News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Toutouxc on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:41AM (#49627426)
I like how the least optimistic scenario is simply LLMs not making a difference, instead of the very real possibility of them damaging education, destroying people’s attention spans and their ability to learn, eroding trust within societies, increasing the wealth inequality and leading to class wars.

I believe the net effect of LLMs is, at this point, firmly negative, and it’s going to take years until they start making up for the mess they’ve created.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by ghm2199 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @12:01PM (#49628695)
Altman, Amodei, Pinchai etc can get together and just put a self imposed ban on themselves and ask the us government to sanction any entity/state attempting to use/release a Recursive Self improving model until the risks are well understood.

This does not mean they can't keep developing it. But it would mean they do not release them to the general public or the public domain. The US government can continue to use and fund these models that are more powerful and use them in situations they understand and a restricted setting. The pentagon has a larger budget than any VC.

Remove the profit motive on self improving recursive models gained from retail/commercial use!

Re:What will our economic future look like? by bigbuppo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:12PM (#49634413)
Would also mean their labs most be fully airgapped and made safe from all known covert channels, no matter how ridiculously theoretical. In fact, their meat proxies, who may be brainwashed into acting on the AI's behalf, must also be kept in extreme isolation. And to make sure that nobody will get close we will need to figure out a way to warn people. Probably start out with a series of signs...

This place is a message... and part of a system of messages... pay attention to it!

This is not a place of honor... no highly esteemed deed is commemorated here... nothing valued is here.

What is here was dangerous and repulsive to us. This mesage is a warning about danger.

The danger is in a particular location... it increases toward a center...

Re:What will our economic future look like? by vharuck on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @08:54PM (#49636833)
Re:What will our economic future look like? by bloppe on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:04PM (#49637871)
No worries. The US can totally just sanction China into giving up on AI research.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by airstrike on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:59AM (#49627730)
Exactly. Bloomberg reports students who use AI perform worse

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-09-08/school-st...

Re:What will our economic future look like? by jmathai on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:33AM (#49628271)
I don't even need to read a Bloomberg report to know this. I've personally experienced noticeable mental decline as my AI usage at work has gone up.

I can only imagine what it does to children whose brains are still developing.

I'm not anti AI and I don't know how to quantify the pros and cons but we need to be honest about what they are.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by palmotea on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @02:25PM (#49631243)
> Exactly. Bloomberg reports students who use AI perform worse

That's good news! The worse students perform, the less competition AI will have in the future and the less effective any resistance will be. The ultimate goal should be to abolish education except for the elite, but we can't get there in one step.

The ideal future we should be shooting for is cross between Idocracy and Elysium: a paradise for tech oligarchy and masses so stupid and dependent that can't possible challenge them.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by vonneumannstan on Friday September 11, 2026 @03:53PM (#49664425)
Used in what way though. Obviously using them to do your homework and doing nothing on your own will hurt your learning.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by keybored on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:25AM (#49628123)
> and leading to class wars.

Aren’t we overdue for one anyway.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by timacles on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:42AM (#49628412)
Class war started about 15 years ago post 2007 financial crisis.

The banks and those who control them all knew where we are headed, so they got a little head start destabilizing democracy.

Once us working class get a grasp of the actual situation, we are going to be so deep in the hole, fighting back is going to be quite difficult when the "asset owners" own and control the majority of the worlds resources, all media, forms of communication, AI, technology infrastructure, mass surveillance. You name it, and they have already made massive efforts to make sure they own it.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by inanothertime on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:54AM (#49628595)
Bravo!!!
Re:What will our economic future look like? by keybored on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @01:26PM (#49630051)
Yup, caught me falling for the propaganda.

1. When the capitalists wage class war: bussiness as usual, some murmuring about widening wealth gap by progressive, diffuse threats to democracy

2. When workers complain about the system: all hands on deck, class war immiment, please think of the children and the stability of society

Re:What will our economic future look like? by brailsafe on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @04:44PM (#49633968)
They might own it, but at a certain point it only matters whether the concept of ownership means anything to the people who don't "own" it. Ownership only works for those with assets because they have police working for them to protect the concept of ownership to begin with, but that only works at a certain scale of disenfranchisement and lack of upheaval. There isn't that much in-practice stopping a sufficiently angry group from attacking most politicians or even every-day wealthy people in their home. Money talks, but if the amount everyone else earns isn't enough to meaningfully contribute to "owning" anything, then those people would reasonably stop agreeing to respect the idea of property or non-violence. People without assets, facing down a continual decline in living standards from 15 years ago, should evaluate whether the system they operate in does anything beneficial for them at all, or whether it mainly serves those who they serve.

We're starting to see it in discrete bursts with Mangione, the paper warehouse fire, and in other non-violent ways with farmer protests, trucker protests, etc.. which have varying levels of support from regular people depending on their wealth class, background, and inclination to agree with the government.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by kian on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @07:17PM (#49635966)
hence the robotics industry, and their robot enforcers. and drones
Re:What will our economic future look like? by conception on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:54PM (#49634978)
Incorrect - https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/powellmemo/

That was the moment that business/wealth/rich decided to turn their resources towards directly influencing and controlling government. Reagan and his made up “welfare queens” came shortly after and wealth inequality has sharply risen since. Wildly successful coup.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by FlowingRiver on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @08:35PM (#49636658)
We are in a silent recession, have been for a long while.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Dlemlo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:49AM (#49627566)
How?

Whatever an LLM can do today, will not come back as is tomorrow.

The biggest issue the LLM today: It kills all the small and niche things. The things were we fit all the other people is getting destroyed. You know the guy who makes websites, the fiverr blender person provoding some basic modelling tasks.

You will just ask AI or AI will use your tool or AI will just produce it for you.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by barbazoo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:11AM (#49627904)
I think the root cause is people not having enough human connection. If we had families, friends, neighborhoods, communities where people know each other and care about each other it wouldn't make a difference what new tool someone brings to group. It's just a tool.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by nhecker on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @12:04PM (#49628747)
I agree with the root cause generally, but balk at the 'if we had' phrasing. We still can have these things, it just takes our own time and energy to get out and be with people face-to-face. Nothing about that is impossible. It is not as easy as sitting behind a keyboard though.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by JKCalhoun on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:16AM (#49627981)
I think you nailed it. Before LLMs showed up on the scene, we had already broken society.

(Thanks, Internet!)

Re:What will our economic future look like? by pixl97 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:24PM (#49637588)
Even before that 24 hour cable TV, talk radio, and TV deregulation were chipping away at society as quickly as they could manage. The internet took the intensity to 10.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Dlemlo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:35AM (#49628293)
Yeah capitalism.

If the AI transofmration takes too long, we might never overthrow capitalism

Re:What will our economic future look like? by treespace8 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:11AM (#49627902)
Like all automations it's not 100% perfect, and they all require a human to monitor them.

Turning over a problem to a LLM as solved means we won't be able to do the task anymore. Because we will never learn how. We will not know that the LLM has made a mistake, and will be unable to fix it ourselves.

Right now we can correct the LLM, as the years go on we will become unable to do so.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by Droobfest on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:50AM (#49628538)
Most people who drive a car have no idea how an engine works. I know and agree it's a scary future, but I wonder if it's really _essential_ to understand things on a deeper level.

Most people are quite capable of understanding higher-order ideas without fully grasping the underlying details too.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by SirYandi on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:30PM (#49634674)
It is essential that _someone_ knows how that car works.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by scott_weber on Thursday September 10, 2026 @12:11AM (#49638313)
Maybe less than we might hope. Not only is the knowledge distributed over the hundreds of people involved in designing a car, there may be conventions/habits of design and manufacture whose purpose has become hazy but are nevertheless important, or details of a design iterated upon whose original motivation is less understood.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Dlemlo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:33AM (#49628262)
If you look at certain documentations, we lost already how we d othings.

USA forgot how to produce things.

This will not prevent us from doing it.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by willis936 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:18AM (#49628000)
Those are ubiquitous things. It makes cheap and common things cheaper, not expensive and niche things. It's not mixing in large amounts of context and nuance with good judgment right now. At a minimum that requires an expensive context window but even frontier models aren't beating experts. Maybe they'll get there one day and maybe soon, but that would require hardware getting cheaper. Dennard scaling is over. Either bet on optical computing lighting the world on fire or be suspicious of the alchemists overpromising.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Dlemlo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:34AM (#49628286)
Doing 3D Modeling was not cheap and not niche.

And we have not seen what the industry will put out on a hardware level. Optical computing is coming, onchip models too.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by somenameforme on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:12AM (#49627915)
You're describing the end of the digital world as we know it, and I feel fine.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Dlemlo on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:32AM (#49628250)
Yeah to a certain degree me too tbh. But the biggest growth from the last 20-30 years was digital.

It allowed a lot of people around the planet to change things.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by akomtu on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:39AM (#49628351)
I noticed that LLMs prevent you from thinking on your own, or at least try to, by injecting their "helpful" suggestions when you need some idle time to think. On Amazon, for example, I was about to find something when their chatbot distracted me with its suggestions I didn't ask for.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by detectivestory on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:53AM (#49627618)
LLMs themselves most definitely will not do that. You can still learn how to make a barrel, but not many people do.. The real fear is the destruction/hiding of public data/resources (which has already been happening for years)
Re:What will our economic future look like? by api on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:55AM (#49627664)
There's not nearly enough mention in these discussions of the real villain behind most of the negative cultural, social, and cognitive effects of things like social media: addiction engineering.

AI will be a net positive unless companies start optimizing it for "time in app" or "time on site" or other "engagement" (addiction) metrics.

Every time that's been done, the result has been a nightmare for everything but those KPIs (of course). Service degrades, discourse degrades, everything becomes toxic and addictive and destructive.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by dgellow on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:12AM (#49627913)
I assumed it was a given in such discussions that companies will optimizing for the worst outcomes for their users. It’s a fairly straightforward incentive from our capitalist system, which is why capitalism needs regulation to re-align the incentives with humans needs
Re:What will our economic future look like? by kian on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @07:15PM (#49635945)
if you think companies optimize for the worst outcome still acceptable for their users to please shareholders, why don't you think governments don't opt for the same with their citizens to please special interests? voting with your wallet is orders of magnitude cheaper and easier than with your feet...
Re:What will our economic future look like? by vouaobrasil on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:47AM (#49627526)
I don't think they can make up for any mess. Because even if LLMs bring about a lack of scarcity across all domains, human beings will be alienated because indvidual differences and skills won't matter any more so we'll have to be genetically engineered to like that sort of future. I don't think a stable and healthy society can coexist with LLMs at all.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by idiotsecant on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:00AM (#49627748)
Individual skills and differences don't matter any less if the system of assigning value to human lives is divorced from how useful that human is to the collective.

If I am not graded on how many widgets I make in a shift and instead can focus on making the most beautiful widget, or the most novel widget, or simply the widget that is most useful to my particular life am I less satisfied?

We've somehow built a worldview based on our whole value as humans being equivalent to how good of a worker bee we are. Let's fix that part.

This is of course a much harder problem than achieving AGI, since it's a messy human problem.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by sublinear on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:23AM (#49628091)
Do a few bad grades really harm economic outcomes, though? Educators took a hard stance against AI rather quickly.

Outside of delusional grifty startups, the broader corporate world is only using copilot for taking meeting notes and (sort of) entertaining the notion of non-devs writing (and not maintaining) their own experimental janky apps where impact is low.

Outside of all the shit-stirrers on HN and clueless bubble social media, I don't see LLMs making a difference. In fact, the fearmongering is at this point insulting to the intelligence of the people who are supposedly helpless against big bad AI.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by wing-_-nuts on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:31AM (#49628225)
Oh hey, it's my point of view from a year ago...

It's definitely changed in that time

Re:What will our economic future look like? by sublinear on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:47AM (#49628492)
I've been hearing this retort every year. The only difference this time is you're not a green account.

If things have actually changed, you wouldn't be begging the question. LLMs, as popularly used, are still just a new kind of search engine for natural language answers to natural language questions. They're portable in a way, too. That's really cool tech, but not a revolution. It's pretty underwhelming compared to previous decades of change. It's a lot more error prone too, since it's a mudball of stats.

If we filter out the unsubstantiated fearmongering, all we've got left to discuss are NIMBY rants and geopolitics. At that point, we're not even talking about AI anymore.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by wing-_-nuts on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @02:54PM (#49632050)
>If we filter out the unsubstantiated fearmongering, all we've got left to discuss are NIMBY rants and geopolitics.

I'm sorry, what?

I'll put it to you again, you sound like me after playing around with gpt 3.5. It was interesting, but it wasn't good. There were still questions as to whether scaling would persist. My doubts were pretty much obliterated. LLMs haven't been mere text completion for a while now. Heck, even a model small enough to fit on my 3090 is now shockingly competent and useful. Does claude sometimes go off on weird tangents making me reel it in? Yeah, but it's genuinely great in present form, and it's the worst it'll ever be.

You're welcome to your opinion. It used to be mine too, but I disagree now. I find pretty much every AI benchmark has shown forward progress, some with non public datasets, and some things have gotten scarily better.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by weakfish on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:28PM (#49634638)
For me, at least, despite being obviously powerful, I just can’t find anything useful to do with it beyond toys.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by sublinear on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:46PM (#49634866)
You're also welcome to put your two cents in, but your replies sound identical to the bots and throwaways of last year and the year before that.

Every time it's the same agenda: trying to keep up appearances of meaningful engagement. In reality, I'm the only idiot willing to engage anymore and the opinion has always been majority negative on practical applications of LLMs from day one. It's not like anyone who frequents HN was blindsided by the initial release of ChatGPT like the rest of the public. The negativity has only grown since then.

There are important niches for LLMs, but they don't really make money without bigger ideas. I am very happy with the results for the broader topics of natural language processing and accessibility. Software is now easier to use and write. People have more agency over technology in general.

These are massive leaps. They are still tiny hops compared to what people's expectations were. That's only a failure of marketing, and a testament to its power even when botched. The end result is the same: the public yawns big and takes the almost invisible results for granted. Talking to a computer finally works like they expected over 20 years ago. Talking to a computer still sucks though. It's an entirely new genre of computer error.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by okaleniuk on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:59AM (#49627726)
Um. Damaging education, destroying people’s attention spans and their ability to learn, eroding trust within societies, increasing the wealth inequality, - all of that has already been done. Long before LLMs. And the only reason there is no class war is... exactly that. Uneducated people with short attention spans and no means beyond basic level are exemplary bad at modern warfare.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by dgellow on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:13AM (#49627927)
LLMs worsen all those existing problems, that’s the whole point being made here
Re:What will our economic future look like? by boogieknite on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:43PM (#49634831)
have one coworker whose clearly lost some ability to think critically because of their overreliance, near obsession, with llm chats. slightly worried they might lose their job

another coworker seems to be early on a similar path but has made some comments about the former coworkers ability that makes me hopeful they dont end up the same way

feels like im talking about old high school friends on a drug path or something. its only anecdotes and i imagine the "perceived damage" is reversible. point is: i think youre onto something about the net effect and were going to have popular definitions for the negative encounters were anecdotally sharing

im a "user" but make Claude interact in an educational format and require sources on assertions. looking back, ive unintentionally cast it as The Librarian from Snow Crash, except if Hiro challenged it frequently. must have been natural after reading Snow Crash a few times. maybe im kidding myself but it feels like i havent lost a step. if im not deluding myself then i could see a world where elementary schools teach responsible llm use of to preserve cognition the same way we had to learn Google boolean search

Re:What will our economic future look like? by pvab3 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:50PM (#49634918)
I can't imagine trying to be a teacher in 2026. I would have never written a single paper or problem set myself in HS and college.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by bradfa on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:25PM (#49637095)
Hand written exams are coming back into fashion. You get a pencil and the exam book. Nothing else. Show your work.

Catching cheaters is still hard but it will keep honest people more honest.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by pixl97 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:22PM (#49637571)
>You get a pencil and the exam book. Nothing else. Show your work.

Back in my day this was the only way!

Well, scantron cards for testing became more common near the end of school.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by pvab3 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @07:50AM (#49642168)
But if I were struggling with an assignment, stuck on a problem, I would have turned to AI after a few minutes of trying to figure it out, and thus lost out on the actual character-forming and memory-building aspects of college assignments.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by Quibblingeek on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @11:38PM (#49638111)
We won’t need teachers in ten years when the messiah’s of AI eliminate the need for real humans and their pesky needs for stupid things like..labor rights and human decency.

But we must continue because we’ll lose some sort of ideological Cold War with a country better positioned to win anyway. It’s all in the name of capitalism so the ends justify the needs.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by FlowingRiver on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @08:26PM (#49636566)
Long term I worry what happens when you absolutely gut out the mental capabilities of a generation or two.

We are only just now seeing the first stages of this, we are at the Facebook in 2008 stage trying to warn people about the societal fluctuations coming but many aren't listening because it is too useful.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by newsclues on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @08:44PM (#49636740)
Same net negative with smartphones and social media.
Re:What will our economic future look like? by nickpp on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:45AM (#49640452)
You can say all that about pretty much any technological advancement, like the computer itself. Heck, people said it about the invention of writing or the printing press!

However, looking back, each single invention was a net positive for us as a species.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by tancop on Thursday September 10, 2026 @07:20AM (#49641809)
- Attention spans are overrated. I know that because I have a pretty short one to the point it's annoying for others. It measures how much you're willing to focus on something you don't want more than the ability to focus on something you do want, like writing this reply. Losing that is a sign that people are tired of boring jobs and badly designed school work and old forms of entertainment that are only alive because of nostalgia or elitism.

- Asking an LLM is objectively a better learning method than reading books if the LLM is giving correct information (and I know that's a pretty big if). Cheating on homework is a workaround that only exists because graded homework is still a thing. If tests are hard enough and have unlimited retakes, kids will learn that practice is worth it and do it with way more focus than if it was forced.

- Inequality has been increasing for decades. It's an inevitable part of capitalism, when the rate of wealth increase is higher for the rich and well connected (like access to private funding rounds or portfolio managers) you get unlimited concentration. Even without that, when you have money left after basic expenses you can invest more of it than someone living paycheck to paycheck.

- Class wars are great. Hopefully we can avoid physical violence but if we can't then tough luck. Should have paid your taxes.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by munksbeer on Thursday September 10, 2026 @07:45AM (#49642116)
> If tests are hard enough and have unlimited retakes, kids will learn that practice is worth it and do it with way more focus than if it was forced.

Wow, I haven't thought deeply since seeing this comment, but on the surface this is actually a really nice idea.

Re:What will our economic future look like? by beepbopboopp on Thursday September 10, 2026 @11:01AM (#49644960)
I mean, this clearly a technology change. Would you have stopped the printing press because young people got worse at verbally telling the ancient stories? Or when kids stopped understanding what a card catologe was?

We are in the middle of a major change and it very well could be net negative, but for the most part history just keeps marching and its fine, just different.