Re:David Simon: 'There are now two Americas. My country is a...
by rayiner on Sunday December 08, 2013 @03:05PM
(#6871135)
The minute you institute property rights, you're forcing everyone to recognize and play along with certain rules. Classic libertarians have no opposition to government intervention when it comes to violently preventing poor people from taking their property. They deem it perfectly legitimate to coerce someone with economic threats but not physical ones. Its wonderfully self-serving for an educated class that tends not to have much in the way of physical strength to force everyone to abide by these rules that devalue physical strength.
To me, the only thing that needs to be said in this debate is that people, given the freedom to structure their society as they wish, have gravitated toward social democracy all over the West. They want everyone to be in it together not just when it comes to certain rights like property that libertarians like to pretend are handed down by God, but also when it comes to taking care of the poor, sick, and disabled and ensuring social mobility through education.
In my view, its immoral to create government to force everyone to follow certain rules, then deny people the right to decide for themselves what those rules should be. But that's the whole premise behind libertarian limited government.
To me, the only thing that needs to be said in this debate is that people, given the freedom to structure their society as they wish, have gravitated toward social democracy all over the West. They want everyone to be in it together not just when it comes to certain rights like property that libertarians like to pretend are handed down by God, but also when it comes to taking care of the poor, sick, and disabled and ensuring social mobility through education.
In my view, its immoral to create government to force everyone to follow certain rules, then deny people the right to decide for themselves what those rules should be. But that's the whole premise behind libertarian limited government.