News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The AirPods Effect by tptacek on Thursday June 18, 2026 @07:38PM (#48593069)
I don't remember any time in my life where it ever felt normal to me to randomly talk to strangers. I went to London when I was a teenager and was made uncomfortable by how chatty the cab drivers were. Later, I worked at a startup and my boss was preternaturally gifted at chatting up strangers, which he did habitually in every setting we were in when we traveled; on the plane, on the bus from the airport, &c. I remember feeling like he was a freak of nature.

And I'm not an introvert!

All of this long predates Airpods.

I think this is a cultural difference, not a technological shift.

Re:The AirPods Effect by exmadscientist on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:15PM (#48593376)
Talking to strangers is a skill. You can practice it! I've made a point of trying to practice, albeit halfheartedly, and even though it's difficult for me, because I like it when other people try to talk to me.

Earbuds stop this practice dead in its tracks. You can't deny that.

Re:The AirPods Effect by xquce on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:18AM (#48595747)
Agree with the first part, very important! Not the second, however.

I joined my local fitness gym some months ago and use it to connect to people in the small town I moved to. Almost every time I'm there I manage to chat to someone briefly, and 50% of them have earpods in. Most of them now look up and greet me when we pass and multiple have up to me on other days to chat afterwards.

It's a skill and part of that skill is being able to give people an out of the chat if they don't feel for it, not interrupting at a bad time (mid set in a gym setting). My starter is usually a quick question with a "thank you so much, I'm new here" and if they reach for earpods to put back as they say you welcome, perfect you don't keep going. For the ones who want to chat keep them off and respond or ask something in return.

So headphones/earpods can be a barrier but for me it's a useful barrier and a clear signal, which helps both parties.

Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:51AM (#48596392)
I just pretend I haven't noticed they have earbuds in and start talking to them. Virtually everyone seems happy to have an interaction, I get the feeling people are a bit starved for random friendly contact.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:03AM (#48597620)
> Virtually everyone seems happy to have an interaction

If a stranger bothers me while I have my headphones on I may act friendly and polite, but I am actually very irritated.

Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:22AM (#48683909)
It's actually funny if you talk to a lot of people, to see that so many are really excited to have a real, random little chat or comment. Even funnier is seeing the rare people who have completely forgotten the small pleasures of living among others.
Re:The AirPods Effect by kdheiwns on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:01AM (#48596820)
I don't wear AirPods/headphones of any sort in public but I don't like talking to strangers while out and about and get very uncomfortable since it's almost always someone trying to get something from me.

But every time someone does randomly talk to me, I smile and laugh and I'm very cordial. Because people who approach strangers generally get quite angry when they're outright shot down. That doesn't at all mean I'm happy to talk. A smile is often just a defensive response.

Re:The AirPods Effect by ChoGGi on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:08AM (#48598152)
Just trying to spread a little cheer and human connection, getting angry is the last thing I'd do.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:02AM (#48599413)
Amen!
Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:24AM (#48683923)
I think HN probably oversamples for people who like to be left alone, which I get. When I talk to strangers it's pretty easy to detect who would be open based on their clothing choices and body language.
Re:The AirPods Effect by steve1977 on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:55AM (#48596415)
I would get very irritated by such behavior. One reason I wear earbuds is to signal that I don't want to get talked to.
Re:The AirPods Effect by GJim on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:13AM (#48596535)
Have you tried simply telling people you don't want to talk?

"Sorry mate, I'm reading" is hardly difficult.

Re:The AirPods Effect by steve1977 on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:18AM (#48596559)
Why would you initiate talk with me in the first place, when we're in a situation where I have not explicitly chosen contact with you? (say on a train)

Also reading something would be a clear signal (also to me) that a person doesn't want to get disturbed.

When I have to tell you that I don't want to talk, you have already disturbed me. So, taking the cues here clearly is on you, not on me, at least in my opinion.

Edit: To clarify a bit, I'm talking about places with involuntary social contact, like for example a train or a grocery store. I go on a train because I have to get somewhere, not because I want to interact with people. It would be a different scenario say in a bar.

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:03AM (#48599440)
If you are in a public space, I think it's totally fair game to initiate talk. It's also totally fair game to signal that you aren't interested.
Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:54AM (#48596774)
If you're reading it's kinda obvious, and it's pretty annoying to be interrupted.
Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:28AM (#48683954)
actually i can say that most people with a book and no headphones are the most ready to have a chat about what they're reading and beyond.
Re:The AirPods Effect by techdmn on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:48AM (#48597966)
This is actually very difficult for a significant number of people. Some people really struggle with saying "no" or enforcing boundaries, some people are very wary of negative interactions with strangers. If you are relying on people to explicitly push back on you, rather than reading more subtle queues, you are quite likely adding stress to someone's day.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:05AM (#48599456)
I think most will pick up on subtle cues. That said, there is nothing wrong with being direct. And for those people who struggle with saying no, well, practice makes perfect.
Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:27AM (#48683945)
I choose to embody the society i would rather live in, instead of following along with the friendlessness and disconnection that results from our deteriorated social sphere. Most people are delighted to have a little contact.
Re:The AirPods Effect by dpkirchner on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:13AM (#48599566)
A dozen times a day, every day? No thanks.
Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:21AM (#48683903)
It's actually funny if you talk to a lot of people, to see that so many are really excited to have a real, random little chat or comment. Even funnier is seeing the people who have forgotten the small pleasures of living among others.
Re:The AirPods Effect by rimliu on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:07AM (#48596861)
So you are bad at reading signs. And that "seems happy" may be just "are too polite to punch you".
Re:The AirPods Effect by norome on Friday June 26, 2026 @04:19AM (#48683883)
when people don't want to talk, they keep one earbud in and the other ready to pop back in. then you say adios and move on. If someone punched me for a friendly comment It's clear who has the problem.
Re:The AirPods Effect by microtonal on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:08AM (#48596493)
Talking to strangers is a skill. You can practice it! I've made a point of trying to practice, albeit halfheartedly, and even though it's difficult for me, because I like it when other people try to talk to me.

It is definitely something one can learn. I also like it very much. Most people are just very nice and love chatting a bit as well (just be respectful of their time and know when to bow out).

There are also other functions that purely having a good time. E.g. when you are in a train with reserved seats, striking op a conversation is also a good way of gauging whether it's ok to leave your bags when you leave your seat to grab a drink or some food. Also, people feel more responsible looking after your stuff once you have socialized a bit.

For me it's not super-difficult. I came from a small village where it is normal to greet people and maybe chat, even if you don't know them.

Re:The AirPods Effect by dpkirchner on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:11AM (#48599532)
> Most people are just very nice and love chatting a bit as well

In my experience, this depends on the context. Everywhere I've lived the only time strangers try to talk to me is to either a) ask for directions (1%) or b) beg for money (99%).

I see people in these comments suggesting we should just say no thanks I don't want to chat -- I'd have to repeat that a dozen times a day. It's exhausting and I don't gain anything from it. I figure these folks must live in totally different locations.

> I came from a small village where it is normal to greet people and maybe chat, even if you don't know them.

Yeah, I could see that. If my village/city wasn't plagued by petition beggars or money beggars or merchant beggars I'd probably be more interested in engaging.

Re:The AirPods Effect by GJim on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:11AM (#48596524)
> Talking to strangers is a skill. You can practice it!

This is HN mate!

You need to design an app so people can practice it. (Alternately, rant something about "pick up artists").

Re:The AirPods Effect by Gigachad on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:41AM (#48597481)
The app should just disable your phone for the day so you have nothing to do but interact with the world.
Re:The AirPods Effect by GJim on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:20AM (#48599635)
We used to advocate governments turning off the internet on Friday nights and redirecting all WWW traffic to a test-card that says "Go to the pub".
Re:The AirPods Effect by pjc50 on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:42AM (#48596702)
> I like it when other people try to talk to me.

Probably an unpopular point on HN, but this is very gendered. There's a lot of women who don't want to be chatted up who wear headphones, and therefore a lot of men who are annoyed at this visible signal that the woman doesn't want to listen to them.

We can leave room for "not wearing headphones is a signal that you're open to talk" without having to pressure people who aren't.

Re:The AirPods Effect by petesergeant on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:02AM (#48597188)
> therefore a lot of men who are annoyed at this visible signal that the woman doesn't want to listen to them

I mean I'm sure there's a guy somewhere who's annoyed by this, but "a lot of men who are annoyed" feels like making up a group of people to be angry at.

Re:The AirPods Effect by ben_w on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:44AM (#48597934)
Given how the media amplify things, it could perhaps be literally just one guy, but FWIW I too have heard of the phenomenon pjc50 described.
Re:The AirPods Effect by mr_toad on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:12AM (#48598846)
> Given how the media amplify things, it could perhaps be literally just one guy

If you go to popular tourist spots in Europe there’s usually that one guy who’s trying to scam everyone who passes by. It only takes one to be a huge nuisance.

Re:The AirPods Effect by someguydave on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:22AM (#48598967)
yep. Just like it only takes a few prolific spammers to ruin email, it only takes a few antisocial con men to make "talking to strangers" seem like an imposition.
Re:The AirPods Effect by petesergeant on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:42AM (#48599885)
Sure, there are plenty of guys who are nuisances in all sorts of situations, but are there lots of guys who are angry that women use headphones?
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:59AM (#48599393)
> There's a lot of women who don't want to be chatted up who wear headphones

This is true, but so is the opposite! I think the most important thing is to be kind and receptive. It's fine to start a conversation with a women wearing headphones, just take it in stride and don't be weird about it if she isn't interested in talking. I do this (with men and women) a lot.

It is true that women are more likely to be approached by creeps, and due to the physical differences between the sexes women are at higher risk in such situations. That said, we shouldn't dismiss women as too delicate or whatever to chat with. They're people!

Re:The AirPods Effect by angiolillo on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:20PM (#48601487)
> It's fine to start a conversation with a women wearing headphones, just take it in stride and don't be weird about it if she isn't interested in talking. I do this (with men and women) a lot.

Not sure where you're from, but where I live, headphones are a well-understood signal that someone would rather not engage in conversation at the moment. Some have been conditioned to placate the kind of people who deliberately ignore these signals by engaging in brief small talk rather than risking a confrontation, but this shouldn't be misconstrued as an interest in talking.

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:07PM (#48602678)
Eastern Canada, where people are generally easy going and friendly. I'd be surprised and disappointed to hear things are different elsewhere, but I don't have the lived experience to say one way or another.
Re:The AirPods Effect by angiolillo on Monday June 22, 2026 @09:44AM (#48630037)
I've lived in a few US cities, but the example of NYC comes to mind. New Yorkers are happy to lend a hand if you're lost, struggling with a stroller on the stairs, or something falls out of your bag. And they're happy to chat at a concert, club, farmer's market, sporting event, carnival, conference, convention, etc.

But a stranger gesturing for you to take off your headphones while you're walking briskly down the street or riding the subway just so they can make smalltalk does not seem socially acceptable whether it's packed at rush hour or mostly empty at 1:00 in the morning.

Re:The AirPods Effect by aiisjustanif on Saturday June 20, 2026 @02:26AM (#48606857)
> headphones are a well-understood signal that someone would rather not engage in conversation at the moment

I live in a big city in the US and for myself and probably most my friend group, this rarely true. Maybe it’s because we are a bit extroverted or do work that is social. For me it’s more that I like music or a book, and just want a distraction from my commute. You can start a convo just don’t be rude and realize I might be getting off my stop soon.

Re:The AirPods Effect by aiisjustanif on Saturday June 20, 2026 @02:21AM (#48606831)
I don’t think it is unpopular as much as it might need clarification of culture and location. There are some countries where genders tend to talk their similar presenting gender in public setting like transportation.
Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:52AM (#48596764)
> Earbuds stop this practice dead in its tracks. You can't deny that.

Yes it's a signal. For you to go find someone else to talk to :)

That doesn't mean I'm antisocial, there's just places where I go to be open to talk to people. Like bars, meetups, stuff like that. And places where I'm just to get from A to B and I don't want to. Usually when I'm in public transport I'm going to/from the office and I'm stressed because I deeply hate working in the office since Corona (no more fixed desks etc). So I need my space.

Re:The AirPods Effect by rimliu on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:06AM (#48596850)
You may like it, others may not. I hate when random strangers talk to me. Unless you are skilled to distinguish willing from not, you are training your skill at the expense of others.
Re:The AirPods Effect by embedding-shape on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:09AM (#48596873)
Kind of black and white. I think everyone agrees to not chat up strangers sitting reading books, listening to music or whatever, but if you're idle, what's the harm in saying "No thanks, I don't want to chat" or something similar if someone asks you something?

And yes, of course don't try to speak with people who obviously don't want to be spoken to. Quick way to find out, is to ask "Can I ask you a question?" and then you leave space both for the people who don't want to chat, and the ones that do :)

I used to judge that based on people's faces, but the faces lie a lot, and some people basically default to looking pissed off, while they can be very warm people, and also vice-versa, so in the end asking up front seems to be the nicest way for everyone to be OK with it.

Re:The AirPods Effect by ubercow13 on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:20AM (#48597326)
What types of social interaction should be permitted in society?
Re:The AirPods Effect by Gigachad on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:42AM (#48597486)
HN is not a good place to ask about social skills.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:05AM (#48597634)
> I like it when other people try to talk to me.

I don’t.

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:01AM (#48599409)
Skill issue I'm afraid ;)

(Said as someone who used to feel the same way, before I discovered the joys of talking to strangers.)

Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:51AM (#48599971)
I don’t mind talking to strangers, I’m actually a very chatty and genial person. Some would even say that I don’t know how to shut up. I just don’t want people (strangers or otherwise) to interrupt me at times when I don’t want to talk.

My question is, why do you think you’re entitled to consume strangers’ time?

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:05PM (#48602661)
I think we see things differently. I view conversation as an offer, with no expectations either way. Whereas you seem to put more weight on it, I'd guess because the ADHD you mentioned in another comment means interruptions are more impactful for you. I'm not sure there is a way to bridge this gap, because for me (based both on my understanding of modern psychological research and personal experience), a world without talking to strangers is a much impoverished one emotionally and spiritually. I'm afraid I'm willing to throw your mental wellbeing out with the bathwater on this, though I feel bad about doing so.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Saturday June 20, 2026 @10:57AM (#48609679)
> I'm willing to throw your mental wellbeing out with the bathwater on this, though I feel bad about doing so.

So what, disabled people should just stay home? That’s your answer, just make society hostile to people like me?

I bet there’s a middle road that you’re not considering, but because it’s not important to you, the disabled person should just accept a lower quality of life for your convenience.

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:44PM (#48635060)
I'd love to learn about this middle road. As I said in my comment, I'm not happy with my conclusion.
Re:The AirPods Effect by dav43 on Thursday June 18, 2026 @07:55PM (#48593203)
My take, is that this effect has removed a lot of the micro communications we make - not necessarily random conversations. It’s taken away random moments that may trigger a short small conversation with strangers.

In part it’s taking away the shared experience in public and making it “my” experience.

Re:The AirPods Effect by garrickvanburen on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:27PM (#48593468)
Whether grocery shopping or an endurance running event (5K+) those with any kind of headphones in are simply less aware of the people trying to get around them.
Re:The AirPods Effect by bombcar on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:27PM (#48593848)
I heard they're thinking of putting cameras in the AirPods - so we'll just add collision avoidance (and backup alarms).
Re:The AirPods Effect by skywhopper on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:44AM (#48596719)
The folks without earbuds who park their grocery carts diagonally across the aisle while standing in the remaining empty space disagree with you.
Re:The AirPods Effect by mlinhares on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:30PM (#48593481)
Completely anecdotal story, me and a friend had completely different experiences going to Portugal. We're both Brazilians so language, food, culture aren't barriers, he's very talkative and would joke and try to interact with random people in the street or restaurants. He had a terrible experience, hated the country, vowed to never come back, said he wasn't welcomed anywhere, people were rude, even waitresses.

I'm more of a "talk when talk is needed" person but still social. i don't really interact with strangers in the street and I assume business social interactions (like restaurants) are just that, business, so I'm polite but i'm not going to crack a joke with someone i've never seen before and will likely never see again. My experience was the complete opposite, loved Portugal, would easily move there if salaries weren't shit, people were nice, i felt welcomed anywhere i went, might have been the only place outside of Brazil i have really felt at home.

I think its important to NOT BE RUDE with the random people you meet in the street but I also see no reason so strike a conversation with them. If I happen to see something that picks up my interest, like a band shirt, book i like or something like that, i might bring it up if we're going to stay in the same place for long, but starting a conversation out of nowhere just isn't a thing for me.

Re:The AirPods Effect by saghm on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:50PM (#48593628)
Sure, but when the only reason I had those random moments with strangers were because they wanted them, and refusing to engage is considered "rude", I'd argue that it already was just someone else's "my" experience before, just "shared" because of societal peer pressure. What changed is that now I have a way to actually assert my boundaries without being the rude one.
Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:50PM (#48593967)
I think it's a mistake to conflate passive signaling with asserting oneself, and whether you like the interaction you might have otherwise had or not (as long as it's not clearly harassment or something) it would be rude to ignore people in public whether that rudeness is delegated to technology or not. It's just another way of turning up one's nose, and it's a gross way to operate imo. If you don't like the people you'd interact with, it seems to me like it should be a personal goal to find a place to work or live that's more palatable from that perspective. If you go about life preferring to pre-emptively refuse interaction with people passively, I'm not aware of a better word than "rude".
Re:The AirPods Effect by skywhopper on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:43AM (#48596708)
Wow, it’s wild that you think you have a right to the attention of strangers with whom you have no business. How is it rude to wish to go about one’s day unbothered?
Re:The AirPods Effect by CosmicShadow on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:45AM (#48597509)
I think if you are in public, you can't expect to be in private. You can try, but it obviously doesn't always work and we are exposed to all types when out of the house.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:16AM (#48597706)
This has nothing to do with expectation of privacy. Private setting or public setting, it’s rude to bother people who are busy.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:08AM (#48599496)
Some of you are unwell.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:45AM (#48599912)
I am unwell; I have ADHD and if someone interrupts me it takes me a long time to get back on track. It’s very inconsiderate.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:46AM (#48599927)
That's fair. I'm sorry you have to deal with that.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:55AM (#48600014)
The problem is that you don’t know what the person that you randomly chat up is dealing with. You could be doing this kind of thing to anyone.

If I have earbuds in, I’m probably listening to classical music. It helps me self-regulate in busy environments. I’m not listening to podcasts (which everyone assumes now, I guess).

If you interrupt me, I’m going to be polite. You won’t know that you’re causing a problem because I don’t like to be a jerk to strangers. That could be happening every time you talk to a stranger for all you know.

People like to make talking to random strangers seem somehow romantic, but it’s actually just selfish. You’re not interrupting my focus for me, you’re doing it for you.

Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:10PM (#48600158)
> You’re not interrupting my focus for me, you’re doing it for you.

While it may be selfish and pointless, it's the default expectation that in public space people can be spoken to, but it costs something to remove that possibility without also physically isolating oneself in some way. Not all public space is necessarily social, you can be alone in a wooded glen which creates a proximity barrier, but trying to preserve your whole private sphere while being in an otherwise potentially social space removes something from that space.

When I deliberately don't want to chat with anyone, I just take a side street or something. Not always possible, but it's rarely worth it; usually work is the semi-public space I'd prefer unbroken focus.

I do think it's overblown to make some grand statement about this behavior if it's only an occasional thing, but if the default expectation shifts to people hesitating to talk to people only because they might have headphones in, I think we've lost something.

Re:The AirPods Effect by jnovek on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:30PM (#48601624)
> it's the default expectation that in public space people can be spoken to

It is not the social norm that anyone can be spoken to in public at any time, you are oversimplifying things. E.g. it is largely considered socially inappropriate to strike up a conversation with a stranger on public transit when you’re squeezed in like sardines; we don’t talk to each other to give the illusion of privacy and space. It’s also not considered socially acceptable to have a conversation with a stranger standing at a urinal. There are significant social rules about which adults and children can speak to each other in social spaces. Etc etc

There are and always have been situations where it is more or less socially acceptable to speak to a stranger in public. Headphones is not a new one, I knew in the 90s that headphones meant “don’t talk to me”.

Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:00PM (#48600068)
I also have ADHD, but the onus is not on others to compensate for that; it wouldn't be labelled unless it prevented us from being compatible with the conplexities of daily life unaided by stimulants. People envy the way I can banter with randoms if I want to, but if I don't, I move on, and deliberately have to practice not getting too derailed.
Re:The AirPods Effect by saghm on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:30PM (#48602286)
If you legitimately think that anyone who isn't extroverted in the same way as you is "unwell", I feel like you could use a lot of therapy yourself.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:48PM (#48602478)
Saying things like "it's rude to bother people who are in public" (paraphrased) is antisocial and reflective of our time, where people live increasingly isolated and atomistic lives, not of human nature. My point is people who are not open to experiencing the lives of others around them are, as social animals, unwell. It's also worth noting that I don't think this is the fault of any individual (although my initial comment was not clear on this point) but rather of modern society which so thoroughly devalues what is human in favour of what is material and saleable.

Edit: I'm also very much an introvert, FWIW.

Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:26PM (#48601576)
Seems like a tragedy of the commons. People don't have a right to your attention necessarily, but you also don't have the right to be unbothered arbitrarily.
Re:The AirPods Effect by saghm on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:19AM (#48598252)
I think your attitude that going out in public is tacitly opting into interactions with strangers is a much more gross way to operate. The assumption that it's easy to just politely decline a conversation (and that not doing so in the form of a conversation itself) seems like an extremely narrow-minded point of view based on your own subjective experience. You're conflating social anxiety with the desire to "assert oneself", when it's closer the opposite; socially anxious people quite often don't want to assert themselves, which is exactly why the "just politely decline" strategy is misses the mark so badly. The fact that wearing the earbuds opts out of that passively rather than actively is the entire reason it's desirable.

In one of my other comments in this thread, I explicitly called out that this desire has nothing to do with like or dislike of the people who I might have social pressure to interact with. Some people find social interaction a net expenditure of energy even with people they like, and having to do that repeatedly throughout the day because I want to go to the doctor or something and society has decided that it's "rude" if I don't engage with literally anyone who happens to want to talk to me when I'm in public is honestly just silly. It's not like I'm keeping the earbuds in and refusing to talk to anyone when checking in at the waiting room; I just don't care to have to have a chat with my Uber driver or strangers on the subway while I'm out, and it's ridiculous to imply that I should just never go in public if I don't feel the way you do.

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:07AM (#48599484)
What is the public if not the space where we interact with others?
Re:The AirPods Effect by saghm on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:29PM (#48602273)
The place between my house and all of the other places I might need to go? Is your argument that people should just not go to the doctor or get driver's licenses unless they're willing to interact with every stranger who wants to talk to them lest they be "rude"? I don't understand how you can in good faith claim that needing to do something obligatory outside of their house or apartment is actively opting into social interaction with literally everyone else in public.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:59PM (#48602590)
You can simply decline the conversation. It's not as big of a deal as you are making it out to be. I'm not saying you have to actively opt into social interaction, whatever that means. I'm saying its reasonable for others to offer social interaction if you're in public.
Re:The AirPods Effect by saghm on Saturday June 20, 2026 @12:50PM (#48610724)
"You can simply decline the conversation" and "it's not a big deal" are entirely subjective and based on the assumption that being extroverted is normal. Your rules of etiquette are that I need to go out of my way to give people the opportunity to talk to me so that I can tell them not to rather than just signaling to them that I don't want to (which saves us both time and lets me quietly enjoy some music on the meantime), which is just bizarre.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:43PM (#48635050)
Your preferred default is also entirely subjective. I'm also not an extrovert. My friends all acknowledge my extreme introversion.
Re:The AirPods Effect by MarkSweep on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:35PM (#48600398)
You say “as long as it's not clearly harassment” as if that is uncommon. Outside of giving directions at train stations, the times when a stranger has started talking to me in public have been almost universally negative. Often times it starts as a friendly conversation before the harassment or begging for money or scamming starts. Other times the people just start out crazy or harassing.

I feel like your conception that “ignoring people either consciously or through technology is rude” makes more sense in higher social trust situations. Like at a party or a bar, where bad actors are less dense and there is an expectation of socializing.

Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:19PM (#48601481)
> I feel like your conception that “ignoring people either consciously or through technology is rude” makes more sense in higher social trust situations.

Yes, but I meant that the more people who block everyone out by default, passively and indiscriminately, contributes to social rust rather than trust. Ignoring or especially telling some people is not inherently rude or bad, but conducting yourself as though everyone is de-facto untrustworthy is a problem that doesn't seem likely to be solved by passively blocking the world out.

Like I added, I don't know why I'd pay to live somewhere where I'd prefer not to interact with anyone. If the place actually does suck, then I should do everything in my power to find somewhere that sucks less.

If you have social anxiety or ADHD, those are personal issues that need to be managed, but I still don't think it's generally a good idea to pick the easiest, least superficially confrontational method to signal that you don't want to talk to anyone.

Re:The AirPods Effect by MarkSweep on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:14PM (#48604415)
> people who block everyone out by default, passively and indiscriminately, contributes to social rust rather than trust

I'll turn this around: when I see people wearing headphones on the train or the bus, I appreciate that they respect everyone around them. Silence is a commons, and the headphone people respect that not everyone wants to hear their TikToks, their phone calls, their hallucinations, or their small talk.

> conducting yourself as though everyone is de-facto untrustworthy is a problem that doesn't seem likely to be solved by passively blocking the world out

Actually it does. Dealing with touts and sales people by ignoring them is usually more effective at getting them to leave you alone. If you engage at all, they manipulate your sense of politeness to draw you into a longer conversation or get you to do what they want. This is also true of most types of grifters and assholes.

Every time I got drawn into a scam or harassment, I could have prevented it by simply not engaging in the first place.

> I don't know why I'd pay to live somewhere where I'd prefer not to interact with anyone. If the place actually does suck, then I should do everything in my power to find somewhere that sucks less.

I live in the SF Bay Area and frequently visit Boston and Japan. In this limited experience, I've had a great time meeting strangers in social situations like at bars. I have never had a positive result from giving a stranger the time of day in public places (outside of giving directions). Maybe these places suck and I should leave, idk, but don't judge me for taking a default deny stance after consistently having negative experiences.

And this is just my male perspective. My female friends have even stronger stances against engaging with random people in public.

Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @08:28PM (#48667249)
There's a subtle difference between what each of us is describing I think. It seems you're arguing that wearing headphones in public isn't generally inherently rude, and you have a selection of anecdotes to support it, and I'd agree that those are plausible and fine.

Incidentally I have no interest in living in SF, Boston, or Japan for various reasons, but it is interesting that I also wouldn't necessarily anticipate they'd be suitable for completely random friendly, welcomed interactions, in transit or wherever. Japan gives me a very siloed, weirdly socially isolated vibe, Boston I haven't been to, and SF just gives me a sort of aggressive individualist capitalism achievement chasing vibe. California cities in general feel like a departure from what I like.

However, I'm not exclusively talking about literally accepting every random encounter in public transit or on the street only. In those places, you do have bars, gyms, third-spaces, cafes, etc.. that are for the most part, "public"; you should be able to connect with people in your community and avoid signalling that you aren't there to participate.

I'd basically agree that wearing headphones out in the world at all is not inherently rude, but wearing them in all of those places, an overwhelming majority of the time, intending to avoid almost any interaction with strangers, is deliberately socially rusty. It almost seems like a strawman I'm arguing against, but it's my impression that's what the ease of AirPods enable, compared to larger less-convenient headphones. You can leave your house with the AirPods in, no wires, take calls without your hands, go to the gym, do your shopping, go to the park, go for a jog, bike ride, and keep the world out end-to-end. It's my view that unless you have a real sensory issue, that's shit for everyone involved at some scale.

Edit: I'd accept that I may not have articulated that so well in prior comments, but thought the overall was implied to mean the degree to which AirPods uniquely enable this

Re:The AirPods Effect by basisword on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:18PM (#48593393)
I definitely think it's generational. Every person I know over 50 could talk to a brick wall for hours. The people I know 30-40 it's a struggle for at least half of them. Under 30 and it gets much worse.

Even the older introverted people I know, who I would characterise as quiet, would find it really rude to get in a taxi and not chat to the driver for the duration of the journey.

With people doing their entire careers remotely now I can only see this shift happening faster and more intensely. Small talk is a skill like any other and I think it's a sad skill to lose on a societal level. And I say this as a serious introvert that doesn't love to make small talk. Nine times out of ten, when I do make the effort to e.g. talk to a taxi driver I come away happier.

Re:The AirPods Effect by AaronAPU on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:28PM (#48593471)
I’ve noticed the age gradient as well. It’s hard to miss.
Re:The AirPods Effect by sanswork on Thursday June 18, 2026 @07:57PM (#48593222)
My mom was one of those people that talked to people everywhere we went and seemed to know someone everywhere too. As a very shy kid I was constantly mortified but I had the startling realisation several years back that I'm that person now just starting conversations all over the place. Oddly enough seeing your comment I think the change happened when I moved to England in my late teens but I didn't recognise it until my 30s. I do wear my airpods a lot on walks these days but I always silence them as I approach people and regularly take them out if it seems like a conversation is about to start.
Re:The AirPods Effect by haaz on Thursday June 18, 2026 @07:58PM (#48593229)
as someone who enjoys talking to strangers, while it is less common in some countries like China, and big cities in most countries, people tend to react mostly the same.
Re:The AirPods Effect by coldtea on Thursday June 18, 2026 @07:58PM (#48593228)
This is common experience also in ND vs NT differences.
Re:The AirPods Effect by fundad on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:01PM (#48593248)
Agreed. These people seem to be panicking that our precious society is suffering because of choices people are making for themselves when that’s just what society is. If they benefit from talking to more people, go ahead and enjoy the benefits. They aren’t owed anything.

I’ll talk to strangers when it makes me feel good. But most of the time I try avoid inviting weirdos to complain about minorities or marginalized people from someone who has driven away anyone close to them.

Re:The AirPods Effect by basisword on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:20PM (#48593420)
>> I try avoid inviting weirdos to complain about minorities or marginalized people from someone who has driven away anyone close to them.

I would suggest that it's your avoidance of talking to strangers that makes you think this is how a lot of them think. And it kind of proves the point that society can suffer because of it. If you went out tomorrow and talked to 100 random strangers for 10mins I'd be surprised if any of them complained about minorities.

Re:The AirPods Effect by fundad on Thursday June 18, 2026 @11:59PM (#48594636)
I said in my post that I DO talk to strangers. It makes me feel good when that’s what I want. It’s also true that most of y’all are sus AF.
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:13AM (#48599558)
I find your negative view of humanity saddening. I think most people are basically good.
Re:The AirPods Effect by angiolillo on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:48PM (#48601826)
That is my experience as well -- most people are basically good.

But my personal experience has also been that the sort of people who ignore social cues and try and chat someone up who is wearing headphones while riding public transit or working out are generally less good.

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:59PM (#48602597)
I think there is some truth to that, especially on public transit.
Re:The AirPods Effect by Natfan on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:27PM (#48593847)
check out some vox populi, you would be surprised
Re:The AirPods Effect by XorNot on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:16PM (#48593784)
That is statistically unlikely. Almost everyone has a "racist uncle" type story and that's what, out of 10 people in your family tops?

Chances are at least 20 of them would.

Re:The AirPods Effect by BoingBoomTschak on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:48AM (#48596382)
Most of the racist uncles don't use that as first subject with complete strangers, that's more of a family thing.
Re:The AirPods Effect by basisword on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:35AM (#48597012)
>> Almost everyone has a "racist uncle" type story

IRL I've never met one real person that has a 'racist uncle'.

Re:The AirPods Effect by anon-3988 on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:06PM (#48593728)
> Agreed. These people seem to be panicking that our precious society is suffering because of choices people are making for themselves when that’s just what society is. If they benefit from talking to more people, go ahead and enjoy the benefits. They aren’t owed anything.

I hope you don't complain when people use social media or have LLM as their daddy to cope then :)

Re:The AirPods Effect by fundad on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:16AM (#48594706)
Yes that’s my definition of freedom.
Re:The AirPods Effect by bsder on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:21PM (#48593429)
It's one thing to isolate against strangers in a subway. It's another thing to be goddamn oblivious in a shared space like a grocery store--to take a random (not) example. It's getting to the point that I have to body up to people to get them to take notice that they're blocking a half dozen of us.

I also do agree with the comment that airpods do seem to get in the way of the most basic of social etiquette. Simple "please" and "thank you" are increasingly rare since you can't recognize the cues when your ears are full of something else.

Re:The AirPods Effect by saghm on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:48PM (#48593608)
As someone who is often pretty introverted, I feel like wireless earbuds just give me a way to act like I already wanted to with less friction. I pretty rarely want to talk to random strangers, not because I have anything against them, but because I just find it takes a lot of energy for me to do so (probably not in small part from having to replicate a lot of what comes naturally from others in terms of social signal reading with extra effort). People seem to be a lot less likely to randomly initiate conversations with me when I'm out in public with my earbuds on, and that saves me from having to decide between feeling even more tired after going out or the awkwardness of trying to cut off the conversation short to avoid spending energy on it.
Re:The AirPods Effect by DANmode on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:39PM (#48604132)
This comment made me think of AirPods usage like eye-glasses usage.
Re:The AirPods Effect by wenc on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:14PM (#48593776)
As someone from Chicago (actual Chicago, south side, not the suburbs), randomly talking to strangers is what we do.

We're talking to strangers at the bus stop, at the grocery check out, or just wherever. It's just phatic conversation, nothing needs to come of it. Chicagoans aren't just friendly, they actually love the art of the conversation -- every conversation is a chance to put in the reps.

But the minute you step into the suburbs, this habit disappears.

Re:The AirPods Effect by tptacek on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:14AM (#48594696)
I grew up on the south side and lived for years in Lakeview; we moved back from Ann Arbor to Oak Park, much later, the only time I've lived "in the suburbs", and Oak Park is more urban than Beverly or Jeff Park are. And then, of course, even after we moved to Oak Park, I still worked in the city every day.

No, this doesn't track my experience of Chicago at all.

Re:The AirPods Effect by pinko on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:44AM (#48596352)
It's a class thing more than a geography thing. Culturally working-class urban Americans are chatty in almost every American city, save the most recently-urbanized ones (like PHX -- and even there there Latinos are chatty even if whitey ain't...)
Re:The AirPods Effect by throwaway2037 on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:26PM (#48601588)
Reading a bunch of these posts, a similar thought occurred to me. When I lived for a short time in Manhattan, I found the friendliest / most chatty were always working class types that ran small businesses or worked in the trades. I wonder if it is nothing more than these people are much more exposed to "strangers" through their professions. As a result, they are much less afraid to open a conversation.
Re:The AirPods Effect by brailsafe on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:58PM (#48594021)
> But the minute you step into the suburbs, this habit disappears.

This is exactly the feeling I get in the suburbs of most places, and I think the nature of car-centric suburbs serves as a decent analogy for the Airpodsification of otherwise more urban areas. Suburbanites want their palace that they can tightly control, and it rarely matters where it is as long as they can drive to anywhere they need to go, but they don't really like people and it feels like a deeply antisocial liminal space. There's rarely any specific reason anyone would want to be there, and even if they did, they'd have to drive, and if they chose not to, people there use their cars as tools for avoiding interactions with strangers. You wake up, get in your motorized comfort bubble / killing machine, and then drive from point A to B and then back to Point A. If you wanted to go hangout, oftentimes the act of driving that you've chosen sucks all that time away anyway. Drivers then get dogs so they have some sort of excuse to interact with other people who have dogs, or kids or whatever.

Then if they're lucky, they wake up one day and realize they don't see any real friends that aren't their immediate neighbors anymore, and they've lost the ability to understand how to meet people outside of work. Their old friends didn't come out for that bbq because it's dead boring and the bbq master is the only one that doesn't have a commute back. The bar in their basement sits empty because it turns out people actually want to go to the pub instead of sitting in the basement. The novelty was never the drinking itself, but the feeling of coming together in the same space and place as other people hanging out having a good time.

Re:The AirPods Effect by throwaway2037 on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:40PM (#48601725)

    > Suburbanites want their palace that they can tightly control
Don't rich people do the same in big cities? That has been my experience. They live in enormous apartments or private homes and drive everywhere. The richest have a personal driver and assistant to do all the chores in their life. The difference with all the other people in that big city: They cannot afford to do the same. The suburbs allows the middle class a chance to get that (some) level of control that they can afford.
Re:The AirPods Effect by projektfu on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:28AM (#48596965)
My experience of Chicago (North side) was that it was full of polite but unfriendly people. This was jarring to my experience growing up in NY, where people tend to be more rude but friendly. I settled in Atlanta, where people are more polite but quite friendly.
Re:The AirPods Effect by jasonfarnon on Thursday June 18, 2026 @09:16PM (#48593786)
Well, what culture are you saying patterns like you?
Re:The AirPods Effect by DANmode on Thursday June 18, 2026 @10:33PM (#48594218)
> And I'm not an introvert!

Consider that you may be!

You’re just surrounded by other people who are also introverted to the point you don’t stand out to yourself.

I’ve driven almost 4000 people home from the airport. It’s almost annoyingly ubiquitous for people to chat up the driver.

Re:The AirPods Effect by fragmede on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:05AM (#48596472)
If I didn't want to talk to a person, I'd just take a Waymo.
Re:The AirPods Effect by Cockbrand on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:57AM (#48597158)
This may not always be an option for the somewhat more than 8 billion people who don't live in areas served by Waymo.
Re:The AirPods Effect by fragmede on Saturday June 20, 2026 @07:20AM (#48608402)
How long do you think that's going to be true? The other "gotcha" is that some 26 percent of humans aren't on the Internet.

I'm sorry, the guidelines state that we should assume the strongest possible argument.

What part of the world could possibly reject the onslaught of an American advertising campaign? If you don't have TVs to see our ads on, well give them to ya!

Re:The AirPods Effect by ErroneousBosh on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:20AM (#48596173)
> I don't remember any time in my life where it ever felt normal to me to randomly talk to strangers > And I'm not an introvert!

See that's interesting, because I *am* an introvert, but I'm quite happy to sit and talk to strangers. I don't mind it at all.

One of the few cultural similarities that I feel like London has with Scotland (where I live) is that you can just talk to people. People will talk. If you go to Glasgow and you ask for directions, chances are that the person you ask will walk with you to where you're going and point out good places to eat and interesting things to see along the way. Boston people have just learned this in a big way.

My son is even more so, and at not-quite-six he already appears to know most of the people in the town of 14,000 people where we live, how their farms are doing, how are the cows, what weight of potatoes are they getting per hectare, what prices they're getting at market, how they're getting on with that gearbox problem with the van. It takes about an hour to walk the mile or so back from school because he's got to talk to all the old guys and ask how they're doing.

Social Networking at its finest. I suspect he won't be stuck for a job when he's older.

Re:The AirPods Effect by SyneRyder on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:42AM (#48596335)
That's strange to me that you mention London as being similar to Glasgow. I've not had the chance to visit either, but my go-to on this topic has always been this faux news story on the Mash Report:

Northener Terrifies Londoners By Saying "Hello"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1YxLiLFjYKc

I hadn't noticed it before, but they even specifically mention the use of headphones as a defense mechanism near the end.

Re:The AirPods Effect by __alias on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:53AM (#48596412)
Yeah the most unbelievable part of this is people randomly chatting in London.

I live in London, and I remember flying to Ireland at some point, and I was seated next to an Irish lady returning home from holiday who sparked up a conversation.

My initial reaction was "Why the fuck are you talking to me?" because I had lived in London so long I was thrown off by a random person sparking conversation. But turns out she was just a lovely Irish lady flying from from holiday

Re:The AirPods Effect by ErroneousBosh on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:12AM (#48596883)
Maybe it depends on where you are and the cultural makeup of the part of London you're in, then?

As an aside, I used to work for the company in Glasgow that build The Daily Mash's website before they got all into the ad-heavy money-at-all-costs thing. It used to be much better and the guys behind are actually pretty decent.

Re:The AirPods Effect by throwaway2037 on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:43PM (#48601752)

    > It takes about an hour to walk the mile or so back from school because he's got to talk to all the old guys and ask how they're doing.
Wow, this really pushes back against the all might HN narrative that the world is now too dangerous to allow this. You have found a real gem of living. My guess: The farmers are probably all too happy to have a young curious lad to talk with a few times a week!
Re:The AirPods Effect by ErroneousBosh on Saturday June 20, 2026 @01:32PM (#48611141)
He's too little to walk by himself just now - he's not quite six, and there are a couple of busy roads.

But he'll just kind of wander about in the park and chat to folk, talk for hours to people at the farmer's market, that kind of thing.

Re:The AirPods Effect by microtherion on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:58AM (#48596428)
Yes, I experienced this a number of times in my life.

Growing up in a small Swiss village I wasn’t born in, I had to learn that you basically greeted everybody you passed in the road, under the assumption that you knew them or were supposed to know them (more conversations were not needed).

Moving to a large Swiss village, I had to learn that saying hi to random strangers was considered weird at best.

First time I visited Southern California, I was very uncomfortable with strangers striking up random conversations. Later in the trip in San Franciso, I felt that the slightly toned down form of this habit was more comfortable for me.

Moving back to Switzerland after having lived in CA for a few years, I had to relearn old habits.

Re:The AirPods Effect by Anthony-G on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:03AM (#48597618)
Similar experience here. I grew up in rural Ireland in the 80s where you said hello to everyone but had a culture shock when I moved to Dublin for college. I quickly realised that you don’t greet everyone. I put it down to a being a matter of scale: in the countryside, it’s easy to say hello to everyone when you’ll usually encounter only a small number of people. It’d be impossible to say hello to everyone in a big city.

I still say hi to people when doing things like hiking a trail that’s off the beaten track: we’re sharing a similar experience and have that one thing in common. If it’s a popular trail or busy weekend, it’s more akin to being in a large town where you don’t say hello.

Another rural-urban division in Ireland is that in the countryside, car drivers greet oncoming drivers – whether they know each other or not – by subtly raising a finger or two while keeping their hands on the steering wheel. Since the 80/90s, this custom has been dying out in the counties near Dublin but I still see it in the West of Ireland. A few years ago, we were holidaying in West Cork and my wife was driving but hadn’t realised we were being greeted by the locals. As a Dubliner, she’d never even heard of this practice.

Edit: By the way, I just noticed your username. Seeing that you’re from Switzerland, I was wondering if it’s a reference to the Celtic Frost album?

Re:The AirPods Effect by donohoe on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:28AM (#48597809)
Oh, I’d forgotten about this! I never drive much in Ireland but was in the car a lot with my dad as a kid. When he’d visit family in Longford this was happening all the time - I just assumed everyone knew him!

Years later, when I’ve been driving and visiting the country, I found myself on the receiving end of this and it all clicked.

Thank you for this wonderful reminder.

Re:The AirPods Effect by ChoGGi on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:15AM (#48598202)
I usually see a hand wave, or lazy salute around rural Western Canada.

Probably a rural everywhere thing?

Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:09AM (#48599514)
Common in rural eastern Canada too.
Re:The AirPods Effect by throwaway2037 on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:24PM (#48601549)

    > Probably a rural everywhere thing?
I would agree from my experiences living in different countries.
Re:The AirPods Effect by psp99 on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:58AM (#48597586)
grüezi!
Re:The AirPods Effect by Brajeshwar on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:59AM (#48596437)
I’ve strange news from the business world. That ability to talk to strangers and be conversational with various topics is actually making him a rather successful boss/business-person. Remember, not just talking, but the far better one is the ability to listen, and take genuine curiosity in the other person’s stories.

I learned, and am still learning, to start with very subtle conversations in contextual proximity to the person without shocking/surprising them. And then, I mostly try to listen more and try to guide them to talk more. You will be surprised at how many a lot are eager to talk to someone, if they are being listented to.

Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:49AM (#48596746)
I'm sure that's true but not everyone is cut out to be a "business-person". I certainly am not. Same with boss, I'm not a team player at all.

I don't mind small talk sometimes but there has to be some kind of common ground. For example with conservative family-first suit types I have nothing to talk about and it feels awkward to make conversation, but with the leather/mesh/blue hair alt/goth types I can talk for hors.

Re:The AirPods Effect by psp99 on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:57AM (#48597576)
Assuming you have nothing in common with someone because of how they dress is just prejudice with better aesthetics :/

The suit guy probably has more interesting stories than you'd expect if you gave him thirty seconds.

Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:58AM (#48598675)
If someone wears a suit they have a reason for it, it's not something people do because they like the feel of it. Because they're really restrictive, expensive and feel horrible. They do it to impress others or to fit in in business. Or when they're trying to sell something.

I'm more comfortable among other outliers.

Re:The AirPods Effect by goodmythical on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:32AM (#48599077)
You think the green haired folks are doing it because bleaching and dyeing their hair is just super duper fun? They're doing it for the same reasons: attention, approval, to fit in with their peers, trying to sell their identity to their peers.
Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:00PM (#48604768)
Well yes I think so. It is fun and cool. I love my crazy outfits too. It's not really about the peers though it's nice getting compliments at parties. It's more about feeling good about myself and feeling like it matches who I am.

Also they feel really good due to the materials being very smooth. Latex in particular is really like a second skin.

I would never feel good in a business suit because it's not who I am. Even if the fabric wouldn't feel horrible I would still be miserable. They're all the same too, like a uniform.

Re:The AirPods Effect by goodmythical on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:42PM (#48605829)
And you can't see, at all, that the folks who choose to wear business suits feel precisely the same way?

That they like getting compliments from the people they interact with? That it makes them feel good about themselves and feel like it matches who they are?

That the suit feels good too them due to the materials being quality and expensive?

That they would never feel good in leather because it's not who they are? That even if the leather wasn't sweaty and sticky, they'd still feel horrible?

Both of y'all are doing the same shit. You're wearing what you want to wear because it feels good to you and it feels good to you because you get compliments on it and getting compliments on it means that you've been accepted by the group you wish to be accepted by.

The suit and the leather gimp suit are the same thing. The vest and the kapris are the same thing. The turtle neck and the neck tie are the same thing. They are all status symbols. They all say "I want to talk to people dressed like this" and probably "I don't want to talk to anyone who dresses like that"

Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Saturday June 20, 2026 @08:30AM (#48608762)
It's not all about compliments. Those are not that important.

But if a business suit matches who they are then I'm not really interested in them. Which is what I said in the first place. I really hate business and the kind of people that spew PR bullshit on LinkedIn for example.

Re:The AirPods Effect by derektank on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:30AM (#48599746)
If your suits feel bad you’re probably not wearing the right suits. They are expensive though, that’s definitely true, so it does reveal some of their preferences.
Re:The AirPods Effect by tennfown on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:39AM (#48599840)
How much money do I need to get a suit that’s not miserable in 90f+ humid heat where even stepping outside in shorts and a t-shirt has you sweating after a few minutes?
Re:The AirPods Effect by groceries8192 on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:54PM (#48600545)
I don't think it's necessarily the suit in that case. As a Florida resident, however, I like my Tommy Bahama suit's breathability but it might not be formal enough for every occasion. There's also some "super breathable" suit that I see being advertised a lot, but I haven't tried one of those.
Re:The AirPods Effect by skydhash on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:57PM (#48603757)
There's a reason suits were not invented in such weather
Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:46PM (#48604692)
Good point, but I'm very sensitive to clothing. I just can't wear them anymore, and I don't have one that fits. The only one I had was just bought in a store. But it was awful.

But really a job where I'd have to wear one means a job working with business people and I would be very bad at that anyway.

For weddings I just don't go if it's too formal, though most of my friends are very polyamorous. If they even marry it's not a huge deal.

Re:The AirPods Effect by dbvn on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:21AM (#48597752)
> I'm not a team player at all

could ya try?

Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:56AM (#48598645)
No. I don't want to change who I am.
Re:The AirPods Effect by goodmythical on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:30AM (#48599049)
>For example with conservative family-first suit types

"hey man, how're the kids?" "Is your wife recovering from [illness] you mentioned last week?" "man, have heard the music on the radio lately?" "what kind of music do you like?" "can I ask you a personal question, what was the hardest part of getting the success you have?" "did you know you wanted to be a boss/manager when you were a kid? No? Oh, you wanted to be an astronaut? Oh man, no way, have you seen the crazy stuff spacex is doing with re-useable rockets? We're getting so close to (relevant sci-fi from when he was a kid)"

You've just got to have an open mind, which you'd think you'd have given your conversational partner preferences.

Re:The AirPods Effect by XorNot on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:35AM (#48599797)
"SpaceX is a fraud. Its all about control. That's why in the future you'll be eating bugs because it's Greta Thunberg".

I am only partly paraphrasing actual conversation with my father in-law.

I cannot stress enough that what you think will work here doesn't: literally every topic will be pivoted towards a rant about which groups are destroying the future (all of them), or how it's all a conspiracy or how they are plotting against you.

You've invented a conversation you think works. I have lived a damn decade of the list of "safe" topics endlessly shrinking, and the punchline is same: 30 damn minutes of alternately being told some half remembered conspiracy theory from Facebook or asking for agreement that group are bad.

That scifi concept from when they were kid? Well they are lying about that for money of course.

It is exhausting to deal with over and over again.

Re:The AirPods Effect by SoftTalker on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:20PM (#48600240)
It's equally tiring hearing about how every problem in society is a result of capitalism and how conservatives are all facists and are scheming for a way to bring back concentration camps and want to deport everyone who doesn't have three generations of native-born ancestors.

There are fringe kooks at all edges of the spectrum and they are all tiring and boring.

But most guys on the train wearing a suit are just normal people who have to dress like that because their work requires it.

Re:The AirPods Effect by wolvoleo on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:52PM (#48604725)
Good point but that's exactly what we in the LGBT community have had to deal with for years now. After a while the will to find a common ground just gets eroded. But that is a bad thing, I agree.

And the thing is a lot of MAGA people do want these things. Otherwise they wouldn't happen.

But yes part of the blame lies with me too. It is as you say very tiring.

Re:The AirPods Effect by goodmythical on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:52PM (#48605542)
I strongly feel that that's the thing that's mitigated modern queer integration into popular society.

I understand that being either loud and proud or even just unabashedly your own self can be trying at times. I know, by first hand experience (as a cis-ish passing transwoman if you squint), that embodying your own reality in public can be a difficult and damaging experience...

But it's just...necessary. Even on a completely selfish front, no one's going to accept me myself for who I am if I can't tell people who I am. And then there's the larger front that those who have come before me did some of the work to make my life easier, and that by my own work I can make the lives of those who come after me easier.

It's just...sad, you know? Like I know it's hard for us to keep banging our heads against the wall. It's hard to go out in public and recieve insult after insult. It is hard to visit an unfamiliar locale not knowing how we will be accepted. But we have to! Literally the only path to acceptance lies through exposure.

That's the real reason that I am so sociable. I know that the only way past the insults is past the insults. If I only ever hide in the closet...well, the closet isn't all that big is it? I believe that if I show up as myself in any and every interaction I can only have a positive effect. At worst, I find people so bigotted that they are beyond help, avoid them, and pray for those few. In the middle everyone lets me slide. At best, I find bigots who I can expose to reality as it is and help them to get over their fears and prejudices.

I have found through experience, that this reality is closer to the best of possible worlds I just described and far from the worst of the worlds I just described. I have been rewarded time and time again in my encounters, finding countless people that I am able to relieve of their fears and knowing that I have saved countless unknown queers from the vitriol that those I have helped would otherwise have spewed.

Re:The AirPods Effect by goodmythical on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:34PM (#48600388)
You can lean in to that though. I live in a rural county with 22k people in the entire county.

But you're painting two different pictures as if they are the same. The suited family type and the conspiracy theorist are different people.

Were I to know that I were dealing with a conspiracy theorist, the pivot is "I wish I could pay as little tax as rich people do (knowing fully well that they often pay far more than I do" or "yeah, it's crazy how the rich always abuse the little guy" or "what would you do if you were in their position (the same? ah well, at least it's understandable. Different, there, you see, there are good people like you and I left to fight the fight!) Or, hell, just for funsies you can play Conspiracy Olympics in which you try to outgun and outthink their own wild ideas. "Oh yeah, well 'spacex is a fraud' is exactly what a russian sleeper agent would say!"

I'll admit that there have been a small number of people that I simply could not connect with on any level, but working in non-profits and with volunteers, you get used to people's quirks and figure out how to work with them on their level. And what's more, you'll often end up being considered one of their few friends or even just "one of the good ones in their book" because so many people are just completely dismissive of them because they don't like their ideas.

You're engaging in exactly the kind of behavior that many of them complain about, their "no one cares, everyone's out to get me" mentality is only enforced by your "it is not possible for me to talk to or associate with these people". You are in fact one of the they that is plotting to remove this demographic from your own reality. It is not a stretch for them to imagine that you would prefer that they did not exist.

Kindness is not complicated.

Re:The AirPods Effect by senordevnyc on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:30AM (#48599742)
It’s legit funny who you’re responding to with this exhortation on how to be a successful boss / business-person.
Re:The AirPods Effect by Brajeshwar on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:09PM (#48602717)
I'm sorry but I usually look at the content, the poster much later or sometimes not at all.
Re:The AirPods Effect by senordevnyc on Saturday June 20, 2026 @07:10PM (#48613894)
Yeah, I don’t think it was bad advice or anything, I just found it humorous.
Re:The AirPods Effect by csomar on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:57AM (#48596796)
The trick to talking to strangers, in my experience, is to find an opportune moment where you have a reason to talk to them (ie: you are both looking at the same departure timetable and you ask about a particular train/flight). The response will determine whether the stranger is open to carrying on a conversation. Of course, if their presence in the shared space is short, this makes it harder as these opportunities are not always present.

Smoking is probably the best lubricant (ie: borrowing a lighter, asking about a brand/vape, etc.) and people when they smoke are usually more open to strike a conversation. That's not an endorsement of smoking (and I've quit very recently).

Re:The AirPods Effect by embedding-shape on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:07AM (#48596858)
> I don't remember any time in my life where it ever felt normal to me to randomly talk to strangers. [...] And I'm not an introvert!

Life's so interesting sometimes! I consider myself an introvert, and I don't remember any point in time where it ever felt abnormal to talk randomly to the humans ("strangers") around you, regardless if you know them or not. We're both humans, why not see who the other one right next to you are? :) Maybe I'm just "too curious".

It was kind of confusing growing up in Sweden, where most people don't share this idea, so of course it felt really isolating when almost zero strangers actually engage even a tiny bit. Luckily, I figured out I lived in the wrong country relatively quick, and now live in a country (Spain) much more aligned with my own mindset, and having the time of my life chatting with everyone and everything, and they even respond back!

Re:The AirPods Effect by 9dev on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:20AM (#48598945)
why do you consider yourself an introvert if you enjoy chatting with everyone and everything?
Re:The AirPods Effect by poncho_romero on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:45AM (#48599211)
I fit this description too. I consider myself an introvert (that is, more introverted than extroverted; very few people are exclusively one or the other) because I need to be alone to recharge. When my "social battery" is full, I eagerly start conversations with strangers, and even when it is drained I'm comfortable talking to people, though I might not desire to.
Re:The AirPods Effect by littlexsparkee on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:38PM (#48600424)
It all depends on the subject - I can talk about cooking, climate change, collapse, film for hours. As for sports, gossip, celebrities, I clam up. Ditto for any talk that's status seeking or not curious and bi-directional.
Re:The AirPods Effect by ptmcc on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:27AM (#48599711)
Introvert doesn't mean one doesn't enjoy socializing, just that one needs quiet down time to recharge from it. Extroverts tend to be energized by socialization. It's also not always so cleanly binary, either.

I really hate that introversion gets conflated with social anxiety or misanthropy on the internet.

Re:The AirPods Effect by 9dev on Saturday June 20, 2026 @03:56AM (#48607262)
well, and I dislike that people feel the need to desperately label themselves with some affliction. At some point you're just pretty close to the center of the bell curve.
Re:The AirPods Effect by embedding-shape on Saturday June 20, 2026 @07:25AM (#48608434)
I'm not sure if you're talking about me self-labeling myself as "introvert" earlier, or specifically about the comment you replied to and the "social anxiety or misanthropy" parts, but I don't see either "extrovert" or "introvert" as any sort of afflictions, more like preferences.

I'd agree "hate" is a strong word and maybe a bit exaggerated, I hope at least.

Re:The AirPods Effect by embedding-shape on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:55PM (#48602554)
I get tired from talking too much with people, and need to rest by being by myself, I guess is the gist of it. Still enjoy it though, like swimming in the sea, tiresome but fun :)
Re:The AirPods Effect by bambax on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:33AM (#48597847)
I don't like talking to strangers and I would consider myself rather introvert, although not extremely (I'm more of a misanthropist, maybe). That said, talking to strangers is really quite easy; I do it sometimes, esp. to entertain my friends while walking on a busy street. It's quite fun. It can happen that you plunge into deep conversations too, with someone you met just seconds ago!
Re:The AirPods Effect by datsci_est_2015 on Friday June 19, 2026 @09:02AM (#48598090)
Technology and culture evolve together - I don’t think it’s a dichotomy.

Teenagers today are probably more likely to share your disinclination towards social interaction because they grew up during a time when AirPods are so ubiquitous.

Re:The AirPods Effect by gib444 on Friday June 19, 2026 @12:16PM (#48600207)
[delayed]