News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:39PM (#6871018)
the NAP is in effect. it's just me and you in the forest, and there's one apple tree. you "own" the apple tree. I am starving, and I "steal" an apple from your tree.

who initiated the aggression?

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @02:45PM (#6871042)
There's no need to quibble about "lifeboat scenarios". You can come up with countless scenarios where there needs to be an "exception" to the NAP, but that's pointless, and a waste of time. It changes nothing about NAP itself, or its basis.

You'll break a rule when you have to, and that's it. It's very simple. If you're in the desert, dying of thirst and someone comes along and starts trying to force you to pay a ridiculous price for some water, then of course you'll do whatever you can to get some. But no sane, independent, objective "court" would punish you for that.

For a clearer picture, start coming up with scenarios where you could adhere to the NAP with zero effort at all.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @04:38PM (#6871537)
>> You'll break a rule when you have to, and that's it. It's very simple. If you're in the desert, dying of thirst and someone comes along and starts trying to force you to pay a ridiculous price for some water, then of course you'll do whatever you can to get some. But no sane, independent, objective "court" would punish you for that.

Then the NAP is not the whole of the law, or necessarily even a useful starting point.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:23PM (#6871712)
Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Sunday December 08, 2013 @05:44PM (#6871809)
I was already building a reply to that. What it seems to boil down to is "I know that I can't define my terms and I know that we don't agree about morality but god-dammit my one moral principle should still be the basis of everything".

Needless to say, I disagree.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:30AM (#6873211)
>> I know that we don't agree about morality but god-dammit my one moral principle should still be the basis of everything

Ah yes, "we just disagree on morality" is a classic avoidance-technique for a Statist that refuses to accept reality. But actually, no we don't. Not if you're sane and not a sociopath. We've both got a conscience, and it usually warns us when we're doing something even somewhat wrong.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by Nursie on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:23AM (#6873507)
>> But actually, no we don't. Not if you're sane and not a sociopath.

Ah yes, "if you disagree with my interpretation of morality you must be a sociopath" is a classic avoidance technique for a libertarian that refuses to accept reality.

>> We've both got a conscience, and it usually warns us when we're doing something even somewhat wrong.

Not everyone's conscience tells them the same thing, neither does everyone's conscience tell them that the NAP is the root rule of the universe. Even yours doesn't as you've admitted in a variety of places.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:09AM (#6873165)
my assertion is that this is not a "lifeboat" scenario. property "rights" are, at their absolute core, a use of force.

to be a true libertarian, you can't believe in property rights.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:38AM (#6873233)
>> my assertion is that this is not a "lifeboat" scenario. property "rights" are, at their absolute core, a use of force.

Nope. Our "rights" are an idea, but one that's aligned with our "intuitive morality". Force only comes into question when someone is violating your property rights. If no one ever does, then no one will ever have to forcibly defend his property rights.

In other words, if someone grabs your iPhone and starts running away, you have the right to try and stop him because he has no right to take your property. It's all very simple when you allow yourself to see it.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Monday December 09, 2013 @06:23PM (#6877810)
> "intuitive morality"

> It's all very simple when you allow yourself to see it.

there's your problem. you're refusing to truly reconsider property rights as a use of force, and appealing to instinct rather than actually thinking about the problem.

to take something out of the public domain and not allow any other people to make use of the object is force, plain and simple.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by anoncowherd on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:58AM (#6881822)
>> you're refusing to truly reconsider property rights as a use of force, and appealing to instinct rather than actually thinking about the problem

You're skirting around having to actually hear what I'm saying and let it sink in. Do I have to repeat myself? "Property is force" is a nice little distraction, and I've been through this with someone else before. Really, property is not "use of force" even though defending it may require some.

But even if you do view property rights as a "use of force", so what? -What do you think that implies? Well, this will probably just get lost in our comment histories, so I won't expend any more effort on this.

Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a... by 21echoes on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:13PM (#6882922)
> But even if you do view property rights as a "use of force", so what? -What do you think that implies?

that a philosophy that is founded on "there are only two rules: property rights are The One True Right, and initiation of force is The One True Wrong" is impossible to take seriously.

> Well, this will probably just get lost in our comment histories, so I won't expend any more effort on this.

nice way to try to take the higher ground while forfeiting. it's okay-- I know thinking is often hard for libertarians.