News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by darth_avocado on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:37AM (#44136662)
I don’t understand how any business leader can be excited about humans being replaced by AI. If no one has a job, who’s going to buy your stuff? When the unemployment in the country goes up, consumer spending slows down and recession kicks in. How could you be excited for that?
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ben_w on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:44AM (#44136721)
Game theory/Nash equilibrium/Prisoner's Dilemma, and the turkey's perspective in the problem of induction.

So far, for any given automation, each actor gets to cut their own costs to their benefit — and if they do this smarter than anyone else, they win the market for a bit.

Every day the turkey lives, they get a bit more evidence the farmer is an endless source of free food that only wants the best for them.

It's easy to fool oneself that the economics are eternal with reference to e.g. Jevons paradox.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:12AM (#44137020)
> turkey's perspective in the problem of induction…

Had to look that up: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turkey_illusion

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by abracadaniel on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:13AM (#44137027)
My long term fear with AI is that by replacing entry level jobs, it breaks the path to train senior level employees. It could take a couple of decades to really feel the heat from it, but could lead to massive collapse as no one is left with any understanding of how existing systems work, or how to design replacements.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by pseudo0 on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:41AM (#44137327)
Juniors and offshore teams will probably be the most severely impacted. If a senior dev is already breaking off smaller tightly scoped tasks and fixing up the results, that loop can be accomplished much more quickly by iterating with a LLM. Especially if you have to wait a business day for someone in India to even start on the task when a LLM is spitting out a similar quality PR in minutes.

Ironically a friend of mine noticed that the team in India they work with is now largely pushing AI-generated code... At that point you just need management to cut out the middleman.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by teitoklien on Friday May 30, 2025 @04:47PM (#44139737)
lol, what it’s soon going to lead to is unfortunately the very opposite of what you’re thinking.

Management will cut down your team’s headcount and outsource even more to India ,Vietnam and Philippines.

A CFO looks at balance sheet not operations context, even if you’re idea is better the opposite of what you think is likely going to happen very soon.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by dagw on Saturday May 31, 2025 @06:52AM (#44143396)
Management will cut down your team’s headcount and outsource even more to India ,Vietnam and Philippines

Management did all that at companies I've worked for for years before 'AI'. The big change is that the teams in India won't 200 developers, but 20 developers handholding an AI.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by lurkshark on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:54AM (#44137474)
I’m actually worried we’ve gotten a kickstart on that process already. Anecdotally it seems like entry level developer jobs are harder to come by today than a decade ago. Without the free-money growth we were seeing for a long time it seems like companies are more incentivized to only hire senior developers at the loss of the greater good that comes with hiring and mentoring junior developers.

Caveat that this is anecdotal, not sure if there are numbers on this.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by cjs_ac on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:58AM (#44137518)
This isn't AI-specific, though; businesses decided that it was everyone else's responsibility to train their employees over a decade ago.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:06PM (#44139883)
If it takes a few decades, they may actually automate all but the most impressive among senior positions though.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by socalgal2 on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:21PM (#44139990)
I agree with your worry.

That said, the first thing that jumps to my mind is cars. Back when they were first introduced you had to be a mechanically inclined person to own one and deal with it. Today, people just buy them and hire the very small number of experts (relative to the population of drivers) to deal with any issues. Same with smartphones. The majority of users have no idea how they really work. If it stop working they seek out an expert.

ATM, AI just seems like another level of that. JS/Python programmers don't need to know bits and bytes and memory allocation. Vibe coders won't need to know what JS/Python programmers need to know.

Maybe there won't be enough experts to keep it all going though.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by scarlehoff on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:53PM (#44140209)
This is what I fear as well: some companies might adopt a "sustainable" approach to AI, but others will dynamite the entry path to their companies. Of course, if your only goal is to sell a unicorn and be out after three years, who cares... but serious companies with lifelong employees that adopt the AI-first strategy are in for a surprise (looking at you, Microsoft).
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by xp84 on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:57PM (#44140236)
> It could take a couple of decades to really feel the heat from it, but could lead to massive collapse

When you consider how this interacts with the population collapse (which is inevitable now everywhere outside of some African countries) this seems even worse. In 20 years, we will have far fewer people under age 60 than we have now, and among that smaller cohort, the percentage of people at any given age who have useful levels of experience will be less because they may not be able to even begin meaningful careers.

Best case scenario, people who have gotten 5 or more years of experience by now (college grads of 2020) may scrape by indefinitely. They'll be about 47 then and have no one to hire that's more qualified than AI. Not necessarily because AI is so great; rather, how will there be someone with 20 years of experience when we simply don't hire any junior people this year?

Worst case, AI overtakes the Class of 2020 and moves up the experience-equivalence ladder faster than 1 year per year, so it starts taking out the classes of 2015, 2010, etc.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by baby_souffle on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:07PM (#44141394)
> Worst case, AI overtakes the Class of 2020 and moves up the experience-equivalence ladder faster than 1 year per year, so it starts taking out the classes of 2015, 2010, etc.

This is my bet. Similar to Moores law. Where it plateaus is anybody’s guess…

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by Nasrudith on Saturday May 31, 2025 @01:28AM (#44142041)
The worst case for such a cycle is generating new jobs in reverse engineers. Although in practice with what we have seen with machinists it tends to just accelerate existing trends towards outsourcing to countries who haven't had the 'entry level collapse'.

We've already eliminated certain junior level domains essentially by design. There aren't any 'barber-surgeons' with only two years of training for good reason. Instead we have surgery integrated it into a more lengthy and complicated educational path to become what we now would consider a 'proper' surgeon.

I think the answer is that if the 'junior' is uneconomical or otherwise unacceptable be prepared to pay more for the alternative, one way or another.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by Traubenfuchs on Saturday May 31, 2025 @06:47AM (#44143373)
As a senior software engineer code monkey this is my greatest hope!
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by asah on Sunday June 01, 2025 @05:48AM (#44149730)
I've heard this fear for decades about COBOL programmers, and yet I don't see this bubbling up except higher costs.

If there's a shortage, in the free market, humans will retrain.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by spacemadness on Friday May 30, 2025 @12:35PM (#44137862)
And we as humans figured all this out and still do nothing with this knowledge. We fight as hard as we can against collective wisdom.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by absurdo on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:46PM (#44141519)
Basically if anyone has an iota of sensibility you should have never taken sama, Zuckerberg, Gates, or anyone else of that sort at face value. When they tell you they’re doing things for the good of humanity, look at what the other hand is up to.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by antithesizer on Saturday May 31, 2025 @08:52PM (#44147927)
>or anyone else of that sort

This category is expansive enough to make fools of almost everyone on hn.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by anvandare on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:01AM (#44136914)
A cancerous cell does not care that it is (indirectly) killing the lifeform that it is a part of. It just does what it does without a thought.

And if it could think, it would probably be very proud of the quarter (hour) figures that it could present. The Number has gone up, time for a reward.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by untrust on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:53AM (#44136832)
Another question: If AI is going to eat up everyone's jobs, how will any business be safe from a new competitor showing up and unseating them off their throne? I don't think that the low level peons would be the only ones at stake as a company could be easily outcompeted as well since AI could conceivably outperform or replace any existing product anyways.

I guess funding for processing power and physical machinery to run the AI backing a product would be the biggest barrier to entry?

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by layer8 on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:56AM (#44136869)
Institutional knowledge is key here. Third parties can’t replicate it quickly just by using AI.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by lubujackson on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:01AM (#44136910)
Luckily we are firing all those people so they will be available for new roles.

This feels a lot like the dot boom/dot bust era where a lot of new companies are going to sprout up from the ashes of all this disruption.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by floatrock on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:04AM (#44136949)
Also: network effects, inertia, cornering the market enough to make incumbents uneconomical, regulatory capture...

AI certainly will increase competition in some areas, but there are countless examples where being the best at something doesn't make you the leader.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by zhobbs on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:02AM (#44136920)
Yeah this will likely lead to margin compression. The best companies will be fine though, as brand and existing distribution is a huge moat.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by azemetre on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:39AM (#44137296)
“Best” is carrying a lot of wait. More accurate to say the monopolistic companies that engage in regulatory capture will be fine.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by jrs235 on Friday May 30, 2025 @04:35PM (#44139647)
Empowering the current US President to demand more bribes.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:19AM (#44137102)
The beginning of the AI Wars?
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by thmsths on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:40AM (#44136690)
Tragedy of the commons: no one being able to buy stuff is a problem for everyone, but being able to save just a bit more by getting rid of your workforce is a huge advantage for your business.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by bckr on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:18AM (#44137079)
“tragedy of the commons” is treated as a Theory of Human Nature when it’s really a religious principle underlying how we operate our society.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by Jensson on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:54PM (#44141103)
People hunted large mammals to extinction long before modern society, so tragedy of the commons is nature in general. We know other predators do it as well, not just humans.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:13AM (#44137034)
… in the interim, of course.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by FeteCommuniste on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:40AM (#44136681)
I guess the idea is that the people left working will be made so productive and wealthy thanks to the miracle of AI that they can more than make up the difference with extravagant consumption.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by isoprophlex on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:44AM (#44136718)
I too plan to buy 100.000 liters of yogurt each day once AI has transported me into the socioeconomic strata of the 0.1%
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by FeteCommuniste on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:51AM (#44136808)
My many robots will be busy building glorious mansions out of yogurt cups.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by Terr_ on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:22PM (#44139994)
Or, as per a Love, Death, and Robots short film, the new superintelligence will be inextricable from yogurt...
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by darth_avocado on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:46AM (#44136746)
If you want to see what that looks like, just look at the economy of India. Do we really want that?
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:22AM (#44137124)
I'd been thinking modern day Russia, but I admit to being ignorant of a lot of countries outside the U.S.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by FeteCommuniste on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:49AM (#44136789)
Certainly not what I want, but it looks like we could be headed there. And the "industry leaders" seem cool with it, to judge by their politics.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by munksbeer on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:50AM (#44136801)
The economy of India is trending in the opposite direction to this narrative. More and more people lifted out of poverty as they modernise.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by darth_avocado on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:57AM (#44136876)
The comment wasn’t on the trend or where things are going and the historical progress the country has made. The comment was on the current state of the economy. The fact that wealth concentration creates its own unique challenges. If as many people were unemployed and in poverty (or in the low income bracket) in the US or any other developed nation, the living conditions would have been drastically deteriorated. The consumer market would have shrunk to the point where most people couldn’t afford to buy chips and soda.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by munksbeer on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:30AM (#44137203)
The point is, I don't see that happening. The reverse is happening in the world. The percentage of people in poverty globally is decreasing each year.

I still fail to see why people think we're going to innovate ourselves into global poverty, it makes no sense.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by darth_avocado on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:49AM (#44137417)
Poverty is decreasing because innovation is creating more jobs. Everything hinges on the fact that people can earn a living and spend their money to generate more jobs. If AI replaces those jobs you’re going the other way.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by const_cast on Friday May 30, 2025 @01:38PM (#44138375)
Right, every economic system we've thought up relies on the assumption that everyone works. Or, close to everyone. Capitalism is just as much about consumption as it is production.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:35PM (#44140431)
Close to everyone doesn't work today. The labor force participation rate is only about 62%.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by const_cast on Saturday May 31, 2025 @06:18PM (#44147322)
Labor force participation rate has increased pretty drastically since 1950. I'd imagine due to better medicine and treatments that allow people to work when they otherwise wouldn't.

But, 62% is very high. Keep in mind that number takes into account not only the elderly and disable, but also children.

Pretty much everyone who can work is working. We don't want children to be working, that's bad. We should all be on the same page about that.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by al_borland on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:04AM (#44136944)
A single rich person can only much door dash. Scaling a customer base needs to be done horizontally.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:43AM (#44136714)
> If no one has a job, who’s going to buy your stuff?

All the people employed by the government and blue collar workers? All the entrepreneurs, gig workers, black market workers, etc?

It's easy to imagine a world in which there are way less white collar workers and everything else is pretty much the same.

It's also easy to imagine a world in which you sell less stuff but your margins increase, and overall you're better off, even if everybody else has less widgets.

It's also easy to imagine a world in which you're able to cut more workers than everyone else, and on aggregate, barely anyone is impacted, but your margins go up.

There's tons of other scenarios, including the most cited one - that technology thus far has always led to more jobs, not less.

They're probably believing any combination of these concepts.

It's not guaranteed that if there's 5% less white-collar workers per year for a few decades that we're all going to starve to death.

In the future, if trends continue, there's going to be way less workers - since there's going to be a huge portion of the population that's old and retired.

You can lose x% of the work force every year and keep unemployment stable...

A large portion of the population wants a lot more people to be able to not work and get entitlements...

It's pretty easy to see how a lot of people can think this could lead to something good, even if you think all those things are bad.

Two people can see the same painting in a museum, one finds it beautiful, and the other finds it completely uninteresting.

It's almost like asking - how can someone want the Red team to win when I want the Blue team to win?

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by neutronicus on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:37AM (#44137276)
There are also blue- and pink-collar industries that we all tacitly agree are crazy understaffed right now because of brutal work conditions and low pay (health care, child care, K-12, elder care), with low quality-of-service a concern across the board, and with many job functions that seem very difficult to replace with AI (assuming liability for preventing children and elderly adults from physically injuring themselves and others).

If you, a CEO, eliminate a bunch of white-collar workers, presumably you drive your former employees into all these jobs they weren't willing to do before, and hey, you make more profits, your kids and aging parents are better-taken-care-of.

Seems like winning in the fundamental game of society - maneuvering everyone else into being your domestic servants.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by const_cast on Friday May 30, 2025 @01:31PM (#44138320)
Right, but the elephant in the room is that despite those industries being constantly understaffed and labor being in extreme demand, they're underpaid. It seems nobody gives a flying fuck about the free market when it comes to the labor market, which is arguably the most important market.

So, flooding those industries with more warm bodies probably won't help anything. I imagine it would make the already fucked labor relations even more fucked.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by neutronicus on Friday May 30, 2025 @04:23PM (#44139573)
It would be bad for compensation in the field(s) but the actual working conditions might improve, just by dint of having enough people to do all the work expected.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by darth_avocado on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:52AM (#44136824)
> All the people employed by the government and blue collar workers

If people don’t have jobs, government doesn’t have taxes to employ other people. If CEOs are salivating at the thought of replacing white collar workers, there is no reason to think next step of AI augmented with robotics won’t replace blue collar workers as well.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by trealira on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:09AM (#44136995)
> If CEOs are salivating at the thought of replacing white collar workers, there is no reason to think next step of AI augmented with robotics won’t replace blue collar workers as well.

Robotics seems harder, though, and has been around for longer than LLMs. Robotic automation can replace blue collar factory workers, but I struggle to imagine it replacing a plumber who comes to your house and fixes your pipes, or a waiter serving food at a restaurant, or someone who restocks shelves at grocery stores, that kind of thing. Plus, in the case of service work like being a waiter, I imagine some customers will always be willing to pay for a human face.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ben_w on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:49AM (#44137413)
> or a waiter serving food at a restaurant,

Over the last few years, I've seen a few in use here in Berlin: https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/robot-waiter-for-sale.html

> or someone who restocks shelves at grocery stores

For physical retail, or home delivery?

People are working on this for traditional stores, but I can't tell which news stories are real and which are hype — after around a decade of Musk promising FSD within a year or so, I know not to simply trust press releases even when they have a video of the thing apparently working.

For home delivery, this is mostly kinda solved: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssZ_8cqfBlE

> Plus, in the case of service work like being a waiter, I imagine some customers will always be willing to pay for a human face.

Sure… if they have the money.

But can we make an economy where all the stuff is free, and we're "working" n-hours a day smiling at bad jokes and manners of people we don't like, so we can earn money to spend to convince someone else who doesn't like us to spend m-hours a day smiling at our bad jokes and manners?

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by trealira on Friday May 30, 2025 @12:22PM (#44137736)
> Over the last few years, I've seen a few in use here in Berlin: https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/robot-waiter-for-sale.html

Wow. I genuinely didn't think robotic waiters would ever exist anytime soon.

> For physical retail, or home delivery?

I was thinking for physical retail. Thanks for the video link.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by pesus on Friday May 30, 2025 @09:06PM (#44141155)
I've seen robot waiters at one restaurant in SF as well, and I wouldn't be surprised if there were more. They'll most likely be here on a large scale faster than we think.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ido on Saturday May 31, 2025 @10:44AM (#44144607)
It’s more a dishwasher level of automation than 3CPO- when you order they enter your table number and the kitchen staff puts the prepared dishes in the shelves in the robot, which the drives to your table. Once it gets there you take the dishes from the robot.

Tech-wise this could have existed 30 years ago (maybe going around the restaurant would have been more challenging than today but it’s a fixed path and the robots don’t leave the restaurant).

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ben_w on Monday June 09, 2025 @12:48PM (#44226366)
This is a long-standing trend with AI.

Often people will say "AI will never do X, or at least it will take decades", and then it does X, and it turns out you can cheat a lot to get X done really easily.

I'm old enough to remember when X was "play chess at top level", followed by 19 years of X = "play Go at top level". Irregardless of what you think of GenAI, the script writers of I, Robot chose X = "compose music and draw pictures".

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ryandrake on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:36AM (#44137257)
> I struggle to imagine it replacing a plumber who comes to your house and fixes your pipes, or a waiter serving food at a restaurant, or someone who restocks shelves at grocery stores, that kind of thing.

These are three totally different jobs requiring different kinds of skills, but they will all be replaced with automation.

1. Plumber is a skilled trade, but the "skilled" parts will eventually be replaced with 'smart' tools. You'll still need to hire a minimum wage person to actually go into each unique home and find the plumbing, but the tools will do all the work and will not require an expensive tradesman's skills to work.

2. Waiter serving food, already being replaced with kiosks, and quite a bit of the "back of the house" cooking areas are already automated. It will only take a slow cultural shift towards ordering food through technology-at-the-table, and robots wheeling your food out to you. We've already accepted kiosks in fast food and self-checkout in grocery stores. Waiters are going bye-bye.

3. Shelf restocking, very easy to imagine automating this with robotics. Picking a product and packing it into a destination will be solved very soon, and there are probably hundreds of companies working on the problem.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by trealira on Friday May 30, 2025 @12:29PM (#44137805)
> 1. Plumber is a skilled trade, but the "skilled" parts will eventually be replaced with 'smart' tools. You'll still need to hire a minimum wage person to actually go into each unique home and find the plumbing, but the tools will do all the work and will not require an expensive tradesman's skills to work.

I'm not a plumber, but my background knowledge was that pipes can be really diverse and it could take different tools and strategies to fix the same problem for different pipes, right? My thought was that "robotic plumber" would be impossible for the same reasons it's hard to make a robot that can make a sandwich in any type of house. But even with a human worker that uses advanced robotic tools, I would think some amount of baseline knowledge of pipes would always be necessary for the reasons I outlined.

> 2. Waiter serving food, already being replaced with kiosks, and quite a bit of the "back of the house" cooking areas are already automated. It will only take a slow cultural shift towards ordering food through technology-at-the-table, and robots wheeling your food out to you. We've already accepted kiosks in fast food and self-checkout in grocery stores. Waiters are going bye-bye.

That's true. I forgot about fast-food kiosks. And the other person showed me a link to some robotic waiters, which I didn't know about. Seems kind of depressing, but you're right.

> 3. Shelf restocking, very easy to imagine automating this with robotics. Picking a product and packing it into a destination will be solved very soon, and there are probably hundreds of companies working on the problem.

The way I imagine it, to automate it, you'd have to have some sort of 3D design software to choose where all the items would go, and customize it in the case of those special display stands for certain products, and then choose where in the backroom or something for it to move the products to, and all that doesn't seem to save much labor over just doing it yourself, except the physical labor component. Maybe I just lack imagination.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by 9x39 on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:57PM (#44141117)
> 1. Plumber is a skilled trade, but the "skilled" parts will eventually be replaced with 'smart' tools. You'll still need to hire a minimum wage person to actually go into each unique home and find the plumbing, but the tools will do all the work and will not require an expensive tradesman's skills to work.

But if you have to be trained in the use of a variety of 'smart' tools - that sounds like engineering to know what tool to deploy and how.

It's also incredibly optimistic about future tools - what smart tool fixes leaky faucets, hauls and installs water heaters, unclogs or replaces sewer mains, runs new pipes, does all this work and more to code, etc? There are cool tools and power tools and cool power tools out there, but vibe plumbing by the unskilled just fills someone's house with water or worse...

> 2. Waiter serving food, already being replaced with kiosks, and quite a bit of the "back of the house" cooking areas are already automated. It will only take a slow cultural shift towards ordering food through technology-at-the-table, and robots wheeling your food out to you. We've already accepted kiosks in fast food and self-checkout in grocery stores. Waiters are going bye-bye.

Takeout culture is popular among GenZ, and we're more likely to see walk-up orders with online order ahead than a facsimile of table service.

Why would cheap restaurants buy robots and allow a dining room to go unmanned and risk walkoffs instead of just skipping the whole make-believe service aspect and run it like a pay-at-counter cafeteria? You're probably right that waiters will disappear outside of high-margin fine dining as labor costs squeeze margins until restaurants crack and reorganize.

>3. Shelf restocking, very easy to imagine automating this with robotics. Picking a product and packing it into a destination will be solved very soon, and there are probably hundreds of companies working on the problem.

Do-anything-like-a-human robots might crack that, but today it's still sci-fi. Humans are going to haul things from A to B for a bit longer, I think. I bet we see drive-up and delivery groceries win via lights-out warehouses well before "I, Robot" shelf stockers.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by DrillShopper on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:40AM (#44137316)
> a waiter serving food at a restaurant

I have already eaten at three restaurants that have replaced the vast majority of their service staff with robots, and they're fine at that. Do I think they're better than a human? No, personally, but they're "good enough".

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by rufus_foreman on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:59PM (#44140552)
>> or someone who restocks shelves at grocery stores

They've already replaced part of that job at one of the grocery stores that I go to, there's a robot that checks the level of stock on the shelves, https://www.simberobotics.com/store-intelligence/tally.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by hnthrow90348765 on Friday May 30, 2025 @07:22PM (#44140664)
>or a waiter serving food at a restaurant

I've seen this already at a pizza place. Order from a QR code menu and a robot shows up 20-25 minutes later at your table with your pizza. Wait staff still watched the thing go around.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JadeNB on Saturday May 31, 2025 @10:05AM (#44144358)
> Robotics seems harder, though, and has been around for longer than LLMs. Robotic automation can replace blue collar factory workers, but I struggle to imagine it replacing a plumber who comes to your house and fixes your pipes, or a waiter serving food at a restaurant, or someone who restocks shelves at grocery stores, that kind of thing. Plus, in the case of service work like being a waiter, I imagine some customers will always be willing to pay for a human face.

Wouldn't you have struggled to imagine most of what LLMs can now do 5 years ago?

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:19AM (#44137094)
Yeah, it's as though "middle class" was a brief miracle of our age. Serfs and nobility is the more probably human condition.

Hey, is there a good board game in there somewhere? Serfs and Nobles™

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday May 30, 2025 @01:04PM (#44138115)
ML models don't make fully informed decisions and will not until AGI is created. They can make biased guesses at best and have no means of self-directed inquiry to integrate new information with an understanding of its meaning. People employed in a decision making capacity are safe, whether that's managing people or building a bridge from a collection of parts and construction equipment.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by whattheheckheck on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:13PM (#44139941)
Has anyone made a fully informed decision?
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by madaxe_again on Saturday May 31, 2025 @05:14AM (#44143027)
Look, human cognition is obviously better than machine cognition, and nobody has ever made a poor argument or decision.

End of conversation.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JadeNB on Saturday May 31, 2025 @10:07AM (#44144372)
> People employed in a decision making capacity are safe, whether that's managing people or building a bridge from a collection of parts and construction equipment.

Surely the modern history of decision making has been to move as much of it as possible away from humans and to algorithms, even "dumb" ones?

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by munksbeer on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:49AM (#44136775)
>It's also easy to imagine a world in which you sell less stuff but your margins increase, and overall you're better off, even if everybody else has less widgets.

History seems to show this doesn't happen. The trend is not linear, but the trend is that we live better lives each century than the previous century, as our technology increases.

Maybe it will be different this time though.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ryandrake on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:40AM (#44137315)
"Technology increases" have not made my life better than my boomer parents' and they will probably not make the next generation's lives better than ours. Big things like housing costs, education costs, healthcare costs are not being driven down by technology, quite the opposite.

Yes, the lives of "people selling stuff" will likely get better and better in the future, through technology, but the wellbeing of normal people seems to have peaked at around the year 2000 or so.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by carlosjobim on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:43PM (#44140476)
I think that's mostly myth, and a very very deeply ingrained myth. That's why probably hundreds of people already feel the rage boiling up inside of them right now after reading my first sentence.

But it is myth. It has always been in the interest of the rulers and the old to try to imprint on the serfs and on the young how much better they have it.

Many of us, maybe even most of us, would be able to have fulfilling lives in a different age. Of course, it depends on what you value in life. But the proof is in the pudding, humanity is rapidly being extinguished in industrial society right now all over the world.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:17AM (#44137070)
> All the people employed by the government and blue collar workers?

You forgot the born-wealthy.

I feel increasingly like a rube for having not made my little entrepreneurial side-gigs focused strictly on the ultra-wealthy. I used to sell tube amplifier kits, for example, so you and I could have a really high-end audio experience with a very modest outlay of cash (maybe $300). Instead I should have sold the same amps but completed for $10K. (There is no upper bounds for audio equipment though — I guess we all know.)

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ryandrake on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:30AM (#44137196)
This is the real answer. Eventually, when 95% of us have no jobs because AI and robotics are doing everything, then the rich will just buy and sell from each other. The other 7 billion people are not economically relevant and will just barely participate in the economy. It'll be like the movie Elysium.

I briefly did a startup that was kind of a side-project of a guy whose main business was building yachts. Why was he OK with a market that just consisted of rich people? "Because rich people have the money!"

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by bluefirebrand on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:22PM (#44140371)
> This is the real answer. Eventually, when 95% of us have no jobs because AI and robotics are doing everything, then the rich will just buy and sell from each other

My prediction is that the poor will reinvent the guillotine

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by hnthrow90348765 on Friday May 30, 2025 @07:39PM (#44140762)
>It'll be like the movie Elysium.

The rich were able to insulate themselves in space which is much harder to get to than some place on Earth. If the rich want to turtle up on some island because that's the only place they're safe, that's probably a better outcome for us all. They lose a lot of ability to influence because they simply can't be somewhere in person.

It also relies heavily on a security force (or military) being complicit, but they have to give those people a better life than average to make it worth it. Even those dumb MAGA idiots won't settle for moldy bread and leaky roofs. That requires more and more resources, capital, and land to sustain and grow it, which then takes more security to secure it. "Some rich dude controlling everything" has an exponential curve of security requirements and resources. This even comes down to how much land they need to be able to farm and feed their security guys.

All this assuming your personal detail and larger security force actually likes you enough, because if society has broken down to this point, they can just kill the boss and take over.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by skydhash on Saturday May 31, 2025 @09:50AM (#44144274)
And this is assuming that they won’t destroy each other. Any society have conflicts and I failed to see a bunch of ultrarich not have any.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by spamizbad on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:24PM (#44140015)
> All the people employed by the government and blue collar workers? All the entrepreneurs, gig workers, black market workers, etc?

I can tell you for many of those professions their customers are the same white collar workers. The blue collar economy isn't plumbers simply fixing the toilets of the HVAC guy, while the HVAC guy cools the home of the electrician, while...

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by Jensson on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:55PM (#44141110)
> The blue collar economy isn't plumbers simply fixing the toilets of the HVAC guy, while the HVAC guy cools the home of the electrician, while...

That is exactly what blue collar economy used to be though: people making and fixing stuff for each other. White collar jobs is a new thing.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:18AM (#44137082)
Business leaders in AI are _not_ excited and agree with your concerns. That's what the source article is about - the CEO of AI lab Anthropic said he sees major social problems coming soon. The problem is that the information environment is twisted in knots. The author, like many commentators, characterizes your concerns as "optimism" and "hype", because she doesn't think AI will actually have these large impacts.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by spacemadness on Friday May 30, 2025 @12:43PM (#44137912)
I think he says this just to hype up how powerful of a force AI is which helps these CEOs bottom line eventually. Cynically “we’ve created something so powerful it will eliminate jobs and cause strife” gets those investors excited for more.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by geraneum on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:52PM (#44140207)
They are. The audience of this talk is not normal people. He’s excited and is targeting a specific group in his messaging. The author is a person like majority.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:36PM (#44140438)
I don't understand what you mean. The audience of this talk is Axios, a large news website targeting the general public.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by geraneum on Saturday May 31, 2025 @08:23AM (#44143790)
I believe he's talking to money, to investors. He does it through Axios, CNN, BBC, etc. Their company is not sustainable at this rate. None of the LLM service providers are. They need money for now and that's why they talk like this.

50% of a group of workers losing their jobs to this tech is not a worrisome future for him. It's a pitch!

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by johnbenoe on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:43AM (#44136707)
You ever thought there’s more to life than work lol. Maybe humans can approach a new standard of living…
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by darth_avocado on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:49AM (#44136787)
I’m yet to be convinced that if majority of the humans are out of work, the government will be able to take care of them and allow them to “pursue their calling”. Hunger games is a more believable outcome to me.
[dead]
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:25AM (#44137155)
To the degree we feel capable, I suspect many of us are doing "what we can".

The worst it gets of course, the more each of us will feel capable of.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by JKCalhoun on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:23AM (#44137141)
If someone is going to suggest UBI, I wish they could explain to me how Reservations have failed so hard in the U.S.. I think that would be a cautionary tale.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by duderific on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:50PM (#44140516)
Decades and decades of mistreatment are not going to be remedied by some modest handouts. That doesn't mean that UBI as a whole could never work.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by 9x39 on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:42PM (#44141055)
Shouldn't we be able to find at least one pilot or prototype with a lasting success story to build off of before concluding we need to do it on a huge scale?
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by codr7 on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:45AM (#44136734)
Excellent choice of words there: new standard.

I'm sure we are, but it doesn't look like an improvement for most people.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by johnbenoe on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:50AM (#44136794)
Not yet at least, but there’s no stopping this kind of efficiency jump. Anyone who thinks otherwise is in denial.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by myko on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:58AM (#44136893)
Maybe, but aren't LLM companies burning cash? The efficiency gains I see from LLMs typically come from agents which perform circular prompts on themselves until they reach some desired outcome (or give up until a human can prod them along).

It seems like we'll need to generate a lot more power to support these efficiency gains at scale, and unless that is coming from renewables (and even if it is) that cost may outweigh the gains for a long time.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by johnbenoe on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:06AM (#44136966)
They’re burning cash at a high rate because of the grand potential, and they are of course keeping some things behind closed doors.

I also respect the operative analysis, but the strategical, long-term thinking, is that this will come and it will only speed up everything else.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by codr7 on Friday May 30, 2025 @09:37PM (#44141281)
The grand potential of short sighted profits with no concern for society nor other humans, yes.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by codr7 on Friday May 30, 2025 @09:34PM (#44141272)
I would say anyone who sees that happening is in denial, because all the proof out there points in the opposite direction.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by codr7 on Friday June 06, 2025 @03:31PM (#44204190)
There are also no indications that it's coming. Anyone who assumes so is delusional.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by rfrey on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:21AM (#44137116)
The most powerful nation on earth isn't even willing to extend basic health care to the masses, nevermind freeing them to pursue a higher calling than enriching billionaires.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by keybored on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:40AM (#44136689)
We have consumer capitalism now. Before we didn’t. There’s no reason it can’t be replaced.

Sure there can be rich people who are radical enough to push for another phase of capitalism.

That’s a kind of a capitalism which is worse for workers and consumers. With even more power in the hands of capitalists.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by roenxi on Friday May 30, 2025 @10:46AM (#44136741)
You're being confused by the numbers. We aren't trying to maximise consumer spending, the point is to maximise living standards. If the market equilibrium price of all goods was $0 consumer spending would be $0 and living standards would be off the charts. It'd be a great outcome.

It just happens that up to this point there have been things that couldn't be done by capital. Now we're entering a world where there isn't such a thing and it is unclear what that implies for the job market. But people not having jobs is hardly a bad thing as long as it isn't forced by stupid policy, ideally nobody has to work.

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by amanaplanacanal on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:04AM (#44136942)
In theory. In reality, how are the benefits of all this efficiency going to be distributed to the people who aren't working? I sure don't see any calls for higher taxes and more wealth redistribution.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:26AM (#44137163)
The source article is an analysis of an interview (https://www.axios.com/2025/05/28/ai-jobs-white-collar-unempl...) where the CEO of Anthropic called for higher taxes and more wealth redistribution.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by DrillShopper on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:43AM (#44137355)
I'm sure the Republican liches in the Senate have some views on that which kill it out of the gate
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by ikrenji on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:51PM (#44140200)
Let's face it ~ almost all work will be automated in the next 50 years. Either capitalism dies or humanity dies
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by alluro2 on Saturday May 31, 2025 @01:57AM (#44142157)
Given the current mechanics evident in the society - declining education, healthcare and rising cost of living, homelessness and exploding economic inequality - who is "we", trying to maximise living standards, and what movement do you see leading towards such an outcome?
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by leeroihe on Friday May 30, 2025 @04:44PM (#44139718)
They want an omnipresent, lobotomized and defeated underclass who only exists to "respond" to the ai to continue to improve it. This is basically what alexander wang from Scale AI explained at a recent talk which was frankly terrifying.

Your UBI will be controlled by the government, you will have even less agency than you currently have and a hyper elite will control the thinking machines. But don't worry, the elite and the government are looking out for your best interest!

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by pdfernhout on Friday May 30, 2025 @09:00PM (#44141129)
We already have that "defeated underclass" courtesy of a century of mainstream schooling (according to NYS Teacher of the Year John Taylor Gatto): "The Underground History of American Education -- A conspiracy against ourselves" https://www.lewrockwell.com/2010/10/john-taylor-gatto/the-cu... "As soon as you break free of the orbit of received wisdom you have little trouble figuring out why, in the nature of things, government schools and those private schools which imitate the government model have to make most children dumb, allowing only a few to escape the trap. The problem stems from the structure of our economy and social organization. When you start with such pyramid-shaped givens and then ask yourself what kind of schooling they would require to maintain themselves, any mystery dissipates — these things are inhuman conspiracies all right, but not conspiracies of people against people, although circumstances make them appear so. School is a conflict pitting the needs of social machinery against the needs of the human spirit. It is a war of mechanism against flesh and blood, self-maintaining social mechanisms that only require human architects to get launched. I’ll bring this down to earth. Try to see that an intricately subordinated industrial/commercial system has only limited use for hundreds of millions of self-reliant, resourceful readers and critical thinkers. In an egalitarian, entrepreneurially based economy of confederated families like the one the Amish have or the Mondragon folk in the Basque region of Spain, any number of self-reliant people can be accommodated usefully, but not in a concentrated command-type economy like our own. Where on earth would they fit? In a great fanfare of moral fervor some years back, the Ford Motor Company opened the world’s most productive auto engine plant in Chihuahua, Mexico. It insisted on hiring employees with 50 percent more school training than the Mexican norm of six years, but as time passed Ford removed its requirements and began to hire school dropouts, training them quite well in four to twelve weeks. The hype that education is essential to robot-like work was quietly abandoned. Our economy has no adequate outlet of expression for its artists, dancers, poets, painters, farmers, filmmakers, wildcat business people, handcraft workers, whiskey makers, intellectuals, or a thousand other useful human enterprises — no outlet except corporate work or fringe slots on the periphery of things. Unless you do "creative" work the company way, you run afoul of a host of laws and regulations put on the books to control the dangerous products of imagination which can never be safely tolerated by a centralized command system...."

In 2010, I put together a list of alternatives here to address the rise of AI and Robotics and its effect on jobs: https://pdfernhout.net/beyond-a-jobless-recovery-knol.html "This article explores the issue of a "Jobless Recovery" mainly from a heterodox economic perspective. It emphasizes the implications of ideas by Marshall Brain and others that improvements in robotics, automation, design, and voluntary social networks are fundamentally changing the structure of the economic landscape. It outlines towards the end four major alternatives to mainstream economic practice (a basic income, a gift economy, stronger local subsistence economies, and resource-based planning). These alternatives could be used in combination to address what, even as far back as 1964, has been described as a breaking "income-through-jobs link". This link between jobs and income is breaking because of the declining value of most paid human labor relative to capital investments in automation and better design. Or, as is now the case, the value of paid human labor like at some newspapers or universities is also declining relative to the output of voluntary social networks such as for digital content production (like represented by this document). It is suggested that we will need to fundamentally reevaluate our economic theories and practices to adjust to these new realities emerging from exponential trends in technology and society."

Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by carlosjobim on Friday May 30, 2025 @06:31PM (#44140413)
That's a very pessimistic view. People can borrow money against their property, then later they can borrow money against their diploma and professional certificates (and nobody should be allowed to work without being certified, that's dangerous). Then later I think it's time for banks to start offering consumers the reproductive right of mortgaging their children, either born or unborn.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by tim333 on Saturday May 31, 2025 @05:29PM (#44147038)
It's like all the farmers soil shoveling jobs were stolen by tractors. People moved on to more interesting things.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by lowbloodsugar on Saturday May 31, 2025 @06:29PM (#44147376)
In all previous such revolutions, humans were freed to do more productive work while the cost of goods came down. But that doesn’t mean the same is true this time. Now the revolution does not make physical tasks easier (like ploughing or spinning thread) but intellectual labor. This time, there are no jobs to go to, since those jobs are also done by AI.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by tim333 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @06:11AM (#44149806)
There are still interacting with other humans jobs.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by lowbloodsugar on Thursday June 05, 2025 @09:03PM (#44196977)
So, prostitution? Bartender? There are still jobs now that require human interaction, but unless interacting with another human is the job itself, then, yes, those jobs are going. McDonalds already has kiosks for ordering. Yo Sushi has beer taps at your table. Young men are walking around having relationships with cute anime girls who listen and validate them (and how are they ever going to deal with an actual human female who has her own needs??). Others on HN are saying AI isn't good enough for this or that, but have you ever tried dealing with a real person in a call center, or a minimum wage employee at the job center, or a sales person at a cheap cosmetics counter. So sure, there are jobs at Chanel, or Audi, or Michelin starred restaurants, for the rich who can not only afford such luxury but enjoy lauding it over the rest of us, but for the rest of us there's Johnny Cab if we even have any way of paying for a ride in one.
Re:The 'white-collar bloodbath' is all part of the AI hype m... by bravesoul2 on Saturday May 31, 2025 @08:38PM (#44147868)
How to move to post-capitalism is the question. We need something money-like to motivate but something different.