everything looks shady if you already go in assuming NVIDIA is guilty. but looking at the bill the govt just passed to disallow remote GPU access and their actions in this case and more, it looks like the govt fucked up by leaving open major loopholes and now they’re looking for someone else to take the blame.
HQ report at least ties it in to other US companies who are subject to the same export regulations, so at the very least, it would require a more coordinated effort between multiple US enterprises and be more of a conspiracy — thus harder to go undetected by US government.
Obviously, government regulators should have easy access to all of this data (including how hard Nvidia really tried to confirm final users for their products), so it shouldn't be hard to get official confirmation sooner rather than later.
This Nvidia bruhaha now starting looks like the infamous US export of cryptography version 2.0, and we know what happened to that initiative [1].
From the Fortune article [2]:
"Nvidia’s CEO was also a strong supporter of open-source AI models—many of which came from Chinese developers like DeepSeek—in the face of criticism that such models posed a serious cybersecurity threat."
[1] Export of cryptography:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography
[2] The Nvidia scandal fuels tougher China chip rules (November 16, 2026):
https://fortune.com/2026/11/16/new-commerce-rule-nvidia-chip...
Instead of providing transparency, they just chose to hide it. Regardless of the motive (whether it's - "stop bother me about it", like you are implying, or "we don't want you to look too deep, as we might be doing something wrong"), it was a pretty negative move.
Well, not really. Gell-Mann amnesia is the term defined in the essay he's referencing. But it's not the term for the phenomenon he referred to.
Gell-Mann amnesia is when you treat the media as trustworthy on subjects you don't know anything about, not when you notice that it isn't trustworthy on subjects you do know something about.
You are incorrect: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect#Engl...
I guess it's too much to hope that you noticed your link supports me and contradicts you?
> Why is it called amnesia if it doesn’t involve forgetting what you knew?
In your opinion, what part of observing that the media isn't trustworthy when you can check their work involves forgetting what you knew beforehand?
> Gell-Mann amnesia is when you treat the media as trustworthy on subjects you don't know anything about
> not when you notice that it isn't trustworthy on subjects you do know something about
Gell-Mann amnesia definition, from my link:
> The phenomenon of a person trusting newspapers for topics which that person is not knowledgeable about
> despite recognizing the newspaper as being extremely inaccurate on certain topics which that person is knowledgeable about.
You are incorrect here.
"Treat[ing] the media as trustworthy on subjects you don't know anything about" and "trusting newspapers for topics which [you are] not knowledgeable about" aren't tricky phrasings that only turn out to mean the same thing if you take a minute to think. They are the same idea stated in almost exactly the same words.
You can't display Gell-Mann amnesia by noticing that the media isn't trustworthy. You can display Gell-Mann amnesia by trusting the media. That's what I said, that's what wiktionary says, that's what you're repeating here, but you seem to believe that you're saying something entirely different.
What do you think you're saying?
The poster of the original comment, you are right, is probably just waking up to the discernment that yields the potential of Gell-Mann amnesia, but has not yet reached the full expression.
This article seems to me to spin otherwise pedestrian events as a coverup conspiracy, when from the bare facts you could say there might be a coincidental alignment. It’s exactly the kind of “factual, but our version of the facts” article that to me screams that it was written by a PR company.
It may be surprising to many people, but you’d be shocked how many articles in “respectable publications “ are actually PR pieces. There’s a whole grey industry of writers out there that can get spin into just about any publication for the right price.
There is a PR war right now going on over Nvidia.
It's hard to agree when the FT is able to charge more than pretty much any other wide distribution newspaper.
It has
They didn't stop reporting revenue, they changed reporting so that singapore revenue falls under US revenue. This was reported by wsj a week ago. Here is a better article
https://www.wsj.com/business/earnings/nvidias-disappearing-s...