I don't agree that "its obviously true that it was the right move". Instead of demoting Pluto, they could have promoted Ceres, and let Eris, Haumea, Makemake, etc, be planets too. Under that proposal, they could even have the category of "dwarf planets" encompassing them, it is just that "dwarf planet" would be a subcategory of planets rather than a disjoint category from them.
My Very Elegant Mother Just Served Us Nachos
I find people do this stuff a lot with space stuff because they're interested in it but don't really know much about it.
It's ultimately irrelevant to the subject at hand and detracts from the conversation.
Just expect to be corrected and "well, achually"-ed by people who follow the current naming system, especially in science circles.
With such “well, ackshually”s as “you didn’t really do any work at all when you were pushing on that tree trunk” and “you specified watts, but you really wanted to use lumens”.
But again, it is useful to classify all of these objects, and understand that some of them will bend the limits of our classifications—like many moons being more massive and larger than Mercury. But moons are moons, planets are planets, and it helps the list of objects from getting too large.
It very much seems like the definition was just shoe-horned to stem any more planets needing to be added. It would be interesting to know if astronomers walk the walk when it comes the definition. If I research when planets were formed would I get the date when their neighborhoods were cleared? Do discussions around large events that send debris into the neighborhood of planets correctly reflect that they cease to be planets until it is cleared?
Alan Stern said it best
>"We're going to call it a cow, except when it's in a herd." A river is a river, independent of whether there are other rivers nearby. In science, we call things what they are based on their attributes, not what they're next to.
>And the IAU definition is even worse, because it produces different categorizations for identical objects, depending on where they are. Get this — Earth at the same distance from the sun [as Pluto] would not be a planet by the IAU’s measure, because Earth can’t clear that zone either. I would say any definition that produces a result where Earth is not a planet under any circumstance is immediately indicted as ridiculous, because one thing we all agree is a planet is planet Earth!
>That's crazy. No wonder teachers and students are frustrated, confused, unhappy. It reflects poorly on astronomy, to have something so illogical.
https://www.space.com/12710-pluto-defender-alan-stern-dwarf-...
Now, Stern's broader argument is that we should not take into account the dynamical behaviour of planets. I disagree, especially since dynamics determine the static future state of any given object. I Take chthonian planets—former gas giants whose gaseous envelopes have been stripped away by the primary. Do we insist that they are still gas giants? No, we even came up with the transitory period when these planets are losing their gas envelopes.
To directly answer your question:
> If a massive object came into the solar system and perturbed orbits, caused chaos and collisions, then any "planet" with debris within its neighborhood would cease to be a planet.
There actually are (multiple) mathematical formulations for 'clearing the neighbourhood'[2]; Stern himself proposed one in the above-mentioned paper. Jean-Luc Margot suggests several more[3].
> Does it realistically outweigh decades or centuries of peoples intuition of the existing definition?
People's intuition for 'planet' in the centuries before telescopes were invented was 'something that moves against the fixed background of stars'—that is literally the Greek etymon for the English 'planet'. We have repeatedly, considerably renamed, retconned, retroactively reworked, revamped scientific definitions over and over again. I think planets will be OK.
[1]: https://doi.org/10.1017/S1539299600013289
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clearing_the_neighbourhood
Yes, “classifications of planets”. So Pluto would still be a planet. Then if you wanted a more specific modifier you could add it, but it’s still a planet.
Major impacts on Earth on a regular basis would indeed upset the applecart of planetary taxonomy.
> because one thing we all agree is a planet is planet Earth!
Of note, the ancient planets did not include Earth. I say this as someone who respects Alan Stern so much that my son is named after one of his projects.Is this classification useful for everyday life? Not at all, but looking at things from different perspectives for a change can be quite amusing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Solar_System_objects_b...
I wasn't arguing against classification, just that I remain unconvinced that the classification which IAU adopted is superior to the alternatives.
One problem with the IAU definition: it only works for our planetary system, not for exoplanets – with the end result that we have two different definitions of "planet", one for our system, one for everywhere else.
Now, of course, that in part reflects that we have vastly more information about our own system than any other – but, a few centuries or millennia from now, I expect we'll know a lot more about some of those other systems – we will probably have sent probes to explore the nearer ones by then – at which point people (or AIs?) will probably push to unify the two definitions. My own bet is they'll be more likely to unify them by dropping "clear the neighbourhood" from the our-system definition than extending it to apply to other systems. Splitting the common category of "planet" into two subcategories based on "does it clear its neighbourhood" works much better than insisting on two disjoint categories based on that criterion when you have very limited information on where that criterion is met.
If they really didn't want people to continue to refer to them as planets, then they should have chosen a completely different noun.
I'm 99.9% certain that the backlash would have been far greater if our solar system suddenly had dozens extra planets.
> But you never hear people explaining why the IAU insists "dwarf planets" aren't "planets" even when "dwarf planets" has several subcategories which don't share the "planet" moniker[...]
Because otherwise the definition would differ greatly from our historical classification. Since it is necessarily arbitrary, sticking close to our history IMO seems like the obvious choice.
Historically, the rest were already classified under minor planets (with the exception of Pluto) I.e. sticking closer to history would have been to not change the name and just move Pluto, which is also not what we did.
Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a dwarf body, which is not a type of planet" it would have still been unpopular, at least clear, no more historically inaccurate than coming up with "dwarf planet", and scientifically accurate.
What the IAU actually decided was "Pluto is now a dwarf planet, which should still not be considered a different type of planet". Since the sole positive attribute of this is it is scientifically accurate, it will have some level of unpopularity and be the cause of endless confusion even after everyone who knew Pluto as a planet is long dead.
I disagree on multiple levels:
1. It would still have gone over very poorly, because many people explicitly oppose the demotion of Pluto. Demoting it to a different category would not change the issue in those people's eyes.
2. I doubt that "[...] a type of planet different than major planets" would improve clarity much for the general public - if you've seen studies or similar, a reference would be appreciated. But changing the meaning of an established term would definitely be far less clear on the academic side (since every mention would be ambiguous before the publishing year and/or individual stances of the authors/journal are known).
3. "Historically accurate" depends on what type of accuracy we're talking about, because IMO this approach is less historically accurate because we'd be changing the definition of an existing term, without a meaningful difference aside from that (since both are literally named X planets).
4. I'd need an argument for why it'd be more scientifically accurate. Since we were unaware of most of the objects in our solar system when the previous classifications were created, it's again IMO much more scientifically accurate to create a new classification.
> Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a dwarf body, which is not a type of planet" it would have still been unpopular, at least clear, no more historically inaccurate than coming up with "dwarf planet", and scientifically accurate.
This one would have been even less popular! It's definitely historically less accurate when talking about Pluto and previous minor planets, though at least I can agree regarding the scientific accuracy.
> What the IAU actually decided was "Pluto is now a dwarf planet, which is not a type of planet at all". Since the sole positive attribute of this is it is scientifically accurate, it will have some level of unpopularity and be the cause of endless confusion even after everyone who knew Pluto as a planet is long dead.
It's definitely less unpopular than "dwarf body" and much more clear than "minor planet (no, the new one)"! And as explained, I'd argue it's historically the most accurate one.
This helps illustrate how arbitrary these classifications are. They depend entirely on what properties are included in the definition. The updated IAU definition is essentially reverse engineered to fit how they wanted to classify the planets.
Yes, those classifications are arbitrary, but then any classification is. If you want to consider Pluto as a planet, you have to include quite a lot of other bodies, which are all qualitatively and quantitatively different from the 8 (which themselves are in 2 qualitatively and quantitatively different groups. Or 3, depending on who you ask).
In the grand scheme of things, it does not matter and astronomers won’t care about the general public’s feelings. It is utterly pointless to get worked up about these things.
Why not? It's an arbitrary line, and there has to be a lower limit somewhere.
In the IAU definition, hydrostatic equilibrium loosely defines a lower limit for all planets including dwarf planets, but at the limits that's a fuzzy property that gets debated for small bodies. In fact Ceres is less massive than what some studies have found to be required for hydrostatic equilibrium, e.g.: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/PSJ/ad55f3 . The abstract of that paper starts out with, "The current IAU definition of 'planet' is problematic because it is vague and excludes exoplanets."
If we had more small planetary candidates in the solar system, they would have had to come up with some additional constraint to separate planets from non-planets.
I wholeheartedly agree with this take. I have something of a personal hatred of poorly executed retconning thus I present the following proposal.
For the sake of simplicity we should use even powers of 10 with earth as the primary reference point. Note that the earth is 10^24, mars is 10^23, and the earth's moon is 10^22 (pluto is also 10^22 and less massive than the earth's moon). It seems "obvious" then that 23-25 are planets, 22 or less are relegated to dwarfs, and 26 and over are giants (jupiter is a 27 and the sun a 30 for reference).
By that logic, if we want to consider pluto a planet then the earth's moon also has to qualify. I don't really care one way or the other but that just doesn't seem sensible to me.
It shows that the line of reasoning makes no sense, because any classification is constructed to fit some of our preconceived notions. Choosing a classification that builds off our social history is perfectly fine, as long as the rules for classification are applied consistently.
That is not the concern here. It seems to me that you're failing to account for intent. Classifications exist to serve a useful purpose. What I object to is mental gymnastics used to gerrymander a particular outcome. These things should conform to something resembling occam's razor - minimalism in pursuit of a generalized goal.
That is literally what happened - a definition for "planet" that is as minimal as possible, while staying as close to our historical categorization as possible.
Now, I know you'll object to the "while staying as close to our historical categorization as possible" part, but that is literally how scientific fields always approach arbitrary classifications. Without taking our historical use into account, there is no "objective" definition you can derive.
If I'm wrong, please give me an example of what kind of definition for "planet" you'd be happy with. But remember, it must not take into account what we today consider "planets" to be.
That's a big overstatement. It's how some soft science fields sometimes do it. You can't get away with that in, say, physics and still end up with useful theories, because your theories quickly break down due to inconsistencies. You can't design working scientific theories by committee, because votes don't affect fundamental physical reality.
Much of astronomy is a hard science, which is why this definition came in for pushback even from astronomers themselves.
Sorry, but this objection reveals that you either don't understand the topic of discussion at all, or you're arguing in bad faith. No theory in physics will break if you change the rules of arbitrary classifications.
Nice false dichotomy and binary thinking.
You're right that arbitrary classifications are arbitrary, obviously. My point is that you can't get away with arbitrary classifications in the context of hard science theories.
There's an example of a definition of "planet" in one of those Plait articles I linked:
> "A planet is a sub-stellar mass body that has never undergone nuclear fusion and that has sufficient self-gravitation to assume a spheroidal shape adequately described by a triaxial ellipsoid regardless of its orbital parameters."
That comes from the following paper: https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2017/pdf/1448.pdf
The Plait articles are worth reading, because they might help disabuse you of the notion that the IAU definition is a good one, and explain why it would make sense to have a better one.
Arbitrary classifications don't factor into hard scientific theories, so I have no idea how this is relevant. Or what "hard science theory" are you thinking of that relies on whether we classify an object as a planet?
> There's an example of a definition of "planet" in one of those Plait articles I linked:
>> "A planet is a sub-stellar mass body that has never undergone nuclear fusion and that has sufficient self-gravitation to assume a spheroidal shape adequately described by a triaxial ellipsoid regardless of its orbital parameters."
How does one arrive at this definition, without taking into account what we today consider "planets" to be? What principle of physics tells you that a planet must be sub-stellar mass, or that it has never undergone nuclear fusion?
You'll have to actually explain how this definition is any less arbitrary, but I don't think you'll be able to, because every useful definition falls under your objection.
No, not always. What you are describing there are shoddy classifications. I already addressed this exact point in my previous reply when I stated that classifications are crafted to serve a useful purpose. It is sometimes useful to hew close to the historical norm; other times it serves no purpose.
> But remember, it must not take into account what we today consider "planets" to be.
An arbitrary restriction that I do not accept.
> please give me an example of what kind of definition for "planet" you'd be happy with
I already did this in my original comment. I proposed an earth centric system that bins mass by powers of ten. My proposed range for planets was 10^23 <= x < 10^26. Hydrostatic equilibrium works well as a constraint to eliminate things that are clearly not earth like (such as black holes) but alternative formulations such as stipulating an acceptable density range are possible (such cross cutting subcategories might even be preferable).
Note that this would result in ganymede being classified as both a planet and a moon. I think that makes perfect sense given how similar in size it is to mars. In fact ganymede being excluded as a planet is precisely the sort of gerrymandering I object to.
The IAU wording is, "...has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape."
In this case it just means that the planet's mass and therefore gravity is sufficient to give it a spheroidal shape. (Technically the equilibrium is with the opposing push from the planet's material, which resists gravity's attempts to compress it. The result is a sphere, made spheroidal in real planets by rotation.)
Less massive objects like asteroids can have weird shapes, like the asteroid Toutatis which has a sort of dumbbell / unshelled peanut shape. The hydrostatic equibrium requirement prevents such objects from being classified as planets, as well as small objects that just happen to be round for other reasons.
This isn't really social history but simply classifying the objects according to intrinsic properties, which seems fine to me. This classification could be applied to objects anywhere in the universe without any problem.
The other two requirements are more problematic and arbitrary. One is that it has "cleared its orbit". Earth, let alone Mercury, would be unlikely to qualify for this if it were at the same distance as Pluto, for example. Rogue planets also can't satisfy this one, and we've observed those.
The other is that it has to be in direct orbit around the Sun, not a satellite of some other object. This excludes exoplanets as well as rogue planets. The rationale for this is that they didn't have enough observational info to say much about exoplanets, but that seems like a flimsy excuse. A good definition would apply to exoplanets by virtue of being theoretically sound, and not having been tuned to fit the way they were trying to classify solar system planets.
Okay, and how did you arrive at the hydrostatic equilibrium requirement? What law of nature told you that planets must be spheroidal?
You're only adding this requirement so the outcome fits your pre-existing desired results, since you're literally arguing for the requirement based on what objects it excludes. And what are the consequences of such arbitrary decisions, according to you? "You can't get away with that in, say, physics and still end up with useful theories[...]"
Do you get the issue with this line of critique? There is literally no useful definition of "planet" that is non-arbitrary.
> By that logic, if we want to consider pluto a planet then the earth's moon also has to qualify. I don't really care one way or the other but that just doesn't seem sensible to me.
Ganymede is larger than Mercury, so a definition that doesn't specify orbiting a star would have to include some moons, or exclude Mercury.
This exposes another problem with this kind of definition - it seems to make more sense to define a body in terms of its intrinsic properties rather than whatever location it happens to be in.
For example, a rogue planet is not a planet by the IAU definition. You'd have to call it something like a free-floating planetary-mass object. ("Free-floating" is not the right term either, but I don't have the research funds to come up with a better one.)
> I have something of a personal hatred of poorly executed retconning
Totally agree. Wanna join me outside George Lucas' house to protest the Kessel Run?
I think that's an example of coming to a useful realization while working through the process. It should serve to illustrate the importance of not attempting to engineer a particular outcome. If the earth were wandering the galaxy clearly it should still be considered a planet, no? And were we living on a body the size of mars that orbited a gas giant we would still be said to occupy a planet. At least assuming the goal is to classify things of a vaguely earth-like nature.
I think the more difficult question is what exactly qualifies as a moon. Anything orbiting a planet, including a smaller one? That seems perfectly reasonable to me. (Yes yes I know the barycenter matters.)
And yes, I think ganemede should be considered both a planet and a moon. That thing is on the same order of magnitude as mars. What useful purpose is served by excluding it as a planet?
a) orbits a star, and is not a star nor a brown dwarf itself;
i) a star is an object that is massive enough and hot enough to conduct protium fusion in its core
ii) a brown dwarf is an object that is massive enough to conduct deuterium fusion, but insufficiently massive (and hence insufficiently hot) for protium fusion
b) has attained hydrostatic equilibrium, that is, it is spheroidal;
c) it has cleared its local neighbourhood of 'rival planets' since its birth;
Ergo, Jupiter is a planet. It is a certain type of planet—a gas giant—but a planet nonetheless.Thus the suggestion for a new dwarf category — precisely because we do label times the barycenter is outside the star differently, as you yourself note.
You were so busy trying to “correct” me, you failed to address the topic.
The topic is pointless hair-splitting and nostalgia. It's like saying we can't ever use F = ma to describe free-body diagrams; we need a full relativistic per-particle QFT simulation to accurately and precisely model every single interation. That is impractical, at least for now. Likewise, we come up with classifications that are useful for the present time. If 'dwarf planet' is a catch all for all the small roundish bodies in our planetary system, then that's OK. I suspect the IAU will make things more fine grained in the relatively near future, anyway.
We can similarly say that “cold dwarf binary systems behave similarly to planetary systems, due to the proximity of the barycenter to the star, with the small”.
And that’s more informative than calling Jupiter a planet.
Like, in high fantasy, right, we have humans and elves and dwarves and orcs and all that. Are dwarves 'less' than elves? Are orcs 'less' than humans? No, they exist on a spectrum or line that is not less or more. Maybe less or more evil, maybe less or more aged or fancy. But in high fantasy you can't demote a elf to be a dwarf or a human into an orc. |
So, my proposal: Include all the dwarf planets in all the science exhibits, the kindergarten posters, the rhymes and meters. Just like with the upper and lower cases of the Latin alphabet. Sure you can forget that the dwarf ones exist, but if it's on everything, then that'll be hard.
Here's a quick one that I put like no thought into:
>Mercury, Venus, here comes Earth!
>Mars is next, let's shout with mirth!
>Jupiter's big, Saturn has rings,
>Uranus and Neptune make eight amazing things!
>Ceres, Pluto, Haumea too!
>Makemake and Eris join the crew!
>Sedna, Quaoar, Orcus, Gonggong,
>Dwarf planet dancing all day long!
So, again, sure, dwarves, fine. But just don't make being a dwarf planet a 'thing', celebrate them too!
Don't forget about Gǃkúnǁʼhòmdímà! Everyone forgets about Gǃkúnǁʼhòmdímà.
Even as a child I could figure this was BS - Cretaceous period dinosaurs evolved from Jurassic period extinct dinosaurs, so bird are not dinosaurs simply because someone decided dinosaurs were all extinct?
As an adult I find this has been rectified, but we're going backwards when it comes to planets.
I don't really know how the category helps anything, though. No astronomer would use the category in any work, they'd use the actual properties of the planet. The only people who might care are those publishing paedogogical material. Is it really that important that kids around the world all learn the same number of planets?
It could easily be taught a different way: there are planets, you can see these ones tonight with your naked eye, you could see these other ones with a telescope. I wish they'd taught me that instead of those silly pictures of the solar system.
Just because it isn't a planet doesn't mean it isn't in our hearts.
"The name Pluto came from the Roman god of the underworld; and it is also an epithet for Hades (the Greek equivalent of Pluto)."