Almost immediately after passage, the California Supreme Court sustained Proposition 13's constitutionality in the Amador case (Amador Valley Joint Union High School District v. State Board of Equalization. September 22, 1978). After a series of legal challenges in the 1980s, the issue of acquisition-value assessments reached the U.S. Supreme Court in Nordlinger v. Hahn. In a stunning 8-1 decision, the court in 1992 upheld California's acquisition-value system.
The court ruled that an acquisition-value system does not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution because it rationally furthers a legitimate state interest. The court said, "The state legitimately can conclude that a new owner, at the point of purchasing his property, does not have the same reliance interest warranting protection against higher taxes as does an existing owner who is already saddled with his purchase and does not have the option of deciding not to buy his home if taxes become prohibitively high."
The court also opined that a state has a rational interest in neighborhood preservation, continuity and stability, and that Proposition 13's system of "locking in" lower tax assessments contributed to such preservation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Protection_Clause
See tiered scrutiny.
It seems reasonable to me that laws or policies that favor people who have been residents of a town for a longer period of time could be used to preserve Sundown Towns. It's fairly easy to see how these policies would benefit those who seek de facto segregation.
Property taxes without caps are just as unfair but in the opposite direction. Why should someone who lives within their means and bought an affordable house be punished just because a bunch of other people swoop in and drive up prices around them. A buyer of a house needs to be able to forecast future tax payments to make an informed decision. If you don't have a yearly increase cap on property tax rates, the buyers future costs are totally unpredictable and up the whims of the markets and bubbles.
tiny violin songs, very sad
OK then, let's talk about reality. Letting incumbents under-utilize valuable real estate is a bad policy. Anyway nobody gets thrown out of their house for owing property taxes in California because the local authorities just put liens on the property. Once the old folks kick the bucket, the local govt collects on their lien from the heirs or buyers.
There are also several other non-old-people-getting-evicted problems with Prop 13 and its siblings. There certainly is not any excuse for the ability to pass your property tax assessment on to your children or grandchildren.
So while you're thinking of (and playing violins for) a certain sect that you know well here in the cosmopolitan city, there are also hundreds of thousands of "99 percenter" property owners throughout California that really do hurt as they scrape to make ends meet with the major (and usually only) asset they will ever own.
[1] http://articles.latimes.com/2009/jul/13/business/fi-hiltzik1...
[2] http://www.car.org/meetings/carmeetings/committee-materials-...
If the value of the property increases, there is incentive for owners to sell. If a developer wants to "utilize valuable real estate," is it not better that they make an offer and that people have choice in what happens to their property, rather forcing out "incumbents" with no choice due to escalating tax costs?
Buying a house with potentially wild inflation of tax costs is about as attractive as buying a house with a variable APR.
The one and only reason the US has 30 year fixed rate mortgages, with no prepayment penalty, available levered 5-10x, all at less than 100 bps over the risk free rate is because of massive government implicit and explicit subsidies.
Absent distortions it doesn't make sense for most people to buy a house -- it's inherently non-diversified, low liquidity, high transaction costs. But American society has for some bizarre reason decided that home ownership is the sine qua non of human civilization and so every level of government intervenes to distort the market in favor of homeownership.
Instead of recognizing this extraordinary intervention, and perhaps being grateful, homeowners tend to either: 1) refuse to recognize that such massive subsidies exist, or 2) see as entirely natural -- and bitch and moan if even the slightest modification is proposed.
It's yet another example of the American phenomenon of socialism for me but not for thee (and none dare call it welfare).
But it's more than that. The truth is, buying a home is the only form of investing on margin for most. Also, it's compulsory investment and savings -- both with the principal payment and in the form of property improvements.
Finally, of course, are the myriad tax benefits.
While it's true that we incentivize home ownership, possibly too much, I think it's unfair that you paint it as an otherwise neutral activity that we strangely endorse with public policy. Land has real value, you can live on (and off) it. It was long seen as the one enduring source of wealth (See John Adams, George Washington, etc). It's much deeper than our postwar tax policies.
I find it weird that people look at houses as "investments". For an asset to be an investment for me, it has to be productive. Buying stock in a company or starting your own is productive; buying farm land is productive (you can use it to produce food). A house in itself doesn't produce anything, it's just an asset. If you're relying on buying it cheap and selling it at a high price, that's speculation, not investment (that house still hasn't produced anything, it just happens to be more valued by other people).
1) Usefulness
2) Scarcity
Something useless and abundant has little value, something very useful and scarce has high value. A house is useful (it's a place to live, with varying personal usefulness based upon geographic location; a house 3 states away from my job is personally not very useful to me, for example) and scarce for any given geographic location.
The fact that copper is useful because you can build stuff out of it, while houses are useful because having a place to live is useful is irrelevant.
[edit] And the both the usefullness and scarcity of houses can change (just like with copper). Someone comes up with a cheaper way to mine copper? Price drops. A locality loosens their zoning laws? Price drops. Someone finds a new, valuable use for copper? Price rises. Big tech boom in the bay area? Price rises.
Anyway, I'm done with this discussion. Feel free to have the last word. It's clear to me that you've made-up your own definition of 'investment' and cannot see past that. Totally your right. But for the rest of us, here's what investment means:
investment noun : the outlay of money usually for income or profit : capital outlay; also : the sum invested or the property purchased
You can also customize and improve a home you own. Many people have housing needs that cannot be met in the rental market. With a home you own, you can make the modifications you need, and accept the impact to your home's value.
Sure, I agree with all of that. However, none of these qualify as economic investments IMHO, unless you decide to start a business out of your home.
Keep in mind I'm focusing strictly on investment in economic terms (production of goods or services). I agree that the house provides various benefits to its owners, just that none of them are economic returns.
I think your argument is thin here.
Speculation in equities is also not an investment in my book. I was referring to buying stock long-term for the dividends, not short-term speculation.
I think your argument is thin here, too.
I'd need to see a lot more justification before accepting that leveraged investments are a net positive either for individuals or for society. In general, leverage increases variability while reducing expected value in the form of interest payments. In other words it is analytically opposite of insurance.
I do agree that program or automatic savings are a positive "nudge" both for individuals and for society, but there's nothing but status quo bias that says that this asset class has to be the heavily favored vehicle for that.
While it's true that we incentivize home ownership, possibly too much, I think it's unfair that you paint it as an otherwise neutral activity that we strangely endorse with public policy. Land has real value, you can live on (and off) it. It was long seen as the one enduring source of wealth (See John Adams, George Washington, etc). It's much deeper than our postwar tax policies.
Prior to the industrial revolution land was the primary means of production. Today that's no longer true, and the vast vast majority of real property (by value not acre) is not used as an input factor for goods. The best translation of those classic references to the importance of land ownership today are modern means of production (e.g. ownership shares in productive businesses), not a quarter-acre of lawn in the suburbs.
Governments ought to be encouraging investment in positive sum productive enterprises, not zero sum positional goods. And at least as a default bias for non-wealthy citizens it ought to encourage holding diversified portfolios of assets with transparent liquid markets and low transaction costs.
It would also reward those who got there early without allowing them to block all progress since there is financial benefit for all.
The thing is? Leases are... very inflexible. In many ways, it's less flexible than buying. Here is the essential problem: If I have a rational, profit-maximizing landlord, every time my lease is up for renewal, he increases my rent to what it would cost me to rent an equivalent place elsewhere plus just under what it would cost me to move. On the other side of that, if I take a longer lease, I'm in a seriously bad position if something changes in my life and I need to move.
This is especially dramatic in commercial real-estate, where the business owner is usually asked to personally co-sign the lease, and where there are fewer laws requiring the landlord to reasonably try to rent vacant units to other people. (and where the tenant is more likely to be able to keep paying rent after moving.)
Three to five years of rent is nearly always more than 6% of the purchase price of the property.
Prop 13 counter-acts the incentive given by market appreciation of the value.
The value may go up according to the market, but the owner's taxes are capped.
This is an incentive to stay, as an owner would face higher taxes and thus higher costs if they simply moved to an identically-priced home.
http://www.boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/faqs/propositions60_90.htm#1
And as you point out, if you are under 55 then none of this applies.
So, the value according the market is not accurate. The value is actually higher. The problem isn't the laws. The problem is the market simply doesn't want to pay an appropriate amount for the person's property.
I'm not sure how a market value can be inaccurate, that implies that there is some objectively correct non-market value that you could meeasure the market value against, which is an odd idea.
What Prop 13's limit on assessment increases does is (in terms of the forces that drive market prices) is decrease supply (because it increases the value of homes to people who already own them, by decreasing the cost -- in property taxes -- paid compared to the utility derived from holding the property), which, considered on its own, increases market clearing price.
It may also increase demand (since it also decreases long-term expected costs for new buyers), but probably more weakly than it increases supply (since the decreased cost is already being realized by sellers -- and more strongly the longer they have held the whome -- wherease it will take several years for the decreased cost to be realized by a new buyer, since purchase events trigger assessment at full value.)
> The problem isn't the laws. The problem is the market simply doesn't want to pay an appropriate amount for the person's property.
The law adds non-transferrable value (or, less simply, provides a non-transferrable abatement of cost) as long as the owner holds the property. This creates an externally-imposed difference in the value to the owner and the value to other market participants.
Property tax caps are perfectly fine. As a homeowner, I will always vote down ANY increase in property tax.
Your mentality values economic optimization over human optimization, and it is one that I reject.
Who are you kidding? You get a lien on the house and then that is used to force a sale to cover the amount due. Hell even home owner associations do it all the time if you don't pay your monthly dues for several months.
Please don't address other users this way on Hacker News. Civility is important here.
The comment is otherwise substantive and would be a fine one if that bit were simply deleted.
I'm not enough of a lawyer to know exactly how that should be structured, but it's a great solution.
The lien we're talking about would be on the difference between the tax paid under Prop. 13 and the tax that would be due if there were no Prop. 13. If the mortgage is underwater, that difference is zero.
In other words, instead of the state foregoing that person's property tax adjustments, it should defer them until the time of sale, and at that point, recover them.
In other words a lien.
Also it's not like values are an eternally increasing step function. Suppose I bought in '95, saw my paper net worth rise thru the boom, then I need to sell at a depressed price in 2001. Without this lien waiting for me, I can take comfort knowing that I'm selling at a depressed price but also buying again at a depressed price. But when you take tens of thousands off the table to pay back taxes, my down payment has eroded significantly, increasing my borrowing cost.
Of course outside of California most people are used to periodic reassessment. It's just part of life. But I think tinkering w/ Prop13 in the ways you describe are possibly worse than just eliminating it and replacing it with an expanded homestead exemption of some kind.
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/avoid-capital-gains-t...
And the transfer tax doesn't hold a candle to the lost property tax revenues on, say, 30 years of ownership.
Indeed one of the huge stories around Prop 13 was an elderly woman with a paid-off house, about to be evicted because she couldn't pay the ridiculous uncapped property tax. She went to city hall with Howard Jarvis to ask for help and when turned away, had a heart attack and died right there in city hall.
http://www.hjta.org/propositions/proposition-13/proposition-...
Also, the anecdote comes from Howard Jarvis himself. Was he lying to further his agenda? This source casts doubt on his story: http://www.americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blog/happy-birthday... - from that source: "White notes that “even though the age of the deceased woman varied as Jarvis repeatedly told this story, the feelings it generated resonated with the public.”" Smells fishy to me...
- My land value has skyrocketed.
- Now I can't afford the property taxes and have to sell the land and retire several times over.
It's not that being priced out is a pure good; it's that it naturally comes with effects that very much soften the blow (at least for homeowners). It's not the sort of extreme personal catastrophe that social policy tries to mitigate in general.
It seems fair to me that the risk of the future variability of the cost of ownership of a property is assigned to the owner of the property.
I understand why you'd rather have someone else take on the risks, but newcomers are an unfair pick. How about an insurer or another financial counterparty? I'm sure it's possible to come up with some synthetic instrument which mimics the price movement of the property and can serve as a reliable hedge.
The reason we have higher property taxes is that school boards and the town/county government continually pass budgets that outpace inflation.
Because they are now wealthier, and can convert the wealth of that house into liquid assets (through sale, remortgage, etc), or income-generating assets (by becoming landlords). That's one of the points of property taxes: to encourage people to do productive things with their asset instead of just sitting on it.
An equally anecdotal counterpoint: "Why should a real estate speculator who bought a house twenty years ago not be forced to pay increasing amounts of property tax on it as they wait for its value to go up?"
Is this really HN I'm on here?
Anyway -- you've never heard of a home equity loan? If you really want to hang on to the property, take out a loan, pay the property taxes with part of it, and use the rest to make the payments. Zero cash flow impact. Or, sell a partial interest in the property to a speculator. There are solutions.
And as 'raldi points out, Prop. 13 could have been written so the accumulated difference between tax assessed and tax paid would have been collected at the time of sale. That would have addressed the owner's cash flow problem without requiring financing, without cheating localities of taxes they need to provide services -- not least, education -- and (getting back to the point of the article) without disincentivizing residential development vs. commercial.
Houses get some sort of special treatment, I guess because people emotionally bond with them. But in a free market we'd not scotch-tape all these special rules around them.
Still, people move for all sorts of selfish reasons, and take on all that burden anyway. The difference between the free market making you do it is an emotional one.
Should you be able to buy fuel for the same price it was when you bought the car?
If the local government is well run, then an individual's property taxes should approximate the cost of providing local government services to them, regardless of the value of their house. If real estate values in a local jurisdiction double without changing the government's costs, property tax rates should be cut in half to compensate. I realize that there's a big "if" when it comes to the "well run" part, but if that's not being done, then you need to fight over the "well run" part, not giving people massively different tax rates based purely on when they bought their house.
I don't think this idea is all that outlandish either. My understanding is that a lot of jurisdictions work this way, either explicitly or effectively through the legislative process. A budget is set, required revenue decided upon, and property tax rates set such that the required amount is obtained. If values go up, rates fall, and vice versa.
This doesn't solve the problem of hyper-local changes, like if just one section of a county becomes extremely popular and prices are driven through the roof, while the rest is unaffected. But again, what's the difference between being driven out due to that and having, say, the local food stores double their prices to to huge demand and drive you out that way?
Every time you see a dysfunctional market, look for the policy which creates an asymptotic condition. That asymptotic condition (or the sum of several asymptotic conditions) is the likely culprit behind the dysfunction.
By asymptotic condition I mean and hard cap or limit that is unchanging based on circumstance (such as time). The reason asymptotic conditions are so toxic is because they become barriers to natural market corrections.
An interesting thought experiment is imagining a policy that allows the eviction of those with rent-control in favor of those who can demonstrate more financial need. I'm trying to imagine how to form this so I can propose it to San Franciscans with rent control when they express ire about techies and the Ellis Act. I'm extremely curious how they will react/respond when they are asked to explicitly acknowledge their position of privilege relative to someone less well off.
Unrelated: Ultimately what we need is the startup equivalent of cities, where people abandon the status quo in established cities and seek out new civic models. Given the right location, I would consider being a founding citizen in a "startup city".
Then there are the transaction and opportunity costs associated with buying...locking up a down payment, closing costs, broker costs. I'm sure I'll buy in the future when I'm at a different point lifewise, but for now renting works just fine.
(This is not a rhetorical question.)
And the "externality" in restricting that land to your private use is captured by the housing market. If you're sitting on a plot of land worth a million dollars, it means you value that land at more than a million dollars, because otherwise you would sell it. Sitting on it is costing you access to a million dollars. Living there is costing you the money you could get by renting it out.
Education on the other hand I expect to remain fairly constant on a per unit (child) basis once a school hits 150 children per grade.
That almost never happens. OTOH, in California, if a home doubles in value in 5 years and doesn't change ownership or have new construction, the assessed value for property tax purposes at the end of that 5 year increase would only be 1.1× the starting tax basis, since Prop 13 limits assessed value to increase at most 2% per year.
If your argument is that the property tax rate on a million dollar home will be lowered until the absolute number of tax dollars paid is the same as that paid on a $250K home, the evidence is to the contrary. Municipalities that see an increase in tax revenues at the same rate more often see it as an excuse to expand the budget than an excuse to lower tax rates, especially in California.
Take a look at local city budgets. When housing prices doubled, the cities tax revenues didn't. They certainly went up overall (I mean, when has a gov't ever not expanded?), but my argument is that often 2house price =/= 2property taxes.
That's an effective cut in the overall property tax rate, but its not a city "adjusting" the rate down to meet the desired budget, its the nominal rate remaining fixed (because that's also capped by Prop 13), and the tax basis value on most properties whose value has increased not reflecting the value increase.
Here in London there are whole apartment blocks owned solely by investors with no-one living in them. That's morally repugnant, a deadweight loss, whatever sophist arguments you can come up with for why really the right thing. Property taxes are a nudge in the right direction.
The charge for council tax is set at the 'band C' level, and scaled up/down for bands A-H. (A being the lowest property value.)
Additionally we have 'stamp duty', which is paid when you sell the house, as a percentage of the sale price above a threshold, and if you've lived in the property for less than three years you're also liable for capital gains tax on the sale.
This isn't an ideal system - but it does present an alternative to what's being discussed here. I imagine that a quick trip through Wikipedia would show other alternatives in use throughout Europe.
Basicallly there is no real way to not be a beholden slave to the monetary system and debt.
Yes, if you're buying a house in the US you are typically going to take on some debt.
No, because that's not true (federal property taxes would probably be problematic under the Constitution, which restricts non-apportioned federal taxes, but property taxes aren't federal.)
(which makes "wealth" taxes problematic or impractical)
If you want the services the city provides, you have to pay for them. They are paid from property taxes. As those raise, so does the rent - after all, you live in the city, so you consume those services, so why don't you have to pay for them? That's your return - getting city services. If you don't like taxes being linked to property value - enact fixed taxes, but then you'd have to rein in city budget costs, including salaries, pensions, benefits, entitlements, etc. Somebody has to pay for all that. If not people living in the city, then who? If you want to stop paying for it, then you need to either stop consuming them, or find some other way to pay - what that would be?
I have been renting for last five years, and I see nothing bad in renting. Though my opinion might be irrelevent to the subject, as I do not live in SF and there is no "frozen property taxes" law in UK.
In 30-year mortgages you are realistically paying more than half your monthly payment as interest, and doing that with pre-tax money means you're conservatively looking at 15% total reduction in monthly payments compared to renting.
You are right that the US has two things to advantage owning: (1) mortgage interest tax deduction and (2) 30-year mortgage terms.
If you're lucky enough to lock in a mortgage rate of ~3%, when you add in the mortgage interest tax deduction, you're practically paying nothing for the money you are borrowing.
However, all it takes is a 10%+ drop in the market when you are selling to wipe out any advantage to owning and often you'll come out behind of someone who rents.
It's a write-off for someone who's making enough money to find it worthwhile to itemize but not enough to pay AMT.
Wealthy families also have access to higher-quality asset-backed loans which typically come with lower interest rates.
Anything over $250k puts you in the top 2% of U.S. households. Your definition of words like "trivial" and "wealthy" might be different from mine.
The rub usually comes when you are older and your earning ability deteriorates. Those who own their house get a significant drop in monthly housing costs while those who are still renting to not. Some people plan well for this, others don't.
When you buy a house, you can't just move even if you need to do it. It is a lot more difficult. That's where I see the 2-3 hour daily commutes, which I feel is insane.
> You also pay money but never see any permanent return, as it doesn't matter how long you've been paying, you can never stop
Yes but at the same time, your capital isn't trapped in the place that you're living in. You also have to pay for yearly maintenance in both time and money (I personally hate this part the most). When you don't own a home, you can more easily do things like investing or using it to start something up.
It probably varies by person, but I don't see that the same. If i was paying $2400/mo in rent, then i bought a house for $2400/mo mortgage, the capital in the house is not part of the capital i would have if i had been renting. That would just be gone.
If rent was $2400/m, I can assure you that a house in the same area would be a lot more than $2400/m unless you put %50 or more as a down payment which is at least a few hundred thousand if not a million dollars. That's a lot of capital. If you choose a house in a cheaper area with a mortgage of $2400/m, then I can guarantee that there will be cheaper apartments in the area as well.
> the capital in the house is not part of the capital i would have if i had been renting. That would just be gone.
I'm not sure I understand what you're saying? Are we in agreement or are you disagreeing?
i will have to find a cheaper area to be able to buy a house(or condo more likely).
> I'm not sure I understand what you're saying? Are we in agreement or are you disagreeing?
Rent: pay $2400/mo for 30 years. Spent: $864k. Capital: $0
Buy: pay $2400/mo for 30 years. Spent: $864k. Capital: Whatever the house is worth. Hopefully around the 3-400k the loan was for, but half would still be better than the rent scenario
Together that doesn't sum it up, sure in that cheaper neighborhood maybe a rental would be $600 a month cheaper, $216k over those 30 years and more with compound interest. But rent doesn't stay the same like a mortgage does (baring intervention). An apartment that went for $1800 a decade ago (locally) goes for well over $2400 now.
1. As you've already mentioned, if you were to stay in the same area rent would be cheaper than a mortgage. Rent is always cheaper than a mortgage for equivalent real estate in the same area. So even if you moved, there would still be really strong reasons for renting since it would still be cheaper than buying a place. So your argument of $2400 rent vs $2400 mortgage is just wrong since moving to a different area will result in $1200 rent (or less).
2. Unlike a mortgage, you're not going to be spending anywhere close to $864k upfront. At most it's only going to be $7200 up front. If you were going to buy a place in the same neighborhood, it's probably going to be about $400,000 upfront, not including closing costs and other fees. Not including stuff like renovation or housing insurance either. Don't forget HOA for certain areas as well.
So if you have 500k in cash, if you rented you've about $492,800 for investing or for starting something up. If you bought a place in the same area, you have nothing for investing or starting something. So this "$0k vs Whatever the house is worth" argument is really flawed, especially when you consider that your capital is "stuck" with a huge opportunity cost unless 1) it appreciates a lot and you're willing to BOTH sell and move into a cheaper place that isn't as nice in terms of location or features (if you're not you're just stuck living in a nice expensive place which isn't a bad thing but remember opportunity cost), or 2) you're a professional house flipper (your home really is an investment and not just a place to live), and you repeat this process every 1-4 years.
If you haven't already guessed, I'm not a renter and I just figured that you want something more than normal people since you roam HN.
FHA loans start at 2.5% down, and $2400/mo puts the total loan amount somewhere around $350k. So bare minimum would be 2.5% down and 2.5% closing for $18k to get in the door. I'm shooting for more like $30k-$35k, but $18k is the minimum.
18k minus 7k leaves 11k that could have instead been invested. To me the value of keeping a portion of my rent as capital(even tied up and with risks of loss) combined with certainty about what my monthly cost will be 10 or 20 years down the line is worth a lot more than that $11k in the bank today.
1. It's very hard to get approved on less than %10 down post 2008, unless you're taking out a jumbo loan which is above $450k, and this is assuming you can meet all the new strict standards with income (based on what's reported to the IRS AFTER deductions) and credit history. How do I know this stuff? I bought my house after 2008, and so did a lot of my friends. On the off chance it gets approved, you'll be paying something called PMI which adds about %15 to your monthly payment. So $2400 turns into about $2760.
2. As I've already mentioned, if your mortgage is $2400 I can almost guarantee that there's an apartment in the same area where the rent is approximately $1200.
3. Using your example, putting a $3600 deposit for a rental is very different from $35,000 down which doesn't include any closing costs or house insurance. If you're in the Bay Area you also have to account for monthly HOA which is about $300-$500 and it can increase at anytime. So your $2400 / mo now turns into approx $3200 / month with PMI. With housing insurance, that baloons to about $3350
4. The type of home $350k buys in the Bay Area is most likely not going to appreciate beyond inflation, unless you buy something that isn't gentrified yet which incurs other types of risk.
I'm not saying its easy, but I think its possible. I'm perhaps being overly optimistic on down payments, the only person i know that bought a house recently did it in TX with 10%
If you rent and retire you can go wherever rent is cheaper. Problem solved
I wonder if both rent-control and prop-tax-caps could be knocked down in an equal-protection lawsuit. Why does the person who moved in yesterday, perhaps far needier than the longer-term resident/owner (and just as deserving of basic civic services) have to pay so much more? Is duration-of-residence a legitimate basis for such strong civic discrimination rooted in law?