News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Glyptodon on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @07:47PM (#45205756)
I'm mildly curious what the reaction to this will be compared to the reaction to other recent political murders, like the Hortmans, or of Thompson.

That said, I think people need to recognize that in many aspects what's happening is connected to societal issues that gun control and gun regulations will have very little impact on - remember, even in Japan somebody could make some kind of battery ignited home-made shotgun and kill Shinzo Abe.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:19PM (#45206018)
> remember, even in Japan somebody could make some kind of battery ignited home-made shotgun and kill Shinzo Abe.

Countries with strict gun control enjoy far lower rates of firearm accidents, suicides, and murders. IMO it's clearly worth the tradeoff. Very few of us live in a place where only guns can solve our problems.

The fact that occasionally someone goes to great lengths to kill doesn't mean we should make it easier for everyone.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by coderenegade on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:59PM (#45207638)
And when those countries run into issues because the government is incompetent, people start wishing they had guns again. It's all well and good to give up guns when the system works, but when it doesn't, you lose self determination.

I live in a country where escalating youth crime is driving a reassessment of castle doctrine (not a thing here), and laws have recently been relaxed to allow pepper spray for self defense in parts of the country. Gun license applications are at record highs here, despite home defense not being a valid reason for a permit.

If the system always worked, there would be no need for guns. But it doesn't, and when that happens, guns level the playing field.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:52PM (#45217611)
Is it guns that keep governments honest and responsive to the populace? Or is it a culture of trust, honesty, and non-violence?

Yemen is in second place for guns per person. How responsive is their government to the people?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by coderenegade on Friday September 12, 2025 @07:21PM (#45227850)
My post wasn't about keeping the government honest, it was about the individual's right to protect themselves from anyone, including the government. Guns empower the individual to defend themselves without having to rely on the effective intervention of government, because they're an equalizer. This matters when the government loses effectiveness, either because resources are stretched thin (so, ineffective policing) or because incompetence or ideology creeps in (the judiciary does a poor job of removing dangerous individuals from the public). In places with effective governance, guns aren't really necessary, and it's tempting to trade them in for a small gain in security. The issue is that governments change over time, and effective systems can become ineffective. When that happens, people suddenly find themselves wanting guns again.

The debate over guns actually hinges on the extent to which the individual should be empowered to defend themselves, and historically, it hasn't just been about guns, but about all weapons, and even martial arts (which have also been banned at various points in history). Governments don't like to empower the individual, because they want to maintain a monopoly over violence (for many practical reasons), and because empowering individuals often creates its own set of trust problems (which is true for anything -- how many drivers are trustworthy, for example). Defenseless individuals are easier to govern from an administrative perspective, and if a government is good at protecting the populace from threats, it works. In fact, it can be better for the population as a whole, at least while the government is competent. But life is messy, and there are points where individuals need to defend themselves. As systems break down, not only does the need increase, but also the effectiveness of the means, because the threats you have to defend yourself against by definition don't play by the rules.

This, imo, is the real point of the second amendment. The Bill of Rights is essentially a declaration that certain rights are derived from a higher authority than government, which is why they are inalienable. No one needs permission to defend themselves, and it's my belief that the right to bear arms was put in there to ensure that should the system fail or become ineffective, the people would still be able to exercise one of their most fundamental natural rights. It certainly wasn't an accident, because it was the second thing that they added. The verbiage around government and militias makes sense in the context of having just fought a war of independence, but it also makes sense when you consider that it's often well-meaning governments that take this right away.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Monday September 15, 2025 @08:01PM (#45256431)
Guns are more often used in crimes (~400K per year) than to stop crime (~70K). Nevermind accidents and suicides.

When was the last time that private gun ownership helped overcome a dangerous government?

Whatever the reason for the 2A, in practice, it has contributed to far more death than it prevented.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by coderenegade on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @07:46PM (#45367366)
And if citizens don't have access to guns, they'll still be used in crimes.

The second amendment isn't about safety or preventing death, it's about the right of the individual versus the overall collective. Governments and systems break down, but what doesn't change is the individual's right to defend themselves. Whether or not you think it improves individual safety in practice is irrelevant, because it's not your call (nor even the government's) to make.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by codyb on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:29PM (#45206115)
So... if anything, this is the exact situation stricter gun laws wouldn't really prevent. Which would be the targeted assassination of a societal figure by a determined ideologue or partisan or mole.

In which case you'd need a strong internal investigatory services in order to root these plots out before they happen by following up on leads and tips.

Well... not to get political, but I think we're hollowing that out too?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by potato3732842 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:06PM (#45206427)
>strong internal investigatory services in order to root these plots out before they happen

Who will necessarily be so strong they'll be capable of pulling such things off to serve their own ends.

It's an intractable problem all the way down.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by msie on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:36PM (#45206179)
Well, you wouldn't be able to reproduce such a long-range kill with a shabbily constructed firearm. You would have to be up close, which would be harder to do.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:40AM (#45210859)
> So... if anything, this is the exact situation stricter gun laws wouldn't really prevent. Which would be the targeted assassination of a societal figure by a determined ideologue or partisan or mole.

My point isn't that outlawing guns would stop every possible scenario. Rather it would make killings of all kinds far less likely, which is a win for everyone--even hate-spewing pundits.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SV_BubbleTime on Sunday September 14, 2025 @09:58PM (#45245291)
Remind us how was Abe assassinated in Japan?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Group_B on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:28PM (#45206107)
I think it's simply too late for real gun control in the US. Like how would that ever be enforced? There's too many guns already, and we have too many people down south that would be happy to smuggle guns back up North. And trying to control the ammo would be even more unrealistic. The gun culture America created over the past 100+ years is a massive mistake, and I don't think there is any undoing of it. Should have been more control immediately post WWII imo.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by danpalmer on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:43PM (#45206255)
I'm not from the US so I only have an outsider's view of the culture, and FWIW I'm also not from Australia although I have emigrated here now.

Australia seemed to have a deeper relationship with guns previously, that stemmed partially out of necessity (farming etc), but there are also a lot of parallels with US culture here – the American dream, being a colony hundreds of years ago, etc, some focus on personal rights and freedoms, being a federation of states, etc. I don't think it was as deep a relationship as the US, but coming from the UK it seemed that Australia had a very different view than the UK.

Australia turned this all around. The culture shifted, and people realised that for the greater good it was something they needed to get past, and they did.

Maybe there's hope for US gun control yet, although the turning point for Australia was a (single) mass shooting. Maybe the US needs a much bigger turning point. I'm a little surprised that the Las Vegas shooting a while ago didn't provide that.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by grier on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:11PM (#45206899)
I live in the US. I don't hold much hope in gun control changing after recent years. Recent federal and state policy is trending towards less regulation and removal of the previous administrations regulations.

In 2024, estimated 16,576 deaths in the US from guns (excluding suicide, which is a very large addition on top of that), and 499 mass shootings.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by hn_acc1 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:57PM (#45206790)
>for the greater good

When 1/3 of the country debates whether a different 1/10 to 1/3 of the country has a right to exist and/or live their lives as they wish (within the bounds of the law!), this can't happen.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:18PM (#45206512)
Worst take today. The 2nd amendment was the SECOND thing the founders put in for a reason. They just got done fighting a war against the government with WEAPONS OF WAR. It was written specifically to enable fighting against tyrannical government, which is VASTLY worse than all mass shooters combined.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by koolba on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:29PM (#45206584)
Those who would give up essential liberty, to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SideQuark on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:41AM (#45209274)
You should learn about the source and context of that quote. It does not mean what you think it means.

For example, https://www.npr.org/2015/03/02/390245038/ben-franklins-famou...

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ryan_lane on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:07PM (#45206873)
The 2nd amendment specifies "well regulated militias", but somehow this part is always left out by gun enthusiasts. The idea was to ensure states can have militias, and that those militias would be allowed to have guns. Somehow this has been stretched by the gun lobby to "everyone should be able to have a gun with absolutely no restrictions", when that's absolutely not what is stated in the 2nd amendment.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by svieira on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:01PM (#45207224)
The members of militias at the time of the ratification of the 2nd amendment were required to supply their own guns by statue, which is how you get the individual right - from the duty to be a member of the militia. Which still exists today (though in statute it is often called the "unorganized" or "state" militia to distinguish it from the National Guard, which is actually a branch of the US Army by statue: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Guard_(United_States)...
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by vel0city on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:27PM (#45207424)
Does it say "the right of the well-regulated militias to bear arms" or "the right for the states to bear arms"?

I'm for a lot more gun control than what we have today, but it's "the right of the people" in the text.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SV_BubbleTime on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:07AM (#45208360)
Neither.

[As a necessity for a free state, A well trained and in good working order group of able bodies citizens capable of fight for defense of self and state, is required], the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.

Militia is just the people. Oxford 1800s has well-regulated to mean “in good working order”.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SideQuark on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:45AM (#45209307)
The bill of rights are about personal freedoms, as is made clear during the discussion leading up to them. All states copied these in some form into their own constitutions, and if you go look at those, most are quite explicit this is a personal right. The claim otherwise is a very recent claim.

Congress around 1982 had the Library of Congress issue a study about this in great depth, with millions of citations to historical documents, which give ample evidence and quotes. You may have to dig to find it, but it's a good read to gain more understanding.

Also the second militia act of 1792 actually required all able bodied men to own guns, and this was the law for well over the following century.

The founders had no qualms about everyone having arms.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:43AM (#45210889)
> The founders had no qualms about everyone having arms.

Thankfully, whatever they meant then, we live today and can change the constitution and the laws to suit present circumstances. Nothing is sacred.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:14AM (#45211966)
>> Nothing is sacred.

This is the thought process of the morally depraved, upon which every tyrannical government establishes its power.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:05PM (#45215026)
Please help me understand what must be kept sacred.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:32PM (#45215846)
I can't but you can read the bible.

It's basically everything, except that which is evil.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:47PM (#45217590)
I've read the Bible at least four times. I'd rather not stone people for being born different. Nor inspire PTSD in children or adults with silly stories about punishment in eternal flames.

Good and evil are even more subjective than how people perceive colors. I hope we can at least agree that murder is wrong, and the tools which facilitate the most murder should be the most heavily regulated.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:43PM (#45218180)
Might have read it but clearly didn't understand the point of the sacrifice and the new covenant. You shouldn't be telling young children they're going to burn in hell for eternity any more than you should talk to them about sex.

Murder is wrong.

Every citizen worth a damn should own guns and the idea that they should not be regulated by the government is enshrined in the 2nd amendment to the US constitution. Every gun law created since is an abberation that should be abolished.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Monday September 15, 2025 @07:51PM (#45256362)
The first three words of 2A is "A well regulated...". IDK where this idea comes from that guns cannot be regulated.

Shall we say prisoners have the right to bear arms? Felons with a violent past? People with mental illness? Surely there must be limits. Few rights are absolute in every circumstance.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 25, 2025 @02:45AM (#45369920)
You don't know what you're talking about when you decide that 'well regulated' means what you think it means. It is because you have done no research on the topic. Here: https://www.heritage.org/the-essential-second-amendment/the-...

If a person shouldn't have firearms, then they shouldn't be on the street. They should be in jail/prison. Period. I don't know that anyone that has argued that prisoners should have guns. You would have to be a fool. If a person shouldn't have access to guns, then they shouldn't have access to any other freedom. The ultimate purpose of owning firearms is to fight a tyrannical government. For that purpose, less limits is better for the people. This right is absolute, and anyone espousing otherwise is a tyrant or a fool.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 25, 2025 @03:05AM (#45370027)
Brits gave up their firearms in 1997. Less than 30 years later, they're being arrested for Facebook posts.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SideQuark on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:12PM (#45379151)
Well regulated meant well trained, not regulated as in restricted or controlled by the govt.

Regulated has more than one meaning. Read which is which.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ryan_lane on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:00PM (#45217934)
I'm not personally against individuals owning guns, but the part that is somehow vehemently opposed is the "well-regulated" part. There's effectively no regulation, and somehow the 2nd amendment has been warped to leave out the part of regulation, to make folks believe they're entitled to guns without limit.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SideQuark on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:14PM (#45379177)
"well regulated" applies not to guns but to militias, and has nothing to do with legal restrictions. It means well functioning, well trained, efficient. It has nothing to do with legal regulations.

The word has many meanings. Learn which one the phrase in the Constitution is using.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ryan_lane on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:11PM (#45445998)
So you're saying that we should be able to add training requirements to use a firearm, if well-regulated means "well functioning, well trained, efficient". Similar to how we require folks to show they know how to properly drive a car before we allow them on the road?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mbs159 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:22AM (#45209174)
What are the odds of winning against a tyrannical government that has UAVs, nukes, tanks, helicopters and jets?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SideQuark on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:38AM (#45209266)
100%. The US took all that capability and could not win in 20 years of fighting in Afghanistan against such a force. Same in Vietnam.

The US populace is vastly larger and better armed and capable than Afghanistan.

The US military requires a massive economy to function. If it tries to attack itself, those little armed people could stop it, the economy would crash, and the US military would crumble without needed support and supplies.

A final issue is the US troops would lose a lot of soldiers if they were told to go attack fellow citizens. The soldiers would quit, would hesitate, would not want to kill people they view as their own people.

So armed citizenry absolutely have major power against the govt.

Finally, if you were in a country where the govt set out to kill its citizens, would you rather have arms or be completely unarmed?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mbs159 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:42AM (#45211567)
The US military would be the defending force, though, which would put The People at a disadvantage. Pushing through the defenses of a multi-trillion dollar military with AR-15s seems unlikely. I don't even think that China's armed forces could defeat the US military, let alone civilians armed with AR-15s

All being said, I am no military guru and I could be wrong

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by NickC25 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:38PM (#45215356)
>The US took all that capability and could not win in 20 years of fighting in Afghanistan against such a force.

We had no military objective in Afghanistan.

Our only goal there was to enrich contractors who had stockholders working at the highest levels in the Pentagon and White House. That goal was achieved spectacularly.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:10AM (#45211924)
Citizens should be allowed to own UAVs, nukes, tanks, helicopters, and jets. It says in the text: "shall not be infringed." Besides that, who do you think is going to do the fighting, exactly?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ta20240528 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:15AM (#45211980)
Quite good actually, except the prize is that you'll end up like Haiti.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by michaelhoney on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:36AM (#45210349)
and yet, what have the NRA types done so far about the tyrannical government
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by rcpt on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:39PM (#45206215)
A lot of stuff would not happen if it took a little more effort. Giving people some extra time to second guess themselves is a big deal.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:20PM (#45206519)
This problem didn't happen in the 50s and 60s, when people brought their guns to school for funsies.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:47PM (#45207138)
Actually it did, just without so much press.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by adgjlsfhk1 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:44PM (#45206679)
It's very doable.

Step 1: get a supreme court that is able to read the 1st sentence of the 2nd amendment

Step 2: ban sale of guns to individuals not associated with well regulated militias (e.g. state national guards)

Step 3. Offer a reward to turn in privately held guns.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by throwaway48476 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:43PM (#45206260)
No one wants to get stabbed either.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jbboehr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:21AM (#45209162)
Or run over by a van.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:48PM (#45206714)
> Countries with strict gun control enjoy far lower rates of firearm accidents, suicides, and murders.

So let’s define what your definition of strict gun control is. Also, if you want people to care more, stop including suicides because it drastically changes the numbers.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:49PM (#45207156)
Suicide would be more rare if guns didn't make it so easy.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Shocka1 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:24AM (#45208088)
I see where you are going there, but I'm not so sure that rings true. Not to get too dark, but IIRC, Japan has higher suicide rates. And most are non-gun methods, like hanging, throwing oneself in front of a train, etc.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by seanmcdirmid on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:30AM (#45208137)
Are you sure you don’t mean South Korea? Japan is about at level with the USA, and actually lower since 2024.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Shocka1 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:53AM (#45212388)
I did not check into SK, but Japan has consistently been about the same or higher with the US for many years. Even with a drop in the last year, still very similar to one another.

The purpose of my original comment was that the US dwindles Japan in firearms, but Japanese still manage to kill themselves just fine. So it's not a strong point by the parent I responded to. If Japan maintained that decrease for several more years, I think this would be worth revisiting, but for now it doesn't have much weight.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by seanmcdirmid on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:52AM (#45213029)
South Korea is really high. Japan used be high but is much lower now (comparable to the USA). You can make your point more quickly today with South Korea’s suicide rate, which is really really bad. Mental health is important, the higher suicide rates in red states could just be about them being more depressed (eg from higher poverty, or overwork?) and having less access to mental health resources than just having more access to guns.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Shocka1 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:58PM (#45213730)
Understand and noted on the points you make. Also, I'm sorry to hear about your friend.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:57PM (#45218242)
suicide is championed by progressives outside this country, and machines have been built to increase nitrogen to give a comfortable death. the left is not against suicide, they are finding reasons to disarm people. this is why they will lose, their arguments are not rational.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Monday September 15, 2025 @08:08PM (#45256492)
Are some progressives championing well regulated suicide (requiring verification and waiting periods) for people who are suffering? Compared to unregulated, ubiquitous, and uncounted firearms which enable suicide+murder+accidents as simply as pointing and pulling a trigger?

What exactly is irrational?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by SideQuark on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:31AM (#45209222)
Japan has strict gun control and an extremely high rate of suicide. The US has more homicides per capita by simply beating someone to death by ones bare hands than many countries have total homicide rate (check data in FBI UCR). Restricting suicides and homicides to only those with guns is a dishonest comparison when the rates without the gun restriction are more useful and flip the outcomes of the discussion. I doubt a murder by non-gun is fundamentally different to a family or society than one by a gun, or any other method.

The Obama CDC study on gun control concluded that guns are used to stop far more crimes than they are used for in crimes. It concluded that a household with a gun saw far less bad outcomes than a household without during home invasions. It concluded a lot of things that didn't sit well with the left, so after all the fanfare to make it, it was downplayed by that admin. Read it, it's quite interesting.

Think through that a bit.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:50AM (#45210942)
> The Obama CDC study on gun control concluded that guns are used to stop far more crimes than they are used for in crimes.

Citation please. NCVS data puts defensive gun use around 70K instances per year while OJP.gov data puts firearm crimes in the 400K range.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by danpalmer on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:36PM (#45206172)
Gun control doesn't need to solve 100% of gun violence to be worth doing.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by akimbostrawman on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:01AM (#45210111)
Mass surveillance doesn't need to solve 100% of crimes to be worth doing.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jiggawatts on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:45AM (#45210427)
Seatbelts don't need to save every life in an accident to be worth requiring.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by alessandru on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:47PM (#45215961)
let's kindly remember patriot act was bush's baby

neocons love to use disaster to further their deep state dreams.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by gnarlouse on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:39PM (#45206209)
In my head I'm praying it's not a Franz Ferdinand. But the trajectory in the cycle of economic booms and bust, it feels at least possible. I hoping I'm wwwwwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa...

............aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaayyyy off.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:52PM (#45206747)
Yeah I have an unfortunate suspicion that 9/10 will be known as the date something went down in the future history books.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Graphon1 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:52PM (#45206315)
> even in Japan somebody could make some kind of battery ignited home-made shotgun and kill Shinzo Abe

ok let's try data instead of feels. Per Capita, what is the number of mass shootings per year in the USA, and in Japan. I did't know the answer but asked Gemini.

The most recent year for which there is data, apparently, is 2023, during which there were 604 mass shootings in the USA, and 1 in Japan. Given the respective population counts, the per-capita rate of mass shootings in the United States was about 225 times higher than in Japan.

Given that, are you confident that your observation that "one guy made a gun once in Japan" is a strong refutation of the idea that the US could reduce mass shootings by strengthening regulations?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Glyptodon on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:21PM (#45206974)
I think you're basically ignoring my point - that increasing numbers of targeted assassinations are not really a gun control issue (today's was seemingly a single shot, so things being discussed in this thread seem pretty not related), but a sign of major societal problems that need to be addressed.

Your response seems very off topic in focusing on "mass shootings" which are at best an ill-defined marketing term created to lump family annihilation suicides with more public mass casualty events like the pulse nightclub shooting in order to launder dubious policies.

But my whole original comment said nothing about mass shootings to begin with.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jrflowers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:36PM (#45207491)
> I think you're basically ignoring my point

You didn’t clarify that by “everything that’s happening” as the preface to your suggestion that gun control is pointless you specifically meant “political assassination and no other gun deaths”. It’s reasonable that someone would see you say that gun regulation wouldn’t have an effect on gun deaths and think that you were talking about gun deaths generally.

It would actually be bizarre for a reader to read “everything that’s happening” and think “the person that wrote this is referring to the first shooting at a school today and specifically excluding the second shooting at a school today”

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jmull on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:15AM (#45210206)
Strong gun regulations have a couple of orders of magnitude impact on one type of gun violence, but you think that’s irrelevant and off-topic to whether strong gun regulations would have an impact on another form of gun violence?

How could that make any sense?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by stronglikedan on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:57PM (#45206794)
there are plenty of regulations already. what we need is to start enforcing them. and also mental heath destigmatization and assistance, since it's a mental health problem, not a gun problem.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ruszki on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:00AM (#45207949)
Why cannot it be both? You definitely have a gun problem, and also a mental health problem. And you even have a mentality problem by thinking that gun is fine on you just to be safe, which is quite acceptable thought over there - the reaction of Americans vs Europeans to the fact that somebody has a gun on them in a friendly group is quite stark. But you have also a stochastic terrorism problem, a grifter problem, an inequality problem, an almost zero social net problem, many monopoly problems. All of these exaggerate your murder problem.

And you clearly have a “too few people want to solve these” problem. Most of you even voted to the person who campaigned that he wants to make these worse.

This won’t be solved, and will it be made worse in America for the next decade for sure.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by potato3732842 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:02PM (#45206403)
The fact that gemini is saying there were 604 is insane. That's literally ~2/day. That doesn't pass the sniff test for any reasonable definition of mass shooting (i.e. indiscriminate shooting of parties not known to the shooter).

The fact that you are just willing to run with such a number says everything we need to know.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:07PM (#45206434)
> The U.S. averages one to two mass shootings per day, with the specific rate varying by year and definition. Organizations like the Gun Violence Archive (GVA) define a mass shooting as an incident where at least four people are shot and either killed or injured, not including the shooter. For example, the GVA reported the U.S. averaged two mass shootings per day in the first half of 2023, with a record-breaking number in 2021.

Here is an Axios article where Gemini is getting its information from:

> https://www.axios.com/2023/07/31/us-mass-shooting-2-every-da...

The data is available at: https://www.gunviolencearchive.org/

We are at 300 so far this year. You can click on mass shootings and get an enumerated list for this year with incidents and sources, I'm not sure if you can go back to other years also:

https://www.gunviolencearchive.org/reports/mass-shooting

You could sample some of the incidents and see if they are being honest or not.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:26PM (#45207413)
Honest question: why would you even post a comment like that when searching online for the answer takes like 10 seconds?

The fact that you want to go with your feels and that you have the balls to degrade someone else who was actually correct is really what says everything we need to know:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_shootings_in_th...

FWIW your "reasonable definition" of mass shooter requiring the victims to be unknown by the shooter seems totally unreasonable to me, and it's not used by any organization that actually tracks these things (the Wikipedia article gives a list of definitions, none of them conforming to yours).

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by acjohnson55 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:01PM (#45206821)
When I lived in Baltimore, mass shootings were a regular occurrence. And that was just one medium sized city.

The vast majority of mass shootings don't make national news, because they happen in high poverty areas. It's not just the inner city, there are parts of rural America that are also quite violent.

It makes the news when someone who "shouldn't be killed" gets killed.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by wyre on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:12PM (#45206465)
Not believing facts because you don’t want to believe them? Says everything we need to know.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:46PM (#45206701)
more like mass shooting is poorly defined
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:59PM (#45206812)
While "mass shooting" does not have a solid agreed upon definition, there is a commonly accepted definition when we talk about one in the US. It's a shooting incident in which there are 4 or more casualties.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_shootings_in_the_United...

That's a very low bar.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by insurancesucks on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:06PM (#45206862)
It's a dishonest bar. The vast majority of us picture a deranged lunatic indiscriminately shooting innocent people.

Gang related incidents are something entirely different.

The definition should not obscure the two (but it would be politically inconvenient to separate them)

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:13PM (#45207314)
> The vast majority of us picture a deranged lunatic indiscriminately shooting innocent people

Just because we picture one thing when we hear a term doesn't change the agreed upon definition of the term.

If the definition of "mass shooting" were a single person, 600 is still way too many to have in a year.

Other developed countries have fewer than 600 gun-related deaths total per year. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2023/10/31/1209683...

The fact that upping the bar to 4 per incident and still gets us 600 is frankly shameful.

> it would be politically inconvenient to separate them

Why? No sane person in the United States "likes" gun violence. I don't think anyone would disagree with the statement "600 incidents of a firearm killing 4 or more people is too many incidents." The question that divides people is how we ought to control it.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:37AM (#45208192)
we would all love no crime, most of us live in the real world and understand mental illness is a thing that exists.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:38AM (#45208543)
You're gonna have to explain your point better. No one said mental illness doesn't exist. Your comment has nothing to do with the definition of mass shootings. No one defines mass shooting as "a mentally ill person who shoots people." It's pretty much given that a mass shooter is mentally ill. The point of contention is what does "mass" mean.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by komali2 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:50AM (#45208981)
You seem to be under the impression that other countries experience even a fraction of the violence Americans experience from guns.

We don't. What's happening in America with the gun violence is uniquely horrifying.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:20AM (#45212686)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%27No_Way_to_Prevent_This,%27_...

Every time. It's sad that it takes a satirical newspaper to point out the obvious truth.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:36AM (#45208184)
this definition is only commonly accepted amongst the left. as an example, would you call a gathering of 4 people a mass gathering. most wouldn’t.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Fezzik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:36AM (#45208527)
I think of ‘mass’ in the context of defining groups of things as just ‘a lot under the circumstances’. A mass gathering for an NFL game is 100,000 people; a mass crowd for a high-school JV basketball game is probably 100; a mass crowd for a 1 year old’s birthday is maybe 50. It’s relative to what is expected under normal circumstances. 4 people being shot or injured is a lot because nobody should be shot or injured.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:59PM (#45218257)
this is again loaded language. the intent is to make things seem more severe than they were. the bombing of Nagasaki was a mass killing, shooting 4 people is a shooting with 4 victims, not a mass shooting.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Friday September 12, 2025 @10:41AM (#45222664)
Why are you so intent on the definition of "mass?" whether "mass" means 4 or 400, one "mass shooting" is one too many. Arguing about how many people are allowed to die in an incident before we do something about it does nothing to prevent this from happening.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by cosmicgadget on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:06AM (#45208350)
Probably because those are two different contexts.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:39PM (#45218150)
no, it’s loaded speech and meant to manipulate human emotion to promote one’s goals.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:30AM (#45208488)
I'd love for you to define it then.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:09AM (#45211170)
it’s simple, don’t use verbiage meant to manipulate emotions. so just call it a shooting. the qualifier mass serves no purpose and changes nothing about how the case is prosecuted. the suspect is still charged with individual murder or manslaughter charges, not one single charge of multiple deaths.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by potato3732842 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:21AM (#45211292)
I'll do one further. I don't care if the verbiage is "manipulative" or has a spin to it so long as the term and definition are not specifically crafted to overload plain english terms to facilitate being misleading with plausible deniability.

That's how low of a bar I'll set and they still can't meet it.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ThrowMeAway1618 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:51AM (#45213025)
There's this thing called "context"[0].

You seem to be unfamiliar with it. Perhaps you might brush up on that?

Just a crazy thought. Toodles!

[0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/context

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:37PM (#45218130)
your hateful response will have no change on anything whatsoever
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ThrowMeAway1618 on Friday September 12, 2025 @05:53AM (#45220487)
Hateful?

Really? Providing definitions of words that seem not to be in one's vocabulary is hateful?

Let's see:

hateful[0] (adjective) 1 : full of hate : malicious 2 : deserving of or arousing hate

Defining words arouses hate?

Should I warn the fine folks over at Merriam Webster that you might come for them?

Or is it that you think suggesting that context is an important part of understanding language is a hateful endeavour?

Please, do tell. This is fascinating!

I wish you well and hope there are folks who will welcome you and make you feel loved. Is that more hateful stuff too, friend?

[0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/hateful

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Sunday September 14, 2025 @10:20AM (#45239915)
it’s your tone and an assumption that i don’t understand the definition of context. it is hateful disagreements like this that radicalize people. your response was hateful, reword it without defining words for people.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ThrowMeAway1618 on Monday September 15, 2025 @02:30AM (#45246735)
Nope.

Not gonna happen.

It's not hateful at all. I wish you no ill will whatsoever.

I'm just calling out what seems pretty clearly to be your lack of nuance/flexibility of the language. Which is something you might expect from a recent English language learner or a child.

Are you one of those? If not, you're pretty clearly being deliberately obtuse.

I won't hazard a guess as to why you might do such a thing, as that would likely be uncharitable.

I'll sum up, in case you're still confused: Calling you out for your tone deafness and/or deliberate obtuseness isn't hateful at all.

In fact, it's meant to inform you of the above as a service, so that you might provide higher quality discourse here.

As for being "hateful," I have no quarrel with you. I wish no harm on you, nor have you earned my ire. Rather, I have no strong feelings about you one way or the other.

If a mild remonstration is considered to be "hateful" by you, I can hardly imagine your reaction to actual verbal abuse. I expect it wouldn't be pretty.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mjlawson on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:57PM (#45206789)
More like that it's politically defined when the numbers become inconvenient.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:04PM (#45206842)
It's OK to criticize the source of the info (LLMs routinely make things up). But it would be been easy for you to verify the info as well.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by thephyber on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:09PM (#45206880)
The definition of mass shooting has been contested for a long time. The WaPo database and the FBI database used different definitions.

IIRC, the difference lies in how many people are involved versus how many people are killed.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by defrost on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:22PM (#45206531)
Meanwhile, overshadowed by the Kirk shooting, an almost mass shooting also occurred:

3 Students, Including Attacker, Shot at Colorado High School, Authorities Say

  Three students, including a shooting suspect, were critically injured in a shooting at a suburban high school in Colorado on Wednesday afternoon, the authorities said.
~ https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/10/us/colorado-high-school-s...

That's just one below a common mass shooting definition threshold.

It's telling that event, leading news in any other country, will likely get buried below the Kirk shooting as "just another day in the USofA".

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by the_gastropod on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:14PM (#45206481)
"Doesn’t pass the sniff test" usually means "I haven’t looked at the data." The U.S. has averaged ~2 mass shootings a day for years. It feels unreal because it is — but that's life in America.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by insurancesucks on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:05PM (#45206854)
You've arrived at something important intuitively.

The majority of "mass shootings" are gang related. Just from gang members with many prior felony's shooting each other (and maybe innocents getting hit in the process sometimes)

This is kept from you purposefully.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by thephyber on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:11PM (#45206897)
> This is kept from you purposefully.

No it’s not. This is constantly reiterated in many news outlets. In fact, Charlie Kirk was probably making that exact point at the time he was shot (my opinion based on his last sentence).

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by insurancesucks on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:18PM (#45206953)
Apparently we need to say it a little louder. We have multiple threads in this comment section of people trying to figure out how the US can have > 500 "mass shootings" a year and do nothing.

I won't be satisfied until we change the definition. Including gang violence from people with multiple felonies is not useful to the conversation.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:01PM (#45207223)
> I won't be satisfied until we change the definition. Including gang violence from people with multiple felonies is not useful to the conversation.

Why should we not count gangs and felons killing 4+ people at once as "mass killing"?!

Because their victims may know them somehow? It's still a serious incident which would be much less likely if guns were illegal. And all we'd lose is some sport shooting and ego points.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by potato3732842 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @06:01AM (#45209737)
Because these are fundamentally different crimes with different motives, people from mostly different walks of life doing them and different preventative steps.

The stuff you do to "solve" drive-bys and targeted drug industry violence won't solve school shootings and vise versa.

To lump them together serves no non-evil purpose. The people doing so are exactly as deserving of marginalization, and ideally legitimate state violence following due process (but that's just a pipe dream of mine), as the people who use a slight of hand to include prescription abuse in stats about cross-border drug smuggling or the people who try and act like literally every instance of domestic violence is the fault of alcohol or whatever. Nobody with even a shred of decency would stand behind those latter two examples. It speaks volumes about HN that the mass-shooting slight of hand is fine though.

And this isn't just a mass shooting crime issue. This is a "people feel emboldened to lie and be shitty because there is no consequence" issue. Bad people perform comparable dishonest slights of hand on all sorts of issues.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:19AM (#45210689)
> The stuff you do to "solve" drive-bys and targeted drug industry violence won't solve school shootings and vise versa.

Are you sure about that? There are probably some differences in prevention and response, but also plenty of similarities too. Like better mental healthcare, outlawing private gun ownership, and teaching non-violent conflict resolution.

> To lump them together serves no non-evil purpose. The people doing so are exactly as deserving of marginalization, and ideally legitimate state violence following due process (but that's just a pipe dream of mine)...

So you're advocating for violence in response to speech?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by potato3732842 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:50AM (#45211660)
>Are you sure about that? There are probably some differences in prevention and response, but also plenty of similarities too. Like better mental healthcare, outlawing private gun ownership, and teaching non-violent conflict resolution.

Targeting the overlap (mental health, guns, etc) is stupid and inefficient unless your goal is to take some action that can be done under that pretext and you don't really care about resource expenditure toward results. There's only so much political capital and surplus wealth round to be directed toward such ends. Something like gun control is massively political expensive. There's cheaper ways to get the same result.

I think the suggestion of addressing non-violent conflict resolution is a great example of that sort of "well I want to do a thing and this is my justification" because while it would certainly address the "traditional crime" end it's perhaps a generally good thing to do but it's not going to affect the mass shootings much because those people typically have little to no conflict with who they're shooting.

>So you're advocating for violence in response to speech?

Yes, and just to be clear I'm also advocating for all sorts of marginalization under the law short of violence leading up to that. Like all matters of law and social norms such marginalization is necessarily backed in violence though perhaps circuitously. The way I see it speech makes us all fractionally responsible for the results of what our words endorse. If society is willing to pay a bunch of cops to levy violence upon people over fairly petty misdeeds then I think it's at least arguably justifiable to direct the same kinds of violence at people who's speech greatly furthers tings and riles up people toward ends that are huge negatives. Politicians, news people, internet personalities ought not to be able to rile people up and then wash their hands of it saying that they were not there when the bricks got thrown or people to get shot.

I'm also aware that this is bad for freedom and human rights but that ship sailed so long ago. If we're going to have prolific law enforcement and subject as many things as we do to it, allegedly for the betterment of society, then screw it, lets' do speech too. If we're all gonna get stomped by the jackboot like this is singapore we might as well enjoy the upsides.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:00PM (#45214958)
Disagree, violence should be a last resort, even within the justice system.

That said, I do agree that people who incite violence in subtle ways--say yelling "fight, fight, fight" to an armed mob then sitting by for hours as they storm the capital--should share in the blame and suffer consequences for their incitement and the neglect of their oaths to protect.

[dead]
[dead]
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by thephyber on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:56PM (#45207189)
You are trying to change the definition of a term to something that literally nobody agrees with nor keeps records of. You are shoehorning data to fit your politics.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ThrowMeAway1618 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:56AM (#45213081)
>The majority of "mass shootings" are gang related. Just from gang members with many prior felony's shooting each other (and maybe innocents getting hit in the process sometimes)

>This is kept from you purposefully.

Right. And since "gang members" are, of course largely ones with a higher melanin content than you and are either foreign born, the children of immigrants or the descendants of folks kidnapped and enslaved here, they're all obviously sub-human and therefore their deaths don't count as much as folks like you, right?

Don't be shy. It's okay to speak up about it these days. That's a good bigot. Nice bigot.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by reissbaker on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:01PM (#45206392)
This was not a mass shooting.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:00PM (#45206818)
I think the fact that this wasn't a mass shooting makes it even worse.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tenuousemphasis on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:22AM (#45208078)
What an unhinged thing to say.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:41AM (#45208557)
Sorry, upon re-reading my comment, I communicated my thought incorrectly.

My intention was to point out that the not-mass shooting overshadowed the mass shooting in the news. Obviously both are bad, but 3 people dying in a single shooting incident is worse than 1 person dying in a single shooting incident, yet the 1 person dying is the one that gets the news coverage.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by account42 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:21AM (#45210238)
People aren't equal in the eyes of the public media. News at eleven.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by abustamam on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:04PM (#45217374)
I think that points out something even more horrifying about the American news cycle. A social media influencer being killed vs high school students being killed. Perhaps that's a bit reductive but I feel like the HS shooting ought to be a LOT more shocking, if it weren't a headline that we sadly have become somewhat blind to.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:45PM (#45206690)
> US could reduce mass shootings by strengthening regulations?

How? without decreasing access for sane people or using any of the previous talking points that have been rejected previously. now’s the time to suggest real change that could have an effect but suggesting the tired “no black rifles” will still go nowhere.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:36AM (#45210836)
New regulation: no private citizens can possess guns, and police must account for every bullet and firearm.

Granted, this decreases access for everyone. But I'd argue sane people would not demand private gun ownership in today's environment.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tekknik on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:09AM (#45211175)
and you’ll get nowhere again.
[dead]
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ninjagoo on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:54PM (#45207177)
That source is so unreliable that you may want to check those "claims" yourself, by hand:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Washington_Times#Controver...

Likely better source that disproves the "claims" in the article above, since perp demographics are in line with the male demographics of the US:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_shootings_in_the_United_S...

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by extropic-engine on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:40PM (#45207095)
> But the vast majority of those 604 shootings are from gang members with many prior arrests shooting each other.

You are just blindly asserting this. Do you have any sources?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by insurancesucks on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:42PM (#45207115)
"Of 267 incidents this year classified as mass shootings by the Gun Violence Archive, nearly all can be tied to gang beefs, neighborhood arguments, robberies or domestic incidents that spiraled out of control.

Indiscriminate slaughter by a lone gunman blasting away at a store, school or some other public place is rare, according to a Washington Times analysis of the archive’s data, accounting for less than 4% of the total."

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2022/jun/16/street-braw...

This is 2022. These numbers roughly replicate for any year though.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nullocator on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:20PM (#45207368)
Maybe the shooter was just having a "neighborhood argument" with Kirk?

I'm struggling to understand what point you're even trying to make? Gun violence is not a concern when we bucket it into categories? Some categories of gun violence are more okay than others?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by extropic-engine on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:29PM (#45215813)
sorry, but “the washington times,” a site whose design and name seems suspiciously chosen to mirror that of the more well known and respected washington post, is not a reputable source by any metric that is not in bad faith.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Washington_Times

it was founded in 1982 by a cult leader. try again

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by insurancesucks on Friday September 12, 2025 @09:46AM (#45222103)
My original comment a few up included a peer reviewed paper in science direct with similar findings across multiple years.

Turn your brain on and critique the data, not the source

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:16PM (#45206494)
If every adult that could carry a gun did, there would be much less mass shooting. It would be minimized shooting, in fact.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by maest on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:33PM (#45207468)
This seems tenuous and directionally wrong based on priors. What evidence do you have for this?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by artificialLimbs on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:17AM (#45211997)
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by inkcapmushroom on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:58AM (#45212448)
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/search/research-news/5504/

https://rockinst.org/blog/public-mass-shootings-around-the-w...

The US is an outlier in how many guns we own, with about 1/3 of American adults owning guns, and we are also an extreme outlier in mass shootings unless you compare us to places that lack rule of law. How many more people need guns before that mass shooting number goes down to 0, do you think?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by maest on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:35PM (#45217523)
Given your link, I'd say every shooting where the bad guy didn't get shot is evidence in the opposite direction? Seems to me there's more of those than your 11 examples.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by tirant on Friday September 12, 2025 @05:36AM (#45220404)
That would only be true in a world where every single human is able to regulate their angry emotions immediately. But that is so far away from human nature...
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by watwut on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:37AM (#45208531)
Asking geminy is like copy pasting a random reddit comment. Fine if it links the resource, not fine otherwise.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2025 @06:38AM (#45209958)
You’re quoting statistics that are irrelevant to the point. Mass shootings are not political violence.

I can come up with a multitude of political violence examples in countries with strict weapons laws - New Zealand, France, Japan. Then if you add in other weapons - cars, knives, bombs, the list gets even longer.

The point is - gun control won’t stop political violence. Perpetrators will use other means at their disposal.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:33AM (#45210813)
> The point is - gun control won’t stop political violence. Perpetrators will use other means at their disposal.

Technically true. But gun control means political violence will have to engage much closer and is less likely to be as deadly. Do we want more or less death+maiming in our political violence?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:26AM (#45211359)
You’re missing the forest for the trees.

The issue is political violence. Whether it’s done up close or far away is a distraction from the fact it exists.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:45AM (#45211595)
Am I? The forest view is that political violence is an inevitable part of life. And that outlawing guns makes them less accessible and therefore less likely to be used in any violent interactions.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by refurb on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:11PM (#45217701)
You are.

No, political violence isn't an "inevitable part of life".

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by paulryanrogers on Monday September 15, 2025 @07:43PM (#45256303)
Violence is part of human nature. So is politics. I'd rather they didn't mix, and we take reasonable measures to stop all violence. But I don't see how we can make violence impossible without changing human nature.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by aiisjustanif on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:55AM (#45211739)
Just to be clear political violence is a broad umbrella of many actions, including violent protest and political assassinations. One can be more of an issue than the other. Personally, in my opinion it’s hard to political violence as a whole is an “issue” when looking from a historically context. However, I do think that political assassination specifically is something that has been an issue historically.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ivape on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:57AM (#45210519)
How come there’s no gun violence in prison but plenty of stabbings? Prison is the highest concentration of violent criminals and yet no gun violence. To quote the great Eddie Izzard, “you can’t just walk up to someone and yell BANG. The gun helps”.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Glyptodon on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:07PM (#45217016)
I can't tell if your comment is serious. Did you know that if everyone lived in a 7x7 cell they couldn't leave there'd be no drunk driving deaths too?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ivape on Friday September 12, 2025 @10:35AM (#45222603)
There’s positives to cars that far outweigh the cost of drunk driving. Gun ownership does not “far outweigh” its consequences.

I will just casually ignore your reductionist argument, I’m sure you’ll understand. Reasonable people don’t argue that way as all arguments would just … boil down to nothing.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Glyptodon on Monday September 15, 2025 @06:02PM (#45255507)
It's hard to take your argument seriously given that (a) prisons are an intentional police state and a generally unpleasant abode, (b) people are still violently dying in them anyway (well over double non-prison homicide rate even with somewhat effective dangerous property restrictions), (c) there's no sane way to apply prison levels of property restriction to the public at large outside of prisons (and we live in a world where the ability to fabricate weapons at home grows day by day), (d) whether gun ownership outweighs its downsides is as similarly complex and judgement driven a question as whether cars do: both have complex downside and benefits with situational and unclear boundaries. That people can with a straight face "why should anyone need a gun" in a country with food deserts and regions with deer overpopulation problems while often treating "why should anyone need a Lamborghini?" as an offensive or silly question only illustrates.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:15PM (#45206487)
Some years back, I had a discussion with an older woman who struck a conversation with me innocently enough about weather or something. She turned the topic to politics and volunteered an opinion, her tone and expression indicated to me that she expected me to agree with her statement. I told her that I respectfully disagreed with her and I also told her why. Her expression soured and she told me that because she was a schoolteacher she thought guns should be banned because too many children had been killed by people using guns on them. I agreed with her that it was tragic and that I hoped we could live in a world where kids wouldn’t die from people using guns on them. In my life I want to be rational and honest and I want to listen to people. I listen to people and I hope they listen to me because that’s how ideas are exchanged. I asked her how I myself could avoid becoming the victim of a genocide without guns. I wonder this myself. I’ve read about genocides, the millions of people dead in China, Russia, Germany, Poland, Africa and Gaza too, I’ve also seen rioting and violence firsthand in Los Angeles and Portland and I wonder how I can ensure that my girlfriend and I will be safe now and into the future. I have no solution except for responsible gun ownership. A few years ago our car was stolen in Portland, the police did not help and the 911 phone service was down at the time. The only way I could get the car was to physically go and pick the car up, a car surrounded by criminals, of course I needed a gun to make sure I was safe. I think about natural disasters or occasions where government is unable or unwilling to protect its citizens - how will good people defend themselves against evil people? I’ve seen violence firsthand so many times that I have a visceral reaction to the thought that someone would take my guns away - I simply wouldn’t let it happen because I know if I did then I wouldn’t be able to prevent myself from being killed and dumped in an unmarked mass grave by a 19 year old kid who thinks he’s doing the right thing because of a mandate from a politician, and I wouldn’t be able to stop evil people.

She disagreed, I disagreed with her, she made points I feel were unfair oversimplifications “guns have more rights than women,” but we had a respectful discussion but she didn’t want to talk with me anymore after that. I would’ve talked with her after because I value what people have to say and I want to have discussions. I think we can have discussions but we should never take away the rights of citizens.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by KayEss on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:38PM (#45207085)
This comes across a lot like you're saying that your personal feeling of safety for you and your family is worth more than the actual safety of innocent schoolchildren who are being mass murdered.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:04AM (#45208343)
I am personally concerned that I may be the victim of genocide, and far more people have died from genocide perpetrated by governments than by school shootings. I’m not trying to be dense, I’m simply saying that history of demonstrated this. I’m also concerned that I will be the victim of violent crime and I’ve also had to defend myself from violent criminals in the past. Have you had any of these experiences? I’m curious to hear your thoughts if you’ve ever feared for your life in this way? Call me selfish, but I personally don’t want to be hurt. Thank you for your response.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Denote6737 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:08AM (#45208700)
IF you are going to be the victim of genocide they will take away your ability to defend yourself first.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by KayEss on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:30AM (#45210303)
This of course plays into the fear US gun advocates have of any attempt to remove their gun rights. If it were to happen though, then maybe as a prepper type with a house and lands in the woods you'd stand a chance against an armed mob that came for you, but certainly not the government. If you're defending your sub-urban house (or even worse flat), I suspect that the gun you have for self defense would make very little difference to the final outcome, but might make you feel a bit better about it.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by KayEss on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:16AM (#45210214)
I have had a gun pointed at me, and I've been where guns have been fired in anger around me.

I'm kind of surprised to hear somebody in America think it's a likely enough thing to happen to be worth the obvious societal cost of the wide spread weapons.

Realistically, if they did come for you, how much use would your weapon be? Do you believe that it would mean the difference between your life and death, or just that you'd feel better going having been able to put up some defence? Several genocides have happened in neighbouring countries from where I live in living memory, and it isn't at all clear that having access to a weapon allowed anybody who was targeted to survive.

The cost in mass shootings (now nearly two per day in the US) is a real cost borne by society at large. Your cost is still only hypothetical, and of unclear value if the worst did happen.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:43AM (#45212938)
It seems you have been around violence but have concluded differently than I have.

I think that all rights are hypothetical until they are used. People in America have the right to free speech and assembly but depending on your perspective these rights are hypothetical for most people because they don’t use their speech or right to assembly very often or to the fullest extent. In some states, women have the right to have an abortion but many don’t use that right so hypothetically for them it doesn’t have any value. I think with the right to keep and bear arms it’s the same, for a good person defending themselves with a gun this hypothetical right becomes applied and has an immeasurable value to them. I don’t think we should discard any of our rights even if they are rarely used. I don’t think the risk of a genocide or civil war is infinitesimal, I think these sort of events happen often and are guaranteed over a long enough timeline. I think that people who are well armed would be better off in these situations and may even be the people who put something like a genocide to a stop.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by KayEss on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:44PM (#45218182)
You're misinterpreting what I said. I said that your ability to defend yourself and your family with a gun was hypothetical.

I can see that you like to think of yourself as a rational thinker about this, but you're refusing to answer the actual criticism: actual people are being killed every day due to the availability of weapons in your society. There are nearly two mass shootings per day. So far this year that has led to 250 deaths and more than a thousand injuries[1]. These are not hypothetical abstractions, which is all you seem interested in engaging with. These are real people, many of them children, who find themselves victims of gun violence. You are arguing that your feeling of safety is more important than their actual safety. All of your arguments amount to a continuation of your position that you put your own feelings ahead of the actual deaths of people in society around you. This is a very selfish way to engage in your society.

[1] https://edition.cnn.com/us/mass-shootings-fast-facts

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Saturday September 13, 2025 @04:08AM (#45230245)
I understand your position, it is terrible that adults and children die by the hands of others. Genocides have happened all over the world and have led to tens of millions of people dying. These events aren’t hypothetical they’re historical but happen in big chunks rather than uniformly distributed and frequent but comparatively small events. I would suggest the statistics indicate that a person is likelier to die from a genocide than from a mass shooting by a factor of >100 and that small arms ownership and competence is more helpful rather than harmful since these tools can enable individuals to defend themselves against state actors or violent groups, or by their existence prevent groups with malicious intent from acting out on their genocidal or authoritarian desires. Something I agree with is the FBI’s assessment that people don’t commit crimes if they thinks it’s likely that they’ll be caught. I think that the collective individuals in our government (these United States of America) wouldn’t want to mandate concentration camps or a genocide because of the concentration of citizens with diverse mindsets who would provide feedback through resistance. There are of course other factors like recency bias that come into play.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jiggawatts on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:50AM (#45210468)
You've talked about your feelings a lot, which is the point.

Guns make people feel safe.

They don't actually make you safer.

You're more likely to be killed by your own gun than someone else's.

Realistically, you have no hope of protecting yourself with a gun if you're surrounded by gangbangers with a bunch of guns all pointed at you.

Etc, etc...

The gun debate isn't a debate about facts, it never was. It's a debate about feelings, and scared people won't change their minds unless they stop being scared.

Nobody in America right now is trying to make people feel safe, not in an era where the President of the United States feels it is appropriate to personally attack... anyone for any perceived slight, in public, with verbal violence and in the case of anyone looking even vaguely hispanic, physical violence.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:48AM (#45212988)
I get where you’re coming from, but I lived in Portland for years where the police were essentially suppressed by the district attorney Eric Schmidt. This led to violent criminals essentially controlling the city at night and which lead to unfortunate outcomes for my family. Simultaneously this came at a time where the previous president was threatening my job and livelihood with mandates and I was receiving emails from our national HR that we may lose our jobs if we did not comply. These two events did not make me feel safe for years, I do feel safer with the current president.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by projektfu on Thursday September 11, 2025 @05:59PM (#45216541)
Mike Schmidt? I think Eric Schmidt was the CEO of Google.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by whatarethembits on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:48AM (#45212998)
Rhetorical: What does it say about America that a large portion of its citizens (assuming OPs feelings are not unique) fear being a victim of genocide? Can't say I've met anyone from any other "developed" nation who share the same dread by simply existing as part of their country.

In other words, the sum total of America's values have resulted in a citizenry that lives with existential dread. Maybe those values need a second look?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:43PM (#45214172)
My thoughts on this is that genocide has been common outside of America in the last ~100 years and that Americans need to act differently than the rest of the world in an effort to keep it from happening here.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by rTX5CMRXIfFG on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:14PM (#45206921)
> how will good people defend themselves against evil people

The problem is in people assuming that they are “good”. That’s hubris. The reality is that everyone is equally capable of evil—we’re just looking at taking guns out of the equation so that gun violence becomes highly unlikely.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slidehero on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:39PM (#45207087)
As someone not from the US I can tell you that the rest of the world just shakes their head in sadness at your logic.

The best offense against a tyrannical government is a general strike. Literally everyone sitting down and refusing to participate.

>I simply wouldn’t let it happen because I know if I did then I wouldn’t be able to prevent myself from being killed and dumped in an unmarked mass grave

You seem to value rational thought. I'll leave it to you to find sources that show that, statistically, you're overwhelming more likely to be killed or injured by your own weapon (accident or suicide) than you are to ever get the chance to use your gun in self defense.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by throwaway3060 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:32PM (#45207462)
I hate to say this - but having known refugees from a tyrannical government, I have to shake my head at this. If a population tried a general strike against a truly tyrannical government, pretty soon that government will start bringing out gunmen. Like in Ukraine in 2014. Sometimes it will work out, but not without sacrifice.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slidehero on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:09AM (#45207689)
>but having known refugees from a tyrannical government

my family escaped Poland as political refugees before the end of communism. Poland famously had bloodless revolution in 1989 exactly this way.

Down tools. stop work and the economy essentially seized up (practically over night).

>Sometimes it will work out, but not without sacrifice.

Sacrifice is always necessary.

If the factories stop, there is no way to move forward, regardless of how tyrannical the government.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by throwaway3060 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:25AM (#45207764)
Do you believe the results would have been the same under a Stalin instead of a Gorbachev?

This isn't to take away from what Poland accomplished then, or to say that such methods can never work in the right conditions. Violent revolutions against established tyrants do not have a great history. But I have a hard time understanding the belief that these methods can work in the worst of conditions.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slidehero on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:33AM (#45207806)
>Do you believe the results would have been the same under a Stalin instead of a Gorbachev?

A little different if you're talking foreign invasion obviously. In Poland's case it was Poles vs Poles and regardless of the level of tyranny, soldiers have trouble shooting their countrymen if they're sitting in a factory.

If the other guy is actively shooting at you though?... The logic is simple to follow.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by adrian_b on Thursday September 11, 2025 @06:02AM (#45209742)
I am pretty sure that a general strike could not have been initiated in Poland without the support of traitors from inside the top layers of the communist party and of the security forces.

In any of the communist countries of Eastern Europe everybody hated the government and they wanted to start a general strike. However, immediately after somebody would say this in loud voice, they would disappear. There have been a few cases when strikes have succeeded to start in a place, but then the government succeeded to prevent everybody else to know anything about this for many years, usually until the fall of the communist governments around 1989, and the strikers would disappear in such cases.

The weakness of the communist governments around 1989, after decades of easily suppressing any similar opposition, can be explained only by an internal fight within the communist leadership.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by vel0city on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:55PM (#45207619)
> Like Ukraine in 2014

You mean the Revolution of Dignity, where mostly unarmed (at least by firearm) protesters stood up against government snipers and successfully removed the pro-Russian government? If anything, it shows one can overthrow their government despite not having much firepower while the government has guns.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by throwaway3060 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:15AM (#45207720)
With more than a hundred people killed by those government snipers. The protestors succeeded, but some paid the ultimate price to do it. If they had a means to defend themselves, maybe there could have been less lives lost.

This was Ukraine, where elections still existed and there was still some air of democracy and institutions. In a place where a tyrant has an established, unshakeable monopoly on violence, what do you think could prevent the tyrant from using that?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slidehero on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:19AM (#45207738)
>If they had a means to defend themselves, maybe there could have been less lives lost.

dude c'mon, be serious.

the response to "my house is on fire" is not "gee I wonder what would happen if I added more fuel..."

The response is to starve the fire of oxygen. Labour is a government's oxygen.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by vel0city on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:21AM (#45207751)
You think there would have been less death if both sides were actively shooting at each other? Are you really following your own logic here?

How did the Confederate uprising go with their arms against the federal government in the US? More or less than a hundred or so deaths? And this was also a country that still had elections.

Do you actually have examples of civil wars in large modern-ish countries where both sides were well armed that resulted in less than 200 deaths?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by throwaway3060 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:34AM (#45207814)
I don't view civil wars the same way - these aren't individual protestors, but separatist military forces. They are violent by definition.

I did say maybe. Yanukovych ultimately fled - presumably he felt his position was threatened. We cannot know how many more he might have been willing to kill if he did not feel as threatened.

This is not advocating for a solution, only to point out that a committed tyrant can be next to impossible to dislodge.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by vel0city on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:41AM (#45207861)
What would have stopped the Maidan protesters from being labeled as separatist military forces if they were well-armed? You're drawing distinctions where there are none.

Where do you think the Confederate forces got their firearms from? They just suddenly popped into existence the moment they became "separatist military forces"? They were the people with rights to bear arms bringing up arms against their tyrannical government.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by throwaway3060 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:52AM (#45207913)
The Confederacy was made of states. Even before the Civil War, each of these had militias.

I'm sure Yanukovych would have labelled them a separatist military - but would the remaining institutions agree? We don't have to assume that the protestors bring weapons from the beginning - it could come only in response to Yanukovych committing to violence.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Shocka1 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:51AM (#45208266)
As someone who has worked all over the world with several different cultures and types of people, including in war zones, saying “the rest of the world shakes their head” is an extremely broad generalization. Different countries have very different experiences with guns, governments, and resistance. I'm sure you have your own perspective that is valuable, but speaking for “the rest of the world” comes across as dismissive and small minded, rather than engaging with the point that was made.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by adrian_b on Thursday September 11, 2025 @05:35AM (#45209572)
A general strike did not work in the past against most communist governments and it is much less likely to ever work in the future, anywhere.

In all the countries of the Eastern Europe where the communist governments were removed, this was possible only due to traitors inside the communist top layer, who had reached the conclusion that their chiefs are too incompetent, so it will be more profitable for themselves to remove all the figures well known to the public and to convert themselves into capitalist businessmen, ensuring the surviving of their power in another form.

For a general strike to exist, it must be coordinated. There must exist someone who must say "Let's do this" and everybody else must start the strike.

This is impossible under a competent tyrannical government. A half of century ago it was impossible because every company, institution or school was infiltrated with informants, who would report immediately any kind of criticism against the government, then the reported person would disappear, e.g. by being interned in a mental health institution. If somehow a strike succeeded to start in a single place, that place would be instantly isolated, with no communications, then nobody outside would learn what has happened, except perhaps many years later, and the strikers would disappear.

Nowadays, this has become much simpler, because the government no longer needs a huge number of loyal human snitches (which had to be redundant, as none of them could be trusted), it can use electronic surveillance monitored by AI.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Bridged7756 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:28AM (#45210762)
No, we don't. Don't speak for the rest of the world, for not everyone lives in your country, let alone in your bubble.

I think your "offense" Is downright naive, if not moronic. You should know how difficult politics are, and what you are asking for, the civilians, the military, just sitting down to "protest" is not only an imaginative fantasy, but I would also wager downright impossible.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:02PM (#45213155)
I don’t think everyone in the entire world disagrees and I think many people in the world do agree with my point of view . I also think it would be more constructive for people who disagree to disagree respectfully rather than shake their head in disapproval - with the understanding that two rational actors can arrive at different and reasonable conclusions because they value parameters differently. I work with statistics and probability every day. It’s my understanding that certain assumptions and modeling were made in the statistics so that the probabilities may not apply to me in general.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by vel0city on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:51PM (#45207594)
Did the gun actually make you safer when retrieving your car or did it just make you feel safer? Did having the gun actually solve any problem, or just increase the chances of someone dying over a parked car?

Aren't there other potential ways to fix society from your example of your stolen car other than "we should just arm everyone"? Shouldn't the answer be we should have police actually help these situations and we should do more to reduce the rates of people living lives where they're more likely to steal a car in the first place?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by coderenegade on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:13AM (#45207710)
There aren't any other solutions that empower the individual. The problem is when the police are underfunded and don't show up, or the judiciary continually lets dangerous individuals out on bail. We should be able to rely on the system, but it's not hard to see why people want firearms when the system fails.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by angelgonzales on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:13AM (#45208394)
In my case, the criminals physically left because I had a firearm. That week the police response time was anywhere from three hours to three days. This was in Portland, Oregon and our car had been stolen three times before, my girlfriend‘s bike was also stolen and my car was broken into three times, my other car was totaled by a drunk driver without any repercussions. We left Portland shortly after meeting a British person who had been kidnapped and forced to withdraw money from ATMs.

I would love to live in a world where everybody has what they want but we don’t live in that world. That being said there is no excuse for somebody taking something that does not belong to them. I was deeply hurt by these experiences and forever changed in the way that I think and act. I learned that sometimes when I told people about the things that had happened to us, I felt that that person had sympathy for the criminals and no sympathy for me. I learned that it is a fact that police cannot be everywhere, they cannot react instantly, and even if they can react sometimes they won’t for political reasons. I still think of the time where I was sucker punched by some man on the street for no reason which is what initially lead me to purchase a firearm for self-defense. I can’t fix society, but I can protect myself and my loved ones.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Jataman606 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:45AM (#45209303)
>I’ve read about genocides, the millions of people dead in China, Russia, Germany, Poland, Africa and Gaza too, I’ve also seen rioting and violence firsthand in Los Angeles and Portland and I wonder how I can ensure that my girlfriend and I will be safe now and into the future. I have no solution except for responsible gun ownership.

No gun will save you during genocide if you are a target. Best case scenario you kill few attackers and die anyway.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by kbelder on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:50PM (#45215981)
An armed person won't stop a genocide, but an armed populace might.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by solid_fuel on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:35PM (#45217518)
Genocides are not committed solely by governments. An armed and divided populace is just as likely to commit a genocide as they are to stop one. Look at the Rwandan genocide. Look at the mass shootings we have here by white supremacists.

All it takes is an armed populace that stands by while “those people” (their neighbors) are killed by extremists (their other neighbors).

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by monkeydreams on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:32PM (#45206602)
> I think people need to recognize that in many aspects what's happening is connected to societal issues that gun control and gun regulations will have very little impact on - remember, even in Japan somebody could make some kind of battery ignited home-made shotgun and kill Shinzo Abe.

... having said that, isn't it funny just how much gun violence there is in the one developed country that allows for open slather gun ownership. It's like, yes, you can never stop a determined person from doing violence, but by reducing the availability and power of fire arms you do stop a lot of fools from doing "mass shooter" levels of damage.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by doom2 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:45PM (#45207127)
Trump was golfing instead of attending the funeral of the Hortmans and used their death to insult Tim Walz. He didn't order flags flown at half mast like he's now done with Kirk. Notable conservative publications like National Review barely covered the Minnesota shooting. He also mocked the attack on Nancy Pelosi's husband.

So I would say the reaction will be quite different, given that Kirk was a political ally and not a Democrat.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jjani on Thursday September 11, 2025 @01:15AM (#45208037)
2 Minnesota lawmakers shot in politically motivated killings, governor says (cbc.ca) 102 points by awnird 88 days ago | hide | past | favorite | 19 comments

At least one HN, this story is already getting 100x(!) the reach, when it doesn't even involve lawmakers.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by account42 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:27AM (#45210281)
So? You didn't even bother to name those lawmakers yourself.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by bluecheese452 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:56AM (#45210516)
This is the perfect example of the exception that proves the rule. I mean it is almost shocking that you would try to say this with a straight face.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ndiddy on Thursday September 11, 2025 @08:23AM (#45210717)
> I'm mildly curious what the reaction to this will be compared to the reaction to other recent political murders, like the Hortmans, or of Thompson.

Trump has already issued a statement blaming his political opponents for the death before the perpetrator has even been identified.

"It's long past time for all Americans and the media to confront the fact that violence and murder are the tragic consequence of demonizing those with whom you disagree day after day, year after year, in the most hateful and despicable way possible. For years, those on the radical left have compared wonderful Americans like Charlie to Nazis and the world's worst mass murderers and criminals. This kind of rhetoric is directly responsible for the terrorism that we're seeing in our country today, and it must stop right now. My administration will find each and every one of those who contributed to this atrocity and to other political violence, including the organizations that funded and support it, as well as those who go after our judges, law enforcement officials, and everyone else who brings order to our country."

> That said, I think people need to recognize that in many aspects what's happening is connected to societal issues that gun control and gun regulations will have very little impact on - remember, even in Japan somebody could make some kind of battery ignited home-made shotgun and kill Shinzo Abe.

The event was set up so nobody could have direct access to Kirk, which would have been required for the "home-made shotgun" approach. There were barricades and bodyguards in front of him, and a waiting car in case he had to be whisked away. Shooting someone from 200+ yards requires more precise weapons than someone can make themselves. I think it's also important to note that Utah literally started allowing open carry on college campuses a few weeks ago. Not only did all those "good guys with guns" not prevent the assassination, having a large number of armed people in a crowd makes finding the shooter more difficult, as we've seen from police arresting the wrong suspect multiple times.