If you can afford to retire several times over, it would by definition have to involve living in a less expensive place (otherwise you'd have the same tax issue). Being forced to downgrade housing quality and/or location is not an obvious win.
Oh, definitely. But when it comes to "problems we should all have to bear a burden to prevent" -- the target of public policy -- it just doesn't seem like that particular problem should be very high on the list.
It's not that being priced out is a pure good; it's that it naturally comes with effects that very much soften the blow (at least for homeowners). It's not the sort of extreme personal catastrophe that social policy tries to mitigate in general.
Don't forget how things used to be -- a single earner working at a factory could buy a house comfortably. Those were the folks impacted.
I mostly agree, however I find moving house is a complete PITA, and I'm fairly young. For someone in their later years, the stress, their physical limitations etc make it very difficult. I don't think its possible to over estimate the difficulty an elderly person could face when forced to move.
- My land value has skyrocketed.
- Now I can't afford the property taxes and have to sell the land and retire several times over.