That's what I don't understand. Are you willfully misinterpreting this statement, or do you really not understand?
Collectively we have a fair to bleeding edge grasp of seismology, magnetotellurics, radiometrics, Gravimetry, tidal modelling, geological time, geological strata, etc.
Are you wilfully misinterpreting these things, or do you really not understand?
I didn't ask the question for fun. You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting the statement by rustcleaner. Why? Why not keep to the HN guidelines, and actually respond to their point? As a reminder:
> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
People that study the planet, as opposed to the biosphere.
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
It is very clear, to native english speakers at least, that was exactly the distinction made above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50515074
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
This is exactly the kind of useless pedantry I'm talking about! It's a completely normal way of speaking, which native english speakers should have encountered countless times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy
You might not like seeing this figure of speech, but can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?
For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.
Should humans alter the insulation factor to such a degree than they disrupt the very biosphere that supports them, that's bad for humans.
As far as planet earth goes, it's another wave of life crashing, with others to follow.
"The planet will not literally blow up" is not an important distinction for anyone.
But I've already wasted far too much time with your poor trolling attempts, please do your "I am very smart" schtick somewhere else.
You asked a question, I answered in good faith, and you've done little other than sling bile since.
Here's an interesting paper: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031992...
it's about something that may very well help a human centric biosphere .. but, you know, it came from people that make a distinction between planetary studies and biosphere studies in order to have a better understanding.
Past changes in climate comparable to current global warming did indeed cause global mass extinctions; the most severe was the Permian-Triassic extinction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...). However, life did recover ... it just took millions of years to do so.
I disagree, therefore that it is 'useless pedantry' to distinguish between the ecological damage in the short-term that will definitely affect humans, and the long-term where the biosphere _should_ eventually recover. If anything, the large amount of time relative to human-scale should make it more alarming, not less.
To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc). I do not particularly care about who "insisted you were wrong", that's up to you.
In any case, skimming through your recent comments, notice a bit of a pattern were our discussions get very argumentative. I wish you all the best, and please forgive me but I encourage you not to think of discussions online as arguments that you have to "win". Do as you wish, but I used to do this, and found it stressful and unhelpful in the long run.
> To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc).
I'd love to hear more about what benefit you see in de-fusing these ideas. The reason I even wrote my initial comment is that I see this brought up almost every time anyone mentions "destroying the earth", but I can't remember ever seeing anything productive grow out of this de-fusing. This makes intuitive sense to me: this response does not address the meaning of a message, only the form, which diverts the discussion from the actual topic.
So I'm trying to figure out what I'm missing. What is the benefit of bringing this up almost every time? Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering, so I still don't know. But I'd genuinely love to hear more about your thought process, because I really want to understand your position!
Stop the slander, re-evaluate your priors, reread your own comments - you were so keen to just keep attacking you missed your chance with me .. maybe later.
This third rock from the sun will happily just keep orbiting on, with or without us, regardless of how much we fart old carbon into the atmosphere.