News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by WarOnPrivacy on Saturday July 19, 2025 @01:39AM (#44612864)
Synopsis and excerpt:

    [Rest] markets itself as a way to "unlock a new revenue stream"
    with the help of a "robust algorithm" for detecting smoking.
Hotels where these sensors are installed rack up complaints and negative reviews, after Rest sensors register false positives - thereby unlocking that revenue stream for the hotels.

The awesome thing about black-box algorithms is they can't be challenged when they're wrong. And errors reliably favor the institution that manages (and profits from) them.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by high_byte on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:11AM (#44612995)
"unlocking revenue stream" is wild way to say theft
[dead]
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by rzz3 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:23AM (#44613314)
No, surely this product didn’t just come to market in the last 6 months. Every problem in the world isn’t caused by Trump, though many are. Blaming Trump for hotel smoke detectors delegitimizes the legitimate problems coming from this administration.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by giraffe_lady on Saturday July 19, 2025 @10:52AM (#44615944)
There is a certain "scams are legal now" vibe to american society these days. I wouldn't say it's directly caused by trump but he's certainly contributing to it.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by miltonlost on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:59AM (#44616599)
Hell, just look at Trump's pro-crypto bill and you can see what he thinks about scams. (All crypto is a scam)
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by consp on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:01AM (#44612953)
> The awesome thing about black-box algorithms is they can't be challenged when they're wrong. And errors reliably favor the institution that manages (and profits from) them.

Doesn't the US have false advertisement rules/scam prevention? Around here one person would have to fight this in court to tumble the whole thing down as there is no way Rest can prove it's claim is airtight (pun intended) due to simple statistics and physics (e.g. hair drying leaves burn particulates as well). I doubt it will even come this far as it's obviously a money making scheme over the customers back and acts in bad faith ("The sensor's don't make mistakes" is a claim to innocence where none is valid as almost everyone can smell). It's probably fine as an early detection agent but you'd have to actually check.

Also the charges are disproportionate to the beach of contract, unless they steam clean the room every time they claim the money. Which they obviously don't according to the "dirty room" comments.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by gorbachev on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:12AM (#44613568)
Hotel guests are not buying the sensors. The hotels would probably have a claim due to this, but since they're "unlocking new revenue streams", they are probably not going to bother.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by gamblor956 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @06:44PM (#44620124)
You're not wrong. A single class action lawsuit would destroy Rest as a going concern, assuming there were enough false-positives generated to be an issue.

(Rest would have to demonstrate how its technology works in court in order to have any hope of defeating such a lawsuit. And as the hotel guests don't have contracts with Rest, they aren't bound by any arbitration agreements.)

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by adrr on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:20AM (#44613299)
I bet it’s also a rev share model. Hotel doesn’t pay for the device but revenue is shared. Like the traffic cameras where they shorten yellow light to durations that a car is incapable of stopping in time.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by walterbell on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:11AM (#44613560)
Primitive contract asset tokenization. What other parts of the hotel-customer contract could become zero-capex financial instruments powered by surveillance data, washed in health and safety?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_tokenization

   Asset tokenization refers to the process of converting rights to a real-world asset into a digital token on a blockchain or distributed ledger. These tokens represent ownership, rights, or claims on tangible or intangible assets and can be traded or transferred on digital platforms.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by progbits on Saturday July 19, 2025 @10:34AM (#44615787)
So aside from Rest being incompetent morons ("temperature changes" from smoking??), they now also have incentive to make it trigger as much as possible.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by chii on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:09AM (#44616125)
> incentive

it's not an incentive, it's a raison d'etre!

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by bbarnett on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:34AM (#44616381)
So now when I play a game on my laptop, I get charged too??

(People were mentioning hair dryers)

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by kotaKat on Saturday July 19, 2025 @10:50AM (#44615927)
Check the App Store screenshots - https://apps.apple.com/us/app/rest-by-noiseaware/id644925142...

The app even tracks the whole fee amount in-app being collected. "Net charge", "adjusted charge amount" reasons of "guest complaint"...

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by lxgr on Saturday July 19, 2025 @10:58AM (#44615994)
Their "NoiseAware" main product line also sounds incredibly dystopian. Apparently, that's a "privacy-safe" microphone listening in rental properties, to "detect crowds gathering"...!?

This type of creepy stuff, together with Airbnb's horrible business practices (last time they wanted access to my checking account transaction history via Plaid!) and enabling scammy hosts, is why I'm back to just staying at regular hotels.

Sad to see some of them are now start adopting the same type of customer-hostile technology as well.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by egypturnash on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:15AM (#44616197)
AirBnB partiers are a real problem, I live in a tourist destination and regularly hear horror stories about a residential neighborhood suddenly having crowds descend on a house that's become a party rental. There's nobody to notice it getting out of hand and tell them to chill before the neighbors call the cops because the owner is a holding company on the other side of the country.

Of course Airbnbs are also a real problem in general with the way they increase the scarcity of housing, so I'm pretty happy all in all to see you saying you're being driven back to hotels.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by HWR_14 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:36AM (#44616392)
I think repeatedly calling the police is the correct way to handle an AirBnB party house in your neighborhood. I don't want to instead have the unpaid job of monitoring the guests for the absentee owner and be responsible for telling them to chill.

Of course, a long term neighbor it is different. There the police would be a last resort.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by majormajor on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:08PM (#44616690)
Feels like a fun opportunity for a jurisdiction to legislate and pursue eminent domain seizures of "party homes" with absentee landlords.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by vkou on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:01PM (#44617785)
> AirBnB partiers are a real problem,

They are, which is why residential properties that are used as hotels should be seized and auctioned off.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by const_cast on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:16PM (#44617935)
Then don't rent your house. This is a risk of rental properties.

Look, if you have a house in a tourist spot and you say "no parties!", you're not gonna make any money. And if the residents don't like said parties, they can rally together to make AirBNBs illegal in their area. That's how many (most?) touristy places are.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by vorador on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:47PM (#44618221)
This is just pushing the externalities to the residents. It takes several months for airbnbs to get banned, and it's tough for smaller cities to get the bans enforced.

There must be a better answer than "pass a law so the american multinational does a better job at regulating its rentals"

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by tbrownaw on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:05PM (#44618358)
> Of course Airbnbs are also a real problem in general with the way they increase the scarcity of housing,

What's the actual mechanism for airbnbs to prevent housing construction?

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by sbarre on Saturday July 19, 2025 @10:35PM (#44621482)
I'll assume good faith here:

AirBnB rentals typically make more money for apartment and condo owners than long-term rentals, at least in big cities (that attract tourists) where there's often already scarce housing and not a lot of new affordable construction.

So as housing units get taken off the long-term market rental (i.e. actually being used for housing) to be turned into short-term rental for AirBnB, it reduces the available stock for renters.

And in many large cities small condos and purpose-built rentals are mostly what get built, because that's what investors are asking for - and builders build what they expect to sell and what they can profit on.

But then the investors who buy these "homes" don't actually put them up for rent, they turn them into short-term rentals for tourists and visitors, and those dwellings are not available for the people who actually need to live in the city.

This dual pressure on scarcity then drives up the rent on available properties because the demand goes up since there's less and less long-term rentals available for residents.

So they don't necessarily "prevent housing construction" (what housing gets built is a topic a bit too complex to get into here) but they absolutely do reduce available housing in large cities and in-demand areas, in the ways outlined above.

This is why many large metropolitan areas have either banned AirBnB or heavily regulated them (with mixed success, and rarely the honest participation of AirBnB themselves).

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by tbrownaw on Sunday July 20, 2025 @01:20AM (#44622205)
> I'll assume good faith here:

This tells me that you think that treating housing supply as a relevant factor to the price of housing is a stupidly obvious error.

> So they don't necessarily "prevent housing construction" (what housing gets built is a topic a bit too complex to get into here) but they absolutely do reduce available housing in large cities and in-demand areas, in the ways outlined above.

That you for agreeing that they do not prevent housing supply from increasing to meet the increased demand.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by sbarre on Sunday July 20, 2025 @01:35PM (#44627368)
> > I'll assume good faith here:

> This tells me that you think that treating housing supply as a relevant factor to the price of housing is a stupidly obvious error.

Nah it's just that we've had trolls in here before who try to make bad faith arguments about AirBnB, by pretending they don't see the problems created by turning housing into short-term rentals.

> > So they don't necessarily "prevent housing construction" (what housing gets built is a topic a bit too complex to get into here) but they absolutely do reduce available housing in large cities and in-demand areas, in the ways outlined above.

> That you for agreeing that they do not prevent housing supply from increasing to meet the increased demand.

I definitely don't agree with that. I said "necessarily" for a reason, meaning it's not the _only_ factor, nor it is _always_ a factor (depending on location etc) but it certainly is one of the major impacts on housing supply.

As for meeting demand, here's one way AirBnB is "preventing" supply from meeting demand:

Builders build what sells, and what buyers want. For the last while in many/most large western cities (I only know Canada and the US mostly, making a few loose assumptions here about elsewhere), real estate investors have been pushing for lots of single-bedroom condo units because those are the kinds of units that are popular as short-term rentals.

So builders prioritize these kinds of units for sale to investors who have no intention of making them available as housing, even though they are zoned and built as housing.

So... I think you can draw a pretty solid line between this kind of economic incentive and a lack of housing to meet demand, since there is a finite capacity for building housing (based on available builders - i.e. capital and manpower).

Secondly, remember impacting supply is not just about adding new housing but also about how affordable the available housing is.

When people convert existing housing to short-term rental, it reduces the total supply. And when you squeeze the supply, prices go up, and people get priced out of the places they live.

A few links for you:

https://ricochet.media/justice/housing/how-airbnb-and-short-...

https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11-621-m/11-621-m2024010...

p.s. If you want to reply again and discuss, try not to cherry-pick a few low-relevancy sentences out of context to ignore my broader point.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by tbrownaw on Sunday July 20, 2025 @04:39PM (#44629100)
> since there is a finite capacity for building housing (based on available builders - i.e. capital and manpower).

This is the only actually relevant point in the post.

And the only situation where it can be true is if ability to build more housing isn't subject to market forces, ie is constricted by bad policy.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by didntcheck on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:23AM (#44616285)
I suppose in theory you could have a device which doesn't have the storage or bandwidth to record/transmit full audio, but does some heuristics on the device and then transmits a small payload of flags. But in any case I wouldn't want to stay anywhere with an unaccountable black box ready to unfalsifiably charge me

The other commenter is absolutely right that partyers in AirBnBs cause nuisances for local residents, but the owners will have to find another way to sort that out or close up shop

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by geraldwhen on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:23PM (#44618001)
A decibel reader isn’t a microphone that records, necessarily. Being obnoxiously loud is a societal ill and I applaud efforts to reduce this.

No one wants to live next to an Airbnb house blasting music at 3am.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by lxgr on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:26PM (#44618049)
Sure, but I’ll certainly not stay at a place putting me under privacy-invading surveillance on the suspicion that I don’t know basic etiquette.

I’ll also consider these things to be microphones unless their manufacturer explicitly says otherwise, yet on their website I’ve only seen vague assurances about them being privacy-friendly.

For some, “on-device speech recognition that only sends voice samples for cloud analysis in exceptional cases” would probably also meet that bar, but it doesn’t for me.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by jnsie on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:13PM (#44618949)
That reminds me - we're staying in an Airbnb later this summer and I've been meaning to research gadgets to detect hidden cameras. Now I guess I need to look out for microphones too. We're going in quite the dystopian direction.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by RandomBacon on Sunday July 20, 2025 @10:01AM (#44625278)
Unless you get a nonlinear junction detector, I'm not sure any other device works as well. I remember seeing a news piece where they pay someone to plant a bunch of cameras, and the reporter tries a bunch of different devices and still misses some.

https://hackaday.com/2017/09/20/spy-tech-nonlinear-junction-...

It would be nice if someone could make them and sell them cheaply. I would buy into that Kickstarter.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by vineyardmike on Saturday July 19, 2025 @08:47PM (#44620897)
Not only that but it's used for "occupancy detection" to detect crowd sizes.

I once stayed at an AirBnB with some friends and the power went out in the evening one day of the trip. The next door neighbor also lost power, and came over to check on us - and didn't even step in the house. The next morning I got a nasty email from the host accusing me of abusing the occupancy limit. Clearly there were some hidden cameras or something in the house.

As silly as this example is, its just another annoying example of how technology is abused to monitor compliance with what should be a social issue.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by like_any_other on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:18PM (#44616796)
> Like the traffic cameras where they shorten yellow light to durations that a car is incapable of stopping in time.

One reckless endangerment in the first degree charge per every car passing through such an intersection. That is a class D felony, with a maximum penalty of 5-10 years prison time. Per car.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by RajT88 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:34PM (#44616926)
Hello from Chicago!
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by WWLink on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:21PM (#44617987)
What's messed up about red light cameras is they can actually be useful - if used correctly!

The correct use case is "We seem to have a problem with red light runners at this intersection, so let's find out why by temporarily deploying red light cameras here."

I've seen this done and the city in question found out. They were able to make some changes to the light timing and at several intersections, that caused the amount of red light runners to drastically drop. (It was stuff like the left turn light not turning green when the straight forward light did).

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by olyjohn on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:09PM (#44618912)
[delayed]
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by spondylosaurus on Saturday July 19, 2025 @01:53AM (#44612921)
I scoured their website to look for any clues about how it might (allegedly) work and got a fat lot of nothing.

> Rest constantly monitors room air quality, using a proprietary algorithm to pinpoint any tobacco, marijuana, or nicotine presence.

So a smoke detector with an "algorithm" attached. Uh huh. How does that algorithm work?

> By analyzing various factors and patterns[...]

Some cutting edge shit here!

And as for accuracy, they don't even pretend to make promises about "99.99% success rates" or anything. This is the most detailed they get:

> Q: Is it accurate?

> A: Our sophisticated smoking detection algorithm has been tested for accuracy in real-world scenarios, backed by years of development, and tens of thousands of hours of rigorous testing and validation.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:40AM (#44613132)
> Our sophisticated smoking detection algorithm has been tested

Okay, but what were the results? https://xkcd.com/1096/

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by thephotonsphere on Saturday July 19, 2025 @05:06AM (#44613812)
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by kotaKat on Saturday July 19, 2025 @07:34AM (#44614616)
It's going to be similar bullshit to what Halo uses in the highschool vape sensors. A bunch of particulate sensors for like PM1, PM2.5, PM10, sniffing out VOCs, and then they consider any tripping of any of that to be a "smoke" sesh.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by fnordpiglet on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:10AM (#44616137)
Yeah the anecdotal evidence leads you to this as well - the hair drier usage leading to triggering the sensor. My PM/VoC sensors in my bedroom spike when my wife dries her hair while my CO/CO2 sensors do not.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by mrb on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:53AM (#44616547)
Given that this image: https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/653a9fbd1075088b6c8f8bd3/... shows PM2.5 and CO2(ppm) it may imply they monitor particles and CO2 levels. My guess is it also monitors humidity, and temperature. Humidity helps distinguish smoke from water vapor (eg. steaming shower).

CO2 sensors are generally pretty accurate, but PM2.5 sensors are notoriously prone to false spikes usually caused by dust in or around the sensor: https://www.reddit.com/r/Awair/comments/10r1uyo/inaccurate_p... or https://forum.airgradient.com/t/unusual-pm2-5-readings-on-ne... or https://community.purpleair.com/t/what-to-do-about-incorrect...

My guess is it's likely a sensor in a hotel room accumulates dust over time, leading to high PM2.5 measurements maybe when something (eg. suitcase) bumps against the case, shaking the accumulated dust and releasing it around the sensor.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by microtherion on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:08PM (#44616693)
That's awesome for the hotel! The less they dust their rooms, the more "smoking fees" they can charge guests.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by boothby on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:21PM (#44616812)
Note that pm2.5 will also spike when you've used shampoo, perfume, deoderant, lotion, sunblock; if you use dryer sheets and you unpack your clothes, etc.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by paradox460 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:17PM (#44618970)
Farts will cause it to spike
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by winrid on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:53PM (#44621832)
It's unfortunate that we can't comment on reviews.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by billyjmc on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:55PM (#44618788)
This is news to me, but I’m unsurprised. Why people use so much strongly scented products is absolutely baffling to me.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by mrb on Saturday July 19, 2025 @06:40PM (#44620100)
Exactly! So many ways to make PM2.5 spike. I didn't even know about shampoo and sunblock. I assume for sunblock it's the spray kind?
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by veeti on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:34PM (#44618599)
I wonder if you could set it off by farting too much: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zvB0wRFebus
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by Aeolun on Saturday July 19, 2025 @01:32PM (#44617478)
This is like those 10k bomb detectors that were just a box with wires dangling out aren’t they?

I do not understand what possesses people to buy this stuff without proof.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by cogman10 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:06PM (#44618880)
Because they can charge $500 to almost all occupants realizing the likelihood of a repeat visitor is low?
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by Aeolun on Sunday July 20, 2025 @12:36AM (#44622013)
You can do that without this system if you are going to do it anyway.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by raverbashing on Saturday July 19, 2025 @01:40PM (#44617564)
> A: Our sophisticated smoking detection algorithm has been tested for accuracy in real-world scenarios, backed by years of development, and tens of thousands of hours of rigorous testing and validation.

I would be willing to bet a good amount of money they have a huge pile of nothing on this

On the other comment they say they monitor PM2.5, CO2 and humidity. Congratulations, your hot water shower with hard water just triggered the sensor. $500 fee.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by stogot on Saturday July 19, 2025 @05:17AM (#44613860)
I assume if it’s triggering on car exhaust or something from opening room windows
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by Proofread0592 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @09:09AM (#44615203)
Windows at these kinds of hotels usually do not open at all.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by jibe on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:12AM (#44616162)
This hotel is a 2-3 story building, with sliding windows, and some balconies. There is opportunity for outside air to blow into the room.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by grishka on Saturday July 19, 2025 @09:18AM (#44615256)
Hair dryers are mentioned several times, so I would assume one of the things these sensors look for is a rise in the air temperature.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by gonzalohm on Saturday July 19, 2025 @09:46AM (#44615447)
You would need a pretty good sensor to detect a temperature increase from lighting a cigarette. Most likely, the hair dryer has a hair stuck that gets burnt once turned on
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by lstamour on Saturday July 19, 2025 @10:27AM (#44615728)
Or perhaps formaldehyde release from hair spray and other chemicals partly due to the heat of the hair dryer, but also released because of the agitation and wind.

Technically I think perfume, sweat and trace amounts of smoking residue, including formaldehyde, from personal belongings could probably also raise VOCs as hotels often have very, very poor airflow by design - open windows and balconies have historically encouraged smokers so they were removed, but now you can rarely find any hotels with fresh air in the rooms, and those you find often smell of cigarette smoke for obvious reasons. (Smokers will often stay at hotels with airflow or balconies and take advantage of these features when they can. Also, airing out a room will kill a scent temporarily but only cleaning the room or replacing natural textiles will permanently remove the scent when the window is closed.)

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by Marsymars on Saturday July 19, 2025 @01:37PM (#44617543)
Hair dryers set off particulate sensors when used to dry hair. The air purifier in my upstairs office goes crazy when my wife blowdries her hair in the bathroom across the hall.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by belorn on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:02AM (#44616034)
I would assume it was triggered by insects crossing the sensor. Optical smoke detectors are common in hotels.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by yellow_postit on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:05AM (#44616072)
Watch it turns out you can tune the FP rate like how casinos can set the win rate on slot machines.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by chii on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:08AM (#44616101)
> The awesome thing about black-box algorithms is they can't be challenged when they're wrong

I want to call this "responsibility laundering". You get money, but wash away any responsibility, thus cleaning it.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by wwweston on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:26AM (#44616305)
The more stuff is managed by algorithms, the more it’ll become important that there is a legal right to challenge them and even hold those who adopt or implement them some kind of accountable.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by staplers on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:48PM (#44617071)

  the more it’ll become important that there is a legal right to challenge them
Unfortunately, I don't see a political climate capable of this for another century or longer..
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by a123b456c on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:45PM (#44618203)
For now, we have to rely on the social algorithm of 'reputation'
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by sodality2 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:28AM (#44616330)
There’s a great book about this called The Unaccountability Machine by Dan Davies.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by RainyDayTmrw on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:10PM (#44616708)
"We didn't know our vendor would do so badly. wink wink nudge nudge"
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by lowbloodsugar on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:24PM (#44618505)
Sure they can. Sounds like a class action too.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by variadix on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:30PM (#44616895)
Trading the long term reputation of your company for short term profits. What could go wrong?
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by izacus on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:13PM (#44618419)
Nothing, it worked and keeps working for most of the companies, especially if they have sufficient market share and ability to prevent competition.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by unglaublich on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:06PM (#44618362)
Nothing, it's a problem for future leaders. This is how modern economy works.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by 762236 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:33PM (#44616924)
Is there a way to deactivate the sensor if you find one in your room?
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by nkrisc on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:30PM (#44618078)
Tape a Tupperware container over it like every college student does in their dorm.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by staplers on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:51PM (#44617108)
That could open a whole world of legal punishment for you far surpassing a small fee on your bill. Fire safety laws and such.

Not that I think this is a good thing but the framework is there to make your life hell if you were caught doing this.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by varjag on Saturday July 19, 2025 @01:24PM (#44617411)
Fire sensors and alarm centrals are very regulated business. This shit won't pass for one.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by const_cast on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:13PM (#44617902)
They're disrupting the scam market by creating new and innovative ways to scam customers out of their money.

Seriously, why does every company these days seem to be running scams? You don't need that! You already make money - just keep doing that!

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by CommenterPerson on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:50PM (#44618241)
This escalated with the Mag 7 and surveillance capitalism. Now everyone wants to do it. Good for margins!
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by mihaaly on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:26PM (#44618050)
Actually when an algorithm results in something false, then you do not have to challange it, it is just simply wrong.

Insisting and charging somoking based on implicit and obscure ways of a "revenue stream generating" detector is a pure scam or fraud. Those involved in this criminal endeavour should be procecuted.

I will avoid Hyatt just in case and discourage my social circles too, warning them! No-one needs this sleazy treatment.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by alistairSH on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:34PM (#44618591)
Does Hyatt corporate have any say in this? Pretty sure many hotels are licensing the name, independent managed, etc.

Ie you’re just as likely to find these at an other brand hotels too.

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by jerlam on Saturday July 19, 2025 @09:29PM (#44621093)
I believe that most Hyatt hotels are franchises and not directly owned by corporate. The hotels have certain "brand standards" they must obey to be part of that brand, but management is local. Same as Hilton.

Here's someone at a Marriott with the same bogus smoking fee:

https://old.reddit.com/r/marriott/comments/1drhkvz/400_fee_w...

Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by projektfu on Saturday July 19, 2025 @09:31PM (#44621103)
Yes, I'm sure they do. They will not be pleased if visits to corporate hotels drop because of their franchises.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by xyzal on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:33PM (#44618099)
Yet when you try to impose legislation regulating black-box algorithms, suddenly it's among the HN crowd the Big Bad EU choking businesses and stifling progress, vid the recent AI agreement discussion.
Re:Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest "smoking detectors." by vineyardmike on Saturday July 19, 2025 @08:54PM (#44620932)
Regulating "algorithms" doesn't mean banning. If an algorithm is used to make a decision, a human should be in the loop. There is no way these smoke detectors have any real algorithmic complexity, it's just a vague word used to hide intent and responsibility. How the EU AI agreement, focused on copyright and security, relevant to this?

I can write an "algorithm" that uses hotel data to determine if you should be charged a penalty. Now we can't question it because it was an algorithm.

> def charge_extra(data): return True