News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by majika on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:08PM (#6870249)
This is a remarkably sensible speech.

The idea that the market will solve such things as environmental concerns, as our racial divides, as our class distinctions, our problems with educating and incorporating one generation of workers into the economy after the other when that economy is changing; the idea that the market is going to heed all of the human concerns and still maximise profit is juvenile. It's a juvenile notion and it's still being argued in my country passionately and we're going down the tubes. And it terrifies me because I'm astonished at how comfortable we are in absolving ourselves of what is basically a moral choice. Are we all in this together or are we all not?

I see a lot of libertarian and anti-government sentiments expressed on HN. People like to construct arguments like "more government vs. less", "higher taxes vs. lower", "less regulation vs. more", but those debates are missing the forest for the trees. The question - and only question - should be what David Simon asks: are we all in this together or are we not?

To me, the answer is blindingly obvious. It's demonstrated by what societies are flourishing - with high economic and social equality, healthy democratic government, protected personal liberties, well-cared-for populaces, and resilient economies - and what societies aren't.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by avar on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:44PM (#6870405)
The libertarian and anti-government sentiments aren't saying that we shouldn't be all in this together, but that we shouldn't be forced to be all in this together. That difference is what the entire argument is about.

Few people are saying saying "let's not do this" for some value of "this", they're saying "let's not force everyone to do this".

That's a very profound difference, it's why having the government make anything its business anywhere in the world is always controversial.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by scarmig on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:58PM (#6870459)
That argument is tiresome.

Many libertarians want to enforce a very particular and ahistorical version of property rights, one dictated from above and with a studied blindness for the reason we've invented the group of rights we think of as property. They want to subject everyone to a society where state violence is used for and only on behalf of people who in the past were granted monopoly access to some material good.

Force seeps through everything we do in a society, because it's a good like any other. Many libertarians demand everyone be forced into a machine of their own invention. And that's not any more damning of them than of anyone else, but they should own it. They're not hoping for a world where people aren't forced into things, but a world where people are forced into their own narrow vision of what's moral and righteous.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by vidarh on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:47PM (#6870752)
I used to freak right wing libertarians out by following this like of thought with them when I was politically active. I had one in tears during a break in a debate because I was there representing a Marxist party, yet I agreed with him about most issues. He could not understand why, and he saw it as destroying his credibility.

I pointed out that to me, as a marxist (some would argue the term libertarian socialist, or left communist would be more descriptive), his arguments for individual freedom was the right starting point for evaluating most policy, but the only logical conclusion is to limit government recognition of property rights too, as a large portion of the laws to protect private property takes away more rights from the public at large than what it offers to the public as owners:

I may gain exclusive rights to a small area, but I lose access and even limited rights to most of the world.

And In fact most countries do recognize that property rights must be limited to various extents to safeguard the rights of the population as a whole, through things like guarantees of access to land areas held in common (or owned by the government) that will not be sold, or legal protections for access to beaches or wilderness that often extends to granting legally protected public access to privately owned land.

The question is not whether or not property rights must be limited, but where to draw the balance. Yet somehow right wing libertarians tends to want to want to tighten property rights, while at the same time they argue for reducing government intervention in pretty much everything else. The inconsistency is glaring to me.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by avar on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:05PM (#6870502)
What I'm pointing out really has nothing to do with libertarianism, for what it's worth it's not a political position that I personally adhere to.

I'm pointing out that whatever your political leaning you don't "just" get the government involved. Even if you think you should have a larger government than you have now the question is what kind of larger government, and once you make the wrong choice there's a huge inertia in the system that makes correcting that choice very hard.

So even people that agree that government should do more aren't easily brought on the bandwagon of the something the government wants to do being the right version of that "more".

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by scarmig on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:18PM (#6870578)
My point is this: the concept of a larger government is very murky, so we should be very careful when we're talking about it. The stereotypical libertarian will propose universal, strict enforcement of violence used to protect people to whom the State has granted monopoly access to material goods. I don't recognize that as a smaller State than someone who proposes that except annually taking some proportion of it and redistributing it.

One state may be better than the other, but it's still all pile of violence, configured in a different way.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:47PM (#6870746)
>> My point is this: the concept of a larger government is very murky, so we should be very careful when we're talking about it.

The US government is pretty fucking large right now, is it not? In fact, it's an Empire, and serves as a great warning example of what a minimal government can/will become.

>> One state may be better than the other, but it's still all pile of violence, configured in a different way.

Exactly. So how about no State then? They say that the difference between a Minarchist and an Anarchist is "about six months". The period of time in between is irrelevant. The point is that a lot of Libertarians end up going all the way once they start seeing reality for what it is.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:10PM (#6870533)
> Even if you think you should have a larger government than you have now the question is what kind of larger government, and once you make the wrong choice there's a huge inertia in the system that makes correcting that choice very hard.

To quote Theodore Roosevelt,

> The citizen must have high ideals, and yet he must be able to achieve them in practical fashion. No permanent good comes from aspirations so lofty that they have grown fantastic and have become impossible and indeed undesirable to realize. The impractical visionary is far less often the guide and precursor than he is the embittered foe of the real reformer, of the man who, with stumblings and shortcoming, yet does in some shape, in practical fashion, give effect to the hopes and desires of those who strive for better things. Woe to the empty phrase-maker, to the empty idealist, who, instead of making ready the ground for the man of action, turns against him when he appears and hampers him when he does work! Moreover, the preacher of ideals must remember how sorry and contemptible is the figure which he will cut, how great the damage that he will do, if he does not himself, in his own life, strive measurably to realize the ideals that he preaches for others. Let him remember also that the worth of the ideal must be largely determined by the success with which it can in practice be realized. We should abhor the so-called "practical" men whose practicality assumes the shape of that peculiar baseness which finds its expression in disbelief in morality and decency, in disregard of high standards of living and conduct. Such a creature is the worst enemy of the body of politic. But only less desirable as a citizen is his nominal opponent and real ally, the man of fantastic vision who makes the impossible better forever the enemy of the possible good.

tldr: don't make perfect the enemy of good. This comes several paragraphs after the famous "Man in the Arena" bit.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by nickff on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:06PM (#6870508)
One might say that socialists want to enforce an oft repeated history of slavery and theft.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:23PM (#6870613)
... if one was trying to grandstand and spout meaningless platitudes.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by trekky1700 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:38PM (#6870692)
Or one could stop looking to the extreme as an inevitability in either case.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by modfodder on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:26PM (#6870957)
One might say the conservatives are doing the same (in the name of capitalism).
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:05PM (#6870501)
> Few people are saying saying "let's not do this" for some value of "this", they're saying "let's not force everyone to do this".

And while this makes sense from a naive perspective, it always rapidly breaks down in reality. That's why Simon, and others, call it juvenile. The complexity isn't hard to see: just use one level of meta.

Given an action or policy or whatever S, have the policy S' of "Do not force everyone to do S". Now take S' as the policy S, and have the new policy S'' of "Do not force everyone to not force everyone to do S."

This isn't contrived. The paradox of tolerance has been a major problem in liberal philosophy for a long, long time. The simplistic notion of "Don't force them" just refuses to engage with any kind of depth, and in doing so, perverts and defeats itself.

This is also assuming that the relevant species of libertarianism under discussion isn't purely economic fundamentalism; that is, it has actual concerns for social libertarianism rather than vapid one-off claims that permit oppression by failing to oppose it.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

[2] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/toleration/

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:56PM (#6870799)
>> The paradox of tolerance has been a major problem in liberal philosophy for a long, long time. The simplistic notion of "Don't force them" just refuses to engage with any kind of depth, and in doing so, perverts and defeats itself.

Nope, the idea of not forcing anyone to do anything is rooted in the Non-Aggression Principle, which stipulates that any initiation of force (violence/coercion) is forbidden. The flipside of this is that everything should be voluntary.

It makes sense if you allow yourself to think about it for a moment. Never mind "but self-defense is violence too!!" - that is clearly seen for the distraction it is, when you draw the line at initiating violence. The aggressor is always in the wrong.

This fits together perfectly with The Golden Rule too: don't do anything to others that you wouldn't want done to yourself.

In reality, there are no "victimless crimes". Whenever someone gets thrown into jail for being in possession of a certain plant, there is no victim, and no crime. Laws represent coercion one way or another. It's either: 1) don't do this or you will be punished, or 2) do this or you will be punished.

Now, when people get punished for attempting to keep their property, something is very wrong. Who's the victim of you trying to keep your property? -No one. OK then, who's the victim in taxation.. ? -Why it's you, of course.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:13PM (#6870877)
The NAP is pretty useless, because it doesn't define what 'force' or 'initiation' means. People have very significant disagreements about these definitions.

Furthermore, it only makes sense in an alternate reality where we're re-set to zero. The NAP doesn't really provide a means from getting from where we are today to a world 'without force,' as if that was even possible.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:18PM (#6870905)
>> The NAP is pretty useless, because it doesn't define what 'force' or 'initiation' means.

Do you also need a definition for, say "rape", "kill", "steal", "rob"? What does it mean to "force someone to do something"? Have you got an inkling, perhaps?

>> The NAP doesn't really provide a means from getting from where we are today to a world 'without force,' as if that was even possible.

Why would it need to? It's not a system of social organization, it's a principle. But if everyone adhered to it, the world would be a lovely place. Sure, not everyone does. But even their choices and actions have consequences, and that's not about to change either way.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:25PM (#6870950)
I specifically mean that libertarians don't view property rights as forceful, but the left does.

> But if everyone adhered to it, the world would be a lovely place.

If it's not a possibility that can happen in the actual world, then the statement is basically meaningless.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:42PM (#6871026)
>> I specifically mean that libertarians don't view property rights as forceful, but the left does.

I don't know what kind of libertarianism you're referring to, exactly. But property is based on property rights, is it not? It makes no sense to think that you have no rights in the absence of a government. Think about it. If there's no government, would you not have the right to defend yourself or your property against an aggressor? -Of course you would. Governments have nothing to do with that.

>> If it's not a possibility that can happen in the actual world, then the statement is basically meaningless

The statement means what it means, even if only as a sentence.

But look, I already acknowledged that not everyone adheres to the NAP. That can't be helped now, and it probably can't be helped ever. But the number of people who aggress against others can sure be reduced through peaceful, sensible, consistent parenting, for example.

The fact that not every single goddamn human being out there is good is not a reason to dismiss libertarian/free-market/anarchist ideas. You'll have to do way better than that, but ultimately, you'll find that reason, logic, and evidence should / can not be dismissed at all.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:10PM (#6871666)
>> If there's no government, would you not have the right to defend yourself or your property against an aggressor?

You're claiming a piece of land as your own but I don't see how you have any more right to it than any other human born on this earth. You initiate force to remove me from what you see as your land. Who's the aggressor? Where does your right to land derive from?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:21PM (#6871709)
Generally, improvements and occupation make it your home. Somebody coming in to take land containing a house you built, a barn you raised, cattle you bred on a crop you are growing, are taking what's yours.

Take this away and nobody would use land at all. Been done in history again and again; result always the same : collapse of farming, which means collapse of the govt.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:37PM (#6871787)
>> Generally, improvements and occupation make it your home. Somebody coming in to take land containing a house you built, a barn you raised, cattle you bred on a crop you are growing, are taking what's yours.

So nobody should be able to own land they aren't using for anything and I should be able to just go and occupy it? Cool.

>> Take this away and nobody would use land at all. Been done in history again and again; result always the same : collapse of farming, which means collapse of the govt.

And now we've moved onto a pragmatic rather than moral absolutist argument, which I agree with entirely.

Now that we're in this territory, let's talk about a bunch of other human-friendly pragmatic moves we could make as a society that might improve everyone's lives, eh?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 09, 2013 @08:59AM (#6874294)
You are actually right. Unused land you occupy can eventually be yours, to some degree. Its called 'squatting' and while it has issues it can correct some imbalances.

I agree moral absolutism is tricky. But think of it as first principles. You have to argue from something or its all situational ethics, which depend entirely upon your point of view.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:27PM (#6876226)
Deriving from a first principle that's so broken and so subjective seems to me basically pointless. Moral absolutism is only useful if you have an absolute. We don't have one, not one we share anyway (him and me, no idea on your views really), so berating me for not joining in when you start deriving from it seems a bit off. It's one of the things about objectivism that really gets me -

"we're the only philosophy based on objective reality!" "But these things are highly subjective?!" "Shut up you sociopath/leech/parasite!"

The squatting thing is interesting, most people hate it instinctively but I'm unsure where I stand.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @03:20AM (#6873342)
>> So nobody should be able to own land they aren't using for anything and I should be able to just go and occupy it? Cool.

Why would the same rule not apply to you? In other words, you can't just "occupy" land, you'll have to use it, just like everyone else.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:21AM (#6873498)
>> Why would the same rule not apply to you? In other words, you can't just "occupy" land, you'll have to use it, just like everyone else.

Who's saying I wouldn't use it? It's pretty radical for a hard-property-rights libertarian to concede I could just go up and take someone's land if I judge it's not in proper use!

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:49PM (#6871057)
I mean all those that subscribe to the NAP: minarchists, 'right libertarians,' voluntaryists, and 'anarcho-capitalists.'

> Think about it.

I have thought about it, and so have many others. This argument is pretty old and tired, and goes way beyond this thread. There have been many criticisms of the NAP by anarchists. The actual, original strain of anarchists: 'left anarchism.'

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:58PM (#6871097)
>> I mean all those that subscribe to the NAP: minarchists, 'right libertarians,' voluntaryists, and 'anarcho-capitalists.'

What exactly is your claim about them, then? I should stop guessing at ideas to refute and let you make a claim first.

>> This argument is pretty old and tired, and goes way beyond this thread.

Which argument? "Think about it" doesn't constitute one, so it seems you wanted to quote something other than what you were supposedly addressing. That's kind of weird.

>> There have been many criticisms of the NAP by anarchists. The actual, original strain of anarchists: 'left anarchism.'

Sure. It's certainly possible to complicate things to no end. But is it worthwhile? Moral rules are not absolutes, but that's alright. The point is to get close enough, and there are often several sensible ways to view ideas, such as "property" for example.

But bickering about the exact definitions of words your opponent happens to use is just a bullshit distraction, intentional or not. I've wasted way too much time on that road already. We both use and understand the English language just fine. There are no obstacles to our communication besides the ones intentionally put up.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:03PM (#6871117)
I did make a claim. The claim is that without specifically defining force and initiation, the NAP is useless. You re-asserted a particular definition, and said 'think about it.' I don't find that to be particularly convincing.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:06PM (#6871138)
>> The claim is that without specifically defining force and initiation, the NAP is useless

And I pointed out that you don't really need any specific definitions for "force" or "initiation" (and that bickering about the definitions for everyday words is a bullshit distraction).

But suppose "force" meant "violence or coercion", and "to initiate" meant "to start" (there's no real confusion about that, at least). With these definitions, what's your problem with the NAP?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:28PM (#6871243)
> With these definitions, what's your problem with the NAP?

Those aren't definitions.

Is it force for someone to own a gun? Is it force for someone to reveal that they're carrying a gun? Is it force for someone to draw a gun? Is it force for someone to fire a warning shot? Is it force for someone to point a gun?

Is it initiation for someone to attack a third party? Is it initiation for someone to attack a friend?

Is it force to covet your property? Is it force to touch your property? Is it force to enter your property? Is it force to illegitimately acquire your property? Is it force to manipulate your property? Is it force to develop your property's uses?

Is it initiation for someone to threaten you? Is it initiation for someone to threaten you abstractly? Is it initiation for someone to threaten your property? Is it initiation for someone to threaten your friends?

That's off the top of my head. Gimme a bit, and I'll "think about it".

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:35PM (#6871276)
As I mentioned already, it's certainly possible to complicate things to no end. But what exactly do you think you've accomplished with this message, besides prompting me to refute bullshit distractions?

>> Is it force for someone to own a gun?

Is it force for you to own shoes?

>> Is it force for someone to reveal that they're carrying a gun?

Is it force for someone to reveal they're not wearing a bra? No, it's not. Coercion requires an intent, a choice, and an action. Why are you flashing a gun? -Has someone just threatened to attack you? -Or have you just demanded money from someone?

>> Is it force for someone to draw a gun? Is it force for someone to fire a warning shot? Is it force for someone to point a gun?

Intent, intent, intent, etc.

>> Is it initiation for someone to attack a third party? Is it initiation for someone to attack a friend? Is it initiation for someone to attack you?

Of course. The one who attacks, ie. initiates, is the aggressor.

>> Is it force to covet your property?

Is it force to covet a woman?

>> Is it force to touch your property?

Is it force to touch a person?

>> Is it force to enter your property?

Is it force to enter Wal-Mart?

>> Is it force to illegitimately acquire your property?

I don't think so. But it depends on stuff.

>> Is it force to manipulate your property?

Is it force to open a door?

>> Is it force to develop your property's uses?

What do you even mean? .. Oh, but don't actually answer that. I have a feeling we're not about to get anywhere in this discussion.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:10PM (#6871431)
> it's certainly possible to complicate things to no end

You're missing the fact that I'm accepting the NAP for the purposes of this discussion. The question isn't whether or not the NAP is valid; it's what the fuck I actually do in real life.

> But what exactly do you think you've accomplished with this message, besides prompting me to refute bullshit distractions?

I offered you a chance to define your terms. A definition is a boundary in meaning where, inside, the term is applied, and outside, the term is not applied. By asking these questions, you learn what the definition is.

You can do a similar series of questions for defining, say, a banana. You might do that by pointing to a series of objects and asking, "Is this a banana?" That's all I'm doing: I'm pointing at a series of situations and asking, "Is this force? Is this initiation?"

> Coercion requires an intent, a choice, and an action.

Like this. This is important. Nothing in the Non-Aggression Principle points this out.

Which categories of intents, choices, and actions may be combined to constitute coercion, which constitutes force? As our understanding of neuroscience develops, how might we gain nuance into understanding what constitutes coercion?

I know the complexity of reality is scary, but unfortunately, I am doomed to live in reality, which is sorta complex and infinitely various.

> Questions related to property and force.

Yeah, I clearly failed to frame the latter three sets as well as I did the first.

This is a question about the definition of violence. For instance, let's say you're carrying a glass sculpture that you like. While arguing with you, I knock it from your hand and it shatters. That obviously constitutes initiation, but does that constitute force? I didn't hurt you, nor did I coerce you, but that nevertheless seems like aggression.

With questions like "If you own" or "If you covet", my intent was to give you a clear place where you could have a fairly simple "no", but still actually have room to say "yes" if that's what you believed.

>> Is it force to develop your property's uses?

> What do you even mean?

This is a reference to Locke's definition of property. If someone cultivates the land and produces value from it, then they own it. If you gain ownership, and then someone else cultivates and produces value, is that force?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:10PM (#6871663)
>> The question isn't whether or not the NAP is valid; it's what the fuck I actually do in real life.

What a particular person does in real life has no bearing on whether a particular moral principle is a good idea. You may be a sociopath who doesn't give a fuck about the NAP, or you may be a gentle person who wouldn't hurt anyone. That's beside the point.

The NAP is a reasonably well defined moral principle. You either think it's a good idea, or you don't. If not, perhaps you'll suggest a better one. Either way, these are just ideas, and then, as you pointed out, there's the real world.

But so what? In fact, the vast majority of people already automatically adhere to the NAP, without ever having even come across the idea. What you're doing here, is preventing the conversation from progressing, preventing us (or yourself) from getting anywhere with this. I've expended months of effort in debating with a couple of staunch Statists, and their favourite bullshit distraction is complicating everything.

See, there really are countless different "lifeboat scenarios" or edge cases you could keep coming up with and bringing up, but they have no bearing on the sensibility of the rationale behind the NAP, or the principle itself. What matters is not the countless edge cases, but the general principles themselves, and most of all, whether they are rational and consistent.

There is no all-encompassing, absolute, 100% objective moral system, but that's alright. Since the best we can do is "close enough", that's what we should aim for. Even the Golden Rule by itself is enough, and not only that, we actually have a "biological moral system" - your conscience is a manifestation of it. We're biologically inclined to behave in a moral way. No, bringing up sociopaths is not necessary here.

>> I offered you a chance to define your terms

Not really. You came in claiming that my definitions weren't definitions. But that's yet another issue that's better left un-bickered. Then you threw various unrelated questions at me, and I responded to them, trying to get you to see that the answers to most of your questions depend on various circumstances etc that aren't known.

>> You might do that by pointing to a series of objects and asking, "Is this a banana?" That's all I'm doing: I'm pointing at a series of situations and asking, "Is this force? Is this initiation?"

Sure, but to what end? You can figure out the correct answers to all of your questions with a moment's thought, at least hopefully. For example, owning a gun is no more "force" than owning a pair of socks. It's about what you do with the gun. Besides, you can strangle someone to death with a pair of socks, but for some strange reason, someone possessing socks is not a problem.

>> Like this. This is important. Nothing in the Non-Aggression Principle points this out.

That's because you can figure this stuff out as necessary, as it comes up. Reasoning is enough.

>> Which categories of intents, choices, and actions may be combined to constitute coercion, which constitutes force? As our understanding of neuroscience develops, how might we gain nuance into understanding what constitutes coercion?

Again, there are endless options for preventing a discussion from getting anywhere. You're just needlessly complicating things. I get it. It's difficult to process this stuff.

But here's a simple question: Does anyone have the right to take someone else's property by force? Now, if you're thinking of asking for a definition of "property", you're just proving my point. "Property" can be defined in several, compatible, sensible ways, but we all intuitively know what it means anyway, and act accordingly. We all know it's wrong for me to take something from you against your will, and vice versa.

Next, since the answer is clearly "No", the next question is: "So why would a human being working for the government have the right to take your property by force then?".. Feel like answering that? -Bear in mind that we're all just people, all part of the same human race, all just individuals, with the exact same rights as every other human being, and the answer should be obvious.

>> This is a question about the definition of violence

No it's not. It's a question of common sense. Yes, the definition of "violence" gets murky when you start digging through it, but that's irrelevant. For example, everyone knows that punching someone in the face for no reason is wrong, and that it constitutes violence. Again, the aggressor is always in the wrong. It's a very simple, but extremely effective rule, and one that actually does fit the way we naturally behave and the kind of things we naturally consider immoral.

>> If someone cultivates the land and produces value from it, then they own it.

Sure, that makes sense. It's roughly the same as Murray Rothbard's idea of "mixing one's labour" with something, eg. land.

>> If you gain ownership, and then someone else cultivates and produces value, is that force?

I'm assuming you meant the same piece of land. Clearly, if the land is already reasonably considered your property, then no one else is allowed to interfere with your control over it.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:34PM (#6871770)
>> The NAP is a reasonably well defined moral principle.

Therein lies the problem though, even if we accept the NAP, we can never agree on what is force or violence and what is the initiation of force. Particularly where it concerns libertarian dialogue in which anything and everything can be and is construed as violence, with the bizarre exception of property rights. It's not reasonably well defined, it's vague and facile.

>> What matters is not the countless edge cases, but the general principles themselves, and most of all, whether they are rational and consistent.

Actually I value pragmatism and social utility well over consistency when it comes to my society. If a society is entirely rational based on a narrow vision of rational morality but ends up worse for the majority of people than one that is morally corrupt from top to bottom... well you'll find me in Corruptopia.

>> There is no all-encompassing, absolute, 100% objective moral system, but that's alright. Since the best we can do is "close enough", that's what we should aim for.

But we should definitely aim for one that respects your morals (property rights) over anyone else's (equal access to land, food etc) ?

>> Does anyone have the right to take someone else's property by force?

Yup, in some circumstances. For instance if your property is radioactive and near my house. There are many other exceptions as you yourself have mentioned.

>> everyone knows that punching someone in the face for no reason is wrong, and that it constitutes violence. Again, the aggressor is always in the wrong

That must be why the good guys in movies are always non-violent pacifists and never, ever punch someone in the face for saying something they don't like about their girl (for instance).

I'm sorry, but you start with an ill-defined premise (the NAP), admit there are hundreds of holes or grey areas, and then try to tell us that we should build our entire moral outlook and society on it anyway. It's rather funny really.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @03:08AM (#6873308)
>> Therein lies the problem though, even if we accept the NAP, we can never agree on what is force or violence and what is the initiation of force

No it doesn't. You're only making a problem where none really exists. Complaining that the definitions of everyday words are unclear is just a bullshit distraction. If that were the case, we simply could not communicate at all.

>> Actually I value pragmatism and social utility well over consistency when it comes to my society.

Yes, well, now we're in the territory of collectivist thinking, which is just completely ass-backwards considering we're all just individuals, not part of The Borg. Collectivism is one of the supporting pillars of States. We're bombarded with the idea that we must all be subject to a ruling class for the common good, that we need to pay taxes to help poor people, and so on.

And before you go there, wanting to keep your property does not mean you want poor people to die. You just want everyone's property rights to be respected.

>> If a society is entirely rational based on a narrow vision of rational morality but ends up worse for the majority of people than one that is morally corrupt from top to bottom... well you'll find me in Corruptopia.

In case you haven't noticed, you already find yourself in Corruptopia. Seriously, dude. Bailouts ring a bell? Campaign contributions (=bribes), etc? You know your politicians are thoroughly corrupt and lie just about every time they open their mouths, and you insist on holding on to that?

>> But we should definitely aim for one that respects your morals (property rights) over anyone else's (equal access to land, food etc) ?

Not "over" anyone else's. Obviously, everyone has the exact same rights as everyone else. That means no one is allowed to take my property, and I'm not allowed to take anyone else's property. It all works out just fine. Oh, and rights can't be in conflict - that would break our notion of rights. Just like black is black and not white at the same time, the right to take someone's property cannot exist while people have the right to keep their property. Get it?

>> Yup, in some circumstances. For instance if your property is radioactive and near my house. There are many other exceptions as you yourself have mentioned.

The obvious answer was "no", and that's enough. We're not talking about edge cases here, because there are countless, and wading through them is pointless. There are even more circumstances where it takes zero effort to adhere to the NAP.

Here's a good rule of thumb: any time you don't want to aggress against anyone, you'll automatically adhere to the NAP, and if you're sane, you'll realize that this is pretty much all the time. See, in reality, there is no problem with the NAP, even if no moral rule can "cover" every possible situation ever. That just can't be required. As mentioned, the best we can do is "close enough", and the NAP certainly is.

>> non-violent pacifists and never, ever punch someone in the face for saying something they don't like about their girl (for instance).

Right, and what fucking sense does it make to physically assault someone for saying something bad about you or your girlfriend? Insecure much? Feeling violent?

>> I'm sorry, but you start with an ill-defined premise (the NAP), admit there are hundreds of holes or grey areas, and then try to tell us that we should build our entire moral outlook and society on it anyway. It's rather funny really.

Dude. You haven't got much to go by here. See above. You know that the NAP works just fine.

Besides, when you say "we should build our entire moral outlook and society on it", who exactly is that we you refer to? What should we do? What should you do? Who's anyone to tell you what you should do, as long as you don't harm others? You're thinking in collectivist terms again, which is understandable, since we've all been brainwashed to think like that. But you need to wake up and realize that we're not The Borg. We're not parts of some collective consciousness. We're all just individuals, and make our individual choices. Choices have consequences, and everyone is responsible for his own.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:45AM (#6873558)
>> No it doesn't. You're only making a problem where none really exists. Complaining that the definitions of everyday words are unclear is just a bullshit distraction. If that were the case, we simply could not communicate at all.

It is indeed very hard to communicate with people like yourself who insist on seeing everything as violence and aggression, but we must try.

And we absolutely can (and do) disagree about definitions. Have you never heard the old socialist line "all property is theft"? Now if I understand you correctly, theft is a form of violence, so to some people property itself is a problem of violence and aggression.

>> Yes, well, now we're in the territory of collectivist thinking, which is just completely ass-backwards considering we're all just individuals, not part of The Borg.

And we all live on a shared planet and all of our actions impact on other people, you do not live on an asteroid with no other people around. Get over it.

>> Collectivism is one of the supporting pillars of States. We're bombarded with the idea that we must all be subject to a ruling class for the common good, that we need to pay taxes to help poor people, and so on.

Nobody I know says you must be subject to a ruling class, though many do say we must be subject to a set of rules that we come up with collectively. Many of them may be covered by NAP, many are not. Otherwise I don't disagree - taxes are generally a good thing, though we should fight inefficiency where we can. And I speak as an earner in one of the 1% highest earning households in my country.

>> In case you haven't noticed, you already find yourself in Corruptopia.

I know, right? And just look at us! Highest standards of living in the world and highest standards of living in history! And look at those places where there's little or no government, they collapse into tribalism, violence, warlords and total social decay! Corruptopia is pretty sweet right?

I'll not deny we have problems (it's Corruptopia after all), but not the sort that I see being solved by adherence to a bizarre, simplistic and flawed moral (non-)axiom.

>> The obvious answer was "no", and that's enough. We're not talking about edge cases here, because there are countless, and wading through them is pointless. There are even more circumstances where it takes zero effort to adhere to the NAP.

No, the obvious answer, and the one you explicitly agreed with is that it depends on the circumstances. It's almost as if there were other moral principles at work that you allow to override your NAP from time to time. How odd!

>> See, in reality, there is no problem with the NAP, even if no moral rule can "cover" every possible situation ever. That just can't be required. As mentioned, the best we can do is "close enough", and the NAP certainly is.

A rule that is as full of holes as that, as disputed in definition, is not a good rule to use as the basis of society.

>> See, in reality, there is no problem with the NAP, even if no moral rule can "cover" every possible situation ever.

If no moral rule can cover every possible situation then how about we don't try and structure society about one rule eh?

>> Right, and what fucking sense does it make to physically assault someone for saying something bad about you or your girlfriend? Insecure much? Feeling violent?

Me, no, but you said everyone knows it's wrong. I was giving the counterpoint that pop-culture is filled with violence and aggression, even amongst the 'good guys'.

>> You know that the NAP works just fine.

I know that it's not the be-all and end-all of the basis for a good society.

>> Who's anyone to tell you what you should do, as long as you don't harm others?

Where the line of harming others starts is entirely subjective. A lot of people deny the anthropogenic global warming/climate change is real, and so continue to wantonly fill the air with greenhouse gasses. They don't see it as harming anyone yet scientifically speaking they are harming everyone for multiple generations.

It's just not as simple as you like to think, and the results of a balanced mix of property rights and collectivism has so far resulted in the best societies the planet has ever seen. Sorry if I seem reluctant to throw that away based on a platitude.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @12:09PM (#6875226)
> Insecure much? Feeling violent?

YES. Absolutely yes. BECAUSE I AM HUMAN, motherfucker. Will hitting you in the face repeatedly persuade you that people are naturally violent? Probably not, but at least it MAKE ME FEEL BETTER. I know this is true, because I've done it. It feels great.

Come on. See if you can explain to me how my natural pacifistic soul is not inclined to slam your skull against a brick wall. If your NAP allows you to hit back? Fuck that. It just means I need to hit you so hard you can't hit back. That's my choice, and the consequences are awesome. I get an adrenaline high; I get to assert my animal dominance; I get to feel the crunch of your bone. It's obvious and natural; you pissed me off, so you made me hit you. I didn't start it; you just shouldn't have pissed me off.

What do I get out of following your stupid NAP? All it means is that I don't get to watch you double over when I kick you in the balls. What good is that to me? If I have a baseball bat, then I really ought to cement my ownership of it by cultivating its usage as a knee breaker. Maybe knock out a few teeth.

You go on. You follow your NAP. Maybe we'll meet someday. And maybe I'll get to watch you cry like a bitch. Maybe I'm insecure. But as the childhood lesson goes, if someone calls you names, you get some sticks and some stones and you go to town. I hope you feel superior. Maybe I'll get lucky and we can see some piss and vomit in addition to blood and tears.

Come on. Wish me away again. If you call on your fairy godmother, maybe you'll see me coming and you can run away in time.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:20PM (#6882005)
Wow :D

I've seen quite a few outbursts brought on by cognitive dissonance, but yours definitely takes the cake. Maybe you'll eventually wake the fuck up in some kind of gulag near Seattle.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Friday December 13, 2013 @09:33PM (#6904294)
It's not cognitive dissonance to admit to insecurity and an interest in violence, dear child. Cognitive dissonance is believing that people are naturally non-violent while having your face punched in.

Telling me I don't exist does not, in fact, make me go away.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by MaysonL on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:30PM (#6871755)
I start digging in "your" backyard, and you shoot me. Who "initiated" "force"?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:00PM (#6871107)
By the way, voluntarists and anarcho-capitalists are one and the same.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:04PM (#6871123)
To me, I agree, but I've heard some of them draw a distinction I don't fully understand and I try to be respectful of identifying people in the way they choose to be identified.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:10PM (#6871152)
I'm not sure what that distinction might be, and I doubt it would be real anyway. Basically the idea is that everything should be voluntary, which is really hard to disagree with whilst being sane.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @06:15PM (#6871934)
Not with their definition of 'voluntary.'
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:21AM (#6873191)
This is their definition of 'voluntary': http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/voluntary

done, made, brought about, undertaken, etc., of one's own accord or by free choice

- Coincidentally, it's also yours.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:39PM (#6871018)
the NAP is in effect. it's just me and you in the forest, and there's one apple tree. you "own" the apple tree. I am starving, and I "steal" an apple from your tree.

who initiated the aggression?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:45PM (#6871042)
There's no need to quibble about "lifeboat scenarios". You can come up with countless scenarios where there needs to be an "exception" to the NAP, but that's pointless, and a waste of time. It changes nothing about NAP itself, or its basis.

You'll break a rule when you have to, and that's it. It's very simple. If you're in the desert, dying of thirst and someone comes along and starts trying to force you to pay a ridiculous price for some water, then of course you'll do whatever you can to get some. But no sane, independent, objective "court" would punish you for that.

For a clearer picture, start coming up with scenarios where you could adhere to the NAP with zero effort at all.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:38PM (#6871537)
>> You'll break a rule when you have to, and that's it. It's very simple. If you're in the desert, dying of thirst and someone comes along and starts trying to force you to pay a ridiculous price for some water, then of course you'll do whatever you can to get some. But no sane, independent, objective "court" would punish you for that.

Then the NAP is not the whole of the law, or necessarily even a useful starting point.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:23PM (#6871712)
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:44PM (#6871809)
I was already building a reply to that. What it seems to boil down to is "I know that I can't define my terms and I know that we don't agree about morality but god-dammit my one moral principle should still be the basis of everything".

Needless to say, I disagree.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:30AM (#6873211)
>> I know that we don't agree about morality but god-dammit my one moral principle should still be the basis of everything

Ah yes, "we just disagree on morality" is a classic avoidance-technique for a Statist that refuses to accept reality. But actually, no we don't. Not if you're sane and not a sociopath. We've both got a conscience, and it usually warns us when we're doing something even somewhat wrong.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:23AM (#6873507)
>> But actually, no we don't. Not if you're sane and not a sociopath.

Ah yes, "if you disagree with my interpretation of morality you must be a sociopath" is a classic avoidance technique for a libertarian that refuses to accept reality.

>> We've both got a conscience, and it usually warns us when we're doing something even somewhat wrong.

Not everyone's conscience tells them the same thing, neither does everyone's conscience tell them that the NAP is the root rule of the universe. Even yours doesn't as you've admitted in a variety of places.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:09AM (#6873165)
my assertion is that this is not a "lifeboat" scenario. property "rights" are, at their absolute core, a use of force.

to be a true libertarian, you can't believe in property rights.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:38AM (#6873233)
>> my assertion is that this is not a "lifeboat" scenario. property "rights" are, at their absolute core, a use of force.

Nope. Our "rights" are an idea, but one that's aligned with our "intuitive morality". Force only comes into question when someone is violating your property rights. If no one ever does, then no one will ever have to forcibly defend his property rights.

In other words, if someone grabs your iPhone and starts running away, you have the right to try and stop him because he has no right to take your property. It's all very simple when you allow yourself to see it.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Monday December 09, 2013 @06:23PM (#6877810)
> "intuitive morality"

> It's all very simple when you allow yourself to see it.

there's your problem. you're refusing to truly reconsider property rights as a use of force, and appealing to instinct rather than actually thinking about the problem.

to take something out of the public domain and not allow any other people to make use of the object is force, plain and simple.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:58AM (#6881822)
>> you're refusing to truly reconsider property rights as a use of force, and appealing to instinct rather than actually thinking about the problem

You're skirting around having to actually hear what I'm saying and let it sink in. Do I have to repeat myself? "Property is force" is a nice little distraction, and I've been through this with someone else before. Really, property is not "use of force" even though defending it may require some.

But even if you do view property rights as a "use of force", so what? -What do you think that implies? Well, this will probably just get lost in our comment histories, so I won't expend any more effort on this.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:13PM (#6882922)
> But even if you do view property rights as a "use of force", so what? -What do you think that implies?

that a philosophy that is founded on "there are only two rules: property rights are The One True Right, and initiation of force is The One True Wrong" is impossible to take seriously.

> Well, this will probably just get lost in our comment histories, so I won't expend any more effort on this.

nice way to try to take the higher ground while forfeiting. it's okay-- I know thinking is often hard for libertarians.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by rayiner on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:05PM (#6871135)
The minute you institute property rights, you're forcing everyone to recognize and play along with certain rules. Classic libertarians have no opposition to government intervention when it comes to violently preventing poor people from taking their property. They deem it perfectly legitimate to coerce someone with economic threats but not physical ones. Its wonderfully self-serving for an educated class that tends not to have much in the way of physical strength to force everyone to abide by these rules that devalue physical strength.

To me, the only thing that needs to be said in this debate is that people, given the freedom to structure their society as they wish, have gravitated toward social democracy all over the West. They want everyone to be in it together not just when it comes to certain rights like property that libertarians like to pretend are handed down by God, but also when it comes to taking care of the poor, sick, and disabled and ensuring social mobility through education.

In my view, its immoral to create government to force everyone to follow certain rules, then deny people the right to decide for themselves what those rules should be. But that's the whole premise behind libertarian limited government.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by adriand on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:06PM (#6870510)
> The libertarian and anti-government sentiments aren't saying that we shouldn't be all in this together, but that we shouldn't be forced to be all in this together. That difference is what the entire argument is about.

That's the kind of facile, juvenile argument the OP decries in this article. To make an analogy, I could equally say, "I shouldn't be forced to be in a family. Families are great and everything, but why do I have to have one?"

Well guess what, I have one because I'm a human being and got born into one. You're an American (or a Canadian or a Briton or whatever). You are part of a society and part of a nation whether you like it or not. So let's make it work for everyone.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by thaumasiotes on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:17PM (#6870573)
This is kind of a funny analogy, perhaps better than you realized. Families and governments compete directly with each other for power over society. The English-speaking countries are way, way out on the government end of the continuum; here, you don't have to be in a family if it's not to your taste. Compared to the rest of the world, Americans, Canadians, and Britons already have only the most tenuous connection to their families anyway.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:24PM (#6870618)
Fun fact: Engels actually wrote a whole book about this: http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1884/origin-famil...
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by cinquemb on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:15PM (#6870553)
> You're an American (or a Canadian or a Briton or whatever). You are part of a society and part of a nation whether you like it or not. So let's make it work for everyone.

Regardless of which lines one did not to choose to be drawn around them, not everyone has an affinity for them, and if history is any example of such, blood will be drawn for those to fight for their will to reconstruct such lines to their choosing…

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by coldtea on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:26PM (#6871232)
>Regardless of which lines one did not to choose to be drawn around them, not everyone has an affinity for them

Yes -- there are always selfish pricks, who think that they should have a say in if they'd have affinity to their family or society or fellow humans.

It's like seeing a child drowning and saying, "well, I don't know this kid or feel anything for this, so why should I do anything to help it?" -- instead of just jumping in just cause it's a fellow human.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by cinquemb on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:08PM (#6871426)
Yes -- we can all pick examples at the extremities that may exemplify how one feels and throw names about in order to convince or deride the fellow human being into a lockstep of some sort.

Yet such men (and women), who stand on the pillars of history, who have helped create the social constructs we find ourselves living by to some degree today, were "selfish pricks" to those who apposed them and died in their wake.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by eudox on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:41PM (#6870709)
>You're an American (or a Canadian or a Briton or whatever). You are part of a society and part of a nation whether you like it or not. So let's make it work for everyone.

"{Nature|The State|Society|Some other abstraction} is the only thing we all belong to, so better get used to it."

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by ant512 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:14PM (#6870548)
> Few people are saying saying "let's not do this" for some value of "this", they're saying "let's not force everyone to do this".

There are four guys in a crippled spaceship. They have 7 hours of oxygen left if they continue to breathe normally. If they all make a concerted effort to breathe slowly they could extend the oxygen to 8 hours. The rescue ship arrives in 8 hours.

They are all in it together. There's nothing that can be done about that.

Now the libertarian astronaut insists that he won't be forced to change his breathing pattern. No way is he going to be forced to do anything different. He's not going to be forced to be in it with the other guys. No amount of cajoling, threatening or reasoning will get this guy to give up his "one-man island" philosophy.

But he is in it with the other guys. Sticking his head in the space-sand doesn't change the hard facts of 7 hours of oxygen and rescue in 8.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by direwolf on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:04PM (#6885845)
Actually, I think this is a really great example, and how you view it says a lot about your philosophy. Let's call the libertarian astronaut Ayn. Ayn is rational, and she happens to really like breathing normally. There's no biological reason requiring her to do so, but breathing more slowly seems inconvenient to her. So she just keeps breathing normally. Since she assumes the other three astronauts to be rational, she expects them to moderate their breathing even further to account for her normal breathing.

At first, this is what happens. The other three astronauts breathe even more slowly to make up for Ayn's normal breathing, keeping them on pace for 8 hours of oxygen. But the other astronauts think this division isn't fair--there's no reason that Ayn should get more oxygen than the rest of them. They decide that they have a couple of options. First, they could all start breathing normally in the hopes that Ayn would start moderating her breathing in response. It would turn the spaceship into a contest of who blinks first, and if no one blinked soon enough, all of them would die. Second, they could kill Ayn, but they believe murder is immoral. They think Ayn's behavior is unfair, but killing is worse, so they don't do it.

Instead, the other three astronauts come up with another option. They vote on and accept the moderated breathing policy for everyone in the spaceship. Ayn refuses to participate in the vote. The other three astronauts unanimously elect one of them--we'll call him Big Brother--to regulate the use of oxygen. Big Brother keeps track of everyone's breathing and can slap people in the face if they don't breathe at the agreed-upon rate. The rules allow any three of the astronauts to vote out the oxygen regulator if he doesn't do a good job, or doesn't comply with the breathing regulations himself. Ayn might not like breathing slowly, but she likes getting slapped in the face less, so she moderates her breathing.

But now Ayn is upset. She argues forcefully that she's a bold risk-taker and that society should incentivize her risk-taking. She took a risk and breathed normally, taking what she wanted even though it created a possibility that the other astronauts would do so as well, which would kill them all. She points out that Big Brother has made some mistakes--he's miscalculated the breathing rate a couple of times and slapped people when they didn't deserve it. She argues for the deregulation of oxygen and the return of the free market. Who's right: Ayn or Big Brother? Neither is perfect, but I'll take Big Brother. The alternative is a game of chicken where the stakes are everyone's lives.

As for this example being contrived, let's change it slightly. Let's say 7 billion people are born onto a planet. This planet has limited drinkable water, breathable air, arable land, and combustible material. We can either let people use those resources however they please, risking the resources' eventual pollution, overuse, and depletion, or we can establish systems to regulate use so that they will be available to everyone for for the foreseeable future. If we don't regulate their use, we can get iPods at slightly cheaper prices, at least in the short term. The point is that people will take what they want and cut corners to make money, even if endangers the health of the human race. Yes, we're all in it together. Personally, I'll take the sustainability of the planet over cheaper iPods.

This doesn't mean that I think the government should regulate everything, that all regulation is good, or that our current system of regulation is optimal. But I think it's inarguable that some things need to be regulated, and that there is a role for government. Can government be inefficient, corrupt, or just plain wrong? Sure. It's fallible, just like any human creation (including private entities). But we need it.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by CamperBob2 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:22PM (#6870603)
Do you have a permit from the EPA to burn all of that straw?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by ant512 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:28PM (#6870637)
It's a contrived analogy, mainly because - as Simon points out in the article:

> Their eyes glaze...It's too much. Too much to contemplate the idea that the whole country might be actually connected.

It seems to me that people struggle to deal with this issue when scaled out to a population beyond their immediate social circle. That's one of the problems.

The other is, as soon as you scale it back to a comprehensible size, people shout "straw man!" and the debate goes nowhere.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by VMG on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:24PM (#6870621)
Contrived example time?

What is the political system on the spaceship that allows three of the four to hold a vote and kill off the least popular guy on the spaceship?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by jjoonathan on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:32PM (#6870666)
It's contrived but it highlights a real problem: free markets are very poorly suited to the task of avoiding tragedies of the commons.

Unless you think tragedies of the commons don't happen in real life, the contrived example is relevant.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by CamperBob2 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:23PM (#6870934)
The problem with the example is that it doesn't illustrate the tragedy of the commons. Self-interest alone will lead the astronauts to do the right thing, because they're rational actors who are fully aware of their situation, and who are not in competition with each other. There's no incentive for the "libertarian" astronaut to consume more oxygen than the others.

In your example, only stupid astronauts (or, I suppose, mentally impaired ones) would fail to conserve their oxygen. It's better to structure your economic views to encourage and expect rational behavior among fully-aware actors, even if this ideal is rarely approached in practice.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by JonnieCache on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:49PM (#6871341)
>It's better to structure your economic views to encourage and expect rational behavior among fully-aware actors, even if this ideal is rarely approached in practice.

Why?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by CamperBob2 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:35PM (#6871524)
Because otherwise you end up allowing naive, irrational, and dishonest actors to determine how your system functions for everyone. It's like airport security.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by VMG on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:36PM (#6871530)
Let's use your contrived example to highlight a new problem:

The three astronauts Yuri and John elect Markus to be the new commissioner of oxygen, while Markus votes for Ronald and Ronald abstains. Everybody delegates total control to Markus, who unfortunately turns out to be a psychopath and kills the whole crew.

What were we talking about again?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @01:27AM (#6873074)
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by ahomescu1 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:58PM (#6871619)
> No amount of cajoling, threatening or reasoning will get this guy to give up his "one-man island" philosophy.

That's an unreasonable assumption. If he doesn't breathe slowly, he dies. As CamperBob2 also points out, it would be completely irrational for the libertarian astronaut to refuse to cooperate, so he'd go along.

The problem most libertarians point out is that we're sometimes forced (by society) to contribute, without receiving anything in return. One-sided trades are the problem, not mutually-beneficial cooperation. When you pay 40% of your income so others get welfare, you're arguably not receiving anything in return.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by fizzbar on Sunday December 08, 2013 @06:22PM (#6871966)
How do you define what the "return" is? Perhaps it's not an immediate causal relationship, but a much more complicated, interrelated set of returns -- like a more cohesive, inclusive, better functioning society.

Paying more for welfare to others might pay off in being able to walk the streets at night without being mugged, for example.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by DerpDerpDerp on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:06PM (#6870511)
Take this as sampling bias if you will, but most of the well-reasoned argument that I've heard from libertarians or anarchists are really just arguments that we should go back to building societies on the scale of city-states, and stop having them on the scale of the US.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by wrongc0ntinent on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:48PM (#6870753)
Scale is where the comparison between those two will break down. The first is power-assertive on an small scale (usually individual). The second has no scale, because the driving motivation would be the questioning of any power structure (not necessarily destruction, as it's usually stereotyped). But I'm describing the textbook version here, not everyday interpretations.

(Edit: i was trying to keep this out of quick searches, but to be clear, lib-----ian vs a-----ism ;)

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:50PM (#6870430)
I just made a very long post that tried to say exactly that. Kudos for your more elegant and succinct answer that captures in four sentences what I'm not sure I did in eight paragraphs.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by patcon on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:55PM (#6870794)
I'm torn here. If you insist everyone make every moral choice for themselves, then we will be unable to maximize the "right" choices. For example: If I want to buy ethical foods, I'd rather shop at a place where all these criteria are enforced. It would be mind-numbingly draining to have to make all these choices myself. Frankly, I would tune out. In a libertarian society, every person would need to be educated on food systems, why some are ethical and why some aren't, etc. And only then could we have an equitable system that is supported by choice. But people don't want to invest that much into understanding the thing that keeps them nourished.

This is the problem I see with libertarianism. Without some form of, hopefully mild coercion, people just tune out based on gut feeling. If they don't want to participate and contribute to something after the quick-and-dirty explanation, then they're out -- nevermind the 3 year study and expert panel that analyzed the issue and recommended process/measure/regulation X.

I agree that our legislation and regulations need to be more responsive and aligned with reality, but gunning for everything to be "opt-out" does not seem sustainable.

Sorry, I go back and forth. I'm not libertarian by any means, but being so highly involved in open source community, I see the value of properly structured voluntary communities. Basically, I'm really torn about everything I've said above :)

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:31PM (#6870979)
>> I'm torn here

That's good. You're sensing that something is wrong.

>> If you insist everyone make every moral choice for themselves, then we will be unable to maximize the "right" choices

Why would "we" need to "maximize" the right choices? Who's we anyway? Aren't we all just individuals, with our own goals and desires that are constantly changing anyway? Who's anyone to "maximize" the "rightness" of your choices, as long as you don't harm others? How bad should you want that bar of chocolate tomorrow at noon? What about in the evening?

See, economies consist of exchanges between people, and whenever an exchange is voluntary, it leaves both parties better off.

There's no "optimization" necessary there. It's all based on each individual's subjective preferences. If you want an apple, and have a dollar, you can give that dollar to someone in exchange for an apple. If you do this, it means you valued the apple higher than your dollar, and the other guy valued your dollar higher than his apple! -Bam. Both are better off. No "maximizing" necessary.

>> In a libertarian society, every person would need to be educated on food systems, why some are ethical and why some aren't, etc

Really? Is it really unclear to anyone that treating animals well is better than treating them horribly? Why would anyone prefer the meat that's produced through treating animals horribly, or even badly, compared to a more "organic" alternative?

Sure, prices are a factor, but just about everyone would like to support treating animals well, right? So if organic production is increased, those prices will fall. It may still be a bit more expensive, but organic, non-GMO food comes with the additional benefit of not being harmful to your health, and that's quite valuable too.

>> nevermind the 3 year study and expert panel that analyzed the issue and recommended process/measure/regulation X.

Who are the "experts"? -Where do they come from? What are they affiliated with? Who paid for the study? What kind of regulation are we talking about? Why would it be good? What's the alternative? How often is coercion better than no coercion? (Pro-tip: never)

.. And so on.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by drakeandrews on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:15PM (#6871184)
How about when someone doesn't support treating animals well. Or values your apple more than your life? Or decides they have this million tonnes of toxic gunk and decides that instead of paying someone who knows how to deal with it he's just going to dump it all in your lake? Or when someone realises that you value organic produce more, and decides to lie and say that their produce is in fact organic?

What happens when someone realises your house is on top of a nice mineral deposit but can't give you sufficient value to vacate your property and decides to burn it down in the middle of the night?

What happens when one person pays another to kill you? It's a free and voluntary exchange. And you're dead. Everyone is better off, right? Right?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:45PM (#6871321)
>> What happens when one person pays another to kill you? It's a free and voluntary exchange. And you're dead. Everyone is better off, right? Right?

I'm sensing a reluctance to process ideas here. Bad stuff is going to happen regardless of how our societies are organized. That doesn't mean it's alright to take someone's property by force, nor that voluntary, "market solutions" to real problems would not emerge.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @01:32AM (#6873083)
> That's good. You're sensing that something is wrong.

Please stop coercing him using appeals to emotion and false authority. It's paternalistic and condescending.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:31AM (#6873216)
>> Please stop coercing him using appeals to emotion and false authority. It's paternalistic and condescending.

Tell me, do you think that when say, 330 million people are systematically punished for attempting to keep their property, something just might, in fact, be wrong?

What about 7 billion people?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @11:41AM (#6875067)
Still with the emotional arguments. Which part of "don't force me" was unclear?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:12PM (#6877026)
Still with the mental gymnastics. Which part of "taxation is extortion" was not clear?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @05:27PM (#6877514)
The part where you have to do semantic contortions in order to make it a true statement. If anyone's guilty of butchering everyday language in order to make an obscure academic edge case, it's your redefinition of extortion to include taxation. Common sense does not make people think "extortion" when they hear "taxation".
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:52AM (#6879831)
>> The part where you have to do semantic contortions in order to make it a true statement. If anyone's guilty of butchering everyday language in order to make an obscure academic edge case, it's your redefinition of extortion to include taxation

Actually, the definition of "extortion" is not controversial, and needs no twisting to fit taxation: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/extort

to wrest or wring (money, information, etc.) from a person by violence, intimidation, or abuse of authority; obtain by force, torture, threat, or the like.

When a mafia threatens people with violence to make them pay "protection money", it's clearly extortion and clearly immoral.. but when governments threaten people with violence to make them pay taxes, that's.. perfectly fine?

>> Common sense does not make people think "extortion" when they hear "taxation".

Actually, it's brainwashing that prevents people from connecting these dots.

Wake up.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:22PM (#6882013)
> Actually, it's brainwashing that forces people into making up connections between these dots.

> Wake up.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Zigurd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:38PM (#6870688)
There is a simple way to address the libertarian argument, IF that argument is honestly about being "forced" to act as a group: Devolve political power until you start being able to say "we" enough of the time to act together.

If you can't agree there is such a viable grouping that enables consensual government action, that's anarcho-capitalism, not libertarianism.

Big nation states make big mistakes, like multi-trillion dollar wars. Smaller governmental groupings are not capable of mistakes on that scale.

The world also needs more diversity of social, economic, and legal systems - the opposite of the monoculture of IP laws treaties like TPP want to create.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by klintcho on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:31PM (#6870660)
So everyone should be able to consume resources on this earth but not be forced to give anything back? I fail to see how this will give us a viable future when some people will be able to "opt out" of society?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by spindritf on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:33PM (#6870352)
The idea that the market will solve such things as environmental concerns, as our racial divides, as our class distinctions, our problems with educating and incorporating one generation of workers into the economy after the other when that economy is changing

Is this idea actually being implemented anywhere? Isn't education, even in the US, almost wholly sponsored by the government? People talk about student loans but those are also guaranteed by the government, right? And then the government grants those loans special status by preventing you from ever discharging them in case of bankruptcy.

I don't know if the market could remove divides but neither does anyone else because it's a completely untested hypothesis.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by touzen on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:52PM (#6870440)
In Sweden private for profit schools and schools run by the municipalities compete with each other. All of them are funded by the tax payers and they get a certain amount of money for every student.

The system is a disaster, with a lot of for profit schools slashing costs to maximize profits regardless of what the consequences are for the students. And that's just one of the many failures of the system.

Basically, the problem is that markets don't necessarily generate the best solutions from a social perspective, markets generate the solutions that create the largest profits. You have to some how get the markets to stop chasing profits, which is easier said than done.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:35PM (#6870679)
>> In Sweden private for profit schools and schools run by the municipalities compete with each other. All of them are funded by the tax payers and they get a certain amount of money for every student.

How the hell can a school be "private", while being funded by taxpayers?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by dobbsbob on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:48PM (#6871051)
They call these "PPP" public private partnerships. What happens is cronies of the ruling party are given money to avoid risk and get to run the business extracting all profits for themselves. The taxpayer is told hey this would cost 10x as much if we ran it.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @03:18AM (#6873337)
Yep, bullshit as usual.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Fomite on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:35PM (#6871001)
The privatization of rewards while the public bears the risk is a pretty well established business model these days.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @03:18AM (#6873336)
Right. I wasn't actually confused about what's going on, just wanted to point out it doesn't make sense :p
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by nickff on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:59PM (#6870466)
Profits ~= value of product - resources consumed

There is nothing wrong with firms making profits, it is a sign of efficiency, and a sign of where resources should be allocated; with time, the least efficient firms are eliminated, and only those which create the most value at the lowest cost remain. The problem is that the product (and its value) may not reflect the objective(s) of the policymakers and the public, and the chief goal of those creating any system should be to properly align rewards with desired outcomes.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by jjoonathan on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:40PM (#6870704)
Easier said than done. I think it's probable that some problems are so difficult to translate into proper market motivations that the cost of the perverse incentives inevitably produced by your attempts will consistently exceed the potential for increased efficiency and miraculous innovation that the market promises.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by nickff on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:59PM (#6870815)
You are neglecting to examine the counter-factual. The current system is abound with perverse incentives and flaws. As to the difficulty of designing a new system; we have thrown money at a poorly designed system for many years with little success, perhaps a redesign would be worth it.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gizmo686 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:33PM (#6870671)
>You have to some how get the markets to stop chasing profits

There is another solution. You could set up the markets so that the way to maximize profits is to create the best solution. For example, imagine if we had a perfect measure of student outcome. You could make the school's pay dependent on their outcome, then the market will find a way to maximize the f(outcome)/cost.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mogrim on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:23PM (#6871218)
Doesn't work in practice, though - you end up with schools "teaching to the tests", to the detriment of other unscored qualities.

The obvious solution: more tests, and more bureaucracy. By the time you've got enough tests you might as well have a state-run school.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by cdash on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:55PM (#6870795)
What do we need the market for then?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gizmo686 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:28PM (#6871246)
To minimize cost. A better example than education would be carbon emissions. Suppose we want to reduce our carbon emission to X tons per year. If we auction off X credits permitting 1 ton of carbon each, the market will find the cheapest way to reduce our emissions to X. Simply being able to measure emissions would allow us to reduce emissions (say, by requiring all companies to reduce by Y%), however, this is almost defiantly going to be more expansive.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by sseveran on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:56PM (#6870455)
If you stop chasing profits then there is no incentive to produce a quality product. The US public schools are a great example of that.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mooreds on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:00PM (#6870473)
But are profits the best way to measure a "quality product" when it comes to something like education?

I would argue not, or at least that externalized costs need to be internalized somehow (regulation or taxation are the typical means).

That is to say, if we have for profit public schools, I'd want their profits to be tied to the long term effects of results of their students, not to yearly test scores.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by nickff on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:11PM (#6870537)
>if we have for profit public schools, I'd want their profits to be tied to the long term effects of results of their students, not to yearly test scores.

This is a great idea! Why not do the same for government-run schoolteachers? This may help attract and retain high quality staff, as well as providing low-skilled teachers an incentive to leave.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by grahamburger on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:03PM (#6871120)
Are you suggesting that I can't determine for myself if a particular school is providing a good long term education for my child? Or that I shouldn't be able to choose to take them to a different school?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by steveklabnik on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:58PM (#6870463)
There's no inherent incentive to produce a quality product when chasing profit either, just one that people will give you money for. Sometimes this aligns with quality, other times, it does not.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by te_chris on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:29PM (#6870654)
Unless schools somehow got paid for good outcomes then this is a specious argument.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @01:36AM (#6873097)
Why do Americans always insist on conceiving of children as products? Why do they always insist that schools produce children? Last I checked, we disallow reproduction at schools.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mogrim on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:46PM (#6871328)
Other incentives are available. Public pressure, for example.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mooreds on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:38PM (#6870378)
Well, there's a rising number of for profit schools and colleges. These are different in that they still get government funding but are run by private companies (as opposed to private schools, which are funded by tuition).

http://chronicle.com/article/Annual-Portrait-of-Education/12...

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by chrisgd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:28PM (#6870640)
People convince the government to defund public schools, they then complain public schools are failing in order to get more private schools built.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mchusma on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:28PM (#6870323)
I think it was a good speech, but because it was so emotional, and not rational. In fact, he was dismissive of any arguments as anything other than his own. To call all other forms of thought juvenile, and simply say "we are either together or not" sounds like the content of a great political speech, not a well articulated debate.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by thenmar on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:30PM (#6870337)
O, if only he had linked to the Mises Institute a few more times!
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by sanderjd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:10PM (#6870529)
I'm not entirely sure what point you're trying to make, but for what it's worth, while agreeing with lots of the speech, I found myself thinking that it was pretty good opinion, but not a great argument.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by thaumasiotes on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:37PM (#6870374)
> The question - and only question - should be what David Simon asks: are we all in this together or are we not?

I can't agree. This is just another way to tell the world at large "you're either with us or you're against us". Posing the question is a good way to convince me that I'm against you.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by nickff on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:18PM (#6870576)
When the someone questions my resolve, I question their aims.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by agilebyte on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:20PM (#6870591)
To me with us means whether I care about my extended families - city, state, nation, World - and how they are doing. Not just taking the view that everybody fends for themselves alone.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mudil on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:26PM (#6870626)
I am not in this together. I am here for myself and my family. To use the famous example of a pencil: no one knows how to produce a pencil. It takes expertise (and infrastructure, i.e. private property) to cut and process wood, to mine graphite and iron for a band, etc etc etc. If some social engineer like David Simon comes in and says "we need to produce pencils together", nothing is going to be done. Because inevitably social engineering means that he (or the bureaucrats that share his ideology) will decide how to shift resources and someone's private property to better produce pencils.

Let's also not forget that founder fathers consistently looked at this and came to the conclusion that an attack on private property is an attack on liberty. That's the reason for a limited gov't.

The big question is why at a time when we have unprecedented size and reach of gov't, and liberty is tramped, we hear these desperate calls that things are not working well?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by eudox on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:36PM (#6870370)
>Are we all in this together or are we all not?

Vague drivel capped by an appeal to emotion. 10/10.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by clarkm on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:02PM (#6870485)
> The question - and only question - should be what David Simon asks: are we all in this together or are we not? To me, the answer is blindingly obvious. It's demonstrated by what societies are flourishing - with high economic and social equality, healthy democratic government, protected personal liberties, well-cared-for populaces, and resilient economies - and what societies aren't.

And the blindingly obvious answer is?

Here's my simple model: large, diverse countries are more unequal than small, culturally homogeneous countries. Just like densely-populated, cosmopolitan regions are more unequal than bland suburbs. Just like world is more unequal than the US.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by jkn on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:38PM (#6870689)
Then don't look at different countries but at the evolution of inequality in a particular country. The rise of inequality in the US since the 1980's is an indictment of the current system. Here's an animated map showing this evolution:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/09/19/w...

And this article has a chart illustrating the inverse relationship between inequality and well-being in the US:

http://aeon.co/magazine/living-together/peter-turchin-wealth...

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by SiVal on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:11PM (#6870538)
Sensible? He points at miles of Baltimore housing projects where "fathers" consider themselves responsible only for impregnating women and the state to be entirely responsible for the child after that as the fault of libertarians. Neighborhoods where everyone assumes from birth that they are permanently exempt from any responsibility for supporting themselves, because that is and always will be the state's responsibility, and are free to spend every day doing what they feel like, are blamed on libertarian ideas.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by justincormack on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:19PM (#6870587)
You are talking about areas where often the only (semi) viable form of income is the drugs trade, and the education system does not work.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by SiVal on Sunday December 08, 2013 @06:01PM (#6871871)
Yet several million people born far away in Mexico with even less education have managed to find viable forms of income in the US without resorting to the drug trade. They didn't have the same welfare system, though.

Before the welfare system made housing entire communities in Baltimore the permanent responsibility of the state, the residents of those neighborhoods worked in construction and built homes for each other. Before the state made feeding themselves and their families from cradle to grave the job of state, they cooked for each other, worked in grocery stores, ran restaurants, drove delivery vans, repaired appliances, did the plumbing.

Before the state permanently eliminated the need to find ways to support themselves and provide for their offspring, the residents of those neighborhoods spoke of hard workers with admiration not derision. Before preparation for supporting themselves was made completely irrelevant, they didn't hold teachers and school work in contempt. Parents used to paint their small schoolhouses and do what they could to scrape together money for schoolbooks that their kids would need to share. Now, painting the much larger school is job of the state, and the kids amuse themselves by destroying the books that nobody they know had to pay for.

This is said to be the fault of the "system" for not taking even more responsibility for the community, without a hint of irony. Yet back when the state did even less and the community supported themselves, they had fewer smart phones but more loving fathers, had fewer schoolbooks but better readers, had less financial stability but far more physical safety.

Yet the article proposes that it is post-war libertarian influence that produced "the horror" of these blighted Baltimore neighborhoods, as if the decades since have been characterized by a rapidly shrinking government.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by JonnieCache on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:01PM (#6870821)
Where exactly does he say that?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by AndrewKemendo on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:44PM (#6870726)
The question - and only question - should be what David Simon asks: are we all in this together or are we not?

I think this question is frankly naïve. Humans have functional limitations on how much we can care about other people, aka Dunbar's number. This is not something you can improve (maybe by .0001%) or create policy around, it's a hard limit.

The fact that, at least in the United States, virtually everyone lives in a place with more than a few thousand people in it, ensures that there will be a conflict between the needs of the group of people around us and our own reactions to those needs.

Add on to that the reality of scarcity of both needs and desires and you have a clear answer: No we are not all in it together.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by penguindev on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:02PM (#6871392)
>Add on to that the reality of scarcity of both needs and desires

Yes! And when people have more than 2.1 children, thus increasing global population, things get even scarcer. So no, your 19 children are clearly not 'all in it together' with my 2, to whom I would like to feed grass fed beef as God - not Monsanto - intended*. But lets all overlook population growth.

[1] Actually I would prefer fish, but lets be realistic - the oceans are now a mercury filled shithole.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gress on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:44PM (#6871316)
Dubar's number not remotely established as a factual 'functional limitation on how much we care about other people'.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by thenomad on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:58PM (#6870809)
That's not what Dunbar's Number means.

Dunbar's Number is "a suggested cognitive limit to the number of people with whom one can maintain stable social relationships."

Having a social relationship with someone != caring about their fate.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by AndrewKemendo on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:44PM (#6871037)
Having a social relationship with someone != caring about their fate.

I think you aren't understanding the mechanism of the theory - which goes beyond the original paper. It has less to do with being able to "be social" (a broader function) than it does with being able to empathize with someone. Empathy is directly related to size and activity within the neocortex.

[1] http://www.pnas.org/content/100/9/5497.long

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by jpttsn on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:44PM (#6870404)
> The question - and only question - should be what David Simon asks: are we all in this together or are we not?

I don't understand: Do you mean that to be a rhetorical question, or do you actually want to debate whether we're "all in this together?"

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by nickff on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:21PM (#6870597)
I believe you were being rhetorical jpttsn; but in any case, Simon assumes no one would ever debate his collectivist query.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by yetanotherphd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:13PM (#6870879)
Replace "juvenile" with "a straw man" and you get a much more accurate statement.

I believe in redistribution of wealth, but I call it what it is: redistributing money from rich people to poor people.

The author dresses it up in fancy sounding (though completely outdated) concepts of "labor" and "capital". Economists also believe in Labor and Capital, they are the variables L and C in macro models. However, we don't believe that there is some eternal battle between the two, because, while people who only own labor would like a better deal for labor, and people who mainly own capital would like a better deal for capital, there is no "deal" to be had. Labor and Capital receive their marginal products, because at the highest level we live in a free market and there is almost nothing the government can do to prevent this. What the government can do is redistribute money from rich to poor. But this probably sounds a bit too socialist for some, so people come up with ways to dress it up in outdated economics.

So I would tentatively answer "yes" to the question "are we in this together...?" but with the condition that answering yes does not imply I support the author's bogus economics.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:49PM (#6870428)
I upvoted you, but I think I disagree largely with the sentiment you expressed. As one of those wacky libertarians, I'd like to defend (what I think is) the default liberty-oriented position. Disclaimer, the following is a series of value judgements, and not necessarily steeped in fact.

The argument isn't necessarily one based on 'more' vs. 'less' government, but 'Constitutionally prescribed' government size. The Constitution speaks of a small federal government, whose purpose it is to defend the rights of individuals from potentially abusive state governments. The Constitution places a higher value on individual liberty than efficiency of government. We see this reflected in separation of powers, an adversarial Congress, limited terms of office, etc., etc.

For many, we see the Constitution as the central governing document of our nation. We don't see it as perfect, in any sense, and we will readily admit to its flaws and faults. Some of us (self included) will even concede that we aren't adept enough at examining social policy to be able to say assertively that a Nordic model of government wouldn't be objectively "better" at granting citizens the liberties they desire. What we can say, fairly definitively, is that we can't have a Nordic model of government with the Constitution as it exists.

That isn't necessarily horrible, or untenable. We can get there from here. We can ratify, amend, and hell, even rewrite the Constution, using Constitutionally prescribed measures. There are, as I stated, many faults with the Constitution, but this is where it excels. Where public sentiment changes broadly enough that there is a clear consensus, it should be easy to ratify the Constitution to get us where we need to be. Where we don't have a clear consensus, it should be very hard -- and indeed it is.

The faults we see with the existing government are generally the faults we see where they have deviated from adhering to the Constitution. The Constitution prescribes transparency in law-making, and to that end, we have a generally open Congress, whereupon we can interact with our legislators and make our opinions known. However, to circumvent that, the president has recently been exercising "Executive Order", and/or delegation to agencies, who have lawmaking authority, but without the same degree of transparency has. If the FDA decides that they want to impose a regulation, for example, they can do so without the passage of a law, despite the fact that the regulation may have _de_ _facto_ authority as a law.

Similarly, executive order bypasses this process. That isn't to suggest it is inherently evil, as we've seen it used for both good and ill, and with varying effectiveness. Regardless, it circumvents (IMO) Constitutionally prescribed law-making procedures.

I think that most people, left, right, center or fringe, that the bill of rights, generally, should be treated as sacrosanct, especially where those provisions relate to the first amendment, religious exercise, etc.. People disagree on others, and that's fine -- where there's a clear consensus, it should be easy for the second amendment to be repealed. There isn't, so it hasn't been, so the government has taken half-measures (again, IMO) in an attempt to side-step the bill of rights in lieu of ratification, to appease their political base. The other, major flaw, is that people's beliefs are fungible. They believe that freedom of speech is sacrosanct, and would point to the first amendment as evidence of that, but so often, they would turn around and suggest that the second amendment is outdated, or relegate its provisions to 'muskets', without similarly acknowledging that first amendments should then not be applicable to digital media, telephones, or whatever other implements did not exist in the late 1700s.

As pertaining to capitalism, our stance is that true capitalism hasn't ever really been tried -- almost as certainly as we've had capitalism, we've just as readily had crony capitalism. In tech, we can readily speak to the abusive power of patents, and we all know for how long they've stifled innovation, been used to discourage new competitors and free market competition. Why we aren't all able to agree that most regulations imposed by government are done to similar effect is always slightly baffling to me, because they absolutely are. An early entrant to a new market is often able to transfer some of their economic might into political sway, making it harder and harder for new entrants to take either from them, widening the income disparity as well as the ability to narrow it using the free market.

That isn't to suggest that we shouldn't all act more communally -- we absolutely should, and it should be encouraged at every step, though never forced. I recently co-established a 501c3 charity to help mitigate the out-of-pocket spending that our teachers often undergo so that they can ensure their children have supplies. They're already underpaid, more often than not, and on average, they spend, out of pocket, up to $2000 a year on supplies that aren't being provided by parents or the school systems. In researching this, I've found what seems to be common advice that "the government is required to provide supplies, so you shouldn't buy any of them," and while that's said, I'm able to see both sides of this argument -- if the government is taxing us, and that taxes goes towards the foundation and operation of schools, then we've already paid our part, and weren't given much of a say in the matter. Contrarily though, I'd want to encourage more voluntaryism in ensuring that teachers aren't operating at a loss in order to educate our children; we should free them from as many burdens as we're able to enable them to be more effective at educating, which is their job, not procurement.

So, what's the answer? Clearly, we should be more communally minded, but many feel that since that communality has been mandated, and that their contributions to society have already been forcibly taken, that they are contributing, whether they like it or not.

Probably, the answer is somewhere in the middle, and I don't claim to know where it is. I agree that we don't currently have it, and our politicians (on both sides) pandering to their political bases isn't actually making us any progress. I don't know that necessarily a reversion to a smaller government gets us there either, nor do I know that a Nordic model does -- both have worked in isolated instances, but I haven't seen anything convincing that either would work well for us, here, with the people that we have. So, to the libertarian, what we're left with, generally speaking, is the Constitution... the rule book for how the nation is supposed to run, and it isn't being followed, and things are poopy. If we want to change the rules, the Constitution lets us, but instead, politicians on all sides are just cheating instead, and that clearly isn't working.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:28PM (#6870639)
Appealing to the Constitution isn't really a valid line of argument, though. The Constitution isn't the Bible. It cannot, and should not, prescribe morality, which is what should drive law-making; nor should any part of it, including the Bill of Rights, be sacrosanct. The Constitution, and its derivates the US Code and state constitutions, are authoritative only to the point that they usefully represent their constituents' morality.

> it should be encouraged at every step, though never forced

I think you'll find that most of your "wacky libertarian" buddies don't see the distinction between these two methods.

> Probably, the answer is somewhere in the middle, and I don't claim to know where it is.

I'd recommend reading this book: http://www.amazon.com/Talking-Strangers-Anxieties-Citizenshi... One of the things it helps do is explain how and why we should negotiate the middle.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by sanderjd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:40PM (#6870708)
His point (as I read it) isn't that the Constitution as written is sacrosanct, but that it is extremely useful to have a document whose rules are 1) executed as closely as possible in the present, and 2) changeable in the future. Otherwise there are no rules, and people are just making things up as they go. I tend to agree that this is the situation we currently find ourselves in, but I think a lot of the blame for it can be placed at the feet of the Constitution being too hard to amend, forcing the kind of (arguably) extra-legal pragmatism we see.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by dnautics on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:17PM (#6870897)
if the government fails to follow its own rules, then there will be a time when the people come to realize that they should not follow any of the government's rules, either.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:53PM (#6870777)
That is indeed exactly what I meant. That said, I think the difficulty found in the amendment process is an indicator that the founders intended the government to move far more slowly than it does, which leads one to believe they wanted less laws than more.

Just an opinion there, but it is (I think) a fairly well supported one.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by sanderjd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:30PM (#6871257)
I think you're probably right about the founders intentions, but I think they were wrong about the speed at which government should be able to move. It's not an easy balance, and there is a real danger of government being too reactive, but I think (like you, just an opinion) that the Constitution is too far the other way for our current society.

edit: wording

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:56PM (#6871091)
> an indicator that the founders intended

This is exactly the mistake I'm trying to point out. "The founders intended" isn't a valid line of argument. "Why do we eat bananas?" "Because the founders intended it." "Why aren't you eating a banana?" "Because the founders didn't intend for me to eat bananas."

> they wanted less laws than more

This works for you because you want less laws than more.

I think that the amendment process is difficult because there are a fuckton of Americans and because the founders didn't trust the states. (Which is also why they had a House of Representatives.) They couldn't foresee the consolidation of federal power that came later, which may have justified an easier process to them.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:14PM (#6871181)
> "The founders intended" isn't a valid line of argument.

Well, it is though. That isn't to suggest that it's the definitive argument or standard to be held to, but it's definitely valid. Justices sitting on the Supreme Court agree, though not all of them. There are definitely competing beliefs, but just saying that isn't valid doesn't invalidate it.

Regardless of whether we agree that it should be the prevailing theory, there are ramifications for its applicability. The House just passed (rather, extended, but same difference) that would, if enacted, ban the manufacture of undetectable firearms. So, we're in a legal morass right now that it is legal for me to manufacture guns at home, and it is legal for me to purchase undetectable firearms, but it is not legal for me to manufacture undetectable firearms at home. What does that mean? Well, presumably, the intent is to prevent me from being able to smuggle home-grown guns onto airplanes. By that metric, if I manufacture a gun that is made of plastic, but that has some metallic (detectable) components, am I in the clear? By the law, yes I am. If, however, those metallic components are detachable, such that I could still effectively smuggle the weapon through TSA screening, does that change the matter?

> This works for you because you want less laws than more.

Who said that I want less laws? I acknowledged in my original diatribe that more individual freedom may not prove to be the most effective outcome, and ultimately, the most effective outcome to win. I don't know what that is. Perhaps it is an application of less laws, perhaps it is an application of more consistent laws, or perhaps it is a more consistent application of law? My biggest gripe, for what it's worth, relates to the latter of those. I believe that the largest problem in our nation relates neither to the relative wealth or dearth of laws, but of their corrupt application. I would wager that many on either the right or left would share this interpretation, whether they know it or not, though I don't know how many would agree on its prioritization.

> They couldn't foresee the consolidation of federal power that came later, which may have justified an easier process to them

This is the statement with which I most disagree. I think that they very gravely foresaw this, and even went so far as to challenge later generations of Americans with the task of preventing it. Hamilton even advocated for this, on matters of efficiency, but ultimately lost out on the argument, though I'd argue that conflict accounts for much of the vagueries of the Constitution that we have now.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:21PM (#6871211)
> Justices sitting on the Supreme Court agree, though not all of them.

Are you the person I previously had a discussion about originalism with on here? I linked Posner for someone a month or two ago; might have been you.

/does search

Yeah. We didn't come to any agreement. :P

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:31PM (#6871260)
Was it me? Link me. I don't remember it.

Just so it's said, neither of us has to be right for our opinions to be equally valid. And regardless of whether or not we agree, originalism certainly has validity in arguments of law, we're just disagreeing with whether or not it should be the standard we hold highest.

I'm not saying that necessarily we should.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:36PM (#6871280)
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:54PM (#6871599)
Thanks. I remember it now. I don't know what to think of the idea that "political corruption" apparently comprises a non-negligible portion of my HN postings, and your pointing it out makes me aware that it is.

Probably time for a self-imposed moratorium.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by kefka on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:03PM (#6871115)
There are 'less laws'. It just so happens one of those laws is "FDA has final say on drug stuffs"...

And then they decide on the real laws. After all, congress already gave them approval.

Yep. Real transparency.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mogrim on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:57PM (#6871370)
> Appealing to the Constitution isn't really a valid line of argument, though.

Fully agree - because it's only valid in the USA. Assuming libertarianism has some value outside of the States, the fact that the Constitution (and the Founding Fathers) may or may not back it up is irrelevant.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:42PM (#6870714)
> Appealing to the Constitution isn't really a valid line of argument, though.

I disagree. Right or wrong, it is the document against which we supposedly make all laws. I'm not suggesting that we appeal to it as it is, rather, appeal to its defined measures for ensuring that it is kept current. Put simply, in football, they have a rule book. That rule book is what we consult on matters of the rules. Sometimes they get it right, sometimes they get it wrong, and sometimes the rules need updating -- but suggesting that we disregard the rule book while playing football seems naive. The rules are necessary.

The Constitution is that rule book. Either follow the rules or write new ones. Why is that so untenable?

> The Constitution isn't the Bible. It cannot, and should not, prescribe morality, which is what should drive law-making;

I disagree that law-making should be driven by morals. The Constitution, in theory at least, should work as a bulwark ensuring that minority opinions are upheld. Just as homosexuals are fighting for equal rights under the law because their moral values aren't shared by enough people, the Constitution is their prescriptive measure. They have equal rights because they are people, and deserving of equal rights, regardless of their or others' morals. We're still niggling over the details of it, but ultimately, I have hope and faith that gay rights will eventually achieve parity in law that the rest of us enjoy.

> nor should any part of it, including the Bill of Rights, be sacrosanct.

... until it is ratified, I disagree.

> The Constitution, and its derivates the US Code and state constitutions, are authoritative only to the point that they usefully represent their constituents' morality.

Perhaps I'm misinterpreting the statement, but by your argument, gays shouldn't have rights if the majority of constituents agree they shouldn't? I disagree here, and I would expect that every minority group should. It's very possible that I've misconstrued your intent though, so please feel free to correct me if I'm in error.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:06PM (#6871139)
> The Constitution, in theory at least, should work as a bulwark ensuring that minority opinions are upheld.

That's not what pluralism is. The key is in ensuring that minority opinions are heard and reasonably considered, not "upheld".

> They have equal rights because they are people, and deserving of equal rights, regardless of their or others' morals.

And yet, that's not actually what the Constitution says. Nothing in the Constitution actually says that people have equal rights. That's why, when they tried to write an amendment to ban gay marriage, they didn't have to include any deletions, because it would have contradicted nothing.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Marriage_Amendment

This is the example you chose; it's not helping your case. :P

Edited to add:

> suggesting that we disregard the rule book while playing football seems naive

That's not what I'm doing at all. I'm saying that "because Constitution" is not the right reason to write law. Gays shouldn't have rights because the Constitution says they should; it doesn't. Gays should have rights because we say they should, and if the Constitution doesn't, then maybe it fucking should.

> Perhaps I'm misinterpreting the statement, but by your argument, gays shouldn't have rights if the majority of constituents agree they shouldn't? I disagree here, and I would expect that every minority group should. It's very possible that I've misconstrued your intent though, so please feel free to correct me if I'm in error.

Your error is that you think moral opinion is static.

If the majority is wrong, then we (1) act to protect the minority and (2) convince the majority that they are wrong. Not sure if you noticed, but the last several years have been full of "LOOK! GAY PEOPLE ARE NOT EVIL! ISNT THAT GREAT!". This is part of the process.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:28PM (#6871247)
> That's not what pluralism is. The key is in ensuring that minority opinions are heard and reasonably considered, not "upheld".

I disagree, but only slightly. Civil liberties are upheld on Constitutionality, on strict (or in today's society, intermediate) scrutiny. This means that the rights of minorities are to be upheld, unless there's a really damn good reason why they shouldn't be. Religious freedom is held fairly paramount in this country, but if I established a religion that allowed me to kill others, it would not be, because of its conflict in relation to the rights of others; it wouldn't uphold even strict scrutiny. However, in regards to gay marriage, the Winstead case was upheld because the state could not even issue plausibility of a rational basis for why the rights of gays should be curtailed. In short, it didn't harm anyone, and as such, the state could not curtail her civil liberties on grounds of Constitutionality.

> Nothing in the Constitution actually says that people have equal rights.

The fourteenth amendment says exactly that, actually. "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."

> That's why, when they tried to write an amendment to ban gay marriage, they didn't have to include any deletions, because it would have contradicted nothing.

That's not really why. I've got another very long argument on here about this subject, but in short, the legal theory behind that is implied repeal, or "leges posteriores priores contrarias abrogant", which means that newer laws supersede older laws where they conflict with each other. As a result, a new amendment needn't specifically repeal a prior provision of the Constitution to have full weight.

> Gays should have rights because we say they should, and if the Constitution doesn't, then maybe it fucking should.

I disagree that it doesn't, but if it should (and I agree that it should), there's a ratification process for that, which means that it can.

> Your error is that you think moral opinion is static.

Respectfully, I disagree there completely.

> but the last several years have been full of "LOOK! GAY PEOPLE ARE NOT EVIL! ISNT THAT GREAT!"

And the problem is that the Constitution has been inequally applied for so long that we even had to. It should have been de facto applied as a matter of course that of course they have the right to marry. The problem is that, for too long, people weren't advocating for gay rights because they had moral objection to homosexuality. Whether or not someone is uncomfortable with someone else's sex life should not give them the authority to disallow them from exercising that behavior in whatever they see fit.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:39PM (#6871302)
> The fourteenth amendment says exactly that, actually.

Depressingly, I actually checked. And I somehow kept skipping over the Fourteenth and reading the Fifteenth, even after I didn't believe it and double checked.

Welp, that kinda fractures my response. :P

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:46PM (#6871327)
There's a lot to be said that the fourteenth wasn't included in either the original Constitution or the original bill of rights, so your point isn't entirely without merit, nor does it go unheard.

There's no person alive who could seriously suggest that the Constitution, either as originally written or as it currently exists, is a perfect document. Anybody suggesting otherwise should be immediately disregarded, IMO, but as I said, it prescribes its own medicine, so where it does fail, the remedy has, at least historically, been fairly straightforward.

It is precisely because it has been amended so well in the past, and that amendments like the federal marriage act have failed, that I hold so much faith in it is a document that can persist.

That said, I think it speaks well of the validity to the Constitution's "living document" mantra that it was indeed added when it needed to be.

It's also another point on original intent, because if you look at other documents of the era, it gives the impression that it was tacitly included, if not explicitly. My (entirely baseless) suspicion is that it was either accidentally omitted, or withheld due to the conflict of slavery its express declaration would have posed.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gnaffle on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:07PM (#6871417)
> As pertaining to capitalism, our stance is that true capitalism hasn't ever really been tried

In some sense, when I hear this argument, I'm reminded by the claim of some Marxists, that you shouldn't conclude that communism doesn't work just becuase it failed in so many countries, after all they didn't implement the communist ideal properly!

As you say, I think neither extreme will ever work well as long as we humans are who we are.

When corporations pour money into politics like they do today, couldn't you say that it's just true capitalism working its way as "intended"? Would this problem become worse or better if we removed campaign funding regulations and?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:28PM (#6871501)
> that you shouldn't conclude that communism doesn't work[...]

I haven't concluded that, and as I think I conceded in the original post (or at least somewhere anyway), I'm not entirely convinced that we've discovered what the true path forward is. Regardless, I agree that there hasn't been a fair application of communism, where both its recipients and its administrators were all held to equal benefit.

> couldn't you say that it's just true capitalism working its way as "intended"?

Well, no, and for two reasons. Either the money shouldn't matter, and no amount of money poured into democracy shouldn't have any bearing on legislation, or the results of said legislation shouldn't contradict the tenets of the Constitution, and would be subject to the same degree of public scrutiny that all laws do.

The former is obviously not true because politicians are corruptible, which is a situation that is potentially not fixable. The latter is obviously not true because it isn't primarily legislation that money buys, but regulation. The regulations imposed by the hundreds of federal agencies aren't done in public, they're simply bought, paid for, and then enacted without public input or scrutiny, to the advantage of those that paid for them.

In short, I think what you implied is that the problem with communism is its unfair application. I would agree with that, and further assert that unfair application, or put more bluntly, corruption, is the only big problem with capitalism as well.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gnaffle on Sunday December 08, 2013 @06:34PM (#6872009)
My implication was that the problem with both communism and capitalism (at their extremes) can only work well under circumstances that aren't met in real life (because humans are what we are). As you say, there are no easy answers, especially so when we face problems that require global cooperation.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bmelton on Sunday December 08, 2013 @06:40PM (#6872038)
I don't think I stated myself well. I understood your point -- Mine is that I don't think there's any system that's necessarily going to work better than either of those so long as there are irrational actors, so we should pick one (we already have chosen capitalism, within the constraints of a federal republic) and try to enforce fairness at every step.

We aren't doing a good job of that now, but ultimately, I see that unfairness as the graven flaw in any system, and more responsible for fault than the system itself (usually).

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by enraged_camel on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:53PM (#6870775)
>>The Constitution speaks of a small federal government, whose purpose it is to defend the rights of individuals from potentially abusive state governments.

The Constitution was written at a time when this country was a much smaller and simpler place. As such, its suggestion regarding the size of the government cannot be taken as prescriptive for the country we live in today.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by dllthomas on Sunday December 08, 2013 @06:40PM (#6872039)
Incidentally, I think a lot of those questions are missing the trees for the forest - speaking in broad terms like "more government or less", "more regulation or less" is not terribly useful. There are tremendously bad ways to add more government and more regulation, and tremendously bad ways to remove them. One may have some bias in one direction or the other, but policies and proposals should be considered, and implemented or scrapped, on their merits. If we're going to be speaking in vague platitudes, then it probably makes sense to stick to a high enough level that it's not divisive, but it's not terribly useful for making decisions either way.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by dobbsbob on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:07PM (#6870849)
To defend the free market position though I don't agree with it, an evil party can be elected in those countries who could purposely mismanage the welfare state and destroy it. Then they point to the ruins and say look this doesn't work adopt our new evil system. Canada and UK try to do this whenever an ultra conservative local or national gov is elected. They can purposely fuck it all up with a wave of the hand which is why relying on government is risky.

Nordic countries also have strict speech controls and censorship which is why a lot of artists leave those countries. Banning films and literature is common

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gnaffle on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:35PM (#6871000)
Huh? When was the last film or book banned in a Nordic country?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by dobbsbob on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:25PM (#6871227)
2011 a serbian film. They only reversed 300 film bans in 2003. It is illegal to 'insult' religion there so if you're a critical cartoonist or author expect to go to court and defend your art from censors. The last book censored was Flemming Rose’s book “The tyranny of silence" and in 2009 they censored a stand up comedian for what was silly satire.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by gnaffle on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:15PM (#6871450)
Did that cartoonist ever get to court? And how was "The tyranny of silence" censored?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by chongli on Sunday December 08, 2013 @12:34PM (#6870358)
Can the Nordic model work in every country, though? All of the Nordic countries have trade surpluses, especially when you look at the per-capita numbers. How would this work in a country of large trade deficits like the US?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by justincormack on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:24PM (#6870616)
Its not really to do with trade surpluses. They have not always had trade surpluses, indeed they mostly had huge banking and deficit crises a while back, the surpluses are more recent (Finland's started with Nokia, which at one point dominated the economy and trade).
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by chongli on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:36PM (#6871006)
I was talking about trade surpluses in real goods. Banking (and other financial activity) is just a form of rent-collection that masks this effect.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by squozzer on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:05PM (#6870504)
I think we are all in this together, whether we acknowledge it or not. Bombs fall on enemy and sympathizer alike.

To me the question is, "Who decides the allocation of the burdens and benefits?"

That answer is obvious. And it's not impartial.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by rmc on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:02PM (#6870489)
Nordic model works if you have a ton of oil.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by ersii on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:31PM (#6870663)
I assume you're referring to Norway, when you speak of tons of oil? Norway is the sole proprietor and large extractor of oil amongst the Nordic countries for what I know.

Neither Sweden, Denmark or Finland extracts any oil - or so little, that it's almost none.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by bananacurve on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:08PM (#6870519)
We have that in the US, its called Massachusetts. Ever notice how no one argues for the European model?
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mortyseinfeld on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:25PM (#6870948)
I see a lot of libertarian and anti-government sentiments expressed on HN.

And I see a lot of leftists on HN that are surprised that this is the case. Why is that?

The question - and only question - should be what David Simon asks: are we all in this together or are we not?

Because all of 310+ million are not in this together. We, as individuals, all have our own dreams, ambitions, interests, and goals.

I see a lot of leftist sentiment expressed on HN - sentiment for the same old failed ideas that was the cause of the so much misery in the last century and to this day.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by g8oz on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:02PM (#6871111)
>>Because all of 310+ million are not in this together. We, as individuals, all have our own dreams, ambitions, interests, and goals.

And as a society you have roads, schools, hospitals, public safety, public health etc. Acknowledging common interests in public goods and following through on the implications of that acknowledgment is not the road to Stalinism that you seem to think it is. Life is not an XOR gate.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by saraid216 on Monday December 09, 2013 @01:42AM (#6873113)
> And I see a lot of leftists on HN that are surprised that this is the case. Why is that?

Heightened expectations of intelligence, probably. I wasn't surprised that it was the case, but I used to be a libertarian programmer until I got an education, so unfair advantage there.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by jrmenon on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:14PM (#6870547)
Not just the Nordic model, but even the achievements of some European countries (notably Germany) and Japan, would have been possible without US security guarantees?

Essentially the US/Nato is the main protector of Western interests, and American taxpayers ( + deficit financing ) essentially props up these 'regimes' - granted they are more democratic, and there is a great deal of autonomy than a traditional vassal states arrangements.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Zigurd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @01:54PM (#6870786)
That is a remarkable interpretation of what, in reality, is a situation where the US demands tribute in the form of onerous intelligence tie-ups that lost their purpose when the Soviet Union dissolved and treaties that spread bad US IP laws to places that have no desire to be screwed up that way.

We now pimp the "Global War on Terror" as a substitute, but some guys in caves with a few kilos of explosives just isn't as compelling as an industrial superpower with h-bombs.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by mogrim on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:05PM (#6871410)
Alternatively, NATO provides legal and moral support to the centuries old concept of buffer states - the US provides military support to stop the spread of communism, which is left unchecked would have reached the US isolated in a hostile world.

As a European (with a keen interest in history) I'm not ungrateful for US aid, but to suggest that aid was entirely selfless is incorrect. (You may wish to draw parallels with the French support that made the American revolution a success, a similar situation...)