News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by delta_p_delta_x on Thursday November 12, 2026 @03:50PM (#50474066)
A planet is an object that:

  a) orbits a star, and is not a star nor a brown dwarf itself;
     i) a star is an object that is massive enough and hot enough to conduct protium fusion in its core
    ii) a brown dwarf is an object that is massive enough to conduct deuterium fusion, but insufficiently massive (and hence insufficiently hot) for protium fusion  
  b) has attained hydrostatic equilibrium, that is, it is spheroidal;
  c) it has cleared its local neighbourhood of 'rival planets' since its birth;
Ergo, Jupiter is a planet. It is a certain type of planet—a gas giant—but a planet nonetheless.
Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by zmgsabst on Thursday November 12, 2026 @04:05PM (#50474269)
Their claim is that it fails (a) because the Sun and Jupiter orbit a common barycenter, and hence Jupiter does not orbit the Sun (or any star).
Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by delta_p_delta_x on Thursday November 12, 2026 @04:14PM (#50474376)
[delayed]
Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by manquer on Thursday November 12, 2026 @05:11PM (#50475059)
[delayed]
Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by zmgsabst on Thursday November 12, 2026 @05:16PM (#50475138)
Yes — their point is that as-written, it orbits a barycenter external to the star: hence doesn’t orbit the star, but they’re in a mutual orbit.

Thus the suggestion for a new dwarf category — precisely because we do label times the barycenter is outside the star differently, as you yourself note.

You were so busy trying to “correct” me, you failed to address the topic.

Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by delta_p_delta_x on Thursday November 12, 2026 @05:55PM (#50475584)
'In orbit around' is frequently used as short-hand to refer to a secondary with mass << primary, to a first order approximation. In the Solar System, even for satellite transfers, the effect of Jupiter on the Sun can and is ignored.

The topic is pointless hair-splitting and nostalgia. It's like saying we can't ever use F = ma to describe free-body diagrams; we need a full relativistic per-particle QFT simulation to accurately and precisely model every single interation. That is impractical, at least for now. Likewise, we come up with classifications that are useful for the present time. If 'dwarf planet' is a catch all for all the small roundish bodies in our planetary system, then that's OK. I suspect the IAU will make things more fine grained in the relatively near future, anyway.

Re:Dwarf planet candidate appears which takes roughly 280 ye... by zmgsabst on Thursday November 12, 2026 @06:06PM (#50475720)
We have QFT precisely because mechanics improperly categorized events.

We can similarly say that “cold dwarf binary systems behave similarly to planetary systems, due to the proximity of the barycenter to the star, with the small”.

And that’s more informative than calling Jupiter a planet.