Can you please stop posting in this snarky and inflammatory style? The guidelines make it clear that this is not what HN is for. Please stop it if you want to keep participating here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
You're getting there.
China stopped reporting youth unemployment numbers. When stats are not reported, but a reasonable reason not given, then there must be some motive behind it. It might be benign, but i would always err on the side of nefarious.
>Nvidia stopped disclosing the scale of its business in Singapore last year
I quoted a line from an article that seemed relevant. I would appreciate you not projecting your opinion of what I thought about it onto me.
They didn't stop reporting revenue, they changed reporting so that singapore revenue falls under US revenue. This was reported by wsj a week ago. Here is a better article
https://www.wsj.com/business/earnings/nvidias-disappearing-s...
everything looks shady if you already go in assuming NVIDIA is guilty. but looking at the bill the govt just passed to disallow remote GPU access and their actions in this case and more, it looks like the govt fucked up by leaving open major loopholes and now they’re looking for someone else to take the blame.
HQ report at least ties it in to other US companies who are subject to the same export regulations, so at the very least, it would require a more coordinated effort between multiple US enterprises and be more of a conspiracy — thus harder to go undetected by US government.
Obviously, government regulators should have easy access to all of this data (including how hard Nvidia really tried to confirm final users for their products), so it shouldn't be hard to get official confirmation sooner rather than later.
This Nvidia bruhaha now starting looks like the infamous US export of cryptography version 2.0, and we know what happened to that initiative [1].
From the Fortune article [2]:
"Nvidia’s CEO was also a strong supporter of open-source AI models—many of which came from Chinese developers like DeepSeek—in the face of criticism that such models posed a serious cybersecurity threat."
[1] Export of cryptography:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography
[2] The Nvidia scandal fuels tougher China chip rules (November 16, 2026):
https://fortune.com/2026/11/16/new-commerce-rule-nvidia-chip...
Instead of providing transparency, they just chose to hide it. Regardless of the motive (whether it's - "stop bother me about it", like you are implying, or "we don't want you to look too deep, as we might be doing something wrong"), it was a pretty negative move.
Well, not really. Gell-Mann amnesia is the term defined in the essay he's referencing. But it's not the term for the phenomenon he referred to.
Gell-Mann amnesia is when you treat the media as trustworthy on subjects you don't know anything about, not when you notice that it isn't trustworthy on subjects you do know something about.
You are incorrect: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect#Engl...
I guess it's too much to hope that you noticed your link supports me and contradicts you?
> Why is it called amnesia if it doesn’t involve forgetting what you knew?
In your opinion, what part of observing that the media isn't trustworthy when you can check their work involves forgetting what you knew beforehand?
> Gell-Mann amnesia is when you treat the media as trustworthy on subjects you don't know anything about
> not when you notice that it isn't trustworthy on subjects you do know something about
Gell-Mann amnesia definition, from my link:
> The phenomenon of a person trusting newspapers for topics which that person is not knowledgeable about
> despite recognizing the newspaper as being extremely inaccurate on certain topics which that person is knowledgeable about.
You are incorrect here.
"Treat[ing] the media as trustworthy on subjects you don't know anything about" and "trusting newspapers for topics which [you are] not knowledgeable about" aren't tricky phrasings that only turn out to mean the same thing if you take a minute to think. They are the same idea stated in almost exactly the same words.
You can't display Gell-Mann amnesia by noticing that the media isn't trustworthy. You can display Gell-Mann amnesia by trusting the media. That's what I said, that's what wiktionary says, that's what you're repeating here, but you seem to believe that you're saying something entirely different.
What do you think you're saying?
The poster of the original comment, you are right, is probably just waking up to the discernment that yields the potential of Gell-Mann amnesia, but has not yet reached the full expression.
This article seems to me to spin otherwise pedestrian events as a coverup conspiracy, when from the bare facts you could say there might be a coincidental alignment. It’s exactly the kind of “factual, but our version of the facts” article that to me screams that it was written by a PR company.
It may be surprising to many people, but you’d be shocked how many articles in “respectable publications “ are actually PR pieces. There’s a whole grey industry of writers out there that can get spin into just about any publication for the right price.
There is a PR war right now going on over Nvidia.
It's hard to agree when the FT is able to charge more than pretty much any other wide distribution newspaper.
It has
Agree the title is sensationalized, but it is a strange move to be making under so much scrutiny:
> “It was probably a rational response to play down the role of the Singapore office in light of the export control rules — you don’t want to be at the forefront of an investigation,” said Robert Walker, a research fellow at the Lowy Institute think-tank.
> “But even if there is no nefarious activity, the act of masking the information raises suspicions and can be counter-productive.”
The gpu export restrictions were put in place because of national security reasons. It is significant to national security because that is the entire rationale for export restrictions - you disagreeing with the order or disagreeing with the premise doesn't factor into national security being the entire reason an export ban was put in place
Your recent SparkFun order contains 1x KIT-13233: FLiR Dev Kit. This item is export controlled by the United States government. By law, we are required to gather the following information from you as the importer:
1) Do you intend to sell or send this item to anyone in any of the following countries: Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Sudan, or Syria?
2) Will this be used in any military applications?
3) Will you be the ultimate end user of this item? If no, please go to 3.a.
3.a) If you are not the end user, who will this item be sold or transferred to? Please include full name, physical address, end use and confirmation that they will not sell or transfer this item to any party in Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Sudan or Syria.
4) What is the end use of this item?
5) Where is the location where the item will be used?
Response to all five questions is necessary before we are able to ship your order. If we don’t hear back from you within one week, your order will need to be canceled.
From memory another one was for my HackRF One.
Singapore is fine with its national security here I guess.
So why stop disclosing those numbers? Well, I think it's become clear that Singapore has become kind of like the Dubai of South East Asia. Dubai servers a purpose in enabling sanctions-busting to a bunch of countries, particularly Russia and Iran [1]. I think it's become clear that Singapore is filling that role with US export controls to China. That's why I believe NVidia stopped reporting the revenue.
At some point somebody would look at the NVidia Singapore numbers and start looking for the GPUs, not find a bunch of them and then and then people start asking awkward questions.
[1]: https://www.sup.org/books/politics/busted-sanctions/excerpt/...
Singapore is the nexus of trade for much of East and Southeast Asia. Companies use it as a shipping location because its laws are specifically tailored for serving that role. It's basically a special economic zone with a sovereign government. (Which, I will add, has also been a part of the US F-35 program since 2019.)
So much of this ongoing hatchet job is drenched in some of the most bad faith arguments I can ever remember seeing in US business reporting (not to mention the demonstrably false claims). Attempting to torpedo the most important company in both the US financial market and US national security, at a time where there is also significant instability in the market sector and global security around AI is equivalent to attempting to trigger a new Great Financial Crisis, and sabotage the Manhattan Project simultaneously.
(Not to mention, do people actually think Lori Huang was unaware of constantly globe-hopping black-leather-jacket-clad Jensen's extensively publicly photographed relationship? People are aware that in major christian faiths, divorce is considered a sin, and separation is the norm? (e.g., in Catholicism, divorce resulting in automatic excommunication from the church up until fairly recently...)
It's all so absurd. And it has been profoundly disturbing to watch the US old-guard press walk in lock step to frantically press such a blatant and insidious misinformation-driven character assassination, with financial consequences that can already be counted in the trillions.
Let’s call a spade a spade. In your book, a boss sleeping with a subordinate is okay if the boss makes lots of money?
The basis on which this is considered a moral travesty is built upon about half a decade of neuroses that have built up in only one single very specific corner of this planet that has 8.4B people living on it, and if you really believe that the yawning gulf between the power of a CEO and that of a multi-multi-millionaire VP of a multi-trillion dollar company is such an unfathomably dark and twisted power differential that it is our moral imperative to torpedo both the US economy and national security to correct it, then your mind is broken beyond any hope of repair.
Tell that to the former CEOs of HP, McDonald’s and Intel who were fired for just sleeping with a subordinate. No national-security undermining or corruption.
Also, your argument that because some action was seen as normal in the past justifies it now can be applied to some pretty horrific stuff.
I mostly agree with your general point that it's not worth taking down the US economy over, but you don't need to argue that extra marital relationships with clear power imbalance are good for that to be true. Not to mention the spy stuff.
I mean, in white bougie software land, many people are still only a couple of decades out from sex out of wedlock isn't a universal scandal. Most of the population of the planet still lives under that regime (to the point that people are literally executed for doing so).
I appreciate you being up front about this. I think a lot of Silicon Valley thinks similarly. Most of the U.S.–and the developed world–frowns on this. It wasn't just "me too." Countless Fortune 500 CEOs have been fired for the same.
My takeaway is Silicon Valley needs shock therapy. It has normalized all kinds of incestuousness and corruption and a religious zeal for the founders embracing both. The best way to do this is by making examples. Jensen is first. Sacks is next. The folks publicly tweeting that they think it is fine for a boss to sleep with a subordinate should be looked at as well. (Note: not convicted for expressing the view. Investigated for underlying crimes.)
The modern developed world is incredibly sexless, in constant gender war and dropping birth rates like a rock. Sex and romance is good and fun and shouldn’t be illegal.
HP and Intel aren’t “other industries” from Nvidia.
> if that didn’t actually happen there’s just nothing wrong with it
There is. It creates massive liability for everyone.
> modern developed world is incredibly sexless
Nobody has an issue with peers sleeping with each other. And disclosed relationships are a thing.
Secret affairs with the boss are a problem beyond prudishness. Exhibit A: Jensen Huang fucking a smuggler and possible CCP asset.
> Sex and romance is good and fun and shouldn’t be illegal
Jensen won’t go to jail for sleeping with an employee. He’s just been fired.
What he may go to jail for is corruption and treason.
If he knowingly enabled smuggling or evading trade restrictions that’s completely different. But again, sleeping with a CEO is different from enabling smuggling.
Fair enough, sorry. I was trying to illustrate why secret affairs by executives manufacture risk where there previously was none.
In this case, Jensen bumbled into a massively compromising position. Then he may have corruptly quashed an investigation into it at Commerce.
> Liability is a very broad theoretical, if there is no wrongdoing like coercion or favouritism there is no actual problem
Not how the last decades of litigation has gone! Have an affair with one report, and all the others can convince any jury in America that the reason they didn’t get anything is because they spurned advances.
The solution you're suggesting is that we protect the economy by protecting bad behaviour by CEOs, because it could be bad for the economy.
What?
It becomes self fulfilling.
A lot of people think corporate decisions should be based on how well he leads the company, not what he does in his personal sex life.
If he shared any secrets or did anything illegal, that is relevant. It seems like the board and world is proactively acting based on controversy and possibility, not on the fact of what actually happened.
So firing him for that sounds like puritan nannies intruding on personal matters. The absolute last thing I want is corporate policy bullshit intruding even more on our personal lives than it already does.
When the lawsuits start rolling in, and shareholder cash goes to $900/hr corporate lawyers in a mud slinging disaster arguing over how person X got fired, promoted, got a raise because of relationship with the boss --- and it goes rapidly downhill from there to retribution --- you'll also have a policy of same like everywhere else to protect your own company.
By then it's not a personal issue. It's a business issue.
By then noise from puritanical whiners will be noise in the background radiation of noise where you are concerned.
You'll be thinking about why moron guy X couldn't keep his pants zipped up at work which then blew a hole in team(s) around pay/raises/firing i.e. concrete legal actions you can't easily repair. Then the money, then the reputation damage... heck you could end up being the biggest puritanical whiner of them all.
Half a decade? I was taught this was wrong when I took my first job over 30 years ago.
This is a popular mantra in Silicon Valley right now. It isn't true.
The CEO's of HP, McDonald's and Intel were fired for sleeping with subordinates. Hell, Jensen has been fired for sleeping with customers and subordinates.
> big companies can protect themselves against these gossip to protect their interests
To protect management's interests. And sure. If the Board helps cover it up, that turns from securities liability to potential fraud.
That seems to me an apt description of your own writing. What precisely are you contesting? The affairs, plural, at least one of which involved a direct report? The widely reported ties to the chinese state? The diversion of hardware?
Your above comment can be described as a bad faith hatchet job that bandies about emotionally charged allegations while failing to make any concrete verifiable claims.
Are series 50 of gamers cards export-restricted ? Because 30's and 40's are trivially unlocked into pro chips and China already mass sells them...
[1] https://claude.ai/artifact/KRkMPHEU2togX3K6WQecTY
I run a site that shows all public financial statements for free [2]. Looks like I might have an error with how I'm calculating the breakdowns.
Not making an argument for against allegations of smuggling GPUs through SG, but it's not widely appreciated how much data centre capacity Singapore is hosting -- its not just the logistics centre and bank for the region, it's the hosting provider as well.
AWS Singapore was the fourth region AWS opened in April 2010, and the first in Asia-Pacific -- before Tokyo, Sydney or Hong Kong. There are a lot of workloads hosted here.
When ap-southeast-1 added a third AZ we made jokes about it being hosted in a container ship anchored in the Strait, as it's hard to know how they managed the required geographical separation otherwise!
Thank you GP. I read HN for informed comments like yours.
Singapore has 1GW of DC capacity while neighboring Malaysia has 8 on track to reach 12GW in 2030.
https://www.mingtiandi.com/real-estate/data-centres/singapor...
https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2026/10/20/123gw-ener...
They'll try to spin anything they can find into negative news against Nvidia
- $104B: That is NVIDIA Singapore subsidiary external revenue and its 48% of NVIDIA's $216B global revenue!
- $19.2B: That is revenue billed to Singapore addresses in just six months, not annual sales to Singaporean end users...
The FT never claimed Singapore consumed $104B in GPUs. The question is where those GPUs went, something your numbers do not clarify. The current CEO ex-CFO is totally on it....
The 104B number is the external revenue of NVIDIA's Singaporean subsidiary in 2025. This includes any orders for GPU chips that happen to get routed through the Singapore entity. For those unaware, end customers generally don't by anything from NVIDIA. Customers by NVIDIA GPUs through a large network of OEMs/ODMs and resellers. Many of the largest companies in this network are based in east asia (eg. Wistron, Foxconn, Asus, Lenovo) and when your local hyperscalar makes a server order, one of these OEMs places an order to NVIDIA for GPUs. Because of this much of this revenue likely comes from end customers all over the world, including the US.
In fact, in one of the 2025 earnings calls NVIDIA stated that 99% of the singapore entity's revenue for export-restricted chips came from the US.
It's a little bit difficult to untangle exactly how much of NVIDIA's revenue came from end customers in the Singapore in any given year. In 2025 it looks to be about 19B. That might be unreasonable for a country singapore's size, but it's certainly not half of NVIDIA's revenue.