News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Gigachad on Sunday March 29, 2026 @05:25PM (#47567502)
Decades of HN users finger wagging and suggesting FOSS hardware has progressed society nowhere. 12 months from EU mandatory replaceable batteries and products across the industry are being redesigned with repairability, usb-c, and user friendly designs.

It’s time to accept regulation actually does work when you have a competent government.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by RajT88 on Sunday March 29, 2026 @05:45PM (#47567691)
Indeed, government regulation is decried mostly because of all the cases where it got polluted by special interests, instead of following the interests of general consumers.

This is how you end up turning a chunk of your food supply into fuel to subsidize crops which aren't all that good at being distilled into fuel in the first place...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Gigachad on Sunday March 29, 2026 @08:29PM (#47569003)
This is mostly because Americans keep electing total morons.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by RajT88 on Sunday March 29, 2026 @09:15PM (#47569332)
I would actually suggest this is symptomatic of the real problem: money in politics.

Elected officials (and some appointed, like SCOTUS) keep changing laws and precedents to allow more and more money in politics. They can't quit all that dark money - without a lot of funding, you don't get elected. Usually the best funded candidate wins.

There was an anonymous oped from a congressman some years back which bemoaned the reality - that 60% of their time was dedicated to meeting with donors for reelection campaigns instead of working on real problems.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by alsetmusic on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:51AM (#47570834)
When one party will violate every norm and law to the greatest extent that they can get away with it, it's pretty much impossible to compete with them. I want good things for people. I can't compete with fascists because they will cheat and lie and employ violence. My positive intent is almost impossible to out thwart their dirty deeds if they are willing to break laws / change laws and I won't.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by throwaway85825 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:48AM (#47571591)
There's only one party and it's color is green. Donors know red or blue doesn't matter, so they give to both.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by gcanyon on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:21AM (#47573348)
That's just an unreal characterization that plays into the hands of the "red" team. One side has put up presidents and congressional leadership that worked (mostly, I'm not saying they're perfect) within the traditional framework of the system. The other has put up a president who literally does not understand the meaning of the word "no," expects that everyone will let him do pretty much anything he wants, and a congress that agrees with him. Notably, that side was different in 2000, 1988, 1980, etc. -- not perfect by any stretch, but not this.

The difference matters.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hypeatei on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:40AM (#47575698)
Do you want another authoritarian, corrupt, cult of personality leader like Trump? Proclaiming "both sides" and ignoring nuance like you're doing is how no one gets held accountable for the real harms that are taking place. Please stop holding water for the MAGAs/GOP.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by throwaway85825 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:51AM (#47575832)
America has had even more corrupt/authoritarian/cult of personality leaders than Trump. They were younger and their brains still worked so they did way more damage than trump too. Most Americans just don't learn much history so can't compare.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hypeatei on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:49PM (#47576701)
> America has had even more corrupt/authoritarian/cult of personality leaders than Trump.

Like who?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by guzfip on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:52PM (#47576743)
Andrew Jackson to this day is a darling among conservatives in America.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by southerntofu on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:05AM (#47571679)
Assuming you're from the USA, your two main parties are exactly like that. The appearances have changed, but Obama drone-assassinating random children on the other side of the world was not much better than what Trump is doing.

Not defending Trump, to be clear, just saying US imperialism and fascism has much deeper roots and that removing Trump is not going to fix any issues the rest of the world has with the USA.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by actionfromafar on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:50AM (#47571992)
It was not better, it was less. US imperialism has deep roots, yes, but a large chunk of the world who would tolerate a moderate level of it, don't tolerate this level.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by nandomrumber on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:13AM (#47573270)
I don’t see any not tolerating it in practice.

A lot of invective, but nothing in practice that really indicates not tolerating.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by actionfromafar on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:54AM (#47573675)
I hear rumblings about foreign companies disconnecting from American services and products. You don't turn large ships on a dime, but they are turning.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by southerntofu on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:54AM (#47575871)
I don't think it was less, though only future historians will come up with actual numbers. It was less public, though.

Most of the world never tolerated it. Even when western governments tolerated it, the population did not; see also the huge worldwide demonstrations against the Iraq war.

I think the difference in perception is because the european oligarchy is now being effectively treated as was previously the rest of the world, so they're now taking a stance because they feel threatened, whereas they previously saw themselves as aligned with the US government no matter what.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by gcanyon on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:22AM (#47573357)
Can you point to an objective assessment of Obama's drone policy?
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by southerntofu on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:49AM (#47575804)
Unfortunately, i don't know of a complete reference resource. I'd be interested if you found one. A quick research later i found this CFR resource [1] which probably underestimates the number of civilians killed.

I remember reports at the time on the Intercept and other media about the entire kill chain. If i remember correctly, the policy was to count anyone who was not proved to be a civilian as an active enemy in the body count. There was this DOD/CIA press conference announcing they made a targeted killing and that their target assessment was mostly based on the individual's height.

Then there's of course Obama famously and publicly joking about his children's lovers suggesting they should behave or would get killed by « predator drones ». [2] Let me know if you dig interesting links on the topic!

[1] https://www.cfr.org/articles/obamas-final-drone-strike-data

[2] https://abcnews.com/WN/president-obama-tells-joke-jonas-brot...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by gcanyon on Monday March 30, 2026 @09:06PM (#47581594)
> famously and publicly joking ...at the white house correspondents dinner. I think that context matters.

I also think drone strikes exacerbate public outrage much the way mass shootings do: if we want to decrease gun deaths, limiting AR-15s isn't the way to do it because the vast majority of gun deaths are handguns. But mass shootings upset people, so we outlaw the guns that upset them. Similarly with drones, people don't get as upset about tens of thousands killed in a broader war, they're put off by the smaller number of casualties caused by drones.

You would think that if the policy was as flawed as you describe it would be easier to find evidence of it now?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by alsetmusic on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:39AM (#47573521)
USA government is corrupt, true. Current admin is balls-out corrupt in ways that have a French legislator calling out that impeachment would have happened there. It's shockingly out in the open corrupt, and that's saying a lot because most of the people ripping us off want to be somewhat quiet about it and not draw attention.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by southerntofu on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:51AM (#47575825)
I didn't hear about this french legislator, but that's funny given the level of rampant corruption in french government. Nothing new (see also Pasqua, Foccart, etc), but in the past decades the information was not widely available so it was at least possible to pretend not to know.

Much of the government including Macron himself are involved in corruption scandals. Others are involved in rape scandals. Others in fiscal fraud. But you're correct they're not as open about it as Trump is.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:37AM (#47575673)
It amazes me that so many people blame the politicians and not the people who elected them.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by frantathefranta on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:23PM (#47576313)
Blaming voters for being stupid is not widely accepted yet.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:25PM (#47576339)
The voters aren’t stupid. They are actively malignant and cheer what the administration is doing.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by mrguyorama on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:28PM (#47577205)
Okay but what solution lies down that road?

That's the problem. People don't want to blame the voters because there's no solution. We are grasping for something that is possible to fix that isn't just "Somehow americans are especially bad at doing very basic things for no reason"

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:42PM (#47578783)
The large citizenries that later (19th century) forced administrations into constitutions and participation in policy started out with state mandated education and a class consciousness that is based on being knowledged and sophisticated. You need to make the next generation as smart as possible as you can, optimally also on topics concerning the society and economics.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:53PM (#47578936)
The late 19th century was also when “Separate but Equal” was enshrined as the law of the land by the Supreme Court and a few decades later there were Japanese internment camps…
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:43PM (#47577387)
Well, I personally am making the “Ben Kenobi” choice. I’m hoping to leave the US and retire and die and make it the next generation’s problem.

I’ve done my part, I have voted for “progressive”/safety net policies and the US has gone in the opposite direction. This isn’t some shrill unthought out plan.

I’m actually in the country now I plan to retire to for six weeks and I’m coming back for a month in the summer, part of the ex-pat community and meeting people, my wife and I have been learning Spanish and I speak it okay and I know the processes for establishing residency here

I’m over dealing with the American people. As a minority, I find the entire attitude outside of the US refreshing even as the only Black couple in our expat group. For reference, my still living parents grew up in the segregated South.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by naikrovek on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:16PM (#47577766)
Well we can’t recall the voters, so there is no point in addressing them. They are a problem because in the US there used to be an FCC rule that said “if you call yourself a news program, you must tell the truth,” and that was overridden by the Supreme Court during Reagan’s term.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:20PM (#47577816)
No there was never a rule about “telling the truth” the rule was “equal time”. So if one party said “vaccines keep people from dying” and the other party said “vaccines would cause you to grow extra limbs” you had to allow them both on.

Second, it had nothing to do with the Supreme Court. The theory was that the airwaves belong to the public and the FCC has jurisdiction. It never applied to cable channels like FoxNews

Third, the current FCC is going after broadcast networks for not being fair under the rule

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:44PM (#47578808)
> The theory was that the airwaves belong to the public and the FCC has jurisdiction.

Now most things go over the shared network (InterNet) so that problem should have fixed it self, no?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:51PM (#47578906)
Airwaves are limited resource - especially spectrum suitable for broadcast. Two companies can’t share the same broadcast spectrum.

The Internet is not a limited resource and not owned by the public and licensed to broadcasters. More than one company can lay cable.

Do you really want the government policing what can be said on the internet?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by fragmede on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:28PM (#47579320)
It does already. Section 230 in the US isn't an unlimited get out of jail free card. Other countries have varying amount of policing, with differing levels of success and corruption. Spain, the UK, and China all come to mind here.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:12PM (#47579749)
Section 230 only has to do with defamation in this context not “misinformation”.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by sehansen on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:31AM (#47571874)
Part of the reason money has such a big influence on elections is that first-past-the-post election system you have over there in the US. When voters have to make a binary choice between two participants, low-information campaigns like hit-pieces are able to make a big difference and are cheap to communicate en-masse. When voters have a actual choice between four parties on the left and four parties on the right, hit-pieces will only make a voter switch from, say, one left-wing party to another. So since the return-on-investment on political advertising is much lower, much less money will be spent on it and there will be less of it. And what will be there will be of higher quality.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by nandomrumber on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:10AM (#47573239)
If any of what you just said was true in practice, Australia would be a gleaming example of how democracies with strong civil society organisations can be run.

Instead, Australia is best described as pigs at the slops trough.

A nation that seems to only want to vote for leaders who have a public humiliation kink.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by MisterTea on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:41AM (#47573538)
> that 60% of their time was dedicated to meeting with donors for reelection campaigns instead of working on real problems.

This is the same story told by Tom Morello, guitarist of Rage Against the Machine (at the end of the early life section): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Morello#Early_life

Key line: "He had to compromise his entire being every day."

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by sandworm101 on Monday March 30, 2026 @09:12AM (#47573869)
Yes yes yes. Dark money. Nepotism. Corrupt courts. Gerrymandering .... anything to deflect from the fact that so many voters still put thier mark beside the biggest idiot. And i mean that literally. American voters like tall people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heights_of_presidents_and_pres...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ToucanLoucan on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:32AM (#47575612)
They're all problems and they all contribute to the reality of our government being unable to actually do anything beyond tax cuts.

* People elect morons because we have been slowly destroying our education system since the 50's and we can barely turn out anyone who can think worth a shit. That's by design, as local elections overwhelmingly swing Republican, and Republicans on balance gain from an ignorant electorate.

* Additionally, we are now bombarded with "information" from wake to sleep every single day, and beyond the actual problems which are already stressful enough, we also have a whole bunch of made up culture war nonsense that mainstream and alternative media loves to discuss, both to fill airtime and because researching and covering nonsense is far less work, less legally actionable, and garners more attention overall. Information overload affects people too and makes them more likely to choose easy/quick things.

* Dark money is also a HUGE issue because it permits capital to influence elections like never before. It's no coincidence all of this shit got turbocharged after Citizens United.

* Gerrymandering is also a huge, huge issue wherein Democrat votes are simply disregarded or packed into single districts, which helps local elections shift further right constantly.

* The courts are also hideously corrupt. The Supreme Court is utterly failing to reign in the Trump administration on everything short of wiping their asses with the constitution, and that's not shocking considering how many of them were appointed by Trump and confirmed by the inept Congress.

And then any time Democrats do manage to acquire something resembling power, they have so many fires to put out that they can barely get us back to an even keel before another "outsider" dumbass comes in and starts screwing it up again.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:42AM (#47575725)
People aren’t electing “morons” out of ignorance. They are electing people that hate the same people they hate. You are blaming ignorance where it is active malice.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:35PM (#47578717)
Electing people for the things they hate is ignorance for politics as a serious field.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:48PM (#47578868)
Again you call it ignorance instead of malevolence.

How is electing Trump any different than George Wallace having a slogan of “Segregation Now! Segregation Tomorrow! Segregation Forever!”?

There was no ignorance. Everyone knows that the government has a “monopoly on [legalized] violence”. If they can elect people who will turn that violence against people they don’t like, they are doing it with full knowledge.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:25AM (#47585215)
Ignorance is a type of action, malevolence is a motivation. You can be ignorant out of malevolence and your ignorance can result in your actions being malicious.

Voting based on who the (to be) elected hate instead of on actual policy is ignorant towards the serious matter of the art of leading a state (politics). Being malevolent regarding politics would be to sabotage elections or trying to dissolve state organs.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:37AM (#47588003)
You mean when thousands of yokels broke into the Capital to try to overturn an election in January of 2020?
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @12:45PM (#47590089)
I thought we are still talking about "electing".
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @07:41PM (#47594938)
They were explicitly trying to “sabotage an election”
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by RajT88 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:57AM (#47575926)
Politics is an arm's race. This is going to be an unpopular opinion, but Democrats do all the same things Republicans do. Arguably they differ in how they do it, and how much. Democrats gerrymander, and as well traffic in conspiracy theories for example (the latter they do less than Republicans, but they still do it).
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by braebo on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:23PM (#47579270)
They aren’t even remotely close to being the same at this point.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by RajT88 on Thursday April 02, 2026 @09:51AM (#47614498)
They aren't the same. Democrats don't traffic in fascism.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by mrguyorama on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:39PM (#47577343)
American government was actually perfectly able to "Do things" right up until 2008. Republicans and Democrats quite literally worked together in Congress in broad cliques that normally crossed party boundaries, and did this all the time. When Clinton's admin was trying to save money on the budget, the fights in Congress frequently crossed party lines and were outright bipartisan, about actual merits (claimed or real) of the programs they were cutting or vouching for. You had Republicans rightly blasting certain Democrats for saying stupid things about the SSC shoulder to shoulder with other democrats.

Then in 2008 Mitch McConnel said, literally to reporters, "I will make Obama a one term president" and declared their job was to not let the government do anything.

And just like that, it became Republican Party Doctrine that you do not cross the party line or else you get fired. This was absolutely supported and highly praised by their constituents! As Democrat politicians continued to work their assess off crossing the aisle, finding any way to keep the country functioning as half of the government declared strike (the irony).

But for some reason we aren't allowed to say this. Republicans directly say their plan and strategy and malice to the camera and we get punished for showing their voters exactly what they vote for.

Democrats are still trying to make deals, because half of them are literally just republicans with a (D), but if you ever ever ever ever cross the aisle as a Republican, even to fix a problem your base has spent decades screaming about, you get primaried.

Republican voters have done this. The republican party has chosen to do this. They own this.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by nine_k on Sunday March 29, 2026 @08:41PM (#47569104)
Not that most other nations do dramatically better, alas.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Gigachad on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:21AM (#47571019)
There's actually few that are this bad. Generally we refer to them as developing countries or war torn.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by gmerc on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:33AM (#47571096)
… and legalized bribes as lobbying.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by varispeed on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:36AM (#47574922)
It is also because corruption is called lobbying in America. Corporate lobbying should be illegal and punished severely (including capital punishment for directors and confiscation of the corporation).
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by cromka on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:00AM (#47575216)
This. Came here to say this. People completely forget about this supposed nuance when comparing US and Europe, but this is exactly what leads to fundamentally different outcomes in legislation and, by extension, people's expectations of their governments. That frog is long-time cooked.

As an ex-expat to US, I never could stop smh over how Americans are not making it a number 1 issue for themselves. Private prison, private healthcare, gun industry, all types of small industries keep US government in their pockets and the society, as a whole, in a complete gridlock, unable to meet its actual expectations.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by analog8374 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:57AM (#47575174)
People believe whatever authority tells them. It's one of those bug/feature things.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by autoexec on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @05:54AM (#47598836)
People believe whatever they want to be true. If people were just slaves to authority the US would have far fewer covid deaths. Some people really are bootlickers, but even then they tend to choose whose boots they bend over for. It's rarely blind obedience to authority itself.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:36AM (#47575661)
It’s not like “privacy first EU” didn’t just try to pass Chat Control
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:52AM (#47575839)
The EU did not pass Chat Control is the key message here. Your framing is strange.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:55AM (#47575889)
And only 40% of people still support Trump. But the analogy is the same.

If you have 10 friends and ask them where they want to eat for dinner and six day let’s go to an Italian restaurant and 4 say “let’s kill Bob and eat him”, you still have a shitty group of friends.

It only takes one controversy to tip the scales. All governments have a propensity to want more power.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by swiftcoder on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:15PM (#47576204)
> All governments have a propensity to want more power.

Some governments have more effective checks-and-balances than others. The EU is a much looser confederation than the US, with significantly more power still invested in the member states (many of whom themselves are also loose confederations of semi-autonomous provinces...)

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:27PM (#47576361)
And let terrorism happen to any number of the member states. They would demand Chat Control being passed
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by swiftcoder on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:03PM (#47576883)
The EU is no stranger to terrorism? The troubles in Ireland, ETA in Spain, Al Qzaeda and ISIL in France/Spain/Germany, domestic terrorism in Norway/Germany/Denmark - all in the last 35 years.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:15PM (#47576199)
The analogy is not the same. Trump was elected. Chat Control failed its vote.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by sham1 on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:26PM (#47576346)
If you want a government of saints, you will be sorely disappointed. The four people who want to kill Bob and eat him for dinner will always exist, and the important part is to not let them actually decide on the dinner plan instead of just throwing your hand up in the air and giving up on planning dinners because some people are loonies and should not be given power.

Yeah, just like with Chat Control and such, it takes vigilance and informing people around you in order to deny these sorts of things from happening, but we can take some respite in it not happening. The USB-C regulation changed things for the better by forcing the most obstinate member of the mobile phone ecosystem to adopt the connector. The replaceable battery regulation will force manufacturers to make their devices more repairable, and that is a good thing.

Discounting that because of political mistakes that were only narrowly avoided seems frankly myopic. You can't just argue against all the good things the EU has done with "whatabout Chat Control"

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by BoorishBears on Sunday March 29, 2026 @06:58PM (#47568347)
That's a great example of their point, all I got was a mechanically inferior connector (putting the most important piece of the female connector on a floating sliver of plastic was a choice) and the cable hell attached to USB C.

If USB C had been so important to me I wouldn't have bought iPhones all those years.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by crimsontech on Sunday March 29, 2026 @08:57PM (#47569204)
I have tried to explain this so many times to people. You could just scrape out the lint from the lighting port with a tooth pick. The fragile part was the easily replaceable cable. Now the fragile part is in the iPhone itself.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by kalleboo on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:42AM (#47570448)
Lightning had the contact springs in the phone, USB-C has the contact springs on the cable. This is the part that wears out, and USB-C moving to the cable is an improvement.

Throughout its life, Lightning suffered from "black pin plague" where when springs in the port wore out, the power pin would start arcing. Now you have a cable with poor connectivity on the power pin, and you use this cable in another Apple device and it starts arcing on that device as well, causing that device to start transmitting this disease. It was a terrible design and USB-C does not have it.

https://ioshacker.com/iphone/why-the-fourth-pin-on-your-ligh...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Gigachad on Sunday March 29, 2026 @09:10PM (#47569291)
Apple was on the design committee for USB-C, they also failed to make lightning an industry standard after 10+ years. The EU didn't design the connector, they just required the industry pick a design, and USB-C is what Apple and the rest designed.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by bigyabai on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:06AM (#47570571)
If Lightning is so important to you then you can still use Lightning-based iPhones. Nobody took away the hardware they sold you, they just mandated that the new ones adopt a common standard.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by catlikesshrimp on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:22AM (#47572888)
If lightning was vastly superior, they could still have a lightning port in addition to the usb, or make a different version with their propietary port for the rest of the world. But it wasn't superior.

I understand the added difficulty of making a version with a different port. Again, if it was Uber superior, it would have made for very good advertisemebt for apple.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by avidiax on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:27AM (#47571053)
You also got a connector that supports much more than USB 2.0 speeds. It also supports high power charging, video, thunderbolt, etc.

Lightning was a dead-end connector that was only kept around to keep the Made-for-iPhone moat drawbridge up.

USB-C makes the right design choice in putting the springs in the cable. Those wear out over time. I've never seen the male part of the female USB-C break, but I'm sure it's possible. But reversing this would require that the springs on the USB-C cable are on the outside, and those are quite fragile, so that sounds like a worse idea.

USB-C is mostly a good design.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hbs18 on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:02AM (#47572754)
> I've never seen the male part of the female USB-C break, but I'm sure it's possible

I know anecdotes don't mean anything, but I have. Every USB-C phone I've ever had, apart from my iPhone that I currently use, ended up with having completely worn out connectors after two-three years of use. They stop holding cables in firm enough and start only making the connection when holding the cable at an angle.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by catlikesshrimp on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:16AM (#47572852)
Could you mention what phone models were those. I haven't seen one port go bad.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hbs18 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:00AM (#47574463)
They were an LG Nexus 5X, a OnePlus 3T and a Xiaomi Mi 8. The ports became loose on all of them over time, especially on the OnePlus where the cable would just fall out if you held the device upright, and in its final days the Xiaomi would need the cable pushed at an angle to make a connection.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Dusseldorf on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:30AM (#47573438)
I don't want to sound like a jerk, but have you considered that you might need to improve your putting/unplugging habits? I used to have connectors and cords break after around that much time. Around 2018 or so I bought a new set of chargers and decent quality cloth sheathed cables. Because all my cords were new, I was much more diligent about carefully plugging and unplugging (no mashing the port, no flexing across the short axis, no yanking by the cord) and eventually a habit formed. Not a single one of those cords, nor any of the ports on my phones, have broken since then. Even the daily use ones next to my bed!
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hbs18 on Monday March 30, 2026 @09:57AM (#47574414)
I treat my phones carefully, I've literally never cracked a screen on any of them, the same goes for handling the charging cable and port. I'm always quite gentle with it, never leaving it propped up by the cable or at a weird angle, and the cables I used were the original ones that came with my devices. Mainly because my phones spend a lot of time plugged in acting as a hotspot for half a week, so I try to minimize the harm I cause by the extra (un)plug events.

The Lightning port iPhone that I used for 3 years however handled my usage just fine (just tried it now and it feels just like it did new), and the USB-C one I've had for half a year seems to be holding up fine as well. These I used with a mix of cheap Aliexpress cables and the genuine Apple ones.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by TheLegace on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:02PM (#47578349)
I don't understand this logic. If lightning connector had less issues than USB-C how could it the users fault for not being careful. This exactly how engineers/developers answer to problems they cause with bad engineering/design choices. Anyone that gives feedback is blamed. It leads to terrible engineering decisions like the USB standard, which frankly has always been bloated and terrible because of its design by committee. As much I would love a standard connection port for all my phones I won't accept substandard engineering. That's why I am still holding onto my lighting connector devices even though on principle I disagree with using them.

Who gets to decide that I have to treat my devices that I pay for like fragile glass vases.

I do both QA and Development and pretty competent at both. I almost never make broken things or poorly thought out because I know this negative feedback loop will continually make the situation worse. Lack of empathy for people that use products just leads to issues like Windows taskbar not even being able to search for applications. Its all the same thought process that leads to the result.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by jen20 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:10PM (#47581960)
A good option here is to use MagSafe for charging. I don't think I've ever plugged anything into the USB-C port on my iPhone.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by nosrepa on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:28PM (#47577202)
Probably a lot of lint in there! My 4 year old phone gets that way until I clean it out with a plastic pick (very vigorously at that) and it's like new again.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hbs18 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:59AM (#47584533)
Lint was only ever an issue with my Lightning connector iPhone. Unfortunately it wasn't the issue with the USB-C phones, the ports were just worn out.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Halian on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:03AM (#47573164)
Would that USB 2.0 Type-C were somehow outlawed, or even better that every device that used Type-C supported everything it can do.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ianburrell on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:33PM (#47577269)
You don't want that. I was organizing my cables and noticed how much thicker the USB3 cables are than USB2. USB2 cables are cheaper than USB3 cables, the latter have gotten cheaper but still buy two USB2 for some USB3. USB3 cables are also shorter cause harder to transmit signal, this has also gotten better.

The flaw is that USB-IF didn't require marking faster cables. Putting a blue ring, stripe, or dot would have solved the problem.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by speleding on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:33AM (#47573472)
USB-C is decent for data transfer. It's pretty poor for power delivery: the pins are too close, so it's not rated for use in bathrooms or kitchens, and there are many more of them than needed for power delivery, making it relatively expensive to use in things like children's toys.

It was a mistake to conflate flexible power delivery and data transfer, you rarely need both at the same time. It's possible to design a better and cheaper 3 or 4 pin power delivery standard that can use higher power. But the law now says USB-C and good luck ever changing that.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:56PM (#47578971)
USB is a bus that is intended to be universal for serial *data*, that is what it is designed for.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Dylan16807 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:25PM (#47582403)
1. The law doesn't mandate USB-C in particular, the port can change without the law changing

2. Nobody was going to add a second port for charging when USB can handle fast charging already. And if you need to charge in a damp environment then use wireless.

3. I'm pretty sure you can add a second port and the EU law doesn't mind at all

And assuming USB 2.0, how much cheaper do you expect a simpler port to be?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raverbashing on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:33AM (#47571890)
Apple can't even make their strain relief on their cables work properly due to "being ugly" so preferring them to USBC is just another case of Apple-juice-kool-aid
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by PunchyHamster on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:31AM (#47573445)
it's ridiculus that this is still the problem ,that's no 1 cause for dead cables for our helpdesk
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by PunchyHamster on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:30AM (#47573437)
Putting spring on the connector part rather than socket part means the easily replaceable part has wear item. Lighting is designed wrong here.

And our helpdesk had more broken lightning connectors than anything else in shop that's ~ 50/50 PC/Mac

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by mrWiz on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:03AM (#47575244)
I’m surprised to hear that it was such a common failure. I used plenty of lighting devices back in their hay day and plenty of USBC devices since they became common. I don’t tend to treat those devices gingerly and have far more issues with USBC than I ever did with Lightning, even accounting for the fact that lots of devices have USBC but only phones and mp3 players had lightning.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by edhelas on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:56AM (#47570864)
Gigachad writing there <3
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by oneeyedpigeon on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:24AM (#47571824)
Their point is almost the exact opposite to the one a 'gigachad' would make.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 0dayz on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:09AM (#47572100)
And yet their name concludes otherwise.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by oneeyedpigeon on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:29AM (#47573424)
Fair point! I didn't even notice their username, in case that weren't very obvious.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:20AM (#47571010)
Having the government regulate the free market is an issue of physical force and should always be discussed as such. Are you willing to deal with men by force beyond retaliation? This issue is moral, not practical.

Besides, it’s easy to sell one’s freedom to a competent government, but it’s insanely hard to get it back when it rots. This has been the case of many welfare states. “Let’s force them to do the damn thing” is the very root of all social conflicts, not a magical solution. Being able to withstand it is a commendable exception, not rule.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by cortesoft on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:32AM (#47571093)
Look, there is certainly a good argument to be made that regulation of this sort isn't the best way to achieve the goal.

However, trying to use an argument that this is 'an issue of physical force' is a ridiculous way to make an argument for that perspective. All laws eventually come down to that, so it is pointless to debate that for every discussion on what the law should be.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:42AM (#47571153)
Laws protect everyone’s rights, both consumers and producers. When they are targeted to favor a specific collective, it’s fair to bring up the issue of physical force. The 20th century is repleted with examples of one social group fighting the other by seeking special privileges and favors.

So I don’t think it’s ridiculous, I think it’s efficient.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ahf8Aithaex7Nai on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:36AM (#47571505)
The perfect example of cognitive dissonance! The government, which mandates that the can of tomato soup I buy must not contain any glass shards, is immediately equated with physical violence. Although the shopkeeper who requires me to pay for the can before I take it out of the store is far more likely to get in my face if I don’t follow their rules. I don’t understand this worldview. You’re selling your freedom to big corporations. Your life expectancy is declining. Your food is of poor quality. Your cities are full of homeless people. But then again, I am an unfree European blinded by communism.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:40AM (#47571930)
If I buy a can of soup and find glass in it, I have a valid claim against the manufacturer. It's a matter of holding someone accountable for fraud or negligence, not a matter of regulation. The proper route is a court, not a bureaucratic agency that preemptively dictates production methods on the assumption that every manufacturer is a potential prisoner.

> get in my face if I don’t follow their rules

If a shopkeeper asks me to leave because I refuse to follow his rules, he's exercising his right to control his own property, he's not initiating force.

> You’re selling your freedom to big corporations.

I'm not selling my freedom to corporations, they can't throw me in jail, or take my property by edict. The government, by contrast, holds a legal monopoly on force.

I am not an American, so I cannot diagnose declining life expectancy, homelessness, poor food, and other problems from afar. But I do know this: personal problems don't give one a moral claim on other people's labor. Need does not justify compulsion, and citizens are not sacrificial animals.

> I am an unfree European blinded by communism.

You hinted that Europe's communist past was somehow not a cautionary tale.

> The perfect example of cognitive dissonance!

Dressed-up ad hominem. You have no idea what I do or don't hold in my mind.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ahf8Aithaex7Nai on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:29AM (#47572234)
> not a bureaucratic agency that preemptively dictates production methods on the assumption that every manufacturer is a potential prisoner.

I see it exactly the other way around. I want this to be clarified upfront, not after I’ve already cut my tongue. What I don’t understand is why market participants are being given special treatment here. There are laws, and they must be followed. That applies just as much in other areas.

> personal problems don't give one a moral claim on other people's labor

Which problem is personal and which isn't? You seem to be twisting this to suit your questionable argument.

> You have no idea what I do or don't hold in my mind

But I read what you write and interpret it. Just as you read what I write and interpret it. Here’s another ad hominem for you: in your worldview, there is no morality at all. At least, none that is consistent. People like you behave toward the state like moody teenagers toward their parents. You don’t want to be told what to do, but you wouldn’t survive a single month without the institution you so despise.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:09AM (#47572463)
> why market participants are being given special treatment here. There are laws, and they must be followed.

Laws are contextual, they depend on more fundamental principles. A regulation that says "you must use this specific screw size" isn't a law in the same sense as "you shall not murder." When a "law" violates the principle of non-initiation of force, when it tells a manufacturer how to exercise his property rights under threat of imprisonment, it's not really a law but edict.

The issue is who decides and when. A court decides after harm occurs, based on evidence of actual negligence or fraud. A regulatory agency decides before anyone does anything, based on hypothetical risks, and compels compliance under threat of force.

> Which problem is personal and which isn't?

A personal problem is one that doesn't involve the infringement of rights against another person. Most problems are personal. One's homelessness doesn't give one a right to another's property. The moment you say "your need obligates me," you've crossed the line into compulsion.

> in your worldview, there is no morality at all. . . . People like you behave toward the state like moody teenagers toward their parents.

That tells me enough about the depth of your study on this subject. Morality is a science of identifying the principles by which a rational being sustains his life. You're not discussing that science, you're reaching for a metaphor.

> But I read what you write and interpret it.

"Cognitive dissonance" is an accusation about the state of my mind, not an interpretation. You don't get to call me internally contradictory and then say "I'm just interpreting."

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by eszed on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:47AM (#47575786)
Yeah, that guy got unnecessarily personal. Let me try.

You're right that civil judgements (and, though you haven't mentioned it yet, reputational brand damage through public exposure) are important checks on harm, but they break down in particular circumstances. In the first place, they're not a fair fight: corporations are able to limit, or even prevent, access to the court system by forced arbitration, jurisdiction changes, or intentionally running up attorney fees beyond what any plaintiffs can afford to risk. They also have ($£€¥, again) larger megaphones than any individual can reliably command.

The toy example of glass in a soup can makes for a perfect case, but civil suits are impossible to pursue where harms are long-term, diffuse, cumulative, or simply too difficult for a jury of lay-people to understand. For instance, we all know that lead is harmful, but when multiple sources of lead exist it's impossible to prove (to the standard correctly required by the courts) that this company's lead caused your particular illness. It's similarly impossible to prove that any particular cancer-causing agent caused any particular cancer, even when we know statistically that it has raised the cancer risk profile of millions of people, and therefore been a causative factor in many deaths.

If we insist that the only mechanism for redress be individual companies held to account in individual cases, we either give up on the idea that corporate behavior can be aligned with the public interest, or (worse?) we make sure that politically-disfavored companies will be scapegoated by the media or the courts, while better-connected players get away with anything at all.

Please allow me to forestall one possible counter-argument: if you, as my Libertarian-ish relatives do, reject outright the idea of "public interest", then we won't have much to say to each other: our world-views are simply too different. Otherwise, I'm interested in what you have to say.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:23PM (#47579276)
I don't know the precise legal mechanisms for handling diffuse harms like the ones you describe. Determining the best means of applying the principle of suing corporations in practice is an very complex question that belongs to the philosophy of law. My task here is only to establish the nature of the principle and to show that it is practicable.

That said, here is my principle: at any time, the government is orders of magnitude more powerful than any corporation. I think it is proper, in some cases, for the government itself to act as a plaintiff, to aggregate evidence, bring suit, and prove causation statistically. I can't delimit that role precisely, but I side with you that in some cases only the government has access to all necessary evidence.

And no, I don't agree with the idea of "public interest." Any claim that "the public interest" supersedes private rights means that the interests of some men are to be sacrificed to the interests of others.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by eszed on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:40PM (#47579445)
> the government is orders of magnitude more powerful than any corporation.

As a practical matter, that's untrue in many, many places around the world, and there are no reasons why it couldn't become true in the USA, or any other advanced democracy. Even if you don't think that is yet the case where you live, can you at least agree with me that many leaders of / investors in large corporations want it to be, and are working towards that end?

I think your position in your second paragraph is at odds with your position in the third.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:34PM (#47580000)
I do agree. In many places, governments are weak, captured, or corrupt. But those are mixed economies, in which state and corporate power fuse into one corrupt swamp: corporations lobby for regulations to crush rivals, officials sell favors. That's not evidence that economic power equals political power, it's evidence that abandoning the principle of a government limited to retaliatory force produces a cold civil war of pressure groups. The solution isn't more regulation, it's total separation of state and economics.

> your second paragraph is at odds with your third

No. The government acting as plaintiff is still retaliatory force: harm occurred, the state helps identify the perpetrator. That's not "public interest" overriding private rights, it's the government protecting individual rights by standing in for many individuals who share a common injury.

And yes, corporate leaders want political power. That's cronyism. They want to use force because they can't win in a free market. It's a road to dictatorship, but the road is laid by the principle of "public interest," not unlimited profit motives.

There's no such thing as "the public," only individuals. When one treats "the public" as a blank check to override private rights, one is really saying: some people get sacrificed to others. The taxi industry lobbying to ban Uber isn't about safety or competition. "Affordable housing" mandates that force landlords to subsidize strangers aren't compassion. This institutionalized cold civil war won't end until the state stops pickign winners.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by eszed on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:38PM (#47581029)
A government

> standing in for many individuals who share a common injury.

Sounds like a synonym for "public interest" to me! Is that a semantic difference, or do you think there's something substantive to it?

I'd like to know how you'd handle the case of a new industrial plant (let's even say it's a brand new technology) that will exhaust lead into the atmosphere. Does the government have to wait until there's demonstrable harm, and then lodge a suit in court? Isn't it... cleaner (for want of a better word, and no pun intended) to have a law in place that says "No Lead-spewing (as defined by [reasonable technical standard]) Allowed", and prevent it being built altogether? From another angle, under which paradigm would hypothetical investors prefer to operate?

In fact, and this is true, industry often requests regulations be put in place, because they'd like to be certain that their investments won't be subjected to the uncertainty of (private or public) litigation. Yes, this can be malign (in the cases of corruption, or regulatory capture, or incumbents freezing out smaller competitors), but at its most basic the request can be seen as benign: "we'd like to comply with community standards; please write down what they are, and we'll follow them" - no violence required or implied. It's also, and to my way of thinking more importantly, a way to break out of prisoner's dilemma equilibria, where all players can agree the sector as a whole will be better off without defectors, but appeal to an outside, neutral party to keep themselves honest.

I'm also curious about what seems to be your premise that The Courts are separate from The State. That's not how I think of them at all! I mean, aren't they, kind of by definition? After all, if one ignores a judgement - even civil - isn't the ruling ultimately enforced by, well, Force?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ahf8Aithaex7Nai on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:59AM (#47583288)
Here is “that guy.” You won't convince them with practical examples, because this is a matter of principle. Freedom and independence from the state are more important to these people than a few people suffering from lead poisoning. From their perspective, living a free life and then dying of lead poisoning is still better than being subjugated by the Leviathan.

> your second paragraph is at odds with your third

Well, well. That didn’t take long.

The teenager was a carefully chosen comparison. The state’s authority over the citizen is similar to a parent’s authority over their child. This is quite humiliating and emasculating. And I agree with libertarians on one point: if the state is against you, you don’t stand a chance. A healthy approach to this has two components. (1) You make sure that the authority is benevolent or at least allows enough leeway for a good life. (2) You create enclaves of freedom. The teenager hides his weed and smokes it secretly, or smokes his cigarettes on the way to school. The citizen leaves some income untaxed and runs a red light now and then. What does the teenager who categorically rejects parental authority do? Run away and become homeless? The difference between them and an adult is that the latter should have enough sense to realize that the romantic notion of a life free from the burden of authority ultimately leads to sadness, coldness, loneliness, and misery—or, if it succeeds at all, merely re-establishes structures in which forms of authority are entrenched. Libertarians feel most oppressed by the state every time they have to wait at a red light or obey a speed limit. They fail to see that, in doing so, they are submitting to a principle of order that is necessary for road traffic to function at all.

> Is that a semantic difference, or do you think there's something substantive to it?

That is a very important point! Philosophers distinguish between the particular and the universal. Libertarians recognize only the particular and reject any notion of the universal, because it negates all particularities. For them, a group is always just an accumulation of individuals. A genuine community—which consists precisely in the participating individuals restricting themselves to some extent for the sake of the community—is inconceivable to them as something positive. Hence the infamous Thatcher quote: “... and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families ...” That is an ideological divide that cannot be bridged through discussion. I’ve gone over this enough times already.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:15AM (#47586209)
> You won't convince them with practical examples, because this is a matter of principle. . . . Libertarians recognize only the particular and reject any notion of the universal, because it negates all particularities.

You describe people who advocate freedom as both mystics indifferent to reality and pragmatists without principle. Which is it?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ahf8Aithaex7Nai on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @10:30AM (#47587926)
Where do I claim that libertarians are pragmatists? They do have principles—just the wrong ones. Incidentally, I don’t think they’re really concerned with freedom, at least not in the Kantian sense.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @11:25AM (#47588744)
I don’t think that either libertarians or Kant are genuinely concerned with freedom. My position is closest to classical liberalism, with different philosophical foundations.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by eszed on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:57PM (#47594576)
I've argued (mostly offline, for my sins) with far more libertarian-ish people than I care to have, and I think piekvorst has a) been a more congenial conversational partner than you gave him credit, and b) approached the subject from a slightly different angle than I'd expected, so I'm still enjoying the interchange. In particular (read our latest replies to each other, if you care), he's in favor of regulating lead pollution, so he's miles ahead of certain of my relatives in both principles and practicalities!

But... Yeah. I'm in much more agreement with your point of view, and he's still Wrong On The Internet, so here we are. :-)

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:49AM (#47585425)
> Is that a semantic difference, or do you think there’s something substantive to it?

"Public interest" today implies a conflict with private interests: a new sports arena, "affordable" housing, protecting domestic jobs. So no, government-as-plaintiff doesn't count.

Personally, I'd define the public interest as interests common to all men: freedom, not sacrifices of some to others. But that's not the modern meaning of it.

> Does the government have to wait until there’s demonstrable harm

Anticipating harm is proper when the decision is irreversible. Example: nobody has a right to physically block a public entrance. That's a right violation you can prohibit in advance. Same with pollution: objective laws ("you may not emit substance X beyond concentration Y") set a clear boundary without dictatign production methods.

But there's no harm to anticipate in, say, Lightning vs. USB-C.

> your premise that The Courts are separate from The State

If you got it from the way I contrasted courts with regulatory agencies, I actually contrasted the way the state can wield force: retaliatory (proper) vs initiatory (improper). Other than that, the courts and state aren't separated.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by eszed on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:25PM (#47593664)
Yeah, I think our difference on "public interest" is semantic. I wouldn't even quibble with your "interests common to all" definition, so the next step would be to draw lines about what, in practice, that means. Frankly, I think we'd agree about a lot of it: sports arenas and (at least in the abstract) "protecting jobs" don't count for me, either!

You are correct about where I (over) interpreted your view of the court system. Apologies for that, and thanks for the clarification. However, I still don't think I understand the distinction you draw between "retaliatory (proper) vs initiatory (improper)". Would you then say that there shouldn't be a permitting / approval system (because that's anticipatory), so enforcement should be limited to taking pollution readings and acting (in retaliation, natch) after a facility is built? Even if you can sustain that position in principle, I think it would be impractical, across a number of dimensions, in reality. But, it's possible that I misunderstood that point, so please explain further.

I also note a segment from one of your earlier comments, where you advocated for "total separation of state and economics". In my view this is utterly impossible. Regulating pollutants is an intervention that (properly, we agree!) works to the economic disadvantage of pollutors. Even more fundamentally, a (functional, large scale) market economy depends entirely on the state's ability to adjudicate and enforce (at least) contractual terms. I don't think your view can be sustained.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by rjmunro on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:53AM (#47575123)
> If I buy a can of soup and find glass in it, I have a valid claim against the manufacturer.

What does that mean?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:40AM (#47575699)
It means you can sue for product liability under common law. Negligence, breach of warranty, or strict liability, depending on jurisdiction. Court decides after harm.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by pixl97 on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:22PM (#47576295)
Right, this typically works very well after you spend tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars getting all the stuff to court in the first place to have a trial drag on for years in discovery all the while the hospital is sending out debt collectors.

Oh, that's if it wasn't actually a shell company in the first place that has no assets.

A good portion of the things you mention existed before we had food regulations, you could sue the business if you had issues with them. The problem is the vast portion of the population is far too poor to do that. Regulations stop the harm before it happens.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:45PM (#47579502)
My claim is narrower: the principle of retaliatory force is practicable. That is, a society can function using only courts, class actions, and government-as-plaintiff, without preemptive editcs on screw sizes or battery compartments.

As I said earlier in this thread:

> Determining the best means of applying the principle of suing corporations in practice is an very complex question that belongs to the philosophy of law.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by pixl97 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:49PM (#47591043)
>My claim is narrower: the principle of retaliatory force is practicable

Ah yes, the school of theory that says it's better to clean up the spilled milk after its been contaminated with uranium waste.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:14PM (#47592092)
You’re assuming that without preemptive permits, nothing stops a company from spewing uranium. But liability, if properly enforced, is a powerful deterrent. The threat of paying full cleanup costs, compensating victims, and facing criminal charges for negligence doesn’t require an official to approve one’s pipe size in advance.

Further, the principle doesn’t deny retaliating in advance when violence can be objectively anticipated.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by pixl97 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:39PM (#47593182)
This does not and cannot exist when the corporate veil exists. Make a corporate shell and throw it away like a used condom.

Add to that a company can cause a trillion dollars of damage while having only a billion dollars on hand. Criminal charges don't fix things, if they did there wouldn't be murderers in jail.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:31PM (#47576429)
Sue them in who's court? With who to enforce the ruling?

The... government?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:42PM (#47579471)
Courts, police, and the army are proper. That's government. The difference is what kind of government. A proper government holds a monopoly on retaliatory force, it acts after someone initiates force or fraud. It doesn't dictate your screw size, battery compartment, or production method before you've harmed anyone.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:18PM (#47579814)
...why? This sounds incredibly arbitrary.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:47PM (#47580131)
It's not arbitrary. It's called the distinction between retaliatory and preemptive force. Retaliatory force requires a victim and evidence of causation. Preemptive force has no objective anchor, hence arbitrary by definition. You can't jail a man for a crime he might commit tomorrow.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:39AM (#47583148)
What im saying is that this distinction is arbitrary. Running a society isn't all about punishing crimes. That's just one minor aspect of a states responsibilities. Standardization is another, arguably more important one.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:40AM (#47583956)
It's far from minor. To ban physical force from social relationships, people need an institution charged with the task of protecting their rights. People's rights can only be violated by physical force. To prevent this, the government's only solution is to hold a legal monopoly on the use of physical force.

If this vested power remains unchecked and unlimited, the government will violate the rights of its own citizens. That's why we should limit its power to retaliatory use.

Standardization is a very valuable asset, I don't deny that. But:

1. Standardization is not limited to forced standardization;

2. It's better to live in a world not fully standardized than to accept the premise that it's right to violate rights for a good cause. The "good cause" shifts the question from "should rights be violated?" to "what kind of violation do you want?" Once we accept that, we lose to totalitarianism. A man who says "let's violate a tiny fraction of rights" would lose to a man who declares "let's violate rights of thousands."

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:51AM (#47584475)
There's more to rights than just physical force.

How do you account for the right to clean water and sanitation [0] without state infrastructure, just as an example?

It feels like you care a lot about violence and force, at the expense of (imo) more important issues societies face.

[0] https://www.unwater.org/water-facts/human-rights-water-and-s...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:00AM (#47584993)
If people without an access to clean water want it, the proper route is to trade with those who do, not victimize them. There can be no right that involves sacrifices of one man to another.

Trying to wield sacrifices at the point of a gun (by an official or legislator) is the most important and disturbing modern issue. It paves the road to all actual social conflicts, unrest, and misunderstanding.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:28AM (#47585241)
The people withholding the water in this scenario are the ones victimizing the ones without. That's where the state monopoly on violence has to come in as a corrective mechanism.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @07:56AM (#47586054)
If "withholding" means actively blocking someone from acessing water they already have a right to, you'd be correct. But that's not what's in your link. Passive possession, "I have water, I'm not giving it to you," is not initiation of force. It's simply not being someone else's servant.

And it's unjust to assume humanity wouldn't help unless forced to.

By calling upon sacrifices, the first target would be engineers, plumbers, and utility workers. Forcing the people who actually produce and deliver clean water isn't justice.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:07AM (#47586143)
You're completely discounting the most perfidious type of violence: economic violence.

Punishing and preventing it is the core purpose of the state.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:19AM (#47586253)
What exactly do you mean by "economic violence"? If you mean fraud or theft, we already agree those are crimes. If you mean something else, I'd like to know what.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by roboror on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:08PM (#47581948)
Are there laws and lawmakers in this scenario?
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @12:31PM (#47589884)
Yes, to settle disputes. The purpose of these laws is the protection of individual rights, not consumer “rights” or any other special “rights” that belong exclusively to one group or race and no other.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by sham1 on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:45PM (#47576631)
And pray tell, who comes up with common law? And who enforces the judgment of the court? And what gives the court the authority to judge on the matter of glass shards in your tomato paste?

Fun fact about the common law in fact is that it came into existence because the English government after the Norman conquest needed a unified theory of law for the king's courts that was distinct from manorial and canon laws. 1154 Henry 2 the Plantagenet ascended the throne and wanted a code of law that would apply everywhere in the realm as opposed to local laws, the aforementioned manorial laws, as well as being secular, unlike canon law.

So without the government, you wouldn't have this common law your legal theory relies on.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by fastaguy88 on Monday March 30, 2026 @01:36PM (#47577320)
>>> If I buy a can of soup and find glass in it, I have a valid claim against the manufacturer. It's a matter of holding someone accountable for fraud or negligence, not a matter of regulation. The proper route is a court, not a bureaucratic agency that preemptively dictates production methods on the assumption that every manufacturer is a potential prisoner.

This is a common conservative trope. We don't need regulation because customers can always sue. (Famous interview with Milton Friedman.) Good luck finding a lawyer who will sue because of some glass in your soup can, or, for more serious cases, who can out last (or match the spending of) a billion dollar corporation. Yes, sometimes the underdog wins. Rich people can sue, and may not need the governments regulatory help. For most people, there is absolutely no recourse, particular for technically complex things, like prescription drugs.

The idea that the legal system can consistently make better informed technical decisions than government scientists is not well supported by the evidence.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:01PM (#47579053)
> If I buy a can of soup and find glass in it, I have a valid claim against the manufacturer.

Only because there is a court system provided by the state and because there is regulation that says that soup doesn't contain glass. Otherwise the manufacturer can just say "You didn't want glass in your soup, sucks, but for us glass in soup is part of the accepted distribution. Be happy that you got additional glass for free." .

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hnfong on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:14AM (#47571757)
> It’s time to accept regulation actually does work when you have a competent government.

Given that it's the EU making those regulations, it looks like the government only has to be semi-competent. Maybe the only requirement is that they're not totally in bed with the big corps making money.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by egeozcan on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:39AM (#47571923)
> Given that it's the EU making those regulations, it looks like the government only has to be semi-competent

Context: I'm not a EU-native, I've migrated to here.

It disturbs me a lot when people keep repeating the "incompetent government" narrative when it comes to the EU, but when you compare it to the dictatorship that I escaped from, they still seem way more competent, surprising when the big advantage of a dictatorship is supposed to be increased efficiency while reducing personal rights.

Personally I cannot name a better government (or governing body, given that we are talking about the whole EU) anywhere else on this planet.

I feel I'm incredibly lucky to live here even when the economy is getting tougher. The only thing that worries me and makes me consider leaving is the right-extremes, which to this day, thankfully had limited influence.

Sorry for the digression, but I just wanted to address this repeating pattern. It's possible that you have very valid reasons to call them semi-competent and that I'm overreacting.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hnfong on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:51AM (#47572002)
Nah it was kinda a tongue in cheek snipe at the EU which may or may not be justified. Appreciate the counter-point.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by egeozcan on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:03AM (#47572067)
Oh, okay. Sorry for the wall of text against the small snipe :) It's just that these things stick.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by dxdm on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:56AM (#47572711)
No, thank you for posting it. Things like this need to be said.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by wolvoleo on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:56AM (#47572705)
Even here in Europe, most of Southern Europe was a bunch of Dictatorships up into the late 70s! Spain, Portugal, Greece...

Not to mention Eastern Europe until the wall fell. All dictatorships in different forms. So yeah we've had our share as well.

The problem with the EU is that it seems to be becoming more susceptible to industry lobbying. As of late they are reducing environmental laws (the banning of ICE cars), weakening GDPR and DMA/DSA etc. Not very happy with that. Ursula herself was all about her 'green deal' during her first administration and now she's breaking it all down.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by catlikesshrimp on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:09AM (#47572798)
I hope you don't live to see the return of dictatorships in Europe. And I don't mean Hungary.

https://jacobin.com/2025/05/ve-day-wwii-fascism-liberalism

There's a storm coming.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by wolvoleo on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:56AM (#47573111)
I know :'(

In my origin country too unfortunately. But not where I live.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by PunchyHamster on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:28AM (#47573418)
>As of late they are reducing environmental laws (the banning of ICE cars)

I think that particular one is because they realized their timeline is impossible to hit without utterly crippling EU

> weakening GDPR and DMA/DSA

There was always a lot of push for that, it is very much "yes/try later" on those legislations, we got the biggest traitor of the freedom out (UK) but there are still countries either interested, or incompetent enough to think the pushed ideas are a good thing

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by throw_a_grenade on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:24AM (#47572901)
It's a bit of hit and miss, really. Like every big organisation, it's not a single, coherent entity, but has branches and departments filled by real, flawed people, so in practice it depends on which industry your're in. For example, digital policy bureaucrats are usually extremely competent, like, they do know how the stuff discussed here on HN works. (That they often have differen expectations from what people here want is orthogonal). Automotive industry is on the other hand squarely in bed with manufacturers (cars, but also accessories like child safety chairs). The average is suprisingly good, esp. in comparison with national bureaucracies.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by nandomrumber on Monday March 30, 2026 @07:56AM (#47573118)
You’re worried about the Right-ists.

When it has been the Left that has largely governed Europe for the previous few decades to bring it to the point where it is now where the economics and defence capabilities of nations that once ruled the world are now laughing stock on the global stage.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by sokoloff on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:18AM (#47573314)
Way back in the times of sailing ships with cannons?

Absolutely Europe ruled the world economically and militarily.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by egeozcan on Monday March 30, 2026 @09:43AM (#47574242)
> nations that once ruled the world are now laughing stock on the global stage

...and yet it gets repeated!

I'm not worried about the right ideology. Last time I took a political test, it told me I'm slightly right-leaning, but that changes every time I take such tests :)

I said that I'm disturbed by the extremists who plan to take away my legally earned rights.

European countries have rules and requirements like most other countries. I looked at their criteria, it sounded fair, took the deal and now I'm here. I pay my taxes, obey the rules, even applied for citizenship (takes ages), and I expect my rights to be protected as well, as long as keep my end of the deal. Those people threaten that golden rule.

Some seem to be obsessed about ruling and military power, and from the outside, they seem to believe that you only are allowed to move in this world if you kill/defeat the previous residents.

Those are the people I'm scared of.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Xixi on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:16AM (#47573299)
I wonder to what extent in this instance it is driven by the EU regulating (mostly) foreign companies rather than (mostly) domestic ones.

Said differently, it is much easier for the EU to be impartial and competent when regulating Apple or Samsung than when regulating Volkswagen or Stellantis...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by PunchyHamster on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:26AM (#47573393)
Well if you have seen how EU regulates domestic companies you would not wonder about that. There is no mercy.

US companies just hit that barrier more often historically because they got used to "lobby it and it goes away" attitude to law, and when it doesn't work we have harpy screeeching about EU using laws to tax US companies that do not want to abide to law in place where they are doing business

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by swiftcoder on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:18PM (#47576238)
> it is much easier for the EU to be impartial and competent when regulating Apple or Samsung than when regulating Volkswagen or Stellantis

They are still regulating the auto manufacturers pretty harshly, and without any particular favouritism, even though that is letting foreign players like BYD eat the lunch of the domestic manufacturers (who mostly seem to have bet the farm on a US-led return to fossil fuel dominance)

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by abc123abc123 on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:19AM (#47572168)
Nope. What the real effect has been is a waste of billions of billions that have gone into changing stuff that never needed changing. Future development has now been slowed down as well in the EU.

All it takes to see that government regulation never works, is to look at how far behind the EU is in terms of GDP growth compared with the US and China who both have a significantly lighter touch when it comes to regulation.

The EU is f*cked, and will become a little socialist region, with manual and tourist industry jobs, where rich people from the rest of the world go for a few weeks of vacation.

I left the EU a long time ago, and I've earned so much money after leaving the socialist madness, that I recommend all young people I meet to do the same.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ywvcbk on Monday March 30, 2026 @06:50AM (#47572670)
It's not self evident this is caused by regulation.

And regulation generally certainly works when it come to regulating and splitting up monopolies and oligopolies, workers right and etc. (US has plenty of both even if its occasionally idiosyncratic)

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by actionfromafar on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:56AM (#47572379)
”Rrgulation never works”, is a very shallow take. It could mean anything. China is an autocratic system. Is that working? The US is going in that direction.

On top of that, Europe isn’t a country. To have less regulation, you need more of it. Unifying regulations, or else you have dozens of completely different jurisdictions. To a large extent, you still do, even with the EU. You can’t sell to the general public in English. There are so many more things holding Europe back than ”need deregulation”.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by abc123abc123 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:04AM (#47584571)
"To have less regulation, you need more of it."

Can you actually see the words you are typing? War is peace?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by actionfromafar on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @11:36AM (#47588954)
Sometimes you in fact need yet another standard to obsolete the previous 27 ones, yes. xkcd://927 notwithstanding.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:53AM (#47575859)
The EU is literally run by conservatives. Where are the scary socialists hiding?
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by abc123abc123 on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:04AM (#47584568)
Check average tax level in EU, compare with channel island and marvel. Please wake up, or the world will go to hell even faster.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @05:15AM (#47584675)
Socialism has nothing to do with taxes, but with ownership of the means of production.

As far as I'm aware, that hasn't been socialized in the EU.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vintagedave on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:38AM (#47573507)
> regulation actually does work when you have a competent government

This is the free market. Free as in, regulated to allow and encourage market entry and competition (as with replacement keyboards), not free as in unregulated. When you look back at when 'free market' was first strongly mentioned as a term, this is what it meant.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by corndoge on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:24AM (#47574776)
Both you and GP are correct!
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by e_i_pi_2 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:28AM (#47574816)
We've also seen this within the US - California generally makes the first move and then companies just follow that law because they know others might change and it's easier than doing it by state. One relatively small law can have a big impact, we also follow GDPR in the US because a lot of companies operate in europe too
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by hilliardfarmer on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:29AM (#47574832)
People need to stop buying apple products. Anyone dumb enough to have already done so deserves what they get.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by rogerrogerr on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:59AM (#47575193)
I guess I'm happy being dumb if it means I deserve a laptop with a battery that lasts all day, a trackpad that doesn't feel like it's covered in dry syrup, a case that doesn't make noises when I pick it up, and a processor that feels like alien tech.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ezst on Monday March 30, 2026 @12:47PM (#47576682)
I haven't used a laptop in the last decade that wouldn't last a whole day on battery, or would hold any of those qualifiers for that matter, from Apple or other manufacturers. Not that Apple are bad devices, but they are flawed like the rest of them (often less, and sometimes more in areas that may matter less to you, the software being a major and increasingly one to me).

Also good to remember that Apple is a company of good devices and tremendous marketing, not a company of tremendous devices per se. That entails a lot of subjectivity and awkward tribalism.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by jen20 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:06PM (#47581940)
OK, so what have you used? Makes, models and years would be ideal.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by ezst on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @06:42AM (#47599128)
Any mid- to high-end pro-line laptop from the usual manufacturers (dell latitude series, lenovo T series, hp pro/elitebook series) gives you that, really (rigidly built body using magnesium/aluminum alloys, good input devices and IO, high-end config, …) and some practical perks (hot swappable batteries, repairable/expandable, on-site warranty, …)
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 0xffff2 on Monday March 30, 2026 @02:22PM (#47577847)
What $900 laptop with a similar form factor and build quality to a Macbook Air am I supposed to buy instead? I did quite a bit of research on this a couple of months ago, with a strong preference for a Linux compatible device (I've never been a MacOS user, and I'm done with Windows after 10 dies all the way). After weeks of research, I came to the conclusion that my best bet was to buy a Macbook Air and hope that Asahi support for M4 chips comes sooner rather than later.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:37AM (#47574938)
Chat control is not something that indicates competence. They're throwing darts and sometimes hit the board.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by throw0101a on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:40AM (#47574982)
> usb-c

Don't forget about the time micro-USB has mandated. Was that "competent government"?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by 1718627440 on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:52PM (#47578914)
That government has a limited jurisdiction over the offenders. They were still effective to the point, that there was only a single company not having microUSB. Granted that wasn't a small part of the market, but also not the largest.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Levitating on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:45AM (#47575043)
We can't rely on the government to step on any time consumers are getting abused. We need to teach consumers to do better.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by Trannosaur on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:53AM (#47575133)
Also, they're ignoring the true cost of unrepairable hardware which is e-waste. Perhaps if they're looking for a lighter hand, they'd suggest that less repairable hardware has to have a tax that pays for its PROPER recycling.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @11:35AM (#47575649)
And making them more repairable as someone else said has tradeoffs. It’s not like Apple is the low cost leader. Choose another vendor
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by fuzzfactor on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:54PM (#47578943)
Engineering failures relating to repairability defects are some of the most annoying.

OTOH they can be a major pillar in a well-orchestrated anti-reuse, anti-recycling, anti-environmental money machine for some manufacturers.

>Choose another vendor

Good advice, I already did once Woz left ;)

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by raw_anon_1111 on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:29PM (#47579329)
Or just pay $70 a year for Apple Care like I did for my M2 MacBook Air and not worry about it…
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by delbronski on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:19PM (#47579220)
Yes! We tried leaving tech unregulated and it did not work. We got huge monopolies screwing consumers at every turn. Time to try something new.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by mannyv on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @12:00AM (#47582599)
Have you heard the good news about regulatory capture?

Probably not if you're one of the public.

Imagine how the world would look if the EU mandated rs-232c ports on all devices. Or 3.5" headphone jacks. Or the use of D batteries for all electronics. How about ms-dos compatibility?

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by entrox on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @02:13AM (#47583378)
Are these examples supposed to be bad? I think the world would be in a better place.