direwolf
But what's going on here is massive, indiscriminate collection of information on people whom the government has no reason whatsoever to suspect of any crime. Not only that, the officer safety and evidence preservation justifications don't apply either. NSA surveillance isn't really comparable to conducting a Terry stop on the entire nation.
This is where the future of Fourth Amendment jurisprudence is headed, and how the courts decide will have huge ramifications for the future of privacy. So again, you're right that there's significant precedent that must be overcome, but it's by no means a done deal. Even some of the conservative Justices in the recent Fourth Amendment cases seem pretty concerned.
So by its terms, the judge's order only applies to these plaintiffs. However, if the opinion is upheld on appeal (see below), it seems unlikely that the NSA would continue the bulk program against anyone without individualized suspicion. If the opinion is upheld it would indeed be very easy for anyone else to sue and get a similar order.
EDIT 2: Footnote 69 of the opinion confirms that it applies only to two plaintiffs, Larry Klayman and Charles Strange. Other plaintiffs did NOT get relief, apparently because they didn't prove they were telephone subscribers.
-------------------------------- ORIGINAL COMMENT
I have a law degree from Stanford, but I have not read the opinion in its entirety, so this is quite possibly premature. The judge ruled that the program is unconstitutional. Typically, the remedy for such a ruling would be for the judge to enjoin the program. That would prohibit the NSA from continuing surveillance against everyone, not just the two plaintiffs.
However, the judge stayed his own ruling, meaning that he will not issue an injunction at this time. He did that to let the government appeal, which it will undoubtedly do. In other words, the ruling will not take effect unless and until it is upheld on appeal. The case was decided in the District of DC, so it will go to the DC Circuit, and (potentially) the Supreme Court. So it could be a long time before it has any effect at all.
Regarding Zikes's comment, unfortunately a district court court opinion has little precedential value. It is not binding on other federal district courts, even within the district where it was decided. It may be persuasive, and it can certainly be cited, but it has no power to bind other federal courts. If it is upheld by the DC Circuit, it will carry a lot more weight.
At first, this is what happens. The other three astronauts breathe even more slowly to make up for Ayn's normal breathing, keeping them on pace for 8 hours of oxygen. But the other astronauts think this division isn't fair--there's no reason that Ayn should get more oxygen than the rest of them. They decide that they have a couple of options. First, they could all start breathing normally in the hopes that Ayn would start moderating her breathing in response. It would turn the spaceship into a contest of who blinks first, and if no one blinked soon enough, all of them would die. Second, they could kill Ayn, but they believe murder is immoral. They think Ayn's behavior is unfair, but killing is worse, so they don't do it.
Instead, the other three astronauts come up with another option. They vote on and accept the moderated breathing policy for everyone in the spaceship. Ayn refuses to participate in the vote. The other three astronauts unanimously elect one of them--we'll call him Big Brother--to regulate the use of oxygen. Big Brother keeps track of everyone's breathing and can slap people in the face if they don't breathe at the agreed-upon rate. The rules allow any three of the astronauts to vote out the oxygen regulator if he doesn't do a good job, or doesn't comply with the breathing regulations himself. Ayn might not like breathing slowly, but she likes getting slapped in the face less, so she moderates her breathing.
But now Ayn is upset. She argues forcefully that she's a bold risk-taker and that society should incentivize her risk-taking. She took a risk and breathed normally, taking what she wanted even though it created a possibility that the other astronauts would do so as well, which would kill them all. She points out that Big Brother has made some mistakes--he's miscalculated the breathing rate a couple of times and slapped people when they didn't deserve it. She argues for the deregulation of oxygen and the return of the free market. Who's right: Ayn or Big Brother? Neither is perfect, but I'll take Big Brother. The alternative is a game of chicken where the stakes are everyone's lives.
As for this example being contrived, let's change it slightly. Let's say 7 billion people are born onto a planet. This planet has limited drinkable water, breathable air, arable land, and combustible material. We can either let people use those resources however they please, risking the resources' eventual pollution, overuse, and depletion, or we can establish systems to regulate use so that they will be available to everyone for for the foreseeable future. If we don't regulate their use, we can get iPods at slightly cheaper prices, at least in the short term. The point is that people will take what they want and cut corners to make money, even if endangers the health of the human race. Yes, we're all in it together. Personally, I'll take the sustainability of the planet over cheaper iPods.
This doesn't mean that I think the government should regulate everything, that all regulation is good, or that our current system of regulation is optimal. But I think it's inarguable that some things need to be regulated, and that there is a role for government. Can government be inefficient, corrupt, or just plain wrong? Sure. It's fallible, just like any human creation (including private entities). But we need it.
That second example is more akin to taking antibiotics. If we accept that killing microbes is wrong, and accept your argument that using antibiotics is moral because it's legitimate self-defense, we have a problem. Antibiotics kill a lot more than just the invading bacteria. So does radiation and chemotherapy. In fact, they kill a lot of microbes who live in a symbiotic relationship with me and live in my body because they help me break down food or fight infections.
The point is, things are a lot more complicated than simply saying that all forms of killing are immoral. At some point we have to accept that there is an ordering of life forms, and killing some of them to save ourselves is acceptable. If we don't, using antibiotics, chemotherapy, radiation, or other similar forms of care crucial to modern medicine is immoral. Once we accept that not all killing is wrong, it becomes an issue of line-drawing.