News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kyledrake on Sunday December 22, 2024 @07:49PM (#42490615)
It's also quite possible that someone falsely claiming to be UHC is doing this. This is a major loophole with the DMCA, there's very little vetting of takedown notices.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by Dwedit on Sunday December 22, 2024 @08:07PM (#42490757)
If you misrepresent that you are authorized by the company making the takedown request, that's literally the only thing that the DMCA considers to be perjury.

So weirdly enough:

* Not owning the copyrighted work and claiming you own it = Okay

* The work you're taking down not even being the claimed copyrighted work = Okay

* Saying you're authorized by the company to file the notice, and you're not = PERJURY

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by dcrazy on Sunday December 22, 2024 @08:21PM (#42490828)
It’s not that crazy when you consider that someone might be wrong about whether their work is even copyrightable, but they can’t realistically be mistaken about whether they are acting as someone’s authorized agent. That’s the kind of relationship that lawyers know very well how to make explicit.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by mithametacs on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:06PM (#42491083)
But they should also have foreseen the routes for abuse. That's also their job.

The DMCA is a disaster.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by matheusmoreira on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:40PM (#42491842)
These laws are bought and paid for by corporations of the trillion dollar copyright industry. They hire expensive lobbyists to get these laws passed. It's no surprise that the laws only foresee the abuse that could hurt their bottom lines.

The better question is: why have the people's representatives failed to protect their interests? Why didn't they foresee the abuses that hurt us all?

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:09AM (#42491949)
> why have the people's representatives failed to protect their interests?

Nobody cares about copyright. There is a vocal minority of us who do. But we're only slightly more usefully engaged on it than the privacy advocates, both sharing a good chunk of people who are lazy or nihlistic about the political process to the point of being politically irrelevant.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by int_19h on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:39PM (#42506032)
It really depends on how you phrase it. If you talk about copyright in the abstract, then yes, few people will care. But ask them how they feel about stuff like this specifically, and it'll be rather different.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by mithametacs on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:27AM (#42492032)
The Senate is quite deliberately there to protect the interests of the wealthy and powerful.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by jgerrish on Monday December 23, 2024 @08:11AM (#42494135)
It's unfortunate that the UnitedHealth Group death has fanned the flames of this hatred of corporations.

Artificial Intelligence is going to change how we work. Many top software engineers on Hacker News may be ok for a while. Although everyone could use help.

But already many artists and junior engineers feel pressure. Lack of copyright protection can make that even worse for many. These are allies and people who we mentor.

Just brainstorming, Social Purpose Corporations could provide innovative co-op opportunities for artists and engineers. That's just one example.

I don't see the management class failing to forsee the financial reality in the global workplace. But I do worry about dependents facing division and hate. Bully that, right?

I can't fucking forsee every possibility, traps and all, though. Maybe not social purpose corporations but just hyper-incubators that enable a million small indy corps. Man, I'm imagining Jar Jar binks manning the hyperspace lychgates across from the content generators.

Sorry, stupid digression. I'm sorry for wasting cycles on that.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by paulryanrogers on Monday December 23, 2024 @08:38AM (#42494295)
Corporations have earned all the hate they get, UHC even more so.

Whether AI decimates the likelihoods of everyone is only more likely with unchecked corpo power in control of everything.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by LocalH on Monday December 23, 2024 @09:04AM (#42494441)
"AI" is like anything else. Big capital will weaponize it to further entrench themselves and further disadvantage smaller businesses and individuals, in the pursuit of increasing profits and growth.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by matheusmoreira on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:14PM (#42496369)
I hate copyright and would rather see it abolished.

AI is just the latest iteration of endless corporate abuses. They think copyright exists to keep the likes of us in line while they get to do whatever they want. If we infringe copyright, they compare us to raping and pillaging high seas pirates but then they turn around and say it's OK to infringe copyright on a massive scale so long as they launder it via AI first.

I want intellectual property gone so that we can do the same. I want them to be forced to open their weights too.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by hulitu on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:30AM (#42500526)
> The better question is: why have the people's representatives failed to protect their interests

Because there are no "people's representatives" after the voting is done. They just go with the biggest bidder. That's why companies are spending bilions on lobbying.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:26PM (#42491468)
They did foresee the routes for abuse and set up a formal counterclaim process. Neither the source article nor the original reporting really explain why the targets of these takedown orders didn't want to file a counterclaim - in some cases there can be privacy concerns, but the T-shirt artist at least has already publicly identified herself.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:46PM (#42491576)
The process is extremely assymmetric, the counterclaim process has much higher requirements than a takedown notice. Like having to actually provide evidence you aren't infringing, provide your real identity, and often convince an AI that your content shouldn't be taken down or least get it seen by a real person. And if you succeed, you just get your content back up. No compensation for any damage caused by your content being down for a while.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by dcrazy on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:31PM (#42491792)
Maybe you’re describing YouTube’s DMCA process? The actual law doesn’t specify any of that [1]:

> If the user believes that the material was removed as a result of mistake or misidentification of the material, the user may submit a counter-notice requesting the reinstatement of the material. To be effective, a counter-notice must contain substantially the following information:

> (i) a physical or electronic signature of the user;

> (ii) identification of the material that has been removed or to which access has been disabled and the location at which the material appeared before it was removed or access to it was disabled;

> (iii) a statement under penalty of perjury that the user has a good faith belief that the material was removed or disabled as a result of mistake or misidentification of the material to be removed or disabled;

> (iv) the user’s name, address, and telephone number, and a statement that the subscriber consents to the jurisdiction of Federal District Court for the judicial district in which the address is located, or if the subscriber’s address is outside of the United States, for any judicial district in which the service provider may be found, and that the subscriber will accept service of process from the person who provided notification under subsection (c)(1)(C) or an agent of such person.

1: https://www.copyright.gov/512/

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:37AM (#42492080)
(iv) sure sounds like giving them your true identity to me.

You have to give them information to sue you (or do other nefarious things), but they don't have to provide you with information that say, you could use to sue them for perjury or try to recover damages from the time it was taken down.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by dcrazy on Monday December 23, 2024 @10:40AM (#42495162)
Again, you seem to be conflating YouTube’s DMCA process (which is designed to optimize the experience for YouTube, not to maximize the rights of YouTubers) with what the law actually specifies. The filer must provide contact information (paragraph iv), which can be used to serve process.

> (i) the signature of the copyright owner or an authorized agent;

> (ii) identification of the copyrighted work claimed to have been infringed, or, if multiple works are on a single site, a representative list of such works;

> (iii) identification of the infringing material or activity (or the reference or link to such material) and information reasonably sufficient to permit the OSP to locate the material (or the reference or link);

> (iv) contact information for the copyright owner or authorized agent;

> (v) a statement that the person sending the notice has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law; and

> (vi) a statement that the information in the notice is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the person sending the notice is authorized to act on behalf of the copyright owner .

I agree the system is intentionally asymmetric, because it was built by people who understand how quickly material proliferates once it’s been posted to the Internet. That makes it abusable to chill speech, as in this case. But the law was also written with an expectation that anonymity does not guarantee full participation in civil society.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Monday December 23, 2024 @11:43AM (#42495698)
"contact information" is not the same as "user’s name, address, and telephone number".

"Contact information" could just be an email address, or even a social media handle.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by Underpass9041 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @08:27PM (#42490863)
As someone receiving a notice you have no idea if it's legitimate or from a AOL account someone made 15 minutes ago, the threat of it being perjury doesn't work when there's no authentication whatsoever of who sent it. Unless the DMCA is signed by Zaphod Beeblebrox the receiver has no choice but to assume it's legitimate.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by SteveNuts on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:15PM (#42491115)
What happens if you ignore it?
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by gruez on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:21PM (#42491144)
You lose safe harbor protections, which means if the notice was legitimate, you could be on the hook for copyright infringement as well.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by bombcar on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:34PM (#42491202)
You can respond and refuse, but you have to authenticately dox yourself to do so, and you assume liabilities.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by eurleif on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:40PM (#42491527)
You're conflating two things: a DMCA counter-notice by an alleged infringer, and the refusal of an intermediary to honor a DMCA takedown notice. Your statement is a mixture of claims that are true about one or the other of those separate things.

DMCA counter-notice:

* Sent by an alleged infringer (in this case, that would be the artist) to an intermediary (in this case, TeePublic) asserting that a takedown notice the intermediary received was invalid.

* Requires the alleged infringer to provide information about themself ("authentically dox").

* Can enable the intermediary to restore access to the material without losing their liability shield.

* Doesn't affect the alleged infringer's copyright infringement liability in any direction (though as with takedown notices, there's the potential for perjury). If the alleged infringer committed copyright infringement, they were already liable for it, and remain so; if they didn't, then they never were liable and still aren't.

Intermediary refusal:

* Simply a lack of action on a takedown notice by the intermediary to whom it was sent.

* Doesn't require anyone to dox themselves, or to do anything in particular. The intermediary can throw the takedown notice in the garbage and go about their day.

* Removes the intermediary's liability shield; the intermediary can potentially be liable for infringement, when they would otherwise would have been immune.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by more_corn on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:50AM (#42492362)
Provider has to take it down. The vendor making the shirt can simply file a dmca counterclaim (basically stating that the dmca claim is invalid) Then the provider puts the content back up and the courts decide.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by amanaplanacanal on Monday December 23, 2024 @04:52AM (#42493189)
One side note: the provider is not required to put the content back up, it is at their discretion.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by LocalH on Monday December 23, 2024 @08:54AM (#42494377)
I don't believe that's true. I think they must make the material available after a proper counter-notification, or they lose their liability shield as per the exception here. IANAL, just reading the text of the law at face value.

(g) REPLACEMENT OF REMOVED OR DISABLED MATERIAL AND LIMITATION ON OTHER LIABILITY.—

(1) NO LIABILITY FOR TAKING DOWN GENERALLY.—Subject to paragraph (2), a service provider shall not be liable to any person for any claim based on the service provider’s good faith disabling of access to, or removal of, material or activity claimed to be infringing or based on facts or circumstances from which infringing activity is apparent, regardless of whether the material or activity is ultimately determined to be infringing.

(2) EXCEPTION.—Paragraph (1) shall not apply with respect to material residing at the direction of a subscriber of the service provider on a system or network controlled or operated by or for the service provider that is removed, or to which access is disabled by the service provider, pursuant to a notice provided under subsection (c)(1)(C), unless the service provider—

(A) takes reasonable steps promptly to notify the subscriber that it has removed or disabled access to the material; Applicability. PUBLIC LAW 105–304—OCT. 28, 1998 112 STAT. 2883

(B) upon receipt of a counter notification described in paragraph (3), promptly provides the person who provided the notification under subsection (c)(1)(C) with a copy of the counter notification, and informs that person that it will replace the removed material or cease disabling access to it in 10 business days; and

(C) replaces the removed material and ceases disabling access to it not less than 10, nor more than 14, business days following receipt of the counter notice, unless its designated agent first receives notice from the person who submitted the notification under subsection (c)(1)(C) that such person has filed an action seeking a court order to restrain the subscriber from engaging in infringing activity relating to the material on the service provider’s system or network.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by eurleif on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:29PM (#42496013)
They lose their liability shield for the act of taking the content down, but that liability shield is of limited value to begin with because they'd typically be well within their rights to take any content down for any reason (or no reason).
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by willis936 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:33PM (#42491201)
I'm not sure how DMCA enforcement isn't a clear violation of the 1st amendment. If you are connected you can use the government to stop speech? Isn't this the kind of thing that US feels very strongly is not okay?
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:31PM (#42491491)
Also the seventh amendment (the content is removed without any trial by jury, and that can sometimes have considerable monetary harm to the content creator) and the fifth amendment (there is a process but it is very questionable, with basically no requirement of evidence of infringement, and no presumption of innocence).
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:18PM (#42491730)
> fifth amendment (there is a process but it is very questionable, with basically no requirement of evidence of infringement, and no presumption of innocence)

There is also no “capital, or otherwise infamous crime,” “criminal case,” or taking of private property “for public use, without just compensation” [1].

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Amendment_to_the_Unite...

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:06AM (#42491932)
I will admit that the fifth amendment case isn't as clear cut as the others, by the letter of the law, but:

> nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law

I would argue that at least in some cases dmca takedown notices can deprive people of property, either by preventing them from making an income from their content, or causing them to lose access to a service for which they paid money, or have access to something of value.

I also think it deprives the poster of some degree of liberty.

Even if it isn't against the letter of the law it is against the spirit.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:36AM (#42492070)
> Even if it isn't against the letter of the law it is against the spirit

By that notion YouTube has the right to call a jury if I decide to cancel.

Where we agree is in the sanctions. For the safe harbor to be removed there should be more process, and it should be explicit.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by hahn-kev on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:34PM (#42491815)
Except you don't have a legal right to post content on a private platform, that private company can do whatever they want, they aren't required to give you freedom of speech.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:26AM (#42492023)
DMCA is a legal mechanism that the platform has to comply with. This isn't a case of a private company removing something that violates the ToS, it is a law that can be easily be abused by a third party to cause content to be taken down.

It's like if there was a law that said if you send a notification to a storage or logistics company that you think one of their customers has counterfeit goods in their storage, the storage company is legally obligated to destroy the suspect property, regardless of whether there is any evidence that it is actually counterfeit. Or even just, that company is no longer allowed to provide service to that customer, and is allowed to seize and keep any property they currently have control over.

I could also talk about how many of these platforms have too much power, and the lack of competition makes it problematic if they have control to censor as they please, but that is really a different topic.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by foobarchu on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:27AM (#42492034)
IANAL but I think this justification sits on very shakey ground when the private company is doing it in the name of the law (DMCA). For the same reason, I of course think the government demanding encryption backdoors by private companies violates the fifth amendment.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by cratermoon on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:03PM (#42491354)
When the government does it, it's bad. When the Free Market™ does it, that's innovation.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:28PM (#42491475)
The 1st amendment applies to the government, so it wouldn't apply unless the DMCA request is to a government website.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by foota on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:43PM (#42491557)
The DMCA is a law that restricts the ability of people to make speech. The government is the one doing the restricting, even if the place the speech is being done isn't controlled by the government.

The argument you're making is applicable when a website decides not to publish your speech (they're not the government, so the 1st amendment is irrelevant), but the DMCA is different.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Monday December 23, 2024 @06:09PM (#42498345)
The 1st amendment only applies to freedom of speech that the government can control/affect directly.

Using the DMCA like this is censorship by copywrite, and it does go against freedom of speech in society at large, but it's not a 1st amendment issue.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_copyright

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 23, 2024 @06:16PM (#42498371)
Lots of arguing around the point, perhaps.

Freedom of speech is an American ideal. It's in the Bill of Rights because it was so important. Not as a tool to restrict this right to just government infringements. It is supposed to be a universal right.

I often wonder at those arguing that it's 'ok' somehow in some circumstances because, not protected except for the govt! Somehow they've lost sight of the ideal.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Monday December 23, 2024 @09:37PM (#42499277)
My dude, it's restricted to just government infringements (Congress) in the Bill of Rights.

> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights

If it was supposed to be a universal right for everyone/everything, it would be something like "no one shall make a law..."

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:35AM (#42501802)
Kid, that's what I said.

American ideals are not restricted to the Bill of Rights. My entire point.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:16PM (#42504600)
That's not what you said.

> It's in the Bill of Rights because it was so important. Not as a tool to restrict this right to just government infringements.

In the Bill of Rights, it's restricted to just government infringements.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by foota on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:00PM (#42504062)
Interesting, thanks for clarifying. I guess the fact that people can counter claim means the ability of someone to truly limit someone else's speech is probably limited, and it's on websites to support that (which I don't think all do, but it's up to them?)

Almost makes me wish it was mandatory for companies to support counter claims and to treat a customer no differently if they've filed a counter claim. (E.g., GitHub can't close your repos as long as you file a counter claim, unless they would have regardless of the DMCA claim.)

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by willis936 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:45PM (#42491569)
It's the other way around. The 1st amendment protects public speech from the government, not the government from the public. Since DMCA is a law made and enforced by the government it is used illegally against the public in violation of the 1st amendment.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Thursday December 26, 2024 @06:23PM (#42518657)
Yes and no. The governments powers wrt speech are limited, but certain things like threats, yelling fire in a crowded theater, and other crimes/regulations do not have 1st amendment protections.

The DMCA is an exception because it's a law, just like a threat or any other illegal material/etc would be and removal of that thing can be mandated by law without it being a 1st amendment issue.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:25PM (#42491762)
> 1st amendment applies to the government, so it wouldn't apply

Eh, the DMCA is still a law providing for civil and criminal sanctions based on speech. There are probably fundamental First Amendment problems with copyright.

The answer to why the DMCA—and copyright as a whole—can exist is the Copyright Clause [1].

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:09AM (#42492216)
Section 8 of the Constitution explicitly allows Congress to protect copyright.

> To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;

The 1st amendment didn't repeal this.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by atoav on Monday December 23, 2024 @07:07AM (#42493826)
Yeah, but current practise isn't in any way promoting the Progress of Science and useful Arts.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:10PM (#42498006)
SCOTUS has ruled multiple times that Congress has the authority to determine policy that they believe best fulfills this part of the clause.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by atoav on Monday December 23, 2024 @07:26PM (#42498676)
Meaning the words of your constitution are worth nothing, gotcha.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by int_19h on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:43PM (#42506044)
This actually kinda makes sense, and the argument goes like this. It is rather obviously subjective what constitutes "promoting science and useful arts" (including the very definition of "useful" etc). So when it comes to enforcing this clause, you need some body to decide on what these translate to in practice. And this can be either the courts or the legislature. Between the two, the legislature is the one that citizens have more control over, so giving it the ability to decide is intended to make these kinds of abuses easier to rectify (just vote for the right guys!) as opposed to dealing with obstinate courts.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Friday December 27, 2024 @05:01PM (#42526472)
Let me assure you that you haven't discovered something hundreds of years of legal scholars didn't yet realize. You are simply mistaken as to how that clause is interpreted within the context of the rest of the document ... part of which outlines the division of roles and responsibilities for judging and executing that clause.

All of that aside, "science and useful arts" never referred to the little guys. This always referred to the interests of commercializing those endeavors.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by willis936 on Monday December 23, 2024 @07:12AM (#42493849)
Correct, just as section 8 didn't repeal the 1st amendment. Congress does not have power to enact legislation that violates the 1st amendment.

Since section 8 exists DMCA is nearly entirely redundant. Repealing DMCA would do nothing to strip copyright owners of their rights.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:22PM (#42498083)
DMCA has withstood a lot of 1A tests in court, even some very specific and narrow fair-use claims. The suggestion that the entire law is infringing is simply unfounded. There are many limitations that the court allows on speech under the 1A, and most of those aren't even listed as exceptions in the Constitution, as copyright is in section 8. As unpopular as it may be, the constitutionality is pretty solid.

> Repealing DMCA

Be careful what you wish for. Repealing DMCA would mean repealing Safe Harbor provisions, which would just make it just about impossible to run websites with user-submitted content. DMCA might have some problems, but do you really want website owners to be held liable for everything a user posts on their site?

> Since section 8 exists DMCA is nearly entirely redundant.

Absolutely not. There is zero overlap between the two. Section 8 doesn't establish any copyright law at all. It merely establishes Congress's right to regulate it.

> Repealing DMCA would do nothing to strip copyright owners of their rights.

That's a pretty loaded statement to make. There are obviously things that rights owners couldn't do if the DMCA was repealed. I think what you're really arguing that those things don't matter? That could be a valid opinion, but it's still irrelevant. If Congress has the power to regulate something, they also have the power to regulate it ineffectively.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by Trasmatta on Sunday December 22, 2024 @08:23PM (#42490842)
I worked front line technical support at a web hosting company in the early 2010s. We were told to just immediately shut down any site when receiving a DMCA takedown request. We were barely paid above minimum wage, and received no training on how to handle legal requests like this - the rule was just "shut the site down".
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by gjsman-1000 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @08:40PM (#42490933)
Before anyone reacts negatively to this - you’ve never seen how much spam, and how many DMCA requests, are completely real. I would personally estimate 90%+.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:01AM (#42491918)
> you’ve never seen how much spam, and how many DMCA requests, are completely real. I would personally estimate 90%+

Source?

There are abundant claims to the contrary [1][2]. (I can't find any quality data either way.)

[1] https://www.plagiarismtoday.com/2019/01/10/youtubes-copyrigh...

[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/youtubers-channels-are-being...

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by matheusmoreira on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:59PM (#42491909)
It doesn't matter. A 10% false positive rate means grave injustices are being inflicted on people on a daily basis. They are being censored by the government at a corporation's whim for bogus reasons. The corporations exploit the fact people will not fight their claims because it costs time and a small fortune to do so.

Spam? Infringement? Irrelevant. Small issues compared to corporate censorship. Let it happen. Not a single person should be censored over it.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kyledrake on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:34AM (#42492062)
Years ago we had an opsec competition called "Karmageddon". The goal was to get as many upvotes on Reddit on an account in one day, with absolutely no ethical limitations to achieving that.

I was winning against 10-20 people by posting a lot of random "f this politician" garbage in the political subreddits (this was in late 2016 and it was a feeding frenzy), until someone posted a "check out this picture of me and my brother I haven't seen in 10 years wearing the same Ghostbusters shirt!" post. It wasn't his brother, he found it somewhere, but it was going viral and I was about to lose.

So I filed a DMCA takedown request with Reddit, and they deleted the post and the picture very quickly after, no questions asked. I ended up winning the competition, but I think we ended up giving the prize to the Ghostbusters guy anyways.

The DMCA is 100% an attack strategy, it works.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by voidfunc on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:36PM (#42491212)
I know someone working for UHC legal.. they're in a vendetta mode over there from what I've been told.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by rblatz on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:45PM (#42491571)
Are they concerned that after their CEO was gunned down in broad daylight over his supposed unethical behavior, and the killer is being celebrated as a folk hero. That by doubling down and doing unethical things they may be putting targets on their own back?

I know if I were at UHC I’d be looking to leave before I ended up on a hit list.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by Aurornis on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:24PM (#42491756)
> I know if I were at UHC I’d be looking to leave before I ended up on a hit list.

UnitedHealth has half a million employees. If you think individual employees are at risk of getting on a hit list then you don’t really understand the scale of the company.

I’m constantly amazed by how some people adopt the uninformed narratives that sprang up in the wake of this murder. I’ve asked multiple people to guess how much cheaper our healthcare would get if we forced insurance company profits to zero and redistributed their C-suite’s compensation to their covered patients. The answer is always off by orders of magnitude.

It’s all very strange. The narratives around this murder and, by extension, the health care system are being invented by people informed about both yet widely accepted as fact. Even details about the scale of UnitedHealth seem lost on people. This is a very large publicly traded company with scores of employees.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:50PM (#42491886)
> asked multiple people to guess how much cheaper our healthcare would get if we forced insurance company profits to zero and redistributed their C-suite’s compensation to their covered patients. The answer is always off by orders of magnitude

The media is conflating the far-right and -left wing fringes who are celbrating Mangione as a person and his literal crime with those holding him as a symbol for their frustrations with our healthcare system.

If you're celebrating the person and the crime, you need to speak to a professional. (You're also in a minority. No, your subreddit isn't the world.) If you're upset about the system, it's reasonable to not care about if you're being fucked by Bob or Alice.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by y33t on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:27AM (#42492031)
> You're also in a minority

[citation needed]

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:31AM (#42492054)
"A majority of voters (68%) think the actions of the killer of the United Healthcare CEO, Brian Thompson, are unacceptable. Seventeen percent find the actions acceptable, while 16% are unsure" [1]. Also [2].

[1] https://emersoncollegepolling.com/december-2024-national-pol...

[2] https://d3nkl3psvxxpe9.cloudfront.net/documents/econTabRepor... page 12

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by Larrikin on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:08AM (#42492212)
That seems like most people who are healthy and military age are atleast somewhat OK with it. Its also excluding people who don't vote and have had their voting rights taken away.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:16AM (#42492247)
> seems like most people who are healthy and military age are atleast somewhat OK with it

About a quarter of under-30 men and a fifth of under-30 women. For comparison, about 20% of Americans "think holding neo-Nazi views is" acceptable [1].

> excluding people who don't vote and have had their voting rights taken away

Where do you see the 2% of Americans [2] who have had their voting rights taken away being excluded by either poll? (Not challenging. That's just methodologically impressive.) Either way, none of what you're citing is material to an 80/20 margin.

I have friends in that 17%. But I also know people who thought Kari Lake was a shoe in, "defund the police" would work or that every guy is an incel. Echo chambers are powerful, especially online, where they can convince a quarter of a single demographic that they're in the majority on celebrating a dude capping a stranger in broad daylight.

[1] https://www.the-independent.com/news/world/americas/us-neo-n...

[2] https://www.sentencingproject.org/reports/locked-out-2022-es...

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by throwawaygmbno on Monday December 23, 2024 @02:13AM (#42492462)
You're selectively moving groups around with your statistics to try and use simple numbers to make it seem like you're always right. 20% of every single person in the US being sort of into Nazis has very little to do with the vast majority of people under 40 (military age) finding it ok with Brian getting shot. The first group includes people who are getting government funded healthcare on top of not having spent most of their lives dealing with insurance companies run by MBAs

Edit: Just noticed statistical manipulation is your job and you're maybe in a similar tax bracket

>> Trade private equity. Former aerospace investment banker, and before that, algorithmic equity derivatives trader. FinTech + Space + B2C angel & seed investor. Jackson Hole local; frequently in New York and the Bay Area.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @02:23AM (#42492509)
> 20% of every single person in the US being sort of into Nazis has very little to do with

I’m saying 20% of Americans can be found who believe almost anything. 20% of Americans supporting something is basically background.

> selectively moving groups around with your statistics to try and use simple numbers to make it seem like you're always right

I’m slicing the data to present a number bigger than 17%. I’m trying to find a group in which a majority support Mangione who aren’t on the far fringes of society. If you’re upset about the slicing and dicing you’re confirming my point.

> the vast majority of people under 40 (military age) finding it ok with Brian getting shot

Where do you see this?

18 to 29 is the most favourable bloc for Mangione, and there favourability is 39%. Not a majority let alone a vast majority. And that’s being generous by combining in somewhat favourable.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by ben_w on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:39PM (#42498174)
> I’m saying 20% of Americans can be found who believe almost anything. 20% of Americans supporting something is basically background.

The Lizardman's Constant is lower than 20%, more like 4% for the survey result that gave rise to the name — and also, despite the name, not constant: https://gwern.net/note/lizardman

Sadly, this also means that your chosen example, instead of illustrating your claim, actually has something to say about the state of the American Overton Window when it was taken.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @06:45PM (#42498503)
> The Lizardman's Constant is lower than 20%, more like 4%

Lizardman’s Constant is, per Gwern, “‘jokester’ or ‘mischevious responders’.” They’re being disingenuous; think: “deez balls” voters.

I don’t think the 17% of respondents who think favourably of Mangione are trolling. I don’t think the 10% flat earthers (or, including those who are “unsure” about the Earth’s roundness, 19%) are bullshitting [1].

There is simply about a fifth of the population—and it’s a moving fifth, there isn’t a permanently-braindead section—that tends to respond one way in just about any survey about fringe or stupid theories. So 17% supporting Mangione (while making it seem like it’s everyone online) isn’t particularly surprising. (Even if a good fraction of them are responding provocatively for fun.)

[1] https://carsey.unh.edu/publication/conspiracy-vs-science-sur...

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by pjc50 on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:50AM (#42493462)
Why do people keep quoting "military age" here? There's no a priori reason why the next CEO shooter might not be underage (common in school shooters) or retired (with time, pain, and guns on their hands)?
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by EE84M3i on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:13PM (#42491411)
You mean a vendetta against the murder suspect, or an actor impersonating UHC sending DMCAs?
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by superkuh on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:46PM (#42491260)
Indeed. Claiming DMCA on something should require KYC for the claimant. If KYC is so easy and un-burdensome that it's being applied everywhere else in our lives surely in such a legal context where 2-parties are central to the dogma the initiating party in a legal case should have to prove it is who it says it is.

Of course this will not happen because the DMCA as used in practice has nothing to do with law or justice and is just a mechanism for corporations to attack humans.

That's not to say there's nothing good in the DMCA as written. The safe harbor provisions are now vital to the continued existence of independent communities on the internet. But in practice safe harbor is often ignored too.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:42PM (#42491538)
> If KYC is so easy and un-burdensome that it's being applied everywhere else in our lives

If by everywhere else you mean finance. Which means you want to burden every single website in America that accepts user-generated content with a banking-style compliance department.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:40PM (#42491526)
I'm really not sure what you mean. Nobody argues that KYC is easy or non-burdensome, which is why it's not being applied everywhere else in our lives. A company like "Print-on-demand merch retailer TeePublic" would find it procedurally difficult and probably economically infeasible to rigorously verify the identity of everyone who sends it a notice of copyright infringement.

It sounds like you may be envisioning a system where the burden is offloaded onto the people sending a notice, but that's just not possible. If you get an email from some person Alice you've never heard of before, you fundamentally cannot know just from reading the email whether it was sent by the actual Alice, or someone pretending to be Alice, or whether there's even such a person as Alice in the first place. To tell the difference, you would have to research Alice and find some independent way to corroborate her identity.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by superkuh on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:41AM (#42571985)
If we fundementally cannot know then why are we believing these claimant "persons" at all? These days it's more likely than not that a DMCA claim is not from the copyright owner (or anyone associated with the owner) of what is claimed. It seems like DMCA is broken in practice and no longer operates in the spirit of the law.

I'm envisioning a system where someone has to prove they actually own the thing before they can claim it, yes. And if proving identity is so hard then maybe there shouldn't be take-downs at all. Let the legal system where identification is required take over. Stop the hundreds of millions of automated para-legal attacks and make it a more managable flood of hundreds of thousands of actual legal actions.

And yes, KYC is extremely burdensome. I suppose when a DMCA claim arrives the recipient should then send back an email with a link to some third party corporation dedicated to KYC (out of a set of government approved companies) which the DMCA claimant will sign up with and pay a small fee to. Most likely the claimaint will have to have a webcam conversation with the KYC company and upload their identifying documents. The result of the identity and ownership check would then be sent to both parties and the process could proceed as per normal.

This would strongly discourage illegal false claims which currently have no mitigation and make up the majority of DMCA actions.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by Aurornis on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:27PM (#42491774)
The article puts ‘United Healthcare’ in quotes and opens with a statement mirroring this same possibility, because the first-pass response to DMCA requests is as you describe: An assumption that it’s legitimate until proven otherwise.

This is very well known and the technique is often abused. Even the source article is presenting this information with a huge grain of salt.