1) Usefulness
2) Scarcity
Something useless and abundant has little value, something very useful and scarce has high value. A house is useful (it's a place to live, with varying personal usefulness based upon geographic location; a house 3 states away from my job is personally not very useful to me, for example) and scarce for any given geographic location.
The fact that copper is useful because you can build stuff out of it, while houses are useful because having a place to live is useful is irrelevant.
[edit] And the both the usefullness and scarcity of houses can change (just like with copper). Someone comes up with a cheaper way to mine copper? Price drops. A locality loosens their zoning laws? Price drops. Someone finds a new, valuable use for copper? Price rises. Big tech boom in the bay area? Price rises.
Anyway, I'm done with this discussion. Feel free to have the last word. It's clear to me that you've made-up your own definition of 'investment' and cannot see past that. Totally your right. But for the rest of us, here's what investment means:
investment noun : the outlay of money usually for income or profit : capital outlay; also : the sum invested or the property purchased
You can also customize and improve a home you own. Many people have housing needs that cannot be met in the rental market. With a home you own, you can make the modifications you need, and accept the impact to your home's value.
Sure, I agree with all of that. However, none of these qualify as economic investments IMHO, unless you decide to start a business out of your home.
Keep in mind I'm focusing strictly on investment in economic terms (production of goods or services). I agree that the house provides various benefits to its owners, just that none of them are economic returns.
I think your argument is thin here.
Speculation in equities is also not an investment in my book. I was referring to buying stock long-term for the dividends, not short-term speculation.
I think your argument is thin here, too.
I find it weird that people look at houses as "investments". For an asset to be an investment for me, it has to be productive. Buying stock in a company or starting your own is productive; buying farm land is productive (you can use it to produce food). A house in itself doesn't produce anything, it's just an asset. If you're relying on buying it cheap and selling it at a high price, that's speculation, not investment (that house still hasn't produced anything, it just happens to be more valued by other people).