News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @04:42PM (#47579471)
Courts, police, and the army are proper. That's government. The difference is what kind of government. A proper government holds a monopoly on retaliatory force, it acts after someone initiates force or fraud. It doesn't dictate your screw size, battery compartment, or production method before you've harmed anyone.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:18PM (#47579814)
...why? This sounds incredibly arbitrary.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:47PM (#47580131)
It's not arbitrary. It's called the distinction between retaliatory and preemptive force. Retaliatory force requires a victim and evidence of causation. Preemptive force has no objective anchor, hence arbitrary by definition. You can't jail a man for a crime he might commit tomorrow.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @01:39AM (#47583148)
What im saying is that this distinction is arbitrary. Running a society isn't all about punishing crimes. That's just one minor aspect of a states responsibilities. Standardization is another, arguably more important one.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @03:40AM (#47583956)
It's far from minor. To ban physical force from social relationships, people need an institution charged with the task of protecting their rights. People's rights can only be violated by physical force. To prevent this, the government's only solution is to hold a legal monopoly on the use of physical force.

If this vested power remains unchecked and unlimited, the government will violate the rights of its own citizens. That's why we should limit its power to retaliatory use.

Standardization is a very valuable asset, I don't deny that. But:

1. Standardization is not limited to forced standardization;

2. It's better to live in a world not fully standardized than to accept the premise that it's right to violate rights for a good cause. The "good cause" shifts the question from "should rights be violated?" to "what kind of violation do you want?" Once we accept that, we lose to totalitarianism. A man who says "let's violate a tiny fraction of rights" would lose to a man who declares "let's violate rights of thousands."

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @04:51AM (#47584475)
There's more to rights than just physical force.

How do you account for the right to clean water and sanitation [0] without state infrastructure, just as an example?

It feels like you care a lot about violence and force, at the expense of (imo) more important issues societies face.

[0] https://www.unwater.org/water-facts/human-rights-water-and-s...

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:00AM (#47584993)
If people without an access to clean water want it, the proper route is to trade with those who do, not victimize them. There can be no right that involves sacrifices of one man to another.

Trying to wield sacrifices at the point of a gun (by an official or legislator) is the most important and disturbing modern issue. It paves the road to all actual social conflicts, unrest, and misunderstanding.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @06:28AM (#47585241)
The people withholding the water in this scenario are the ones victimizing the ones without. That's where the state monopoly on violence has to come in as a corrective mechanism.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @07:56AM (#47586054)
If "withholding" means actively blocking someone from acessing water they already have a right to, you'd be correct. But that's not what's in your link. Passive possession, "I have water, I'm not giving it to you," is not initiation of force. It's simply not being someone else's servant.

And it's unjust to assume humanity wouldn't help unless forced to.

By calling upon sacrifices, the first target would be engineers, plumbers, and utility workers. Forcing the people who actually produce and deliver clean water isn't justice.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by vrganj on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:07AM (#47586143)
You're completely discounting the most perfidious type of violence: economic violence.

Punishing and preventing it is the core purpose of the state.

Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @08:19AM (#47586253)
What exactly do you mean by "economic violence"? If you mean fraud or theft, we already agree those are crimes. If you mean something else, I'd like to know what.
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by roboror on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:08PM (#47581948)
Are there laws and lawmakers in this scenario?
Re:My MacBook Keyboard Is Broken and It's Insanely Expensive... by piekvorst on Tuesday March 31, 2026 @12:31PM (#47589884)
Yes, to settle disputes. The purpose of these laws is the protection of individual rights, not consumer “rights” or any other special “rights” that belong exclusively to one group or race and no other.