News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by vintagedave on Monday May 25, 2026 @07:02AM (#48265491)
> a uniformity that eliminated diversity and that chose homogenization over communion

Unrelated to AI, but a wonderful support of the breadth of humanity in this anti-DEI time.

> We must, then, avoid the “Babel syndrome,” namely the idolatry of profit that sacrifices the weak, a uniformity that neutralizes differences, and the pretense that a single language — even a digital one — can translate everything, including the mystery of the person, into data and performance.

There is a lot to read here. I am curious where the meditations on the 'mystery of the person' will go: a brief search doesn't show further mention. The encyclical appears to focus on exhortations for us, humans, than on the nature of AI. Probably wise at this stage. I feel it is not AI that is either positive or negative, but its use of it, and the call-out to the growth of private industry as more powerful among nation-states is a strong statement for a institute like the Vatican to make:

> Technological power thus takes on an unprecedented, predominantly “private” aspect, which makes it even more challenging to discern, govern and direct such power toward the common good.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by vintagedave on Monday May 25, 2026 @07:52AM (#48265788)
I fear I have committed the sin (I mean that word, here) of commenting before reading the entire article. Often it is the comments that set the tone of interpretation and communication more than the article itself, because people read the comments, not the article.

To somewhat mitigate that, here are items that are striking me as I read more. (I hope you'll forgive that this still directs the comment in the direction of my own lense.) I'll keep updating the comment.

> Looking at our own time, we cannot ignore the fact that the protection of human rights [as declared by the United Nations in 1948] has been exposed to two particularly serious dangers. The first is that these rights are declared in a purely formal sense, while technological progress continues alongside covert or overt violations of human dignity.

I read this as a warning of how rights are words, but actions are performed regardless of them. It aligns with something I've been trying to word, which is that as I've seen more and more abuses of power, I've come to believe that ethics requires external accountability, which can often require its own power - a conclusion I don't want to come to; I would prefer social agreement and communal spirit rather than external power. But either way, I do feel it's very clear there are a lot of people, very much in tech too, who simply do what they want regardless of its harm. They justify it to themselves; they don't stop themselves; no one externally stops them.

> Along with a greater awareness of the value of every human person and their rights, recognition of minority rights has also grown. Yet, there is still a long way to go to ensure that the rights of a great many, namely women [are guaranteed.] It is, therefore, not enough to state simply that men and women have equal dignity and rights; it is necessary that this be reflected in concrete decisions, such as in laws, access to employment, education, social and political responsibilities, and the way society listens to and values women’s contributions.

In 2026 American politics terms, this reads as pro-DEI to me.

> the first major principle of Social Doctrine that I wish to highlight: the common good. We can describe it as the social expression of the dignity recognized in every person. ... For a Christian, going beyond the narrow confines of one’s own interests and committing oneself, within the limits of one’s ability, to the common good is a non-negotiable value, as is the promotion of life.

'Non-negotiable.' Very clear words.

> When politics abandons a long-term perspective and reduces itself to short-term calculations or sterile polarizations, then the language of the common good loses credibility, and, at the same time, social inequalities and divisions grow.

> 64. This also applies to international politics.

and,

> I invite everyone to conceive of ways of cooperating and of more effective international institutions, capable of safeguarding the global common good without compromising the legitimate diversity of peoples and nations. Indeed, the promotion of the common good can never be separated from respect for the right of peoples to exist, to preserve their own identity and to contribute their unique qualities to the family of nations.

I love the support for international cooperation and peace and organisations that support it. It reminds me of the post-WW2 sense, the era that gave rise to the United Nations, Unicef, etc - organisations almost forgotten in the news we see on HN today, with the possible exception of the WHO.

> [84] Moreover, any attempt or plan to eliminate or subjugate a nation is gravely immoral and therefore unacceptable.

The beauty of this - or its tragedy - is that it is so easy to apply to many situations today, actions undertaken by many nations.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by vintagedave on Monday May 25, 2026 @08:00AM (#48265848)
> the earth’s goods — soil, water, air and natural resources — are given by God to the entire human family to sustain the lives of all, and that every person has an inherent right to the use of such goods, both now and in the future. ... Today, we are called to recognize that this universal destination applies not only to material goods, but also to immaterial and cultural goods.

Immaterial and cultural goods. This is a fascinating view on non-tangibles and one I feel inspired by. Reading this I asked myself (wait for the larger quote in a minute) how this affects views of IP, learning when texts are not available, cultural impact of characters and stories, the output from universities, publication of papers, ownership of research done by public or even private (!) funds, and more. Particularly I wonder about open weights vs open source for AI, and open source as a concept: where the old-school 'free software' GPLed version seems -- perhaps I am showing my bias -- most aligned with the ethical stance here?

> 66. Certainly there is a right to private property, which has its own specific meaning and purpose, yet it is always subordinate to the universal destination of goods.

'Always subordinate'.

> among the goods that are universally intended for everyone, we must also include new forms of property, such as patents, algorithms, digital platforms, technological infrastructure and data. In a context where the wealth of nations depends increasingly on knowledge and technology, when these goods remain concentrated in the hands of a few, without adequate forms of sharing and access, a new imbalance is created that contradicts the universal destination of goods. In turn, it widens the gap between the included and the excluded, between those who can participate in the digital revolution and those who remain on the margins.

Wow!

I cannot interpret this; it's not my right. But moving from the questions I asked above, to this paragraph, is powerful.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by hammock on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:28PM (#48270032)
I think he is saying we need big cross-border government to force compliance and fight against Trump and his cronies, and more taxes / debt to fund this
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by vintagedave on Monday May 25, 2026 @05:07PM (#48271687)
> I'll keep updating the comment.

For future reference, ten hours later I have still not finished reading all of it. It would make a great blog post to continue this comment thread once done.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by lukan on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:16PM (#48269206)
"It is, therefore, not enough to state simply that men and women have equal dignity and rights; it is necessary that this be reflected in concrete decisions, such as in laws, access to employment, education, social and political responsibilities, and the way society listens to and values women’s contributions. As long as this gap persists, we cannot say that society truly and fully recognizes that women have the same dignity as men."

So ... women should have the same dignity as men and should get the same access to "employment, education, social and political responsibilities". But of course they cannot be trusted with spiritual matters, so they cannot become priests. In other words, to me this is still the same old hypocrisy that made me leave that institution and also today make me deeply distrust any words of wisdom coming from there.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by hammock on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:34PM (#48270080)
The textbook answer, not that I am agreeing with it, is that no women priests is not a choice that the Catholic Church makes, but rather a reflection of received wisdom and ground truth. The same way perhaps a man is understood to be unable to get pregnant, a woman is understood to be unable to perform the sacraments. Or as John Paul II stated in 1994, “the church has no authority whatsoever to ordain women” even if it wanted to
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by comfysocks on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:45PM (#48270822)
That reads a bit like: an equal role in external politics, but not in internal church politics. It’s hard to have a role in politics if you don’t have a voice.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by elmomle on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:33PM (#48270071)
Many Catholic believers are huge stickers for tradition. The previous Pope didn't go nearly so far as to allow female clergy, and he was not viewed with respect by many conservative Catholics. If the Pope declared that the church must allow female clergy, and if that didn't cause a literal schism, he would nevertheless lose the respect of most Catholics who didn't already agree with him.

If the Pope decides that it doesn't actually accomplish much good to force the issue when Catholics as a whole aren't ready for it, he could either try to advance women's rights without tipping the boat over, or he could just not bother.

This Pope is choosing to try to be a voice for good, and seems to do so from a deep desire for moral justice in an imperfect world. I'm grateful for that.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bromuro on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:39PM (#48269495)
Your argument is a bit stretched. Women had and have a principal role in catholicism, the fact that cannot be priest is not that important or seen as discrimination.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by lukan on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:48PM (#48269626)
Oh my, I assume you are male?

Just declaring the discrimination to be "not that important" is quite typical then (as it does not affect you) and well, my catholic aunt would disagree, but she is not important.

May I ask, what the principal role of women is in catholocism, besides being good mothers?

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by luismedel on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:24PM (#48270636)
Politics, football (soccer) and religion are always very sensitive topics.

Maybe the OP's "not that important" was an unfortunate way to put it.

I think the answers you ask for are in Ordinatio Sacerdotalis[0]

[0] https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_letters...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bigstrat2003 on Monday May 25, 2026 @10:47PM (#48274404)
Trying to argue against someone's point by bringing their identity into it is not a good argument. It is a cheap rhetorical trick that only obscures the truth, not helps to bring it out.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by lukan on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @05:24AM (#48277226)
And .. what is this comment if not a rhetorical trick to obscure the truth, that the catholic church is in fact deeply entrenched in gender discrimination?
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by darkwater on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:46PM (#48269603)
> the fact that cannot be priest is not that important or seen as discrimination.

Says who, exactly?

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by luismedel on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:18PM (#48270571)
Catholics.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by goosejuice on Monday May 25, 2026 @07:10PM (#48272940)
> 11 A woman[a] should learn in quietness and full submission. 12 I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man;[b] she must be quiet. 13 For Adam was formed first, then Eve. 14 And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner.

> 34 Women[a] should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak, but must be in submission, as the law says. 35 If they want to inquire about something, they should ask their own husbands at home; for it is disgraceful for a woman to speak in the church.[b]

Kind of hard to believe people are ok with this now or were ever ok with this.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by goosejuice on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:36PM (#48269463)
In this case spiritual and political are one in the same.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by crooked-v on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:35PM (#48270095)
Only if this is also the Pope declaring that women can be priests.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by goosejuice on Monday May 25, 2026 @06:56PM (#48272853)
I'm simply pointing out that it's a ecclesiastical monarchy. Political office and religious authority are intertwined. One woman has reached a cabinet level position as of 2025, something allowed for the first time in 2022. Even she can't perform the full duties of her job because they require a title only a man can be granted.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by danaris on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:47PM (#48269608)
You speak as if the Pope can just change that unilaterally, with no cost.

Now, I don't know if Pope Leo actually believes in the full equality of men and women or if he's really being a hypocrite here. It's fully possible that you're absolutely right to scoff at him for it.

But the thing is, the limitation of priesthood to men in the Roman Catholic Church is such a deeply ingrained thing, it would be very, very hard for a single Pope to change it, especially early on in his papacy. If one wanted to, one of the first things he'd have to do would be...

...why, it would be to release an encyclical talking about the equality of men and women. Whether that was its core message or not.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by lukan on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:54PM (#48269692)
Yes, I am aware of that. And I don't know much about the current pope, but he seems progressive and can only go step by step, like Franziskus.

What I do know is, that a main motivation to introduce the celibate, was that priests don't inherit church land to their offspring anymore.

In other words, I applaud reforming what is possible, but I would not want that job as hypocrasy seems required. Because on the other hand all this should be gods own unique church and I could not preach that, while knowing about all the well, human compromises so to say.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bigstrat2003 on Monday May 25, 2026 @10:45PM (#48274395)
> So ... women should have the same dignity as men and should get the same access to "employment, education, social and political responsibilities". But of course they cannot be trusted with spiritual matters...

Nobody has said that. You are attacking a strawman. The actual teaching of the Catholic Church is that because Jesus was a man, and because priests act in the priestly role Jesus held, that priests must be men. Which you may still disagree with. Fair enough. But in that case argue against the actual teaching, not a strawman.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by lukan on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:10AM (#48280125)
It is not a strawman that the catholic church only allows men as priests.

But can you find me some teachings of Jesus where he said, women cannot be priests?

I am not aware of any. Also not that a priest is a replacement of Jesus.

But I am aware that we don't even have direct sources from jesus, but 3. hand at best. So there are lots of christians who think women as priests are fine. So it is a choice the catholic church made centuries ago and it is a choice to not change. Their choice. And mine to stay away from them, but still comment on their wisdom.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by chrisweekly on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:04PM (#48269794)
On what basis does the pope speak about gender equality and women's rights? As the representative of the catholic church, the cognitive dissonance is profound.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by tw04 on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:40PM (#48270168)
> which can often require its own power - a conclusion I don't want to come to

Unfortunately we’re quick to forget that all of those words were put on paper after a time of violence, and ultimately they are a social contract between the many masses and the few “in power” that we agree to adhere to rules instead of committing violence to force behavior.

But ultimately there is only one logical conclusion to the game when parties stop playing by the rules and that’s violence, whether we want it or not. What i think you’ll find most often is the men who commit the most “crimes” against the social contract are the biggest cowards who have never faced violence or consequences and think they never will.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by boxed on Monday May 25, 2026 @08:08AM (#48265908)
> > a uniformity that eliminated diversity and that chose homogenization over communion

> Unrelated to AI, but a wonderful support of the breadth of humanity in this anti-DEI time.

I mean.. DEI was in reality homogenization and eliminated diversity. Just because you agreed with the small amount of allowed opinions/people doesn't make it more diverse.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by vermilingua on Monday May 25, 2026 @08:47AM (#48266198)
Perhaps, perhaps not; but you can't possibly argue that the current anti-DEI climate better fosters diversity than a pro-DEI or a-DEI environment.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by boxed on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @01:59AM (#48275577)
Agreed. Especially since it radicalizes the woke side even more, it's an escalating war leaving everyone worse off.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Forgeties79 on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:03PM (#48269081)
The anti-DEI “movement,” especially what we see in the US, is mostly thinly veiled racism by another name.

All one has to see is how frequently people call any non-white/non-male hire or appointment a “DEI-hire” because they can’t possibly conceive that marginalized groups would see any success based on merit. They start from a position where they are all incompetent and being given an unfair advantage until proven otherwise. It’s also on you to guess whatever their arbitrary bar is.

[dead]
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Curosinono on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:20PM (#48269249)
The racial quota is used to support minorites.

You don't need to generate a new account just to spew racism.

You can argue that yo udon't think DEI helps and suggest an alternative but DEI is not racism even if you put it like this on purpose.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Forgeties79 on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:28PM (#48270035)
Is interesting to me that I often see that kind of default response (“racial quotas”) as if that’s all DEI is when you get down to it. It’s really about creating a space that includes everybody and creates opportunities for all. There are many ways to approach that.

I know in my brief time being involved with a DEI initiative the discussion was never about how many of any particular demographic we hired. It was about asking if we had internal barriers that disproportionally impacted certain groups. I think that’s a very different mindset than “quotas.” But people arguing in bad faith generally aren’t looking for nuance so here we are.

Edit: to be clear, this is directed at the other commenter not you

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by boxed on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @01:35AM (#48290086)
How isn't it racism though? Separating people and counting them and giving them different treatment based on race is literally "discrimination" and "racism".

The woke movement has distanced themselves from the teachings of Martin Luther King even. Literally quoting MLK was what got Coleman Hughes into trouble with TED. It's quite absurd.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by boxed on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:06AM (#48275634)
> The anti-DEI “movement,” especially what we see in the US, is mostly thinly veiled racism by another name.

The one we see on the news yea. But sane voices have been trying to stop this madness for decades and it only got worse and worse. Then fascists could easily scoop up such a clean win because the weapon was just lying there being ignored by the Democratic party. It's an own goal.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by daveguy on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:05PM (#48269094)
DEI was only ever meant to reflect the diversity of society in our institutions (which historically have been and continue to be homogeneous compared to society). Of course there are better and worse ways to create the outcome of increased diversity. But thr recent backlash is the antithesis of diversity, wrapped up in the propaganda of "reverse racism."
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by boxed on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:04AM (#48275616)
> DEI was only ever meant to reflect the diversity of society in our institutions

That sounds reasonable, but it's not really true. It was a tool to DISTORT the diversity of society by making minority groups front and center to a disproportionate degree. The more minority the better. This isn't reflecting the diversity of society, that's flipping it over.

I'm not saying the intentions weren't good. They were. But good intentions don't matter after a certain point. Communism for example is all about good intentions and every time we try it it leads to mass casualties. After a while you have to wise up.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by daveguy on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @09:34AM (#48279694)
Why wouldn't there be a period when more diverse groups are accepted at a higher than societally present amount until representation is more balanced? Because little Johnny feels entitled to get preferetial treatment when the system works for him, but insists everything be absolutely fair when he's not the recipient? After a while you have to wise up. Quotas aren't the best way, but they are certainly the most straightforward way. Best way would be to provide the social safety nets that dumpty-doge gutted. If the applications are more diverse the quotas are less important (but possibly still important if there is discrimination on things like names).
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @03:33PM (#48284835)
What you're describing is a straightforward violation of civil rights laws (assuming you're talking about the United States). Like it or not, "little Johnny" is just as protected from discrimination as these "more diverse groups".

But I'll give you credit for your candor. Few DEI advocates are as honest as you about the movement's discriminatory nature.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by daveguy on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @05:14PM (#48286057)
Little Johnny isn't a protected class and never will be. Little Johnny has had 250+ years of preferential treatment behind him. Boohoo Little Johnny.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @05:38PM (#48286339)
You seem to be misinformed about what protected class means: Race, gender, religion (including absence of religion), are all protected classes. It is irrelevant which race, gender, etc. is being favored or disfavored. The use of race as a factor in employment, in any way, is prohibited. It is not legal to discriminate against men any more than it is legal to discriminate against women. It is not legal to discriminate against whites and Asians any more than it is legal to discriminate against Black and Latin people. The idea that civil rights laws oly prohibit discrimination against some races and some genders while permitting discrimination against others is a very common piece of misinformation espoused by proponents of DEI.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by daveguy on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @06:29PM (#48286868)
But also, preferential treatment for underserved communities is legal and does not mean anyone is being discriminated against. I.e., "reverse discrimination" is bullshit. Sorry.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @06:37PM (#48286954)
Repeating this doesn't make it true. Use of protected class as a factor in employment is illegal, regardless of which race or gender is being favored or disfavored. You're right, "reverse discrimination" is bullshit: it's just discrimination, regardless of who is being discriminated against. This was argued all the way up to the Supreme Court: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ames_v._Ohio_Department_of_You...

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 applies to both the majority and the minority equally. And the Supreme Court's unanimous opinion was written by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson no less! You're just wrong on the facts here.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by boxed on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @01:32AM (#48290071)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Students_for_Fair_Admissions_v...

In fact, asians were as a "race" treated very badly historically with camps for japanese-americans during WW2 and before that quite a lot of discrimination. That DEI kept up that discrimination even at Harvard and lost under the guise of DEI shows that the DEI mission is not only illegal but stupid.

Note also that while DEI proponents scream that the US is racist, somehow people who arrive from Nigeria and are more black than most US blacks and know the language less, and have no connections, and start out with even less wealth do quite well on the whole. DEI isn't just bad, stupid, and illegal. It's also falsified as a scientific idea.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bombcar on Monday May 25, 2026 @09:57AM (#48266911)
The “mystery of the person” is a common theme in Catholicism - it can be seen in other (especially the “social”) encyclicals. Rerum Novarum by the current pope’s namesake is worth a study.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by vintagedave on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:43PM (#48269554)
Thankyou. I am not Catholic so was unfamiliar with the term. I'll read about it.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by irdc on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:55PM (#48269704)
Not a Roman Catholic but I am occasionally interested in what the Church has to say on ethical matters. What does the Church understand by "mystery of the person", and how does it relate to the assertion by the Church that, for example, gender (one aspect of the human subjective experience) can be understood purely in terms of biology?[0]

0. https://www.catholic.com/qa/the-churchs-position-on-transgen...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by learntofly on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:33PM (#48270075)
“So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.” (Genesis 1:27, ESV)
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by irdc on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:36PM (#48270102)
Sure, but that was before the Fall.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by sorokod on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:30PM (#48270693)
You have to Ac-Cent-Tchu-Ate The Positive
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by ricardobeat on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:14PM (#48269896)
I don’t think you can take any writing by american TV priests as gospel
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by irdc on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:35PM (#48270096)
Sure, another source then: https://www.vox.com/2015/2/20/8078979/pope-francis-trans-rig...

I just cannot reconcile the idea of personhood being valuable with reducing humans to mere biology.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bhinml on Monday May 25, 2026 @08:18PM (#48273458)
> In January, Francis said teaching the gender theory in developing countries is “ideological colonization” by wealthier nations.

Sounds about right to be honest. The claim that being a woman or a man is merely a matter of self-declaration is indeed an ideological view that arose from the western world.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by svieira on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:23PM (#48283702)
Humans are not "reduced" to biology. Their biology is presumed to "reveal" something about their personhood. And no matter how they feel about their hair, their hips, their eyes, etc. they ought to receive them as a gift from God and enter into a dialog with Him about how they ought to make use of the gifts He has given them.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by irdc on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @03:23PM (#48284674)
However, don't you feel as though biology thereby becomes an impediment to loving the whole person?

Edit: I'm sorry, I'm being a little vague here, so let me clarify: biology is what decides our appearance, and our appearance then influences how we interact with people. If ones appearance contradicts ones inner sense of personhood, how can that person ever truly connect with other people? And if they cannot connect, then how can they love and be loved (which if I remember correctly is one of the two major commandments in your religion)?

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by svieira on Thursday May 28, 2026 @08:59AM (#48308345)
> If ones appearance contradicts ones inner sense of personhood, how can that person ever truly connect with other people?

https://woforgmedia.wordonfire.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/0...

https://www.wordonfire.org/articles/pope-francis-and-the-ele...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by irdc on Saturday May 30, 2026 @09:21AM (#48335876)
And yet, if someone with such an affliction could have it fixed via medicine, they would jump at the chance. As would you, by the way. Requiring people not to because of one’s convictions is certainly the height of something and it isn’t good.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by svieira on Thursday June 04, 2026 @01:20PM (#48401699)
"The affliction" in his case is skin overgrowth, in the other its the dysphoria, right? But which is the moral way to cure either?
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by kingandqueenov on Monday June 08, 2026 @10:56AM (#48446238)
By the same token, God gives us dysphoria as a way of encouraging us to use those gifts as He intends. God made us trans people to be trans. The entire process of transition is a creative one. As much as anything else, gender dysphoria is an invitation to shape your humanity, to take some small part in the creation of your self. It is "in His image" to shape humanity, especially one's own.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by fatherzine on Monday May 25, 2026 @10:02AM (#48266977)
'you shall have no other gods before me'. operationally, a warning. false worship is dangerous. we get what we worship (value above all, orient towards, optimize for). heaven or hell, read it immanently or transcendentally, personally or collectively. either way, choosing the right worship is paramount.

the conundrum: what is the right objective? puerile attempts, eg "maximize flourishing" or perhaps "minimize suffering" are trivially countered by paperclip machines fulfilling the letter while laying utter waste

'mystery of the person'

given the context, some keywords for orientation: free will, rejection of temptation, the cross

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Curosinono on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:18PM (#48269232)
You are joking with your anti-DEI comment right? You do know that you do talk about the christian church?

They do nothing to include everyone. They are not standing up when it counts or excumante churches and believes who do not follow proper humanitarity.

They are not even in the forefront of fighting climate change which hurts billions.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by po1nt on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:44PM (#48269571)
I don't believe there was an era in history more DEI accepting than nowadays.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by zaneyard on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:04PM (#48269797)
What is the point of this comment? Do you mean to say we should cease the pursuit of DEI because we've "come so far"? Of course that's engaging with you with the assumption that you're not intentionally ignoring the weaponization of the movement in the US to further the goals of the current administration.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by po1nt on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @03:54AM (#48276527)
That would be a strawman. I am not living in US and don't care about US politics other than they are rising my diesel prices.

I'm just pointing out that historically this is the most DEI friendly we have ever been. If americans would be able to see outside a 4 year election cycle and realise there is a whole world outside the TDS zone, we could have a more civilised conversation than throwing strawmans around.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by zaneyard on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @04:47PM (#48285749)
I'm not refuting what you said, I'm asking you to elaborate why you said it.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by po1nt on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @06:55PM (#48287132)
Because I feel like it's unappreciative to act like we didn't make any progress. It's really degrading to people that really did put in an effort (like myself). It's like comming to a celebration of a sport victory with "you could have done better" attitude.

So let's now focus on why you assumed a hidden meaning somehow connected to "current administration"? Why this knee jerk reaction?

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by idiotsecant on Monday May 25, 2026 @01:48PM (#48269622)
We should just stop using the term DEI. It has been demonized in the common parlance so successfully that to a ton of people it no longer means 'people who are different are made valuable by that difference'- it's been demonized into essentially meaning 'give black people and women jobs they don't deserve'. It's a prime example of propaganda through language pollution.

For whatever reason HN has been slowly goose stepping towards the future lately so I expect this to go over like a lead balloon but I don't much care.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:10PM (#48269862)
> We should just stop using the term DEI. It has been demonized in the common parlance so successfully

Whatever term you pick to describe a concerted effort to overcome the tendency to bigotry, they'll just hijack that, too.

There's a whole industry built around this, and the media is so receptive to the right-wing that they'll openly describe how they'll do it[1], will execute the plans in public, and the mainstream media will act as their stenographers.

[1] https://xcancel.com/sykescharlie/status/1396844806547050499

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by thegrimmest on Monday May 25, 2026 @04:17PM (#48271184)
I think the demonization comes from people resenting the use of authority to restrict liberty, and from conflating the resentment of authority with bigotry. In this case, let private people discriminate freely.

"The trouble with fighting for human freedom is that one spends most of one's time defending scoundrels. For it is against scoundrels that oppressive laws are first aimed, and oppression must be stopped at the beginning if it is to be stopped at all." -H. L. Mencken

I think people should be allowed to make their own choices in terms of whom to hire/associate with, with absolutely no outside intervention. That doesn't make me a bigot.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by hammock on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:38PM (#48270135)
Do you mean there’s a whole industry built around DEI? Or that there’s a whole industry built around countermessaging the DEI industry?
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:47PM (#48270247)
> the DEI industry

isn't really a thing so much as it's a collection of principles that can be implemented. To the unprincipled, this needs to be converted into a literal enemy that can be vilified, because any attempt to force them to adhere to principles is an attack.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by hackinthebochs on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:11PM (#48270485)
No DEI industry you say? https://web.archive.org/web/20240710195414/https://time.com/...

>The lucrative industry shows few signs of waning–from the spike in well-compensated diversity consultants and czars; to online courses and degree programs at prestigious schools; to professional organizations and conferences; to the commissioning of ever more studies, task forces and climate surveys. The buzzword is emblazoned on blogs and books and boot camps, and Thomson Reuters, a multinational mass-media and information firm, even created a Diversity and Inclusion Index to assess the practices of more than 5,000 publicly traded companies globally.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:46PM (#48270234)
DEI wasn't demonized because it tried to fight bigotry. It demonized itself because it routinely became a dishonest two-faced movement that public denied to be discriminatory, but then privately implemented policies that explicitly discriminated on the basis of sex and gender.

When your leaders publicly condemn the idea that your company is discriminating on the basis of sex, but then privately institutes a system of reserving headcount for women, that'll make most people real cynical about DEI.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by hilariously on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:59PM (#48270355)
And those in power who went out of their way to demonize DEI, is that why they didn't like it? I would argue strongly that no, they had their priors already set, and anything help black people or poor people (the new proxy for hating black people) was bad and they'd lie through their teeth about the impact to get anyone on their side.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:14PM (#48270512)
Yes, they did dislike it because it was discriminatory, not because it helped poor and Black people. I don't know the views of people you've met, but in my circles the opponents of DEI are mostly tech workers in SF and Seattle - not exactly a conservative demographic. I can't count a single Republican between us.

The course of our relationship with DEI was pretty similar: in university we earnestly believed that women were discriminated against in tech hiring. One of us even built a prototype anonymous interviewing platform. Once we entered the workforce, there was pretty big whiplash when we started getting visibility into our own companies' hiring pipelines. Many of us - including myself - found ourselves actively carrying out discrimination on the basis of sex and race. Mostly sex, though - while our DEI advocates often invoked racial disparities to emphasize the need for these discriminatory policies, the actual beneficiaries of these policies were mostly white and Asian women.

Does this make me any less likely to support better school funding, and other public benefits that help poor people and Black people? I don't think so. The discriminatory practices of tech company hiring is pretty far removed from these issues in my view. Why would should an underserved school not receive better funding because some tech companies preferentially hired an Asian female over an Asian male? I see no connection between these two.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:52PM (#48270290)
Can you cite any companies which violated federal labor law in this way?
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:57PM (#48270328)
Three out of the four companies I've worked at, for one.

YouTube was sued for directing one of its recruiters to exclusively advance diverse candidates for a period of time, and eventually settled with the recruiter [1].

Intel [2] and Microsoft [3] both tied specific percentage quotas to executive's compensation. If saying "reach this racial and gender quota or I'll penalize you financially" isn't discrimination, I'm not sure what is.

Perkins-Coie explicitly excluded applicants from its diversity fellowship program if they didn't meet certain racial, sexual orientation, or other requirements [4].

1. https://www.wsj.com/articles/youtube-hiring-for-some-positio...

2. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/04/why-is-...

3. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-17/microsoft...

4. https://www.reuters.com/legal/second-major-us-law-firm-chang...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by phillmv on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:20PM (#48270584)
i like how when a company obviously discriminates against women and minorities by hiring almost entirely white guys that's fine that's to be expected but if you try to fix that discrimination it's an evil conspiracy
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:23PM (#48270619)
The fact that the company is majority white does not make discrimination legal. If the Perkins Coie wants to do things like anonymize its interviews, or send fake interview packets to its recruiters and looking for disparities in call back rates then that would be a genuine attempt at identifying potential discrimination.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by phillmv on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:33PM (#48270718)
the discrimination already happened! it's not possible to end up 80% white guy without discriminating. it's curious that the status quo isn't nearly as concerning.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:36PM (#48270750)
> it's not possible to end up 80% white guy without discriminating?

This is untrue, though. The fact that a company does not have representation that is exactly equitable with the general population is not evidence of discrimination.

In fact, you can end up with disparities much larger without discrimination. It's even possible to actively discriminate against a group, and still have that disadvantaged group be overrepresented by a factor of 3 or 4.

That was the case with the Harvard admissions lawsuit. Even though the university was actively discriminating against Asian applicants, the undergrad population was ~20% Asian, despite ~6% of the applicants being Asian.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by phillmv on Monday May 25, 2026 @05:24PM (#48271851)
>The fact that a company does not have representation that is exactly equitable with the general population

i didn't say exactly equitable, i said 80%. it's not possible to have 80% white guys and not be discriminatory.

you're making a bad faith apples to oranges comparison, to say nothing of the merit of Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard. your viewpoint and disinterest is very clear, i don't know why you even bother arguing about it.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @05:43PM (#48272011)
Yes, it is possible to have an 80% white organization without discrimination. Perkins Coie is ~80% white but is gender representation is much closer to parity [1], so I'm not sure why you're referring specifically to "white guys".

The relevance of SFFA vs. Harvard is to demonstrate that it's possible to have a substantial overrepresentation - over 3x in the case of Asians at Harvard - despite actively discriminating against the overrepresented group. Whites are only ~1.2x more common at Perkins Coie relative to the general population.

You can keep repeating the line that because a company has X% of Y race it must be evidence of discrimination as many times as you want, repetition doesn't make it true.

1. https://perkinscoie.com/about-us

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by phillmv on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:05AM (#48280072)
not going to debate bad faith right wing cause celebres arguing the inverse.

i see it with my own two eyes when i have to yell at recruiters to stop bringing me all-male candidate slates, i see it from studies in social sciences, and i know it from having seen the progression over my own career and listening to my female colleagues. at the end of the day a lot of men don't see women and minorities as people with full agency.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:53AM (#48280675)
If you did a cursory review of the social sciences on this topic, you'd know that the demographics of people going through the prerequisites to working at a place like Perkins Coie does not match the general population. College attendance has racial disparities, as does law school attendance. Whites have half and 1/3rd the fail rate at the bar examination as compared to Latin and Black people respectively. Even absent discrimination, there are plenty of factors that drive law firms to have larger representation of white people.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by thegrimmest on Monday May 25, 2026 @04:19PM (#48271218)
This is absurd. Why is it possible to end up with a majority black, tall, male, NBA team without pre-selecting on basis of race, height, or sex?
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bigstrat2003 on Monday May 25, 2026 @10:54PM (#48274448)
> it's not possible to end up 80% white guy without discriminating.

That is not remotely true. Individual choices, as well as experiences which shape the candidate pool, can cause such lopsided numbers. In my view, the single biggest problem with the (quite well intentioned) diversity initiatives is that they assume, without evidence, that any organization with lopsided demographics must therefore be discriminating. But that is a fallacy and undermines the entire endeavor they are engaged in.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by phillmv on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:00AM (#48280005)
there's loads of evidence, y'all just don't like engaging with it cos you don't like the answer because fixing it is work and fundamentally women and minorities are not seen as people with full agency.

i'm old enough to remember when software engineering conferences were _2%_ female. it's exhausting to be having this same conversation decades later.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:41AM (#48280532)
What is the evidence? Did we send identical applications, differing only by ethnicity, to Perkins Coie, and did they respond to the non-white applicants at lower rates? Did Perkins Coie institute policies like withholding bonuses if leaders hired too few white applicants? What indicates that Perkins Coie is preferring white applicants over equally qualified Black or Latin applicants?

You insist there's evidence of discrimination, but all you've done is point to the % of white people at the company and insist it's too high.

But as a counterpoint, 40% of the developers at my company are Asian, despite them making up 6% of the US population. That's an overrepresentation of over 6X. In fact, whites are slightly underrepresented. Does that mean we're discriminating against non-asians? Is this evidence that whites are discriminated again, on account of their underrepresentation? Of course not.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:06PM (#48270448)
YouTube was never found guilty of anything, they just paid to make the argument go away. In the case of Intel and Microsoft you're conflating incentives with quotas. These companies wanted more diversity in their staff, which is a valid and laudable goal, and they were willing to pay extra if that was achieved.

Would you like to try again?

edit: your later addition of Perkins Coie also was settled/dismissed and never adjudicated, and the executive order which claimed to penalize them for discrimination, which was adjudicated later, was a summary judgment in their favor[1].

The real takeaway is that a lot of people are very mad about what they imagine DEI to be.

[1] https://www.perkinscoiefacts.com/filings/memorandum-opinion-...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:31PM (#48270703)
Yes, the lawsuit against Perkings Coie was dropped, after the law firm agreed to stop engaging in discrimination. As per the case, Parkins Coie did explicitly require that applicants to its diversity fellowship be Black, Latin, or a member of the LGBTQ community. The lawsuit was dropped after Perkins Coie agreed to expand eligibility to all applicants, regardless of race and sexual orientation.

What about the Perkins Coie lawsuit serves to highlight the notion that DEI is often implemented through discriminatory manners? Do you deny the eligibility criteria that Perkins Coie set for its diversity fellowship.

> and the executive order which claimed to penalize them for discrimination, which was adjudicated later, was a summary judgment in their favor[1].

This judgement is largely unrelated to their discriminatory fellowship requirements. The lawsuit about the fellowship was resolved in 2023, before Trump took office. This was a judgement against Trump's executive order - it is not a judgement of Perkins Coie's employment practices before he took office.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:19PM (#48270574)
They settled out of court, YouTube didn't prevail in court. The evidence speaks for itself. Did you not read the emails that plaintiff's manager sent, explicitly telling him to cancel all non-diverse applicants' interviews?

You can read the complaint itself: https://regmedia.co.uk/2018/03/02/wilberg-v-google.pdf

> Please continue with L3 candidates in process and only accept new L3 candidates that are from historically underrepresented groups.

> We are still pre-Goodburger roll out, so that means the only candidates that need pre-allocation are L3s. And we should only consider L3s from our underrepresented groups.

Engage with the evidence of the lawsuit before proclaiming that it's meritless because YouTube settled with the plaintiff, rather than going to court and losing. If these emails were fabricated YouTube would have a slam-dunk case against the plaintiff. But they chose to settle.

> In the case of Intel and Microsoft you're conflating incentives with quotas

The incentives were implemented in the form of quotas. You're writing as though these are mutually exclusive things, when they're not.

"Your salary is $110,000. If you don't meet a quota of 40% women, I'm docking our pay by $10,000 as a penalty for failing to meet this quota."

"Your salary is $100,000. Because we want to make the company more diverse, we're giving a $10,000 bonus for reaching an inclusion milestone of 40% women."

This is exactly what Intel did, from the Atlantic article:

> But in the past couple of years, Intel decided to try a few other approaches, including hiring quotas.

> Well, not quotas. You can’t say quotas. At least not in the United States. In some European countries, like Norway, real, actual quotas—for example, a rule saying that 40 percent of a public company’s board members must be female—have worked well; qualified women have been found and the Earth has continued turning. However, in the U.S., hiring quotas are illegal. “We never use the word quota at Intel,” says Danielle Brown, the company’s chief diversity and inclusion officer. Rather, Intel set extremely firm hiring goals. For 2015, it wanted 40 percent of hires to be female or underrepresented minorities.

> Now, it’s true that lots of companies have hiring goals. But to make its goals a little more, well, quota-like, Intel introduced money into the equation. In Intel’s annual performance-bonus plan, success in meeting diversity goals factors into whether the company gives employees an across-the-board bonus. (The amounts vary widely but can be substantial.) If diversity efforts succeed, everybody at the company gets a little bit richer.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:57PM (#48270953)
> You're writing as though these are mutually exclusive things

That's how the law sees it.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @04:03PM (#48271021)
When has the court upheld a policy of setting a specific percentage racial or gender quota, and penalizing employees financially if that quota is not met? If I told my employees "I'll reduce your pay by 90% if you hire any pregnant women" that's not discrimination against gender and family status? You really think a court would buy this argument? Of course, 90% is a much bigger proportion of salary than the DEI bonuses in the example above, but fundamentally this is no different of a policy - it's still tying compensation to the protected class of hired candidates.

And again, you're still glossing over the other two examples: A manager at YouTube explicitly directed a recruiter to only proceed with diverse applicants. And Perkins Coie did, in fact, restrict eligibility for its fellowship program on the basis of race and sexual orientation (this was settled in 2023 after they agreed to stop discriminating. The 2025 judgement you linked above doesn't in any way defend Perkins Coie's hiring policies, only that Trump couldn't further punish them by banning them from federal buildings).

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @04:14PM (#48271151)
> When has the court upheld a policy of setting a specific percentage racial or gender quota, and penalizing employees financially if that quota is not met?

Irrelevant.

> And again, you're still glossing over the other two examples

Two examples is not a pervasive problem in my opinion, so it's super easy to gloss over.

What is a pervasive problem is the tables being very tilted against certain groups of people.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @04:40PM (#48271442)
If the courts haven't found in favor of companies using quotas as incentives, then you have no basis to claim that that quotas are legally acceptable as long as they're framed as incentives. This is directly relevant to your claims.

I find it noteworthy how often proponents of DEI talk in vague, euphemistic terms. You left me to guess what you mean by "certain groups of people". The group that I've witnessed benefit the most from DEI in tech companies is women - not Black people, or poor people. And the experimental evidence on the gender disparity in tech company recruiting does not back up the idea that women are disadvantaged when it comes to applying to tech companies: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID3946621_cod...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Monday May 25, 2026 @10:23PM (#48274246)
> If the courts haven't found in favor of companies using quotas as incentives

The courts don’t conflate these activities and as we’ve discussed, recruiting incentives related to broadening the applicant pool are perfectly legal and proper. This has nothing to do with hiring unqualified people based on identity as you imply. Hope this helps.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @12:32AM (#48275028)
> The courts don’t conflate these activities and as we’ve discussed

Again, what is the basis of this statement? You're not actually backing this claim up with anything, you're just postulating it as fact. From what I can find, companies are being sued for this practice: https://nfclegal.com/dei-legal-development-spotlight-warm-up...

> Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed a lawsuit accusing Starbucks Corp. of violating state civil rights through its DEI policies by: ... Tying executive compensation to participation in race-based mentorship programs and race-based employee retention rates; and

I have not been able to find a single instance of a company successfully defending a policy of tying compensation to race and gender quotas. Your claim that the courts have given the green light on tying compensation to racial and gender quotas is not the consensus I'm finding.

> recruiting incentives related to broadening the applicant pool are perfectly legal and proper.

Tying compensation to quotas also incentivizes narrowing the applicant pool to exclude the demographic that doesn't belong to the quota. Again, if I told my employees, "I'm docking your pay if you hire any pregnant women", am I broadening the applicant pool to include more non-pregnant people? Or am I incentivizing them to narrow the applicant pool to exclude pregnant women? "Diversity goals" and caps are two sides of the same coin. Tying a bonus to a diversity goal X% women is the same as instituting a penalty if a cap of (100-X)% men is exceeded.

Remember, Microsoft and Intel tied quotas to proportional representation. If I have 8 men and 2 women on my candidate docket, and I need to reach 40% women, I could try and attract 3 more female applicants. But if the desired female applicants don't materialize, I could also decline to hire some of the men to push women's proportional representation up enough to reach the 40% quota. I can't guarantee whether more women apply to join the team, but I can unilaterally decline to move forward with some of the men.

> This has nothing to do with hiring unqualified people based on identity as you imply

Where did I write about unqualified people getting hired? I've re-read my comments twice, and nowhere do I imply that people are hired based on identify characteristics.

I've found that this is a common theme among DEI proponents: try and imply that people who highlight the existence of discriminatory policies as denigrating the qualifications of the groups favored by DEI preferences. I have generally not witnessed unqualified applicants being hired on account of DEI discrimination, rather it's mostly qualified men that aren't getting interviewed in order to prop up female representation percentages.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @05:38PM (#48286338)
> I have not been able to find a single instance of a company successfully defending a policy of tying compensation to race and gender quotas.

Simply repeating the conflation of quotas with incentives ad nauseam doesn't make them the same thing.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @05:52PM (#48286509)
And for the fifth time, incentives and quotas are not mutually exclusive. A company can create incentives that are implemented through quotas.

"Your salary is $100k. If you don't meet a quota of X% women I'm reducing your pay by $50k."

"Your salary is $50k. But I'm offering an incentive of $50k if you meet a quo... - excuse me - diversity goal of X% women."

You can keep repeating that this isn't a quota as long as you call it an "incentive", but anyone engaging in good faith sees it for what it is: it's setting a specific numeric quota on the basis of protected class, and penalizing workers who don't meet that quota.

In fact IBM was sued and paid a settlement of over $17 million for tying compensation to diversity metrics: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/ibm-pays-17-million-resolve-a...

> The United States alleged that IBM took race, color, national origin, or sex into account when making employment decisions, including by using a diversity modifier that tied bonus compensation to achieving demographic targets.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by mullingitover on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @05:48PM (#48301222)
> In fact IBM was sued and paid a settlement of over $17 million for tying compensation to diversity metrics:

That's one way of putting it.

Another way is IBM bribed Trump's personal lawyer 17 million in furtherance of Trump's hobby horse, bigotry, in exchange for a billion dollars[1].

> [May 21, 2026 5:25PM] The largest recipient is IBM, which is slated to receive $1 billion

[1] https://www.cato.org/blog/trumps-presidential-portfolio-goes...

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @07:57PM (#48302428)
Bigotry does not mean an automatic win at court. I continue to be impressed at the mental gymnastics you're willing to jump through to rationalize the belief that tying compensation to racial and gender quotas is legal. It doesn't matter that companies are being sued and paying out settlements for their illegal DEI practices, it's all just a conspiracy!
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by api on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:26PM (#48270022)
It also refers to a wide range of different policies that need to be evaluated on their merits. These policies are not all the same.

It’s become a thought stopping cliche. Modern discourse is absolutely loaded with thought stopping cliches so it’s not the only one by any stretch.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by urbnspacecowboy on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:06PM (#48269822)
> We should just stop using the term DEI. It has been demonized in the common parlance...

We should just stop using the term woke. It has been demonized in the common parlance...

We should just stop using the term social justice. It has been demonized in the common parlance...

We should just stop using the term critical race theory. It has been demonized in the common parlance...

We should just stop using the term diversity. It has been demonized in the common parlance...

And on and on and on. Why should we stop using terms because bigots demonize them "in the common parlance"? Bigots demonize every term.

Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by iugtmkbdfil834 on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:13PM (#48270504)
Feel free to use either, but you will be summarily ignored.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @01:24AM (#48275349)
You should consider the possibility that the hostility towards those who disagree with you (i.e. assuming they are bigots rather than good faith interlocutors) is part of why your efforts are met with resistance. Simply put: you catch more flies with honey than vinegar.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:12PM (#48269887)
Opposition to DEI is not opposition to diversity so much as it is opposition to discrimination. More than just discrimination, DEI often came in the form of a particularly dishonest and two faced approach to it. Unlike affirmative action - which in my experience tends to acknowledge that sometimes justice requires a measured and deliberate exception to equality - DEI often tried to simultaneously condemn the idea that we were discriminating in favor of certain groups, while also effecting policies that were overtly discriminatory.

If I told my executives I would dock their pay if they exceeded a cap of X% men in their org, would that be discrimination? I doubt many would contest that issuing explicit penalties for breaking a cap on a particular gender. Ah, but what if I gave executives a bonus for reaching an "inclusion milestone" of (100-X)% women? That's not discrimination - that's DEI. Microsoft [1] and Intel [2] both instituted this policy.

My own past employers extended this logic to headcount. In 2019 we instituted a policy of reserving EDP (engineering, product, & design) headcount for "diverse" candidates. What does does "diverse" mean? It means women of any race, as well as Black and Latino men - though in practice >95% of "diverse" candidates were white and Asian women. Each quarter, 20 heads were reserved for hiring "diverse" candidates, and when managers hired from this reserved pool it did not count towards their allocated headcount. You see, if I have a headcount of 100 and I exclude men from applying to 20 of those, then that's discrimination. But if I have a headcount of 80 and we allocate 20 additional headcount that's exclusively available to women, that's not discrimination that's DEI.

This is why, as contradictory as it may sound, I do consider myself supportive of affirmative action, but opposed to DEI. Certainly there are some groups that implement DEI in a transparent and honest manner, but my read is that DEI tends to be done in a two-faced manner while "affirmative action" carries the connotation of being upfront that sometimes equality needs to be honored in the breach to ameliorate the unequal circumstances of reality.

1. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-17/microsoft...

2. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/04/why-is-...

[dead]
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by khazhoux on Monday May 25, 2026 @03:06PM (#48270447)
Ad hominem. It would be better to argue against his points than his person.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by Manuel_D on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:41PM (#48270175)
In case you couldn't infer from my username, I am Latin.
Re:Magnifica Humanitas (Encyclical Letter) by kendallpark on Monday May 25, 2026 @05:28PM (#48271869)
"Mystery" is a theological concept that is translated from the Greek word "mustérion." [1] Mysterious, mystical, secret, divine, not fully revealed. This sort of ineffable, irreducible truth you can touch but cannot fully grasp.

The reaction of astronauts to seeing Earth from space -- the mystery of creation. Parents seeing pieces of themselves echoed in their children who are nonetheless distinct and surprising -- the mystery of the person.

Much of the meditations in the encyclical are related to human dignity and fraternity. An example:

> Finitude, when truly accepted, does not diminish us but opens us to recognizing the face of God and others. Indeed, precisely because we experience limits — vulnerability, suffering and failure — we can recognize the inviolable dignity of every person, both our own and that of others.

[1] https://biblehub.com/greek/3466.htm