News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by sjwright on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @05:52AM (#6558802)
A loophole used by Apple.

And Google, and Microsoft, and Adobe, and Facebook, and Oracle, and Pfizer, and Starbucks, and General Electric.

But Apple makes the headline. Normally this would be headline whoring by the predictable media, except that this is the BBC, and I thought Starbucks was made the whipping boy for tax evasion in the UK.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by riffraff on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:13AM (#6558846)
I _think_ the difference is google and microsoft are using a different loophole (double irish), which by the way wouldn't be closed by this change.

EDIT: to clarify: apple is playing with one subsidiary being resident "nowhere", whereas other companies have subsidiaries being resident in tax havens. The reform will forbid the former, not the latter.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by ra on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:19AM (#6558861)
So the headline should be, "Ireland to close Apple's tax loophole, but leave bigger one open"
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by glomph on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:55AM (#6558938)
That isn't usually how headlines work unless there is a stronger connection.

'Police catch one thief but leave all others on the street'

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by mcherm on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:24AM (#6559204)
More accurately: "Ireland will not close Apple's tax loophole; won't close the other one either.", since the article explains that all Apple needs to do is to declare it's Irish subsidiary to have a tax domicile of Bermuda (or anywhere else without corporate income tax) and Apple's current loophole remains intact.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by raverbashing on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @10:21AM (#6559779)
Exactly

There are ways this can be worked around (quite easily as pointed)

Nothing changes in practice

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by IanCal on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:48AM (#6558922)
The headline is accurate as it is.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by yapcguy on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:19AM (#6560123)
The new Apple slogan should be:

"Made in China. Designed in California. Taxed in Bermuda."

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by Ecio78 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:24AM (#6559002)
That's why the Finance Minister's declarations are quite silly:

"Let me be crystal clear. Ireland wants to be part of the solution to this global tax challenge, not part of the problem," he said.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by mattmanser on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:50AM (#6559054)
It's actually quite genius as evidenced by other comments in this thread.

People now think the double Irish is closed when it isn't.

And when another country publicly condemns Ireland, the finance minister can say "we've already closed one, we're working on it!".

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by yetanotherphd on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @10:08AM (#6559700)
I think that is unfair. Ireland chose to have a low corporate tax rate, a decision that can be motivated by many considerations. While this does create a loophole where companies try to pay corporate tax in Ireland on profits that, without careful accounting, would usually be taxable in other countries, this does not mean Ireland is in the wrong. If he is speaking in good faith, then Ireland should want to keep its low corporate tax rate, but fix the accounting rules that allow profits to be shifted from one country to another so easily. These rules are not necessarily within Ireland's control (I'm not an expert in international taxation, though I find it fascinating).
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by yapcguy on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:18AM (#6560118)
This is what Google is doing.

$4.9 billion of sales occur in the UK, which is 10% of global revenue. However, only $29 million of corporation tax is payable to the UK - that's 0.3% - because Google lies and says that UK sales are actually Irish sales.

This deception occurs because basically 99.9% of the work is done in the UK, but the final signature on the sales contract is made in Ireland. This is from a Google whistleblower who was featured in the UK press.

Of course, the Irish subsidiary doesn't pay low corporate taxes on all this revenue, because it happens to have HUGE expenses in the form of intellectual property royalty payments, which need to be made to Google Bermuda (or whatever other tax haven they are using to hold the IP).

So really, Ireland is getting shafted too, just like the UK.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by vittore on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:33AM (#6559520)
I thought they use dutch sandwich EDITed oh, it is below - double irish with dutch sandwich. oh I like this name!
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by gillianseed on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:48AM (#6559335)
Well according to a dutch documentary I recently saw, Apple invented what was nick-named a 'double irish with a dutch sandwich' method of avoiding taxes by funneling profits through several different countries for their different tax laws.

Microsoft and Google and a ton of other huge corporations quickly followed suit so certainly they are just as much to blame, but I guess this loop-hole is attributed to Apple as they 'invented' it (but forgot to patent it, what gives!?).

As to the 'closing' of this loophole, allow me to chuckle. The insane amount of money these corporations can avoid in taxes due to these loopholes means that they will remain in one form or another.

Corporations are controlling governments these days, might aswell accept that the dystopian corporate controlled future of William Gibson is pretty much upon us.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by jmngomes on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:38AM (#6559541)
And closing this/any loophole would also lower Ireland's attractiveness as a European HQ for global companies, which could do more harm than good to Ireland's economy...
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by Jare on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:49AM (#6560314)
It may hurt in the short term, but it seems to me the value Ireland gains as a country from these companies is rather thin.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by Peroni on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:06AM (#6558827)
Apple is categorically the largest employer out of everyone on your list. They employ over 4,000 in Ireland alone and should this particular tax loophole impact that number, it would have a monumentally devastating long-term effect.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by madeofpalk on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:08AM (#6558830)
Not to mention Apple are the ones who 'pioneered' this 'Double Irish With a Dutch Sandwich' scheme.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by ry0ohki on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:21AM (#6558990)
Not to nit, but General Electric has at least 4 times as many employees as Apple.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by darrhiggs on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:00AM (#6559086)
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by Peroni on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:30AM (#6559016)
Globally that may be true but Apple definitively employ more people in Ireland than GE.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by josefresco on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:46AM (#6559050)
But Apple makes the headline

If this was 1999 it would have been Microsoft. If this was 1960 it would have been GE.

Apple get's the headline because it's generating the most profits.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by twistedpair on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:40AM (#6560246)
Apple is in the headline because it got you to read the article. Same reason most media outlets publish articles about Apple, positive or negative.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by creativityland on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:11AM (#6558968)
The trend for anti-Apple posts here on HN frontpage seems to be growing. Yet we see positive news from Google almost everyday. Anyone else?
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by icebraining on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:53AM (#6559065)
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by freehunter on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @10:09AM (#6559707)
Trends like this come and go. 20 years ago, we would have seen growing anti-Microsoft posts, and 10 years ago we would be seeing positive news from Apple almost every day. Companies fall in and out of favor, and the trend will always reflect that.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by frank_boyd on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:10AM (#6559123)
I don't know about other people, but since Snowden's revelations about the companies that partner with the NSA, all of them are dead to me.

And that includes: Google, Apple, Microsoft, Skype, Yahoo, Paltalk, and the rest of them on these slides.

They are letting us down and we should treat them the exact same way.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by justincormack on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:20AM (#6558986)
Apple invented the double Irish Dutch sandwich, and were a pioneer in this space. As usual Google and Microsoft just copied the real pioneer!
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by chipaca on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:43AM (#6558910)
AIUI the other companies on your list are using a Dutch Sandwich, which is not plugged by this.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by loceng on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:02AM (#6560022)
Let's see if Apple or others cut back on supply to Ireland of products - because they can make more supplying more to other areas they don't have to support the local economies of..
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by zimpenfish on Thursday October 17, 2013 @05:20AM (#6564322)
Not to keep banging the same old drum but Starbucks weren't evading any tax at all - they were paying exactly what they were legally obliged to pay.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by DanBC on Thursday October 17, 2013 @05:35AM (#6564356)
Starbucks were paying what their accountants said they were legally obliged to pay.

But we don't know if that's actually what they're legally obliged to pay, because it's weird and borderline and hasn't been tested by courts.

Vodafone didn't think they were evading tax, but ended up making a deal with UK tax authorities to avoid court.

(http://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/aug/18/vodafone-tax...)

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by rsynnott on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:35AM (#6559031)
In the UK, yes, but Starbucks doesn't do much tax avoidance in Ireland; Google, Microsoft and Apple are the big ones here.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by James_Duval on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:47AM (#6559329)
Typically, that would be Amazon, or the big banks. Starbucks is actually a new one on me.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by badman_ting on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:21AM (#6559459)
Yeah, I always notice that too and have long been tired of it. But ya know... Apple is roughly the biggest corporation in the world now. It kind of makes sense that they would be the focal point. Except that the "predictable media" as you put it have been doing this since long before Apple was so huge.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by DrJokepu on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:22AM (#6558875)
The BBC is known to be often critical of Apple. I don't know if this is a good or a bad thing.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by selectstar on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:35AM (#6558894)
If possible, please substantiate that?
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by IanCal on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:49AM (#6558924)
The BBC are, according to the complaints, biased for and against everyone. I see them as being pretty fair if everyone complains about them.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by gmac on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:29AM (#6559225)
Unfortunately that's pretty much the BBC's own definition of impartiality — as was articulated by its head of news a few years ago — and it's deeply flawed.

It means that issues or actors are given favourable coverage in proportion to their ability to muster or manufacture complaints. In important cases (e.g. around Israel/Palestine), this is not strongly related to the merits of the arguments.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by IanCal on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:01AM (#6559380)
This is not the only definition, but it does help. If they get complaints that they are giving the Conservatives too much and too little airtime then it's a good indication that they're dealing with them reasonably.

> It means that issues or actors are given favourable coverage in proportion to their ability to muster or manufacture complaints.

Only if they use this to alter their output. It's more of a contrast to the other situation where you get lots of complaints on one side and none on the other, which suggests (but doesn't mean) you're treating things badly.

If they responded to just the complaints (rather than trying to think about how likely people are to complain/praise each side) then they'd never allow a gay kiss on screen (the responses are phenomenal when something like that happens).

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by northernmonkey on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:47AM (#6559327)
Is that a hunch or is there supporting evidence?
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by ogig on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:32AM (#6558891)
Don't ask me exactly how, but Apple (and others i guess) manages to get paid by Spanish taxing organism by declaring negative results. They do redirect the benefits and payment of taxes to Ireland, where i guess that happens again. Spain pays Apple in concept of fiscal help, they might need some, right?

http://cincodias.com/cincodias/2013/05/22/empresas/136920666...

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by vaadu on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:46AM (#6559324)
Apple made profits outside of the US and is keeping that money outside the US. They are also in full compliance with tax laws. They have no obligation to pay more in taxes than the law requires.

The whining here smacks of envy.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by notahacker on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:57PM (#6560737)
The article here explains how according to tax authorities, a Apple's Irish registered subsidiaries avoided Irish tax by being based nowhere for tax purposes (earlier in the year they had the cheek to issue a corporate communication stating they didn't use tax havens...). Legal or not, if you think that's anything other than a perversion of the truth I have a bridge to sell you.

The apologism here smacks of someone that didn't read the article.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by maaku on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:20PM (#6560501)
WTF? This isn't about the U.S. at all. It's about making money in the UK, Germany, etc. and yet, somehow, most of that money making it to B.V.I. with minimal (<1%) tax burden.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by WalterSear on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:24PM (#6560521)
You think that maybe they should pay taxes somewhere else, though? It's not the US that's being shafted - everywhere else is, including Ireland.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by hackerboos on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:35AM (#6559032)
Headline should be 'Apple forced to use other Irish tax loophole'
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by DigitalSea on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:42AM (#6558906)
I noticed something interesting the other day on my bank statement as I pay for a LinkedIn premium account and it says, "LinkedIn Ireland" or something along those lines. LinkedIn uses Ireland to dodgily get out of paying tax too. Every major company does, its been a known loophole for a long time now.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by netcan on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:10AM (#6558966)
Google bills most non US clients from Google Ireland too. Obviously there are tax considerations. But Google (non US) and Linkedin genuinely have big presences in Ireland. They do account management, customer service, accounting, etc out of massive Dublin offices. Language, availability of educated generalists and willingness of European employees to immigrate to Dublin are also big considerations. They aren't billing to shell companies.

This is a genuine loophole that is being closed, not an intentional piece of policy.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by infinitone on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @03:32PM (#6561631)
Yup, even some startups do- I had a wire transfer from a startup from Ireland.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by Peroni on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:20AM (#6558865)
A more extensive and detailed explanation here: http://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/ireland/ireland-w...
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by lazyjones on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @05:45PM (#6562327)
The only efficient way to combat such tax loopholes is to abuse them. I'm not claiming that Apple or any other of these behemoths is doing it for that purpose of course, but smaller companies should do the same until it hurts governments enough to get them to act. They don't care about a few huge companies avoiding taxes as long as all small companies are paying theirs.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by wikiburner on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:10AM (#6559415)
Just curious - you hear rumors that the E.U. is considering clamping down on Ireland's tax laws.

Is there any truth to this? Could it happen anytime soon?

If so, does Ireland then consider leaving the E.U., or is Ireland's E.U. membership more important to those U.S. companies than the tax benefits?

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by sjwright on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @05:53AM (#6558807)
More information about the underlying tax loophole: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by IanCal on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:53AM (#6558933)
This isn't the same loophole, this is for "Ghost Companies" which have no declared tax residency anywhere.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by ma2rten on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:59AM (#6558948)
It says that the Dutch Railways company (Nederlandse spoorwegen) uses that scheme, which is interesting, because that company is state-owned. You wouldn't say that that company is interested in tax evasion. Crazy world that we live in.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by digitalengineer on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:21AM (#6558989)
Why not? Even our Dutch Royal Family have such constructions. (Via the palace and Guernsey).
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by ma2rten on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:40AM (#6559299)
Because normally the profits would go into Dutch treasury, either in the form of tax or dividend. This way a part goes to the Irish.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by jacques_chester on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:52AM (#6559058)
Tax reduction. Tax avoidance or evasion is a crime.

Edit: I'm wrong, see below.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by jiggy2011 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:02AM (#6559097)
Usually tax avoidance means legal , tax evasion means illegal.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by jacques_chester on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:41AM (#6559303)
Oh sod, you're right. I hate being on the wrong side of XKCD386.

Anyhow, this is why I prefer "tax reduction". It doesn't rely on correctly choosing between two synonyms :D

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by furyg3 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @05:14AM (#6564307)
As a non-accountant, what's the permanent solution to these types of race-to-the-bottom tax-shelter problems? I mean, other than all countries everywhere agreeing on taxes?

Increased sales tax paid where the consumer is located?

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by jellicle on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @10:30AM (#6559836)
The real loophole is in U.S. law, which allows Apple to make large profits selling things in the U.S. but not pay any tax on them through the magic of self-dealing transactions.

It's as if you gave all your income to your cat - whose bank account you happen to control - and then were able to deduct those gifts fully from your tax return, leaving you with no income and no tax liability. The tax man wouldn't look kindly on individuals doing that, but does look kindly on large corporations doing that. Odd.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by sigzero on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @10:36AM (#6559871)
Can you point to an article that explains this better? Because if not, I call shenanigans.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by Spooky23 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:27AM (#6560178)
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by pslam on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:11PM (#6560442)
Are you sure? This is repeated often and immediately refuted every time. Apple pays all its tax obligations in the US, which means paying taxes on sales in the US. The dealings in Ireland are foreign tax related to foreign sales, where the US is not owed anything.
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by grinnick on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:31AM (#6558889)
Is this going to hurt the (currently thriving) tech/startup scene in Ireland?
Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by patrickk on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:37AM (#6558896)
I would say having the big tech giants in Ireland has virtually no impact whatsoever on the Irish tech scene. There doesn't seem to be any movement of staff from tech giants to startups for example, or any investments by tech giants in Irish startups. Israel is way more successful at the latter, also at achieving acquisitions by major US tech companies.

Disclaimer: I live in Ireland, and have worked in a startup and interned in Apple.

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by hopeless on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:29AM (#6559224)
Yep, totally agree.

There's almost no interaction between the big tech multi-nationals and local tech scene. This is mostly because the large "tech" companies mostly employ finance, sales, support and logistical staff in Ireland rather than the raw technical talent of the "startup" scene

Re:Ireland is to close a tax loophole used by Apple by rsynnott on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:38AM (#6559035)
Probably not. As noted in the article, it just requires them to proxy to a company in a tax haven (Bermuda etc) instead of to a company with no domicile. Ireland is still required as part of the loop.