News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by cmiles8 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:44AM (#50354310)
I would never let my child play contact football. The data is beyond clear that this sport causes irreparable life altering damage to the brain.

A lot of football players also suffer from mental health issues which, not to state the obvious, is likely not helped by banging your head all the time.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thrwaway73637 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:53AM (#50354452)
playing at nfl level and kid level is something very different
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by alistairSH on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:58AM (#50354537)
Yes, and?

It's well established that the effects of repeated head trauma are cumulative, with progressively longer healing periods, worse symptoms, etc. And that sub-concussive impacts also accumulate along with the concussive impacts.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by estearum on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:58AM (#50354538)
As someone who has had multiple concussions in other sports, the impacts in youth football are absolutely sufficient to cause concussions and more minor (but still cumulatively damaging) trauma. The fact that they're a repeated part of the game and not occasional incidents is very, very bad.

Requiring a child to play football should be actual child abuse, and even allowing it should be frowned upon the way that letting a child play with a blowtorch is.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thrwaway73637 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:04PM (#50354636)
there you said it: you got concusions from other sports. so why single out football as the worst thing ever?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by lkjdsklf on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:07PM (#50354696)
CTE isn’t caused by concussions. Hence the rest of their comment.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by hibikir on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:21PM (#50354932)
Due to the number of concussions per minute played. It could be worse (boxing), but it's not difficult to see how some sports are far riskier than others
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by toast0 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:28PM (#50355066)
Certainly, football isn't the only thing people do that leads to head injuries.

But if it is significantly worse than other sports, why not single it out as the worst thing ever?

Several sports increase the risk of CTE, but football has been more studied, I think because the incidence of obviously impared former players is higher than in other sports.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dwaltrip on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:39PM (#50355234)
[delayed]
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by estearum on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:47PM (#50355367)
> The fact that they're a repeated part of the game and not occasional incidents is very, very bad.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by alistairSH on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:13PM (#50356750)
Because football is the most studied and has one of the highest (if not the actual highest) rates of head trauma per time played.

Rugby and ice hockey are certainly bad, but at least the impacts are generally limited to play near the ball/puck, whereas with American football, essentially every player has an impact on every play (WR blocking on rush plays, etc).

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by mikestew on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:31PM (#50356981)
So why ignore the part of their comment that answers your question:

The fact that they're a repeated part of the game and not occasional incidents is very, very bad.

I've gotten a concussion falling off an electric scooter. But slamming my head on the pavement isn't the point of riding an electric scooter, and if you're doing it regularly, you're doing something wrong. Unlike contact football.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:43PM (#50361574)
When I played some 30 years ago I was taught explicitly not to use my head for any technique, be it blocking or tackling, etc,
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by estearum on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:46AM (#50362188)
That's nice but empirically we know (and anyone can observe) that head impacts are pretty much the norm in ~100% of plays.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by kyawzazaw on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:01PM (#50354597)
did you even read? the bulk happened at collegiate level

also there are studies on this

McKee et al. (2023) – Neuropathologic and Clinical Findings in Young Contact Sport Athletes Exposed to Repetitive Head Impacts (JAMA Neurology) [https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaneurology/fullarticle/2...]

Alosco et al. (2017) – Age of First Exposure to Tackle Football and Later-Life Cognitive Impairment and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms (Translational Psychiatry) [https://doi.org/10.1038/tp.2017.197]

even intl football headers have concerns

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thrwaway73637 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:05PM (#50354652)
i couldnt find the paper just the news article
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by sanex on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:01PM (#50354603)
Sure but the quality of gear you get in the NFL is much higher than what your typical kid gets. I regret the two years of football I played in high school.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thrwaway73637 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:05PM (#50354645)
did you enjoy it at the time?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:40PM (#50355261)
I'm sure people enjoy heroin at the time.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by butlike on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:57PM (#50355546)
The best part about heroin is your brain can recover from it. CTE not so much.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by sanex on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:27PM (#50356040)
Not enough to play senior year
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ourmandave on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:28PM (#50356053)
The average weight of the front line NFL player is over 310 lbs.

At that size ratio from kids to pro, they should be rivaling Dark Helmet from Space Balls.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by moate on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:02PM (#50354613)
From an injury perspective: What are they? Let's assume we're talking MS/HS football where the mass of the players is enough to really do some damage.

Provide your data Mr. Thrwaway, if that even is your real name.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thrwaway73637 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:07PM (#50354683)
oh the citation/data trick and personal attack. lovely
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jamiek88 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:32PM (#50355132)
From the article: The bulk of the head impacts that these former NFL players experienced didn’t occur at the NFL level. They occurred at the collegiate level ... and at the high school level and in many cases the youth level. And all of those cumulative hits to the head added up to result in an increased risk,” said Daneshvar.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Ekaros on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:25PM (#50357686)
I have understood that in general any type of sudden acceleration and deacceleration is enough to cause potential damage. So it is just not the hard hits it is any situations which brain moves against the skull. Over long enough period these will add up and cause cumulative damage.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by chrisBob on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:06PM (#50354660)
Yes! A child with a developing brain, and no medical staff on the sidelines is potentially in a worse situation.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:17PM (#50354869)
> playing at nfl level and kid level is something very different

Correct. NFL payers are better paid, get better medical care, have better training and equipment, and their brains are more developed.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by kakacik on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:44PM (#50355337)
As mentioned elsewhere here the damage is cumulative and started in their youth
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ramesh31 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:57PM (#50355541)
>"playing at nfl level and kid level is something very different"

The damage is done by the time they reach that point. Average NFL tenure is only 4 years, but anyone who reaches that level has been playing since they were 8.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by chrisBob on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:08PM (#50354715)
I am surprised by the otherwise intelligent and caring parents I have met who had their elementary schoolers playing tackle football. I don't understand that decision at all.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by badgersnake on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:28PM (#50355073)
Unless it’s actually banned below a certain age, what are you going to do if that’s what they want to do with their life?

If they don’t play and everyone else does, their development will be many years behind their peers which makes it unlikely they could play at a high level.

But maybe you’re okay with that.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by swatcoder on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:38PM (#50355218)
[delayed]
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by badgersnake on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:32PM (#50356113)
I guess you missed the point so why don’t I spell it out to you.

The correct thing to do is to ban tackle football below a certain age. Probably college. That levels the playing field.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by swatcoder on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:42PM (#50356270)
Ah. Yes, I didn't pick that up in what you wrote. The seeming fatalism about how there's not much to do until or unless that happens eclipsed it. That seemed to be the focus of your comment and I could only re-contextualize it once you made it more clear her.

Sorry about the misread!

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by plorkyeran on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:45PM (#50357140)
I'm down with banning tackle football for kids, but "the people who play as kids have an unfair advantage in going pro" is an incredibly weird reason to think it should be banned.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by badgersnake on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:37PM (#50415315)
It takes away the incentive.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by everdrive on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:40PM (#50356230)
>And like any responsible parents, they presumably also don't just defer to what their elementary aged children "want to do with their life" nor feed into the exaggeration that "everybody else" does anything at all, let alone play tackle football.

This is the only wise position. Despite the commonly and misleading film tropes, children do not know themselves perfectly. Often the adults "holding them back" are doing those children a great favor.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:38PM (#50355225)
If they don't play a game which damages their brain when they are children, they won't be able to go into a career which damages their brain as an adult. Hmmm.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by kakacik on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:41PM (#50355277)
Gotta stick to the crowd at all costs, its so uncomfortable outside of it right
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wat10000 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:15PM (#50355847)
99.9% of high school football players aren't good enough to make a career out of it no matter what they do. Avoiding literal brain damage at the cost of forcing my child into a group they're virtually certain to be in anyway seems totally fine.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:46PM (#50361592)
This goes for all athletics … so why even have them at all ?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by cj9 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:08AM (#50361696)
Because they don't all cause brain damage...
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:19AM (#50361744)
Soccer probably does. Wouldn’t be surprised if same goes for wrestling.

And different sports have different safety concerns.

Distance running is known to cause increase chance of cardiac arrest.

How about gymnastics, some of those dismounts are pretty dangeroud

Why single out one of them

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by cj9 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:06AM (#50363042)
Because other sports still don't have (from the article) an almost guaranteed chance of brain damage long-term. That's what we can literally see from differences in the brain tissue, not even considering what we can't see and don't know.

It's singled out because it's the single sport that appears to lead to life-altering effects from invisible injuries, rather than an acceptable cost/risk of accidental injury or increased chance of extremely rare events in other sports. They are open for debate just the same if evidence comes to light.

The real question is why you believe your personal experience has any bearing on the facts presented, to the point of farcical argument. It's a shame that anything we enjoy may later turn out to be harmful, but you are arguing the equivalent of: "I smoked all my life and I'm fine", "but red meat gives you cancer too", "why are you targeting smoking when people drink", "people have died choking on air".

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by badgersnake on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:56AM (#50364366)
In adults at least, it’s their brain and if that’s what they want or do with it, in spite of the risks why shouldn’t they?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wat10000 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:23AM (#50365201)
Of course. But we’re talking about children. And children playing is vital to any high level sport. Nobody starts playing anything at the age of 18 and goes on to become a top player.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wat10000 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:23AM (#50365209)
Fun, exercise, socialization.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ilamont on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:53PM (#50355472)
Same here. When did Boston University start publishing about the CTE/football connection? 10 or 15 years ago? A couple I know, one with a public health degree from an Ivy, still let one of her kids play through all of that, and he played at the college level, too.

At the same time, a lot of parents (myself included) steered kids to other sports. That had another effect: there was even more pressure on parents who didn't care about CTE (and their kids) to get into football because kiddie leagues and especially high school teams were short of players. This happened to a friend whose two boys were strong hockey players, the coach at their school pushed them to try out for football the following season.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by acketon on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:35PM (#50357801)
> Same here. When did Boston University start publishing about the CTE/football connection? 10 or 15 years ago?

Our science writers at BU have been writing about CTE research for at least that long. Oldest I could find was 2010. We've published a lot on the topic on our main news site and our science publication:

Brink CTE stories: https://www.bu.edu/brink/tag/cte/

BU Today CTE stories going back to 2010: https://www.bu.edu/today/tag/cte/

Some favorites:

This 5 part series: https://www.bu.edu/brink/series/cte-how-bu-is-changing-the-g...

This story about Youth Football: https://www.bu.edu/articles/2018/youth-football-linked-to-ea...

And this video from the Director of the CTE research center talking about how these discoveries impacted her as a huge football fan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUsDvKyhtA4

I'm a creative director @ BU and our designers have occasionally helped our editorial teams with story designs for these types of research stories. It's been interesting watching the progression of the research over the years and as a parent as well I would not let my kids play football based on the research. There are other, less risky sports they can enjoy. Skiing, Martial Arts, etc. I don't believe we can or should protect them from all risk, but this CTE research has been a clear enough signal in how football is played for me to be wary of letting them play.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by frmersdog on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:00PM (#50358122)
Tbf, IIUC, hockey's not much better. Same issue: high speed collisions in padding that makes high speed collisions seem less damaging than they actually are. Boxing, too. Most field sports aren't much better.

Lift weights and play tennis or baseball.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by sodastar on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:24AM (#50366912)
Baseball and Tennis are really gruesome on tendons, joints and ankles. Apart from colliding with a second baseman while trying to get there is also a potential concussion risk, not even talking about getting hit in the head with a wild ball or any other abstruse risk. I guess in terms of longterm damages with irreparable damages basketball might seem the safest unless you are a high-flying guard thats 6"1 and dunking over people 15 inches taller.

sure you tear an ACL here and there, but thats nothing modern surgery cant fix.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by frmersdog on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:08PM (#50370816)
Basketball's a bit fraught since the NBA does their best to memoryhole Muggsy Bogues. God forbid the meta shift to making having a manlet or two on the roster advantageous. Wemby can't even bend that low!

Somewhere, there's a dude in spandex and legwarmers muttering to himself, "It's my time." [Maniac plays softly in the distance]

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wat10000 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:21PM (#50355948)
It's a deeply ingrained cultural tradition in a lot of places. It's an extremely hard sell to tell people to reject their traditions because of a relatively nebulous and uncertain danger. "I played football and I was fine" is a powerful argument.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by alex43578 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:47PM (#50356350)
Still doesn’t mean you can’t look at those people as foolish, no different than if they handed a cigarette to their teen or let their kid get obese.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by brailsafe on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:34PM (#50357789)
[delayed]
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wat10000 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:52PM (#50358021)
"Preventing them from learning to navigate the world"? We're talking about football.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by alex43578 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:43PM (#50358617)
There's a dozen alternative sports they can play with far lower injury rates.

Encouraging them to get a drivers license is fine (run cross-country), but getting them a driver's license and buying your 16-year old a sports car with bald tires and no seatbelts (football) is negligent.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by preg_match on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:54PM (#50359880)
Football was most definitely a net-negative for my life. All I learned is how to be homophobic, how to be hateful, and how to get hurt.

There is something to be said about the socialization of sports. But there is such a thing as negative socialization, regression even. I would say football consistently has one of the most toxic cultures of any sport. It’s improving, very slowly. But there’s more to gain than just lower head injury risk by switching to a different sport.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by bmitc on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @07:42PM (#50360208)
> Football was most definitely a net-negative for my life. All I learned is how to be homophobic, how to be hateful, and how to get hurt.

I played football and yet never drink, have never done drugs, am not and was never homophobic, never got into trouble etc.

Would I let a kid play football now, with all the knowledge of CTE? No. I absolutely even worry about it for myself. But it's a bit odd, to me, to say "football made me a bad person".

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by preg_match on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:35PM (#50361540)
I mean I’ve of course unlearned the regressive social circumstances of football, nor is it unique to football. It’s fairly common in many male-dominated spaces, particularly ones which tend to cater to toxic ideals of masculinity or, as it is sometimes euphemized, comradery.

I think basically all people who were socialized male have had these experiences at one point or another, whether it be in football, in class, in the military, at sleepovers, in the locker room.

My point is more so that football has a particular “culture”, or it did when I was a kid. And that culture was not necessarily socially productive at a young and impressionable age. When we see certain behaviors in particularly young men, we have to wonder where they come from, and what we are doing to cultivate that.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by hollandheese on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:55PM (#50359887)
I think it's far more destructive to allow a child to play a sport that basically guarantees that they'll end up with massive brain damage.

If cars, alcohol or weed caused 75%+ of the people who used them to have massive brain damage then it'd be unreasonable to allow people to use those too.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:01PM (#50356557)
CTE is not nebulous and uncertain. If it were not for "tradition", it would be considered child abuse to let them repeatedly slam their brains into their skulls.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wat10000 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:23PM (#50356885)
It absolutely is when we're talking about humans evaluating risk in the context of an important part of their culture. The consequences come decades later and are far from certain.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by frmersdog on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:06PM (#50358196)
"I xed and I was fine," is pretty much it. Why beat your kids? Why let them go into large amounts of debt for college? Why circumcise your boys? No real thought of if circumstances have changed or if the original assumptions/data were flawed.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dyauspitr on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:12PM (#50357527)
There is something to be said for optimizing a life for safety, which just ends up being a milquetoast life. Male culture for a very long time has been about cheering on so-called “stupid” behavior, and honestly, it’s the most beautiful thing about masculine culture. It values courage and breaking away from the group. It’s not something we should lose. I’m gonna go as far as to say it’s probably the whole reason we have civilization.

Yes, you’re optimizing for your kids individual life but nothing we Americans do anymore is holistic. It’s all short-term thinking.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by watwut on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:56PM (#50359896)
It does not value breaking away from group. It values conformity with the group. And the test of conformity is willingness to do stupid damaging things.

And they are not courageous. They are so scared they will be seen as unmanly or outsiders, that they will do, enable and tolerate pretty much anything.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by preg_match on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:57PM (#50359899)
Following the group in hurting yourself is not courageous, nor is it “breaking away”. Quite the opposite.

Masculine culture has traditionally, and currently, favored conformance and lack of individuality over basically everything else. It’s one of the more toxic parts of masculinity as portrayed by the patriarchy.

There are many ways to be a woman. There are many ways to be a gay man. There’s really only one way to be a straight man, if you want to be valuable in the eyes of the patriarchy. It’s all about conformity, conformity, conformity. No deviancy, no thoughts, just a blank slate of a man ready for work, family, and an early death, be it at war or doing stupid things.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dyauspitr on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:23PM (#50370981)
Conformity on things that are hard and furthers the human race is my cup of tea. But I also don’t agree with your analysis, the conformity is primarily around not dabbling in anything that could be considered feminine that I whole heartedly support. Other than that, masculinity encourages breaking the mold in every other facet.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by preg_match on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:43PM (#50371232)
As I’ve said, there’s only one way to be a straight man. Masculinity encourages conformity in all aspects of life.

How you dress, how you speak, how you walk, who you are friends with, what shows you watch, who you respect, how you show that respect, what you do, how you earn a living, how you have sex, how you obtain relationships. Everything, from life until death.

The perfect man is the perfect cog. He works, he doesn’t think too much, he walks and talks right, he makes moral love to his wife, and he raises his kids in a standard American family hand-picked for him by his forefathers. Any deviance from that is marks-off.

I think a lot of men need to believe that their life just so happens to perfectly fit the mold, but you see, it’s by choice. If that’s what they need to believe to be happy, then okay. I’m fine with that.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by watwut on Thursday November 05, 2026 @04:35AM (#50377135)
They are not furthering the human race. They are literally the kind of people human race would be better off without.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by erentz on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:45PM (#50357921)
The adult culture around high school football in the US is creepy to me. All these grown men pushing and promoting and getting excited (and aggressive) about it, with stadiums and equipment and media that would put most professional leagues overseas to shame.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by scoofy on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:41PM (#50358589)
I grew up in Texas when football was basically religion. My parents flatly forbid me from playing. Any other sport was fine, no football. Every single person I knew on the team ended up with at least some kind of minimal, permanent injury. This was a decade before there were publications about CTE.

I'm quite thankful that I never ended up on the team, and think the entire concept of high school football is incredibly stupid given what we know about CTE.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by matty22 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:13AM (#50365809)
When I played little league and high school football we had this one activity we did called "The Door". Essentially, it was a piece of plywood stuck in the ground so that you could not see who was on the other side of it. We broke into two lines and you just ran full speed around the door not knowing who you were about to smash into. The teams and coaches essentially cheered when someone got a "stinger". That was when you got hit so hard that your head felt like it was getting stung by a bee...I often wonder what effects that kind of stuff has had on my life.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by briffle on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:11PM (#50359513)
I've so far seen 3 ambulances at high school soccer games, and one at a football game. (the football player was fine, and back to school the next day, just being SUPER cautious about his neck after a tackle).. the soccer players, 1 concussion, and 2 broken bones.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by preg_match on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:46PM (#50359817)
It is somewhat common to break bones in soccer, but bones heal. Soccer is not like football. Football is a sport where you’re supposed to run into other people, often head first.

Of course people get hurt in soccer, but that’s out of the ordinary. For football, getting hurt is the ordinary. Most likely people aren’t calling ambulances because getting shaken up and a bit nauseated is par for the course for football.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by bmitc on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @07:38PM (#50360187)
> Soccer is not like football

True, but soccer is also susceptible to CTE. It is becoming increasingly apparent that soccer, particularly headers and on field collisions, also yields plenty of CTE cases. So much so that some soccer organizations are introducing protocols, such as no headers for youth soccer.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by cmrx64 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:33AM (#50363186)
these were already forbidden when my younger brother was playing youth soccer 20 or so years ago in the northeast US.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by sokoloff on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @09:07PM (#50360752)
I think we had an ambulance on-site for all our high-school football games.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:23PM (#50354984)
Tackle football is basically the only sport my kids are not allowed to play. I don’t talk about it because I don’t want it to become something forbidden and therefore cool, but if they naturally find their way there and start getting pushy about it, it’s one of the few things I’m prepared to put my foot down about with no compromise.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by brianwawok on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:06PM (#50355672)
Football, boxing... seem the top two to cross off. I think skiing is perhaps the third to cross off.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by badc0ffee on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:22PM (#50355957)
At least with skiing, getting hit in the head isn't the point.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by zbentley on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:03PM (#50357380)
Anecdotal, but: I only know 3 people with TBIs personally. All three got them skiing or snowboarding. One died.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ErroneousBosh on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:24PM (#50355988)
Wait until you hear about shinty.

Have you ever seen ice hockey? Okay well imagine that if it was on a field and if you made it into a really fast and violent contact sport.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by unregistereddev on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:55PM (#50356454)
I'm interested and after work will look for video to better understand game action. But there's no way that shinty is "really fast" compared to ice hockey. Ice hockey players routinely move 15-20mph (~24-32km/h) and occasionally sprint upwards of 25mph (40km/h).
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ErroneousBosh on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:41PM (#50357098)
Yeah, they just scoot about on the ice and don't actually play.

Ice hockey is a really boring sport.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by mikestew on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:29PM (#50356961)
Field hockey, yeah, I've heard of it. And there's no way a field hockey player is going to run as fast as an ice hockey player skates.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ErroneousBosh on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:40PM (#50357089)
No, field hockey is a totally different thing. Like ice hockey, field hockey is non-contact, and very slow, and you're not allowed to lift your stick off the surface.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jerlam on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:49PM (#50357979)
Ice hockey is a full-contact sport so I don't know what sport you think it is.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jerlam on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:12PM (#50358986)
To follow up, my guess is that it's "Bandy" which is a predecessor of ice hockey with sticks and skates, sometimes called ice hockey, but with a much larger rink and less contact:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bandy#Bandy_and_ice_hockey

Ice hockey is generally used to mean the specific Olympic sport invented in Canada and played professionally in the NHL at the same level as the NFL.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ErroneousBosh on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:17PM (#50359566)
No, it really isn't. You're not allowed hit other players.

In shinty a perfectly acceptable tackle is to hook someone's legs out from under them and then hit them as they go over to make sure they stay down for a bit.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:50PM (#50361604)
> No, it really isn't. You're not allowed hit other players

Uh, what? Do you know what a body check is ?

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by mikestew on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:57PM (#50358079)
You've never actually watched an ice hockey game, have you?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:19PM (#50359063)
They likely made a typo. It reads like they’re trying to contrast the sports.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ErroneousBosh on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @06:16PM (#50359556)
I have. It's pretty mild stuff.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by KingMachiavelli on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:45PM (#50356302)
Skiing is pretty awesome and IMO risk of concussion or serious injury is very low if you are not a freestyle or extremely aggressive/risky skier.

Football and boxing involve guaranteed sub-concussion head impacts every session and likely full concussions at least a few times a year.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by kenjackson on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:54PM (#50356447)
A few years ago in my team of 12 -- we had 4 people in knee braces due to injuries from skiing. Given how little people actually ski, it seems like the sport with the highest injury rate (injuries per minute) -- at least based on my anecdotal data.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by adrian_b on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:46PM (#50357163)
Presumably the risk of injuries during skiing is similar to the risk of car accidents when driving, i.e. very high for certain people, but negligible for most.

Anecdotally, I have many friends, of both sexes, who like to go skiing, and after many decades none of them has ever been injured. Some falls from time to time are unavoidable, but if the speed is not excessive for the terrain and the fall is managed correctly, most falls will not result in injuries.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by gnarcoregrizz on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:22PM (#50357645)
agreed. seems the beginners get injured more. I was in a race league throughout school. no super g or downhill races so speeds were tame. I don't recall any major injuries, just scrapes and bruises. seemed pretty safe provided your gear is set up correctly (DINs were still at 10+ haha), and you spend time in the gym
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by bluGill on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:20PM (#50357622)
Knee Injuries are not in the same league as brain injuries.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jr3592 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:12PM (#50356725)
Skiiing? Please do explain
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:19PM (#50356827)
Skiing becomes incredibly dangerous once you get into like…your 40s and beyond unless you have been doing it pretty consistently your whole life. And even then it’s still very dangerous. High speeds, downhill, crashes are serious.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jr3592 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:44PM (#50357909)
ah okay, yea makes a lot of sense... I would add that motocross is probably also in that camp. Lots of people ride as kids, stop, and then start again later in life. Its a very dangerous sport with lots of significant hard falls.

But its also a lot of fun. Its crazy how much we crave excitement in life but that excitement often carries enormous risks.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:57PM (#50358082)
Yeah I wouldn’t be caught dead trying to snowboard down a mountain anymore lol
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Ekaros on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:19PM (#50357619)
I take it means downhill. Not cross country which to me seems safe, apart from causing asthma in Norwegians for some reason... But downhill version involves going relatively fast or really fast with some small change for sudden stop, which in very few cases is safe.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by adrian_b on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:56PM (#50358070)
The downhill version may involve going very fast, for the people who choose this (and who are thus likely to be involved in accidents).

People who do not like unnecessary risks can go downhill as slow as they choose. Skiing speed is controllable, unless you are an inexperienced beginner, in which case you should not attempt to go downhill where that is too steep.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dfxm12 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:33PM (#50357019)
If you're worried about head trauma, just consider that football is being widely studied right now. Look at the stats of basically any contact sport: wrestling, soccer, hockey, etc. There might be fewer studies, but they all show that the athletes are significantly more likely to develop these types of brain disorders.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:22PM (#50357653)
They aren’t. I can tell you offhand soccer and hockey both have lower rates of CTE’s, soccer by a significant amount. You shouldn’t correct people and tell them to go research things you haven’t even looked up yourself.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dfxm12 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:48PM (#50357966)
Why do you think it is incorrect?

"This analysis revealed that risk ranged from a 5-fold increase in Alzheimer’s disease, through an approximately 4 fold increase in motor neurone disease, to a 2 fold Parkinson’s disease in former professional footballers compared to population controls."

https://www.thepfa.com/news/2019/10/21/field-study-increased...

"...the odds of having chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) increased by 34% each year [of ice hockey] played, and 18 of 19 National Hockey League players had CTE."

https://www.bumc.bu.edu/camed/news-events/articles/2024/larg...

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:53PM (#50358031)
Yes hockey has CTE’s but it’s a lower rate than US football. Nobody is saying it’s super safe or doesn’t have CTE cases.

You said other sports are worse than football.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jjtheblunt on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:39PM (#50357072)
soccer headers are ok? (clearly they're not.)
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by 5upplied_demand on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:00PM (#50357350)
The US Soccer Federation has proactively banned headers at the U11 level. It's not really a good example.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Forgeties79 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:19PM (#50357620)
The concussion rate in American football (especially pre-NFL) is significantly higher than soccer’s and as the other commenter said, soccer orgs have been addressing it (way better than the NFL has) for a long time. It’s also more preventable in a way it simply isn’t in American football.

They don’t even compare tbh

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jjtheblunt on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:00PM (#50416574)
seems plausible since heading a not heavy ball differs than heading a 240 lb human moving in the closing direction, but is there data that you're referencing?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by pton_xd on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:36PM (#50356175)
I tried contact football in 7th grade and only lasted 1 practice session. I was shocked by what I saw; other kids throwing their bodies into each other as if they were just bags of meat, sometimes colliding head-on. The ferocity with which they did it seemed like a source of pride for them and there was this sense of one-upmanship on who could tackle the best. The whole thing felt insane to me and I backed out immediately. I was heavily involved in other sports like baseball and basketball so I was used to competitiveness, but nothing on that level of disregard for safety.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by joquarky on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @08:01PM (#50360333)
Give teenagers permission to physically punish their peers and you can bet they will give it 110%.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by jimbokun on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:41PM (#50356250)
Equivalent of boxing and other combat sports, I suppose. Equipment that makes a sport almost requiring high speed collisions on every play safe doesn’t exist.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by boplicity on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:05PM (#50356626)
They should remove all padding and safety equipment, and institute severe penalties for any contact that could cause injury. The sport would probably become sane, but people like the violence, so this isn't going to happen.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dfxm12 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:31PM (#50356979)
~60% of rugby league players in one study were found to have CTE [0]. I bring this up because they don't wear pads, and I often hear that this makes them play safer (which might be true, but not to a meaningful degree; they still are not "safe").

FWIW, the NFL seemingly increasingly penalizes and expands the definition of unsafe hits every year. If people just liked the violence, BKB or power slap would be much more popular than they are.

0 - https://apnews.com/article/cte-australia-rugby-league-035e24...

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by pessimizer on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:44PM (#50357907)
"Safe" is a strawman, and "not to a meaningful degree" is simply a lie. Fewer serious injuries is meaningful.

That being said, rugby is a different game. Football for the most effected players is one crushing impact per down, and a lot of waiting around and planning. Without helmets, half of the players would be knocked out cold. Rugby is not like that.

Every down in football is basically like a sumo tachi-ai (initial charge.) It's absurdly stressful without a helmet to do it even once a day between professionals. People would have to stop leading with their heads.

> If people just liked the violence

This is irrelevant. I love gridiron football, I think it's the best team sport ever invented, especially for spectators. I don't just like the violence, I like the violence. I have to accept the fact that I might not like it as much if people weren't leading with their heads. It's also the smartest game in my opinion, and I'm amused by upper middle-class people in the US thinking that "soccer" is classy (because Europe) when all the players are so much dumber (let's talk about heading; that ball is soft, too.)

American football is an atrocity, though. Even at the professional level, it doesn't pay enough for how bad it hurts you (and careers are shortest for the people who see the most impacts.) At the college level, forget it.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by adrian_b on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:32PM (#50357003)
Not combat sports in general, but the combat sports where hitting the head of the opponent is a valid method for winning.

Boxing is by far the worst from this point of view, much worse than the combat sports that allow knock-outs but also have other alternatives, like MMA.

Combat sports like judo or fencing are much safer than American football.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thinkcontext on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:08PM (#50357464)
It shocking how different Olympic boxing is from pro boxing. Almost all Olympic style bouts finish and are decided on points, whereas pro boxing is primarily about inflicting damage, most often to the head to score a KO.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by pessimizer on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:21PM (#50357640)
Boxing is far worse than other combat sports because of the thick gloves, and plenty of combat sports don't involve significant head impacts at all.

The equipment to make it safe is the problem - it allows you to take orders of magnitude more blows to the head. There were many people saying that to improve the safety of football, you should get rid of helmets entirely.

Padded helmets in football and padded gloves in boxing serve the same purpose as having filters on cigarettes. Filters on cigarettes allow you to smoke a lot more, and a lot of the stuff that is worst for you is not filtered out.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by dfxm12 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:22PM (#50356873)
I see you emphasize "this" sport. I think it is important to understand that American football happens to be studied & reported very rigorously at this point in time. I hope you recognize that players of many other contact sports suffer higher rates of neurodegenerative disease that the average person, like all sorts of combat sports, association football, hockey, etc...

To the NFL's credit, they have made rules and equipment changes to address this.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by wdr1 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:23PM (#50356880)
Respectfully, did you ever play tackle football? I ask because it's easy to look at something you're not familiar with & not see the value.

I played football in high school & college. Did I get hurt? Yes. But I also got hurt in other sports. My worst injury by far was in baseball (it required ~22 stitches & I couldn't see out of one eye for a while).

With every activity there's a tradeoff with risk.

Let's say we take tackle football off the table. We ban it from high schools, justifying it based on a study showing it produced 3.96 injuries per 1,000 practices or competitions & 8.22 concussions per 10,000 (the highest for both).[1]

Okay, but then do we also ban woman's soccer?

It's the second highest, at 2.65 injuries per 1,000 practices or competitions and 6.11 concussions per 10,000.

Or why let our children take any risk?

As a parent, I know I can't shelter my children. They have to take some risk. I let my children ride a bike, knowing full well there is a non-zero chance he could get by a car. We live in a big city & I let my pre-teen walk to meet a friend at a local burger joint for lunch, knowing full well there are bad people in the world who might do something untoward to him.

As for CTE specifically, I am very concerned about in the NFL. I have mixed feelings if I'm complicit in things by watching. As a diehard Bears fan, I found Dave Duerson's story heartbreaking. I'm supportive of the guardian helmets and hope the league starts to mandate them.

But the athletes in the NFL are not like amateurs. They are far bigger, far stronger, far faster. You can't take the CTE data from professional & extrapolate it to high school, etc.

[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11113040

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by nitwit005 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:34PM (#50357032)
> Okay, but then do we also ban woman's soccer?

It's fairly likely they'll change the rules to reduce injuries. In the US, they already banned kids under 10 from deliberately heading, with some practice rules after that.

And ultimately, changing the rules is sort of like a ban. You can't (competitively) play the original sport.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by onlypassingthru on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:36PM (#50357050)
Yes, we take tackle football off the table for HS athletes and below. And then replace it with flag football. It's cheaper for the school, safer for the kids and has the benefit of being more coed friendly (a necessity for small schools that struggle to find enough players).

Soccer is addressing the concussion issue by banning headers. I think the current rule is no headers for U12s and below. That will probably be adjusted upwards to U14s at some point.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by kleiba2 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:03PM (#50357395)
Notice that you don't really do a lot of headers if you consider the course of a full game: the main risk does not come from the ball on your head, but from some other player's body who's also trying to get to the ball.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by engineer_22 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:27PM (#50357713)
That's right but these collisions are often predicated by an attempted head ball.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by nonethewiser on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:03PM (#50357399)
Lower levels of football are the safer ones though. In terms of reducing CTE it would be better to remove NFL then College.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by snapcaster on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:11PM (#50357502)
This is nonsense, the numbers of people involved in these are orders of magnitude different
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by onlypassingthru on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:17PM (#50357596)
Tell that to all of the HS players who have gotten concussions playing football. I struggle to think of anyone I know who didn't get at least one concussion playing HS football.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:25PM (#50361482)
I never did, played 4 years including two years varsity
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by cj9 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:11AM (#50361709)
It hasn't done your logical reasoning any favors though.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:14AM (#50361718)
You seem to be suggesting a concussion is automatic thing for a high school football player.

And I started all four years, The first two years on both offense and defense.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by asdf333 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:06PM (#50357433)
there isn't much need for headers in soccer. I think inevitably it will be banned across the entire game in due time
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by onlypassingthru on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:14PM (#50357551)
There is at the elite level.† Kids games, not so much.

† https://news.northeastern.edu/2026/07/12/world-cup-headers-2...

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by skrtskrt on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:07PM (#50358922)
Headers are an enormous part of the game, they are their own discreet skillset. I expect rugby-style headgear to become the norm starting in youth leagues though.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by bgirard on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:40PM (#50357088)
Do you think overall injury rates tell the whole picture when some of them are CTE? It would be more convincing if you were showing data about CTE.

I'd rather my child accept a high risk of sprain, than even a low change of CTE.

I know a ex-professional football player that doesn't let his children play football.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by TacticalCoder on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:53PM (#50357252)
> Or why let our children take any risk?

My daughter does Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu since a few years already now: her uncle is a black belt. She skateboards too. Those aren't "safe" sports. BTW she already dislocated someone else's arm (nothing serious but the other person wanted to "see if BJJ works": she got her answer).

And yet there are sports I won't let her do, like proximity flying or basejumping for example.

Saying: "All sports have risks, so all sports are equally risky" is a logical fallacy.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by Goronmon on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:54PM (#50357273)
Respectfully, did you ever play tackle football?

I did, and I agree with the comment you responded to.

Pretty much all my worst injuries are related to football, sprains, hip issues, knee issues, and a concussion that took me out of a game in college.

>Or why let our children take any risk?

Why let our children take all risks?

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by pwthornton on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:56PM (#50357299)
I played tackle football, and while I agree my worst acute injuries were in other sports, you do just get a lot of head jarring hits in football. It's the nature of the game. You get these hits when everything goes right. That's what people are talking about with tackle football.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ckosidows on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:56PM (#50357301)
I was a kid with a father deeply invested in football who wanted me to play. I never really felt I had the option to quit until the day he told me it was okay my junior year of high school. I was a child and though I never experienced an injury, tackle practice often pitted me against older, much larger kids. I took a lot of big hits that I just walked off but left me shaken.

I fear I have some mild anger problems. I can't tell you if any of it is even related to football, but if I could go back and stop myself from playing football in middle and high school, I would in a heartbeat. I hated the sport and felt trapped. I imagine I'm not the only kid with a similar story. And just because I never had an official injury doesn't mean the sport had no effect on my developing brain.

Kids don't always have the autonomy to make decisions for themselves; we don't let them use cigarettes or alcohol, get tattoos, etc. The sport has the ability to leave lasting damage on those playing it unlike other sports because impacts are intrinsic to the game as it's currently played. Other sports like soccer can and have banned headers.

I think it's reprehensible to continue allowing children to continue playing contact football.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by thinkcontext on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:59PM (#50357329)
The injury data for football you cite are not relevant because they do not include CTE related findings. CTE itself can be caused even if no recorded injuries take place, it is the repeated pounding to the head that doesn't necessarily have to cause a concussion.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by carabiner on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:09PM (#50357476)
My friend played varsity in HS and swears he'd never let his kids play it. He's a hardcore runner and endurance athlete today (did his first 100 miler) today.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by 5upplied_demand on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:11PM (#50357503)
> Respectfully, did you ever play tackle football?

I did for eight years, from 5th grade through 12th grade. There was a lot of value in learning aspects of teamwork, comradery, and working towards a common goal. However, given the hard data we have on the potential dangers, I am not letting either of my sons play. There are plenty of other ways (and sports) to get those lessons with much lower risks to their developing brains.

I think we can all agree that injuries to the brain are especially worrisome for children, especially when compared to common baseball injuries (hamstring, elbow, rotator cuff, etc.)

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by moron4hire on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:32PM (#50358477)
Speaking of teamwork, comradery, and working towards a common goal, could you imagine if highschool engineering clubs were funded as well as the football teams?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by engineer_22 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:26PM (#50357699)
Those statistics are a good starting point, but if you were to measure concussion versus minutes played, and ranked by severity of concussion, you may find the numbers underrepresented football's risk.

Most of a football game is spent waiting for resumption of play, while girls soccer is continuous.

Football also introduces a different type of collision than those experienced on a soccer field (conceding girls soccer can be pretty intense). Dangerous football plays are by design, often straight ahead collisions, while contact in soccer is often incidental and head balls can be helped with technique.

We are finding lifelong debilitating disease in football players, at rates far exceeding other sports, so I think it's fair to scrutinize the risk. Entering a profession that promises a 75% likelihood of degenerate brain injury is a sobering thought. Then consider high school and college football players are exposing themselves to the risk of developing some form of this disease before they're old enough to understand the risk, and without a luxury lifestyle to show for it.

FWIW, I played American football for 10 years and I relished contact, but older and wiser now I think I could have scratched that itch in a safer way.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by stouset on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @04:04PM (#50358159)
Replace every reference to “tackle football” in this comment with a sport we haven’t traditionally let kids participate in—like full-contact MMA—and you’ll realize how ridiculous it sounds.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @11:34PM (#50361536)
How about wrestling ?
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by stouset on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:17AM (#50362708)
Show me statistics that correlate wrestling with CTE and we can talk.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by plqbfbv on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:21PM (#50359072)
[delayed]
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by pwthornton on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @02:55PM (#50357286)
Play flag football. It's a great sport without the terrible risks. It's also being played by girls too.

I coach middle school girls. It's a blast. It has by far the most strategy of any youth sport.

If I had sons, I wouldn't let them play tackle football before high school, and I would have to think long and hard about that even.

I enjoyed flag football as a coach so much that I built my own play creation and team management software (https://getplaylook.com). One of the things that you get with flag at an early age because you aren't so focused on the physical side of the game is a higher emphasis on technique, particularly route running, and play design. Good play design can scheme people open, even if your team isn't very fast.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by strangattractor on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:16PM (#50357572)
Football is obviously a problem? Boxing and UFC are literally sports where the goal is to pummel someone's head.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by john_strinlai on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:17PM (#50357593)
>Football is obviously a problem? Boxing and UFC are literally sports where the goal is to pummel someone's head.

yes. unfortunately, more than one thing can be a problem at the same time.

Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by KylerAce on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @03:18PM (#50357608)
It would be neat to live in the world where this wasn't true
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by casey2 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:33PM (#50359200)
There is a difference between a 90lbs "tackle" and a 500lbs one.
Re:Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year ... by ericmcer on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @05:49PM (#50359342)
Seriously, the athletes who get hurt in the NFL are the ones that "made it" as well. No one even cares about the hordes of players who suffer a career ending injury in college or high school.