News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by RHSeeger on Monday July 07, 2025 @10:46AM (#44490931)
When I was looking for a new Primary Care physician, the first appointment I could get was for 6 months out. I wound up being able to solve the problem with a video call, but that only worked because of the specific situation.

The last time my doctor had to reschedule, the next appointment was over 2 months out. Admittedly, it was a reschedule of a yearly checkup, and being 2 months overdue for that isn't a huge deal; but it does indicate lack of "supply".

This was all with good insurance, and the _ability_ to pay out of pocket if I needed to. There is a lack of supply for health care at the moment, at least in the area I live in (NE US).

> Needing a day of answer from your health provider feels rare to me. The few times I've needed that, I would go to an emergency room.

Going to the emergency room for something like the flu or other condition that is easily treatable but needs a diagnosis/test is... crazy. The cost difference between a doctor's visit and the emergency room is staggering.

Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by taeric on Monday July 07, 2025 @10:52AM (#44491003)
My question was to ask if we are really that much different than other places? Because, I've heard anecdotes of similar situations from everywhere. And, indeed, the link I posted calls out that the US is basically typical for most things.

And fair that flu or something shouldn't need emergency room, but there are also urgent care clinics that are good for that sort of thing. And the few times I've had to call my doctor, I got through just fine.

Which is all to say, in a distribution, you expect variance. I've largely always found myself on the low end of these distributions, so I'm curious what the distribution is.

And I fully cede that we should continue to strive to get better.

Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by vjvjvjvjghv on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:06PM (#44491757)
"My question was to ask if we are really that much different than other places? Because, I've heard anecdotes of similar situations from everywhere. And, indeed, the link I posted calls out that the US is basically typical for most things."

Yes, it's typical with the addition of being insanely expensive and cost is totally unpredictable even with insurance.

Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by Projectiboga on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:06PM (#44491759)
We have been restricting the supply of medical professionals in the USA since after WW2. Our medical schools have been keeping supply lean by being below what our population needs.
Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by RHSeeger on Monday July 07, 2025 @11:11AM (#44491215)
> there are also urgent care clinics that are good for that sort of thing

It's also worth noting that visiting Urgent Care clinics is getting more and more expensive, with insurance covering less and less of it. It's frustrating, because they really are a convenient system.

Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by ryandrake on Monday July 07, 2025 @02:00PM (#44493019)
It's too bad, because Urgent Care is your only option if you're still waiting for your "new patient appointment" with a primary care doc. I was in the same boat as GP poster, where new patient appointments were 6 months in the future, so we just went to Urgent Care for everything in the meantime. Of course, after 6 months, we found out the doctor was retiring and not taking any more new patients, so we had to wait another 6 months for the next primary care doctor on the list. An entire year of waiting, just to get a primary care doctor, in the non-socialized-medicine USA.
Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by ceejayoz on Monday July 07, 2025 @04:03PM (#44494119)
Fun fact: Urgent cares owned by hospital chains can be substantially pricier, too. In my area:

https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/getmedia/80e07f2b-b8a4-44f0-b...

> A hospital-based urgent care clinic is a clinic that is owned and operated by a hospital… Services provided at hospital-based urgent care clinics must be billed in the same way they would be billed if those services were provided at the hospital.

Re:LLMs should not replace therapists by ceejayoz on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:19PM (#44491888)
> And, indeed, the link I posted calls out that the US is basically typical for most things.

We are typical in wait times and outcomes.

We pay 2-3x as much as the rest of the developed world for that.

https://www.oecd.org/en/data/indicators/health-spending.html

https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2024/06/society-at-a-gl...