(This is not a rhetorical question.)
And the "externality" in restricting that land to your private use is captured by the housing market. If you're sitting on a plot of land worth a million dollars, it means you value that land at more than a million dollars, because otherwise you would sell it. Sitting on it is costing you access to a million dollars. Living there is costing you the money you could get by renting it out.
Education on the other hand I expect to remain fairly constant on a per unit (child) basis once a school hits 150 children per grade.
That almost never happens. OTOH, in California, if a home doubles in value in 5 years and doesn't change ownership or have new construction, the assessed value for property tax purposes at the end of that 5 year increase would only be 1.1× the starting tax basis, since Prop 13 limits assessed value to increase at most 2% per year.
If your argument is that the property tax rate on a million dollar home will be lowered until the absolute number of tax dollars paid is the same as that paid on a $250K home, the evidence is to the contrary. Municipalities that see an increase in tax revenues at the same rate more often see it as an excuse to expand the budget than an excuse to lower tax rates, especially in California.
Take a look at local city budgets. When housing prices doubled, the cities tax revenues didn't. They certainly went up overall (I mean, when has a gov't ever not expanded?), but my argument is that often 2house price =/= 2property taxes.
That's an effective cut in the overall property tax rate, but its not a city "adjusting" the rate down to meet the desired budget, its the nominal rate remaining fixed (because that's also capped by Prop 13), and the tax basis value on most properties whose value has increased not reflecting the value increase.
Here in London there are whole apartment blocks owned solely by investors with no-one living in them. That's morally repugnant, a deadweight loss, whatever sophist arguments you can come up with for why really the right thing. Property taxes are a nudge in the right direction.
The charge for council tax is set at the 'band C' level, and scaled up/down for bands A-H. (A being the lowest property value.)
Additionally we have 'stamp duty', which is paid when you sell the house, as a percentage of the sale price above a threshold, and if you've lived in the property for less than three years you're also liable for capital gains tax on the sale.
This isn't an ideal system - but it does present an alternative to what's being discussed here. I imagine that a quick trip through Wikipedia would show other alternatives in use throughout Europe.
Basicallly there is no real way to not be a beholden slave to the monetary system and debt.
Yes, if you're buying a house in the US you are typically going to take on some debt.
No, because that's not true (federal property taxes would probably be problematic under the Constitution, which restricts non-apportioned federal taxes, but property taxes aren't federal.)
(which makes "wealth" taxes problematic or impractical)