welfare not as "these slouches are rewarded for the laziness" but as a price you pay so that unemployed people are not forced into violent property expropriation from you.

When large swaths of population don't have an access to money-making jobs, it significantly affects middle class well-being.

Of course you can "get yours" and double down on police and live behind electric fences South Africa style, but that's not pretty.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by UVB-76 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:34AM (#11619358)
The "get yours" mentality is flawed because all you end up doing is imprisoning large sections of the population for poverty-driven crime, and you end up paying for their imprisonment.

What do prisoners get while in prison? Basic necessities, like food, shelter, warmth.

A kind of basic income, if you will.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Chronic51 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:14AM (#11619541)
Basic income except the rich and powerful cannot stop outside their home?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by _Understated_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:43AM (#11619398)
I don't think anyone wants a Sci-Fi dystopia: It doesn't benefit anyone.

Government should provide every citizen with basics should they falter: Food, clothing, shelter, education etc. I absolutely believe that is a basic human right.

What I don't want is to fund anything other than a safety net: Welfare should be a helping hand to get you back on your feet or to give you a start - Nothing more.

It should also come with an expiry date!

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pjc50 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:54AM (#11619451)
> Government should provide every citizen with basics should they falter: Food, clothing, shelter, education etc. I absolutely believe that is a basic human right.

> What I don't want is to fund anything other than a safety net: Welfare should be a helping hand to get you back on your feet or to give you a start - Nothing more. It should also come with an expiry date!

These two statements completely contradict one another. There are plenty of people who aren't going back on their feed any time soon due to disability or mental health issues.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by _Understated_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:04AM (#11619505)
You are right, they are contradictory - I was typing faster than I was thinking.

I believe in a kind of 2 tier system but I didn't get that across.

e.g. You lose you job and the welfare system keeps you going at your current burn rate (you will likely have to make some adjustments but you won't lose your house!) until you can get back on your feet. Let's say 12 months (pulled that figure out the air!)

After that, the basic welfare system comes into play where you will be given food, shelter, clothing, education etc.

That's the basic human right part I meant.

I am glossing over the details but at a high level you are kept afloat at your current level for a period, then you are given the basics for as long as you need them.

As for disability, that would be kind of basics+ (Not trying to make light of it but it's easiest to put it that way). I believe that it's every citizens duty to take care of people that just can't help themselves through disability. Their case be slightly different e.g. a house may need modifications, special transport etc.

Does that make sense?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pjc50 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:07AM (#11619517)
That seems quite a lot like the current UK system, although with more generous insurance after loss of employment and simpler claiming in the basic system, rather than negotiating the benefits maze.

(It's more complicated once you consider immigration and asylum, but hardly anyone not subject to that system understands it)

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pjc50 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:22AM (#11619289)
Child benefit is almost-universal. It was completely universal until a conservative government started means-testing it on the parents.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by _Understated_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:24AM (#11619305)
It's crazy. I absolutely don't need it but for some reason I qualify.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pjc50 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:44AM (#11619399)
It's not really for you - it is child benefit, after all. Think of it as basic income for kids, to keep them clothed and out of the factories.

I'm in favour of bringing back the Education Maintenance Allowance, and making it very slightly performance-related.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by _Understated_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:11AM (#11619535)
Haha, of course :)

However, I am not in favour of Government handouts. How much money did it cost to give me £80 back? £100? £150?

Would it not be better to reduce my tax so I pay £80 less each month?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pjc50 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:38AM (#11619646)
It might be cheaper to take the money and give it to everyone than build an elaborate means-testing system that requires taking far more information, a more complex computer system, more arguing over corner cases, and so on.

Straight handouts appear to be by far the most effective way of reducing poverty and its negative effects. It's rather like the War On Drugs; you can choose a system that moralises at people or one that improves their outcomes, but if you want to improve outcomes you have to give up moralising control.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by takno on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:33AM (#11619614)
It costs maybe 81 pounds a month to give you your 80 pounds. If it was means tested it would cost massively more per person you gave it to. In addition plenty of needy people would go without because they didn't know about it, or couldn't fill out the forms, or got arbitrarily sanctioned because their meeting with the job centre was on a day when the "advisor" hadn't met his sanctioning target
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by humanrebar on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:49AM (#11619694)
The government has interest in people investing in future growth (children), so it's subsidized. The alternative would be to tax childless people more heavily so they are always revenue-neutral with respect to retirement, health, and disability benefits.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by toyg on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:41AM (#11619386)
In UK? You always qualify, but you'll have to pay it all back if your income goes over a threshold. In its current form, it's basically an interest-free loan for 12 months.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:18AM (#11619272)
Absolutely. And even those who can't / won't work _still_ won't be able to find a place to live or eat well because rents and food prices will go up to compensate for it.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by rlpb on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:03AM (#11619203)
If the market rate for dirty jobs goes up, will the basic income be enough, or will I struggle to pay for my waste collection (and everything else) on the basic income alone?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:19AM (#11619273)
Which is a good point. Ultimately all costs get passed on to the consumer -- so where does it end?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by sergiosgc on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:59AM (#11619476)
It ends when the cost is so high that automation becomes cost-effective. Basic Income, as much as minimum wage, is a collective push towards skilled labor, away from menial tasks.

In general terms, UBI seems sane. I see two implementation problems. First, worldwide society competition: Can my society support UBI and compete with China? Second, automatic system balancing. What is the correct UBI level? Can we leave it out to be hashed by politicians?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by panic on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:30AM (#11619338)
As costs go up, consumers buy less. There's a certain price which maximizes profit: that's where it ends.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:38AM (#11619374)
Exactly. I have 5 apples. There are 5 people willing to pay at least $2 for them, so I sell them for $2. That's basic economics.

With a basic income, now most of these people have more money. So I can charge $3 per apple, and even if I only sell 4 of them I still make $2 more than I made before. I eat the last apple myself, and the person who only has the basic income doesn't get an apple at all.

I think universal welfare makes more sense.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by sokoloff on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:05AM (#11619510)
However, the $12 you got in case B is not worth as much in the market as the $10 you go in case A, since the economy appears to have suffered 50% inflation in the meantime.

Your $12 in case B has a purchasing power equivalent to $8 in case A.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by panic on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:47AM (#11619417)
If you have a monopoly on the only five apples in the world, why were you charging only $2 in the first place? In a competitive economy, somebody else will be happy to sell an apple to the last person.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:52AM (#11619444)
In practice that's not true and I suggest you research the amount of fruit that's left to rot in fields because companies decide it's not worth selling it.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by a3n on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:35AM (#11619624)
10k/year, or whatever it might be, isn't that much. Most people would want more, and you'll need to work for more.

As to "who would do the dirty work." You probably didn't mean it this way, but the question implies that we have to keep people down in order to do the work that "we" need them to do.

When something is in short supply, you compete for it. UBI would bring competition to employers, especially at the lower incomes. Part of that competition would be with "not working," but it would also be with other employers, as it would then be easier for people to look for or prepare for other jobs, and it would make it easier for people on the bottom rungs to expect better treatment.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by the-dude on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:50AM (#11619155)
Dirty jobs already are paid a premium. I would expect the differences to be amplified though, for good reason?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by T-A on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:20AM (#11619274)
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by UVB-76 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:30AM (#11619335)
This only applies to our global economy if every country were to implement UBI, and with similar amounts.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:50AM (#11619437)
Right, so as long as Chinese slaves make our junk, it's all good right?

Lovely.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by k-mcgrady on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:52AM (#11619169)
In my opinion a UBI won't work until we can automate more of these jobs but in the short term I agree with you that the wage for them would go up to attract people. It would also depend on the size of the UBI. If the UBI is just enough to get by comfortably but not enough to make big expenditures like a new TV/phone etc. then people will have to continue to work to afford luxuries. A lot of people do those jobs because they don't have the skills necessary for other jobs so if they want luxuries they will still do them (maybe part-time instead). I could also see highly skilled people who want extra money for one big purchase to take on a job like that for a few weeks (which you couldn't really do at a tech company).
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ww520 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:59AM (#11619477)
If no one does dirty jobs, their price goes up until it's worthwhile for someone to do them (think of Uber surge). Basic supply and demand.

More costly dirty jobs encourage automation and they will be automated away. The trend has started long ago. It used to take 3 people per garbage truck to collect trash, one driver and 2 people physically pick up the trash cans. Then it was 2 as better trucks came along. Now it's one driver per truck, as the truck has mechanical arms to collect the trash.

With driverless trucks in the horizon, it is not far fetch to have one driver overseeing 2 to a small fleet driverless trucks to collect garbage on a street in parallel.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nihonde on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:23AM (#11619292)
I'd like to think that if you've got a civilization that people feel is worth keeping, the "dirty" jobs become a shared responsibility.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:38AM (#11619372)
Low-skilled dirty jobs should either be automated, or they should be treated like taxation.

Everyone, without exception, has to pitch in and do them - to a reasonable standard, with doubled time for slacking, and serious punishments for avoidance - for [very small number of days a year].

If that sounds authoritarian, consider that's how work already functions for most people - except they're compelled to do it all the time, not just for [very small number of days].

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by adynatos on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:48AM (#11619427)
are you insane? can you see any way a trained neurosurgeon will want to pitch in sweeping the streets instead of using that time to do his highly specialized job and make enough money for it to hire two people to do the sweeping for him? this is absurd! take your totalitarian socialist society and get off my lawn.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nihonde on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:45AM (#11619670)
Actually, I see it every day in Japan. Elderly people, many of whom had distinguished careers, are up early in the morning to clean the streets——and believe me, this happens everywhere in Japan because there is no litter, no dead leaves, nothing. And you will see the same almost everywhere in Japan.

I met a retired Toyota engineer who was an expert in the hydrogen fuel-cell technology that is now in the Toyota Mirai. When I met him, he was volunteering his time to keep Atsuta shrine clean and feeding the local roosters, something he does whenever he feels like getting out of the house.

What I have learned in Japan is that if people feel like there is a chance of doing a good job together, it becomes a pleasure (not a chore or an imposition or an exploitation) to contribute. I believe this is universal, but Japan happens to have touched the magic ring (for the time being).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by aninhumer on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:50PM (#11625412)
I do wonder if the job-for-life culture in Japan helps with this. Perhaps, rather than people being lazy because they can get away with it, not being terrified of losing your job means they can actually appreciate it, and learn to take pride in their work.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by nihonde on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:41PM (#11626006)
Probably that, plus a decent safety net of social services, plus teaching children to take responsibility, clean up, etc. Lots of factors involved, but the good news is that it can be done.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chongli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:56AM (#11619462)
Tons of people already do some of the dirtiest jobs around for free. One example is caring for severely disabled and/or elderly people. Sure, there are facilities for these people where workers get paid to care for them but many rely on family members to care for them without any financial compensation.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gaius on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:56AM (#11619182)
The basic income will provide only the basics - if you want luxuries, you will still need a job.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:25AM (#11620377)
Is having a child a basic or a luxury?

This idea seems to be built on a notion that there are needs and that their are wants, and that we are only going to give enough to supply needs. But there are two major underlying problems with this.

First, even if we assume that needs and wants exist, you aren't going to have agreement on what falls in what category. For starters, is having children a need or a luxury? Is a clean place to live a need or a luxury? Is having a healthy food a need or a want?

Second, I'm not sure the division between needs and wants is even real. Yes, you'll die without food in a few weeks, die without water in a few days, and die without air in a few minutes, but what about something that increases ones likelihood of dying in a few years, but not any shorter? For example, a starving person can survive off a very poor diet for a much longer time than with no diet, but if they are missing vital nutrients, they will still eventually die. Or look at loneliness and the negative effects it has on people. You won't die within a year from lack of human contact, but your overall life expectancy will drop greatly (except for infants, who will die from lack of human contact, as shown in a few experiments which scientists are ethically banned from reproducing).

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gaius on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:41PM (#11623140)
It's a lifestyle choice, same as any other. If you want a certian lifestyle beyond the minimum, be prepared to earn it.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by drawkbox on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:03AM (#11619205)
On top of that you might be able to only have to work half a year or jobs could be shared among multiple people. Jobs may even pay more for harder work. Sharing jobs or partially working might also be needed to keep prices/inflation low, this actually meshes with the gig economy that is being talked about and moved to it seems. Entrepreneurship would be a huge result of basic income as well as competition for workers and increase in demand along with more consumers.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:22AM (#11619286)
I'm not convinced it will even provide the basics. There would be nothing to stop rents / real-estate prices from going up to compensate. Or food, or utilities. It's simple supply and demand.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dllthomas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:39PM (#11622183)
There would be competition to stop rents and real estate from going up to compensate. It may or may not be sufficient.

Note that it is not merely a question of competition of perfect substites. An apartment competes with a house, but also with a shared apartment, with living with family, with leaving the area. And note that a Basic Income quite directly increases the supply of "housing near some source of income".

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chongli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:57AM (#11619471)
Basic income would not significantly increase the demand for food or accommodation. How does "simple supply and demand" work in this case?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gambiting on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:18AM (#11619555)
If a baker can make the same amount of money not working thanks to basic income, it follows logically that you have to pay him/her more to stay and work, which increases the cost of bread for everyone. So now you have more money to spend but everything went up in price.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by alexvoda on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:37AM (#11619987)
Not necessarily. In scenario 1 with no basic income the baker only receives what he is paid. If there were no other providers, and the baker would not desire to do this work he could charge more to stay and work. This would apply until he has competition in one way or another.

In the second scenario, he receives BI, but the same market forces would apply and he would only be able to charge more as long as there are no competitors. Additionally, since everyone will receive BI this will grant people more potential free time. Time they could use to make their own bread in case the baker raises prices. In this scenario the baker would have less incentive to work but would also have more potential competition in case he raises the prices.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by cdash on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:42AM (#11620032)
The baker CANT make the same amount of money not working though. The baker makes additional money on top of the basic income.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:02AM (#11619495)
People will be able to pay more for it.

Remember, part of demand is the amount people are willing and able to pay.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chongli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:57AM (#11619728)
People's willingness to pay is not strictly positively correlated to their ability to pay. In many cases, such as rubinelli's example of increased mobility, an increase in ability to pay is marked by a decrease in willingness.

Overall, I'd argue that by increasing a person's ability to pay for anything you increase their ability to walk away from all kinds of bad deals. One of the best examples of this is given by Terry Pratchett:

The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.

Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.

But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.

This was the Captain Samuel Vimes 'Boots' theory of socioeconomic unfairness.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by msandford on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:24AM (#11620371)
Remember also that people's wants are effectively unlimited in aggregate. If we could all have 100 foot yachts and spaceships and Ferraris we collectively in large majority would choose to have those things. You know, in the absence of any negative consequences for those actions.

A beef carcass might have 500 pounds of meat on it, but only 5-10lbs of that is tenderloin. If we all have enough money to buy tenderloin it doesn't immediately follow that cows are then made up of nothing but tenderloin. So the price of tenderloin will go up until the demand balances the supply again. You can take this and apply it nearly anywhere in the economy and find it'll be approximately correct for a great many situations.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chongli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:05PM (#11621844)
You know, in the absence of any negative consequences for those actions

And there's the rub. Even if we could make 500lb all-tenderloin cattle you wouldn't see people buying hundreds of pounds of beef tenderloin for themselves every day. Billionaries like Bill Gates can already afford millions of pounds of tenderloin yet you don't see him eating that.

Basic income might cause the price of tenderloin to go up a little bit but so what? It's not going to do anything to the price of corn or rice or wheat. Maybe the price of an apartment in Manhattan will go up a little bit (I doubt it) but not a house in rural Wisconsin.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by msandford on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:29PM (#11623063)
> And there's the rub. Even if we could make 500lb all-tenderloin cattle you wouldn't see people buying hundreds of pounds of beef tenderloin for themselves every day.

First off, we can't make an all tenderloin cow. And second, that's the problem! If filet cost 1/4 of what it did now consumption might go up 100x. And obviously, it can't. But people would try. Until the price went up enough that the market for tenderloin started to clear again. But people have this extra money, right? So they can afford to spend more on hamburger. Congrats, we've raised prices!

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by chongli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:46PM (#11623178)
People have the extra money but they don't have to spend it on hamburger. They can spend it on durable goods as illustrated by the Discworld quote above. And just because demand for something goes up doesn't mean prices will. Often increased demand is a signal that a new market has opened up and this draws in competitors, causing prices to go down.

Look at the headlines about solar panels! Demand for solar panels is much higher today than it was 20 years ago and yet prices are dramatically lower.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by rubinelli on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:31AM (#11619606)
One thing to consider is that basic income increases mobility. Without the pressure to stay in large centers, where most jobs are concentrated, people can migrate to lower-cost areas.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dsq on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:31PM (#11622093)
And so the next, inevitable step after benefacting loyal citizens with their stipend would be price controls so that greedy kulaks - sorry, property owners, can't profiteer like that. Cast your vote for the next General Secretary!
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by akgerber on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:38PM (#11630050)
Given a sane zoning regime, the supply of housing will increase in response to increased demand.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by empressplay on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:16AM (#11619259)
I think that once landlords, housing markets and other needs-businesses such as utilities and food providers realize they can hike their prices to absorb the basic income, there will still be plenty of people collecting waste.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by fsloth on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:11AM (#11619233)
I would presume the quality of low-paying low-income jobs will increase. If people have the opportunity to leave there is an actual business incentive to treat employees well. I would presume the overall "quality" of the workforce would increase, as the detrimental effects of poverty on cognitive development and capacity is well known.

So who will do the dirty jobs? I presume ways are found in which to make them less distasteful. They are not about "dirtyness" per se, but about application of high dexterity manual labour on various tasks.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dagw on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:09AM (#11619526)
No matter how you structure BI, there will always be people who won't be getting it. If only citizens get it, then there will be lots of permanent residents who still need jobs, if citizens and permanent residents get it, then there will be lots of people of temporary work and student visas who still need a job etc. etc.

"Worst" case scenario. You end up having to import a bunch more foreigners to do those jobs at the lower wages.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Spooky23 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:42AM (#11619658)
That's already happening. I pay the guy mowing my lawn as much as the 40th percentile IT or programmer working at my company.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:23AM (#11620935)
Do you give him the salary and benefits of a 40th percentile programmer and pay all of his expenses in addition to that? Do you pay him as much as the billable rate of a 40th percentile programmer?

I doubt either one. To compare a full-time employee's hourly wage to an hourly billable rate you will generally want to multiply the hourly wage by about 2.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Spooky23 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:10AM (#11621316)
His average is about $60/hr. Plenty of IT full time, W2 contractors are billed at $45/hr fully loaded.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by tempodox on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:04AM (#11619504)
And the price for the production of waste would go up, too. Not necessarily a bad thing.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mrottenkolber on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:18AM (#11619556)
You sound really afraid of having to collect your own waste.