Interesting way to frame the constraints of reality.
It’s not far from what I’ve always thought. We simply will not solve these problems with broad self-denial. It’s an absurd notion, even if the monastic sheen of it sounds nice.
Reality doesn't allow for any such thing and wishing for it doesn't make it so.
Consequently, ignoring that reality will see you running head-on into a wall. With wildly devastating consequences: El Niño is just one immediate symptom, look at the AMOC. It collapsing will see about 70% or more of Earth's population wiped out. Along with the corresponding capacity for crop growth.
What you need to do is actually preventing foreseeable calamities, not complaining about people pointing you at them.
People in communism, or nearly any other socioeconomic system, also want more housing, transport, food, energy, and children.
Reality includes public opinion, which even authoritarian systems have to account for to some extent. So even if the reality is that climate change will be so devastating that it needs to be addressed by any means necessary (I don't know if that is the reality, but let's say for the sake of argument that it is), that necessity has to be sold to people somehow. And it's difficult to convince people to accept impoverishment if the truly major negative consequences of not acting on climate change are ones that will not happen for decades, as seems to be the case at least in temperate regions. To get public buy-in in such a situation, it may be more advantageous to figure out how to be able to sell the necessary changes in a way that is not accompanied by impoverishment.
Note how absurd the framing here is: "impoverishment" of whom and meaning what? US Americans, among the richest in the world, "falling" to the average? Who is supposed to pity them exactly?
Your idea of "consequences not happening for decades": WTF? So, so long as its not you who bears the downsides, you don't care? How sympathetic.
"Public buy in" is a chimera. You propose, they would buy into anything they're being told, so long as it sounds attractive to them. What's that supposed to mean?
Either, the public believes anything they're being told anyway, or they have to actually grow up and learn to know the truth themselves. It's not about whatever nonsense "political system", it's about epistemology.
As for the AMOC timeline: you could use your own rational mind to figure that out, but you prefer for others to tell you. Unless they tell you what you don't want to hear? Seriously?
> consequences of not acting [...] are ones that will not happen for decades
Are you aware of the movie "Don't look up"? Because if not, it might be worth a watch before reading your own comment again. If so, I really wonder what your interpretation of the movie was, since, to me, your comment reads pretty much exactly like how that movie plays out.
Humans aren't mindless animals, helplessly falling prey to their basic instincts. Claiming as much is an utter absurdity, that should become obvious when observing how selectively that deflection is being used.
"Lifestyle", convenience and "just not getting the long term aspects", those are simply lies. People know perfectly well.
The problem is, they've been taught it was OK for them to act like children, shirking responsibility. They're being covered for by comments like yours.
there are entire subcultures built on exposing the very "basic instincts" that a considerable majority of us humans fall for. these subcultures are called "religions." all of them attempt to control these "instincts" through concepts such as a "deadly sin".
some things pretty much are the human nature. we make miracles not out of desire for utopia but when we are under a gun. and this particular one is pretty big. extinction-level, I'd say.
They’re ignoring it because they can, and fuck you.
Trying to convince them is pointless because it isn’t about that, and never was.
All you’re doing is wasting your time and showing even more people that their approach works.
-Greek proverb you've probably heard before
Who are making their societies great again, I hear!
It’s a lie that decarbonization is going to result in material impoverishment. “Oh my things!!”
It hasn’t worked.
Unless you consider an alarm rising in families living in tents ”working,” but you’d be the only one.
We can have expensive “renewables” (they’re not) if, as Jimmy Carr says, “you don’t give a fuck about poor people.”
I don't know what you're getting out of so much lying.
The reason why comes down to exergy. In most cases, we can extract more useful work from a kwh of electricity than a kwh of fossil fuels. And people can usually get more food, more useful energy, more transport, and if they want more kids, in a renewables based economy.
Or you could get battery + solar and it’ll basically just work for a couple decades and then become recyclable. There’s not even a land problem; it would take less land than we currently use for the corn ethanol mixed into gas.
This would be true, if only it weren’t for the reality that everywhere renewables have penetrated the market to an extent worth talking about electricity has gotten much more expensive and significant deindustrialisation has occurred, as well as the loss of many small businesses that can no longer survive due to that deindustrialisation and / or those much higher electricity costs.
"Deindustrialization" has little to do with electricity costs. If you're serious please tell us the split between labor and electricity costs for an average car factory in the US, Europe, Japan, and China.
Coal power and even gas is unnecessary. Mixture of nuclear and renewables is the future. In developing world and China renewable capacity is growing really fast, because it genuinely is the cheapest way to generate energy.
saving our species
The earth will do fine, and probably better, once we extinct ourselves
This third rock from the sun will happily just keep orbiting on, with or without us, regardless of how much we fart old carbon into the atmosphere.
That's what I don't understand. Are you willfully misinterpreting this statement, or do you really not understand?
Collectively we have a fair to bleeding edge grasp of seismology, magnetotellurics, radiometrics, Gravimetry, tidal modelling, geological time, geological strata, etc.
Are you wilfully misinterpreting these things, or do you really not understand?
I didn't ask the question for fun. You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting the statement by rustcleaner. Why? Why not keep to the HN guidelines, and actually respond to their point? As a reminder:
> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
People that study the planet, as opposed to the biosphere.
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
It is very clear, to native english speakers at least, that was exactly the distinction made above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50515074
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
This is exactly the kind of useless pedantry I'm talking about! It's a completely normal way of speaking, which native english speakers should have encountered countless times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy
You might not like seeing this figure of speech, but can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?
For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.
Should humans alter the insulation factor to such a degree than they disrupt the very biosphere that supports them, that's bad for humans.
As far as planet earth goes, it's another wave of life crashing, with others to follow.
"The planet will not literally blow up" is not an important distinction for anyone.
But I've already wasted far too much time with your poor trolling attempts, please do your "I am very smart" schtick somewhere else.
You asked a question, I answered in good faith, and you've done little other than sling bile since.
Here's an interesting paper: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031992...
it's about something that may very well help a human centric biosphere .. but, you know, it came from people that make a distinction between planetary studies and biosphere studies in order to have a better understanding.
Past changes in climate comparable to current global warming did indeed cause global mass extinctions; the most severe was the Permian-Triassic extinction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...). However, life did recover ... it just took millions of years to do so.
I disagree, therefore that it is 'useless pedantry' to distinguish between the ecological damage in the short-term that will definitely affect humans, and the long-term where the biosphere _should_ eventually recover. If anything, the large amount of time relative to human-scale should make it more alarming, not less.
To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc). I do not particularly care about who "insisted you were wrong", that's up to you.
In any case, skimming through your recent comments, notice a bit of a pattern were our discussions get very argumentative. I wish you all the best, and please forgive me but I encourage you not to think of discussions online as arguments that you have to "win". Do as you wish, but I used to do this, and found it stressful and unhelpful in the long run.
> To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc).
I'd love to hear more about what benefit you see in de-fusing these ideas. The reason I even wrote my initial comment is that I see this brought up almost every time anyone mentions "destroying the earth", but I can't remember ever seeing anything productive grow out of this de-fusing. This makes intuitive sense to me: this response does not address the meaning of a message, only the form, which diverts the discussion from the actual topic.
So I'm trying to figure out what I'm missing. What is the benefit of bringing this up almost every time? Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering, so I still don't know. But I'd genuinely love to hear more about your thought process, because I really want to understand your position!
Stop the slander, re-evaluate your priors, reread your own comments - you were so keen to just keep attacking you missed your chance with me .. maybe later.
Earth was about 800 million years old when the first signs of life appeared, and it was 3 billion years old before multicellular life appeared. It took another billion years before things like animals and plants appeared (the Cambrian explosion), and since then there's only been like 500 million years of history.
Most mass extinctions have happened in the past 500 million years and have killed off huge swathes of life on the planet, but new lifeforms have come back, on a much shorter timescale than 4 billion years, because it hasn't had to start from scratch. That's what we mean by "fine".
I seriously doubt the majority of humans agrees that "planet earth will be fine" means "planet earth still has any life left", so that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.
You asked, and got a reasonable answer, which you rejected.
>that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.
Since you seem to have a notion of the "correct yardstick", please share in what ways Planet Earth will not be fine without humans (i.e. your candidates for the correct yardstick).
We already produce too much of virtually everything, and that's the whole problem.
I don’t think that can be the only reason. For over a decade PV has been cheaper than coal^1, but many of the people opposed to reducing climate change have remained staunch supporters of the coal industry.
^1 Yes, some caveats apply, but as PV/renewables continue to fall in price, fewer and fewer do.
IMO this inverts the real chain of causality: it's because carbon reduction has been connected to material impoverishment.
There's endless propaganda blaring how only endless growth can give us prosperity. If you even think about advocating for decreased energy usage, you want to kill poor people and China to win (I've had both of these thrown at me on HN).
We have a multi-trillion industry who has been pouring billions into psychological manipulation. IMO evaluating statements like the quote in this light makes a whole lot of things make sense.
So if you believe we can do without those, sure.
But we can’t.
Concrete is carbon emissions intensive, if you believe we can do without it, sure.
But we can’t.
Nobody said we should stop producing concrete.
As far as concrete goes, wood is often a good alternative. In Nordic countries we even build big apartment blocks from it. Cutting forests, building from the wood material, and replanting is a great way to remove carbon from atmosphere for a long time.
I'm not sure we "need" more people driving a 2.5 ton studio apartment 40 miles to work each way through the desert.