Re:SF’s Housing Crisis Explained
by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:55AM
(#7591795)
Even in the absence of property taxes, utility and maintenance costs (and changing market rates for required labor and materials that drive those) would pose the same risk. Property taxes are hardly the only required expenses that might go up when owning a house (and, in CA, have strict constitutional limits on increases, unlike most other necessary expenses.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Isn't the issue with property taxes that weath taxes are not legal under the constitution. The government is not allowed to just tax (ie, take) your assets. Income and Real estate are just imperfect proxies "wealth".
Re:SF’s Housing Crisis Explained
by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @11:27AM
(#7592287)
> Isn't the issue with property taxes that weath taxes are not legal under the constitution.
No, because that's not true (federal property taxes would probably be problematic under the Constitution, which restricts non-apportioned federal taxes, but property taxes aren't federal.)
Property taxes are used (primarily) because states & localities don't have clean jurisdiction or nexus on a household's financial assets.
(which makes "wealth" taxes problematic or impractical)