It all makes sense if you think about welfare not as "these slouches are rewarded for the laziness" but as a price you pay so that unemployed people are not forced into violent property expropriation from you.
When large swaths of population don't have an access to money-making jobs, it significantly affects middle class well-being.
Of course you can "get yours" and double down on police and live behind electric fences South Africa style, but that's not pretty.
What do prisoners get while in prison? Basic necessities, like food, shelter, warmth.
A kind of basic income, if you will.
Government should provide every citizen with basics should they falter: Food, clothing, shelter, education etc. I absolutely believe that is a basic human right.
What I don't want is to fund anything other than a safety net: Welfare should be a helping hand to get you back on your feet or to give you a start - Nothing more.
It should also come with an expiry date!
> What I don't want is to fund anything other than a safety net: Welfare should be a helping hand to get you back on your feet or to give you a start - Nothing more. It should also come with an expiry date!
These two statements completely contradict one another. There are plenty of people who aren't going back on their feed any time soon due to disability or mental health issues.
I believe in a kind of 2 tier system but I didn't get that across.
e.g. You lose you job and the welfare system keeps you going at your current burn rate (you will likely have to make some adjustments but you won't lose your house!) until you can get back on your feet. Let's say 12 months (pulled that figure out the air!)
After that, the basic welfare system comes into play where you will be given food, shelter, clothing, education etc.
That's the basic human right part I meant.
I am glossing over the details but at a high level you are kept afloat at your current level for a period, then you are given the basics for as long as you need them.
As for disability, that would be kind of basics+ (Not trying to make light of it but it's easiest to put it that way). I believe that it's every citizens duty to take care of people that just can't help themselves through disability. Their case be slightly different e.g. a house may need modifications, special transport etc.
Does that make sense?
(It's more complicated once you consider immigration and asylum, but hardly anyone not subject to that system understands it)
I'm in favour of bringing back the Education Maintenance Allowance, and making it very slightly performance-related.
However, I am not in favour of Government handouts. How much money did it cost to give me £80 back? £100? £150?
Would it not be better to reduce my tax so I pay £80 less each month?
Straight handouts appear to be by far the most effective way of reducing poverty and its negative effects. It's rather like the War On Drugs; you can choose a system that moralises at people or one that improves their outcomes, but if you want to improve outcomes you have to give up moralising control.
I don't see that happening to be honest but I do see something worse...
Won't the price of everything go up for those that don't currently need the welfare system? Is this a sort of stealth tax increase on the middle class?
I live in the UK and pay a lot into the system but I am by no means rich. I don't claim anything except child benefit (dunno how I qualify but I do... for £80 a month or something).
If you remove the need for someone currently on welfare to take a min-wage job then that means the job either doesn't get done or the salary for it must go up. So, if it goes up, then that company's price will go up or they face going out of business.
If they manage to stay in business, I will need to pay more to use their service than I did before but if they go out of business because I am not willing to pay it, they end up claiming welfare and my tax goes up to pay for it.
Honestly, I don't see an upside for anyone except those that can't/won't work!