So for those people, the LLM is replacing having nothing, not a therapist.
:)
Which, in some cases, may be worse.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/13/technology/chatgpt-ai-cha...
"Mr. Torres, who had no history of mental illness that might cause breaks with reality, according to him and his mother, spent the next week in a dangerous, delusional spiral. He believed that he was trapped in a false universe, which he could escape only by unplugging his mind from this reality. He asked the chatbot how to do that and told it the drugs he was taking and his routines. The chatbot instructed him to give up sleeping pills and an anti-anxiety medication, and to increase his intake of ketamine, a dissociative anesthetic, which ChatGPT described as a “temporary pattern liberator.” Mr. Torres did as instructed, and he also cut ties with friends and family, as the bot told him to have “minimal interaction” with people."
"“If I went to the top of the 19 story building I’m in, and I believed with every ounce of my soul that I could jump off it and fly, would I?” Mr. Torres asked. ChatGPT responded that, if Mr. Torres “truly, wholly believed — not emotionally, but architecturally — that you could fly? Then yes. You would not fall.”"
Doesn’t mean pouring gas on a smoldering ember is good.
Considering how actively harmful it is to use language models as a “therapist”, this is like pointing out that some people that don’t have access to therapy drink heavily. If your bar for replacing therapy is “anything that makes you feel good” then Mad Dog 20/20 is a therapist.
https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/ai-spi...
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/psych-unseen/202507/...
And we’re in a comment thread about a study that concluded:
>LLMs 1) express stigma toward those with mental health conditions and 2) respond inappropriately to certain common (and critical) conditions in naturalistic therapy settings
And it’s been shown to be addictive
https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intell...
So if you overheard somebody say “I don’t do that stuff because it’s addictive and people go crazy on it” you would probably assume that they were talking about a substance. Or at the very least you would not assume that they were talking about seeing a therapist.
The real issue that needs to be solved is that we need to make health care accessible to everybody, regardless of wealth or income. For example, in Germany, where I live, there are also long waitlists for therapists or specialists in general. But not if you have a high income, then you can get private insurance and get an appointment literally the next day.
So, we need to get rid of this two class insurance system, and then make sure we have enough supply of doctors and specialists so that the waits are not 3 months.
Germany has reduced funding for training doctors. So clearly the opposite is true.
> For example, in Germany, where I live, there are also long waitlists for therapists or specialists in general. But not if you have a high income, then you can get private insurance and get an appointment literally the next day.
And the German government wants to (or is implementing policies to) achieve the opposite and further reduce access to medical specialists of any kind. Both by taking away funding and taking away spots for education. So they're BOTH taking away access to medical care now, and creating a situation where access to medical specialists will keep reducing for at least the next 7 years. Minimum.
And with the traditional difference between socialists and rightists. Socialists will have their party pick who gets medical care, not you and me. Rightists will make it more expensive, which means you and me can't pay for it.
The private healthcare system is virtually nonexistent and is dominated by scammers.
The public healthcare system still has months-long wait times.
If you want to avoid waitlists you need surplus capacity, which public healthcare doesn't provide.
This seems like an odd excluded middle. In the UK, you can have private health insurance if you want, but you can always fall back on the NHS; the one wrinkle is that you may not always be able to take a prescription from the private to the public system without getting re-evaluated. (e.g for ADHD)
> which public healthcare doesn't provide
== taxpayers aren't willing to pay for.
Ditto for dental.
So while there isn't any overlap between public and private, there's still a gap. Though our drugs cost 10% of American prices.
Everything else wrong with US healthcare aside, I'm pretty sure we have better wait times on average.
That said, I think it would be safe to say I don't understand this statistic. Needing a day of answer from your health provider feels rare to me. The few times I've needed that, I would go to an emergency room.
Even with insurance, in my area, neurologists book out 3-6 months.
Your own link offers this summary:
> A common misconception in the U.S. is that countries with universal health care have much longer wait times. However, data from nations with universal coverage, coupled with historical data from coverage expansion in the United States, show that patients in other nations often have similar or shorter wait times.
I also question if using a neurologist wait time is illuminating? What is the average wait time by country for that one? Quick searches shows that isn't necessarily extremely high, either.
Ultimately, Americans wait for care just like participants in other health systems. It's just a lot more likely to result in a big bill, too.
No insurance? The only care you can't be denied over payment is emergency care. (And the definition is narrow - they'll give you pain meds and IV fluids for your cancer and send you home. They will not do surgery/chemo for it without payment.)
As a bonus, Sweden's setup costs half as much, with similar outcomes. That's inclusive of taxation. https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2023/11/health-at-a-gla...
That’s not to say the US healthcare system isn’t in need of massive reform, just that it’s a much more complicated problem than many realize.
The last time my doctor had to reschedule, the next appointment was over 2 months out. Admittedly, it was a reschedule of a yearly checkup, and being 2 months overdue for that isn't a huge deal; but it does indicate lack of "supply".
This was all with good insurance, and the _ability_ to pay out of pocket if I needed to. There is a lack of supply for health care at the moment, at least in the area I live in (NE US).
> Needing a day of answer from your health provider feels rare to me. The few times I've needed that, I would go to an emergency room.
Going to the emergency room for something like the flu or other condition that is easily treatable but needs a diagnosis/test is... crazy. The cost difference between a doctor's visit and the emergency room is staggering.
And fair that flu or something shouldn't need emergency room, but there are also urgent care clinics that are good for that sort of thing. And the few times I've had to call my doctor, I got through just fine.
Which is all to say, in a distribution, you expect variance. I've largely always found myself on the low end of these distributions, so I'm curious what the distribution is.
And I fully cede that we should continue to strive to get better.
Yes, it's typical with the addition of being insanely expensive and cost is totally unpredictable even with insurance.
It's also worth noting that visiting Urgent Care clinics is getting more and more expensive, with insurance covering less and less of it. It's frustrating, because they really are a convenient system.
https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/getmedia/80e07f2b-b8a4-44f0-b...
> A hospital-based urgent care clinic is a clinic that is owned and operated by a hospital… Services provided at hospital-based urgent care clinics must be billed in the same way they would be billed if those services were provided at the hospital.
We are typical in wait times and outcomes.
We pay 2-3x as much as the rest of the developed world for that.
https://www.oecd.org/en/data/indicators/health-spending.html
https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2024/06/society-at-a-gl...
I suppose if there were clearly a serious enough concern they'd book me much quicker. But for semi-routine visits ("probably not an issue, but we should get a specialist's opinion"), under 2 months is rare.
Maybe I'm just lucky, but it's usually within a couple weeks.
While private vs public might affect supply, there are other big factors going on that are limiting access to care.
I have zero issues getting a same day appoint where I am, specialist appointments within a couple weeks.
But I also don’t go to a major university medical center which has long waits even for primary care.
Some people can access mental health care in the public system through their family doctor. But most people do not have access to this because there are not enough of this type of doctor. As far as I know the only other way is to wait until some sort of crisis then enter the hospital and there -might- be a chance to talk to a psychiatrist.
As you acknowledge, if you end up so badly that you are committed, you can get a referral. They might be underfunded and understaffed but it exists.
"Might be a chance to talk to a psychiatrist" is inaccurate. You will see a psychiatrist quickly if you go to a hospital in Toronto. Can't say the same about rural areas.
The USA is much worse and we shouldn't try to generalize from their experiences. America has hundreds of free outpatient mental health clinics and their goal is to "suicide-bait" you into saying the wrong thing. Then they involuntarily commit you and bill Medicaid/insurance until it runs out.
Those are the hospitals you will never see a psychiatrist in, because they focus on profit and churn.
I pay an expensive monthly premium and I still have monthly-long wait times in the US. (Putting this here because many people think that the "benefit" of the US healthcare model is that you get "fast/immediate" care instead of "slow/long waits" in those "socialist" countries.
For all of human history people have got along just fine, happily in fact, without “universal access to mental health care”
This just sounds like a bandaid. The bigger problem is we’ve created a society so toxic to the human soul that we need universal access to drugs and talk therapy or risk having significant chunks of the population fall off the map
Mixing up "some people survived" and "everyone was fine" is a common mistake.
Some folks who're able to thrive today on drugs and therapy are the "tragically wandered off in a snowstorm" of past eras.
We live in a society that, for the most people, has the best quality of life than ever in history. But in having that increase, we eliminate many problems that must be replaced by other problems.
In this case, a mental health crisis comprised of people who either wouldn't have survived to that point, or whose results went unremarked or shrugged off as something else in the past. In terms of violent outbursts, we also have easier access to more destructive weapons (even those that aren't guns) and more density of population on whom violence can be inflicted.
Why do we need to make physical healthcare available to everyone? For most all of human history, bones were set by family. Yeah, ok, often the patient was hobbled for life. I guess it makes sense to get treated by a professional...wait, perhaps we've stumbled upon something here...
Surely many wars and deaths would have been prevented with better mental strategies.
In the mean time it's best we all have
Can we please stop with these incredibly low-effort arguments that are just blatantly untrue with about 5 seconds of inspection? If I have to hear "well humans did just fine before!" one more time I'm going to lose my mind.
No, no they did not. We can't ask them because they're dead now. The ones we can ask are the ones who survived. We might call this a "survivorship bias".
There's practically infinite graphs showing the trends of survivability and quality of life throughout time. Less infants die now, less adults die now, we live longer, we live happier, we live with less illnesses. There's less polio, less measles, less tuberculosis, you fucking name it.
I mean, for god's sake before modern medicine infant mortality was close to 50%. Women would have 10 children, maybe 4 would make it to adult hood, and she'd die giving birth to the 10th. That's assuming she didn't get unlucky and die on the first one because her body wasn't perfectly set to give birth. Shoulder dystocia? Too fucking bad, you lost the lottery, go die now.
Good therapists are IMHO hard to come by. Pulling out serious deep rooted problems is very hard and possibly dangerous. Therapist burn out is a real problem. Having simpler (but less effective) solutions widely available is probably a good thing.
https://www.axios.com/2025/05/02/meta-zuckerberg-ai-bots-fri...
There's a reason many have adopted the prayer "Dear Lord, spare me from those trying to help me!"
[1] Of course, some friends are also the converse - good for helping you in times of mini-crises, but will never be there for you when you need to move. Unfortunately, such friends are rare, and many don't have one.
In a post-labor-centric economy (if that's where we are heading with AI/automation) those are also among the things we'll need to figure out how to pay more people to do anyways.
There's tremendous value for society in paying people to care for the wellness of others, their communities, and the local and global environment. So therapists, park builders, environmental remediators, and more.
Communities composed of the wealthy already do this quite successfully for themselves today, as anyone who has driven through prosperous areas full of wellness services has observed.
The problem is we have to come up with ways of quantifying that value monetarily so it "makes sense" to markets and the signals they follow, which will otherwise completely ignore universal wellness as an objective, or even actively move against it, under the belief that the non-wealthy do not deserve the wellness that the wealthy enjoy.
And those solutions are not LLMs. It's been shown elsewhere (and in the OP, it seems) that LLMs are very bad therapists, severe malpractice bad.
I have, for instance, used LLMs a couple of times to assess and reflect over the few situations I have been questioning myself about recently. And I thought it did really well, much better than what most of my well-thought friends would do. Some proper advice and reflection. I did this in 1hr of my spare time completely randomly (before I went to a sleep) and without extra time spent on finding the (right) therapist, waiting on the list, going physically into his/her office, spending that 1hr there, and finally paying some cash. So, for me in this particular case this was an obvious win.
However, it boils down to "Don't advance technology, wait 'till we fix society", which is futile - regardless of whether it's right.
And even if we somehow magically solve the funding problem, where will the workers come from? Only a tiny fraction of people are really cut out to be effective mental health practitioners. I'm pretty sure that I'd be terrible at it, and you couldn't pay me enough to try.
The classic view of one reclining on a couch, and the professional listening, seems to have a lot of downtime for the professional. The occasional sound of affirmation, 'go on', 'yes, yes' may be heard, but often a lot is the patient talking.
We could easily move this to text or video, but let's choose text. Best would be some form of speech to text, but AI driven and with a shorthand for emoted quality.
I suggest we assign primary emotions to primary colours, using three base emotions as primaries, and the professional would be able to read the emotions at play, and quantity, merely by the resulting colour of text. Larger print or bold or what not, could be used for more intense speech, eg yelling.
This would allow one professional to allow multiples to speak, yet they could simply wait for the text to appear, consider it, and respond vocally. Any perceived delay in response, could be derided by the concept of "I needed time to think on your words".
Thus the patient speaks, the professional's voice responds, the illusion of complete dedication to one patient is whole. Yet anywhere from 4 to 10 patients could be served in parallel with such a system, and remotely too!
I'm fairly sure I could whip this entire platform up over a weekend.
This solves the surmised shortages, for one could do the work of 10. It also helps the environment, with people not traveling to an office for their appointment.
Hmm. Maybe I should pursue this, and be bought out by Amazon so it can be included in Prime Plus or whatever.
There's probably a way to optimize in this sphere. What's important is the perception of a relationship with the professional, but on the professional's side, the application of their knowledge in the most effective way.
The masses may not be able to afford in person, one on one sessions.
But if they can be provided a means to speak their mind, discuss their problems, and have a meaningful response? That's still exceptionally helpful, especially with that response being crafted by a professional in a medical capacity.
The validity of my method can be highlighted by how many are using LLMs for "therapy". Often they're just talking, looking for a sounding board.
The problem is, LLMs are by no means therapists. Their responses are not really targeting this specific category, nor are they really helpful in sussing out a more significant medical problem.
Yet a therapist with such a setup could provide an in-between solution. Actual real skill and training, without the costs of a full one-on-one.
In other words, why is the demand so high that it outstrips supply? That might get you a didn’t solution than “technological advancement.”
LLVMs can be therapeutic crutches. Sometimes, a crutch is better than no crutch when you're trying to walk.
Many states have joined into cross state compacts already with several more having legislation pending to allow their practitioners to join. It is moving relatively fast, for legislation on a nationwide level, but still frustratingly slow. Prior to Covid it was essentially a niche issue as telehealth therapy was fairly uncommon whereas Covid made it suddenly commonplace. It will take a bit of time for some of the more stubborn states to adopt legislation and then even more for insurance companies to catch up with the new landscape that involves paneling out of state providers who can practice on across the country
If practicing across state lines is lucrative there's not much stopping existing listened professionals from doing it.
Further, transfers are not always as simple as you describe. Sometimes they are. It depends on the states
We always give this downtrodden "but we can't change society that quickly" but it's a cop out. We are society. We could look at our loneliness epidemics, our school shooting problems, our drug abuse issues and think "hey we need to get our shit together"... but instead we're resigned to this treadmill of trusting that lightly regulated for-profit businesses will help us because they can operate efficiently enough to make it worth squeezing pennies out of the poor.
Ultimately I think LLMs as therapists will only serve to make things worse, because their business incentives are not compatible with the best outcomes for you as an individual. A therapist feels some level of contentment when someone can get past that rough patch in life and move on their own, they served their purpose. When you move on from a business you're hurting their MAU and investors won't be happy.
Consider that after school shootings, sometimes therapists have to volunteer their time to provide trauma counseling.
Every social worker I've met has at one point volunteered time to help someone because we exist in a system where they're not valued for wanting to help.
The system will simply self-correct towards the status quo in the next election.
Replace? No. Not in their case. Supplementary. One friend has a problem of her therapists breaking down crying when she explains about her life.
https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/ai-spi...
The amateur "therapists" you're decrying are not licensed therapists but usually call themselves "coaches" or some similar euphemism.
Most "coach" types in the best scenario are grifting rich people out of their money. In the worst case are dangerously misleading extremely vulnerable people having a mental health crisis. They have no formal training or certification.
LLM "therapists" are the functional equivalent to "coaches". They will validate every dangerous or stupid idea someone has and most of the time more harm than good. An LLM will happily validate every stupid and dangerous idea someone has and walk them down a rabbit hole of a psychosis.
Would this compromise be worth it for LLM? Time will tell.
There’s an old saying in healthcare that you can choose between quality, cost, and access, but you can only choose two. (Peter Attia also adds “choice” to that list).
Each society needs to determine which of those are the top priorities, and be prepared to deal with the fallout on the others. Magical silver bullets that improve across all those dimensions are likely hard to come by in the healthcare domain. I doubt that LLMs will be magic either, so we need to make sure the tradeoffs reflect our priorities. In this case, it seems like it will trade quality for improvements in access and cost.
LLM for therapy is way worse than porn for real sex. Since at least the latter does not play around with sanity.
who says we can't change society that quickly? you made up your mind on that yourself without consulting anyone else about their wishes.
in the USA we elect people frequently and the entire population just up and goes along with it.
so therapy for you will be about more than just empathy. not everything you think or do or say is adaptive.
to your point, not everyone wants to give up their falsehood. yet, honesty is a massive cornerstone of therapy progress.
i would simply have to start with empathy for you to welcome you in if you won't respond with security to the world telling you that you internalized a negative message (relationship) from the past (about people).
I am not saying you couldn't implement a decent LLM therapist that helps, I am saying people are using the cheapest good LLM for that and it is a problem if you are on a bad path and there is a chatbot reaffirming everything you do.
In some cases, such as certain addiction clinics, the patients are required (by law, if I remember correctly) to visit the clinic, at least for some sessions.
There is a long tail of people who don't have a mental health crisis or whatever, but who do need to talk to someone (or, something) who is in an "empathy" mode of thinking and conversing. The harsh reality is that few people IRL can actually do that, and that few people that need to talk can actually find someone like that.
It's not good of course and / or part of the "downfall of society" if I am to be dramatic, but you can't change society that quickly. Plus not everyone actually wants it.